Why Pakistan should not recognize Israel now (Urdu) |Pervez Hoodbhoy
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 лют 2025
- ABSTRACT: Arab countries are putting enormous pressure on Pakistan. Loans are being demanded back and manpower export has nearly stopped. Saudi Arabia and UAE want Pakistan to accept Israel's existence in spite of its annexation of the West Bank and declaration of Jerusalem as its capital. Here's why Pakistan should not play by the US-Arab game.
Totally agree. Pakistan must support Palestinian.
سر! آپ کی تجزیہ کا انتظار تھا؛اس موضوع پر۔ شکریہ
Iran was the second Muslim-majority country to recognize Israel as a sovereign state after Turkey.
Bhai Nasha hua wa hai?
Sir aapne sach bola hai....sirf sach..!!! Pakistani nahi jaantay ki Zia ul haq ne king Hussein(Jordan) key kehne par pelestines par zulm kiya....
Israel will not lose sleep over Pakistan's recognition in the first place!
Just two facts you need to recall.
If you claim Muslims were part of what is today's Palestine and therefore own it, Jews were thrown out of Medina during early Islamic times including of Mohammedan era?
So by that logic Israel can claim Medina !
Also in today's Israel , Muslim Israelis of Arab descent are seen in military service defending their nation !
Palestinian leaders disagree with all the proposals to solve the regional issue ONLY to fill their coffers and a solution will stop that happening !
Also it is prudent to ask whether Israel recognises Pakistan as a nation worth taking notice of or not in today's standards of excellence !
A tiny nation Israel is miles ahead in technology and innovation which Pakistan can only dream of !
Such a hollow , delusional argument with no tangible insight ,this !😎
What about the atrocities Israel is doing on Palastinen people by killing them and occupying their land's
Bro leave them they have no heart ❤️ in then they are hypocrites@@qumbermurtaza9186
When Muslims do anything wrong it is terrorism we condemn it all condemn it
But when America and Israel do it is not terrorism because they are strong and we are weak very weak @@qumbermurtaza9186
Aaj mujhey Pura yakeen hogaya hey key aap eik sachey insan Hein
Khuda mujhey aur Meri naslon ko aap jesa neik insan banaey
और एक यहुदी पर इतने सालो से जुल्म कि इन्तहां होती आ रही है उसका कुछ नही । कितने दोगले लोग है । मै एक हिन्दु हु और यहुदी के साथ हु मगर साथ मे ए भी चाहता हु कि प्यालेष्टेनी और यहुदी मिल के साथ रहे । अपना अपना मजहब माने और खुश रहे ।
Pervez bhai, why so much agony in accepting Israel when UN has accepted it. Does it matter to the rest of the world? Pakistan is no posterboy of human rights anyway as it denies this to its own citizens. Just as in hardline Islam there is no place for human rights.
even india did not recognize. we all had in passport. not valid for israel. but now things have changed..
India recognized Israel in 1950 but yeah full diplomatic relations were established in 1992
@@shivanginirai5087 India acted appropriately.
@@shivanginirai5087 yes you are 100 percent right
Scratch a surface, u find a hardliner behind the veneer modern intellectual muslims in Pakistan.
Bro, have you heard about a word called ghairat ? Do you understand what it means ? Self respect.
@@tauseefhussain3936 but I think self respect should continue with capabilitie
Totally agree with you sir 💯
As a highly intellectual personality we listen to ur views carefully and with great keenness. I may like to add that Israel is a theological state and we need to discourage such nationalism as our societies are entering into a civilized age and theological based ideologies find no place in modern state systems because present day religious leaders are intolerant to other faiths. People like King Solomon, King David, Prophet Muhammad were not extremists and other faiths were tolerated and accommodated in their states whereas we may see intolerance for minorities in present day theological states. Old Testament is full of hatred against Sons of Ismael and the war between these two communities is never going to an end if such ideologies are supported by international circles. We, however, do have equal respect for Jewish prophets and many Muslims keep their children names after the names of these holy people.
LMAO. Orthodox population of Israel is much fewer than Pakistan.
I may like to add that policy making in the age we are living -in is not based on population strengths. We are passing through an age of science and technology and nations with more technologists and scientists shall lead the world. Pakistan stands nowhere in this race whether our population is orthodox or liberal because both these circles have negligible contributions in R&D. Israelite, on the other hand, are well equipped with latest technology and well supported by the West for transfer of new developments. I worked with a few persons of this community. majority of their liberals and orthodox rubbies have anti-Ismael sentiments and its better we keep away from this new love affair.
@@KidsStories9999 Conservative population tends to have less tolerance towards other religions. So in this context population strength does matter.
Trying to count countries other than Israel that were created based on religion. I heard there was one more 🤔
@@im_sandeep_kaskar While having respect for conservative people I may like to add that S&T have brought a logic based change in our societies and every ideology has to be validated by logic and reasoning to be accepted by the mainstream people. Unfortunately, orthodox circles from all religions are reluctant to be open to questioning and should not be supported at all especially by the West. I hope US will soon withdraw its support for Israel to bring peace in the region.
Have Palestine spoke a single word for Jamu and Kashmir in the favour of Pakistan?
Yes Sir. you are very correct , the same thing i mentioned
Excellent analysis!
Dr. Sahab. What are your views on the illegal occupation of Balochistan in 1947?
Wrong question to wrong person .... He is still living in Pakistan
Ghadar mera tera sr ulawon ga.
It wasn't the occupation of while Balochistan but kalat who was ruled by the Khan; Khan of kalat.Quaid e Azam did made a promise with him that baloch's will get 50% of everything resourses extracted out of Balochistan but when Quaid e Azam died nothing was full filled as the state was under democratic crisis.I am also a Baloch.
Most of the population of balochistan is muslim and 98% of people there want to live with pakistan . Only 2% are those who are living a levish life outside on the money given by countries like india , take the example of kalbhushan yadav, what he was doing in balochistan ??You only want to spread a false propaganda !!
@@m.kamran6210 but what the state is doing in Balochistan can't be justified by this Statement.i know the nawab's are corrupt but the state is not paying attention on this matter properly.
good analysis packed in logic and reason
Agree with Dr.Hoodbhoy
How Pakistani treat Bengali, Pashtun, Baluchi? What happen to 20% Hindu and Sikh since 1947? This jahil will not talk about what Pakistani Muslim are doing to under age Christian, Hindu, and Sikh girls. Read up on UN REPORT ON HUMAN RIGHTS OF 2020.
How come Israeli policy twenty years before is different than today,so why accepting Israel was Kosher in 2000 but is not today? Insanity and Iranian agenda
I thought this gentleman to be a Science Scholar of high repute but he is much interested in geopolitical affairs.
Pakistani Made Him that why he is Discussing geopolitical affairs !!
He is both.
@@beamishwabe1526 you mean to say 50-50 ??
Why you took independence from British why don't you stay colonized
@@pcp3457 so with this logic arunachal belongs to china and aksai chin tok
Converted musalman roti kee chinta karo tum log oahle yee decide karo kee kaafir kaun hain shia ahmedi barelvee etc phir aa kee kashmir kee baat karna uskee baad jijad e fee saabi illha hoga tum log uske baad bahnoo see shaadi eg first cousin shadi kee baare mein soho kaha Kashmiri kee baat karte hoo 65 saal kee baad eek hindu government aaye hai india mein aage aage dekho hota hain kya kabhi sichna converted hone kee kaaran katwana padta hain re godi converted
Very great information
Sir from where we can get these book
If someone have in pdf plz share with us
Sir, before presenting your views on Kashmir and India.
i think you should read about History of Kashmir, Massacre of kashmiri pandits by Pakistani militants.
Read general Akbar khan's biography.
and What is Pakistan doing to Kashmiri people.
@Bhadwa Modi what about the Hindus and Sikhs killed there?
20000-30000 Hnidus and sikhs killed as well.
Selectively ignore it? Those lives don't matter?
Typical mindset
@Bhadwa Modi Below is the article of the first instigation of massacre. during 1947 partition.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1947_Mirpur_massacre
Read this and let me know who started this.
1880 kashmiri muslims where heavly taxed that a lot migrated to the punjab a lot of kashmiris in west punjab pakistani punjab the jammu dogra mahraja was a evil bastard
@@zaidhussain3658 what is the basis of your comment?
These kind of nonsense is what propaganda is.
You know how many hindus were killed by Mughals like Aurangzeb?
Whom you call your Hero.
Have you heard of Moppla goencide in Kerala of hindus?
Most of the Pakistani's ancestors were forcefully converted hindus whether you acknowledge or not.
It is written in the history.
Dr sahib we lived in same house in F -11 i am Dr hassan brother of Dr shakeel .we less happened to exchange thoughts with one another though we lived in same house .
Dr. Hoodbhoy , beggar nations often get bullied into submission . So , nothing extraordinary is being done with Pakistan .
Shallow response. It is not due to “Mazhabi Tassub”. Its about Palestinian cause. If there are two states, Pakistan should accept Israel.
Listen carefully before rushing to comment
shame on you palastine for palastinians
You the real intellectual hats off
Stay blessed
What Pakistan does with Israel is their choice. But don't even talk of J&K. It is an integral part of India.
Scientific delusions at its peak
اور اگر پاکستانی ریاست مفاد کی خاطر اسرائیل تسلیم کرتے ہیں تو وہ حق بجانب ہیں کہنے میں کہ “ پاکستانی قوم۔۔۔۔ کے لئے ۔۔۔۔ بھی بیچ دیتی ہے” انکی تاریخ کی کتابوں میں یہ ہی رقم ہو گا
Sir, agreed but army establishment is ready to accept Israel through some civilian puppet leader.
Excellent
I agree with u sir
اسراٸیل ایک سیاسی ریاست ھے مگر افسوس اسے سیاست کی الف ب کا بھی پتہ نہں
Izrail se agar nafratat hai to hame Saudi ko bhi apna dushman samajhna hoga
Great sir.
جو ملک عظیم اسرائیل کا منصوبہ رکھتا ہو بھلا وہ کیونکر آزاد فلسطین کی بات سنے گا.
Country which has already planned for the greater Israel, how can it think about liberation of Falasteen.
بہت عمدہ اللہ سلامت رکھے آپکو۔
Absolutly right
Whether pakistan recognises Israel or not, Israel will move on. So, how does it make any difference?
10:35👍👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏🙏
درست سر، مشروط شرائط پر کچھ سمجھ میں آتا ہے ورنہ انکے سامنے جھکنے والی بات ہو گی
دوسری بات ،سر، انکی کامیابی یہ ہے کہ وہ کوانٹٹی سے ذیادہ کوالٹی پر یقین رکھتے ہیں وہ کیس بھی معاملے میں ہو لیکن ہمارے ہاں کوانٹٹی میٹرس
تیسری بات، سر بچپن میں پلین کریش پر ہم نے مٹھائیاں بٹتے دیکھی ہیں۔
Agreed..
زبردست
Sir my question is that if we stand with kashmir why are we trading with India. Should Pakistan BAN india too
why we not developed in science and technology is because we blocked our thought process by saying that there is no revelation .that psychologically let us not innovate .because all what scientist conceive is also type of revelation .
عراقی یزیدیوں کے بارے بھی فرماییں
مسلمانوں کا اتفاق ہی ان مسائل کا واحد حل ہے۔
Good
Excellent and precise analysis
Sir what does it matter if Pak does not recognize ... Do u know Israel 17.2% has Arab population they are servicing in army...What kind of support u are giving to them. if Pak really wants to support why dont pak army go and fight for them....
Very good
Sir single national cirriculum ki b video bnae
Thank You Dr. sb for your analysis. But Dr. Sb tell me one thing which may be different from this topic that; Are you in favor of Iran means should Iran make its nuclear Bomb?? And One thing more I know You were the main opponent when Pakistan was making its nuclear bomb. But On the other side when you read and even you have inferred in your Dawn Column that Abdul Salam was also in try that Pakistan should make its atomic bomb and you became much excited? Why this excitement here? I hope you will reply in some of your videos. Thanks in anticipation. Be blessed and be happy always
SIR, WILL U PLZ TELL THE NATION. EXCEPT. ASLAAM BAIG SB, WHERE ,OUR EX ARMY CHIEFS R STTELED.
Sir you are my inspiration and i'm proud of you apny insaneyat ka sath dya or aik acha tajzya kya sir ab molana fazalurrehman (diesel) kyun nhi bolta Palestine cause ky lye.
I don't understand. If pakistan accepts Israel later, all reasons you cited would remain the same. For instance it would still affects the kashmir policy. Also Just by changing the prime Minister of Israel would not change anything. I'm surprised that you had this analysis.
Well done
Sir, an independent palestine has several issues,the foremost being weak,ineffective,infighting leadership. Geography is another issue.History also another issue as it never was an independent state: no king,sheikh or emir.
Apno par sitam ghairon per karam.
Aaplog jo pakistan mai hinduwo ke sath kr uska kya?
Tum log jo apne fellow hindu dedies k sath desi po...rn sites py krty ho kamazkam ham vo nae krty hindues sath.
@@fahadnazir945 kya krte h hum?
Jo ravana ny seeta sath kia tha
@@fahadnazir945 Jo aisha bachchi ke saath hua tha. Ooii maa.
@@atulvaibhav5376 lolxxxxx she become one of powerful women in the world. her father abubaker bacome sucesscor of prophet and first caliph of islam.
but bu...rning grandmo....ms in the name of su....tte was ok as per baktus logic.
For Hoodhboy to say Iran has a nuclear weapon program is "grave injustice" of facts. Not to mention Iran's fatwa against building of nuclear weapons makes this wesk argument. Also, how come Hoodhbhoy does not push an argument of a Secular Palestinian State based on equal right for people of any fauth. One person one vote should be the mantra of the progressives. He reflects duplicity of his political philosophy for Israel vis-e-vis Pakistan.
♥️♥️♥️♥️
I thought you as a free minded person but I was wrong
👏
Real man 💗
Sorry to say but it seems like ap bhi bik chukay hai pti k hatho..like whatever
Shi kha biky h ya dray gy h
because quran called bani israel in chapter bani verse 104 not jews .
Abhi aachi deal nahi de raha israel..they should offer sea facing banglow to bajwa with green card in US or Canada and 2 to 3 European bride to imran with lot of cash and pakistan will accept israel for the bigger cause
Plz write the word in rather than urdu . We r from indis so.....
That's what I was expecting from a liberal and this is the true liberalism
Thanks for supporting muslims for once.
Nice man 👌 and good video 👍
Beggars can't be choosers
Yahoodi aaj dunya me Jo kch kr rahay he uska hukum unhe un ka Mazhab deta he Jis tarha hm Muslims namaz parhatay he hajj krte he waghera woh apni promised land hasil kr k waha apni khaas Hakoomat bnana chahtay he to iss me unki Kya ghalti he? Baki Pakistan agar Israel ko accept krta he to phr hm Kashmir k lye kis tarha awaz uthayege ku k India kahayga Palestine k Muslims ki apko parwa nahi Kashmir ki parwa ku he ? PLEASE ANSWER
Dr HB also wants to quietly do it,Ahista say,just Hypocricy doesn't allow it
Sir AP ki logic smj sy bahr Hy k Israel ko naytin yaho k bahd tasleem KR layna chahiy ... should be remember one thing is that in future no change will be policy of Jews and Israel ....mind it
Bahi Sahab....20 Saal Pehlay Kya Palestine Ma Doodh Aur Shahad Ki Nehraun Bah Rahi Thi......Agar Ap k Ghar Per Koi Qabza Kerlay Aur Apko Ek Bathroom Rehnay Ko Dede To Kya Aisa Qabza Qabool Ker Lainay Chahiye....????
Wo hamesha se yahudio ki Dharti hai bus Islamic invaders ki wazah se usko bhagna pada ab wo apni Dharti par wapas rehne aaye hai apni country ko wapas lene me kya problem hai invaders ko bhagame me kya problem hai
@@freeman4758 bahi Sahab...Zara History Ki study kerlain Thori c....Jews ko Kisne Wahan Se Nikala Tha....Unki Apni Religious Books Ma Is baray Ma Kya Likha Ha....Kuxh To Samajh Honi Chahiye Insan Ma Bahi..
@@aliabrar3886 bhai jara otomon empire ko minority ki nazar se pad lo aur hamre Rasool ki hadeeso aur tarikh par gaur farmaye jo yahudio ke mutaliq hai
Masalan waqaya e Banu quraiza
@@freeman4758 Ek Momin ko Ghazwa e Banu Quraiza per fakhar hona chahiye....Wo Ek Treaty k Bawajood Musalmanon se Dhokay ki saza Thi...Unki Apni KITAB k Mutabiq Unko Milli Ha.....Whatsr Your Problem.....????
Kesi Muslim Ko To Nahi Ho Sakta....Balka Kesi Achay Insaan Ko Bhi Is ma Koi Pareshani Nahi Hogi.....Agar Masla Hoga To Sirf Extremists (Jews) Ko Aur Mushriqeen (Idol worshipers) Ko...
@@aliabrar3886 sabhi mardo ka katl kar bachiyo ko londiya banane par kya faqar
I have high respect for Prof sahab. But I have a question: Pakistan needs Israel more or Israel needs Pakistan more?
Is that even a question ? Pakistan is still surviving without accepting israel since 1947 . We can go on as well without accepting it . As for israel's Acceptance of Pakistan will be a huge thing for them as we are the only super power and if we accept it all the other small Islamic nation's will accept it openly . I hope you get my point #peace
@@tarikkhattak5546 How Pakistan is a superpower, on which parameters? If you want to say that due to Nuclear power, it is a superpower then things are a different. If you say that Pakistan is surviving even without recognising Israel so is Israel. And remember Israel is a highly developed country. If relations are made Pakistan will get more than Israel. So, Pakistan needs Israel more than vice versa.
@@mrramanpoonam I meant to say in Islamic nation's Pakistan is the only nuclear country and that matters alot to Islamic nation's . Yes you are right we will benefit alot from the agriculture technology and cyber security. But my brother the thing is we don't have to accept it under any external pressure that we are facing it right now . If the palestinian issue is resolved there is nothing else stopping us from accepting them .
Yes you're right i hate nitanyahu
Impressive openion
Baloch donot want to live with sunni punjabi muslim......we should support Balochistan.
You fool don't watch Indian media. These are all wrong news. Baloch regiment Army is the bravest army of Pakistan thousands of recruits are the part of it. Only few armed groups supported by India for their personal gains are troubling Pak Army but Army have taken over them and started defeating resulting hundreds of armed people surrendered. Indian criminal policies are at the verge of complete failure.
Hahahahahahahahahaha
Dr HB should better ponder on Indian atrocities in IIOJ&K instead of towing Iranian agenda
me sir aap ki bey inteha izzat karta hu, mgr black september per jitna mene parha hai, us hisaab se israeli jaarhiyat k effectees Palestinians ko jordan ne apny mulk me jaga di, jaha se unhoune takhreeb kaari shuru ki or jordan nhi chahta tha k us ki sarzameen se israel per koi bhi kisi bhi qisim ka hamla ho ya aisi bat ho k khud uski salamti khatry me parr jaye, yaha tk k aisy bhi waqiyata hain k falasteeni inteha pasandon ne jordan army tk ko qatal kiya or un tk se baaghi hue, aisi situation me king israel or america ki tarf gaya, or zia ul huq bilkul yaha se bina ijazat gaya tha or jaisa aap ne kaha bilkul yehi baat hai, or theek is black september k 6 saal baad ye chief of army staff ban gaya, jab k is ka turn bhi nhi aaya tha, or haal hi me israeli newspapers me zia ul huq ko israel ka behtreen dost qaraar diya gaya hai.. mgr khair.... aap ne ek tarfa baat ki... falasteeni itny bhi seedhy nhi hain... ye log shikaar rahy hain propaganda ka.. saamny muslim dunya aany se katraati hai, to mercenries ko hire kr k ye sab karwaya jaata hai jo k ghalat hai.. officially koi un k saath nh kharra hota.. or youn muslim terrorist bhi hai ab
Sir aap nytnyhu pr kiu bolty h jb ki agr koi bhi ayga wo shi hoga
Aap trmp ko bura khty kiu ho jb ki bydn bhi whi kryga jo tramp ny kia
Aap andajy pr pak ko chlana chty h kiu
Shi baat yh h ki is bary aap k muslim jaag gya h
Kiu aap smjty h inky jany k baad israil shi ho jayga
India pr bhi aap shi nhi bol pay aaj
Dikat sirg kuran m h jisky karan muslim jahil bnty h
How derogatory he talks about Riyals and Dollars,pathetic
Watch ghalib kamal, Harris sultan, zafar heretic, ex Muslim spartacus, urdu freethinker, faceless talks
My respect for you 📈📈📈🫡🫡🫡😻😻
Kashmir issue bahut different hay janab. Israel ko problem hay ke hamas jaisi organization jo sirif alag riyasat nahi balke pore israel ka khatma chahti hay, in ko taaqit mil Jaye gi free palestinian state ki Surat may. Pakistan is tarah pore india pe qabza nahi karna chata
@Pramod Reddy get lost jahil admi. This discussiin is not for bigots
Your question is totally wrong
How you justify pakistan stance in reference of jiyaulhaq action
you were then in Quad e Azam university .
Dr. Please Talk AbOut Ur RelatiOnship With Shushant Singh RajpOot... 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
Pervez Hoodbhoy ka dimaag 🧠 kharab ho gaya hai
PH ko pakistan mei rehna h jaha independent opinion bana kar aaj ki Pakistan state k against jaana hawa k rukh k khilaf jaana h. Phir dusery taraf pichhale 73 saal mei jo military + relegious goons k gang up ka environment banaya gaya h uske khilaf bhi aikdum nahi ja sakte. Aik 2 dhar ki talwar k blades per chalne jaisa h.
Pakistan ki apni koi international ahmiyat nahi reh gayi h. Aur jo thori bahut h bhi vo AQ Khan ki WEST se chori ki gayi nuclear tech k balbute hi h.
Abhi Israel ki baate kar local mahol banaya ja raha h.
Jis din UAE aur KSA ne Pakistanio ko apne yaha aane se rok diya aur vapis jaane ko kah diya, Pakistan ghutno k bul chalega aur shayad 2021 mei dekhne ko milega bhi.
Dragon bhi mauka ki talash mei h.
Apni thook rozana Pakistan se chatwayega hi.
Sir aaj aap bhi glt or jhut bol rhy h
Please comment on Balochistan
Why can’t Pakistan take all Palestinian in ???
UMMA IS CALLING
That's what Israel wants brother to bring there Jewish community and settle into Israel
Palestinians are fighting for there land and saying this would really hurt them who have lost the beloved ones in this struggle
@@saimtanweer5720 Jew yahood were there before you Mohammadan and your abbu masih
Mohammadan are occupiers
@@dharmikrakshak8340 they also came to settle there , first Abraham pbuh came and then after exodus Jews came from Egypt to settle in that land along with PALESTINIANS AND others , so that land was for all not just Jews
Now when they were kicked by "pagan" roman empire in 70 AD , then spread across the world and some came back to Palestine when muslim started to rule in 7th century ad and Palestinians accepted Islam now after the holocaust they were kicked from all European countries and came to Palestine and Muslim accepted there entry , then when they settled then they are trying to throw out all non Jews from there house
What will you call a person who comes to your property and say leave it my great great used to live here 2000 years ago and what will you do , give your property??
@@dharmikrakshak8340 when Christian or muslim started to rule Palestine , there were very few Jews in Palestine , much left it after 70 ad
What if today the native black American , says to all white European people living there to leave , will they leave there house and place??
@@saimtanweer5720 only Mohammadan are making problems..Mohammadan was imposed on them .just like you