This short film illustrates how so called civilised people just cannot leave people alone who choose to live in a more simple and money free tribal way. These are the true protectors of our planet's environment.
These sustainability agendas were devised by evil people who value land ownership above all else. They forget that death isn't far off for any of us, falsely thinking conquering the entire globe will somehow save them from the inevitable.
Very cool satirical short film... Progress & development are effectively relative and impose by our society & ways of life ! A lot of themes and subjects of debate in 2 minutes. Thank you a lot, from France.
आदिवासियों ने आपको आग दिया, खेती दी, धान दिया, लोहा दिया, सिंदूर दिया, वृ़क्षों-नदियों के प्रति आभार का बोध दिया. जब आपने सरस्वती सुखा दी, आपको गंगा दिया. आपकी भाषाओं को शब्द दिए, आपको सभ्यता दी और आपको लोकतांत्रिक होना बताया. आपको गाना, नाचना और अन्य कलाएं सिखायीं. उन्होंने कुछ भी नहीं थोपा आप पर. न भाषा, न संस्कृति, न धर्म और न खानपान. फिर आप क्यों जबरन थोप रहे हैं उन पर अपना ‘विकास’?
This isn't about all development projects for goodness sake. Why does everyone have to put a blanket over everything. This is a brilliant video high lighting the worst kind of development. People that have already been brought into this economic system and have lost skills pertaining to gathering resources and creating civilisations need help to sustain themselves once more! We were all like the community depicted in the video at some point.
que horror. such arrogance not to see that the communities living in harmony with nature and natural rhythm were better before our crazy disconnected rhythm !
this video has the right idea behind it, but it's also got a lot of problems. For one, it highly exoticizes cultures of less "developed" nations and is someone idealistic in its depiction of them as living in a kind of utopian society. While a lot of corporations are certainly not doing a lot to help the situation, they're not the only problem either.
Silly. Those happy people in the forest - when they stop being nomadic and their population starts to grow....start having all the problems the rest of us had to have and deal with.
This animation may as well be shot in black and white because that's exactly how its narrative is enumerated. Western development models have their fair share of flaws, yes, but please bring to my attention any other models that have more rapidly and effectively lifted populations from poverty levels, decreased child mortality rates, and increased standards of living.
Who said these people are in poverty? What does "poverty" even mean to you? That they earn less than a dollar a day? Do you really think they need more than a dollar? (You can't compare it to yourself and your own costs). They have lived that way for many many many years and don't need Western money to save them. I am indigenous myself and my community is fighting Western development off our land (I unfortunately was sent to school in the US but cannot wait to go back and live my life in my own culture and way). Westerners need to open their eyes and realize that their way of organizing society is not the only way and they can't go around imposing such way on everyone.
8 років тому+1
+dunzerz People have also lost their ancestral lands, homes, and yes, even their lives after struggling against Western development when they saw it was not for them.
As the video depicted, now we aren't bringing Europe to them, we bring them Brazil... And even if we brought them the West, isn't it a loss for the world, that everyone lives in the same way... Is that diversity worth those lifes? But first of all, civilization is now being brought to them quite violently - which makes them not willing to join it
This short film illustrates how so called civilised people just cannot leave people alone who choose to live in a more simple and money free tribal way. These are the true protectors of our planet's environment.
These sustainability agendas were devised by evil people who value land ownership above all else. They forget that death isn't far off for any of us, falsely thinking conquering the entire globe will somehow save them from the inevitable.
That is some hard, salty truth.
Very cool satirical short film... Progress & development are effectively relative and impose by our society & ways of life ! A lot of themes and subjects of debate in 2 minutes. Thank you a lot, from France.
Let us save Tribals, Save planet! let us do it together!
Coolest comment
The best way to save them is leave them be, no tourism,no tribal products etc,they will regrow their environment,.and save us idiots.
thats the truth right htere.
Unfortunately true
abs right!
आदिवासियों ने आपको आग दिया, खेती दी, धान दिया, लोहा दिया, सिंदूर दिया, वृ़क्षों-नदियों के प्रति आभार का बोध दिया. जब आपने सरस्वती सुखा दी, आपको गंगा दिया. आपकी भाषाओं को शब्द दिए, आपको सभ्यता दी और आपको लोकतांत्रिक होना बताया. आपको गाना, नाचना और अन्य कलाएं सिखायीं. उन्होंने कुछ भी नहीं थोपा आप पर. न भाषा, न संस्कृति, न धर्म और न खानपान. फिर आप क्यों जबरन थोप रहे हैं उन पर अपना ‘विकास’?
Fantastic analogy
Isn't development brilliant?!
¿Who is the music from? Thanks
Can I ask you for a ton of literature I could read about this?
And especially what's that hedge at 1:40?
Thanks
This isn't about all development projects for goodness sake. Why does everyone have to put a blanket over everything. This is a brilliant video high lighting the worst kind of development. People that have already been brought into this economic system and have lost skills pertaining to gathering resources and creating civilisations need help to sustain themselves once more! We were all like the community depicted in the video at some point.
Very good film. Is there any version with portuguese subtitles?
que horror. such arrogance not to see that the communities living in harmony with nature and natural rhythm were better before our crazy disconnected rhythm !
this video has the right idea behind it, but it's also got a lot of problems. For one, it highly exoticizes cultures of less "developed" nations and is someone idealistic in its depiction of them as living in a kind of utopian society. While a lot of corporations are certainly not doing a lot to help the situation, they're not the only problem either.
What problems do "less developed" nations have? Also that was not a utopian nation depicted it was a people surviving.
+Trife Bboy And thriving from the looks of it.
+Trife_Bboy abusive tribal rituals
First World countries have their abusive tribal rituals, as well.
yeah but not like, oh, bullet ant stings, suffering of a thousand cuts, blood initiation, cannibalism, etc.
Hello SIIT PEEPS
One interesting case: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jarawas_(Andaman_Islands)
Silly. Those happy people in the forest - when they stop being nomadic and their population starts to grow....start having all the problems the rest of us had to have and deal with.
Cant we just keep them the way they are, that is call indigenous development. Just mind our own urban development.
This animation may as well be shot in black and white because that's exactly how its narrative is enumerated. Western development models have their fair share of flaws, yes, but please bring to my attention any other models that have more rapidly and effectively lifted populations from poverty levels, decreased child mortality rates, and increased standards of living.
Such as? ...
Who said these people are in poverty? What does "poverty" even mean to you? That they earn less than a dollar a day? Do you really think they need more than a dollar? (You can't compare it to yourself and your own costs). They have lived that way for many many many years and don't need Western money to save them. I am indigenous myself and my community is fighting Western development off our land (I unfortunately was sent to school in the US but cannot wait to go back and live my life in my own culture and way). Westerners need to open their eyes and realize that their way of organizing society is not the only way and they can't go around imposing such way on everyone.
+dunzerz People have also lost their ancestral lands, homes, and yes, even their lives after struggling against Western development when they saw it was not for them.
As the video depicted, now we aren't bringing Europe to them, we bring them Brazil... And even if we brought them the West, isn't it a loss for the world, that everyone lives in the same way... Is that diversity worth those lifes?
But first of all, civilization is now being brought to them quite violently - which makes them not willing to join it
Who's here from TU103?
Tawan Momo โถ่โมโม่
ก็หลายคนอยู่มั้ง
Here's a better idea just stay out of there's lives. 😓😥
The environmentalists have to kill the enemies.
lame