How misguided peanut allergy recommendations created an epidemic | Peter Attia & Marty Makary

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 42

  • @fastenbulbous
    @fastenbulbous Місяць тому +12

    Why peanuts specifically, though? There isn’t an epidemic of people being allergic to exotic foods/ingredients from other cultures that they wouldn’t have been exposed to early in life.

    • @DimitriTheBarbarian
      @DimitriTheBarbarian Місяць тому

      @@fastenbulbous and how do you know that? Peanut story has been propagated by some doctor association and accepted by mainstream. Unless exotic fruit death raise public awareness, you won’t know about it.

    • @stevenqirkle
      @stevenqirkle Місяць тому +2

      Google “why are peanut allergies so severe” if you want a detailed answer, but the short summary is: “The combination of multiple allergens, numerous immune binding sites, heat stability, digestion stability, enzyme blocking, and the effect on the gut lining”

  • @GasPipeJimmy
    @GasPipeJimmy Місяць тому +16

    I’m really, really curious about this as peanut allergies were unheard of in the 1970’s and 1980’s.

    • @jasonhsu4711
      @jasonhsu4711 Місяць тому +3

      YES! The parents of the 1970s and 1980s were NEVER told to keep their babies in a peanut-free bubble. Clearly, some change out there led to the proliferation of peanut allergies. Could it be certain chemicals? Too much ultra-processed junk food food? Something else?

    • @WillFinch-k4j
      @WillFinch-k4j Місяць тому

      @@nothing1099No peanuts are not gmo and you could eat organic and avoid the chemicals.

  • @darrenfitzpatrick8013
    @darrenfitzpatrick8013 Місяць тому +2

    We introduced peanuts to my son's diet at 6momths old. This was when we found out he had a severe peanut allergy. During my partners pregnancy, we ate all different nuts including peanuts, so we find it bizarre that, he would have this allergy.

  • @tommyrq180
    @tommyrq180 Місяць тому +2

    “Why not show some humility!” Because that’s the problem. There is none to show amongst bureaucrats. None of the incentives promote humility, especially among high-level bureaucrats. And let’s be clear. The people, the masses, want and need confidence and even absolutism and bombast in their experts. It’s not just the expert bureaucrat problem. It’s also their “hosts” in the parasitic sense. Ask doctors. Patients want a confident “do this!” Rather than a lesson in statistical probabilities and RCT lingo. So it’s a rather thorny, synergistic, very human problem.

    • @Cathy-xi8cb
      @Cathy-xi8cb Місяць тому

      Humility gets trounced by malpractice costs and administrators. Parents really are out there on their own now. 40 years ago I was cautioned to write therapy home programs as if I would be getting sued the next day. Things have only gotten worse. I feel sorry for parents AND doctors. Do not let your kids go to medical school unless they insist. Far better careers out there with less stress and still lots of $$$ and status. Lots of them.

  • @staceydi6787
    @staceydi6787 Місяць тому

    I hope science can figure this thing out. I am the youngest of 5 kids born to the same parents.
    I was born in the 90's when peanut allergies were a bit of a novelty. I'm the ONLY kid in my family with a food allergy. My poor mom went crazy trying to figure out what she did. Obviously, it was a freak situation and not her fault. I still carry an epi pen, although I've never had a reaction. Apparently, I'm amazing at avoiding peanuts because a recent blood test proved I'm still highly allergic to them.

  • @CMVBrielman
    @CMVBrielman Місяць тому +7

    I’m grateful that even in my part of the country (deep blue state) our pediatricians always encouraged us to gradually introduce peanuts and other possible allergens as early as possible.
    Our second daughter had a slight reaction to peanuts at 5 months or so. So we held off for a couple months, and very slowly gave her larger amounts of peanut products in her meals. Lo and behold: no problems.

  • @Mateuszyk
    @Mateuszyk Місяць тому +2

    I will make peanut butter straight from my peanuts no matter what! Just gonna smeck than little harder

  • @WillFinch-k4j
    @WillFinch-k4j Місяць тому +2

    I was born in 1949 and have since consumed copious amounts of peanut butter love it still. Growing up I never heard of anyone with any degree of peanut allergies much less anaphylactic shock. Crazy why would you listen to such stupid advice about food when there was not a problem with earlier generations?

  • @florin5236
    @florin5236 Місяць тому +1

    I am from Romania and I don't know anybody with any allergies. I moved to USA 22 years a go and almost everyone have a allergies to one food or another.

    • @JayR-vz7ke
      @JayR-vz7ke 20 днів тому +1

      And yet they say it’s the greatest place on earth to live…I guess if you enjoy the smell of medical equipment and never ending doctor visits LOL!!

  • @dmonk952
    @dmonk952 Місяць тому +1

    jmo it may be a pesticide allergy, some people respond to some pesticides differently and peanuts are soaked in pesticides

  • @VanderlayLux
    @VanderlayLux Місяць тому

    I think American agro-chemicals/ pesticides and food additives might also be playing a role. Once we understand the intestine / microbiome better, all will be revealed.

  • @ShastaTodd
    @ShastaTodd Місяць тому +1

    Glad I do not have this as I LOVE pb!

  • @dmonk952
    @dmonk952 Місяць тому

    so many pesticides on peanuts you are probably better off avoiding

    • @WillFinch-k4j
      @WillFinch-k4j Місяць тому

      I only eat organic peanut butter, no problem with that.

  • @cindymcj5887
    @cindymcj5887 Місяць тому +1

    So my granddaughter who breaks out in hives and has difficulty breathing when exposed to peanuts is the effect of "the medical establishment"? It's already difficult to convince her teachers that she has a real problem and to keep an EpiPen available for anaphylaxis. I only accessed the short version and am unconvinced. How about offering an alternative rather than an opinion that endangers her life? You've lost me on this one.

  • @jenniferelliss318
    @jenniferelliss318 Місяць тому +9

    It now seems that the peanut butter no longer being sold is now saving lives of many babies and young children in 3rd world countries. At least a good outcome from the crazy overreaction to a few cases of peanut allergy.

    • @orcanimal
      @orcanimal Місяць тому +6

      How is it saving the lives of many babies? I thought the argument was that abstinence was making pean allergy more severe and that actually introducing peantuts earlier (in small doses of course) had kept peanut allery rates AND reaction severity much lower

    • @DimitriTheBarbarian
      @DimitriTheBarbarian Місяць тому +4

      😂 did you miss the whole show

    • @WillFinch-k4j
      @WillFinch-k4j Місяць тому

      Amazing that I’m still able to go to my local supermarket and find shelves loaded with organic and non organic peanut butter.

  • @subterrainia
    @subterrainia Місяць тому +2

    Stick with the SENNA apparel.

  • @Xiv2022
    @Xiv2022 Місяць тому +3

    Antihistamine usage by childbearing age women.

  • @ezra420420
    @ezra420420 Місяць тому

    Peanuts are poison

    • @WillFinch-k4j
      @WillFinch-k4j Місяць тому +1

      No for you maybe for me yum, give me more.

    • @ShastaTodd
      @ShastaTodd Місяць тому

      @@ezra420420 no Peanuts and other legumes are certainly not poison.