The Worst Possible Way to Lose a B-17

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 сер 2022
  • This is the tragic story of B-17 Flying Fortress "Miss Donna Mae" and how she would be destroyed by a friendly bomb. Made using IL-2 Sturmovik and War Thunder. #Shorts #WW2History #WarThunder
    If you want to support TJ3 History and get access to special VIP content, please check out these awesome links!
    Patreon - / tj3history
    TJ3 Gaming Merch Store!
    teespring.com/stores/tj3-gami...
    Follow me on social media for updates!
    Discord - / discord
    Twitter - TJ3History
    Twitch - Twitch.com/TJ3Gaming
    Instagram - TJ3History

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,2 тис.

  • @KingslayaJ
    @KingslayaJ Рік тому +2604

    Dying by friendly fire has to be one of the worst and most frustrating ways to die

    • @bacoon6499
      @bacoon6499 Рік тому +57

      well in this case they likely didn't know what had hit them, but i'm sure other cases of friendly fire in world war one and two would have been frustrating for both parties

    • @damndirtyrandy7721
      @damndirtyrandy7721 Рік тому +56

      Worse than a death spiral? 🤔 oh, you don’t know what a death spiral is? 😂 thought so. It is called a death spiral because the centrifugal forces of the fall make it impossible for the crew to move and bail out, meaning you have plenty of time to complicate your mortality before impact.

    • @bacoon6499
      @bacoon6499 Рік тому

      @@damndirtyrandy7721 no one asked randy and no one cares you know about the death spiral

    • @BritishGrenadier69
      @BritishGrenadier69 Рік тому

      ​@@damndirtyrandy7721 Oh stfu know it all. They know that. They are right, friendly fire IS the worst and most frustrating ways to die.

    • @noth1ngtoseehere
      @noth1ngtoseehere Рік тому +1

      You cant be talking. You choke your men with the Force.

  • @catfish252
    @catfish252 8 місяців тому +733

    I feel terrible for the crew that dropped that weapon on the Miss Donna Mae, I'd hate to have to live with that memory.

    • @SEPK09
      @SEPK09 4 місяці тому +31

      war will always have human error

    • @jhardycarroll
      @jhardycarroll 4 місяці тому +9

      The bombsight decides when to drop the bombs, not the bombardier

    • @wllwll-zh7ig
      @wllwll-zh7ig 4 місяці тому

      They probably didn't. War is Hell on earth. Unfortunately politicians love it and make fortune after fortune. America must pay close attention and do our duties as freedom loving citizens and make damn sure government is afraid of doing anything less than what is right for the country and the citizens who employ them. Criminals have hyjacked America government because the people failed. Government can't be trusted and need majority of citizens babysitting them. America is in for very hard times and politicians and their friends all live like royalty off of citizens debt.

    • @billymadison8574
      @billymadison8574 4 місяці тому +68

      ​@@jhardycarroll...huh? The "bombsight" is just the tool to measure ground speed & calculate impact location. Bombadiers were the literal "bomb aimers" who targeted & controlled their Norden sights & the release of muntions.

    • @LeydenAigg
      @LeydenAigg 3 місяці тому +5

      ​@@jhardycarroll"Look, Ma! It's a rawgabbit!"

  • @MrRennen
    @MrRennen Рік тому +323

    The guilt of killing a comrade or a friend must have been painful

    • @DeFunnyGuy1
      @DeFunnyGuy1 10 місяців тому +5

      You need to also mention the rest of the crew that died
      how dare you

    • @75732
      @75732 4 місяці тому +25

      @@DeFunnyGuy1wdym how dare you everyone in that squad was was probally friends so when he says lost a comrade it refers to everyone

    • @jono.pom-downunder
      @jono.pom-downunder 4 місяці тому

      Yet the keep doing it

    • @PauloPereira-jj4jv
      @PauloPereira-jj4jv 4 місяці тому +11

      ​@@DeFunnyGuy1... how dare you make such stupid comment?

    • @aisaxonawiat6484
      @aisaxonawiat6484 4 місяці тому +1

      ​@@DeFunnyGuy1....idiot

  • @TJ3
    @TJ3 Рік тому +789

    Also, meant to say "Horizontal Stabilzer" here! Sorry.

    • @amppari_234
      @amppari_234 Рік тому +7

      Isn't it the vertical stabilizer, as it stabilizes the vertical axis?

    • @User2o2
      @User2o2 Рік тому +30

      @@amppari_234 No, because the stabilizer is horizontal to the tail. The vertical stabilizer is the one that goes up and down and holds the rudder.

    • @Fox2-Videos
      @Fox2-Videos Рік тому +5

      @@amppari_234 It’s kind of confusing lol. User2o2 explained it pretty well

    • @amppari_234
      @amppari_234 Рік тому +1

      ​@@User2o2oh, ok.

    • @brianjob3018
      @brianjob3018 Рік тому +1

      ​@@User2o2 You mean back and forth, not up and down.

  • @tehscope9422
    @tehscope9422 Рік тому +677

    I'm really surprised that didn't happen more often considering how many planes took part in each sortie.

    • @iblockpuncheswithmyface1490
      @iblockpuncheswithmyface1490 10 місяців тому +24

      And how many bombs were flying around.

    • @SirDaffyD
      @SirDaffyD 10 місяців тому +112

      It did happen more often. It just happened that a camera was filming from the offending bomber at the time.

    • @Dilley_G45
      @Dilley_G45 9 місяців тому +39

      It did happen a bit, not always on film. It was one of the concerns the RAF had when introducing the bomber stream but they calculated it as negligible

    • @ericmccaffer6113
      @ericmccaffer6113 7 місяців тому +12

      .. that is why they fly in strategic formations..

    • @tehscope9422
      @tehscope9422 7 місяців тому +20

      @@ericmccaffer6113 I think they flew in formation foe better protection against German fighters.

  • @jwhoward182
    @jwhoward182 3 місяці тому +63

    My father was a WW2 combat veteran in the 15th AF. He did not want to talk about missions he flew until the last few years of his life. The horror of this issue was one thing he did tell me about.

    • @Gwaithmir
      @Gwaithmir 3 місяці тому +9

      I can understand why. I served in Vietnam for 2½ years. I can't talk about some of my experiences to this day.

    • @bluskytoo
      @bluskytoo 3 місяці тому +5

      my father was also in the 15th AF on B-24s , he had nightmares every single night of his life.

    • @liesenden
      @liesenden 3 місяці тому +1

      I"m also cannot tell my experience to you all because its a secret,so I will keep it secret in my secret folder.

    • @earlhester825
      @earlhester825 3 місяці тому +1

      Mishaps like this are part of war. Its sad but true. War is horrific on all levels. I feel for the pilots and bombardier that dropped those bombs

  • @afmoney161
    @afmoney161 4 місяці тому +94

    Sadly this was really common early on in the war. Bombardier's would be so focused on keeping the norden bomb sight on the target that they would drift on top of other aircraft and drop. They started having only the lead aircraft sight the target and all the other bomber would drop on that que. Reduced them having to all adjust in formation, saved alot of lives.

    • @riccicrozzie8204
      @riccicrozzie8204 4 місяці тому +7

      Norden*

    • @afmoney161
      @afmoney161 4 місяці тому +6

      @@riccicrozzie8204 Good catch stupid autocorrect!

    • @greenwave819
      @greenwave819 3 місяці тому +3

      actually it wasn't very common

    • @afmoney161
      @afmoney161 3 місяці тому

      @@greenwave819 So tell me why the procedure changed?

    • @briwire138
      @briwire138 3 місяці тому +2

      I thought the lead aircraft of the flight carried out the aiming and the remaining aircraft released their load when they saw him drop his bombs.

  • @samwilliams4176
    @samwilliams4176 Рік тому +129

    Fun fact that photo was taken from the bomber Kismet. I knew the belly turret gunner, Wilbur Richardson, he was on that flight and remembered when that happened.

    • @zachlukman5766
      @zachlukman5766 10 місяців тому +6

      That was fun 😮

    • @randybackgammon890
      @randybackgammon890 4 місяці тому +1

      Yea some fun that

    • @Outlaw_j84
      @Outlaw_j84 4 місяці тому

      Well why didn’t he say anything?? He just watched it happen?

    • @samwilliams4176
      @samwilliams4176 4 місяці тому +5

      @@Outlaw_j84 he was a belly turret gunner. There isn’t really a way to communicate to other planes from his position. Let alone in the middle of looking for enemy fighters. The plane that dropped the bombs was above his airplane too. However being suspended underneath his airplane doesn’t really give him the best view of what’s happening above.

    • @robertjensen1048
      @robertjensen1048 3 місяці тому +3

      The cat my wife owned when I met her was named Kismet. That cat hated me and I hated him in return.

  • @jefferyepstein9210
    @jefferyepstein9210 3 місяці тому +61

    This sort of thing happened in Vietnam as well. My uncle and his navigator were flying an F105 when another jet released its drop tank and it struck my uncles plane. They were able to eject but his navigator was killed during the ejection. My uncle was confirmed as being alive and captured however he passed away while being held prisoner.

    • @cardinalbob1
      @cardinalbob1 3 місяці тому +11

      Punching out can be dangerous! Even under so-called good conditions. Bless his soul.

    • @jmjones7897
      @jmjones7897 2 місяці тому +5

      RIP.
      Hell of a way to go

    • @av8va
      @av8va 2 місяці тому +3

      FYI, an F-105 carried an Electronic Warfare Officer, not a Navigator. The 2-seat versions were made for detecting and destroying SAM sites. Called by their mission designation, they were known as Wild Weasels. Weasels brave and aggressive crews, heroes all.

    • @jefferyepstein9210
      @jefferyepstein9210 2 місяці тому

      @av8va Thanks for the information. This is their story if interested.
      Accounted For 06/27/1983
      Name: Larry William Biediger
      Rank/Branch: United States Air Force/O4
      Unit: 354th Tactical Fighter Squadron
      Date of Birth: 23 April 1933
      Home City of Record: LA COSTE TX
      Date of Loss: 28 January 1967
      Country of Loss: North Vietnam
      Loss Coordinates: 215800 North 1052500 East
      Status (in 1973): Missing in Action/PFOD
      Category: 2
      Aircraft/Vehicle/Ground: F105D
      Missions:
      Other Personnel in Incident: Claude Silva, missing
      Refno: 0586
      Source: Compiled by P.O.W. NETWORK from one or more of the following: raw
      data from U.S. Government agency sources, correspondence with POW/MIA
      families, published sources, interviews and CACCF = Combined Action
      Combat Casualty File. 2020
      REMARKS: REMAINS RETURNED 06/03/83
      CACCF CRASH/PILOT
      KNOWN CAPTURED/VERY ILL APRIL 1967 DIED
      No further information available at this time.

    • @duartesimoes508
      @duartesimoes508 2 місяці тому +1

      The North Vietnamese prisons were at least as horrible as if run by the Gestapo or NKVD. That people like MacCan were able to withstand such savagery and survive is breathtaking. My sincere condolences.

  • @RonaldHawes-sr3cr
    @RonaldHawes-sr3cr 8 місяців тому +116

    My stepfather was the sole survivor of his B-17 crash. Tail number 911. he was 23 years old on his 23rd mission flying over Austria out of Italy.

    • @danielleahy15
      @danielleahy15 4 місяці тому +3

      What position was he in?

    • @BarkerVancity
      @BarkerVancity 4 місяці тому +13

      my grandfather survived a crash in a bristol blenheim. crashed it in the desert after germans sabotaged it. was considered missing in actions for a few weeks till he was able to contact base. had burns all over his body, but the didnt look to bad. survived the desert because a random caravan with camels found him

    • @Outlaw_j84
      @Outlaw_j84 4 місяці тому +8

      And my step father was General Patton

    • @robertjensen1048
      @robertjensen1048 3 місяці тому +2

      @@BarkerVancityWas he the airman who hid his injured girlfriend in cave and then went for help?

    • @abelis644
      @abelis644 3 місяці тому +15

      ​​@@BarkerVancity
      My Dad was a small French kid, born in Tunisia, living on a farm during WWII.
      There was an Allied airfield nearby.
      My Dad had 5 older sisters, in their late teens and the Spitfire pilots, Canadians and Americans, would often visit, have dinner, hang out.
      One day a Spitfire crash-landed in the field behind the farm.
      My Dad ran up to see.
      The pilot was fine thankfully but the plane was toast.
      The pilot decided to give my Dad the altimeter off his plane & unscrewed it.
      A Jeep arrived just as the pilot was giving my Dad his new "toy"... but it was quickly grabbed by a superior officer.
      Instead, they gave my Dad the little back tire!
      😂😂😂
      My poor Dad bemoaned that Altimeter decades later!
      I've looked for the names of the pilots he would talk about but he didn't speak English as a child back, so I'm not sure if the names were right.
      I also don't know if these were first or last names.
      There was a Marshall, maybe Martial, a Cohen, a McDuff...
      Marshall may in fact have been one perdon, Marshall Cohen, I'm not sure...
      I know they flew Spitfires.
      I think the airbase was near Le Kef in Tunisia.
      I wish I could have found these men for my Dad years ago, but we didn't have the internet then.
      Incidentally, the reason I'm Canadian today is thanks to those wonderful fighters who made such an impression on both my Mom & Dad that they decided to immigrate here.
      I thank my lucky stars everyday for their choice!
      Thanks for listening!😊
      Isabelle, Victoria British Columbia.👋🇨🇦🌠

  • @nickhaynie5980
    @nickhaynie5980 8 місяців тому +47

    Unfortunately, there's also footage of a similar accident involving a B-24 Liberator. A bomb dropped from a bomber above tore the left wing off the B-24 causing it to fall from the sky

    • @davidschaadt3460
      @davidschaadt3460 4 місяці тому +1

      A real close up view also ,really sad(Horrific).🙏🪖🙏

    • @TheGodParticle
      @TheGodParticle 4 місяці тому +4

      Yeah I've seen that, all the fuel starts spraying out, I don't think the crew escaped that sadly.

    • @fleebee3639
      @fleebee3639 4 місяці тому +1

      If I remember correctly that was a low level bombing mission on a Ploesti, Romanian refinery or oil field. There was a stream of bombs falling in front of the B24 and one went right through the left wing between the inboard engine and wing root. It instantaneously burst into flames as the wing folded.

    • @owainglyndwr16
      @owainglyndwr16 3 місяці тому

      Pathe News claimed the B24 was hit by enemy fire. Why is friendly fire covered up? It happens regularly in most wars truth be known.

    • @jeffreyyucel9373
      @jeffreyyucel9373 3 місяці тому +3

      @@fleebee3639 Yes, it was the bombing raid on the oil fields at Ploiesti where that footage is from. And those were just the unlucky few who had cameras on them filming. Think about how many more happened that didn’t get caught on camera. Especially when flying in the box formation and taking hits from the flak guns drifting you over the top of another B-17 four stacks beneath you. Or getting moved out of position from incoming bogeys hitting you with 20mm cannon rounds.

  • @lukewise1227
    @lukewise1227 4 місяці тому +10

    All those .50's firing in the air when under attack, hundreds of aircraft trying to form up, sometimes at night, before flying to the target, damaged aircraft flying into others, allied or axis. It all occurred, there is numerous interviews and written documents on it. It was just not spoken about, on either side of the war.

  • @ivansanta-maria1328
    @ivansanta-maria1328 Рік тому +82

    I always wondered about that like when they were flying in those formations stacked on top of each other if that could happen if bombs from another bomber could accidentally drop on someone underneath probably happen more than once

    • @jadenhumphrey8778
      @jadenhumphrey8778 Рік тому +1

      Yeah same

    • @georgielancaster1356
      @georgielancaster1356 9 місяців тому +5

      It did happen quite a bit, even worse in the 1,000 bomber raids.
      Also, Fighters on same side, sometimes flew into each other - or into an enemy fighter - though there are several recordings of fighter pilots unable to bring down a German bomber, out of ammunition, deliberately flew into the bomber, to stop it. One was definitely a Polish fighter pilot.
      Plus a number of bombers flew into each other - horrifying.
      I think a RAF fighter pilot deliberately flew into a German bomber, aiming for Buckingham Palace, and the King of England.
      He planned it to try to survive himself, and he did.
      Can't remember his name. But he became an instant hero.

    • @Codename_Horizon
      @Codename_Horizon 9 місяців тому

      @@georgielancaster1356hè found the tail section of the German bomber to be inviting

    • @exceptionalanimations1508
      @exceptionalanimations1508 8 місяців тому +1

      yea I think there are pictures even of a bomber that got a bomb straight through the fuselage, but it survived

    • @jonnyharris2612
      @jonnyharris2612 5 місяців тому

      ​@@georgielancaster1356 i think there were a lot of great Polish pilots that flew for the Allies

  • @yankeecornbread8464
    @yankeecornbread8464 4 місяці тому +5

    Not to mention the sad destruction of those on the ground. Sometimes parents receive word that their son has fallen. Sometimes it’s the soldiers who get the notice.

  • @heathhalfhill6401
    @heathhalfhill6401 3 місяці тому +29

    Over 30,000 airmen died in WW2. Such heroic and brave very young men. Greatest generation imo ever. Respect💯

    • @damedusa5107
      @damedusa5107 3 місяці тому +2

      Over 30000? You are way off. Lots lots more than that.

    • @Domdeone1
      @Domdeone1 3 місяці тому

      55,000 approx & 18,000 injured or taken POW

    • @thepeanut2681
      @thepeanut2681 Місяць тому

      ​@@damedusa5107 note the "over" part

    • @damedusa5107
      @damedusa5107 Місяць тому

      @@thepeanut2681 if you want to get technical, USA, British, allied ??? He doesn’t state. But if it’s allied the numbers are well over 150000

  • @_Pawel_
    @_Pawel_ Рік тому +43

    War Thunder is very good for record videos type. 👍👍 Good work

  • @treylem3
    @treylem3 4 місяці тому +8

    Depicted in this animated vid, that was the Horizontal Stabilizer that was damaged by the bomb dropped, not the "vertical stabilizer". However, the Vertical stabilizer likely broke off afterwards, as aerodynamic loads were exceeded. ✌️

  • @jordannewsom4578
    @jordannewsom4578 11 місяців тому +16

    The bomb hit the horizontal stabilizer not the vertical stabilizer.

    • @cdncitizen4700
      @cdncitizen4700 4 місяці тому +2

      Came here looking for anyone else who spotted this error.

    • @Outlaw_j84
      @Outlaw_j84 4 місяці тому

      👍🏼

    • @robertjensen1048
      @robertjensen1048 3 місяці тому +1

      The worst accidents are caused by hitting the 45-degree stabilizers.

    • @Svannuta
      @Svannuta 3 місяці тому

      ​@@robertjensen1048wait till you damage the destabilizers

  • @AbnRgr
    @AbnRgr 3 місяці тому +2

    My dad was a B 17 bombardier. Said what scared him the most was knowing the hundreds of aircraft all jinking around for position were mostly flown by young 20 something's like himself. So many accidents.

    • @AbnRgr
      @AbnRgr 3 місяці тому

      The AF won the sky, which controlled the ground which won the war. The horrors of trench warfare were avoided but many thousands of brave flyers died.

  • @olderthanyoucali8512
    @olderthanyoucali8512 Рік тому +7

    Every death in Wartime is Tragic!

    • @StrategicBomberEnjoyer
      @StrategicBomberEnjoyer Рік тому +1

      Indeed

    • @randybackgammon890
      @randybackgammon890 4 місяці тому +1

      Those who send you have an odd opinion on that one

    • @Name-ps9fx
      @Name-ps9fx 2 місяці тому

      I was fortunate to have spoken with a WW2 bomber vet a few times before he passed away...he mentioned all the deaths he and his crew had caused, men, women, and children. It was just so overwhelming for him. I don't know if it had finally caught up to him, or if he'd had those regrets all his life post-war.
      RIP to all vets and civilians who had to experience war.

  • @limemason
    @limemason 7 місяців тому +3

    "Did we hit the target?"
    "Well, uh, not exactly."

  • @William-guy
    @William-guy Рік тому +51

    Damn that'd be the most pain in war thunder

  • @Thedogwithnoname677
    @Thedogwithnoname677 9 місяців тому +70

    The mission restarted because “Friendly Fire will not be tolerated”

  • @Astonman
    @Astonman 3 місяці тому +1

    It’s a miracle that this sort of incident did not happen more often. The crew who dropped must have been mortified. Affected them for life. Incredibly sad for all.

  • @lordhue
    @lordhue 4 місяці тому +4

    Fratricide is a reality in all warfare, even with the modern weapons and equipment of today. It’s something we work hard to avoid, and I’ll admit that every time I’ve had to release ordinance under direction rather than direct visual confirmation I had concerns about this reality.

  • @garry358
    @garry358 4 місяці тому +9

    Apparently that's how Glenn Miller was lost, his aircraft was underneath a bomber which had to jettison its payload and that was that.

    • @bad74maverick1
      @bad74maverick1 3 місяці тому

      Glen Miller disappeared in 1944 aboard a civilian transport. He was trying to get to France after his flight was cancelled for bad weather. He obtained a seat on a transport through an officer friend of his. Because it wasn't allowed he didn't report to his chain of command he was leaving in a civilian transport and took off with another Lt Colonel aboard and were never seen again. He was missing for days before army command knew about it, the day after he disappeared the battle of the bulge began and the army was scrambling. There was no one who saw them after take off, there was no one who reported seeing the C-64 Norseman he was in. No one reported hitting an aircraft after jettisoning their ordnance.
      he simply disappeared, and nobody new for days.

    • @jonashellsborn7648
      @jonashellsborn7648 3 місяці тому

      ​@@bad74maverick1aaaand I read about this some months ago, that a gunner or similar reported "hey, theres a plane down there". Note that your argument is _technically_ correct as this guy didnt identify serial number nor nationality markings. This jettison zone was allegedly in the waters south of England.

    • @bad74maverick1
      @bad74maverick1 3 місяці тому

      @@jonashellsborn7648
      Edit: I said "Cite your sources for the "hey theres a plane down there" and how it's attributed to the Noorduyn UC-64A Norseman carrying Miller. Surly there is a date also attributed to your source that would put the bomber crew in the same area, at the same day, at a reasonable time."
      I realized you were citing Shaw's comment he made about what he thought happened in a return to base mission. Sorry about that. It's been a while since I studied this great mystery.
      The RAF Training Unit at Twinwood Farm, where Miller left from, had cancelled flights because the weather was so bad before he left anyway. They would have also been passing each other in opposite directions as Miller was heading toward France and the bomber would have been heading home if jettisoning bombs making hitting it almost impossible especially if not using bomb sights, maps and topography (to intercept it) and randomly dropping bombs as they passed one another at the exact same traverse. Also if it was in southern England it wouldn't have been miller as Twinwood Farm is closer to central England north of London which means Millers plane would have been heading south east to Paris from northern England and not in southern England.
      If you are referring to Shaw's interview and description, which I assume you are, not only were they off course, but the weather was so bad he wouldn't have seen the plane from the height they were at. In fact a navigator/observer in the same flight refuted what shaw said “Considering that we were jettisoning from an altitude of 3,000 feet with almost nil visibility, in my opinion it’s a ridiculous claim from any observer.”
      Dennis Spragg an investigator backed that up "The lowest altitude any Lancaster reported for a jettison was 5,000 feet,” he told the Guardian in 2017. “The recommended jettison altitude was 6,000 feet. One mile is 5,280 feet. A Norseman flying almost one mile below would have looked like an indistinct flyspeck.”. Shaws account was originally backed up by several other accounts but the other two didn't describe a monoplane and one account said the plane was flying in the same direction. It was also described as a kite, something the RAF used as markers, and they were flying in an official jettison area. Of the 100 plus bombers many indicated that they could barely see their wingtips, let alone so far below. Given the testimonies, I'd say there is little to no chance miller was in that area and that far off course. I would say it's most improbable.

    • @bad74maverick1
      @bad74maverick1 3 місяці тому +1

      @@jonashellsborn7648 UA-cam keeps deleting my replies to you. I will try to send them in sections. YT seems to hate discussions with facts and accounts involved.

    • @bad74maverick1
      @bad74maverick1 3 місяці тому

      ​@@jonashellsborn7648
      I believe the account you are referring to is Shaws account of that day. shaw stated that they saw a plane (kite) way down below as they jettisoned bombs in the south channel, where the zone was to dump them. Miller left RAF Twinwood Farm when they had grounded their training flights because of bad weather. Miller broke protocol and took a civilian transport which wasn't allowed and didn't inform his chain of command. From Twinwood Farm to Paris is central England north of London would mean flying in a southeast direction. To get to southern england they would have been far off course and since they took off from near london they would have known when and where they hit the coast.

  • @johnwtobin156
    @johnwtobin156 Рік тому +2

    "Friendly Fire" really sucks. 😢

  • @jamesdavide6744
    @jamesdavide6744 4 місяці тому +1

    Long time ago I read an article surmising that something similar may have happened to Glenn Miller. It is quite possible that his plane was below the clouds while above a formation of bombers returning from a scrubbed mission salvoed their bombs in the English Channel

  • @mariano7699
    @mariano7699 Рік тому +3

    Bedroom rivals eliminated in comprehensive styles

  • @YTlovesPedos
    @YTlovesPedos 4 місяці тому +21

    “We fought the wrong enemy” - Gen. Patton

    • @JoeMun
      @JoeMun 3 місяці тому +1

      No they did not, are you actually serious?

    • @1allanbmw
      @1allanbmw 3 місяці тому +3

      Patton was referring to the Russians.

    • @JoeMun
      @JoeMun 3 місяці тому +1

      @@1allanbmw no he wasn’t..

    • @tonyweaver2353
      @tonyweaver2353 3 місяці тому +1

      ​@@1allanbmwPatton was actually referring to ourselves hence the friendly fire

    • @therooster1339
      @therooster1339 3 місяці тому

      ​@@JoeMun yes he absolutely was. You shouldn't make seething comments since you obviously have zero knowledge of historically accurate history, and only regurgitate zionist supremacist propaganda

  • @hanskanns1710
    @hanskanns1710 4 місяці тому +2

    I bet there have been a lot of friendly fire by the gunners as well. Bullets don't stop after 500m

  • @dietmarfinster3176
    @dietmarfinster3176 4 місяці тому +1

    War is hell, even if you experience it at your own hands

  • @stoneman8387
    @stoneman8387 Рік тому +9

    Very dramatic. Funnily enough, it happened more often that one bomber put its load in front of or on the nose of the other. This happened even at night (no formation flight) more than 23 times.

    • @dukecraig2402
      @dukecraig2402 Рік тому +3

      Given the scope of the bombing campaign it's a wonder it didn't happen a lot more than that.

    • @benr.9628
      @benr.9628 Рік тому +3

      I couldn’t stop laughing as I read that

  • @bermandonahue5234
    @bermandonahue5234 Рік тому +5

    RIP …god bless those men

  • @StevenBaer-zv6lq
    @StevenBaer-zv6lq 3 місяці тому +1

    Death by friendly fire is actually the worst thing ever.

  • @andrewbranch4075
    @andrewbranch4075 4 місяці тому +1

    I saw footage of that happen to a B24. The bomb went right through the port wing root and she burst into flames. It was a sickening pointless thing to watch and I never found out if anyone got out.

  • @TJ3
    @TJ3 Рік тому +15

    Woooo, love this guy.

  • @terrydaniels8460
    @terrydaniels8460 Рік тому +3

    Amazing this is the kinda story that should have been lost never known. But it wasn't lost these poor souls story was told
    With a picture as proof
    Amazing

  • @rogerrendzak8055
    @rogerrendzak8055 4 місяці тому +2

    "Her vertical stabilizer would, break off". But, what we're seeing is, a horizontal stabilizer, disintegrating.

    • @AMCguy
      @AMCguy 4 місяці тому

      Vertical because it controls axis maneuvering and stability.

  • @TK-7173
    @TK-7173 Рік тому +1

    Me testing if friendly fire's on be like:. (All jokes aside this was a horrible accident, sheesh friendly fire's gotta be the worst way to go)

  • @NathanCoady
    @NathanCoady Рік тому +4

    My great uncle died in WW2 he flew a smaller plane

    • @guaporeturns9472
      @guaporeturns9472 6 місяців тому

      What plane?

    • @NathanCoady
      @NathanCoady 5 місяців тому

      @@guaporeturns9472 I forget but it was a big British plane

    • @guaporeturns9472
      @guaporeturns9472 5 місяців тому

      @@NathanCoady You just said it was a smaller plane..? 🤔 Please start making sense.

    • @NathanCoady
      @NathanCoady 5 місяців тому +1

      @@guaporeturns9472 mb but it was a Lancaster

    • @guaporeturns9472
      @guaporeturns9472 5 місяців тому

      @@NathanCoady Gotcha.. thanks for clarifying. Lancaster is a cool plane. They have one in some museum in southern Alberta I visited years ago.. was a big, beautiful plane.

  • @shawnhierlihy3690
    @shawnhierlihy3690 Рік тому +11

    My uncle was a Lanc pilot in WWII. On one mission they dropped the entire load (about twice that of a B-17 on normal raids) on a lanc below them. The plane was disintegrated. My uncle's comment, "the stupid bastard was out of formation".
    War is hell.

    • @StrategicBomberEnjoyer
      @StrategicBomberEnjoyer Рік тому

      Rest in peace to the poor crewman ❤

    • @DeFunnyGuy1
      @DeFunnyGuy1 10 місяців тому +1

      Your Uncle is a bastard for not respecting the crew

    • @thethirdman225
      @thethirdman225 5 місяців тому

      It happened to Flt Lt Bill Reid, V.C. too, though his aircraft was on the receiving end.

    • @randybackgammon890
      @randybackgammon890 4 місяці тому +1

      The formation was as much too blame.Impossibly tight to prevent such unfortunate occurrence happening .Especially at night.Your uncles reaction sounds callous but war can do that to a man.Its a bad thing at the best of times.✌️

  • @ImGoingSupersonic
    @ImGoingSupersonic 3 місяці тому +1

    That would be crazy having 1000s of feet to think about your guaranteed death.

  • @robertknight4378
    @robertknight4378 4 місяці тому +1

    Soldiers have been dying from Friendly Fire for years in several Wars it's sad☹

  • @jebby16
    @jebby16 Рік тому +8

    Friendly fire runs rampant in war.

    • @RockaRollaSteel
      @RockaRollaSteel 9 місяців тому

      And bombing civs still happens to this day. War never changes.

  • @realstraightedgepunk1191
    @realstraightedgepunk1191 Рік тому +5

    2nd worst way*

  • @Roadking556
    @Roadking556 4 місяці тому +1

    With friends like this who need enemies

  • @alexwilkins4410
    @alexwilkins4410 4 місяці тому +1

    It has been theorised that bandleader Glen Miller may have died the same way by flying under a formation of bombers while dropping their bombs

  • @MP-16productions
    @MP-16productions Рік тому +29

    Bro forgot to turn off friendly fire

    • @DeFunnyGuy1
      @DeFunnyGuy1 10 місяців тому +3

      Haha funny, but they have many people in these B-17's it is serious

    • @HaseebIhsan
      @HaseebIhsan 8 місяців тому

      okay nerd they deserved it
      @@DeFunnyGuy1

    • @snackmastersupreme
      @snackmastersupreme 5 місяців тому +1

      ​@ISee1994 how?

    • @snackmastersupreme
      @snackmastersupreme 5 місяців тому +1

      ​@@HaseebIhsanhow?

    • @Biervor4
      @Biervor4 5 місяців тому

      @@snackmastersupreme because they killed innocent civilians. Duh

  • @stevewilliams2560
    @stevewilliams2560 Рік тому +4

    God bless there souls🙏❤️

    • @DeFunnyGuy1
      @DeFunnyGuy1 10 місяців тому +1

      Finally someone actually respects the crew, everybody keeps making jokes, I have to admit they were funny but they never realize these are multiple people in there

  • @PvtRyder
    @PvtRyder Місяць тому +2

    That’s what I always wondered like has this actually ever happens and this video has answered my question thanks for this video

  • @christianifechukwu9865
    @christianifechukwu9865 3 місяці тому

    The screaming after the uncomfortable silence finally broke me....😂😂😂😂

  • @PIFFthePUFF420
    @PIFFthePUFF420 Рік тому +8

    bombing innocent civilians at Dresden.. some call it Karma

    • @DannyBoYfutube
      @DannyBoYfutube 7 місяців тому

      Every single country did it

    • @mizzyroro
      @mizzyroro 6 місяців тому

      Kraut.

    • @DannyBoYfutube
      @DannyBoYfutube 6 місяців тому

      @@mizzyroro your poop 💩 is made of kraut

    • @deadon4847
      @deadon4847 3 місяці тому

      Like the innocent civilians in Guernica, Spain in 1937 and Warsaw in 1939 or millions dying in the concentration camps?

  • @topphatt1312
    @topphatt1312 Рік тому +4

    “This is B-17 Flying Fortress Miss Donna Mae”
    Me: no that’s War Thunder

  • @deanottinger1616
    @deanottinger1616 Місяць тому

    I remembered a documentary on the History Channel (When it aired real actual documentaries.) that was about Bombing Raids of WWII.
    There was old footage of B17s flying in tight formations for protection during missions. On several records, Historians had to go over and inspect closely as some unfortunate crews had either got shot down by flak or friendly fire.
    Then there was the Churchhill Raids.

  • @user-hg6pq3rg9z
    @user-hg6pq3rg9z 3 місяці тому

    Poor soldiers.Even 80 years later I feel nothing but sorrow.

  • @larry-5561
    @larry-5561 Рік тому +4

    I'm Sorry for the Men and their Families who gave their lives for their country!
    GOD BLESS ALL WHO DIED IN ALL WARS!!

  • @metalcoffin6667
    @metalcoffin6667 Рік тому +4

    Love it how you used war thunder to make this video

  • @robertmetzger6467
    @robertmetzger6467 6 місяців тому +1

    I Saw Actual War Footage of The Bombers in an "F"d Up Formation and a Bomb took out a Wing of a B-17 a couple Guys got out

  • @KrautGoesWild
    @KrautGoesWild 3 місяці тому +1

    I remember seeing the photos in the manual to 'Secret Weapons of the Luftwaffe' for the first time.

  • @saxybeast128
    @saxybeast128 Рік тому +3

    Sure the officers on that plane got promoted and the enlisted saw jail time.

  • @just_violet
    @just_violet Рік тому +4

    Damn recreating this incredible event in War Thunder must have been fun

  • @user-zs3qr3xh5x
    @user-zs3qr3xh5x 2 місяці тому

    The way he said 'unfortunately perished' got me for a sec

  • @Codi500
    @Codi500 3 місяці тому +2

    Never trust your team mates

  • @Daniel-wd4jg
    @Daniel-wd4jg 3 місяці тому

    Mr. Bachman taught Biology @ Benson Tech Portland Oregon. B17 tail gunner. I was young and immature and never really appreciated the sacrifice and courage of this awesome Man.

  • @LudosErgoSum
    @LudosErgoSum 3 місяці тому +1

    Well, the never lived long enough to learn the lesson of the "high ground".

  • @TheGrievousReviews
    @TheGrievousReviews 2 місяці тому

    Peace to those who perished in Miss and those of Trudy who have to live with that memory.

  • @tonbopro
    @tonbopro 3 місяці тому

    drifting over friendlies is the one thing that scares us when the payloads are dropping

  • @B61thermonucleargravitybomb
    @B61thermonucleargravitybomb 3 місяці тому

    My grandpa had a similar experience, ye was flying a b24 liberator with napalm when an unscheduled b17 group flew underneath his group and got firebombed. It scared him for life and he eventually even wrote a book about it

  • @tperry5117
    @tperry5117 3 місяці тому

    I read an account of a gunner who said a huge amount of losses were from friendly fire from fellow gunners and mid air collisions.
    He stated that the losses were staggering from friendly fire or incidents.
    Especially at the first part of us entry

  • @johnheart6890
    @johnheart6890 3 місяці тому

    Oh Lord! That was so bad for the men that died, but can you imagine how bad the survivors felt after that catastrophe?

  • @lukehutchens4778
    @lukehutchens4778 3 місяці тому

    Such a tragedy...
    You know the crew responsible for accidentally hitting them with their bombs was absolutely devastated. Poor guys never wanted to hurt their fellow brothers in arms.
    Peace and Love To All ✌️

  • @Rocket351
    @Rocket351 3 місяці тому +2

    Vertical stabilizer? Last time I checked it was the horizontal stabilizer

  • @MBBRAVO-tw6qu
    @MBBRAVO-tw6qu Місяць тому +1

    They had to live with that forever....

  • @raydrexler5868
    @raydrexler5868 3 місяці тому

    My wife’s grandfather was a belly gunner in a 17 after he was in a 24 hunting U-boats. I don’t know how he made it through over 50 missions but I am glad he did.

  • @jpol3808
    @jpol3808 3 місяці тому

    It's sad but still yet it is war history that needs to be told so it's crew is never forgotten.

  • @justsomeguy6240
    @justsomeguy6240 3 місяці тому

    Imagine being responsible for that. I’d never sleep again.

  • @mikescarlett4704
    @mikescarlett4704 3 місяці тому +1

    Very peaceful, Thanks for sharing!

  • @frankblosse119
    @frankblosse119 3 місяці тому

    There's a lot of family Guy back in those days I hope those guys rest in peace God bless them

  • @bendanger6428
    @bendanger6428 3 місяці тому +1

    Looks like something went through the leading edge of the left wing too.

  • @stevedavis5704
    @stevedavis5704 3 місяці тому

    My uncle had a book off photos from WWII put out by Readers Digest. One of the pictures was of a B-17 on a mission. In the picture another plane got under it as it released its payload. The picture shows a bomb striking the plane right on the wing by the fuselage and then the wing beginning to break off. No names were given but the affected bomber was lost.

  • @kellybreen5526
    @kellybreen5526 4 місяці тому

    I remember seeing these photos in “Air Wat Over Hitler’s Germany” which was published by American Heritage.
    I remember the caption reading that the crew bailed out.
    It is good to see the record set straight, even if it is not the ending that I would have hoped for.
    There are quite a few photos of bombers that made it home after getting hit by a “friendly” bomb.

  • @KornPop96
    @KornPop96 3 місяці тому +2

    "WHOOPS!"

  • @shoofly529
    @shoofly529 3 місяці тому

    I think this is actually shown in the movie 'Twelve O'Clock High'. Near the end of the movie, live footage of a bombing mission is used & a plane with that exact damage is shown flying-then a few secs later, & for only for a split second, that plane is shown diving out of control.

  • @peterfranks6243
    @peterfranks6243 3 місяці тому

    They say that's the way Glenn Miller got it, he was crossing the English channel when a bombing patrol ditched it's unused cargo over his plane

  • @FortisLeader
    @FortisLeader 3 місяці тому

    A similar thing happened with a flight a Lancaster bombers during a night raid, a bomber above dropped the payload just close enough for one bomb to completely take the whole rear of another Lancaster off.

  • @novakradakovic4752
    @novakradakovic4752 3 місяці тому

    Horrible way to go. R.I.P. to all those men in that B17. And all those that never got back.

  • @DcStuds
    @DcStuds Місяць тому

    Bro forgot to turn off friendly fire💀🙏🏽

  • @kirktravis5780
    @kirktravis5780 3 місяці тому

    How I learned to remember vertical vs horizontal is the v tail on a plane is for vertical they go up and down. Horizontal the cross bar goes side to side.

  • @theEVILone0130
    @theEVILone0130 Рік тому +2

    Damn that sucks.

  • @kingoftehstranges
    @kingoftehstranges Рік тому +1

    Mattel electronics presents: B-17 Bomber

  • @benjaminfrazier5419
    @benjaminfrazier5419 3 місяці тому

    Saw the photos in a book I borrowed from the library as a child: Air War Over Hitler’s Germany…never forgot it.

  • @ethanplaysroblox6253
    @ethanplaysroblox6253 11 днів тому

    B-17:so I learned this from a Japanese kamakaze manual

  • @Project_Atlas7
    @Project_Atlas7 3 місяці тому

    The Bomber normally takes a look before release and inform the pilot to head home after release.

  • @glenwoodriverresidentsgrou136
    @glenwoodriverresidentsgrou136 8 місяців тому +1

    It has been theorized that this is how Glenn Miller’s aircraft was lost while he was being transported across the channel in a Lysander. A group of RAF bombers that had been unable to find their target due to weather jettisoned their bombs over the channel on the return leg of the mission so as to avoid having to land with them. Though the wreckage was never found, some people think one of the bombs struck the Lysander which was in the area at the time.

    • @jerrychase4177
      @jerrychase4177 8 місяців тому

      Not many know this! "And now you know the rest of the story."

    • @davidschaadt3460
      @davidschaadt3460 4 місяці тому +1

      I've heard that account also.

  •  Місяць тому

    Imagine the guilt and shame suffered by accidentally causing the deaths of your comrades!

  • @OutragedCreator
    @OutragedCreator Рік тому +1

    My friend said the b17 would have gone straight up because if it were to go down the rudder would have been hit by a bomb he said but I didn’t believe him but did a bomb hit the rudder

  • @securitycameras6054
    @securitycameras6054 3 місяці тому

    No many made it to the 25th mission where they came home. That crew that did this most likely suffered a horrible fate themselves...

  • @zopEnglandzip
    @zopEnglandzip 3 місяці тому

    Some famous pics of a Wellington that made it back after a bomb went through the fuselage. Think I've seen similar pics of a b17.
    Hitting barrage balloons over England was also common for allied bombers, they apparently downed more allied aircraft than enemy.

  • @chrisk1732
    @chrisk1732 3 місяці тому

    That also occurred to British bomber squadrons coming in on formation bombing runs. Due to different altitudes & head wind speeds ,in broken cloud .dropping bombs whilst over other squadrons aircraft ..on the same bombing target.