The Murray one is a perfect example of an umpire’s ego being too big to admit they were wrong. Ridiculous decision anyone with eyes can see the mark is out
It was close and I don't blame Mo for thinking it was in But the Goffin umpire was the pure definition of an egotistical idiot who knows he's wrong but refuses to change his decision
Pliskova v Sakkari, when Pliskova smashed near the right side-line, and hit the ball well in, got called out, and she smashed the umpires chair; this may be the WORST I ever saw (look that one up). But if THAT wasn't the worst, then surely Cirstea having to challenge SIX calls in one set (correctly), must be a record. I dont understand how the linespeople could be so bad, so consistently. Absolutely appalling performance from the officials. I cant wait for the day when there is some form of electronic line calling. It will totally eliminate that area of argument, and bring a fairer playing field to everyone.
As an avid tennis fan and watcher, seeing this video actually makes my blood boil. We have a unique situation with our sport where we can get objective, consistent calls using technology on all surfaces. 2025 can't come soon enough
It is not his job to interfere. You can't just be giving points at such a moment, no matter if the umpire made such a big mistake. He could've, but definitely not his fault. You should be asking how a human with two eyes can miss something like that. That one is for suspension. Plus, the point would probably be his, since his lob was perfect.
I remember being an umpire for other kids games when I was 11 or something. I had to both do the umpiring and all the line calls. One time I was the umpire for some older kids, maybe 16-17 but I'm not sure. They were hitting hard and close to the line all the time. Especially very hard serves. It was stressful af to make correct line calls since I wasn't used to such high level matches. One of the players got mad at me at the start of the match for not calling a close serve out. Luckily it was clay so I could go down and verify that the ball was out.
adel nour messed up big time. even tho khacahnov was gonna lose the point, that ball was at least a foot in. and also what happened to mohamad layhani at rome?
We have to start getting these more consistent correct instead of making highlight reels about how frustrated players get when they lose a point on a bad line call.
please keep in mind that umpires and line umpires are just trying to do their job, everyone makes mistakes, we are human .. just some seconds not 100% focused or lost the ballmark can end up in huge drama where always the umpire gets blaimed for … this is not fair. They are just trying to do their job as best as they can .. and everyone can have a rough day 🙏🏽🥹 when everythings goes well, no one points out how good the job from an umpire was .. just always pointing out mistakes
man some of these empires are so bad, worse than the weekend warriors at the park. the goffin one he had clear view, he shouldnt even come down the chair, and the massu lahani one was even worse he dindt wanna come down the chair. massu robbed 3 points and funny lahani "corrected" the hardest ball LOL its 2024 almost pls ATP get techologized
On average, linemen/empire make between two and three mistakes per match. But some mistakes are huge. If I was Khachanov, I wouldn’t move away from the mark, and ask for the supervisor, the tournament referee, and even for god himself to come check it.
That first match is an absolute shit show. How tf isn't there Hawkeye in place there!? Using marks on the ground on clay is also stupid af. If the technology is there, use it.
When you see blatantly bad calls like this being made, I think it calls into question the validity of certain matches. I wouldn't be shocked if instinctively, the better players received more leniency than lower ranked lesser known players. Hypothetically, would the Big 4 still be the Big 4 today if auto hawkeye was implemented decades ago?
What was we he supposed to do? It was called out by the line judge and the umpire overruled it even after looking at the wrong mark. Umpires never go back on their overrules
Impossible situations really. Those balls are traveling so fast, and the line judges and umpires really have no way of being 100% certain. Obviously you can’t give the player the benefit of the doubt, but it’s too bad hawk eye couldn’t have corrected those absolutely horrendous calls. Not that humans are or should be held to that standard, but if the mark of the ball is completely out then it’s out dude… stop imagining things. Thank god in the future it will all be electronic.
The Murray one is a perfect example of an umpire’s ego being too big to admit they were wrong. Ridiculous decision anyone with eyes can see the mark is out
you can see it from the moon
It was close and I don't blame Mo for thinking it was in
But the Goffin umpire was the pure definition of an egotistical idiot who knows he's wrong but refuses to change his decision
Wish Murray would have grabbed his phone and take a photo and spread it on socials so we could all see the ref blunder.
@@along1298 how's this different from this one?
@@Nat-oj2uc The ball was closer to the line than the Goffin situation
Kachanov out is 10 CEntimetres In 🤣🤣
Absolutely 10-15 cm i swear
Goffin should have been up by 4 games to 2 and ended up losing 6-3 6-1 to Rafa... How cruel ☹
It's not cruel because he faced rafa
@@Laland_1196it is cruel because it was out. Even Rafa must follow the rules
@@aythanraherisoanjato3056 And Tennis TV glorifies this umpire behaviour… shame on them
Typical Nadal match
@@mfzoom5401how? there’s written “controversial”
In summary, GET RID OF LINE JUDGES
Pliskova v Sakkari, when Pliskova smashed near the right side-line, and hit the ball well in, got called out, and she smashed the umpires chair; this may be the WORST I ever saw (look that one up).
But if THAT wasn't the worst, then surely Cirstea having to challenge SIX calls in one set (correctly), must be a record. I dont understand how the linespeople could be so bad, so consistently. Absolutely appalling performance from the officials.
I cant wait for the day when there is some form of electronic line calling. It will totally eliminate that area of argument, and bring a fairer playing field to everyone.
I actually don’t understand HOW the ump in the first clip is still an umpire on the atp. His calls were outrageous
Lahyani gets away with his crap umpiring by smiling.
He's one of the best and most respected by the players. No one is perfect.
As an avid tennis fan and watcher, seeing this video actually makes my blood boil. We have a unique situation with our sport where we can get objective, consistent calls using technology on all surfaces. 2025 can't come soon enough
I hope you'll be replaced by some technology too soon enough
Totally agree. Wasn't it supposed to be 2024?
Evans is such an unfair player. I can't believe he didn't see the ball hit the court on after Karen's first shot!
It is not his job to interfere. You can't just be giving points at such a moment, no matter if the umpire made such a big mistake. He could've, but definitely not his fault. You should be asking how a human with two eyes can miss something like that. That one is for suspension. Plus, the point would probably be his, since his lob was perfect.
hes always crying too , throwing tantrums every set. and CMON CMON! u think that kinda person would be fair play like nadal?
it wouldve been good sportsmanship to ask for a replay, but he did'nt have to and its not his fault for not doing it
They dont have challenges in Antwerp?
@@smashthestateXwhat do you expect from a cocaine addict?
I remember being an umpire for other kids games when I was 11 or something. I had to both do the umpiring and all the line calls. One time I was the umpire for some older kids, maybe 16-17 but I'm not sure. They were hitting hard and close to the line all the time. Especially very hard serves. It was stressful af to make correct line calls since I wasn't used to such high level matches. One of the players got mad at me at the start of the match for not calling a close serve out. Luckily it was clay so I could go down and verify that the ball was out.
Point being?
@@tiberiusiorgulescu The point was to make you read
@@tiberiusiorgulescu point being that most people and casual fans underestimate how difficult of a job it can be.
The End. 🙂
I saw both Tsitsipas and Nadal pointing to wrong ball marks. So much gamesmanship from those two. They should be called out
I saw sissy stealing money from 15k people at once
adel nour messed up big time. even tho khacahnov was gonna lose the point, that ball was at least a foot in. and also what happened to mohamad layhani at rome?
We have to start getting these more consistent correct instead of making highlight reels about how frustrated players get when they lose a point on a bad line call.
It's just a game relax
Where’s the Donaldson one? 😂
sorry were kachanov’s challenges over?
please keep in mind that umpires and line umpires are just trying to do their job, everyone makes mistakes, we are human .. just some seconds not 100% focused or lost the ballmark can end up in huge drama where always the umpire gets blaimed for … this is not fair. They are just trying to do their job as best as they can .. and everyone can have a rough day 🙏🏽🥹 when everythings goes well, no one points out how good the job from an umpire was .. just always pointing out mistakes
Why didnt khachanov challenge??
There was no challenge in that tournament
I didn't know that umpire messed up so much when he was younger.
man some of these empires are so bad, worse than the weekend warriors at the park. the goffin one he had clear view, he shouldnt even come down the chair, and the massu lahani one was even worse he dindt wanna come down the chair. massu robbed 3 points and funny lahani "corrected" the hardest ball LOL its 2024 almost pls ATP get techologized
All these umpires and line judges should have been fired right after the damages they caused.
Right they should be jailed. Bet you never make mistakes 🤡
I think some matches are rigged and some umpires are sports betting addicts and they make their own odds and bets.
Layani again and again, what a surprise !
And people calling him the best umpire. He is one of the worst, he just smiles and gets away with it.
How many of these calls was he involved in? More than half?
@@ey039524 Yeah but he was right on all but the Andy Murray one.
Say what you will about the calls but i find challges much more entertaining than automatic robot calls
Rafa vs ferrer underrated rivalry .they played nearly 20 times in clay but no extended highlights from their clay clashes..
Subtitles would have been nice.
Tennis don't need judges' human error. Get rid of them already. We have all the tech, believe me
When are you gonna be replaced at your job?
Don’t get me wrong I know Kachanov is known as an incendiary attitude in the sport but he was done _DIRTY_
First game clearly fixed
good that Goffin ignored the umpire at the end
Wanna know why there probably calling them out A. They want the other person to win B. Maybe it’s because half of. These empires are old
I wouldn’t take an umpire job even if I were offered USD150,000 a year
7min in, Nadal not honest enough to pipe up that his ball was well long, while the umpire was making a fool of himself.
stupid comment
7 umpires disliked this video :p :p
Antwerp had no hawk eye during Covid?
In Murray case the ball was Out !
That referee is making too many errors! Hint! Hint!
On average, linemen/empire make between two and three mistakes per match. But some mistakes are huge. If I was Khachanov, I wouldn’t move away from the mark, and ask for the supervisor, the tournament referee, and even for god himself to come check it.
if they also take compilation from WTA, the call in Amarissa Toth vs Zhang Shuai should be on the top of this list. It was pure garbage call
That first match is an absolute shit show. How tf isn't there Hawkeye in place there!? Using marks on the ground on clay is also stupid af. If the technology is there, use it.
Karen wants to speak to the manager
When you see blatantly bad calls like this being made, I think it calls into question the validity of certain matches. I wouldn't be shocked if instinctively, the better players received more leniency than lower ranked lesser known players. Hypothetically, would the Big 4 still be the Big 4 today if auto hawkeye was implemented decades ago?
I think so. Look at the Federer vs Nadal Wimbledon #5 for Fed. Nadal challenged 4 times and won all 4, by 1 or 2 ml. Federer still won.
Frkn umpires should be fired !
Referee trying to screw himself a Russian! Again and again. We are fed up with this attitude!
Никаких линейных и судей на вышке, только глаз орла, система должна следить а не тупые людишки
True
Beating Nadal on clay is almost impossible, even when all the calls are RIGHT!!
GET RID OF THE BLOODY UMPIRES THEY DO MASSIVE MISTAKES CALLS IN IMPORTANT MATCHES
Most cases here are not controversial at all. They are either pure robbery or malpractice.
У судей глаза в попе находятся
Lost a ton of respect for Rafa for his behavior against Goffin
what did he do ?
what did he do ?
on what exactly?
What was we he supposed to do? It was called out by the line judge and the umpire overruled it even after looking at the wrong mark. Umpires never go back on their overrules
I'm sure Nadal is so sad about losing respect from a loser like you
he nadal goffin fiasco, the narrators were why didn't the linesman came up and told the umpire he was mistaken, easy it was nadal that is why.
Tennis is still so primitive
Thats a vintage khachanov cheating perfr9amcne
Goes to show Federer and Nadal have received favourable calls their entire career.
errore humano est
ok
ラヒカスが遂に白日にさらされる
Demostrativo histórico de que poco importa la época, siempre le van a robar al tenista chileno.
So glad Nadal lost the slam race to Novak. Justice served in the end.
The decision is made by umpire. Not the players, not the coaches, not the audience
Massu
Impossible situations really. Those balls are traveling so fast, and the line judges and umpires really have no way of being 100% certain. Obviously you can’t give the player the benefit of the doubt, but it’s too bad hawk eye couldn’t have corrected those absolutely horrendous calls. Not that humans are or should be held to that standard, but if the mark of the ball is completely out then it’s out dude… stop imagining things. Thank god in the future it will all be electronic.
21 sekunder ago!!!!!
What was the problem of the last one? Federer hit a winner lob anyway. I hate these kind of players
Shelton and Alcatraz are so annoying
murray stop crying and just retire.
Why don't they just have a var for tennis for every point. It could be done in milliseconds