Gay Means Mentally Ill? | LGBTQ+ Psychiatrist Analyzes Homophobia & The Qatar World Cup

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 129

  • @villainoir
    @villainoir 2 роки тому +61

    I have no respect for someone who doesn't respect my existence

    • @dibsdibs3495
      @dibsdibs3495 2 роки тому +2

      Not homophobic but know people with the more conservative perspective and they respect and acknowledge your existence, they just disagree with your actions. At least the Jewish and Christian ones I’ve spoken to.

    • @icomefromoogaboogaland
      @icomefromoogaboogaland 2 роки тому +3

      No one cares, in a healthy society you shall either re evaluate your choices or fear for your life

    • @CrazyKevin22
      @CrazyKevin22 Рік тому

      @@icomefromoogaboogaland but it’s not a choice so that’s straight up BS

    • @icomefromoogaboogaland
      @icomefromoogaboogaland Рік тому

      @@CrazyKevin22 you always have the choice to not act upon them, similar to pedophiles

    • @Diogo85
      @Diogo85 Рік тому +12

      @@icomefromoogaboogaland Sexuality isn't a choice.

  • @Firegen1
    @Firegen1 2 роки тому +32

    Thank you for hitting this Dr Carthy. The FA's human rights record leaves a lot to be desired but the bravery of players who have come out during and after their careers. The comments already arriving are deeply worrying so if nothing else, I want to offer a positive comment to say thank you for your work online and out.

    • @elijahmalachi45-6dieker8
      @elijahmalachi45-6dieker8 2 роки тому

      Matthew 19:12 says God prefers the same sex relationships. Eunuchs that are born that way are transgender. Eunuchs made that way by others were abused. Those that choose to live like Eunuchs for the sake of the Kingdom of heaven are bisexual people that she's partners of the same sex but opposite in regards to gender.
      I am Elijah a Malachi 4 5-6 so any discrepancies in the Bible are decided by me. Male or female is determined by gender located in the brain. I am the 4Runner to the return of Jesus.

    • @Phatnaru0002
      @Phatnaru0002 9 місяців тому

      Well, a mental illness is considered something that debilitating and/or inhibiting to daily lifestyle and instincts of survival, correct?
      Well, being gay is sexual fixation which impairs a person's ability reproduce, a vital function and instinct for survival, and of one finding balance with their masculinity/femininity through a partner of the opposite sex.
      I don't really see how you can label something socially unacceptable, like incestuous relations, or age gaps, or interspecies, as a mental illness, but not homosexuality. Seems like it's all based on what you can get away with arguing for socially and what you can't.

  • @maggiepie8810
    @maggiepie8810 2 роки тому +11

    FIFA are unfortunately always terrible when it comes to human rights.

    • @imranhasan4109
      @imranhasan4109 Рік тому +2

      Football is a game. It has nothing to do with anal sex.

    • @thespclflash456
      @thespclflash456 Рік тому +3

      @@imranhasan4109 You're right, football has nothing to do with sex. So all heterosexual players should avoid showing any sort of intimacy with their partners, such as kissing or holding hands.

  • @TheRealityfades
    @TheRealityfades 2 роки тому +3

    The dsm here in the US used to have homosexuality listed in it.
    Homosexuality was classified as a mental disorder in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) beginning with the first edition, published in 1952 by the American Psychiatric Association (APA). This classification was challenged by gay rights activists in the years following the 1969 Stonewall riots, and in December 1973, the APA board of trustees voted to declassify homosexuality as a mental disorder. In 1974, the DSM was updated and homosexuality was replaced with a new diagnostic code for individuals distressed by their homosexuality. Distress over one's sexual orientation remained in the manual, under different names, until the DSM-5 in 2013.
    And even though there has been progress, people are still hateful and horrible. Like, I don’t care what anyone identifies as, as long as they are happy.

  • @erinrenman1479
    @erinrenman1479 2 роки тому +32

    I don't understand how it's possible to be this ignorant in the 21st century, religion or no. Plenty of religious people, including Muslims, are not like this, so it's not as if there is a 1:1 correlation between religiosity and homophobia/transphobia. And there are plenty of secular people who are just as bigoted as some religious people.
    Hate and ignorance are a choice, and they are not a choice that needs to be respected.

    • @chevalierdenoir754
      @chevalierdenoir754 Рік тому +2

      because you live in a liberal society but that's not the world

    • @erinrenman1479
      @erinrenman1479 Рік тому

      @@chevalierdenoir754 No, I live in a fact-based society. Everyone lives in a fact-based reality, and there is no valid reason to ignore facts in favour of belief, whether that's religious or political.

    • @chevalierdenoir754
      @chevalierdenoir754 Рік тому +2

      @@erinrenman1479 NOPE not everyone, unfortunately, lives in a fact-based reality, that is rather idealistic of you. For a lot of people religion is all the logic they need.

    • @erinrenman1479
      @erinrenman1479 Рік тому +1

      @@chevalierdenoir754 There are plenty of progressive religious people too, of all faiths, so religion isn't even an excuse to ignore truth

    • @xdtijnntssyu3314
      @xdtijnntssyu3314 Рік тому +1

      All Muslims are like that actually

  • @Charlottec968
    @Charlottec968 2 роки тому +5

    proud of the lionesses that have spoken out about this, Beth Mead was the first I saw but others have as well

  • @aaronkneile
    @aaronkneile 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you for posting this!

  • @powerviolentnightmare5026
    @powerviolentnightmare5026 2 роки тому +20

    What is this world cup everyone is talking about? There is no world cup this year. There is one next year in Australia.

    • @elijahmalachi45-6dieker8
      @elijahmalachi45-6dieker8 2 роки тому

      Matthew 19:12 Eunuchs that are born that way are transgender. Eunuchs made that way by others were abused. Those that choose to live like Eunuchs for the sake of the Kingdom of heaven are bisexual people that cheat partners of the same sex but opposite in regards to gender.
      Male or female is determined by gender located in the brain. Anybody saying anything different is now blacked out from the holy Spirit and part of the Great Tribulation that started September 1st. You'll mental tournament will get worse and worse until you either repent and accept truth or wait too late and die. Of course asking questions is okay but I am Elijah of Malachi 4:5-6 so any discrepancies in the Bible are decided by me.

    • @Charlottec968
      @Charlottec968 2 роки тому +2

      apparently they're letting men play football now, shocking I know!!

    • @elijahmalachi45-6dieker8
      @elijahmalachi45-6dieker8 2 роки тому

      @@Charlottec968 Matthew 19:12 says God prefers same-sex relationships. Matthew 19:12 Eunuchs that are born that way are transgender. Eunuchs made that way by others were abused. Those that choose to live like Eunuchs for the sake of the Kingdom of heaven or bisexual people that choose partners of the same sex but opposite in gender.
      I am Elijah of Malachi 45-6 so any discrepancies in the Bible are decided by me. Male or female is determined by gender located in the brain and anybody saying any different is now part of the Great Tribulation that started September 1st until they either repent or way too late and die with the wicked. I am the forerunner to the return of Jesus.

  • @matesafranka6110
    @matesafranka6110 2 роки тому +4

    I don't have any problem with football fans as long as they keep it behind closed doors.

  • @sandraisyearning
    @sandraisyearning 2 роки тому +8

    Fun fact: Anton Hysén is a gay footballer who came out when he was still active. He later went on the swedish version of Strictly and won and became a household name in Sweden. I know he and his family had a reality show, but I didn’t really watch more than 5 minutes here and there.
    (And thanks for reminding me to get to reading my brother’s uni paper he wrote on the LGBTQ+ people in football)

  • @tecallaghan
    @tecallaghan 2 роки тому +2

    The club that I support, FC Sankt Pauli (based in Hamburg, Germany) are well known for their fan culture of anti-discrimination and fighting for equal rights for the LGBTQIA+ community. In fact, our club co-captain Jackson Irvine is also the captain of Australia (who are playing in the tournament) and head of Australia's Players Union. He has recently penned an article for FIFA's players union FIFPRO calling out for LGBTQIA+ equality and has spoken before about using the international platform that they have to highlight these injustices where possible. We don't have anyone currently at the club who are publicly out and I 1000% agree with your point, but I just want people to know that there are some clubs and people out there who are challenging for our rights wherever they can 🤎🤍🤎🤍🤎🤍

  • @kimsteinke713
    @kimsteinke713 2 роки тому +2

    Thank you for doing this I just found your web video I'll subscribe Thank you it's so needed I'm 61 Grandma gay grandma I've been working in different areas but thank you so much. 🙏😇

  • @MastigosAtLarge
    @MastigosAtLarge 2 роки тому +7

    I love every single one of your videos. You bring amazing insight to every topic you cover. With the holidays here, would you consider reacting the The West Wing's episode "Noel"? The context is that Josh, who is the Deputy Chief of Staff, was shot during an assassination attempt on the president, and is basically forced into therapy by the Chief of Staff Leo McGarry. The therapist (in my mind, as someone who's been in therapy for fifteen years) is extremely aggressive in pushing Josh to confront his trauma both from the shooting and from earlier in his life, and is basically played as this Sherlock Holmes figure who solves the "mystery" of the trauma going back to Josh being a child. Since it's an older episode of TV, I haven't been able to find anyone reacting to it, and I really think it would be valuable.

  • @michaelstotzer4912
    @michaelstotzer4912 2 роки тому +11

    There was also Germany's Thomas Hitzlsperger who came out after his professional career.

  • @HeliosPlayGames
    @HeliosPlayGames 2 роки тому +2

    Could you do a video about new Philosophytube video concerning British Healthcare System problem?

    • @seamstressdragon8707
      @seamstressdragon8707 2 роки тому +1

      That was an excellent video and so heartbreaking for Abigail and the trans community.

  • @youleeahnah
    @youleeahnah 2 роки тому +26

    This is just sad. Such limiting beliefs.. i hope one day those countries make progress out of that sad, dark place they are in right now. People are people and there's no way but to equality and acceptance. ❤

    • @bloomy27
      @bloomy27 2 роки тому

      Their own people will have to hate for freedom from religion like Iran or else it won’t ever happen

    • @icomefromoogaboogaland
      @icomefromoogaboogaland 2 роки тому

      It's a healthy society, when homosexuals fear for life

    • @22.muhammadakbarputraardan47
      @22.muhammadakbarputraardan47 2 роки тому +2

      I'm proud to be muslim

    • @imranhasan4109
      @imranhasan4109 Рік тому

      Fu*k yourself rather than becoming homosexual.

    • @Diogo85
      @Diogo85 Рік тому +3

      @@icomefromoogaboogaland Homosexuality is unhealthy? Bruh!

  • @petergivenbless900
    @petergivenbless900 2 роки тому +4

    I am reminded of two very different responses to South African Apartheid in the '80s; the Springbok rugby tour of New Zealand in 1981 (when I was a 12 year old living in Hamilton, where one of the matches was disrupted by protests), and Paul Simon's enormously popular album 'Graceland', a few years later, which defied many of the self-imposed cultural bans, to bring black South African music to a wider audience. After his release, Nelson Mandela spoke of the encouragement that the Springbok protests brought him and his supporters at the time because of the attention it drew in rugby mad South Africa, but I am skeptical about what can really be achieved by protest and disruption alone; I think that it needs to be combined with the softer, less confrontational, approach of "familiarisation" that positive exposure can foster. One of the most effective tools for helping those with debilitating phobias is exposure therapy which balances confronting to source of fear with the reassurance of safety and gradual familiarisation; why should homophobia be any different?

    • @caitie226
      @caitie226 2 роки тому +1

      It's never one way with a problem so complicated and entrenched.

  • @TheMissXT
    @TheMissXT 2 роки тому +2

    There is a german sportsreporter on Sky who came out now on live tv!

  • @6Fiona6_P_6
    @6Fiona6_P_6 2 роки тому +3

    OMG. Then by krafft-ebing’s standards that makes me Pathological. Because I’ve never wanted to have children. I’ll be 59 on Monday the 14th November. And I’ve never regretted my choice to not have kids. I don’t hate or dislike children. I just didn’t want children……. ⚛️☮️🌏

  • @cooperbaird1192
    @cooperbaird1192 2 роки тому +2

    I have worked with a lot of Somalian Muslims in the oilfield. They truly love our country. Wholeheartedly the love this place. I asked them why the US is demonized in so many Muslim circles. He told me that the majority of Muslim hatred towards America is due to drone strikes, so it’s very localized. However the only thing they found shocking and (I’m sorry) weird* is “all the gay people”

  • @nizarmohaisin
    @nizarmohaisin 11 місяців тому

    Correct 💯
    Respect Qatar

  • @owenfitzgerald5928
    @owenfitzgerald5928 2 роки тому +1

    Jake Daniels is an English league footballer out as gay not in the prem but still good to see

  • @qienna6677
    @qienna6677 2 роки тому

    China Uncensored discussed how sporting events such as the World Cup and the Olympics continue to be controversial on these matters because it's the authoritarian regimes who can afford to take the financial loss of hosting such a big event, whereas countries with a better human rights track record have to justify it to the taxpayers (such events almost never make a profit in the long term).

  • @mixedupmenopausaladhd3999
    @mixedupmenopausaladhd3999 2 роки тому

    Please do respect my gingham tablecloth.

  • @Wally-pu2hh
    @Wally-pu2hh Рік тому

    There's some damage in other places too 😂

  • @eliah8098
    @eliah8098 2 роки тому

    Love the choice of drag race still for this!

  • @WolvenDogma
    @WolvenDogma 2 роки тому

    Much love from Pennsylvania

  • @nicholasdean3467
    @nicholasdean3467 2 роки тому

    I never got religious people. They worship a religion that focused on Roman aggression against Christianity. Even though historically, Romans and Christians lived largely peacefully together. The same can not be said about the religions formed around early Christianity.

    • @chevalierdenoir754
      @chevalierdenoir754 Рік тому

      stop picking on Christianity i know it's easy for you because Christians don't fight back but this is a Muslim country. If you do your research you will find out that Christian nations or countries with Christian majorities are the most tolerant toward LGBTQUIA ppl.

  • @binghamguevara6814
    @binghamguevara6814 2 роки тому +3

    6:56 Is he implying that homosexuality and LGBTQI sexual feelings were de-classified not because scientists declassified them as mental disorders, but because of Stonewall and lgbt people making a fuss, and visibility. 7:39. isn't that wrong?

    • @kimsteinke713
      @kimsteinke713 2 роки тому

      That is not so they declassified them in the '70s after realizing that the psychologist were brainwashed by propaganda. Pay attention Go read and then come back and school us later okay when you know what you're talking about.

    • @mixedupmenopausaladhd3999
      @mixedupmenopausaladhd3999 2 роки тому +4

      The DSM is literally just a construct that attempts to understand issues of great complexity almost entirely through a lens of a certain age and demographic group.

  • @chevalierdenoir754
    @chevalierdenoir754 Рік тому +1

    Being LGBT in places like Qatar, parts of Africa, and the Caribbean can be damaging to the mind. I actually sympathize with some of these countries who are homophobic because it's just too much for them to process they are just allowing women to drive. Asking them to accept LGBT is a HUGE leap. Also, look at the men they are very traditional Muslim society they won't change their views at the drop of a hat. I just wish they would treat migrant workers from India and Africa better.

    • @domiusdom7883
      @domiusdom7883 Рік тому

      AHAHAHAHAHA I don’t know if this is sarcasm or not, but shit it made me laugh 😂

  • @binghamguevara6814
    @binghamguevara6814 2 роки тому

    What do you think of Ancient Greece pedarasty, (man-boy love)? The Greek practiced this for 500 years.
    Were these men mentally ill, practicing an undiagnosed sexuality or sexually perverts?

  • @qienna6677
    @qienna6677 2 роки тому

    I'd love to see you react to Call the Midwife Season 4 Episode 3, if you haven't already.

  • @allyintheoven7713
    @allyintheoven7713 2 роки тому

    Please can you react to words on bathroom walls on netflix? It’s a film about schizophrenia and if he interested to see your take on it!!

  • @elijahmalachi45-6dieker8
    @elijahmalachi45-6dieker8 2 роки тому +1

    Anybody saying that same sex marriage is a sin when it is not is now blacked out from the holy Spirit and part of the Great Tribulation that started September 1st. Not only is same-sex marriage not a sin, but God prefers it! God prefers it so much that he says he prefers it for the sake of the Kingdom of heaven!
    Mathew 19:12 Eunuchs that are born that way are transgender. Eunuchs made that way by others were abused. Those that choose to live like Eunuchs for the sake of the Kingdom of heaven are bisexual people that choose partners of the same sex but opposite in regards to gender.
    Anybody teaching anything other than this is now blacked out from the holy Spirit and part of the Great Tribulation that starts September 1st. Your mental torment will get worse and worse until you either repent and accept truth or way too long and die.

  • @editor5879
    @editor5879 2 роки тому +2

    طريق سئ لتمضي حياتك عليه
    ستندم في النهاية
    وبخصوص ما تتحدث عنه الشذوذ الجنسي تم إزالته من الأمراض بسبب ضغط سياسي وأطباء كثيرين تحدثوا عن ذلك

    • @AChildressABright
      @AChildressABright 2 роки тому +1

      Translation from Arabic, so this one can‘t hide behind a foreign language:
      It‘s a bad way to live your life by, you will regret it in the end.
      In particular, you don‘t report regarding the homosexuals (literally: sexual deviants, common term in the Middle East) that their removal from (the list of) illnesses was due political pressure. A lot of doctors report this.

  • @aaachriamahoe9928
    @aaachriamahoe9928 2 роки тому +2

    It's not healthy thing

  • @houssamlabiod
    @houssamlabiod 2 роки тому +1

    One word : SUBJECTIVE

  • @moealn
    @moealn 2 роки тому +1

    Homosexuality is truly strange.

    • @user-sf5fk6ox4c
      @user-sf5fk6ox4c Рік тому +1

      @moealn Bexause male/female relations are so normal, right?! please....

  • @susannehuber3996
    @susannehuber3996 2 роки тому

    Or you just like people of the same sex…. Maybe it’s as simple as that. Nothing more and nothing less.

  • @vostok3ka
    @vostok3ka 2 роки тому +2

    Ain't gonna lie, as a person who's Arab, the amount of hate Qatar is getting is kind of hurtful to everybody I know and have spoken to in this region, because the Russians hosted last time, and they have done some really horrible things over the decade and didn't get as much hate. Same as the US who bid for next one has committed literal war crimes and done horrible things to Hispanics and also aren't getting flamed. It's just a little hypocritical from the media I think, idk

    • @Likeomgitznich
      @Likeomgitznich 2 роки тому +9

      But there’s a difference, the messed up stuff other countries did is “in the past” where as, this is an current and enforced piece of legislation.
      As for hurting Arab/Muslim peoples, I agree but if we are being honest, if it wasn’t this we’d just find something else to scream about. If we are talking about how it hurts economically, history really shows us that no matter what host nations promise they will do post event, it all just falls to shit.
      The world just freaking sucks ass.

    • @vostok3ka
      @vostok3ka 2 роки тому +1

      @@supaleetkillah man, calm down lmao, I live here, there are loads of gay people, I know some myself. I know how things are here and it is NOT what the media portrays. Safety is guaranteed, I personally have seen the things they have done to protect and keep people safe. I'm not whining, I'm stating facts bud, never said they were damaged. Good god lol

    • @vostok3ka
      @vostok3ka 2 роки тому

      @@supaleetkillah 😭

    • @lovemyself6441
      @lovemyself6441 Рік тому +1

      @@vostok3ka Are there gay people in Arab? Really? Isn’t it’s illegal and has death penalty.

  • @0deepak
    @0deepak 2 роки тому +5

    Guess which religion they’re from?

    • @notmyhairyarmpits
      @notmyhairyarmpits 2 роки тому

      I was from a Buddhist country where people caught in homosexual relationships will be sent to 10 years in prison. Christianity also demonizes same sex relationships by conflating it with pedophilia. The problem is not religion, it is homophobes. Please don't use people like this as an excuse to be Islamophobic

    • @carinarose8600
      @carinarose8600 2 роки тому +9

      Guess which religion most of their victims come from?
      Yes, the same religion.

    • @0deepak
      @0deepak 2 роки тому +3

      @@carinarose8600 They’re protesting against LGBT education in the USA and UK as well.

    • @0deepak
      @0deepak 2 роки тому

      @@carinarose8600 They protested in Michigan and Birmingham recently.

    • @MarcosLopez-ky5yg
      @MarcosLopez-ky5yg 2 роки тому

      The one that is based on pretending to know this they don't know

  • @shiroyasha4995
    @shiroyasha4995 Рік тому

    being homosexual is fine.. but forcing others to accept you is not. do whatever you want just dont bother others

    • @jijitters
      @jijitters Рік тому +9

      If you don't "accept" people being who they are, then you're a bad person. You're the problem here buddy, not the people asking you to leave them be.

    • @MM-pk3rl
      @MM-pk3rl Рік тому +1

      ​@@jijitters do you accept Hitler? I see

    • @thespclflash456
      @thespclflash456 Рік тому

      @@MM-pk3rl I don't think you can compare consenting adults being in a relationship with each other because they were born attracted to the same sex to the man who killed millions of innocent people.

    • @badge5575
      @badge5575 Рік тому +1

      @@jijitters so if you dont support a psychopath for committing crimes your a bad person because that who they are

    • @bigbrain3907
      @bigbrain3907 Рік тому +1

      ​@@MM-pk3rlYou're comparing someone who purged 6 million people for no reason other than "jews bad" to people who literally just wanna live without christians and muslims losing their shit

  • @Souu998
    @Souu998 2 роки тому +2

    Keep your pronouns to your own country.

  • @theredpriest
    @theredpriest 2 роки тому

    Doesn't mean you're necessarily "mentally ill" but it's not the standard. Man+woman. That's what you need to propagate the species. And a species'...ANY SPECIES... ONLY GOAL is to; grow, mate, multiply, and EVOLVE. You can't do that as LGBTQ. Even lgbtq could not exist without that standard. Man+woman. It's a very oxymoronic life-stance. So while a lgbtq might not be mentally ill, there IS some disconnect as to why they are. What is it? That we don't know yet. We only have theories.

    • @emesea.2181
      @emesea.2181 Рік тому

      Yes, it's not the standard, but there is nothing wrong with it either. Now you brought up animals, let's talk about how almost every animal do gay activities. So yes, we need a man and a woman to reproduce, but why does everything have to be around it? If everyone in this world was straight, we would overpopulate. We need gays to stop that.

    • @Diogo85
      @Diogo85 Рік тому +4

      Standard doesn't mean crap.

    • @theredpriest
      @theredpriest Рік тому

      @@Diogo85 Standard is exactly what it means. The "norm". And it obviously means something as you owe your existence to it. Unless you argue that your life is meaningless, to which I would say all further discussion is unnecessary then.

    • @thespclflash456
      @thespclflash456 Рік тому +3

      @@theredpriest Life is meaningless. There is no inherent "meaning" to life. You can take the reproductive stance, where all sex should lead to reproduction, but at that point you're essentially equating humans to their animalistic instincts. That doesn't work either, as primates are well known for same-sex relationships. You can either say that humans have evolved beyond our evolutionary purposes and have become unique, individualistic beings, each with their own desires and needs, or you can reduce us to that primal need for reproduction, in which case, by that logic, anyone with fertility issues has no value as a human. Humans make their own meaning. Everyone has their own unique one, but there is no all-encompassing meaning.

    • @maraque16
      @maraque16 Рік тому +2

      LOL LGBTQ+ people are perfectly capable of having kids and starting families. Many do, in fact.

  • @elijahmalachi45-6dieker8
    @elijahmalachi45-6dieker8 2 роки тому +1

    And who would trust a psychiatrist anyhow, all they want is your money.

  • @elisa7881
    @elisa7881 2 роки тому

    Blame FIFA not Qatar.