A Typical 3-year-old Sorting cards

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 чер 2009
  • A "typical" 3-year-old, at least on Phil Zelazo's card-sorting task (as followed up by Munakata & Yerys).
  • Наука та технологія

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,2 тис.

  • @EV3Showcase
    @EV3Showcase 4 роки тому +5059

    Sorry, I’m still slightly unclear on the rules of the color game

    • @camioso
      @camioso 4 роки тому +22

      😂😂

    • @Sophie-ui6hi
      @Sophie-ui6hi 4 роки тому +177

      ReMemBer in tHe cOloR gAmE ReD oNeS go hEre anD blUe oNes Go HerE

    • @kzcreationzmore
      @kzcreationzmore 4 роки тому +8

      I was going to the comments to find this lol

    • @andreaswill615
      @andreaswill615 4 роки тому +23

      Ok i think i got it. Whats my name again?

    • @vincentmalpica
      @vincentmalpica 4 роки тому +3

      Racial segregation

  • @chloemarvin3330
    @chloemarvin3330 5 років тому +4974

    i think it’s really amazing how he flipped the card upside down to put it into the case after paying attention to her fixing it. she didn’t have to verbally comment on it.

    • @danm2084
      @danm2084 4 роки тому +235

      Yes I think they pick up on seeing things and copying (like monkeys) more than verbal explanations. Notice she never demonstrated what to do when she switched to the shape game, but she did demonstrate how to do it in the color game.

    • @samedifference5504
      @samedifference5504 4 роки тому +71

      You are very easily amazed. I have some keys in my pocket, which look really cool when I jingle them around.

    • @21area21
      @21area21 4 роки тому +158

      @@samedifference5504 Well, you clearly don't have much appreciation or understanding for cognition. What that kid does is amazing and as you can see by the likes on this comment, a lot of people agree. The kid figured that out that the woman wanted the cards face down without her telling him.
      Also, this experiment is really what's flawed here. There is no failure on the kids part. The woman just speaks in a boring and repetitive manner, and I don't blame the kid for tuning out. She also speaks fast with lots of words and when transitioning games, she didn't give much of a clear indication to the kid. Just some rambling that he paid little attention to.

    • @samedifference5504
      @samedifference5504 4 роки тому +16

      @@21area21 I feel like a monkey would be easily able to start flipping the cards upside down. Also I didn't know more likes meant your comment was more valid. I shoulda mentioned Keanu reaves in my prior argument I guess.

    • @michalgabriel9647
      @michalgabriel9647 4 роки тому

      It would be amazing if she didn’t had to correct him and flip the cards for him 😏

  • @Verseaurainbows
    @Verseaurainbows 6 років тому +4068

    Remember we're playing the colour game

    • @vchabal
      @vchabal 4 роки тому +93

      Remember we're playing the shape game

    • @Andrew-jw4vc
      @Andrew-jw4vc 4 роки тому +127

      Could you please remind me where the red ones go and the blue ones go

    • @baeguetteman412
      @baeguetteman412 4 роки тому +90

      Talking like an Oblivion NPC repeating the same voicelines over and over again

    • @BDK27970
      @BDK27970 4 роки тому +30

      Red ones go here, and blue ones go here...

    • @jagjitroudh9894
      @jagjitroudh9894 4 роки тому +42

      You know if she hadn't kept repeating that, I'd have gotten confused.

  • @cornelisgraper8678
    @cornelisgraper8678 4 роки тому +2662

    He will nevet forget the colour game, that shit scarred his brain for life.

    • @31redorange08
      @31redorange08 4 роки тому +44

      Why? He was good at that game. He sucked in the shape game and even noticed it.

    • @lostpockets2227
      @lostpockets2227 4 роки тому +18

      it doesnt help that the woman is totally dead face staring him in the eyes with no emotion whatsoever like wtf lady what is wrong with you??

    • @66LordLoss66
      @66LordLoss66 4 роки тому +66

      @@lostpockets2227 If she showed emotion, it would have altered the child's decisions. The child would try to avoid the answers he thinks she would not want.

    • @konrione5349
      @konrione5349 4 роки тому +21

      @@66LordLoss66 yeah, i noticed that, he seemed to look for something to confirm that he got the right answer

    • @tash5540
      @tash5540 4 роки тому +9

      @@66LordLoss66 That's the point of the game. Listening for words and piecing them together.

  • @DahBjorn
    @DahBjorn 12 років тому +2640

    Haha, she sound like an NPC ...

    • @21area21
      @21area21 4 роки тому +77

      Same. No wonder the kid tuned out her instructions. Clearly he is very smart to pick up on stuff like her desire to have him place cards face down, even without any instruction 0:41.

    • @lillym.1612
      @lillym.1612 4 роки тому +1

      Ikr

    • @zarrowthehorse
      @zarrowthehorse 4 роки тому +10

      @@21area21 I think that's more mimicking than being smart

    • @21area21
      @21area21 4 роки тому +36

      ​@@zarrowthehorse "Just mimicking" is completely neglecting the complexity of what's happening.
      My point is that the "mimicking" action requires understanding the rules of how to sort in order to do so.

    • @donnatellamymum6735
      @donnatellamymum6735 4 роки тому +28

      I mean she was trying to limit verbal cues with her speech so of course it sounded stilted

  • @ranamiray
    @ranamiray 4 роки тому +1731

    Woman: we’re playing the shape game
    Max: nah bish we playing the color game

  • @comradecrimson509
    @comradecrimson509 4 роки тому +941

    When she stops saying "good job" and starts saying "ok" 😔

    • @dannyboygregory-mccormick9157
      @dannyboygregory-mccormick9157 4 роки тому +43

      I felt that :(

    • @stelcxantisto
      @stelcxantisto 4 роки тому +51

      The kid didn't catch the different of "good job" and "ok", she said "ok" when he put the card in the wrong place and it make him super confused. I am sure if she corrected him once at the first time he got it wrong, he won't be wrong again. Kids follow adult's example and feedback rather than the instruction.

    • @jasonpatterson9821
      @jasonpatterson9821 3 роки тому +42

      @@stelcxantisto That's just it. The purpose was to see what he would do, if he would adapt to the changed rules on his own, not to see if he could learn to do it over time. If I had to guess, she shouldn't have been saying, "Good job," at all during the experiment. Likely there was a script that she was supposed to follow exactly that made her seem robotic and she had to add to it for practical reasons just to keep kids engaged enough to finish.

    • @stelcxantisto
      @stelcxantisto 3 роки тому +4

      @@jasonpatterson9821 Agree, she can say something neutral, rather than good job or ok.

    • @leroyleon4411
      @leroyleon4411 3 роки тому +5

      This is why the child got annoyed at a point, whatever he does, no sign of appreciation.

  • @RandomPostsOnTheWeb
    @RandomPostsOnTheWeb 4 роки тому +1577

    Take a shot everytime we have to remember we’re playing the color game.

    • @milster08
      @milster08 4 роки тому +25

      I’m dead now!

    • @michaelcoelhojr6851
      @michaelcoelhojr6851 4 роки тому +33

      We aren’t playing the color game, we are playing the shape game

    • @monkchips
      @monkchips 4 роки тому +1

      I am now playing the colour game with the ceiling tiles in A&E!

    • @caroline8166
      @caroline8166 4 роки тому

      the more we drink the more we forget

    • @Kreamations
      @Kreamations 4 роки тому

      Matthew 🤣🤣🤣

  • @deaththekid16
    @deaththekid16 4 роки тому +1667

    When the kid said “I’m bored” I felt that

    • @Jupblup
      @Jupblup 4 роки тому +27

      Balrog360 Same, but I still finished the video

    • @DonkChlonk
      @DonkChlonk 4 роки тому +34

      4:33 timestamp incase anyone’s wondering

    • @Erraticfox
      @Erraticfox 4 роки тому +6

      @@DonkChlonk bruh I was stressing waiting six minutes to find that spot

    • @sanchit8864
      @sanchit8864 3 роки тому

      😂😂😂

    • @dragovern
      @dragovern 3 роки тому +2

      I thought he was going to say " i'm confused "

  • @ChadFaragher
    @ChadFaragher 4 роки тому +893

    I often worry that this is how I do my job, and nobody has the courage to tell me.

    • @relaxolotl_ltoloxaler
      @relaxolotl_ltoloxaler 3 роки тому +13

      I feel this.

    • @heidihol
      @heidihol 3 роки тому +4

      This is why asking for feedback is so helpful in professional settings but it requires vulnerability, humility, and confidence

    • @CaptChrispy
      @CaptChrispy 3 роки тому +12

      @espoir inconscient "I drive a flower delivery truck."

    • @martinshoosterman
      @martinshoosterman 3 роки тому +3

      @@CaptChrispy wait thats illegal

    • @hugow3266
      @hugow3266 3 роки тому

      Same

  • @sspito
    @sspito 4 роки тому +463

    The first rule of the shape game is that you never stops talking about the rules in the shape game.

  • @franciscofragoeiro5229
    @franciscofragoeiro5229 4 роки тому +868

    Pretty much, she says the rules so many times that he stops ignoring them, so when they change, he's like RIGHT HEEEEEA and keeps on with the previous rules

    • @kratos9524
      @kratos9524 4 роки тому +74

      its to see how the child responds to rule changes, does it understand the change or has the repeatance of the rule left a mark in the memory, its all about adaptation to the new game rules

    • @thebeetalls
      @thebeetalls 4 роки тому +119

      @@kratos9524 I think Francisco's hypothesis is correct. After hearing the same phrase over and over again, the child stopped listening. Even adults do this.
      Instruction caching is a very effective optimisation in computing -- particularly so for complex instruction set architectures. 🙂

    • @ziul123
      @ziul123 4 роки тому +69

      @@thebeetalls except later in the video she asked him to point out where trucks go and where flowers go in the shape game, and he correctly pointed the boxes out. So he didn't stop listening before the shape game explanation

    • @thebeetalls
      @thebeetalls 4 роки тому +27

      @@ziul123 When she asked where the "trucks" go he got it right, when she asked where the "blue trucks" go he got it wrong.

    • @ziul123
      @ziul123 4 роки тому +56

      @@thebeetalls yes. That means he was still listening, his brain was just not developed enough to overwrite the rules for the color game. Your observation doesn't invalidate what I said before

  • @PabloPerroPerro
    @PabloPerroPerro 4 роки тому +112

    This has to be the worst sorting algorithm I've seen in my life

    • @fabianlopez2060
      @fabianlopez2060 3 роки тому +5

      TRUE. but he's still a toddler. He wasn't paying attention anymore the color game was just engraved in the poor things memory. No wonder he stopped paying attention. I think we ALL stopped paying attention.

    • @shaaf99
      @shaaf99 Рік тому

      Proof that humans especially little onea are stupid

  • @CeladonHairExtraordinaire
    @CeladonHairExtraordinaire 4 роки тому +585

    Remember we're playing the shape game. In the shape game trucks go here and flowers go here. Here is a flower, where does it go in the shape game?

    • @kikodiaz
      @kikodiaz 4 роки тому +15

      Was just reading it when she was saying it :b

    • @josephrose4582
      @josephrose4582 4 роки тому +113

      Right theeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaa

    • @fldsfmfr8277
      @fldsfmfr8277 4 роки тому +9

      Right at the top of this thread, because you're my beautiful flower 💚

    • @thehaigu321
      @thehaigu321 4 роки тому +1

      @@fldsfmfr8277 h

    • @Schneemi
      @Schneemi 4 роки тому +4

      IN HEEEEEEEWWWEEE

  • @Lukemccarthy2011
    @Lukemccarthy2011 4 роки тому +605

    **Boy 20 years later driving a truck into a toll station**
    Sign: 'If your driving a truck please use the lanes to the right'
    Driver: **Swerves left**

  • @NoName-sj7cv
    @NoName-sj7cv 5 років тому +1023

    They should do this with terrorist this was pure torture to listen to those rules.

    • @milster08
      @milster08 4 роки тому +46

      No Name ReMeMbEr, We’Re PlAyInG tHe CoLoUr GaMe

    • @VestinVestin
      @VestinVestin 4 роки тому +43

      "Down on the fucking ground!"
      "This is the hostage game. The hostages go out the door, and the terrorists stay inside. Where do the terrorists stay?"
      "Uhhh... Here?"
      "Good... and where do the hostages go?"
      "Out there..."
      "Great ^^. Buh-bye!"

    • @abcd123906
      @abcd123906 4 роки тому +2

      No Name A reporter should also use this on Donald Trump: "Remember, in the popular vote game, the person with more votes wins and the person with fewer votes loses. Who would've won in 2016 in the popular vote game?"

    • @Eternence
      @Eternence 4 роки тому +5

      @@abcd123906 but thats not how it works... (Electoral college and all)

    • @abcd123906
      @abcd123906 4 роки тому

      Clinker Yes, I know, but Trump was pretty sour about not having also won the popular vote.

  • @trapped_monkey
    @trapped_monkey 6 років тому +699

    Like deeeeeEEeeeEeEeeeez????

    • @ayoubmerzak1733
      @ayoubmerzak1733 4 роки тому +5

      Deeeeeezzz hhhhhhhhhhhhh

    • @diabl2master
      @diabl2master 4 роки тому +29

      *Right heeeeeerreee

    • @tash5540
      @tash5540 4 роки тому +13

      He was going slow because he wanted confirmation

    • @mind-wont-ize9702
      @mind-wont-ize9702 4 роки тому +6

      Exactly. He wanted confirmation cuz he had a feeling he was wrong but as she kept on saying okay he kept on going with the color game....notice how he always hesitates.

    • @mylink.orb17
      @mylink.orb17 3 роки тому

      I read this just as he said 'HeeeeEEEeerre' 😆
      Also, like 666 🤘😈

  • @Phlebas
    @Phlebas 4 роки тому +883

    I feel like this was more of a test of the child's patience than his pattern recognition abilities.

    • @kovuyt3330
      @kovuyt3330 4 роки тому +31

      If I was that kid I wouldve just gotten fed up off her

    • @timturner7609
      @timturner7609 4 роки тому +50

      He clearly was not interested in the shape game. He would have left at the end of the color game if he hadn't been forced back into the seat. He even tried to bail on the shape game and had to be restrained by security lol

    • @lisaruggieri2359
      @lisaruggieri2359 4 роки тому +3

      He was confused and was looking for help

    • @ernestlam5632
      @ernestlam5632 4 роки тому +14

      Children are just simple adults . Adults have this same thinking but with more layers on top. I do wonder if he would have done better if he had not been told the color game rules repetively. The real insight is where she calls the cards by both characteristics. Color was given priority.

    • @Taytyaaytyat
      @Taytyaaytyat 4 роки тому +4

      @@ernestlam5632 I wonder if that's just because colors come before their noun in english. As in, said first

  • @Akirilus
    @Akirilus 7 років тому +323

    I think Max realized he dun got it wrong and decided to bail =)).

    • @panderzbananderz9320
      @panderzbananderz9320 4 роки тому +12

      Darathu That’s what I was thinking too. The game was rigged anyway. She demonstrated the color game but not the shape game. He did not realize that anything had changed. Her voice is annoyingly the same no matter what.

    • @youknowtherulesandsodoi4369
      @youknowtherulesandsodoi4369 4 роки тому +10

      That's the point

    • @Swagmittens
      @Swagmittens 4 роки тому +14

      girl: where do the trucks go?
      Max, realising he made a mistake: ah shit

    • @madhavraghu
      @madhavraghu 4 роки тому +1

      @@panderzbananderz9320wdym it was rigged that was literally the experiment

    • @Cookiedible
      @Cookiedible 4 роки тому +1

      @@panderzbananderz9320 he did realize since when asked when the trucks/flowers go in the shape game he pointed the right ones. The point is not to demonstrate but to let his abstract thinking do the work.

  • @MrTigroz
    @MrTigroz 4 роки тому +107

    Points for confidence. “Right THEEEEEIA.”

  • @hobbes296
    @hobbes296 3 роки тому +105

    It was interesting watching him second guess himself at some points. Like there were points where you could tell he sort of had the right idea about the shape game in his mind , but wanted confirmation, which he obviously didn't get, so it's just overridden and he just goes back to what he knows.

    • @smashypeople
      @smashypeople Рік тому +5

      2:49 exactly

    • @blissful4trees
      @blissful4trees Рік тому +4

      This kind of set up is mindf*** and soul damage to the innocent children. I am mad at the mad professors setting up these kinds of laboratories

    • @PichDextro
      @PichDextro Рік тому +6

      @@blissful4trees No and no mate, try again.

    • @waldoman7
      @waldoman7 Рік тому +2

      You're exactly right. He got disturbed enough by the weird game and weird acting person to leave and seek some reassurance, after which he got one right.
      Or, maybe that's us projecting. Ah, adult psychology xD

    • @jakeg3126
      @jakeg3126 11 місяців тому +2

      ⁠@@blissful4treesthey’ve done this stupid torture test for probably close to a century. Depending on age they force you to do some version of this if they do IQ test or challenge your mental cognition or whatever. I’ve had to do it several times before because they want to see if memory is ok with the whatever seizure drugs, or maybe whatever drugs/transplants in school just to see how I was doing. Luckily they shut up when you get to a certain age and you have to figure it out on your own later.

  • @hiimshana
    @hiimshana 4 роки тому +161

    He’s smurfing. He knows the trick. He’s not gonna let her win.

    • @starwarslego12
      @starwarslego12 4 роки тому +3

      CHALLENGER Shape Game Pro SMURFING in BRONZE!!

  • @chrisco8295
    @chrisco8295 11 років тому +431

    right deeeearrr

  • @Verseaurainbows
    @Verseaurainbows 6 років тому +617

    I can't believe this amazing child endured this woman's crap for almost 5 minutes. THAT'S some impressive prefrontal development

  • @Rikipedia42
    @Rikipedia42 Рік тому +21

    That feeling when you're stuck on a game tutorial but it's bugged and no matter how much you try you can't get past that one piece of dialogue saying "Oooh Kayyyhhh, remember we're playing the SHAPE GAME, remember flowers go HERE, and trucks go HERE"

  • @thisguy356
    @thisguy356 4 роки тому +57

    6 minutes of Max having existencial crisis
    The internet: mmh... *interesting*

  • @ninstagram
    @ninstagram 4 роки тому +49

    2:20 now we're gonna play the shape game
    Kid: I'm out

  • @jackmiddleton2080
    @jackmiddleton2080 4 роки тому +109

    4:22 I wonder if it is possible he put it together for a second and was disappointed with himself.

    • @megalocoman
      @megalocoman 4 роки тому +21

      It was like, "I'm done with your shit, I got confused"

    • @Sheridan2LT
      @Sheridan2LT 4 роки тому +4

      It was. IT DEFINITELY WAS THAT thank you!!

    • @bleedinghearts4768
      @bleedinghearts4768 4 роки тому +5

      Lmao he got mad cuz he KNOWS what he done did

  • @haelotny6523
    @haelotny6523 4 роки тому +29

    He is so cute 😭💕
    I love how he makes sure to flip the card before setting in down. Sweet little man

  • @SuddyBS
    @SuddyBS 4 роки тому +182

    Instructions unclear, I sill can’t remember where the blue one goes.

    • @Doopliss666
      @Doopliss666 4 роки тому +7

      Clearly it goes right theeeeeeeee

    • @Andi-ll1fh
      @Andi-ll1fh 4 роки тому +6

      But we're playing the shape game.

    • @naboost9485
      @naboost9485 3 роки тому +2

      can you put it in the box ?

    • @tohanov1
      @tohanov1 3 роки тому +1

      @FBI Somehow I don't doubt that

    • @mikelr9633
      @mikelr9633 3 роки тому +1

      Im wondering. How many ppl have an fbi account. Cause i see them everywhere

  • @Speedswiper
    @Speedswiper 5 років тому +148

    Remember, we're playing the color game. In the color game, red ones go here, and blue ones go here.

  • @Thyco2501
    @Thyco2501 3 роки тому +19

    I liked how he flipped the card once he noticed that she had done the same at 0:54. Smart kid.

    • @BrianBull
      @BrianBull 9 місяців тому +1

      ya i caught that awesome!

  • @aizhol
    @aizhol 9 років тому +133

    I wonder where would he put a yellow submarine?

  • @RydalS
    @RydalS 4 роки тому +232

    He seems like he is very unsure of themselves when they start playing the shape game, but since he's never corrected, he keeps putting them in colours. He takes the "ok" to mean the same as good job. And he ignores the rules of the shape game because he has no attention span to listen to the rules every time.

    • @christinestevenson4482
      @christinestevenson4482 4 роки тому +71

      Jacob Stevenson They're not trying to teach the kid, it's an experiment on child development. She's probably instructed to not make eye contact when he looks for validation as he puts the cards in. To not give any cues that he's doing it wrong, because they want to see his thought process, *not* the way he reacts to the adults.

    • @Pfillep
      @Pfillep 4 роки тому +32

      Yeah, Christine is right. This is a controlled test with possibly dozen of children and quantifiable outcomes.
      Of course you could instruct the boy better and change sentences, tone of voice, change facial mimics or add more feedback to better "guide" his behaviour.
      However. That would skew the results if you want a general understanding of 3yr olds average development. You have to act the same for every child for the tests to be comparable.

    • @Pfillep
      @Pfillep 4 роки тому +24

      @Jacob Stevenson
      Yeah. This should not be understood as a lesson, this is simply data gathering.
      The goal is not that children learn anything from this. They usually don't and it is sometimes even counterproductive to learning. It is not harmful though if the child is not tested every day...

    • @mipuntodevista3988
      @mipuntodevista3988 4 роки тому +1

      He’s mind has left the chat.

    • @NotSandhorst
      @NotSandhorst 4 роки тому +2

      So it's basically school???? RIP

  • @jayworldjs
    @jayworldjs 4 роки тому +16

    This is exactly how I train people at my job through repetition of practical application and yet, I still have to repeat myself too.

  • @jackrandello9089
    @jackrandello9089 2 роки тому +22

    During the colour game, there was positive reinforcement for putting blue cards in the blue box. While in the shape game even when the boy put the correct shape in the correct box there was no positive reinforcement. I believe this could've impacted the results, Cheers.

    • @amethystsunangel1955
      @amethystsunangel1955 Рік тому

      I didn't notice that he got any correct in the shape game.

    • @daniidee
      @daniidee Рік тому

      @@amethystsunangel1955 yes, just one

  • @Greennoob2
    @Greennoob2 4 роки тому +28

    it's interesting how when he thought he was playing tbe shape game wrong, he waited, maybe looking for a response from the tester, and when he got the same feedback as with the colour game, he assumed the outcomes are the same.
    I'm probably over-assuming.

    • @Cookiedible
      @Cookiedible 4 роки тому +6

      @Darren Munsell Yeah but the goal isn't to see him learn through feedback. The goal is closer to demonstrating that he still hasn't acquired the capacity to make a Caesar salad but switch to a Niçoise when told to (provided he knew both recipes, the same way the child know what trucks, flowers, red and blue mean)

  • @applejuice8271
    @applejuice8271 4 роки тому +39

    Nice androids we have nowadays! She looks exactly like a human, that's so impressing!

  • @amersleiman4120
    @amersleiman4120 4 роки тому +57

    What was the darn prize... I want to know if the kid got hustled

    • @mproductions8285
      @mproductions8285 3 роки тому +11

      The prize was not having to play the shape game anymore

    • @NieColall
      @NieColall 3 роки тому

      @@mproductions8285 Damn. So basically I work my ass off to die at the end. Interesting perspective, brb I'm gonna kill myself now

    • @NieColall
      @NieColall 3 роки тому +1

      @@lordoa I made a joke but I really appreciate the effort you did to make me feel better in case im serious

  • @SkyNinja759
    @SkyNinja759 3 роки тому +2

    This lady gives off unskippable tutorial energy.

  • @AmanBansal0601
    @AmanBansal0601 6 років тому +59

    That was painful to watch

  • @cipherxen2
    @cipherxen2 4 роки тому +11

    Woman : Remember we're playing color game
    Kid : That's enough. I'll ignore all the other rules, because I'm bored.

  • @harshrajsinghrathore2812
    @harshrajsinghrathore2812 4 роки тому +8

    It's more like the routine of it that the kid gets used to I think
    When he stood up to leave and then sat back down , he got it right. After a while I feel like he's not even listening anymore

  • @sminthian
    @sminthian 3 роки тому +17

    I wish they would tell us their interpretation of this. He understands the rules of both games. But he won't do the second one. You can tell he keeps looking at her for a reaction if he's correct or not, and she knows that and isn't giving a reaction. So, is he actually confused by how to play the game, or is he testing her reaction and isn't liking that she won't tell him if he's right or wrong?

  • @keiganogrady7481
    @keiganogrady7481 4 роки тому +6

    Anyone else break into cold sweats when she switched from the colour game to the shape game

  • @wiggycat3145
    @wiggycat3145 4 роки тому +6

    And now I activate my pot of greed, which allows me to draw two additional cards from my deck!

  • @ejanocrowsnatcher6785
    @ejanocrowsnatcher6785 4 роки тому +6

    lol 0:51 he turns around like
    "this lady be crazy why am I here with her" XD

  • @markahc
    @markahc 4 роки тому +4

    I think he just stopped listening to the rules after hearing them a bazillion times.

  • @brittonspeciale9075
    @brittonspeciale9075 4 роки тому +9

    I'm 18 years old and I'm still trying to figure out where the flowers and the trucks are supposed to go.

  • @littlemissdancerx333
    @littlemissdancerx333 10 років тому +3

    Thank you for this video! It helped out a lot with our Theory of Mind lab and DCSS card sort.

  • @erkinoztekin
    @erkinoztekin 4 роки тому +27

    This comment section is full of experts who know better than actual child psychologists.

    • @furletov
      @furletov 3 роки тому

      These 'psychologists' can't keep him engaged for 5 goddamn minutes

  • @RealTalkChristina
    @RealTalkChristina 4 роки тому +14

    4:25 aight imma head out

  • @marianacarvalho5239
    @marianacarvalho5239 4 роки тому +15

    I think this also tells us that after some repetition we stop paying attention

    • @Cookiedible
      @Cookiedible 4 роки тому +2

      Nah, he understood the rule since he could answer the questions about the shape game in the absence of cards.

    • @xHSBunny
      @xHSBunny 3 роки тому

      true tho.

    • @GrubKiller436
      @GrubKiller436 3 роки тому

      Because she just sounds that dull after the 50th time. And he wanted to leave.

  • @ButiLao44
    @ButiLao44 4 роки тому +5

    6:02 my teachers after they just witnessed me legendarily failing

  • @pinheadlarry8401
    @pinheadlarry8401 4 роки тому +3

    4:22
    Max: Aight imma head out

  • @iannacn4951
    @iannacn4951 4 роки тому +3

    I wonder how they feel viewing themselves 10 years later

  • @dabdotnet
    @dabdotnet 4 роки тому +14

    This guy is gonna be 14 this year. Wow, i want to see him do it today.

  • @angelomenezes1203
    @angelomenezes1203 11 років тому +10

    Thank you so much for this info. I found the video very interesting and I would include it in my Cognitive Class presentation on "Executive Function."

  • @clover-il7tf
    @clover-il7tf 3 роки тому +1

    “Right theeeeeere!”
    So cute!

  • @jayzeldietermiguel6430
    @jayzeldietermiguel6430 4 роки тому +2

    "can you put it in?" This is by far the most adult thing you can say in a family friendly video

  • @kzcreationzmore
    @kzcreationzmore 4 роки тому +3

    Her: Okay we are playing the SHAPE game. Can you tell me where the TRUCKS go?
    Him: Here? *points to the truck*
    Her: mhm and where the flowers go?
    Him: here: *points to flowers
    Her: Good. Here is a truck, where does it go?
    Him: FLOWER!

    • @apieceofschmitt
      @apieceofschmitt 4 роки тому +1

      Her: Verbally says "Truck"
      Him: Points to image of truck
      Her: Presents image of a "Blue Truck"
      Him: Mind goes "BLUE! BLUE!" since colors provide more basic and immediate stimulus than shapes, and he places it in the Blue position.
      It's the visual that's confusing him. Is she held the image of the card toward herself and told the child it was a truck, and asked where it went, my guess is he would answer correctly.
      I'd like to see this experiment in reverse order.

  • @NJoint
    @NJoint 4 роки тому +6

    My thoughts during the video:
    THIS KID IS A GENI...oh no, nevermind, he is not.

  • @alexandersanchez9138
    @alexandersanchez9138 4 роки тому +1

    After the disruption, he was briefly able to change gears. That’s useful information.

  • @Charlie092
    @Charlie092 4 роки тому +2

    The colour game... a game of life and death

  • @ShubhamSharma-tn3wm
    @ShubhamSharma-tn3wm 4 роки тому +5

    "Can you put it in??"
    "Right deaaaa"
    "Stupid Men"
    🙄

  • @clazdelune
    @clazdelune 11 років тому +67

    But Max does recognise that flowers and trucks are different shapes. At three years old, his brain is not developed enough to be flexible like ours, so when you give him a new rule, his brain cannot inhibit the old colour rule.

  • @onthespoke2
    @onthespoke2 Рік тому +2

    they had us in the first half not gonna lie

  • @iAdden
    @iAdden 2 роки тому +2

    Max has other things to do and he’s tired of telling you where it’s supposed to go 😂😂😂

  • @RydalS
    @RydalS 4 роки тому +4

    She's really sounds like a robot 🤖

  • @Akirilus
    @Akirilus 7 років тому +6

    I don't think the kid knows what the word shape is tbh.

  • @HashlessBrown
    @HashlessBrown 3 роки тому +1

    The aim of the study was to find the level of patience in kids and this kid showed tremendous patience with 'Remember we're playing..'

  • @InstinctRush
    @InstinctRush 4 роки тому +1

    Getting a 3 year old to sit through and complete this task is the real achievement captured in the video

  • @oOKazeKitsuneOo
    @oOKazeKitsuneOo 5 років тому +10

    Reminds me of when I was 7 or 8, I kept going down the water slide at the local pool backwards. When I got to the bottom, the life guard whistled and yelled a single word I couldn’t understand (probably because the rushing water sounds from being dunked in the pool).
    I continued to go down backwards many more times and she would blow the whistle once and yell that one word each time that I still couldn’t understand.
    It took me several times to realize she was whistling at me, but because she never scolded me, asked me not to go backwards, or even looked at me, I figured it was just a thing they did when people went down the slide backwards.
    Finally, after going down what seemed like 15+ times (backwards), she stopped me and said I wasn’t allowed to slide down the slide backwards. And I didn’t slide down the slide backwards after that.
    Slightly different, but still! Shows that kids really need clear boundaries and corrective action rather than passive reactions.
    I’m a vegan now and I could draw parallels there too, but I don’t wanna get too preachy, haha.

    • @FireStormBaller
      @FireStormBaller 4 роки тому +6

      Q: How can you tell if someone is vegan?
      A: They’ll tell you.

  • @KaizerKilborn
    @KaizerKilborn Рік тому +4

    He had an example the first game, but no example the second game. This shows he does not trust the words he hears as much as his eyes with the rules shown to him as the first one is my guess.

  • @MarjoForcado
    @MarjoForcado 3 роки тому +1

    “Can you put it in?” Literally thats what she said

  • @osamabinladder9677
    @osamabinladder9677 4 роки тому +3

    i would totally destroy this test

  • @fabionidas4832
    @fabionidas4832 4 роки тому +4

    We're playing the comment game. In the comment game, words go here and likes go here
    ⬇️

  • @anitaanil6333
    @anitaanil6333 4 роки тому +5

    What if this kid watches this video now, after 10 years of uploading😆

  • @user-vg8kd7zl8x
    @user-vg8kd7zl8x 4 роки тому +1

    애기 중간중간에 거울 보는 거 귀엽... 이와중에 한국인 나밖에 없네..ㅠㅠ소외감

  • @DaltonHBrown
    @DaltonHBrown 4 роки тому

    Im most amazed that he put the cards face down correctly even without being told.

  • @michaelgubser9528
    @michaelgubser9528 4 роки тому +3

    I was watching this video at 3:58 o’clock in the morning

  • @deanmoncaster
    @deanmoncaster 4 роки тому +3

    Apparently she explained the rules of the game but I think I missed it when I skipped 5 seconds of the video.

  • @Anonymous-vr9hp
    @Anonymous-vr9hp 4 роки тому +1

    Okay, we're playing the shape game and in the shape game we don't stop until you're banging your head off the table, okay

  • @nerhu59
    @nerhu59 11 років тому +2

    That's kinda the point in perseveration behavior within the DCCS task. After the dimensional rule switch is made, instructions may not be repeated, it would interfere with the measured behavior.

  • @JuliaPetrova
    @JuliaPetrova 11 років тому +8

    Where's my prize, lady?

  • @durzapoduszka
    @durzapoduszka 5 років тому +29

    ReMEmBeR iN a COloUr gAmE rEd onEs gO HeRE AnD BlUe OnES Go hERe.

  • @TheAcdcninja
    @TheAcdcninja 3 роки тому

    When he started to work out the flipping of the card too I was so impressed

  • @ashlady9
    @ashlady9 4 роки тому

    When he flipped it over! What a precious child!

  • @abcd123906
    @abcd123906 4 роки тому +9

    Somehow I feel like if she'd said "no, no, no, is that really the right answer?" the first time he made the mistake in the shape game, he would've gotten it the rest of the way. You can see him hesitating the first few times when they switch to the shape game.

    • @tommasobonvicini7114
      @tommasobonvicini7114 4 роки тому +4

      I think this too: he never realized he was wrong. The OK sounded to him exactly like the GOOD JOB, but it wasn't OK to fail. The thing I am not sure about is the end goal though: if the end goal is to put the child in a contradictory state, to stimulate his self-critique, than I would say that was the right thing to do, otherwise I am quite doubtful.

    • @abcd123906
      @abcd123906 4 роки тому +7

      @@tommasobonvicini7114 Exactly! The difference in her response between when he got it right or wrong was almost undetectable, especially for such a young child. But he was clearly frustrated for the second half of the game. I think he knew something wasn't right.

  • @marioserpico2223
    @marioserpico2223 3 роки тому +10

    [4:41] He can see right through her (mad face) 😒 "She's a witch!"
    _Generally, this test shows that visual stimulations are better developed than linguistic ones, at the age of 3._
    It also shows, through its execution, that reward system and repetition is highly influencing the child's decision.
    Furthermore, within the visual observations, the child responds better on the color rather than the shape of the object.
    In addition, the child expects to play a game regardless of what the rules are or how it's called. So, it only pays attention to the first part of the 'game' which happens to be the color game.
    (+) Specifically this child seems to be easily bored [2:20] - He even admits to it [4:32]
    The point made by this test is interesting, non the less, biased. The (average) data needs to be combined with other test's (average) data for a more accurate conclusion. [ In which it was already done, in real life, by real scientists, a long time ago, in a galaxy far.. far away ]
    The child pays more attention on the word 'game' rather than the word 'shape' or 'color'. [ So what is actually expected of the child, the child is unaware ]
    The color game was played first, the shape game was played last. [ What about the reverse order? ]
    The color game was introduced with visual instructions from the 'Dealer' lady, while the shape game was not introduced visually. Both games were explained verbally.
    Visual pointers were present at every turn.
    The verbal explanations were mentioned every step of the game, yet the child did not pay attention to them.
    The verbal understanding of the child was briefly evaluated [3:58], confirming that it has full comprehension of what is verbally inferred in terms of language, but not its 'meaning'.
    The child did not get 'rewarded' when he got the shape correct [5:05] [ No Good job? ]
    OK
    No children were hurt, or damaged in any way because of this test.
    And we don't have to play the shame game.
    I am not a specialist. This is 'just' a youtube comment.
    I enjoy wasting my time, and so are you 🤨

  • @stuart124
    @stuart124 4 роки тому +1

    He learned an important life lesson; to tolerate people you find tedious.

  • @wonder7798
    @wonder7798 3 роки тому +1

    He knew and was looking to her for approval. That is why he no longer wanted to play because he was unsure

  • @danielcreevey6364
    @danielcreevey6364 11 років тому +10

    I'm pretty sure the kid knows were the colours go now

  • @max903br3
    @max903br3 4 роки тому +6

    Woman: were do the truck goes?
    Boy: visible confusion

  • @lisakay8253
    @lisakay8253 4 роки тому +1

    This looks like an exhausting task to administer lol

  • @JosefLarsen
    @JosefLarsen 4 роки тому

    Am I the only one actually finding this really relaxing and soothing?

  • @MiRoo427
    @MiRoo427 10 років тому +5

    hahahahahahahaha can't stop laughing

  • @harrymayhew1516
    @harrymayhew1516 5 років тому +4

    U reckon he's playing the colour game ?

  • @dannyboygregory-mccormick9157
    @dannyboygregory-mccormick9157 4 роки тому +2

    5:14 "I just played that game!" He's so done I'm dying 😂

  • @mrym.a6640
    @mrym.a6640 Рік тому

    I love the way he say theeeeeeeere hahah so sweet