The Rubber Hand Illusion - Horizon: Is Seeing Believing? - BBC Two
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 лип 2024
- Subscribe and 🔔 to the BBC 👉 bit.ly/BBCUA-camSub
Watch the BBC first on iPlayer 👉 bbc.in/iPlayer-Home www.bbc.co.uk/horizon
Horizon explores the strange and wonderful world of illusions - and reveals the tricks they play on our senses and why they fool us.
#bbc
All our TV channels and S4C are available to watch live through BBC iPlayer, although some programmes may not be available to stream online due to rights. If you would like to read more on what types of programmes are available to watch live, check the 'Are all programmes that are broadcast available on BBC iPlayer?' FAQ 👉 bbc.in/2m8ks6v. - Наука та технологія
1:40 nice camera shot bud
he wanted to capture the beauty of the beach, a true cinematographer...lol
Sabrina Spencer Perfect moment to capture the beauty of nature while explaining your buisness with hand movements
NieCola they're geniuses
FunForSameer ii
FunForSameer I
**Smashes hand with hammer**
“Wait... Wrong hand....”
dont steal other people's comments
Ace SoulSlayer I didn’t. I just came up with it. If other people have the same kinda thing, then it’s a coincidence. It’s honestly not that creative, tbh.
Ace SoulSlayer And I like how you said, “Other people’s comments,” implying that more than one person has it. Further proving my point.
@@scrogg6105 *because
@@scrogg6105 yep i know what you mean, i have alot of time right now but i dont know what do with it
plastic hand: hi
brain: i own you now
Get yo ebony outta here
´´So it feels like this is your hand right?´´
*ｈｉｔｓ ｈａｎｄ*
"Try that at home with your kids!" Cause I always have a couple spare rubber hands at home
ha hah ha... thank you .. good chuckle out of that one.
You could use some real hands.
I wonder how old ur kids are now
Who doesn't have rubber gloves at home?
Amazon $8
Well, I did it to several teenagers and adult counselors at the summer camp I worked at, and they all said they felt "as if they felt the pain" for a second, and in their stomachs. After doing it to about 10 people, someone wanted to do it to me. Even on me, after doing it to so many others, I was surprised how well it worked on me. I really did feel it in the pit of my stomach, and my brain thought my hand had been smashed for a moment. Very very strange, fascinating feeling
fake
@@lagillas You forgot to say 'gay'. If you're gonna troll at least put in the bare minimum effort smh
carms@@lagillas
"Try that at home with your kids"
*accidentally smashes kid's head with hammer*
Hahaha i was thinking the same thing
"Accidentally" 😏
"Try that at home with your kids"
*accidentally smashes both hands*
1:27 "Try that at home with your kids!"
^this gimme goosebumps for some reason...
What wasn't included in this video which was shown in the actual show was that in many people there was the perception of PAIN not just shock at the hammer suddenly hitting the hand. I don't understand why they failed to include that point in this demonstration. These people didn't seem to exhibit that reaction at all. Having watched the video of the show it would seem that the whole point in doing the demonstration was to show your brain relies often on what you see vs what other senses tell you is really happening. Not showing the pain reaction (for those that had it) would seem to make this version of the video rather pointless. Sure, people flinched when the hammer suddenly was brought down on the fake hand but I think it's fair to say that could/would happen in most cases without anything to do with what was going on with the "real" hand. I would think you could illicit that same response with just the person sitting there and suddenly hitting the fake hand sitting on table. What's the point?
thank you - i didnt see the show but i expected the results youndescribed.
i was actually going to comment that this experiment was really mean lol
is the name of this episode "is seeing believing?"? also yeh i agree, i even jumped at the hammer smash! and whenever i like knock my hand or my knee against something i automatically say ow because i expect it to hurt, even when it feels like nothing at all
Yeah, thanks. I was trying to figure out... what's the point?
To startle them at the possibility of being hit OR to feel pain on the rubber hand. The video doesn't really make clear which it was suppose to be.
It's just bad editing on the BBC producer's part here.
wrg, can say anyx nmw, nst as fair or not
Was that scary?
yea
Goood we like that
**smiles creepily**
"Was that scary?"
"Yea."
"Right, because I suddenly, without warning, slammed a hammer down right in front of you. Anyone watching would jump."
This "experiment" proves nothing.
go home and try that with your kids yea
Isn't he suppose to hit the actual hand?
Why would he mr. hammer
the answer is yes.
no no no no no no no no no no no
Yup! Try it at home with your kids!
I believe that's what they call in science an unethical experiment. Although, I have to admit, I bet such an experiment would obtain some interesting results.
would have been lolz it he had actually hit there real hand
U died
Hahaha
10 years ago. R u alive
There was a House episode on this. "Okay your hand is back. Now, clench both your hands. NOW......... let go."
ITS LUPUS!!!?
mhks68 It's never lupus
+willj78 except that one time when it is lupus
It would have been nice to see over his shoulder to know what the real hand was doing in response to the sight of the hammer coming toward the rubber one. Did it flinch? Did it stay still? That seems like an obvious shot to have given us!
fucking with minds 101
I wonder whether it'll work with me - I'm black. I don't know that I'd see a white hand as my own.
Naturally High Your brain has no race
Naturally High ikr
Can't believe people are just starting to reply to this comment 5 years after it was written
Yeah stupid
Naturally High It's a hand in a glove. Race won't matter.
I wonder if someone goes through this experiment for long enough time, if that person would actually feel the pain.
Debasish Ray Chawdhuri no it doesnt work that way. this is a very simply trick to fool you into believing something. if you are aware, you wont care.
They wouldn't because there's physically no pain receptors in the hand.
i actually agree
Look up "phantom limb" pain
No
I'd like to see the outtakes where he hits the wrong hand.
Now, I'd be really interested on studying pain receptors and seeing if they light up or if it's just an impulsive OW. I'd also like to compare those results to whether people playing video games felt pain when their character got hit (since I know that I tend to react as if I were hurt, and other people do too, even though there's no pain).
Exactly. Someone has to test this idea.
Snake, that's a serious injury. It won't be able to heal on it's own...
Are you hurt? Try a little harder next time.
Boss come in... Boss?!.... BOSS!!?!?!??!?! Argh!
“AAAUUUGG”
MISSIONS A FAILURE BOSS
goliiad stop playing around, snake?! SNAKKKEEEEEEE
when a black person does the experiment do they have a second darker hand to make it more convincing
They could, but it wouldn't matter. Supposed to work either way.
It wears cloves
@@RodeoSwappingBoogie cloves??
Nah.
Not all black people are darker skinned though? They come in many skintones just like other races.
@jerzees I concur with your observation wholeheartedly.
"I never new these rubber bands had blood and bones and stuff!"
*w a i t*
I'd love to see an overhead view of all three hands. Great info but showing the reactions of those hidden left hands would've been a serious plus.
Did they yank their hands from the table in fear of the hammer?
I thought there was a video of overhead shot.
The entire episode is worth watching.
The best part of this illusion is that it works with amputees. If the stump of someone missing a hand is brushed next to a rubber hand they feel as if a hand is being touched!
Surely this is more to do with associative conditioning. They may feel pain from the hammer, because ever other action is being done in synchrony with the real hand. Therefore being hit in the rubber hand with the hammer may elicit fear, because they may anticipate also being hit on their real hand.
That would actually be a really interesting experiment.
nice work!
I've ALWAYS wanted to try that!
The placebo affect can change how you look
I've been saying out loud every day that I have plumper lips and they look bigger!
Chegando aqui em Set de 2020 por causa do super Podcast "Naruhodo" eps 253! Excelente!
I was only watching this on the computer screen and I was flinching when he hit the rubber hand with the hammer...
its all about focus (when someone is looking at something the mind start accepting the suggestions) :)
i would like to try this at home !!!
dude at the end it looks like there is a big storm! its kewl
Consider this: The brain didn't adopt the rubber hand. It simply correlated the synchronization of stimulation and extrapolated that a simular experience was probably gonna hit the actual hand, so it has reason for fear.
If the brain actually believed the rubber hand belonged to it, wouldn't it experience pain of some sort?
Shit's not adding up lol
+Myron Hyman No beacause there is not pain receptors in rubber hand
+GamingMarin There aren't pain receptors in "phantom limbs"
+Myron Hyman *either but there's still pain.
It does experience "phantom pain" to an extent, and that's part of the shock the participants feel.
The brain wouldn't assume that a similar experience was going to affect the hand. They said it felt like their own hand.
Oh wow 8 years later..
UA-cam:lets put this in someone's recommendation
Interesting...........brings to mind an idea........
I participated in a similar test where they position a mirror in a way that you see your real right hand and the mirror copy of your right hand on the left side.
Then they stroke both hands at the same time which is fine because the sensory image fits the visual one. But then they stroke only the right hand but since you see your imaginary left hand being stroked too you could swear that you feel something on that side too... Very creepy :)
It’s like in a dream where you have an imaginary, ethereal body and when it gets hurt in the dream, you actually think that you feel it!
"Try it home with your kids! yeah!"
I think that freaking hammer out if nowhere slamming a table in front of their face scares them more than it hitting the fake hand
Anyone else just suddenly remember this episode and looked it up?
What a nice angle!
*Try That At Home With Your Kids*
I love how that hammer came out of the nowhere
This effect works on people who've lost a limb, like losing your leg but when you use a prostetic you feel pain for it
I would be startled just by the guy slamming the hammer on the table
"try that at home with your kids!" HAHAHA
he does actually stops brushing the real hand at some point. but the eye's are transmiting the brain that the stroke is still in progress, so the persone actually felt the stroking even though it doesnt actually happen to them
I'm unconvinced, this only demonstrates the power of suggestion , imo.
Here's the things I see about this. This can be seen as both a hypnotic and conditioning exersize. As such it could used to illustrate and educate about how to examine things. The brain works both directions, both by association and by dissection.
This experiment was originally done in 1998 by Botvinick, M &Cohen, J...... just in case anyone is nerdy and wants to know... :P
I'd be scared also if I was partaking in an experiment and suddenly the scientist smashed *anything* with a hammer right in front of my face.
It’s the BBC!
-Etce
I'd be afraid of accidentally hitting someone's actual hand if I was at that booth all day.
Wait, I really want to try this.
Hey BBC, You should see " WTF Bending A Mans Mind " It would freak you out.
HAHA, that was really cool! I wish there were more vids like that on youtube. :)
Im pretty hard to impress, but that was really impressive! Thank you for sharing.
Saw it on Buzzfeed a while ago, but still worth watching again.. Crazy stuff man. I subbed.
Aaah! You hit my actual rubber hand!
Even I feel Nervous before the smashing
Alternatively, you could say he is, by being open, giving them the chance to prepare against the illusion. I think you'd find that not explaining the experiment would yield the same results.
Time:
12:38AM
PT
I luv BBC 💕😀
I thought the same thing!
01:40 looks like the Mr. Robot cameraman got a new job.
my hand felt like the people are feeling
Great trick
@jerzees i tend to agree with this statement
How can you do this without a rubber hand easily it’s not like I have a rubber hand just lying around
*Person flinches in pain*
"Isn't that WEIRD?! How FUNNY, HUH?"
*Hammers rubber hand*
Man: "Try that with your kids :)"
this is like that episode in House, MD!
Remodelling the self: We have created a mental representation of our own body, a kind of GPS mapping system, its accuracy is good but not perfect; this allows us to easily find in space with eyes close a finger from the other hand or touch our knee. Through our daily chores, this 'mapping system' or mental representation is getting constant tactile and visual information that reassures the position of the body in space; or in other words, keeps the body-self wrapped up within the skin. Interestingly if we mislead the incoming information by mimicking the body (fake hand) the sense of body-self seems to leave the skin or in this case, the self moves somewhere else.
I find thought-provoking the fact that our sensation of body-self has been fed and reinforced for as long as our age, yet this experiment in only 2 minutes or less manages to move the self out within some degree.
dats awsome!
I really want to try this trick on me!
I thought it was my hand too and when you hit it with a hammer i jumped
I thought that there was something familiar with the background theme. Then I realised, that it is from Mega Jump.
Rubber Hand Illusion?
"Illuuuuuuuuusions, Michael.
I borrowed the rubber hand from Buster."
@Tatrer I think its because even though you don't hit their actual hand with the hammer for an instant they feel the pain that they would have felt had their real hand been hit, hence the whole neuro adoption thing or whatever he was talking about, your brain believes even for a moment that the plastic hand is yours and so makes you feel pain in accordance with what you dee, not what you feel
U still there?
Whats the song at the beginning? I have heard it in other videos.
I don't even understand how someone could think this.
Thank you, internet.
“Here comes a fun surprise” 🔨 🙄 😅😂🤣🤣🤣
التكامل متعدد الحواس - multi sensory integration
That is exactly what I thought, kinda disappointed that a very valid point got spam flagged for having too many thoughts when this point of view has a valid reason to be presented.
Omg he sounds exactly like the guy from veritasium!
same here!
Bro ur literally smashing that with a hammer anyone would be shocked even without the experiment
professor!
this is cool
I wanna try thisss
We can change how our brains behave.
another great though experiment to share with you is when u are just before going asleep imagining yourself staying at the edge of the high building's roof almost falling down) your legs will be shaking) or u can imagine anything smth that will activate nerves muscles so that part of ur body will be reacting like in reality)))
Wow yeah did not think about it they probably moved it away! (Or did they....? If not it may be super cool because they tried to move the rubber hand but couldn't because it's not connected.)
doing this for my science fair project
and that's why virtual reality is super cool
I dont know if this applies but this happens to me durring video gaming as my character gets hits with shields on i feel like ive been "thumped" on my side and i flinch and go "oof" if my character gets hit without shields sometimes durring intense firefights il actualy hurt very bad on my sides or chest but usualy never on my back and clench my teeth for a sec but only durring exciting figts i cant help myself its like reflex after so much gaming.
So this is pretty cool and they explain that the subject thinks the hand is their own but they don't explain why they smash the fake hand with the hammer.
...i want to try this!! XD
Imagine if he smashed the wrong hand with the hammer
I remember him from the McGurk effect