The Liberty Incident Revealed
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 вер 2024
- More than forty-five years after the deadly attack on the USS Liberty by Israel's Air Force and Navy in 1967, it is still a matter of controversy. The combined Israeli assault during the Six-Day War in June 1967 killed 24 Americans and wounded 171, while the Liberty was monitoring 12 miles offshore in international waters. Cutting through all of the conspiracy theories, Capt. A Jay Cristol, USN (Ret.) has spent a quarter-century researching what really happened that day. In his newest book, The Liberty Incident Revealed: The Definitive Account of the 1967 Israeli Attack on the U.S. Navy Spy Ship, he combines his painstaking analysis of the incident drawn from all of the sources, including tapes of intercepts recently released by the National Security Agency; formerly classified and open-source documents; and his interviews with all then-living individuals directly involved in the incident. Join Cristol as he explains why he contends that the documentary record is clear-the incident was a tragic case of mistaken identity. This event took place March 18, 2014.
He doesn't address Liberty signalmen who have testified the jamming of both naval communications frequencies AND the international distress frequencies.
Jamming communications equipment is an act of war. Jamming international distress frequencies is a war ctime.
"his interviews with all then-living individuals directly involved in the incident"
That is pure unadulterated bullshit.
Cristol interviewed few -- if any -- USS Liberty survivors. It would be a long row to hoe to argue the position that USS Liberty survivors should not be included in the list of "all then-living individuals directly involved".
His reason for not interviewing USS Liberty survivors? Because we are too close to the incident and that fact would color our testimony.
The logical question following that statement is why didn't that remove the Israeli participants from the list of individuals that should be interviewed? After all, they were as close to the incident as we were and they are the ones who are accused of committing War Crimes during their attack on the USS Liberty. Wouldn't those facts tend to color the testimony of the Israeli participants?
Apparently Cristol doesn't think so.
Perhaps he has the hidden agenda he accuses us of having.
Here's some info on "our" Mr. Jay Cristo which you'll find MOST interesting. www.ussliberty.org/whoiscristol.htm
Hasbara served by Cristol/Israel no longer has its effect in this time of peoples' greater access to information. Anyone that's heard the testimony of USS Liberty survivors and has read The Moorer Report knows the attack on Liberty is one of the worst crimes and longest-running cover-ups in history. Truth is on the side of the LVA and, one day, so too will be justice.
Strange how you've interviewed hundreds of Israelis, and plenty of US Officials not on the Liberty, but NOT everyone who was on the Liberty itself. Also the question re calling his book the Liberty Incident question is valid, and you did not answer this question. You seeming to say that both the US and Israel were both to blame is ridiculous. What were the US at fault for? Did they shoot and torpedo themselves?. You also seem to omit facts like they were in international waters, the lack of anyone firing on the ship really try to identify the ship themselves. Why cant you just be honest and admit the Israelis were at fault and should have admitted it straight away and helped the families and survivors etc.
Dean Rusk, U.S. Secretary of State at the time of the incident, wrote:
“I was never satisfied with the Israeli explanation. Their sustained attack to disable and sink Liberty precluded an assault by accident or some trigger-happy local commander. Through diplomatic channels we refused to accept their explanations. I didn't believe them then, and I don't believe them to this day. The attack was outrageous.”
But hey maybe we should believe this guy instead?
yeah he was nearby in a dingy
Except Dean Rusk was a lifelong ENEMY of Israel so not exactly an unbiased person.
Trust him he was there on the Israeli side, rubbing his hands together, knowing he can sell a book one day.
Very well said! Truer words couldn’t be spoken clearer.
Phillip Nelsons' book REMEMBER THE LIBERTY. He goes into great detail. He interviewed former crew men. He proves the idea was LBJ's. Mosha Dian was the push behind the attack.
Maybe you should have asked the crew. They believed what was happening to them. So did the Captain.
Captain McGonagle was a real gentleman. He and his entire crew deserved much better than this.
The Egyptian flag is half black. It cannot be confused for an American flag. Using the stripes/visual acuity formula is a red herring.
Their ships were Black and Gray, not Gray and White like ours.
@@Sovereign_Citizen_LEO That pretty much says it all. Good point!
No, Egypt flag is 1/3 black, and you cannot notice it from far away.
No, there is no such rule for ship coloration.
Example of a sunk gray Egyptian ship:
static.timesofisrael.com/www/uploads/2019/11/000_1M38B3-640x400.jpg
It's not a incident it's a attack. And this guy calling the survivors conspiracy theorists?
Exactly... so shameful and evil.
This Judge never indicated that he spoke to one surviving crew member. That says it all. He is no Columbo
Why was the Liberty Incident kept out of the news? Why were those involved told not to say anything or be penalized?
They overheard through radio communications Israelis killing large amounts of Palestinians.
exactly.....he keeps using the word "conspiracy" as though threatening every survivor with prison or worse is not a conspiracy itself, a cover up IS a conspiracy. This guy sucks
Because LBJ told the Navy to cover it up so we could keep Israel as an ally.
Because Israel runs USA media (ask Nixon), Israel has a 4000+ lobby in Washington pressuring & threatening all politicians, everyone bends to them. ADL , who are paid along with Israel itself by USA taxpayers $$BILLIONS
@@harvey1954 keep Israel as an ally???
You think our motivation in covering up an attack by Israel is so we could keep Israel as an ally?
That makes sense to you?
Israeli's have a US in their pocket who doesn't know that...more and more i watch this video more and more i get upset...
Apparently a LOT of people still don't realize it, sadly.
US is israel..
The tapes prove Israel knew it an Amercian ship
Yes, almost an hour after the attack.
And at the beginning of the tapes they call it "unidentified ship" and "Egyptian cargo ship"
@@abebabe3069 Well, you'd hardly expect them to say it is a US vessel, otherwise it could not appear to be a "mistake". (Too bad the huge US flag was flying in the breeze as stated by a crew member. Seems they "missed" that.)
@@pkgum6910
But why do it in the first place?
@@pkgum6910 Once you see the Author's bias it explains a lot, these were left out intentionally
www.ussliberty.org/whoiscristol.htm Quote from him about his motivations He says ''virulently anti-Semitic organizations'' like the Liberty Lobby continue to ''fan the fires'' about the Liberty to smear Israel"
@@pd4954 ok well that's Israel's answer to everything is to play the victim. Anytime they do something messed up and get caught they deflect and say all the criticism is because of anti semitism.
so all the surviving crew members are lying ? were you on board ? you sir are a liar!
Should be called "The Liberty ATTACKED, Whitewashed." There, I fixed it.
Lol!
1) A mistake?Israel is on record identifying the Liberty during a recognizance in the morning, and prior to the commencing the attack.
2)There are several points which can made to argue the US Israeli relationship is not mutually beneficial to the US. For one, obviously, Israel has no oil, unlike it’s Arab neighbors and drives up the cost. And of course the Palestinians. I could go on and on. The Liberty attack is important because it shows how little Israel cares.
3.The US didn’t want Israel to go to war at that time.
4. The initial Navy investigation was a joke. They didn’t interview anyone other than the Captain who went along. They threatened the service men to not even tell their families.
They are God's Chosen (sounds like the Master Race) so everybody else is second best.
How does America's relationship with Israel benefit the United States? There is no strategic value in Israel for the United States. If anything, the United States has more to value with a relationship with Saudi Arabia because of oil or Egypt because of the Suez Crisis.
You're evaluating the relationship in the light of contemporary times. You need to turn the clock back 50 years. At that time, the most important (in terms of strategic oil resources) region in the world (to an industrialized economy such as the United States) was on the verge of falling into the Soviet orbit. Syria, Jordan, Egypt and I believe Libya (possibly Iraq as well, but don't quite me on that) were all very heavily influenced (and militarily equipped) by the Soviet Union. Turkey was walking a delicate balancing act between the two super powers and didn't want to get caught straddling the high-wire. Saudi Arabia was closely aligned with the US, but had to be careful not to be seen too pro-US. By virtue of the process of elimination, there was really only one country in the eastern part of the Mediterranean that we could consider suitable as an ally, and that was Israel. The really ironic thing is that Israel was pretty close to a communist state, given the kibbutz and collectivist living, but the State Department and the media were careful to downplay that inconvenient embarrassment. Anyway, 50 years later, now that we are on the verge of breaking our dependency on foreign fuel, that strategic alliance between Israel and the US isn't quite as imperative as it once was; in another ten years, it might not even exist at all.
CaesarInVa All those are important facts. However the most important but least mentioned fact is that the Judao/Christian community believes the rebirth of Israel after WWII is prophetic. Israel continues to be our only democratic friend in the Middle East.
ua-cam.com/video/PxpGkD9AMeA/v-deo.html
$$$$$$$$$$$$
Israel has a MASSIVE US lobby.
The most obvious question to me, why was the Liberty assumed to be a Arab ship? It didn’t have Arab markings on the hull or anywhere else, that I’ve heard. A Arab Ship would have Arab numerals for Identity on both sides.
Lies.
Hahaha
Easy to notice you are no sailor, nor have any knowledge of the Arab world.
Arab ships don`t have "Arab markings", nor they can be visible from so far away by the planes
@@abebabe3069 Easy to notice your own bias with all your comments. Testimony from an actual sailor that was there, not this "researcher" with an agenda, much like yourself. They machine gunned the life rafts from the torpedo boats, they shot up a huge American flag on one of many strafing runs. Here is a quote of your compatriots agenda "He says ''virulently anti-Semitic organizations'' like the Liberty Lobby continue to ''fan the fires'' about the Liberty to smear Israel" Facts about the author www.ussliberty.org/whoiscristol.htm
@@pd4954
There is no evidence for a huge US flag in any image nor video
@@abebabe3069 There is testimony from sailor that were on the ship, if you care to look. Your propagandizing author has left so many things out, he is glaring in his bias and he even admitted to such. Much like you he isn't interested in the truth
The radios were jammed.
When conspiracy becomes cover-up.
In case you all didnt get it, this Jay Cristol, is a lying FRAUD, that should be rotting in THE PRISON.
Shameless presentation. Traider 1st class
Traitor is spelled the way I did.
[Hand wringing intensifies]
John Haddon also collected plant samples around Israel’s Dimona complex that confirmed the Israeli’s had stolen enriched uranium from the NUMEC plant in Apollo, Pennsylvania. This uranium was likely fabricated into nuclear weapons before the 1967 war. Israel had planned to use nuclear weapons as a doomsday device in the Sinai if the war went bad and the Egyptians were about to invade Israel. I think the Israelis feared the Liberty might have intercepted communications regarding the disposition of these weapons.
ua-cam.com/video/tx72tAWVcoM/v-deo.html
The government that couldn't figure out Nine Eleven, now wants your health........
.
...
Just look at his nose.... It will instantly tell you that he is biased
Absolute rubbish ! This is history being rewritten.
and very *badly,* at that..the 'colonel' [he doesn't deserve that title, imho] is a liar, spewing only hateful nonsense..it's quite evil of him, actually.👎🙅🏾♀️
btw, are *any* of the docos on this channel legitimate?? have never been to it before, knew nothing about it even existing.
included a link to a doco, if you haven't already seen it..in my OP. currently posted above, in the main thread [who knows where it might wind up, though..maybe in their virtual 'circular file']..because i'm very unhappy about the video above that they uploaded..really, it's a sickening treatise on the topic of what happened to the *USS* Liberty and all those souls on board her.
anyway, take care [esp., re: the current pandemic and simultaneous global economic meltdown we seem to be living through..i'm waiting...and waiting..to wake up from the terrible dream of it. 😐]..what a crazy, *crazy* world we might have made for ourselves.☯💫☮🙋🏾♀️
There are enough eye-witness accounts that contradict this video.
@@747fa You should post this as a separate comment. Great to see!
Eye witness from where?
Link?
@@abebabe3069 EVERY link I've attached to you is different--so MAN UP and be more objective rather than another Zionist shill that makes the rest of us Jews look bad!
ua-cam.com/video/t0deT7s43vY/v-deo.html
@@U2Brrr
Ok, Israel paid the families.
Where is the proof the attack was deliberate?
@@abebabe3069
UA-cam is your friend. Seek and ye shall find.
What about the audio recording hours and hours before identifying the ship as American???
A. Jay Cristol is Jewish. He has allegiance to Israel, not the USA. His opinions and "expertise" are therefore irrelevant.
Anyone claiming that the attack on the Liberty was an accident is either a liar or a fool.
Well shit why did one jet refuse to shoot and the piolet was sent to prison. they knew sense 6:15 that morning!
Interview me, I could give you more facts then this guy.
Paltry amount for a 13-year court battle!
Dual allegiance Government propaganda.
It was not a mistake.Israek knew wtf they was doing/Knock it off.SMDH
Unmarked fighter planes / That is so against the Geneva convention
Who said the planes were unmarked?
Which clause i
@@abebabe3069 the Captain
@@mastergavinzimnik9082
Captain of what?
How could he see that?
@@abebabe3069 "Who said the planes were unmarked" the sailors that were on the ship said that,, there is videos of their testimony but big surprise it was left out by this biased propaganda. Real facts of the author here www.ussliberty.org/whoiscristol.htm
Quote from the author "He says ''virulently anti-Semitic organizations'' like the Liberty Lobby continue to ''fan the fires'' about the Liberty to smear Israel" now you know why important parts are conveniently omitted.
@@pd4954
Only some sailors said that. Sailors are deeply traumatized by the death of their comrades, and affected by their beliefs.
Even a large flag is very hard to see from a moving plane, miles away
Hasbara
So a contributing factor to the Liberty's getting the crap shot out of her is that either she missed or someone mis-transmitted (or a combination of both) FIVE messages telling her to stay well out of the combat area? I don't know about anyone else, but as for myself, the thought that our communications were so f'd up that ships could be sailing around missing numerous messages (including nuclear submarines and other first-line, nuclear deterrent forces that could have been missing launch orders and other important signals) is much more disconcerting than the thought that LBJ or the Israelis (or both) were up to some sinister machinations. If this guy is right, its only by virtue of divine providence that either side of the Cold War didn't nuke the world back to the Paleolithic Era.
CaesarinVa. Suzanne is probably right. Some disturbing information regarding Mr. Jay Cristo. www.ussliberty.org/whoiscristol.htm
@Suzanne I have a feeling that he was subsidized by Israel reps in Miami to write this piece of trash propaganda.
His nose doesn’t seem to point towards the truth unfortunately… 💫
Several investigations conducted into the incident by the U.S. Navy, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the CIA, the U.S. House and Senate, the NSA, and the Israeli government. All investigations into the matter similarly blamed lack of communications and found no reason for anyone involved to face criminal charges.
American inquiries, memoranda, records of testimony, and various reports involving or mentioning the Liberty attack include, but are not limited to, the following:
U.S. Naval Court of Inquiry of June 1967
Joint Chief of Staff's Report of June 1967.
CIA Intelligence Memorandums of June 1967
Clark Clifford Report of July 1967
Senate Foreign Relations Committee Testimony during hearings of the 1967 Foreign Aid Authorization bill, July 1967
House Armed Services Committee Investigation of 1971
The NSA History Report of 1981
The U.S. Naval Court of Inquiry record contains testimony by Liberty crew members, exhibits of attack damage photographs, and various reports. The court concluded that the testimony record revealed "a shallow investigation, plagued by myriad disagreements between the captain and his crew". According to the Navy Court of Inquiry's record of proceedings, four days were spent hearing testimony: two days for fourteen survivors of the attack and several U.S. Navy expert witnesses, and two partial days for two expert U.S. Navy witnesses.
@Suzanne AGREE!
As if any of that information is trustworthy. How many politicians are bought by foreign interests?
They where doing shit they didn't want us to see or here and it wasn't hard to confuse the commanders giving in the orders
A crappy attempt to whitewash
Present some evidence to back your claim.
I don't like how they frame it as a 'Spy' ship... As if just listening was doing something wrong....
read BLOOD IN THE WATER BY JOAN MELLEN
Anyone can write anything, what evidence does he present?
@@abebabe3069 read it......
@@ROYKENDALL
What EVIDENCE is there?
Why should I read a book which doesn`t present any sincere evidence?
Truth about the author of this propaganda www.ussliberty.org/whoiscristol.htm
@@abebabe3069 why instantly believe that it doesn't have evidence? Why be so low IQ and so lazy to not search for truth? Are you a Jews can do no wrong simp? You are obviously interested in the subject if you are here, why be so lazy? Always always spend equal time researching both sides of a story or you do yourself and everyone you open your mouth to a great disservice.
"Clearly a case of mistaken identity." Total crap.
This is all BS don't believe a word
So our closest friend attacked us?
Our greatest enemy. Their motto is "war by deception"
Doesn’t look like they’re your closest friends… 😕
Liar, Lair, pants on fire.
I stopped watching when said "...England.. " went to war.
Traitors
You can tell how these comments are not genuine and mostly bots
I don’t believe one word you have said, another, investigation by someone neutral.
55:32 Freudian slip maybe....
You weren’t there shill.
So the naziisrsel pilot shot with eyes closed? Or he doesnt care eventhough he see an American flag on that ship
36:05 translation of them are the key
attack you mean
A judge? You sure??? C'mon. ..... for real?
10 million truck drivers are needed in les united states right now
AIPAC dollars 🤑
We would do the same if somebody is in our back yard. Not Russia or China, we are not that stupid.
Taylor Angela Jones Lisa Rodriguez Laura
The US ordered it.
Misinformation laughs at truth, unfortunately.
We love Israel. We want the best for the Jewish state of Israel, now established in the land of Israel, the land that once held all 12 tribes of Israel.
Evangelical Christians are lovers and supporters of the Jewish people of Israel, - and also the Arabs and Palestinians. We love and support the people on both sides, but not necessarily their political rulers or their secret service activities. Nor do we hold them up to be pillars of virtue and to be supported in everything they do.
And why? Because the Judeo-Christian people, (who we are supposed to despise BTW), are the people of JACOB. Yes, the Jewish House of Israel, and the European non-Jewish House of Israel are both the people of the 12 tribes of that tricky shyster Jacob.
Jacob is not perfect. He is still wrestling with the Angel of God. His people, and those from every nation, grafted in or adopted in to All Israel as a Congregation-Commonwealth, are a spiritual house. They are a swelling company of redeemed people from both houses of Israel, and beyond, all of them on a journey to the Holy City. We are a global company of people on a pilgrimage to becoming Israel, “prince and contender with God.” This is the deep spring story of holy history as it unfolds on this planet.
So are there bad apples in the barrels of both houses of Israel? And do they occasionally do naughty things like the assassinations started by Mrs. Golda Meier? Do they plan and commit unlawful nefarious deeds, and then use their mainstream media and their technocrats to tell lies and censor the truth about what really went on?
We could count of a dozen instances right off the bat. There was the attack on the USS Liberty during the IsraeliArab war in 1967. Here is the story on that.
ua-cam.com/video/vyiP1tUOxig/v-deo.html
When all these strange events are researched a pattern of lies and deception emerges. We see shenanigans perpetrated in both the Western superpowers and in the present state of Israel. As we saw in the attack on the USS Liberty, the two often work together in collusion to achieve their respective objectives.
Do the means justify the ends? Well, the fourth vow Jesuits think so. And the bad apples in our respective governments seem to think so as well.
So how can we move forward in our present nation-states without war and discord if we are found to be in a godless Mafiosi style state of corruption? How can we continue to remain under the blessings of the God of Israel, (who loves us dearly), if He becomes Someone we do not want to get too close to?
So we continue to pray.
We pray for the Peace of Jerusalem.
And we pray that Jesus Christ, the Prince of Peace, the Savior and coming Deliverer of Israel, will be invited into human hearts everywhere.
Will good overcome evil at the end of the saga? Well, as we survey the ongoing story from Genesis to Revelation the answer is quite clear. And it is “Yes!”
See
ua-cam.com/video/0hk0L3dx9H8/v-deo.html
palestine stays winning
as if a book of myths and a religon that is corrupt prove anything at all.
Squelch this yoo toob.