The nature of time - Boundaries of the Knowable (7/10)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 вер 2024
  • We all start off thinking there is just the one time the same for everyone. Professor Russell Stannard shows how relativity theory shows this not to be the case.
    (Part 7 of 10)
    Playlist link - • Boundaries of the Know...
    Transcript link - podcast.open.ac...
    Related content in:
    Space, Time and Consciousness: Track 1 www.open.edu/o...
    Boundaries of the knowable www.open.edu/o...
    Study a free course on the arts and humanities at the Open University www.open.edu/o...
    Study module S207 The physical world with the OU
    www.open.ac.uk/...
    Study R14 BA (Honours) Arts and Humanities (Philosophy)
    www.open.ac.uk/...
    The Open University is the world’s leading provider of flexible, high-quality online degrees and distance learning, serving students across the globe with highly respected degree qualifications, and the triple-accredited MBA. The OU teaches through its own unique method of distance learning, called ‘supported open learning’ and you do not need any formal qualifications to study with us, just commitment and a desire to find out what you are capable of.
    Free learning from The Open University
    www.open.edu/op...
    For more like this subscribe to the Open University channel
    / @openlearn_ou
    Like us on Facebook: / ouopenlearn
    Follow us on Twitter: / oufreelearning
    #OpenUniversity #thought

КОМЕНТАРІ • 47

  • @kapplejacks22
    @kapplejacks22 13 років тому +10

    Has anyone ever noticed that when you dream, it sometimes seems as though you've been dreaming for hours, but when you awake, you realize that you've only been dreaming for an hour or less?

    • @JohnDoe_69
      @JohnDoe_69 2 роки тому

      Yeah and? There's always the coocoo heads with their hoodoo "theories" in the comments...

    • @noahian3215
      @noahian3215 Рік тому +2

      @@JohnDoe_69 well what’s your theory?

    • @nd264u7
      @nd264u7 6 місяців тому

      I heard dreams only last s few seconds

  • @Homeostase.medicina
    @Homeostase.medicina 2 роки тому +5

    This is definitely the hardest video to understand of this series hahahaha! It's kinda hard to view time from such a different perspective after years seeing it as separated from the 3D. It really impresses me how Eistein was able to come to this conclusion by himself! True genius!

    • @dragon___
      @dragon___ 2 роки тому +1

      basically, the faster you are, the less you age

  • @GENCE.01
    @GENCE.01 14 років тому +5

    Confusing, so much so that even Professor Russel gets confused. Thank you for all of the videos, I'm loving it, but this episode was the most difficult to fit in my head, until now. I already knew the theory of Einstein that said time is different with speed, but it is still difficult to understand how speed can change time...

    • @life42theuniverse
      @life42theuniverse 2 роки тому

      If the viewer runs around or watches at 0.5x the program takes longer...

  • @swaroopa1965
    @swaroopa1965 8 років тому +9

    this guy is amazing!

    • @joxnjoxn399
      @joxnjoxn399 2 роки тому

      He has a good sense of humor right? Not to mention being a great teacher

  • @builderbuilder616
    @builderbuilder616 10 років тому +3

    I like all the episodes, very Interesting and thought provoking , and I love the humour at the ends :)

  • @DiGiTaLdAzEDM
    @DiGiTaLdAzEDM 13 років тому +1

    After thinking quite hard about time, I came to the conclusion that time is change, or rather the perception of change. What is change? change is the conscious experience of the sequential unfolding of that which IS. At some level of 'reality' all events from the largest to the tiniest exist simultaneously--timelessly. Time is the experience of that reality manifesting in a sequential manner. That's the best I've come up with so far anyways.

  • @clintonraubenheimer5879
    @clintonraubenheimer5879 10 років тому +1

    10:38 could not help laughing because right up to that point I was pausing the video to wrap my mind around what he was saying

  • @SeladorCellardoor
    @SeladorCellardoor 13 років тому +1

    The problem I have with the idea of the block universe is as follows: It seems to me to be quite plausible that if time is literally part of the whole continuum, then past, present and future events are there, frozen, as an existing part of the universe. But if our experience of time is merely a psychological mechanism, surely it requires the passing of time for the mental experience to happen. Like all theories of time this seems to need a meta-time to work.

  • @JoeyCbr
    @JoeyCbr 2 роки тому

    Why have I only just found this guy, this is really well put together

  • @odairfernandes1912
    @odairfernandes1912 10 років тому +2

    Although I have seen many videos talking about this subject, I have to admit that this video brought me new things to think about it. Great!!!!!!!!!

  • @qcon81
    @qcon81 13 років тому

    you r the greatest. u just awoke me. thanks for the videos professor!

  • @3fast5you
    @3fast5you 12 років тому +2

    If I swing my arms around while spinning in a circle, will that make my arms older than me?

  • @Sorya-gf7qw
    @Sorya-gf7qw 4 роки тому +2

    Assume that guy in craft makes a phone call to guy on planet , what will happen then ? so does space guy says - hey buddy slow down I cant understand a thing .

    • @namahshrestha3226
      @namahshrestha3226 2 роки тому

      Just like the reduction in relative distance. I assume there will be something that'll make things seem normal.

  • @twistedbasser
    @twistedbasser 10 років тому +3

    Thank you so much for the ending to this video. For a few years now I have been questioning the fundamental implications of time. I seem to be settled on it being rather more a unit of measurement than a building block of reality. Our experiences of past and future are but illusions created by our consciousness to try and explain how our lives have beginnings and endings. There is no past or future, they are not real...... Seems that perhaps our understanding of time going faster or slower to an observer may be simply an example of perspective, or as Einstein would have loved to put it.. relativity? Oh wow, then again perhaps our struggle to understand time changing for an observer is related to the classic struggle for a unifying theory.. Perhaps time changing relative to the speed of an observer is related to the quantum theory of how light itself can change from being a wave or a particle depending on observation..

  • @Sorya-gf7qw
    @Sorya-gf7qw 4 роки тому +1

    watch videos at 2x speed for some time and then read some book or think it will appear that your mind is thinking faster for some time . ( almost same thing 1:15)

  • @TearyEyesAnderson
    @TearyEyesAnderson 13 років тому

    In that way 'Time' is what is observed by the motion, each person can agree that there was motion but not agree exactly by how much, or the speed of that motion, since it will seem to have changed depending on the perspective of the observer. However the 'Time'/motion is either moving forward or at rest, in which way time could possibly stop if the speed of light or, the absolute zero were reached. One no motion and no time, the other change couldn't catch up to the motion/'Time'.

  • @Larro4
    @Larro4 14 років тому

    Great video!

  • @TearyEyesAnderson
    @TearyEyesAnderson 13 років тому

    I see 'Time' as motion, not as a fourth dimension, but as motion with in the 3 dimensions. Just like if u see a person on the 3rd floor of a building at the corner of 1st & 2nd street. Each obsever will see that person in slightly a diferant way as 'Time' is seen in a differant way by observers. At point a, b, & c there is a dot, & the next instant the dot is somewhere else it is motion/'Time' because the dot isn't where it was before. If it moves back it is still motion & continuing onward.

  • @NEMOPMORPHY
    @NEMOPMORPHY 2 місяці тому

    I’m here because of the Illuminatus Trilogy by Robert Shea and Robert Anton Wilson

  • @TearyEyesAnderson
    @TearyEyesAnderson 13 років тому

    @feliztex I think it's been reported that even astronauts in orbit and satellites show 'Time' keepers slow down, and when they come back to Earth they do pick up speed again, but just to the amount that they slow down, so they and their clocks are still behind when they get back to Earth. As if there is something slowing down the atoms while going fast, and like Absolute Zero, move less and less when they go in a straight line and 'Time' slows. I give my theory of 'Time' above.

  • @deathing
    @deathing 13 років тому

    @NKblade On the contrary, 0,0,0 being everywhere is only true if space is infinite.
    The conservation of momentum means that the universe's center of gravity has never shifted, that is where all matter and space emerged from, making the center of the universe and the 0,0,0 point

  • @Moonsabie
    @Moonsabie 13 років тому

    i was reading Kant in a sunny room today and i was observing the shadow cast from the mound of one page to the face of the another i Noticed when the page is flat the shadow does not move but as i bend the page the shadow starts to move Much faster in fact then the hand that bends it inward .. then for the first time age (27) it Occurred to me anything that Moves has a curve !Our universe is made up of Curves! everything.

  • @Quazi-moto
    @Quazi-moto 12 років тому

    I SO dig this guy =-D

  • @Tiggermk4
    @Tiggermk4 11 років тому

    Uh...if all motion is relative, then is saying that someone is moving at x% of the speed of light not a nonsensical statement , except in relation to another observer ? That being the case, does that not mean time itself (as well as motion) requires an observer to make sense? P.s. Love the series

  • @aqwertgbvcxz
    @aqwertgbvcxz 12 років тому

    There is a difference between relative time and absolute time. Relative time is space dependent. Absolute time is not space dependent.

  • @Hellacool66
    @Hellacool66 13 років тому

    @Liusila that is soooooooooo crazy!!!!!!!!

  • @xFlared
    @xFlared 12 років тому

    imagine how slow the time would be if you were in the part of space where all the material is millions of light years away. :O

  • @deaddirt3214
    @deaddirt3214 2 місяці тому

    Time is relative to the observer

  • @3fast5you
    @3fast5you 12 років тому +1

    Wow, mincfuck!
    My mind is all blown, this is amazing.

  • @SeladorCellardoor
    @SeladorCellardoor 11 років тому

    Yes, but the phrase 'temporal becoming' implies a meta-time.

  • @shrinik1969
    @shrinik1969 14 років тому +2

    Cool ... where is zero of time axis? Big bang? The marking of past, present and future has to identify the reference point. According to who? There is no answer to the question "what is the time in the universe now". And the point of "now" is itself has to be with respect an observer. Where do you put (0,0,0) of space 3d?

  • @youcrackers2
    @youcrackers2 12 років тому

    lmao at the ending

  • @Hellacool66
    @Hellacool66 13 років тому

    could i get younger by going around the world twice as fast as the world... ? obviously not running..

  • @Liusila
    @Liusila 13 років тому

    @Hellacool66 no but you could age much slower
    *mind explioooosiooons*

  • @Sineburst
    @Sineburst 11 років тому

    the block universe... Neincreft