Taco Báez Correct, and whenever they did 3-part harmonies, it was almost always (if not always) that way, with Paul singing the high notes, John singing the mid notes, and George singing the low notes.
JB Fonfrias Strictly on the technical side, Abbey Road, even 50 years ago, was the world leading recording studio, with resources that are found virtually nowhere today. Their microphones then are still considered the state of the art, musically speaking. The Neumann U47, which they seemed to own by the dozen, is so highly coveted as a vocal microphone today it is worth 50 times its original price. The studio was wholly owned and operated by EMI, who custom designed and built the recording electronics. There is literally no parallel to this anywhere else.
@@JoaoGabriel-lk9cv people on here are making out they are the very zenith of harmonies...theyre not......the reason they are charming is that they are DIY self taught 'brothers' who have spent so long together and are doing things their way. They are not say pin point accuracte harmonies in the way that say simon and garfunkel did, where they used to spend hours watching each others lips as they sang to get very close. As lennon himslef said, the beatles knew how to be competent in the studio but all their best stuff was in handburg, whi;lst obviously creatively thats nonsense, i know tightness wise he's probably right. The beatles main focus wasn't harmonies, they just became a good squad at doing it..but nothing they are doing here is mind blowing..it's just good competent harmonising..what is genius is their melodies.\Just an example here of clearly better reharsed harmonies....they are way more precise...obvs creatively they are no where near the beatles..but there were countless bands that could do what the beatles did harmonically..thats my point. ua-cam.com/video/VNUgsbKisp8/v-deo.html
That's the image that immediately springs to mind for me when I think of The Beatles. After they'd stopped wearing identical suits but before they went through the psychedelic/hippie phases.
@@cockshield : 1966 was no different than the previous four years, 1962-1965, whereby they did not appear wearing matching outfits, particularly at press conferences, which is where the photo above that you are referring to was taken. As of and during their last ever tour, North America 1966, they had NOT "... stopped wearing identical suits... " and remained dressed identically on stage as they had in previous years throughout their tours all around the world and as they still would at their last ever North American tour performance in 1966 at Candlestick Park, San Francisco. The Beatles always wore identical suits when performing in concert 1962 through 1966. Offstage, in these same years, they didn't necessarily wear matching outfits all the time. 1962: www.beatlesbible.com/wp/media/1962_beatles_041.jpg 1963:www.beatlesarchive.net/wp-content/uploads/50beatles29-The-Beatles-pose-sitting-on-a-wall-1963.jpg 1964:www.kansascity.com/entertainment/music-news-reviews/m3c2gn/picture740869/ALTERNATES/FREE_960/IMG_a1_beatles.jpg_2_1_UT1I22E4_L36299679.JPG 1965:4.bp.blogspot.com/-_fa7tF4X7cI/T1NWAwuV0_I/AAAAAAAADKw/nVpqwca0Nn8/s1600/uktour1965_promoshot.jpg 1966:farm3.staticflickr.com/2590/4132376982_a88aa631d1_b.jpg *********************************************** "IDENTICAL SUITS" THROUGHOUT 1966 : 1966 ON STAGE : LONDON - ua-cam.com/video/8TWuTj7bVrc/v-deo.html 1966 ON STAGE : WEST GERMANY - 2.bp.blogspot.com/-WkWulLjHn2w/UYsDtyYgTAI/AAAAAAAAS4U/sWxD0R5lLts/s1600/$(KGrHqQOKosFF0Bg+kSmBRerLeuGl!~~60_3.jpg 1966 ON STAGE : TOKYO - www.dw.com/image/16269317_304.jpg 1966 ON STAGE : SHEA STADIUM -mlb.mlb.com/assets/images/3/0/6/142732306/cuts/GettyImages_529142743_onrb2wal_j1jqkpud.jpg 1966 ON STAGE : AUGUST 29, SAN FRANCISCO - ksr-ugc.imgix.net/assets/012/425/249/232ae89e3fdac8f7b257c7d61865d6c1_original.jpg?crop=faces&w=1552&h=873&fit=crop&v=1463760576&auto=format&q=92&s=70b1d73983ac11eef6cf2d77cff222b3
practice practice practice :) there's a theory the Beatles were as good as they became because they did their "10,000 hours" playing those Hamburg clubs relentlessly before ever signing to Parlophone
What i can say is that Green Day's Worry Rock kinda have the same arrangement/sounds similar as this but ofc its just faster, maybe you can also when you keep on practising and trying?😊👍
They were SO lucky to have met up with George Martin and the fabulous Abbey Road. Studio 2 has a tiled wall that gave the vocals a special resonnance.. Plus the studio was full of wonderful tube amp and pre amps with Neuman 47 Ribbon mics. You could not have a better combo of talent and infrastructure to enable the Fabs to achieve briallence
Any imperfections add to the song. It gives tension in just the right spots. Freddie Mercury often went slightly off pitch to create a little tension and release in his songs creating a more diverse sound.
@@raesmith2164 That's my position as well. I've listened to all and collected all of the Beatles' catalog since the 60s. When Giles Martin remixes them, I notice every missing artifact and wonder why he would remove them? But if McCartney's ok with it, who am I to complain? However, I believe Lennon would say to leave them in...and then change his mind a week later, such is John.
@origamiChef would say it was the beatles' "puberty/adolescence" time... they were transitioning from that cute and teenage bopper band vibe to that hippie and meditating, older Beatles kinda vibe type of band😊😊👍👍
Man the Beatles really knew how the make music. Listen to how locked in their harmonies are. When will the leading rock/pop act in music ever be the most innovative and forward thinking again? Soon I hope
I was trying to perfect my reggae sound and stumbled upon these vocal videos now I can’t get John George Paul and Ringo out of my head again. “oh ,I can’t sleep at night” . It took me 35 years to 40 years to move on to other music . my friends joke around and laugh at me and say you’re stuck in the Beatles and they turn me onto music from the 70s 80s 90s and onward that I’ve never heard.Or didn’t care to hear because I was stuck in Beatle- land. And happy
Sometimes when harmonies are perfect it is almost as if there are more voices than singers. I’m not talking about double tracking, it’s harmonics than seem to come from another plane.
Well, it's said that John almost always double-tracked, he thought his voice was too thin. This sounds like everybody was doubled and I was thinking maybe even tripled. This is not to say that there aren't overtones or harmonics in play as well.
@@djinnisequoia When playing chords on my guitar, I hear notes that aren't there ... I try to isolate that tone individually from the chord form, and it's not there. Must be the overtones?
It's hard to believe that it took them years to get a record deal when you look at the absolute shit that we have to listen to today h how standards and talent have disappeared.
It didn't take years for them to get a record contract, really. In fact, they only did a few auditions for labels before EMI/George Martin decided to take them on. Before that they were a bar and small club band without realistic aspirations to something as lofty as a record contract. Only after Brian Epstein became their manager did recording even become a possibility. Once he was their manager, it was only months before they had a deal.
@@ChrisMaxfieldActs I think they were knocked back quite a lot-George Martin was Epstiens' last chance and he dreaded going back to Liverpool and having to tell them he had nothing for him.I think he may have made at least three business trips to London before Parlophone came up.
Musical geniuses at work....and this is just one song out of over 200 that were pretty much all hits. I don't think we'll ever see another band like this again.
The vocals are amazing and the way they harmonized was fantastic! Somehow their voices always blended well together! I like to hear Paul or John sing a song and hear the other two or three harmonize behind him. It always sounds great! That was one of their secret weapons! The Everly brothers had great harmonies too but they were brothers so their voices blended well naturally. The Beatles were just lucky, I guess, that their voices blended so well together. They sound like their related but their not. Brilliant singers!
The Everlys were huge influences on John and Paul, and they and George worked a lot from their earliest days on their harmonies. And the lucky accident of the four Beatles being in different registers added to their ability to be brilliant. Also, Ringo's very distinct voice can be heard in harmony on "Flying", "Maggie Mae", and "Carry That Weight".
“Making all his nowhere plans for nobody.” “In my life, I’ve loved them all.” Same album, same writer, same singer, same three chords: F Fmin C. Two very different songs. The genius of John is, I never noticed until I starting learning Beatle songs on ukulele 50 years later. The fun of singing along with The Beatles is you get to play so many songs three times, once for each voice.
those are not the chords. In My Life is in A and this song in E. So, the chords are F# minor, to Aminor back to E, in Nowhere Man, and in "IN MY Life"...D, Dm then A
True, thank you. I learn from fake books, so whatever key my arthritic left thumb can handle, I strum along. (To quote a Ringo song, I can play if it’s in C). I’m trying to point out the sweet uses of the VI-vi-I progression, with the minor plagal cadence. The Beatles rarely repeated the little tricks that make each recording unique, so I’m intrigued that this is hidden in plain sight.
I'm now hearing this song as a precursor to John's "Watching the Wheels"...Here he seems melancholy about the nowhereness; fourteen years later he was to claim and even champion it.
going down in history with the likes of Mozart! You know how you got bored hearing the same songs of certain bands! I still love and enjoy all the Beatles songs! It's great!
This was an unusual track in that John sang all the vocal parts, with the only exception of the last line “making all his nowhere plans for nobody”, in which Paul adds his voice. It’s one of the reasons why they very rarely performed it live.
My mum and dad saw them in London 1965 and the only part of a song they heard amid the screaming was ‘he’s a real...’ and it was screams for the rest of the show.
markyd h Nope. Try reading ANY of the Beatles’ biographical books. This song was unique in that John sang ALL the parts except the harmony on very last line. And, up until the end when smoking started to lower George’s range, he always sang the top harmony. Listen to All My Loving if you don’t believe.
Miguel Aguilar He wasn’t bored and tired, he was singing in the psicodelic way, before Strawberry Fields Forever or like I’m Only Sleeping, Tomorrow Never Knows, etc...
Even without the backing track and only the isolated it still sounds great except the silent guitar bridge in the middle. Truly shows the power of the beatles as musicians.
I could listen to their vocal harmonies forever
Ditto that Christian.
George's backup vocals aren't flashy, but he really does a great job with perfect lower tone harmonies. Rock solid!
their recordings will be around along time. hard to top them.
Same
The Beatles were unique in that they always sounded as good or even better live. A truly tight group with 4 very talented individuals.
When McCartney hits that high line at the end i still get chills.
day tripper me too
@@nolamccollian3211 I love it.
Fun fact: Goosebumps my music is actually called friesian!
It almost makes me cry, it’s too much too handle sometimes honestly
You're not the only one
Paul - High
John - Mid
George - Low
Taco Báez Correct, and whenever they did 3-part harmonies, it was almost always (if not always) that way, with Paul singing the high notes, John singing the mid notes, and George singing the low notes.
Ringo - Drums
@@briantaylor2.023 Yeahh. In "This Boy" and "Yes It Is" for example, Paul singing the high part, George the mid part and John the low part
i thought they all been quite high most times
@@trudisko1446 the melody, if you can discern it, is called the lead vocal.
Lennon has made my life so much better.
Lmao😂
Getting better all the time
@@Townshend90125 can't get no worse right?
@@ahdddd well it’s the new year so as Paul would say “it’s getting better all the time”
@@Townshend90125 and as you would say John, it can't get no worse
Hearing Paul's high harmony at the very end sends me shivers :-)
He sounds reminiscent of his solo career in the last line, such as 'Junior's Farm'.
Paul up to 1966, just magic
He is still magic..amazing musician!❤
@@Flash023 after 1966?
@@midapita different person in my opinion
Recorded over 50 years ago, & their vocal harmonies are still mind boggling today - bravo boys !
JB Fonfrias Strictly on the technical side, Abbey Road, even 50 years ago, was the world leading recording studio, with resources that are found virtually nowhere today. Their microphones then are still considered the state of the art, musically speaking. The Neumann U47, which they seemed to own by the dozen, is so highly coveted as a vocal microphone today it is worth 50 times its original price. The studio was wholly owned and operated by EMI, who custom designed and built the recording electronics. There is literally no parallel to this anywhere else.
Mind boggling is the perfect description of these ravishing harmonies. Been listening since 1964 and still can't figure it out.
Yeah but sadly one year after this was recorded one of them died in a car crash and was replaced with an imposter
They take vocals and harmonies to a whole new level.
no it's the melodies...there are countless brilliant harmonies through history
69birdboy no, it really is both
@@JoaoGabriel-lk9cv people on here are making out they are the very zenith of harmonies...theyre not......the reason they are charming is that they are DIY self taught 'brothers' who have spent so long together and are doing things their way. They are not say pin point accuracte harmonies in the way that say simon and garfunkel did, where they used to spend hours watching each others lips as they sang to get very close.
As lennon himslef said, the beatles knew how to be competent in the studio but all their best stuff was in handburg, whi;lst obviously creatively thats nonsense, i know tightness wise he's probably right. The beatles main focus wasn't harmonies, they just became a good squad at doing it..but nothing they are doing here is mind blowing..it's just good competent harmonising..what is genius is their melodies.\Just an example here of clearly better reharsed harmonies....they are way more precise...obvs creatively they are no where near the beatles..but there were countless bands that could do what the beatles did harmonically..thats my point.
ua-cam.com/video/VNUgsbKisp8/v-deo.html
@@69birdboy ... it's both
@@pedestrian_0 by name pedestrian by nature
What an iconic photo..
That's the image that immediately springs to mind for me when I think of The Beatles. After they'd stopped wearing identical suits but before they went through the psychedelic/hippie phases.
Yes, really love their late 65 to mid 66 look. Really stylish and modern, but still Beatleish
I hope everyone is noticing that Paul held the cigarette in his right hand if you know what I'm referring to ☝🏽️
@@cockshield : 1966 was no different than the previous four years, 1962-1965, whereby they did not appear wearing matching outfits, particularly at press conferences, which is where the photo above that you are referring to was taken.
As of and during their last ever tour, North America 1966, they had NOT "... stopped wearing identical suits... " and remained dressed identically on stage as they had in previous years throughout their tours all around the world and as they still would at their last ever North American tour performance in 1966 at Candlestick Park, San Francisco. The Beatles always wore identical suits when performing in concert 1962 through 1966. Offstage, in these same years, they didn't necessarily wear matching outfits all the time.
1962: www.beatlesbible.com/wp/media/1962_beatles_041.jpg
1963:www.beatlesarchive.net/wp-content/uploads/50beatles29-The-Beatles-pose-sitting-on-a-wall-1963.jpg
1964:www.kansascity.com/entertainment/music-news-reviews/m3c2gn/picture740869/ALTERNATES/FREE_960/IMG_a1_beatles.jpg_2_1_UT1I22E4_L36299679.JPG
1965:4.bp.blogspot.com/-_fa7tF4X7cI/T1NWAwuV0_I/AAAAAAAADKw/nVpqwca0Nn8/s1600/uktour1965_promoshot.jpg
1966:farm3.staticflickr.com/2590/4132376982_a88aa631d1_b.jpg
***********************************************
"IDENTICAL SUITS" THROUGHOUT 1966 :
1966 ON STAGE : LONDON - ua-cam.com/video/8TWuTj7bVrc/v-deo.html
1966 ON STAGE : WEST GERMANY - 2.bp.blogspot.com/-WkWulLjHn2w/UYsDtyYgTAI/AAAAAAAAS4U/sWxD0R5lLts/s1600/$(KGrHqQOKosFF0Bg+kSmBRerLeuGl!~~60_3.jpg
1966 ON STAGE : TOKYO - www.dw.com/image/16269317_304.jpg
1966 ON STAGE : SHEA STADIUM -mlb.mlb.com/assets/images/3/0/6/142732306/cuts/GettyImages_529142743_onrb2wal_j1jqkpud.jpg
1966 ON STAGE : AUGUST 29, SAN FRANCISCO - ksr-ugc.imgix.net/assets/012/425/249/232ae89e3fdac8f7b257c7d61865d6c1_original.jpg?crop=faces&w=1552&h=873&fit=crop&v=1463760576&auto=format&q=92&s=70b1d73983ac11eef6cf2d77cff222b3
I wonder if he finished that cigarette. I wonder if that cigarette finished him?
They are so good that they’d get more of my money for an isolated vocal box set
Now that’s a great idea! Wish they’d do THAT!
This may be the best version of the isolated vocals of this song-so much emotional expression comes through.
I wish I could write just one song as good as this.
practice practice practice :)
there's a theory the Beatles were as good as they became because they did their "10,000 hours" playing those Hamburg clubs relentlessly before ever signing to Parlophone
Do it man, do it.
What i can say is that Green Day's Worry Rock kinda have the same arrangement/sounds similar as this but ofc its just faster, maybe you can also when you keep on practising and trying?😊👍
Forget about it. You've already lost.
Don't worry -- everyone does.
They were SO lucky to have met up with George Martin and the fabulous Abbey Road. Studio 2 has a tiled wall that gave the vocals a special resonnance.. Plus the studio was full of wonderful tube amp and pre amps with Neuman 47 Ribbon mics. You could not have a better combo of talent and infrastructure to enable the Fabs to achieve briallence
Neumann U47's were condenser mics, not ribbons.
@@donmathews5885 lol
Analog tape recording !
Hi Steve, the U47 is a condenser microphone not a ribbon. The Beatles did use ribbons though, especially a Coles 4038 on Ringo's drumkit.
Personally I’d just have from 2:32 on repeat constantly - that end harmony
They just had (have) pure, natural talent.
George sounded amazing there.
No autotune! Zero autotune!
Any imperfections add to the song. It gives tension in just the right spots. Freddie Mercury often went slightly off pitch to create a little tension and release in his songs creating a more diverse sound.
@@raesmith2164 That's my position as well. I've listened to all and collected all of the Beatles' catalog since the 60s. When Giles Martin remixes them, I notice every missing artifact and wonder why he would remove them? But if McCartney's ok with it, who am I to complain? However, I believe Lennon would say to leave them in...and then change his mind a week later, such is John.
@@hungfao that's very much like John to do that 😁
Man, they were good.
They were fab.
This photo is unfamiliar to me, but serves once again to confirm the remark that there were no bad photographs taken of the Beatles. Nice audio work!
Obviously a candid shot.
Ickly Moor U.S. tour August 1966
@origamiChef would say it was the beatles' "puberty/adolescence" time... they were transitioning from that cute and teenage bopper band vibe to that hippie and meditating, older Beatles kinda vibe type of band😊😊👍👍
@@kjthekunoichi Only 7 or 8 months before the Sgt Pepper pics were taken. (Those 8 months certainly made a hell of a difference.)
What a superb singer John Lennon was! Beautiful voice...Amazing
I agree, wonderful warm tone.
Alvaro Freitas Although John himself didn’t like his voice and often went out of his way to alter it .
@@dickjohnson1158 Yes he double tracked for that reason. It must have been hard having Macca right next to you doing what he could do with his voice.
Unique voice
I think his Scouse accent helped shape his distinctive tone.
George was great at the low vocal harmonies. Very easy to sound flat when singing down low like he does. One of the great harmony singers ever.
they were something else... there will never be another!
If you want a suggestion, I'd be interested in "I'm Only Sleeping" could hear nice John self harmony and you can hear him clearly say "Yawn Paul"
It’s unfortunate we didn’t get a surround mix for revolver, otherwise we’d have the vocal track more clearly
John self harmony ? When ?
@@feeno1188 i think he means double track
The french Timelord John self-harmonized on Come Together
Link?
John's voice here is just.. simply outstanding!
WOW! These guys were amazing.
Lennon's voice is so dominant especially on this song and album!
Man the Beatles really knew how the make music. Listen to how locked in their harmonies are. When will the leading rock/pop act in music ever be the most innovative and forward thinking again? Soon I hope
Lennons voice 🙌🏾
Fabulous! The Beatles had wonderful harmonies that lifted many of their songs out of the ordinary to the extraordinary.
Great song with vocals. Great harmony and John what a voice.❤❤
I was trying to perfect my reggae sound and stumbled upon these vocal videos now I can’t get John George Paul and Ringo out of my head again. “oh ,I can’t sleep at night” . It took me 35 years to 40 years to move on to other music . my friends joke around and laugh at me and say you’re stuck in the Beatles and they turn me onto music from the 70s 80s 90s and onward that I’ve never heard.Or didn’t care to hear because I was stuck in Beatle- land. And happy
ジョージのパートが一番目立たないくせに一番難しいという不条理、それをさらっとこなせるジョージは本当にすごい
George a touch flat at 1:53 but he recovers. Love this!
That's quite an ear you've got there.
George always got the middle part which is the toughest to sing.
Amazing! Thank YOU so much for posting...Their vocals are the best there is!
Sometimes when harmonies are perfect it is almost as if there are more voices than singers. I’m not talking about double tracking, it’s harmonics than seem to come from another plane.
From heaven
I'm pretty sure these were double tracked.
Well, it's said that John almost always double-tracked, he thought his voice was too thin. This sounds like everybody was doubled and I was thinking maybe even tripled. This is not to say that there aren't overtones or harmonics in play as well.
@@djinnisequoia When playing chords on my guitar, I hear notes that aren't there ... I try to isolate that tone individually from the chord form, and it's not there. Must be the overtones?
The music becomes more than the sum of its parts.
Best voices in Rock 'n' Roll history!
It's hard to believe that it took them years to get a record deal when you look at the absolute shit that we have to listen to today h how standards and talent have disappeared.
It didn't take years for them to get a record contract, really. In fact, they only did a few auditions for labels before EMI/George Martin decided to take them on. Before that they were a bar and small club band without realistic aspirations to something as lofty as a record contract. Only after Brian Epstein became their manager did recording even become a possibility. Once he was their manager, it was only months before they had a deal.
@@ChrisMaxfieldActs I think they were knocked back quite a lot-George Martin was Epstiens' last chance and he dreaded going back to Liverpool and having to tell them he had nothing for him.I think he may have made at least three business trips to London before Parlophone came up.
Beautiful. God, I miss the Beatles sooo much.
Beatles harmonies are something out of these world. They just make a magical match
With a little bit more practice, these guys may get somewhere.
lol I’m guessing that’s sarcasm?
Dude r u stupid Their beetles dumass
@@natek5249 It's a joke.
@@natek5249 r/wooooosh
& dude r u dum??? It was serious gosh
Early Lennon is my favorite of all time. So unique.
What wonderful harmonies from these fab guys ,,,its always a treat to hear classics from the 60s era lol xx l;ong live the beetles ......
Have always loved this song, lyrics, harmonies and the boys.
One of the greatest songs of all time!
" When McCartney hits that high line at the end i still get chills." ABSOLUTELY ! STIIL THE SAME FEELING SINCE FIRTS HEARING IN 1965 .
Musical geniuses at work....and this is just one song out of over 200 that were pretty much all hits. I don't think we'll ever see another band like this again.
When Paul hits the end with the high pitch is just perfect timing…
Brilliant!
Paul rounds that off to perfection!
People always brings up the beach boys. But man The Beatles harmonies are just 100% spot on everytime. Its 100% perfection
Beautiful. Hugs from Brazil
unbelievable blend... those three voices were such magic together...
Anyone who says Paul’s an egomaniac, just listen to how much he puts into being a sideman/harmonizer on these songs
The vocals are amazing and the way they harmonized was fantastic! Somehow their voices always blended well together! I like to hear Paul or John sing a song and hear the other two or three harmonize behind him. It always sounds great! That was one of their secret weapons! The Everly brothers had great harmonies too but they were brothers so their voices blended well naturally. The Beatles were just lucky, I guess, that their voices blended so well together. They sound like their related but their not. Brilliant singers!
D RolyPolyMan , Don and Phil, BLOOD harmonies!
D RolyPolyMan most voices blend well
The Everlys were huge influences on John and Paul, and they and George worked a lot from their earliest days on their harmonies. And the lucky accident of the four Beatles being in different registers added to their ability to be brilliant. Also, Ringo's very distinct voice can be heard in harmony on "Flying", "Maggie Mae", and "Carry That Weight".
Fantastic harmonies !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Genuinely one of the John's best lyrics imo
To be able to pull this off live back in the day with no monitors proves they were the greatest band ever!!
They have reached immortality in the best of worlds
Stunning.
They harmonizing was off the charts. Always.
❗️❗️❗️❗️Это одна из величайших песен в истории человечества! (Сергей Казаченко из Санкт-Петербурга, Россия)
Beautiful!
Low part is very difficult.
George, good job!
The beginning reminds me of bedtime whenever I heard their voices in my head.
Gorgeous!
so BEAUTIFUL...
Thanks, Dr Winston! =)
Beautiful!
“Making all his nowhere plans for nobody.” “In my life, I’ve loved them all.” Same album, same writer, same singer, same three chords: F Fmin C. Two very different songs. The genius of John is, I never noticed until I starting learning Beatle songs on ukulele 50 years later.
The fun of singing along with The Beatles is you get to play so many songs three times, once for each voice.
those are not the chords. In My Life is in A and this song in E. So, the chords are F# minor, to Aminor back to E, in Nowhere Man, and in "IN MY Life"...D, Dm then A
True, thank you. I learn from fake books, so whatever key my arthritic left thumb can handle, I strum along. (To quote a Ringo song, I can play if it’s in C). I’m trying to point out the sweet uses of the VI-vi-I progression, with the minor plagal cadence. The Beatles rarely repeated the little tricks that make each recording unique, so I’m intrigued that this is hidden in plain sight.
@@robranney-blake8731 THANKS ...they were truly great songwriters
@@robranney-blake8731 C F Fm C That's an old Country Gospel style turnaround.
Learning uke myself
Beautiful 3 piece harmony by Ringo!
The day John was murdered..I listened to Nowhere man..everyone else listened to Imagine..but for me, this was Lennon
John, the voice
Thank you so much! Very beautiful!!!!!
los más grandes de toda la historia.
I'm now hearing this song as a precursor to John's "Watching the Wheels"...Here he seems melancholy about the nowhereness; fourteen years later he was to claim and even champion it.
God I love this song! Beatles FOREVER!!!!!!!!
I've been here since Beatlemania! I think I was 11 or 12. The Beatles were and always will be
going down in history with the likes of Mozart! You know how you got bored hearing the same songs of certain bands! I still love and enjoy all the Beatles songs! It's great!
Una de mis favoritas de John que bella
"You won't see me" would be a good candidate for this treatment. Fantastic background from George and John.
This was an unusual track in that John sang all the vocal parts, with the only exception of the last line “making all his nowhere plans for nobody”, in which Paul adds his voice. It’s one of the reasons why they very rarely performed it live.
Wrong on all counts. The entire song is a three-part harmony and it was part of their set list throughout 1965!
My mum and dad saw them in London 1965 and the only part of a song they heard amid the screaming was ‘he’s a real...’ and it was screams for the rest of the show.
you couldn't be more wrong. learn first, then comment.
nonrepublicrat Cue Jim Carrey as the Grinch : “Wrongo !!!!!” Dude, you’re clueless.
markyd h Nope. Try reading ANY of the Beatles’ biographical books. This song was unique in that John sang ALL the parts except the harmony on very last line. And, up until the end when smoking started to lower George’s range, he always sang the top harmony. Listen to All My Loving if you don’t believe.
A very nice job isolating vocals! ty, so much!
Just play the original stereo vinyl of Rubber Soul and mute the left track!
Another one of my favorite John harmonies is the low harmony on IF I FELL, right after he does the intro.
También en Because.
新たな気持ちで聴ける。😃サンキュー😆💕✨
Nice work by original boys.
Some of Paul’s final efforts.....
Christopher Cirocco I thought the same thing about your post three weeks ago, right before you died and were replaced.
Fab, thank you for posting!
Aaaaa la la la...
I really love their harmonies ❤️
Just flooring...
Definitely the greatest band
I'm crying
Absolutely beautiful voices... Lennon is singing bored and tired!
In a good way
Miguel Aguilar He wasn’t bored and tired, he was singing in the psicodelic way, before Strawberry Fields Forever or like I’m Only Sleeping, Tomorrow Never Knows, etc...
Brilliant
Even without the backing track and only the isolated it still sounds great except the silent guitar bridge in the middle. Truly shows the power of the beatles as musicians.
Fantastic
Now Here Man !
Greatest song ever written
at this point (1965) they had already been singing together for at least 8 years -- even by 1962 they were tight, ...God were they tight !!!!
AHHHH LA LA LA LA
Double tracking their voices gave them a nice chorus like effect.
The vocals made this song
And the super clear guitar!
More often than not i feel like a nowhere man
m Mathieu Schuler its being so happy that keeps you going ?
Nowhere man, the world is at your command.
I feel like an old splintered droomstick, meself.
Still a great pop rock song....without the rock instruments. I'd say yes to a boxed set if Beatle Isolation songs!
❤️
Pure talent
They look so fucking cool in that picture
Paul admitted this was particularly difficult harmony-wise.
They sound so great here. You can tell they lost a lot of magic though if you hear them at the Budokan in Japan singing this. The fire was lost.