Shashi Tharoor on BBC Documentary on PM Modi I "If India has moved on... I Barkha Dutt I Bottomline

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 січ 2023
  • Shashi Tharoor, Congress MP but also an effective and vocal voice against British Colonialism, speaks to Barkha Dutt on the government decision to block the broadcast of a BBC documentary on PM Modi. The government has called the documentary "malicious propaganda". The opposition is calling it censorship. The BBC is caught up in a storm of its own in UK- its chairman is accused of owing his post to Boris Johnson after helping him secure a personal loan, while he was UK PM.
    The order was issued under the emergency provisions of the Information Technology Rules, 2021, for allegedly casting “aspersions on the authority and credibility of the Supreme Court of India, sowing divisions among various communities, and making unsubstantiated allegations regarding actions of foreign governments in India”.
    #bbc #bbcdocumentary #narendramodi #india #britain #british
    Support Independent Journalism. Support Mojo. Here: rb.gy/5f3ppi
    Subscribe to us for more updates:
    Follow us on Twitter: / themojo_in
    Like us on Facebook: / themojostory
    Instagram: / mojostory.in
    For more videos: ua-cam.com/channels/rdP.html...
    Disclaimer: The views of guests who appear on Mojo Story, as well as the views of interviewees or speeches by public figures or those in the news, are their personal opinions. At no point do they reflect the views of the organization.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 594

  • @loneranger1265
    @loneranger1265 Рік тому +100

    Shashi Tharoor ji you truly deserved to be the United Nations Secretary General for at least two terms, you are the pride of India and your eloquence is second to none, you are the star of the east 🙏👍👌👏💐🇮🇳😘

    • @varunsriniwasan6561
      @varunsriniwasan6561 Рік тому +2

      Of that was the case, the US, the world's most Liberal Democracy did not support this Johnny's candidature.

    • @skj4210
      @skj4210 Рік тому +1

      "I will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve. Therefore strike off their heads and strike off every fingertip of them."
      "Allah"(Quran 8:12)
      "Fight everyone in the way of Allah and kill those who disbelieve in Allah." Muhammad (Ibn Ishaq 992)
      "Love your neighbor and pray for those who persecute you." Jesus (Bible, Matthew 5:44)
      "Love your neighbor as yourself." Jesus (Bible, Mark 12:31)
      "He who lives by the sword will die by the sword." Jesus (Bible, Matthew 26:52)

    • @MeMe-sy5xp
      @MeMe-sy5xp Рік тому

      I fully agree with you

    • @MeMe-sy5xp
      @MeMe-sy5xp Рік тому +3

      Dr Tharoor,
      BJP cannot tolerate any remark about their" monarch" Modi. He is not an ordinary mortal . Probably they can compare him with Lord Ram. The government is still in fool's paradise." The Vishwa Guru" is with out clothes in the eyes of the world.

    • @koolbean2034
      @koolbean2034 Рік тому

      Johnny does not belong to the 'yes pappa' category. 😸😺

  • @SubhashSharma-mr7ic
    @SubhashSharma-mr7ic Рік тому +41

    Very sensible & balanced response. Good Sashi Thraroor.

  • @PseudoProphet
    @PseudoProphet Рік тому +26

    BJP government never ignores such things, these things make Modi more popular, how can BJP not make a big fuss out of all this. 😅😅😂😂

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Рік тому +1

      If fear so much why was it release at all. Yes. It's good for Hindus cause as they unite them more so that Hindus bring him back to power with 400+seats in 2024.

    • @gargimandal5992
      @gargimandal5992 Рік тому

      Pesudo Sickular this is the right name for the youtube

    • @gargimandal5992
      @gargimandal5992 Рік тому

      @India a failed State Itni tweet karne bhi atta nahi milega

    • @THUGPUTIN
      @THUGPUTIN Рік тому +3

      Indian watching this is basically giving more votes to bjp... I don't understand, why this is banned... This exposes how biased one sided other journalists media are, which are promoting ravish Kumar, Dhruv rathee (leftist) etc....
      Let's be honest, bjp wants voters to watch this illegally so that bjp proves itself right that UK is against modi...
      For the last 4 years, bjp is being criticised for choosing West(USA, eu&uk) over Russia... Bjp sticking with Russia during war and this documentary brings huge vote bank to bjp..

    • @gargimandal5992
      @gargimandal5992 Рік тому

      @Robert Clive the founder of India E ADHA GAWAR A.I .
      AKAL TO NAHI HAIN

  • @tworiversmeet
    @tworiversmeet Рік тому +16

    Tharoor knows fairly well that a documentary on him (and his marriages, death of Sunanda) can be both informativ but also manipulative. Indian journalists should do documentaries on some western leaders.... and see how they react.

    • @radhikakumar2331
      @radhikakumar2331 Рік тому +1

      Fantastic points!!

    • @tworiversmeet
      @tworiversmeet Рік тому

      @@radhikakumar2331 India often lets the West judge our politicians and policies. Time we take a good look at them. Quite a few are pure hypocrites. Great rhetorik followed by selfish and inhuman decisions as in the case of the USA.

  • @a2z2technologies99
    @a2z2technologies99 Рік тому +3

    BBC is not British Raj, British Raj is not BBC. Do not forget they have covered issues inimicable to British government too. We must appreciate their hard work in making the progrom a talking point in international circles where our own journalists have failed

    • @deepasmitlenka7682
      @deepasmitlenka7682 Рік тому

      But we will still not allow BBC for what they have done to us for 200 years.... Yes. .... That's racist but that's fun😂😂😂😂..... Especially to UK it deserves...... The British during Raj used to kill people from entire village and dead bodies were carried on bullock cart from morning till evening..... So not forget to show your strength to their offsprings ......😂😂.... We r 5 th largest economy bro😂😂

  • @joesilveira4756
    @joesilveira4756 Рік тому +21

    Keeping dirt under the carpet does not help, truth keeps surfacing...

    • @Pork393
      @Pork393 Рік тому

      Sure it has!! Thanks to the social media!

    • @abhishek_kothari
      @abhishek_kothari Рік тому +6

      You British Christian breed teaching about truth 🤣

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Рік тому +3

      Let durt of Kashmir that made Hindus ran from Kashmir be documented by it. Let it make documentary on Suburmsti train burning, on Sikhs killing in 1984, innumerable bomb blasts happened, target killings happened, who engineered CAA riots by misleading muslims, post election violence in WB so other killings, what happened in the name of blasphemy not happened in Nupur's episode and why real culprit Zubair was released and Rehmani allowed to escape!?

    • @shivaRamaKrishnaRocks
      @shivaRamaKrishnaRocks Рік тому

      Then you should question ur existence looter (I meant looser but even my smartphone knows what's ur reality)

    • @rorsail
      @rorsail Рік тому +1

      Ok so then those who want to keep digging up mughal violence and invasions today are justified too?

  • @viswaashok1624
    @viswaashok1624 Рік тому +2

    Truth is always bitter .if it is extremely bitter how can we drink ?we have to spit it off. That is the irony of today's INDIA .

  • @anarkali_217
    @anarkali_217 Рік тому +2

    Shashi lives n writes books on Colonialism but suggests that victims Muslims should forget lanat

  • @shanindia100
    @shanindia100 Рік тому +5

    The follow up with the 2nd BBC documentary links so well with the first. So Tharoor is slightly off here. Why can't you appreciate a well done documentary?
    Childish reaction or not, the content is truth which they are trying to make all forget and it's difficult to have it paraded all over again.

    • @amtrailsinfra
      @amtrailsinfra Рік тому

      @your dad so many documents already done..also make a document on hindu temples built over destroying jain and buddhist temples

  • @davidkrupadanam1179
    @davidkrupadanam1179 Рік тому +30

    Shashi Taroor is speaking the truth about BBC documentary

    • @georgetimothy7819
      @georgetimothy7819 Рік тому +1

      Shashi Tharoor has very beautifully presented what our mature response should have been.

    • @rjhaveri8bh
      @rjhaveri8bh Рік тому

      @@georgetimothy7819 No muslims ever mentioned till date what good congress did for muslims but they always ask Modi what he done for muslims. They ask Modi for accountability for Gujarat riots but why the same muslims dont ask Lieutenant General Zameer Uddin Shah accountability for Gujarat riots when he was directly responsible for law and order during the riots. He is same man who was incharge of army to control 2002 gujarat riots ...he never said anything against modi for gujarat riots.
      No muslims ever mentioned till date what good congress did for muslims but they always ask Modi what he done for muslims. They ask Modi for accountability for Gujarat riots but why the same muslims dont ask Lieutenant General Zameer Uddin Shah accountability for Gujarat riots when he was directly responsible for law and order during the riots. He is same man who was incharge of army to control 2002 gujarat riots ...he never said anything against modi for gujarat riots.
      Tell me why muslims dont call General Zameer Uddin Shah butcher of Gujarat.
      Kyu ki fake media ki post karne ki aadat hai real fact explore karna nahi hai.
      Muslims are the biggest hypocirates.
      Pakistan General Tikka Khan orders the killing of 3 million Muslims in East Pakistan in 1970, Muslims were silent, Princess Hend was Silent not a word.
      You remember who is princess Hend of Sharjah, read till the end I will share to your why princess Hend is doing these TV interviews, you will know how Islam is bad for muslim women, they are forced make money by hindu hatred due to own issues.
      Pakistan killed 26000 million Muslims in Pakistan General Zia Ul Haq orders the killing of 26000 Palestinian Muslims, Muslims were silent, , Princess Hend was Silent not a word.
      Pakistan killed 2 Million Baloch Muslims, NWFP muslims, Sindh Muslims, Gilgit/POK muslims, but still Muslims were silent, Princess Hend was Silent not a word.
      Pakistan has killed tens of thousands of Muslims in Baluchistan, more than 20,000 are missing, Muslims of Pakistan and JK remain quiet; Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word.
      Pakistan has killed tens of thousands of Muslims in FATA and parts of FATA, Muslims of Pakistan and JK remain quiet; Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word.
      Pakistan helped Americans to kill millions of Muslims in Afghanistan, Muslims of Pakistan and JK remain quiet; Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word.
      Pakistan helped Americans to kill millions of Muslims in NWFP, Muslims of Pakistan and JK remain quiet; Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word.
      Turkey butchers Armenians, Muslims of the world, Pakistan and JK remain quiet; Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word.
      Turkey butchers Muslims (Kurds), Muslims of Pakistan and JK remain quiet; Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word
      Iraq Kills Kurds, Muslims of Pakistan and JK remain quiet; Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word
      Muslims kills Muslims in Iraq, Muslims of Pakistan and JK remain quiet; Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word
      Turkey, Saudi Arabia and others kill Muslims in Syria, Muslims of Pakistan and JK remain quiet; Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word
      Saudi UAE Bombed/Killed Muslims in Yemen, Iraq, Syria but Muslims were silent. But the Muslims of Turkey Pakistan Malaysia and Kashmir remained quiet. Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word
      Muslim country Saudi Arabia hanged 50 Muslim minorities including 15 year old in one day I don't recall any Indian Muslims put a post on Facebook, Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word. Where was your love for Muslims when Saudi was killing Muslims.
      During the Muslims protests in Bahrain in 2009, the state asked Saudi Arabia another Muslim country for help. The army of Saudi Arabia opened fire and shot at the Minority Muslim protestors straight away killing them, they kidnapped the minority Muslim leaders from their homes in the darkness of night and put them into a unknown desert jail where they were tortured for the next 1 year. I don't recall any Indian Muslim post about it. Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word.
      Shameless Muslim PM of Pakistan Imran Khan and Muslim President of Malaysia Dr. Mahathir Mohammed are silent about the persecution of Chinese Uyghur muslims. Shameless PM of Pakistan Imran Khan said in an interview he never even heard of the matter. Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word to expose such Muslims.
      They are silent about Pakistan army killing Muslims in Balochistan. Such fake love for muslims should be exposed by muslims themselves but instead we have to write to you cause you spread hatred against India. Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word to expose such Muslims.
      www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/china-religious-ethnic-minorities-uighur-muslim-harvest-organs-un-human-rights-a9117911.html
      facebook.com/trtworld/videos/2225051441148359/?t=1
      Even several Arab and Muslim nations including Saudi Arabia gave petitions in United Nations, not to take action against China for persecution of Muslims in China. But Muslims of the world are quite and Princess Hend was Silent not a word to expose such Muslims.
      Hypocrisy and Bigotry of Muslims and the Arabs is amazing,.
      Who the fuck is fake Princess Hend to interfere in Indian matters. She is only divorced wife of Prince of Qatar struggling to get her son to UAE. She needs money to fight case to get her son from qatar she takes bribes from china and pakistan. She also took money from Rahul Gandhi for congress propaganda.
      Princes should know that UAE got runaway princess only because of India, so Princess Hend should shut her mouth. She only comes on leftist channels she has no guts to come on right channels for interview otherwise she will know real facts. .
      One can only feel pity for a desperate mother struggling to make ends meet to fight her legal battles she needs money she will do this by taking money from congress, pakistan and china to defame Modi and BJP.
      Will not leave Qatar until I have my son accompanying me, says Emirati Princess on her custody battle,
      World News | wionews.com
      www.wionews.com/world/will-not-leave-qatar-until-i-have-my-son-accompanying-me-says-emirati-princess-on-her-legal-custody-battle-249868

    • @georgetimothy7819
      @georgetimothy7819 Рік тому

      @@rjhaveri8bh you seem to have a lot of information about the matter. I just endorsed the view that we should move on. Is there an issue in it. You are entitled to your opinion and every one else too.Let us live and let live.

  • @kaushal9566
    @kaushal9566 Рік тому +16

    Wonderful to speak about inclusive India of all kinds of people

    • @rjhaveri8bh
      @rjhaveri8bh Рік тому

      Prime minister Modi under went a rigorous SIT and court process to be acquitted from any involvement.
      But the Congress party of india faced no trial for colluding with the Pakistani trained Muslims who burned godhra train.. The Congress faced no trial for genocide of sikhs in punjab.. The American faced no trial for the genocide of red Indians, the Canadians faced no trial for the killing of their native population.. The Australians faced no trials for genocide of native aborgine population of Australia.. The British royal pedophile family and never faced any trials for the rape of children, women and for killing of millions of indians. Now the left liberal media will not talk about any of these genocides because they have an agenda against the hindu prime minister of india Mr.Modi..

  • @thomasjoseph6007
    @thomasjoseph6007 Рік тому +9

    Excellent analysis, very eloquently expressed. Much appreciated ,Sir.

  • @arvindrajput5328
    @arvindrajput5328 Рік тому +1

    Agreed with you

  • @bhushanbari5643
    @bhushanbari5643 Рік тому +22

    What a pleasure to listen to Dr Tharoor

  • @milindapanha
    @milindapanha Рік тому +19

    If Shahi Tharoor were to be leading Congress, I would vote for them.

    • @firdossheikh7147
      @firdossheikh7147 Рік тому +1

      Yup !! Me too. 🙏🏽🇮🇳

    • @satindra21
      @satindra21 Рік тому +1

      Me too.

    • @agnescraig2912
      @agnescraig2912 Рік тому

      The Gandhis will never allow that to happen. Recent votes for the President were a case in point. Just the same as Mouha in the TMC who is head and shoulders apart from Mamta Banerjee

    • @satindra21
      @satindra21 Рік тому

      @@agnescraig2912 True.

  • @mushtaqbeg1652
    @mushtaqbeg1652 Рік тому +1

    Always pleasure to listen to Shashi Tharoor on issues... leaving his admirers simply dazzled by his intellectual brilliance, articulation nd eloquence!... Mirza Mushtaq Beg, Anantnag,

  • @sundar452000
    @sundar452000 Рік тому +14

    Absolutely wisely said Dr Shashi Tharoor. Fully agree with the points said.

    • @arunjetli7909
      @arunjetli7909 Рік тому

      this hypocrite did not care about the freedom of direct gif nupur sharma

  • @jalisaaishakhan1411
    @jalisaaishakhan1411 Рік тому +1

    The best talk and the best strategy to the BBC documentary,agree totally with you Shashi Tharoor Sir .

  • @MK-zd1kj
    @MK-zd1kj Рік тому

    How can I see this documentary film 🙏

  • @zefreenarafique2652
    @zefreenarafique2652 Рік тому +1

    Well said..

  • @aaaaak05
    @aaaaak05 Рік тому +26

    Fabulous Sir! !!! Wish people like you and Mahua Moitra ruled our nation !!!

  • @Jayrum293
    @Jayrum293 Рік тому +6

    Episode 2 effectively blows up the argument that this was all in the past. The first set the stage for what is happening now. And shame on Barkha and Tharoor not to focus on the merits of the documentary.

    • @akhilnagath
      @akhilnagath Рік тому

      Were can we find those documentary ?

  • @gil47
    @gil47 Рік тому

    So correct it’s important who is grown up by in the room.

  • @krishnamoorthyj8327
    @krishnamoorthyj8327 Рік тому +3

    Sashi tharoor like person are responsible for the success of modi rss bjp to come to power..

  • @saga1476
    @saga1476 Рік тому +10

    The eloquent Mr. Tharoor is treading very carefully on this Modi / BBC documentary, because there is a documentary in the making on Mrs. Indira Gandhi’s Emergency period.. very cleverly articulated Mr. Tharoor. Bravo !

    • @rjhaveri8bh
      @rjhaveri8bh Рік тому

      Prime minister Modi under went a rigorous SIT and court process to be acquitted from any involvement.
      But the Congress party of india faced no trial for colluding with the Pakistani trained Muslims who burned godhra train.. The Congress faced no trial for genocide of sikhs in punjab.. The American faced no trial for the genocide of red Indians, the Canadians faced no trial for the killing of their native population.. The Australians faced no trials for genocide of native aborgine population of Australia.. The British royal pedophile family and never faced any trials for the rape of children, women and for killing of millions of indians. Now the left liberal media will not talk about any of these genocides because they have an agenda against the hindu prime minister of india Mr.Modi.. These Psedo secular media and journalists did not want to support Kashmir files such people are Pakistani hashish smokers who will only support those who pay them money this is why I called journalists are same as prostitutes.

    • @Bunnybunny-pq2qp
      @Bunnybunny-pq2qp Рік тому

      Why would he, he has written negatively about the emergency quite a lot and it is well known that he sees emergency as a bad thing and considers most of indira gandhi's policies as bad and has written 2 books on that.

  • @NM-fc8vu
    @NM-fc8vu Рік тому +1

    It is always a pleasure to listen to Dr. Shashi Tharoor.

  • @kalpanakabra9542
    @kalpanakabra9542 Рік тому

    silence is considered to be acceptance.

  • @hotpepperRJ
    @hotpepperRJ Рік тому +37

    Facts whenever they come out are facts.

    • @gauravkr4857
      @gauravkr4857 Рік тому

      But kashmiri files movie is propaganda.

    • @budsurtees4224
      @budsurtees4224 Рік тому +1

      @@gauravkr4857 Because it's a movie with actors and dramatization, instead of a documentary which features actual footage and the people involved. There's a substantial difference between the two, and if you reclaim your surrendered brain you might be able to understand it.

    • @rjhaveri8bh
      @rjhaveri8bh Рік тому

      Prime minister Modi under went a rigorous SIT and court process to be acquitted from any involvement.
      But the Congress party of india faced no trial for colluding with the Pakistani trained Muslims who burned godhra train.. The Congress faced no trial for genocide of sikhs in punjab.. The American faced no trial for the genocide of red Indians, the Canadians faced no trial for the killing of their native population.. The Australians faced no trials for genocide of native aborgine population of Australia.. The British royal pedophile family and never faced any trials for the rape of children, women and for killing of millions of indians. Now the left liberal media will not talk about any of these genocides because they have an agenda against the hindu prime minister of india Mr.Modi..

    • @budsurtees4224
      @budsurtees4224 Рік тому +1

      @@rjhaveri8bh Stop indulging in whataboutery and address the issue at hand.

    • @rjhaveri8bh
      @rjhaveri8bh Рік тому

      @@budsurtees4224 The BBC documentary simply represents propaganda of those who hate growth of India under PM Modi, they want old Congress govt to come back so they can continue corrupt partnership business of looting India.
      The BBC documentary fails to inform that Prime minister Modi under went a rigorous SIT investigation and court process to be acquitted from any involvement in the killing of Muslims in the Gujarat riots.
      But the Congress party of india faced no trial for colluding with the Pakistani trained Muslims who burned godhra train.Many of them trained in Pakistan and as per the justice Nanavati commission were given logistics by members of Congress why there was no trial against the Congress despite the evidence. The Congress faced no trial for genocide of sikhs in punjab. The AAP party and Kejriwal faced no trial despite one of their party members caught red handed participating and supporting the rioters with weapons.. The American faced no trial for the genocide of red Indians, the Canadians faced no trial for the killing of their native population.. The Australians faced no trials for genocide of native aborgine population of Australia.. The British royal pedophile family and never faced any trials for the rape of children, women and for killing of millions of indians. Now the left liberal media will not talk about any of these genocides because they have an agenda against the hindu prime minister of india Mr.Modi.. These Psedo secular media and journalists did not want to support Kashmir files such people are Pakistani hashish smokers who will only support those who pay them money this is why I say today journalists as no different from prostitutes.. Actually the fact is more Muslims are killed by Muslims in Muslim nations like Pakistan but there is no trial against Pakistan.. There is a genocide of Urighur Muslims in china but Muslims are silent.. This is not about genocide of Muslims this is about hatred against Hindus by the global leftists, Communists and woke supporting lobby. If BBC and UK Parliament was really interested in truth they should have probed who was funding BBC to illegally probe Indian internal matter.

  • @muhammadakramariff6466
    @muhammadakramariff6466 Рік тому +4

    Truth always hurts.

    • @devarajv7308
      @devarajv7308 Рік тому

      Muslims in India don't believe in India. this is also true.

  • @nishalall3510
    @nishalall3510 Рік тому

    💐

  • @ushavarkey4052
    @ushavarkey4052 Рік тому +7

    Such a pleasure to hear him speak

  • @sivaramanmudaliar9728
    @sivaramanmudaliar9728 Рік тому +1

    If the media can discuss ad nauseam even today about emergency why not Gujarat 2002 ? What is media afraid about ? Do they always keep remembering nightmarish encounters & Justice Loya?

  • @samuelgeorge3210
    @samuelgeorge3210 Рік тому +5

    Very good analysis
    A big salute to both of you

  • @frederickpicardo6784
    @frederickpicardo6784 Рік тому +5

    Very good explanation by Shashi Taroor

  • @kay--2
    @kay--2 Рік тому +5

    We close the window when foul smell comes...don't we?

    • @aruntomsan
      @aruntomsan Рік тому

      Not a great comparison... As far as censorship goes, almost everyone knows banning something only makes it sexier (whether it is BBC documentary or Satanic verses). I have watched the documentary and i can assure you it has zero new information. So that being the case, GOI could have just released a couple of statements and ignored it. If they had done that, no one including me would have watched it cuz there's nothing new in there. This censorship just drew attention to it.

  • @cobra2611
    @cobra2611 Рік тому +1

    Let me wait for a program on Digvijaya Singh deploring him on his comments on balakot strike… 😵‍💫

  • @satindra21
    @satindra21 Рік тому

    Nice interview.

  • @vandanathakur4968
    @vandanathakur4968 Рік тому

    👍.

  • @syedakramulla9304
    @syedakramulla9304 Рік тому +7

    truth is feeling suffocated, we should allow the truth to come out and breathe... truth should have its time... please give time a chance...

    • @varunsriniwasan6561
      @varunsriniwasan6561 Рік тому

      Yes, all the riots that took place since 1967 under the Congress should be exposed

    • @princerajput3864
      @princerajput3864 Рік тому

      Yes fact is Muslim radical killed Hindu and Hindu retaliated

    • @SASA-dj7bf
      @SASA-dj7bf Рік тому

      According to Quran & hadith....convert non believers to believers or if not then kill them...
      why iz ur take on it,u agree on this?

  • @dattatrayadas7846
    @dattatrayadas7846 Рік тому

    Amazing analysis!

  • @lilaclavender409
    @lilaclavender409 Рік тому +2

    And say, "Truth has come, and falsehood has departed. Indeed is falsehood, [by nature], ever bound to depart." (Qur’ān 17:81)

  • @ramharitham
    @ramharitham Рік тому +15

    Watching his interviews you will learn something new every time. Streisand effect 🙂

  • @rakeshramesan7543
    @rakeshramesan7543 Рік тому

    bemused - puzzled, confused, or bewildered.; ve·he·mence - the display of strong feeling; passion

  • @maheshdash6930
    @maheshdash6930 Рік тому

    This panel is above supreme court... wow look who are speaking

  • @saibald
    @saibald Рік тому +3

    So to the point and exceptionally articulated by the master writer. Another stupendous Tharoor

  • @shaunbird8051
    @shaunbird8051 Рік тому +12

    Only Shashi Tharoor can talk like this no other. And all this is most relevant and pertinent. It is the present Ruling Regime who have over reacted and the consequence is now truly unfolding. Now it the PM alone who has to come forward and make the appropriate clarifications and not let his Juniors to do the clarifications. Jai Hind !

  • @marwinmenezes7758
    @marwinmenezes7758 Рік тому +5

    People who have lost loved ones can never move on.. How are we encouraging unity among people and prevent such massacres in the future? I agree that all countries have such issues. But the way to go forward is to create laws that the will prevent such riots in future. This is similar to US congress refusing to ban Guns

    • @bkp95
      @bkp95 Рік тому

      Yes ,59 hindus burnt alive by muslim mob also could not move on .

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Рік тому

      Because without guns more people are killed by criminals!?. Otherwise why people oppose banning them!? It's reported that there are people who kill for 100 dollars also, but it's developed rich country!?

  • @abinashjena8406
    @abinashjena8406 Рік тому +15

    I mean Tharoor is a true gentleman. He is so accurate in his views and opinions most of the time and bang on in this case also.

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Рік тому +2

      Until one documentary comes on Khangress and his wife's death case. How Khangress is the cause of Islamisation and christianisation of the country, how Kashmir was made muslim majority state by driving away Hindus three,how it and LeLi gang is cause of Rohingyas migration to WB to Kashmir that endangered Hindus lives, how his native state is made as IS hub of activity (He dare not speak about it due to fear of being beheaded!?) etc.

    • @srivi2009
      @srivi2009 Рік тому

      True gentleman. Sure! Sunanda Tharoor’s investigation is still going on… let’s wait for what that has to say.

  • @rajendrayadav-cw9no
    @rajendrayadav-cw9no Рік тому +2

    Shashi Ji really great

  • @TheStringBreaker
    @TheStringBreaker Рік тому +3

    *Excellent insights by Mr.Tharoor!*

  • @GVashi
    @GVashi Рік тому +1

    That time congres in central government,They failed punish Modi and Amit shah. Now shashi defendModi indirectly .How can you easily say move on think you’re victim in 2002 if your family is victim what you both think

  • @metaworldinfotechbiotech303

    I agree with Mr Tharoor such things should haven't come after all settled people have forgotten it. Same People should have opposed #Kashmir files as well

  • @100airwolf
    @100airwolf Рік тому +2

    just now waiting for an indian production about winston churchill.

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Рік тому +1

      Exactly. And also how Khangress allowed islamisation and christianisation of the country by giving for wakf boards, missionaries and churches!?. How many terrorists attacks happened on Hindus since independence and Khangress's active and passive role in it.

  • @vivMak23
    @vivMak23 Рік тому

    There was no need to ban the video, let it play , who cares.

  • @amnindermavi3566
    @amnindermavi3566 Рік тому +2

    The less barkha dutt speaks, the better interview will be

  • @takahapana557
    @takahapana557 Рік тому

    Everything that discloses mistreatment is labelled as propaganda by the culprits to exculpate themselves from any blame. Where is justice?

  • @diva7892
    @diva7892 Рік тому

    awesome dr.tharoor.... awishy and suave!

  • @bharati6190
    @bharati6190 Рік тому +3

    It is such a pleasure to hear him speak. Wonderful conversation.

  • @asheshdutta
    @asheshdutta Рік тому +1

    Shashi Tharoor is a finest Prime Minister that India will never have. What an eloquent and civil speaker. Most of the politicians these days aren't able to articulate properly let alone demonstrating civility in public discourse.

    • @sanmankelkar4208
      @sanmankelkar4208 Рік тому

      Most of the Indians don't understand English. Hence eloquent doesn't matter. BBC and hypocrites like Barkha and Tharoor can't handle the success of Modi. Still I am a big fan of Tharoor's English. Ending on a final note Modiji is the greatest pm of India so far

  • @pramodkulkarni3747
    @pramodkulkarni3747 Рік тому

    I greatly agree.
    One can done similar documentaries about BBC and Uk and Comunist, Naxals , Muslims etc

  • @sivaramanmudaliar9728
    @sivaramanmudaliar9728 Рік тому +1

    It is reprehensible that there is a suggestion that India must move on. If it happens to his/her family would s/he move on forgetting the pogrom .Even in South Africa when the rule by Whites has ended The South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) was set up by the Government of National Unity to help deal with what happened under apartheid. As an old civilization( RW supporters/activists swear by it & wear it on their sleeves) should not India emulate South Africa on not only 2002, but also on 1984, Assam riots. Muzaffar Nagar riots , religious riots all over India beginning at least from 1947

  • @chettukuzhysivadas3206
    @chettukuzhysivadas3206 Рік тому

    Censorship is anti-democratic; we are democratic and not totalitarian.

  • @surenm4981
    @surenm4981 Рік тому +2

    Mr Tharoor deliberately or otherwise misses a primary point of a journalistic effort like that of BBC; the documentsry is very relevant because of BJPs continuing and bolder posture on minorities. Tharoor just continues to harp on what could have been better for the government. May be he is constrained by thoughts on his own political future...

  • @shayondebroy5106
    @shayondebroy5106 Рік тому +1

    So cautious to even criticize the govt. That's where Congress stands today.

  • @anj3067
    @anj3067 Рік тому +2

    Wonderful to hear Tharoor's mature democratic view.. 👌🏻

  • @vrindadevi5659
    @vrindadevi5659 Рік тому +2

    I am proud of my country and Its prime minister.

  • @msnageshrao
    @msnageshrao Рік тому +2

    Why BBC did not make documentary on plight of kashmiri pandiths who had to flee from their home land?

    • @princerajput3864
      @princerajput3864 Рік тому

      Bana chuke h ...dekh le

    • @stayreasonablestayreasonab8133
      @stayreasonablestayreasonab8133 Рік тому

      I used to have some respect for BBC earlier. Now, after they have stripped themselves naked, I got to know what they really are.

    • @rorsail
      @rorsail Рік тому +2

      @@princerajput3864 no. There's no such documentary by the BBC.

    • @princerajput3864
      @princerajput3864 Рік тому

      @@rorsail dekh mil jaegi

    • @rorsail
      @rorsail Рік тому

      Because BBC is filled with closet islamists and they don't care about that issue.

  • @SagarPatil-ts2mp
    @SagarPatil-ts2mp Рік тому

    Our Representative at the global level is getting blamed after the Honorable SC have given him clean chit , Doesn't It disrespect our judicial system and us ? That too when India is hosting G20. How can we ignore it ?

  • @kmochhary6160
    @kmochhary6160 Рік тому +1

    The ruling dispensation at the centre is extremely intolerant to the critical and uncharitable comments made by the opposition leaders and independent journalists.

    • @hrishihru
      @hrishihru Рік тому

      independent ? :D :D .... they are all presstitutes

  • @jijyat7956
    @jijyat7956 Рік тому

    Send the Link for Modi documentary

  • @manjunathnanjmy26
    @manjunathnanjmy26 Рік тому

    Dimmis, Sahebs, Coloniality and Commies but Hindus need to be matured in action!!! Kudos

  • @vpkumar1950
    @vpkumar1950 Рік тому

    How is mojo an independent channel. I see it a bit scared.

  • @rashidjafry1552
    @rashidjafry1552 Рік тому +5

    Your thoughts and intelligence are beyond praise. It's always a pleasure listening to you. God Bless

  • @hameed7939
    @hameed7939 Рік тому +2

    Like wise the issue of colonialism is dead in 1947 when India got independence from Britain then why on earth Mr.Modi's minions in the foreign ministry spoke to presspersons about this.The involvement of Mr.Modi directly in the 2002 Gujarat pogrom is well-established and well-know even before this BBC's documentary was broadcasted. But what the BBC's documentary does is to give credibility to the "allegations" that Mr.Modi was the one who gave a free hand and even worse was directly involved in the 2002 pogrom.

    • @rjhaveri8bh
      @rjhaveri8bh Рік тому

      Prime minister Modi under went a rigorous SIT and court process to be acquitted from any involvement.
      But the Congress party of india faced no trial for colluding with the Pakistani trained Muslims who burned godhra train.. The Congress faced no trial for genocide of sikhs in punjab.. The American faced no trial for the genocide of red Indians, the Canadians faced no trial for the killing of their native population.. The Australians faced no trials for genocide of native aborgine population of Australia.. The British royal pedophile family and never faced any trials for the rape of children, women and for killing of millions of indians. Now the left liberal media will not talk about any of these genocides because they have an agenda against the hindu prime minister of india Mr.Modi.. These Psedo secular media and journalists did not want to support Kashmir files such people are Pakistani hashish smokers who will only support those who pay them money this is why I called journalists are same as prostitutes.. The Muslims killed 400 million humans where is the trial and apologies..

  • @rajbali4
    @rajbali4 Рік тому

    Why isn't this guy leader of the opposition is beyond me?

  • @satindra21
    @satindra21 Рік тому

    Thank you, Barkha in letting Dr Tharoor join you ‘alive’.😂

  • @kaushal9566
    @kaushal9566 Рік тому

    Don't be surprised Mr. Tharoor about Government 😜

  • @kavitakhanna177
    @kavitakhanna177 Рік тому

    Govt should not have reacted at all. We all know what happened and it is for us to accept or not. There was a mass killing in the 2nd wave of COVID.

  • @KR-wz1sn
    @KR-wz1sn Рік тому +3

    Where is the link? Please share it. We all would like to see what the BJP is afraid of.

  • @navinharia1243
    @navinharia1243 Рік тому

    Varifocal contact lenses makes her blink like crazy.

  • @bindir1421
    @bindir1421 Рік тому +1

    If the govt was bothered about public disorder they should have banned kashmir files.

    • @amtrailsinfra
      @amtrailsinfra Рік тому

      yes govt should also rebuild the jain and buddist temple that were once destroyed to build hindu temples

    • @bindir1421
      @bindir1421 Рік тому +1

      @@amtrailsinfra new information

    • @amtrailsinfra
      @amtrailsinfra Рік тому

      @@bindir1421 get educated.. study proper history book

  • @anarkali_217
    @anarkali_217 Рік тому

    Those who think this is not hypocrisy are deaf n blind.

  • @PawarNitin45
    @PawarNitin45 Рік тому

    Govt is right on banning documentary instead they should ban bbc in India.

  • @willwell4450
    @willwell4450 Рік тому +5

    He has very positive perception about who we are as a group when he says a documentary would not be a reason for public disorder, considering the fact a lot of chaos ensues after some WhatsApp forwards and messages. Heck Padmavat created a ruckus.

    • @arunjetli7909
      @arunjetli7909 Рік тому

      this guy is a fifth column supporter of imperialism and islamic exclusivist agenda

    • @gopaulangappan8407
      @gopaulangappan8407 Рік тому

      Absolute trash from two hoars in India

    • @arunjetli7909
      @arunjetli7909 Рік тому

      so why did he criticize nupur Sharma dies she not have freedom of expression even about saying documented facts

  • @biswapriya1
    @biswapriya1 Рік тому

    Shashi Tharoor, your argument is surprisingly devoid of logic. When a country's apex court gives a clean chit to Modi about 2002 riots recently, and the persecution of the Muslim other shows no signs of abatement whatsoever, it's only logical that a film like this will be made in which the underbelly will be made apparent yet again. That it comes from a foreign channel should be of no concern at all. What can be said however, that the BBC will naturally have a westerner's limitations with respect to analysing in greater detail the majoritarianism in India. Hence, something on the subject by honest Indian journalists as a follow up might add to this very important subject.

  • @eltiger-thetiger6915
    @eltiger-thetiger6915 Рік тому

    You're asking a person who has subdued Indian judicial system in his wife's murder about a 2002.. wow.. great journalism 👏🏻👍🏻👌🏻.

  • @JJ-hi4gh
    @JJ-hi4gh Рік тому +4

    He is not just an opponent of the british narrative about their colonial past but more importantly he is a congress party parliament member whose opinion on matters like these are highly political

    • @subbaraotanguturu9271
      @subbaraotanguturu9271 Рік тому +1

      He face Antony's son, Rahul Antony's fate if he doesn't support BBC's narrative. Poor creature!

  • @ashfaqali5083
    @ashfaqali5083 Рік тому +2

    Can't agree with the thing that we hv moved on... If Mr Modi was involved in the genocide, which he was, why hasn't he been punished yet is what should concern every indian. Can we afford such unjust precedent in a pluralistic nation... Tharoor you can do better.

    • @Harsh-rf9k
      @Harsh-rf9k Рік тому

      U don't believe in supreme court
      Only in asmani kitab
      That's why we r not developing

    • @ashfaqali5083
      @ashfaqali5083 Рік тому

      @@Harsh-rf9k i hv full faith in constitution not the dishonest and ambitious executives, like i hv faith in the book not the molvis. The court which hears arnabs plea in a week's time takes years to hear a plea on downgradation n disempowerment of a state.
      We r not progressing because of andhbhakts like urself who see God's in livestock and value what comes out of smones digestive canal over human blood.

  • @devarajv7308
    @devarajv7308 Рік тому

    I'm sure though the court has relived tharoor in Sunanda's case if some channel pickup the same case and comes with controversial projection it's sure tharoor will not sit quiet and give the same reply.

    • @dattatrayadas7846
      @dattatrayadas7846 Рік тому

      Sure, he might go to court, instead of triggering emergency powers, unlike our respected butcher...oh wait our PM.

  • @abrahamkoshie1967
    @abrahamkoshie1967 Рік тому

    Government over reaction is simply because of guilty conscience...

  • @chakraborti1212
    @chakraborti1212 Рік тому

    Agree entirely that the Govt has managed to pump up curiosity for the BBC documentary even among those those who would have normally never cared. Ideally the best slap that you can service on the perpetrator of something you don't like is to ignore that entity. In banning the object , we only prove that we are still enamored of the ways of our colonial masters who used to prohibit seditious literature hoping that such stupid action would stay rebellion.

  • @nandananraghu4756
    @nandananraghu4756 Рік тому +1

    I dont agree with Shashi Tharoor. After seeing this documentary portraying Modi as a Villain, people in our country naturally will form a feeling that BJP and Modi are against the Muslims. Whereas the fact is Modi took appropriate action and was not instrumental for the riots, where many Hindus too were killed. Supreme Court after 20 years of hearings gave a clean chit to Modi.

  • @uaeindi
    @uaeindi Рік тому

    Govt did make this a big issue as govt wants everyone to vote based on religion

  • @josephjohn7317
    @josephjohn7317 Рік тому

    Had the leaders in the BJP ignored the documentary it would certainly have helped the party but unfortunately by condemning it had ignited the interest even in those not interested at all in the events of such distant past to view it & draw conclusions therefrom...

    • @THUGPUTIN
      @THUGPUTIN Рік тому +1

      Lol, what are smoking...? Do you even know how vote bank works?
      Bjp is winning with congress/uk strategy.. Divide and rule..
      Bjp ignoring this is huge loss... Bjp wants people to watch this just like kashmir files so the best way is to ban it(kashmir files became popular before release because many called for ban...) same goes to pathaan movie...
      This proves bias of global media who are supporting ravish Kumar, Dhruv rathee etc...
      And global media wants to change govt in India to stop Indian development... This narrative will bring in votes... Simple.. Facts..
      Congress was pushing bjp is with uk/eu/usa leaving Russia behind... Bjp sticking with Russia during war and this documentary proves bjp right...
      Pakistan and UK criticising any govt is viewed as positive in Indian vote bank politics😂🤣😂

  • @georgekoshy6253
    @georgekoshy6253 Рік тому

    A government that practising media control could not have reacted in any other way. Why does tharoor suddenly lose interest in history. We move on despite history.

  • @SureshKumar-iy3yd
    @SureshKumar-iy3yd Рік тому +1

    It is curious the govt considers two decades as a very long period and therefore raking up muck from that period is motivated. But z it has no qualms about going after Aurangazeb, who allegedly committed crimes over 400 years ago!

  • @kavitakhanna177
    @kavitakhanna177 Рік тому

    Are we going to is equal to for every situation. Emergency was bad, but does it allow us to ignore the current events. I remember during the emergency people were talking against it in their circles. Can you imagine this now??? Iam talking about people in govt set up. IT WAS A.DECLARED.EMERGENCY.

  • @bangaloretrailrider2472
    @bangaloretrailrider2472 Рік тому

    Nobody would not even have thought twice about this documentary if not for the response of our Government. If there is nothing true about it why bother??? Only those who something to hide will overreact.

    • @rorsail
      @rorsail Рік тому

      That's obviously not true considering how much we Indians love to hype anything that anyone says about us. Especially by the west. It would create countless media debates and maybe even violence. It was absolutely right to block such propaganda.

  • @shanindia100
    @shanindia100 Рік тому

    Indeed! Just because favourable judges, handpicked probably for the purpose, gave a clean chit, it doesn't fool all Indians! Sorry! Would have thought Tharoor to be more sensible. After all the Kohinoor, Jallianwala Bagh etc is little more than 22 years!! Why should you speak about those. Losing respect for Tharoor! Sad.

  • @vrindadevi5659
    @vrindadevi5659 Рік тому

    Shashi should distance away from Congress to maintain his image.