Ron, thank you for a timely lesson on how honorable men behave in a crisis. Americans in 1861 believed in honor, integrity, decency, respect and morality. The event of Gen. Scott's retirement, and how it was managed, should remind us how important those values are for today's America.
It’s a shame how few people today really know much of anything about the great Winfield Scott who played such a huge role in the early life of the republic.
Imagine in 2024. If a leader knew that his infirmities prevented him from fully serving his country and stepping down on his own recognizance. Imagine that
Your choice of focus for this, and for many other videos that you post from time to time, makes the study of history poignantly relevant and meaningful. That you let the past speak for itself in the midst of our current events with so little commentary... this is a lesson in restraint, the mark of a gifted teacher. Thank you. Sincerely.
Now to make it really relevant, talk about when a "leader" who was a completely mentally unfit puppet, had propaganda cover for him for 3 years calling anyone who questioned his mental acuity "conspiracy theorist", then when it became too obvious, he was thrown out by his puppet masters , in favor of the unpopular DEI hire replacement he was forced to take on to placate riotous mobs who hate this country. oh and talk about how they denied primary voters any say in the candidate, for the third election cycle in a row (for democracy!)
Thanks. I had always known he came up with the Anaconda Plan but not what happened to him afterwards. A shame he was not in his prime to lead the Army of the Potomac for the next couple of years.
The most esteemed General Scott was fortunate that he had and, what is more, knew that he had a mighty, growing army and an outstanding Federal government with a loyal Congress and perhaps the greatest of all U.S. Presidents, assisted by a highly competent Presidential Cabinet, all of which could take over from him on his retirement and perform those duties necessary to preserve his precious country from a rebellion that sought to destroy it. He had laid the mighty, continent wide foundation for victory and could, in good conscience and relief, hand it to others to complete.
Do you know where the letter to Sec. Cameron is today? My hometown is Lewisburg Pa. where he lived for some time. His brother James house is the home to the Milton Pa historical society. Col. James Cameron was one of the first officers in the US Army killed in the civil war.
My 3x grandfather fought under Scott at the Battle of Lundy Lane near Fort Niagara during the War of 1812. Col. Scott was wounded in that action. He was a little perturbed that his name was giving to a distant fort near the Kansas and Missouri border. I believe he deserved a better placement of a fort as well.
True... And yet, as I noted the length of the sentences in that first report, I could not help but think that there is something to be said for the art of brevity in the convenience of our thoughts. Nonetheless, it certainly is wonderful to hear the English language employed with such skill and such a glorious flourish.
I have to remind myself that in the mid-19th century written/printed media was the only real option for long distance communications. In this context, choosing precise words and constructing sentences to accurately convey thoughts, instructions, and other information was critical.
@@lifeonthecivilwarresearchtrail It's an art we have all failed to practice well. Instead we have speech writers who speak for our leaders and those leaders are happy to read other's works as their own.
Every one in America had the sense of doing everything for the good of the country. I think Scott hung on long enough to see the country stay UNITED hence why he passed in 1866. Not that long ago I must add as my Great Grandfather was born that year and he bought the Farm that I still live and farm on 110 years after he purchased it.
I did not find any references to them making context in the short period of time between Appomattox and Scott's passing in 1866. Further research needed!
Ron, my first impression is how our dear countrymen on average cannot speak good English. Stories like this are evidence of this fact. Regardless, Winfield Scott did so much for the USA and this story is well received! Thank you!
Ron, thank you for a timely lesson on how honorable men behave in a crisis. Americans in 1861 believed in honor, integrity, decency, respect and morality. The event of Gen. Scott's retirement, and how it was managed, should remind us how important those values are for today's America.
It’s a shame how few people today really know much of anything about the great Winfield Scott who played such a huge role in the early life of the republic.
How timely. Your devotion to primary sources cuts through layers of interpretation and gives us a clear window to the past. Thanks for your work.
Outstanding video, thanks for sharing our history!
Excellent video. He lived to see the Union preserved and his plan executed.
That I'm sure gave him the deepest life satisfaction than if he had attempted to command active armies
Imagine in 2024. If a leader knew that his infirmities prevented him from fully serving his country and stepping down on his own recognizance. Imagine that
Great leader who knew when to step aside in favor of younger men like Grant
Your choice of focus for this, and for many other videos that you post from time to time, makes the study of history poignantly relevant and meaningful. That you let the past speak for itself in the midst of our current events with so little commentary... this is a lesson in restraint, the mark of a gifted teacher. Thank you. Sincerely.
Now to make it really relevant, talk about when a "leader" who was a completely mentally unfit puppet, had propaganda cover for him for 3 years calling anyone who questioned his mental acuity "conspiracy theorist", then when it became too obvious, he was thrown out by his puppet masters , in favor of the unpopular DEI hire replacement he was forced to take on to placate riotous mobs who hate this country. oh and talk about how they denied primary voters any say in the candidate, for the third election cycle in a row (for democracy!)
Ol' Fuss and Feathers
Thanks. I had always known he came up with the Anaconda Plan but not what happened to him afterwards. A shame he was not in his prime to lead the Army of the Potomac for the next couple of years.
The most esteemed General Scott was fortunate that he had and, what is more, knew that he had a mighty, growing army and an outstanding Federal government with a loyal Congress and perhaps the greatest of all U.S. Presidents, assisted by a highly competent Presidential Cabinet, all of which could take over from him on his retirement and perform those duties necessary to preserve his precious country from a rebellion that sought to destroy it. He had laid the mighty, continent wide foundation for victory and could, in good conscience and relief, hand it to others to complete.
Do you know where the letter to Sec. Cameron is today? My hometown is Lewisburg Pa. where he lived for some time. His brother James house is the home to the Milton Pa historical society. Col. James Cameron was one of the first officers in the US Army killed in the civil war.
Sorry to report I do not. Perhaps in the general's papers.
I should like to have heard some of his observations during the war, what his last letters or statements contained.
You may find his memoirs of interest: www.google.com/books/edition/Memoirs_of_Lieut_General_Scott_LL_D/et5dTcg3fq4C?hl=en&gbpv=1&printsec=frontcover
Agreed.
My 3x grandfather fought under Scott at the Battle of Lundy Lane near Fort Niagara during the War of 1812. Col. Scott was wounded in that action.
He was a little perturbed that his name was giving to a distant fort near the Kansas and Missouri border. I believe he deserved a better placement of a fort as well.
I believe that we have collectively lost full command of the English language.
True... And yet, as I noted the length of the sentences in that first report, I could not help but think that there is something to be said for the art of brevity in the convenience of our thoughts. Nonetheless, it certainly is wonderful to hear the English language employed with such skill and such a glorious flourish.
I have to remind myself that in the mid-19th century written/printed media was the only real option for long distance communications. In this context, choosing precise words and constructing sentences to accurately convey thoughts, instructions, and other information was critical.
@@lifeonthecivilwarresearchtrail It's an art we have all failed to practice well. Instead we have speech writers who speak for our leaders and those leaders are happy to read other's works as their own.
Say what?
The Anaconda probably beat the Confederacy all by itself.
Was Scott a Major General, or Lieutenant General at retirement? He looks to have three stars on his epaulets. Thank You. Great work.
Ah Brevet Lt. General.
For my money, Scott is the greatest general in US history
Every one in America had the sense of doing everything for the good of the country. I think Scott hung on long enough to see the country stay UNITED hence why he passed in 1866. Not that long ago I must add as my Great Grandfather was born that year and he bought the Farm that I still live and farm on 110 years after he purchased it.
Hey Ron, did Soctt and Lee ever reconnect after the war?
I did not find any references to them making context in the short period of time between Appomattox and Scott's passing in 1866. Further research needed!
The Harrisburg Telegraph getting some play...bravo!
Ron, my first impression is how our dear countrymen on average cannot speak good English. Stories like this are evidence of this fact. Regardless, Winfield Scott did so much for the USA and this story is well received! Thank you!
Before you complain about others you should look in a mirror. Proper English NOT good English. Maybe a little more schooling than you have might help.
...and he staved off a military conflagration with Britain in "The Great Pig War" in 1859.
Halftime ended July 13 2024
Too bad we don't have generals like this today, who are not Woke! !
You have been lied to again! Our military officers and ncos are far superior in every way than any other country in the world!
I may have misunderstood th date but Lincoln died in 1865 how could he have been there in 1866 must have been Johnson
He retired 1861.