Agreed, the transitions from the first part through the middle to the last part are very smooth. Most of the other short edits have a very abrupt transition cut in the middle. This edit is even a bit better than the official shortened version from the 'Echoes Best of PF' album (that one cuts off the guitar solo!) and yet this is still 2 minutes shorter than that one. Anyway, love this edit, you don't feel like you are missing anything (except maybe 6-8 minutes of utter nonsense).
@@dam1106 hey thanks haha I know this is a 4 year old comment but I made this channel and edit when I was 14, glad to see people are enjoying it still. I get notifs for it on my Gmail lol. Have a good one!
i literally had a connection with time and universe while listening to this song high. The piano intro is like the time talking to you… the music is like time talking to you.
Pink Floyd really could have done with trimming the song down like this. I've nothing against long songs, but Echoes in particular comes out feeling bloated. Thanks for fixing that up!
As much as I love Pink Floyd, I wasn't a fan of the 5 or so minutes of creepy ambiance complimented by guitars screaming in agony. It's not like they're annoying to listen to, it's just that the lack of actual music for that length of time makes it boring to listen to after the 1st time. I'm sure there's some meaning I'm unaware of, so I don't think it should be excluded, just shortened and blended into the following build up, to save time.
There's a great video from a channel named Polyphonic that explains Echoes perfectly, it's called "pink floyd's first masterpiece", it made me appreciate every second of the song
I think if a non pink floyd fan were to see a 14 minute long song along with “shortened version” they’d lose it
You know it’s PF when the shortened version is 14 minutes long.
The BEST short version so far...
Agreed, the transitions from the first part through the middle to the last part are very smooth. Most of the other short edits have a very abrupt transition cut in the middle. This edit is even a bit better than the official shortened version from the 'Echoes Best of PF' album (that one cuts off the guitar solo!) and yet this is still 2 minutes shorter than that one. Anyway, love this edit, you don't feel like you are missing anything (except maybe 6-8 minutes of utter nonsense).
sometimes the nonsense is nice, but most of the time you listen for everything but that
@@dam1106 ua-cam.com/video/p7dOOiTpaak/v-deo.html (7 Minute) My own version. I'm sure you like this more. More realistic and Remaster !
@@dam1106 hey thanks haha I know this is a 4 year old comment but I made this channel and edit when I was 14, glad to see people are enjoying it still. I get notifs for it on my Gmail lol. Have a good one!
Fun fact: If you start this version when the second verse ends in the original track, this will be finished before the third verse starts
4 minutes and like 59 seconds to 19 minutes and like 15 seconds. so like 13 minutes, I'm not sure about that.. But I could be mis-understanding
Thank you! I found the long ominous silence disturbing in the original, thank you for cutting it down.
There’s a big difference when you listen high and when you listen normal to this song
When you listen to it high it feels too short
i literally had a connection with time and universe while listening to this song high. The piano intro is like the time talking to you… the music is like time talking to you.
Pink Floyd really could have done with trimming the song down like this. I've nothing against long songs, but Echoes in particular comes out feeling bloated.
Thanks for fixing that up!
You are a moron?
As much as I love Pink Floyd, I wasn't a fan of the 5 or so minutes of creepy ambiance complimented by guitars screaming in agony. It's not like they're annoying to listen to, it's just that the lack of actual music for that length of time makes it boring to listen to after the 1st time. I'm sure there's some meaning I'm unaware of, so I don't think it should be excluded, just shortened and blended into the following build up, to save time.
There's a great video from a channel named Polyphonic that explains Echoes perfectly, it's called "pink floyd's first masterpiece", it made me appreciate every second of the song
I really wish Pink Floyd had edited the song this way! Good edit!
They did. Look up the echoes edit from echoes: the best of Pink Floyd.
Love the orignal, Love this too. Thank you for uploading for when you don't have the time to listen to the full 23 minutes :)
this is pure bliss, thank you to whoever made this
Damn even the shortened version is long
Very nice edit!
Psychedelic to the ears
Oooohh very well done ;D thank you for making the scary part short ;D
great job i love it
I agree
And I agree with you
And i agree with the guy agreeing with you
Three freeeeze
Found this via reddit. Nice. The whale songs are a tad annoying!
Photon7908 no
Same, but 5 years later, also it's not that annoying, just sometimes you don't want to hear a whale screaming in your ears along with phantom voices
🗣️🔈💕❣️💞❤️💖❤️🔥
rubbish! The important part of the original at 14:44 is missing.
???
@@SexyAlien2
ua-cam.com/video/Ygb-xprXVyM/v-deo.html
@@Starlight_Silver yes, that`s the right version. the important part is from 10.25 to 10.30 in this link