Has the IAS lost some of its sheen and has it been overtaken by MBA? Are traditional professions losing out? We debate on The Big Fight. Watch full show: www.ndtv.com/vi...
There have been many IAS and IFS as well in my family and I am absolutely aware of their reality. No one thinks beyond self promotion. Nation has never been their priority. It sounds very good in studios. Everything is far from reality. Still exception might be there . Generally honest officers get too many transfers. They are always in vulnerable situation. I would like everyone to follow their heart as far as career is concerned.
Worst thing is that when a Engineer from India's top institute IITs pass out with CS,IT, electronics branch and then they start preparation and qualifying UPSC. It is completely waste of talent and time.If he/she should work in his own field with more compassion then today we would atleast produce a single indian made mobile or Laptop brand.
Woh bhai jis ka jo mann hai woh karega chalo 10% chale gaye civil services ke taraf aur 90% ne kitna hardware mobile bana diya hai.prblm yeh hai ki woh R& D hota nii hai bas ratta maro bas 5-6% engineer hi actually dimag se kuch banane ki koshish karte hain aur woh loag better opportunity ke liye bahar chale jate hain
Mba is for money minded people...to create jobs,build companies They are the pillars of economy of a country Ias is an administration service,you can improve the system and punish corrupt people that's all
Dear This is Nitin I am writing this letter on behalf of all of the person who do not have job or who are working in Private sector. WHY WE DO NOT HAVE ANY DEFINED RULE SET OF PRIVATE SECTOR. I have some query and i think it will be helpful for all of us. Question1 Do we have any Private sector manageable firm or sector in Government who are managing and thinking about private employee. Question2 Do we have any particular rule or criteria about private sector Like how much minimum or maximum salary increment should have in a financial year for private firm employee. Question3 If we are paying equally Tax and all the relevant things than why Government is not involve in Private sector. Question4 Do we have any Minimum or maximum Salary structure for private employee to given by Government of india. Question5 Why we are donating money or giving extra Focus to IIM/IIT/NIT Student,If other than these Institute all are fake or worst than why Government give tham permission. Question6 Do we have rule in government for private employee who can complaint or share their problem with Government of India. Question7 If Government is unable to think or focusing on Private College,Private Employee than why they are ducting Tax from our Salary. Question8 We are paying tax from our salary but if we are buying any thing from market than we have to again pay tax or vat it mean dual pay.Why ? Question9 If i am not wrong than every 3 or 4 year Government provide Huge increment in salary for Government Employee so oblivious Rate of food and all the item will be increase than in this case who are thinking about private sector employee. Question10Could anyone in Government sector who can anyalise about Last 10 year profit Chart.Who Give More Profit to Government of India,Private or Government Firm. Question11If we are paying Similer TAX/VAT/Water/Telephone/Light Bill than why this two sector divide Private and Public. Question12 If Government is not receiving any profit from Private sector than why MR Modi welcoming MNC in india. Question13 I can share many Student and employee who has reputed Degree and Skills but they do not have job or if they are working than maybe started their journey from 0.00 Rupees or 5000 RS.why?But if you joined Government Job than its defined Salary Structure Why? Question14 Why Every Minister or big donation only for Government College or Government Employee. Question15 Even Every Government Firm have 3rd Party Support from Private Sector than Why Government treating us as private Firm. Question16 If State Government Do not have Caliber to connect with private college and private employee than why they welcoming Private sector in india. Question17 I am sharing my opinion and real finding. Even i am working in Big MNC and i have reputed profile and Salary but every year i am receiving 3 to 6 percent hike in salary what do you think market rate is also increasing like this.Answer me. I am not greedy about salary i have choosen Private sector because i love to work in exciting environment but where is exciting Salary at all our family is depends on our income. What is Job Security in Private Sector provided by Government of India. Do you think only IIT/IIM/NIT having skill student or extraordinary manpower if yes than all of the above question is not important but if not than why we do not have any GOD FATHER in private sector.
At Last My question is why Divided all things in Private and Government sector if we are paying same tax/vat/bill,otherwise set separate rule for private and government sector. Why many of the student from Private colleges are without job but IIT/IIM student having 3 to 4 job offer. Note: I am not opposing IIT/IIM or Government sector I just need if Our government providing extra donation and care to this college than what is use of more than 500 private college(every state). Yes we are working in private Company because of my own choice but we have caliber to bit any Government exam within year or two year but I hate Government Sector. If i am wrong than analyse Growth Graph of indian economic than you can find who are more supportive for government. My question is suppose we are working and supporting any client of USA than client provided salary is 10 time more than our indian salary.Why and who are taking care of this. Suppose if i am working in xyz and my Client is USA based than they providing us more than 40 lakh as per ther policy than why we are receiving 5 Lakh per year.It means where is reaming 35 Lakh of my hard work. In Private Sector why we do not have any government provided Rule set like do not disturb employee after job hours or week off. I came after job and writing this letter because i am thinking about all of the person not only me but it will be waste if no one reply or thinking about this.
I m a govt employee....n I know whtz d situation in govt sector.....n in conference pvt sector r more successful than d govt.....itz tym to again change d Indian economy policy which last formed in 1991.....
i have done engineering nd got the job in MNC.. bt i rejected to do the job in any privet and govt organization... now m a former..so kehne ka mtlb hai bhai bs wo kro jo krna tumhe accha lgta hai...just follow your dream, khushi usi mai milegi ... nd koi kam chhota ya bda nahi hota hai...
Enterprenuers r the biggest social worker because they r creating jobs for millions. Kunahl bahl, sachin bansal, narayan murthy r the kings. Where a govt servant can stand with them.
I've seen interview of many doctors, some of them from Aiims also left their job and prepared for upsc and got into Ias and clearly said it is far better than mbbs
BUT DON'T EXPECT ONLY NEWS READERS OR JOURNALIST OR THESE KIND OF PROGRAM CONDUCTING PERSONS ONLY TO KEEP ON TEACHING TEACHING THEY HAVE A FAMILY THIS IS SUMMER VACATION EACH ONE PLANS TO VISIT TEMPLES FAMILY WANT TO MEET YEARLY ONCE ATLEAST GOVERNEMENT JOB MEANS PRIVATE JOB MEANS EVERYONE WANTS FOOD CLOTHES HOME OFFICE SCHOOL COLLEGE HUMAN BEINGS MUST LIVE AS HUMAN BEINGS
INDIANS CAN WEAR GIRL CAN WEAR PATTU LANGAALU CHEERA CHUDIDHAR WE CANT WEAR WHATEVER THE CINEMA ACTRESSES ARE WEARING... GENTS MEANS WHAT THEY ARE GOING TO WEAR PANT SHIRT, T SHIRT, SAFARI, COAT SUIT.... INNER WEAR ALSO
I can see how the job of the civil servants has enormous impact and can be extremely fulfilling. But as Mohandas Pai later mentions in the program, the path to get there is very brutal. A few hundred civil servants are selected every year from a pile of hundreds of thousands. Further more, the means is extremely rote where you spend long hours of study over dry books. It is hardly the kind of preparation that leads to an enlightened mind. It is the kind of process the is designed to weed out the people who can't put in the time and work. So for most the civils exams are a very poor investment of time. Those who fail neither have any skills, nor a job, nor fulfillment nor any life experience. The civils exams is a purely a numbers game. Very few win by design. Where as in the army, corporate or entrepreneurial field, every day you could have real life experiences that will not go waste. They offer way more flexibility. The market depends on more skill, not on numbers.
But hamare parents ko koi samjhayega ye sab? Hamey toh paidaa hi kia tha na government job ke liye, bas isiliye mey is dharti mey paidaa hua aur ab sar raa huin, ek number km milaa toh puraa saal barbaad.
@@TejasM14 but my parents don't want all these? One of my biggest curse is my neighbor guy is an government engineer, so i face the brunt...I am just waiting till the day of self-anihlation, self destruction....already on its path.
THANK SUJATHA THAT AMERICAN DOMINATION HAS BEEN STOPPED TO SELL OUR OWN RICE ALL THINGS NEEDED TO PREPARE NORTH INDIA TIFFIN CHAPATHI, IDLY, DAL, BIRYANI SOUTH INDIA IDLY, DOSA, POORI, ANNAM, SAMBAR, BIRYANI SWEETS MEANS FESTIVAL BORELU, LADDU, MYSORE PAK... TEMPLES WILL BE VERY FEW HUMAN BEINGS ONLY LARGE IN NUMBERS LIVING IN INDIA
JUST NOW I WENT AND SAW 1. ALLAHABAD BANK 2. PUNJAB BANK 3. THEN TAMIL NADU ONLY BANKS FROM ANOTHER CITY IS OK YOU WO;N'T KILL BECAUSE TELUGU ONLY VERY EASY TO TARGET OTHER LANGUAGE SPEAKING VERY STRONG HINDI PUNJABI PERSONS KNOW YOU PEOPLE TAMIL WON'T TARGET THOSE STRONG HINDI SPEAKING, PUNJABI SPEAKING
There have been many IAS and IFS as well in my family and I am absolutely aware of their reality. No one thinks beyond self promotion. Nation has never been their priority. It sounds very good in studios. Everything is far from reality. Still exception might be there . Generally honest officers get too many transfers. They are always in vulnerable situation. I would like everyone to follow their heart as far as career is concerned.
How to follow heart if it is about job to survive
@indu Cruz , totally agree
Family maanegaa? Hamare family waalo ko bas government job chahiye isiliye paidaa kiye the hame
Worst thing is that when a Engineer from India's top institute IITs pass out with CS,IT, electronics branch and then they start preparation and qualifying UPSC. It is completely waste of talent and time.If he/she should work in his own field with more compassion then today we would atleast produce a single indian made mobile or Laptop brand.
India lacks good research and development option
Woh bhai jis ka jo mann hai woh karega chalo 10% chale gaye civil services ke taraf aur 90% ne kitna hardware mobile bana diya hai.prblm yeh hai ki woh R& D hota nii hai bas ratta maro bas 5-6% engineer hi actually dimag se kuch banane ki koshish karte hain aur woh loag better opportunity ke liye bahar chale jate hain
@@Ashish-ss5nt india mey bas rattta maaro aur pass kro aur uske baad puri jindagi family ki gaali sunte rho.
Bagal kaa ladka ye bn gya, wo bn gyaa...hm toh galat paidaa ho gye na, gaali khane ke liye paida hua thaa, mey toh ghar chorne waalaa huin, nhi chahiye bhai mujhe aisi jindagi....usse acchaa raaste mey fate kapro mey bhikhaari ban ke rhu, kam sey log rehem toh krenge.
I think debate ended from where it was started.... follow your dream..... legitimate one
Entrepreneurs are the best way to get the opportunity to fulfill their needs and they self developed
Entirely foolish discussion. Completely reflective of bureaucratic official meeting. Begun to decide something, ended up going no where/ every where.
Television debate are always this type
In my opinion, each and every job is best in it's own way and also necessary for the betterment of our country.
This type of debate can only be seen in Ndtv..
wow!! how peaceful were the debates back then.
Mba is for money minded people...to create jobs,build companies
They are the pillars of economy of a country
Ias is an administration service,you can improve the system and punish corrupt people that's all
Ans: Agriculture
There is nothing like the best job or the best career. Think about your interest, aptitude, ability and choose your career.
Dear
This is Nitin
I am writing this letter on behalf of all of the person who do not have job or who are working in Private sector.
WHY WE DO NOT HAVE ANY DEFINED RULE SET OF PRIVATE SECTOR.
I have some query and i think it will be helpful for all of us.
Question1 Do we have any Private sector manageable firm or sector in Government who are managing and thinking about private employee.
Question2 Do we have any particular rule or criteria about private sector Like how much minimum or maximum salary increment should have in a financial year for private firm employee.
Question3 If we are paying equally Tax and all the relevant things than why Government is not involve in Private sector.
Question4 Do we have any Minimum or maximum Salary structure for private employee to given by Government of india.
Question5 Why we are donating money or giving extra Focus to IIM/IIT/NIT Student,If other than these Institute all are fake or worst than why Government give tham permission.
Question6 Do we have rule in government for private employee who can complaint or share their problem with Government of India.
Question7 If Government is unable to think or focusing on Private College,Private Employee than why they are ducting Tax from our Salary.
Question8 We are paying tax from our salary but if we are buying any thing from market than we have to again pay tax or vat it mean dual pay.Why ?
Question9 If i am not wrong than every 3 or 4 year Government provide Huge increment in salary for Government Employee so oblivious Rate of food and all the item will be increase than in this case who are thinking about private sector employee.
Question10Could anyone in Government sector who can anyalise about Last 10 year profit Chart.Who Give More Profit to Government of India,Private or Government Firm.
Question11If we are paying Similer TAX/VAT/Water/Telephone/Light Bill than why this two sector divide Private and Public.
Question12 If Government is not receiving any profit from Private sector than why MR Modi welcoming MNC in india.
Question13 I can share many Student and employee who has reputed Degree and Skills but they do not have job or if they are working than maybe started their journey from 0.00 Rupees or 5000 RS.why?But if you joined Government Job than its defined Salary Structure Why?
Question14 Why Every Minister or big donation only for Government College or Government Employee.
Question15 Even Every Government Firm have 3rd Party Support from Private Sector than Why Government treating us as private Firm.
Question16 If State Government Do not have Caliber to connect with private college and private employee than why they welcoming Private sector in india.
Question17 I am sharing my opinion and real finding.
Even i am working in Big MNC and i have reputed profile and Salary but every year i am receiving 3 to 6 percent hike in salary what do you think market rate is also increasing like this.Answer me.
I am not greedy about salary i have choosen Private sector because i love to work in exciting environment but where is exciting Salary at all our family is depends on our income.
What is Job Security in Private Sector provided by Government of India.
Do you think only IIT/IIM/NIT having skill student or extraordinary manpower if yes than all of the above question is not important but if not than why we do not have any GOD FATHER in private sector.
At Last My question is why Divided all things in Private and Government sector if we are paying same tax/vat/bill,otherwise set separate rule for private and government sector.
Why many of the student from Private colleges are without job but IIT/IIM student having 3 to 4 job offer.
Note: I am not opposing IIT/IIM or Government sector I just need if Our government providing extra donation and care to this college than what is use of more than 500 private college(every state).
Yes we are working in private Company because of my own choice but we have caliber to bit any Government exam within year or two year but I hate Government Sector.
If i am wrong than analyse Growth Graph of indian economic than you can find who are more supportive for government.
My question is suppose we are working and supporting any client of USA than client provided salary is 10 time more than our indian salary.Why and who are taking care of this.
Suppose if i am working in xyz and my Client is USA based than they providing us more than 40 lakh as per ther policy than why we are receiving 5 Lakh per year.It means where is reaming 35 Lakh of my hard work.
In Private Sector why we do not have any government provided Rule set like do not disturb employee after job hours or week off.
I came after job and writing this letter because i am thinking about all of the person not only me but it will be waste if no one reply or thinking about this.
great...true..
nitin shukla there is no doubt whatever you are telling it's greatest truth of our country
You said nice sir
yes dual tax system does exist
I m a govt employee....n I know whtz d situation in govt sector.....n in conference pvt sector r more successful than d govt.....itz tym to again change d Indian economy policy which last formed in 1991.....
Be a politician......
alok kumar Be a gangster. And politicians will work for you.
Well said😀
@@TheClinchMagazine not in up.... encounter awaiting
@@srbhsngh796 UP is a shithole
@@TheClinchMagazine indeed
Well it is OLA or Uber driver.
lol I was right 2012 video😁 no job for youth these days
i have done engineering nd got the job in MNC.. bt i rejected to do the job in any privet and govt organization... now m a former..so kehne ka mtlb hai bhai bs wo kro jo krna tumhe accha lgta hai...just follow your dream, khushi usi mai milegi ... nd koi kam chhota ya bda nahi hota hai...
Bahut badhiya ye baat bank SSC ki aulaado Ko kaun samjahega
Bhai kitna acre hai profit kitna hai annual
Enterprenuers r the biggest social worker because they r creating jobs for millions.
Kunahl bahl, sachin bansal, narayan murthy r the kings. Where a govt servant can stand with them.
Doctor is best career and cannot be compared by any profession
why didn't we get the full discussion? it was so to the point.
hats off to Kunal Sir
MBBS is the most respected and most liking job among the youth
I've seen interview of many doctors, some of them from Aiims also left their job and prepared for upsc and got into Ias and clearly said it is far better than mbbs
Now,Answer: Entrepreneur
Actually worker cooperatives should be the way
But 90% startups fail
@@rayzard3687 but 99,99% fails in upsc
man! this snap deal CEO...can kick all of their asses...I think he was the only person who was not biased...
Agreed.R u from private sectors or entrepreneur background?
I don't think so......he has more money that doesn't mean he can kick other peoples asses.......ya he was unbiased....on that point I agree
The biggest civil service to the nation is to be a successful entrepreneur
It was so direspectful. The anchor is sitting while all the distinguished panelists are standing
Navdeep Jha don't you know that's a format .. you are an idot
I guess there should have been more young people like Kunal in the debate.
Actually,worker cooperatives should be the way to go they work for people not profits more,example amul and lijjat papad
The highest civil services is the steel frame of the country ! We can't compare it with any other things.
The incredible civil services !
Bhakk jhuggi waale
@@shrisub881 lode chup
Only clever and trained wisery group know how to cheat /fool innocent people.
Bihari spotted
babus are worse than the colonizers
Very nice presentation. - Jolly Uncle
BUT DON'T EXPECT ONLY NEWS READERS OR JOURNALIST OR THESE KIND OF PROGRAM CONDUCTING PERSONS ONLY
TO KEEP ON TEACHING TEACHING
THEY HAVE A FAMILY
THIS IS SUMMER VACATION
EACH ONE PLANS TO VISIT TEMPLES
FAMILY WANT TO MEET YEARLY ONCE ATLEAST
GOVERNEMENT JOB MEANS
PRIVATE JOB MEANS
EVERYONE WANTS
FOOD
CLOTHES
HOME
OFFICE
SCHOOL
COLLEGE
HUMAN BEINGS MUST LIVE AS HUMAN BEINGS
Ola driver is the best
If you are an IAS you can do something, what you guys did so far for country.
Nicely done
Now snapdeal also lost 😂😂
Why does the host interrupts the guests so often?
lovely panelists
Time to go out of India is the best option. Job situation and mafia is bad part in india.
kuljit singh ...these days immigration and Visa process is too complex and tough my friend...
Other countries don't want Indians as Indians are taking their jobs.
Where can I find this full debate?
Why they are not given a seat
.....
Whatever you want to be, be smart and world class.
Upload full episode
time to make everyone to go through a short tenure in the defence services
Trade job s is best like plumbing,electrical,HVAC,Carpentery.
INDIANS CAN WEAR
GIRL CAN WEAR
PATTU LANGAALU
CHEERA
CHUDIDHAR
WE CANT WEAR WHATEVER THE CINEMA ACTRESSES ARE WEARING...
GENTS MEANS WHAT THEY ARE GOING TO WEAR
PANT SHIRT, T SHIRT, SAFARI, COAT SUIT....
INNER WEAR ALSO
I can see how the job of the civil servants has enormous impact and can be extremely fulfilling. But as Mohandas Pai later mentions in the program, the path to get there is very brutal. A few hundred civil servants are selected every year from a pile of hundreds of thousands. Further more, the means is extremely rote where you spend long hours of study over dry books. It is hardly the kind of preparation that leads to an enlightened mind. It is the kind of process the is designed to weed out the people who can't put in the time and work. So for most the civils exams are a very poor investment of time. Those who fail neither have any skills, nor a job, nor fulfillment nor any life experience. The civils exams is a purely a numbers game. Very few win by design.
Where as in the army, corporate or entrepreneurial field, every day you could have real life experiences that will not go waste. They offer way more flexibility. The market depends on more skill, not on numbers.
But hamare parents ko koi samjhayega ye sab? Hamey toh paidaa hi kia tha na government job ke liye, bas isiliye mey is dharti mey paidaa hua aur ab sar raa huin, ek number km milaa toh puraa saal barbaad.
@@TejasM14 but my parents don't want all these? One of my biggest curse is my neighbor guy is an government engineer, so i face the brunt...I am just waiting till the day of self-anihlation, self destruction....already on its path.
Great
7.39
Nobody has any answer.
FOREIGN FOOD
PIZZA BURGER
BREAD
CAKE
THIS CANNOT BE TAKEN DAILY AS TIFFIN
BHAIYYA --CHAPATHI, DAL RICE, BIRYANI..DAILY FOOD OKAY
DON'T KNOW WHETHER BHAIYYA IS VEGETARIAN OR YOU EAT NON-VEG FOOD
HENCE STOPPING MY WORDS HERE ITSELF
🤣
What the bureaucrats are doing . public understand well. They can't be sounder pichai. Indira nooi.and Bill gates.
Complete video can be seen here
www.ndtv.com/video/player/the-big-fight/what-is-the-best-job-for-today-s-youth/249656
More such discussion must be there with panel of such dignitaries
Completely biased discussion.
Sir apna channel asl mein desh ki sewa Kar reha hai Bakki to vikke hue hai
Kabhi aarakshan pe bhi discussion kar loo
worthy of parents..earn money
ias is only if good memo
those wanting chair..hav good english
rest fcked up if bad hand writing..
jai ho B HARAT
PULLA REDDY AVENUE TELUGU NAMES IN CHENNAI STREET NEAR ANNA NAGAR
Debate on job
IAS is the god's boon ! And nothing has the capacity to withstand the god's boon ! B for boon then
B for best !
Bhakk Bihari badzaat
sound is not clear
is kunal bahl ki to khud company bnd ho gyi
Hand 🖐️ job
man these old people are such jerks , kunal , the youngest among them is the most humble , optimistic and successful person among them .
THANK SUJATHA
THAT AMERICAN DOMINATION HAS BEEN STOPPED
TO SELL OUR OWN
RICE
ALL THINGS NEEDED TO PREPARE
NORTH INDIA TIFFIN CHAPATHI, IDLY, DAL, BIRYANI
SOUTH INDIA IDLY, DOSA, POORI, ANNAM, SAMBAR, BIRYANI
SWEETS MEANS
FESTIVAL BORELU, LADDU, MYSORE PAK...
TEMPLES WILL BE VERY FEW
HUMAN BEINGS ONLY LARGE IN NUMBERS
LIVING IN INDIA
lol there are standing
Unnecessary
chai vala bano
totally dumb discussion, no vision at all , no wonder we have unemployment and population explosion in this country
Best job nowadays. Whatsapp admin.
likes dis
Politician
click show more
Watch full show :
sir it is a Hindi channel and your are all Indians so why your speaking English
i am an indian from andhra pradesh.......i don't know Hindi...
Can anyone suggest me some cool joB which don't look study or experience
capitalism!!
IAS is best job
JUST NOW I WENT AND SAW
1. ALLAHABAD BANK
2. PUNJAB BANK
3. THEN
TAMIL NADU ONLY
BANKS FROM ANOTHER CITY IS OK
YOU WO;N'T KILL
BECAUSE TELUGU ONLY VERY EASY TO TARGET
OTHER LANGUAGE SPEAKING
VERY STRONG
HINDI
PUNJABI
PERSONS KNOW
YOU PEOPLE TAMIL WON'T TARGET THOSE STRONG HINDI SPEAKING, PUNJABI SPEAKING
the anchor is arrogant....