Ultimate Camera Backpack Guide & Review for 2022 / 2023! --- NINETEEN Bags compared!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 лис 2022
- Buy them and watch my full reviews here!:
Tenba Axis 24L V2
amzn.to/3DAahvx
Tenba Axis 32L V2
www.bhphotovideo.com/c/produc...
Wandrd Prvke 21 V2
www.bhphotovideo.com/c/produc...
• The New 2021 Wandrd Pr...
Langly Alpha Globetrotter XC
www.langly.co/
• The All New 2022 Langl...
Shimoda Explore V2 30L
amzn.to/3h8AObS
• Shimoda Explore 30 V2!...
Mindshift Backlight 26L
amzn.to/3fxorFX
• Mindshift Backlight 26...
Brevite Runner
brevite.co/products/the-runne...
• The Brevite Runner ---...
Gura Gear Kiboko City Commuter
amzn.to/3DVATaP
• Gura Gear Kiboko City ...
Gura Gear Kiboko 2.0 22L
amzn.to/3Uua3x7
• Gura Gear Kiboko V2 22...
Peak Design Everyday Backpack V2 20L
amzn.to/3hdWP95
• Ultimate Peak Design E...
Peak Design Travel Backpack
amzn.to/3fCHDlK
• Peak Design Travel Bac...
Incase DSLR Pro Backpack
amzn.to/3NDEQW2
• Incase Camera Pro Pack...
Think Tank Shape Shifter 17 V2
amzn.to/3zKEozv
Think Tank Urban Access
www.bhphotovideo.com/c/produc...
• Think Tank Urban Acces...
Think Tank Backstory 15
amzn.to/3Wo0t0i
Wandrd Duo
amzn.to/3U3RrEn
• Wandrd DUO Review - My...
Lowepro Fastpack 250
amzn.to/3fDspg3
Lowepro ProTactic 450 AW II
amzn.to/3FKYSvJ
Best bag comparison I've seen by a lot. Thanks for all of the hard work I'm sure you put into this one!
thanks!!!!
Superb and very helpful videos. I'm looking the camera bag myself at the moment. Might try to go to Tenba Axis V2 32L for my Canon C70. Was thinking for good looking Langly ALpha Globertrotter XC, seems also can fit Canon C70 unrigged.
Time sync as following: (also Desy Cheng has dedicated review on some bags in the description)
Tenba Axis V2 24L - 0:40
Tenba Axis V2 32L - 2:35
Wandrd Prvke 21 V2 - 4:10
Langly Alpha Globetrotter XC - 5:53
Shimoda Explore V2 30L - 7:09
Mindshift Backlight 26L - 8:56
Brevite Runner - 10:04
Gura Gear Kiboko City Commuter - 12:03
Gura Gear Kiboko 2.0 22L - 14:02
Peak Design Everyday Backpack V2 20L - 15:55
Peak Design Travel Backpack - 17:15
Incase DSLR Pro Backpack - 18:50
Think Tank Shape Shifter 17 V2 - 20:47
Think Tank Urban Access - 22:43
Think Tank Backstory 15 - 25:38
Wandrd Duo - 26:55
Lowepro Fastpack 250 - 28:26
Lowepro ProTactic 450 AW II (honorable mention) - 29:37
Desy Cheng's preferred bags - 30:03
Fantastic review! Thank you 🙏🏼
The ultimate bag review indeed!
Great review Desy and thank you. I've been thinking of purchasing the Tenba V2 and after seeing your review on it I pretty sure that's what I will be doing now.
Lately I've been using hte Nanuk NPVD 30L as my primary camera backpack =). I still have the Tenba and it's still great! But the Nanuk is just a bit slimmer and not as bulky
I appreciate the video. I just got through test driving the Peak Design and Nomatic Everyday bags and came away disappointed with both. I think I’m gonna try the Tenba. My goals are to hold my Song A74 and a 70-200 lens mounted and to hold my 16 inch MacBook. I would love if it could double as a work bag but I’m thinking this is gonna be a difficult ask.
Hey! Great video! One thing though, to truly make this the greatest guide: Could you please add in timetamps at the times you talk about each bag on the video? 😁 This would really help out whenever anyone is in need to quickly jump to, and reference specific buying choices in the future 🙏🏼
thanks for the suggestion! ill try and get around to updating this during the winter break hopefully!
I guess he didn’t get around to it 😂
@@DesmondCheng yes please do this - really annoying without timestamps (otherwise a really useful vid)
Winter has past and now we are approaching the next winter, and still no TimeStamp....
It has now been several decades later, these bags are no longer relevant. And look.. STILL NO TIME STAMPS!
desy the best bag reviews on the internet.
THANKS!!!
Thank you very much for this detailed comparison!
no problem!
Thank you for the video. I own about half the bags you showed but definitely look one or two others now. These days Canon RF lenses present a new challenge do to their girth and large hoods. My bags I use for Sony kit are not as challenged. Between a close friend and I we own your top four. We each own two of them. Will definitely be looking at some others now. Thanks.
thanks for a very thorough video. A few on this list that I was originally considering. I have since been thinking about the PGYTECH Onemo or wandrd prvke 31L V3. The ever moving target of the perfect camera bag. I need something to carry my gear (canon 70d with 3 lenses (including 70-200mm) but also some other non camera stuff. Clothes, etc for a day/2 day trip
Great vid, thanks.
Excellent work - very useful =- thank you
thanks!
How would you compare the camera gear capacity between the Tenba Axis v2 vs the Mindshift Backlight 26L, and also the carrying comfort? Thank you!
Good video. The thing about camera bags is that if you're doing photography professionally, for weddings or sports events, then you won't be able to have that bag with you. Unless you want to hump a backpack while doing a wedding. I mean, you don't just want to set it anywhere, it won't be safe. I have a tendra roller camera bag and when I use to do weddings I left it in the car. I transferred the lenses to my lens bag (the shoot sack). I was able to carry my lenses and a flash and other accessories in a basically ergonomic bag that has the messenger compact bag look and it's stylish.
The Mindshift BacklLight bags are great for adventure stuff. I got the 18L not expecting to use it for anything but short outings but it's become my main bag for 3 years now. Having a side pocket on each side is great. They both hold plenty of stuff. I've dragged that bag over numerous sharp lava floors in lava tube exploring and it held up great. Comfortable mountain biking too.
i had the backlight bag, it was great!!
Thanks! Really helpful.
My preference is the following:
1. Gura Gear 22L+. It’s on order and I am anxiously awaiting it. I
am looking to house a Sony mirrorless with a 200-600 on one side and another body with 24-70 or 70-200 on the other, plus other lenses. This can handle it comfortably while having it impeccably organized. It’s also carry on compliant.
The 16L+ can also accommodate a Sony A7R body with an attached 200-600 on one side, leaving the other side for other bodies/lenses. The 16L+ can fit underneath an airline seat. Great to relieve overhead compartment anxieties.
2. Mindshift Backlight 26L: probably the best moderate to difficult day hiking camera backpack. The genius of this one is you have a camera section and a 7L front section.
The front section is used for food, protein bars, first aid kit, flash light, water bladder, etc. The 2 water bottle holders are also necessary for longer hikes. There’s also straps for both hiking poles, as well as a tripod.
The camera section can comfortably handle a camera with attached 200-600 lens, plus another mirrorless bodies and lenses.
So it’s 2 backpacks in one. Most camera backpacks are just that - camera backpacks. Leaving you without much space for hiking related stuff.
This backpack is also very comfortable. The Backlight 26L is one of the most popular camera hiking backpacks as a result.
Like the video, love that you have all the bags and all that. I would like to see a ranking on screen and maybe a pro/con section. Doesnt have to be super amazing gfx just so people could more quickly skim thru.
thank u! yeah i agree, ill try and include more graphics next time!
Incredible video man. Swinging by my local camera shop to confirm my 16" MBP will fit in the Think Tank 15. Thanks for the great reviews all in one video.
Thanks! yeah the 16" should fit in there
@@DesmondCheng took your advice and opted for the Tenba Axis V2 24 👊🏼
great vid, in the hunt for a camera pack can be tough when there are hundreds to choose from.
thanks!
Thanks for the video. What would you say is the best bag for 2x canon r3 with couple lenses?
either the think tank urban access 15 or tenba axis v2 24L
oh and pgytech onemo2 which just got released yesterday!
I have the fx3 rigged out, and I think you answered my question about fitting it in the tenba Axis 32l without breaking it down. Thanks
awesome!! it will also fit into the langly alpha glovetrotter!
Great video, Desy! I like the Tenba and Think Tank you show at the end. Have you been able to review the Wantoncraft Commander or Pilot backpacks at all? Thanks for sharing your opinion.
unfortunately i have not had a chance to see those packs in person!
You mentioned you switched from the think tank to the temba. Does the tenba still fit your r5 with battery grip attached?
Which bag do you think would fit an FS7 with fisheye lens and an FX3 + 28-135 PZ better, the Tenba 32 or Pgytech 35?
Can you recommend a backpack that's not too big for a large tripod? Thank you!
Is it possible to put the camera with grip like Z9 or R3 and mounted 70-200mm lens into Gura Gear Kiboko 22l+?
I have the Kiboko Commuter 18 L. Just finished my first trip. Nikon Z8 with 24=120, 100-400, 40mm f/2, 17-28, and 20mm 1.8. 14 inch MacBook Pro, and an 11 inch iPad Pro. Plus chargers and cables and batteries.
I have the think tank hard drive v2. I’ve yet to find a better bag that fits as much stuff. I’ve also never had an issue with bringing it on planes as my personal item along with my carry on. I wish someone would make something similar that looks alittle better though
thats a great bag! i had that at one point!
Great video! Like you I have a bit of an addition when it comes to buying and trying the ultimate bag/back pack combo. - One bag you didn't have in your review (perhaps it wasn't out yet when you did this) is the PGYTECH OneMo 2 35L-45L - This is similar in size to the Peak Design or the Peter McKenna bag but without the expensive price tag. As a videographer, I was able to fit everything in this bag, audio gear, drone, lighting kit, 2 bodies, additional lenses and more - its great!.
yup got that bag after i made this video! here is my review of it! ua-cam.com/video/pLde3AYA4Uw/v-deo.html
Oh my god the Tenba 32 seems perfect! This looks to be exactly what I've been wanting. Thank you for the great comparison! Also thank you for your sacrifice in trying so many bags lol. I'm a bag head so I get it.
haha glad i could help!
But also one bag came out after I made this video, the PGYTECH onemo2. They have a 25L and a 35L. They 35L is a contender to the Tenba 32!
@@DesmondCheng Which one feel sturdier if you don't mind answering? They seem pretty similar but I'm leaning towards the Tenba still. Advice?
@@almond1505 The PGYTECH has a few more features, and it does feel a bit sturdier. The one thing I don't like about the Tenba is that hole/pocket opening up on the inside when you pick it up via the grab handle. Both are great though! personal preference... but I would say maybe the PGYTech is gonna be bigger!
@@DesmondCheng I think I'm going to order both and return the one I like more, thanks again for all the help! It's crazy that the PGYTECH is almost $50 cheaper and comes with an extra bag.
@@almond1505 nice, let me know how it goes!
Well that was cool, Last night I decided to get the Tenba Axis 24 v2! :D. Great review/comparison, thanks Desy!
glad i could help!
another bag that i have been using a bit more recently is the gura gear kiboko+. stay tuned for an updated vid on that!
@@DesmondCheng Looking forward to it! The Molle on the Tenba is part of what sold me. I currently use an EDC/Tactical handgun backpack with Cubes from Vanguard (Awesome products!). So I have all the Molle added pouches etc. I need for the 24l v2. It’s the side access (on the correct side!) that I’ve been missing. I did have the PGYTech (camo) but the side access was too small and on the wrong side for me personally. Snagged the Tenba on eBay for $129 having only been used a couple times. Looking forward to putting it through it’s paces. Thanks again, great review.
enjoy!@@cohoonatube
You have to try the Compagnon Element Backpack. I have it and I am very very satisfied with it. I bet it would be in your top 3
Same I would recommend the Compagnon Element.
Thank you for this Desy! This was such a great video. I was hoping you had included one more bag in your review, as I cannot decide between the Langly Alpha, and the K & F Concepts Multifunctional Camera backpack; was hoping you had tried this one too...but I don't see it in any of your videos (and I swear you did one!). Thank you again though - I absolutely love the way you get right into the bags, the good and the bag. Nice work!
thanks! no i havent tried the kf concept one yet! I just ordered the new Wandrd Stratus that came out yesterday, excited for that one! But here are my current faves:
- Nanuk 30L N-PVD
- Wotancraft Pilot 18
- Wandrd 21L
- Shimoda Explore V2 30L
I haven't been using my Langly as much these days...
Oooh I love my Wandrd bag for hiking. Would love to see you do a review on the Stratus! I have a bag addiction lol. Thanks Desy!
Thank you for the review. A question: do you believe a Canon 6D would fit the PRVK Lite and pass through the side opening? Thank you again.
i have not used the Lite so I can't say for sure. But if the dimensions are the same for the opening as the 21L, then yes it would fit!
Hello, Great video for me. I want to buy a new bag.
Love your video. So helpful. I’m probably going with the Tenba, but will the 24L hold an R5 with grip?
yes it will!
@@DesmondCheng Thank you for the response!
What a video! Wow! But what do you think about the Nomatic Peter Mckinnon ?
thanks! I havent used it yet so I can't give you my thoughts about it.
hi @DesmondCheng im looking to get a backpack for my travel soon. I currently have a sony a7ii with the sigma 35mm and 24-70. I'm kind of overwhelmed by the infinite options of backpacks. do you have a specific one you would recommend? Went through this video and cant solidify on one, im more on the smaller/medium sized bag nothing too large. if you could help me out with getting the right one that would be great. thank you.
It's a great question because I also find myself constantly switching between bags.... But for the small-medium range, I've been using the Think Tank Urban Access 13 and the Think Tank backstory 15. The Wandrd prvke is also another good option.
OR just get a camera insert like the Tenba BYOB and put it into a regular backpack. I've been loving my Osprey Parsec bag lately.
I was considering getting the Thule Covert, looks nice, they have in 24L and 32L which are two reasonable sizes.
i bought the thule once! i returned it though. just wasnt for me!
@@DesmondCheng thanks a lot for the reply and the great videos. What do you think it was the main problem? And did you get the 32L or 24L one?
@@danieldelariva4653 i got the 24L one, to use as an everyday backpack. i honestly dont remember why i returned it! i had the wandrd prvke 21 already so maybe i just didn't need this one.
@@DesmondCheng cool! I think I will buy the Prvke 21L since as of now I don’t have any gear. I just didn’t like the waterproof texture a lot but I think the size is great.
Have you tried the Summit Creative Tenzing 40L?
no i have not! But I'm looking at it now and it looks awesome!
Watched the whole video, super helpful. Thanks. Last month I bought the Wandrd Provoke 21L but my gear just didn’t fit, looking for a replacement ever since. Seems like the Tenba is the one!
My problem is that I use a adapter ring on Nikon Z6ii with 70-200 f2.8. It’s a pretty long setup that doesn’t fit most camerabags sideways. But it seems like the Tenba could just work for me!
glad i could help!
bag got delivered, have to send it back... my 70-200mm is too long for the top loader (using a mirrorless camera + adapter ring). And I really want to acces my camera from the top of the bag. Bit of a bummer...as I love the bag's aesthetics and feel.
Is there maybe a bag you can recommend that has a deeper main loading zone? Thanks mate
@@DesmondCheng
@@jophermans ahh sorry to hear! Other bags that do top loading: LowePro Pro Tactic, Incase Pro Pack, Tenba Axis 32L, Thinktank Backstory 15
We appreciate the inclusion, Desy, cheers 👌🏻
no problem!! When are you going to make an Urban Access 15 V2?!?!?! Make it all-black and slightly tactical-ish! It would be a dream!!!
Camera backpacks need to be versatile, comfortable, fit your needs and reliable. I could not care less whether or not they are "attractive" or "look good"... I like the Guragear Kiboko with the two separated compartments which allows to separate full frame gear from crop frame ones if you carry both types of cameras.
Love the gura gear!
Is the 30L version of the Prvke deeper/better? I’m currently using an eos r, with 24-70, 100mm and 16-35… and looking for backpack replacement that would comfortable, could also fit a 16” and accessories for day usage, like photo walks and trips. A tripod, a water bottle, maybe jacket, snacks… you know the deal… hard to find something that would mix style x versatility x comfort, right? Some bags looks like you’re carrying a coffin, so deep and rigid they are all the way through, from the upper part of the bag to the bottom… still in the search…
the 30L is a bit bigger yes!
I just got the new Wotancraft Pilot backpack, that one fits camera gear better than the Wandrd 20L.
@@DesmondChengthink tank urban 15! “The most versatile”! And so it seems, indeed!
i still use it to this day!@@guidolima
Really wanted to hear your opinion on thr BP250AW III lowepro. You only mentioned it's similar to the II but it's far from similar.
Hopefully you can check it out.
if they made it in all black, ill buy it!
@@DesmondCheng Ended up buying it and bought the All black color.
Pros- it's very light ; Negative - the fabric feels less durable.
@@hogsa7287 oh where did u find the all-black version? i cant seem to find it
Think Tank Urban Acces 15 or Pgytech Onemo 2?
i prefer think tank!
Your only issue with the Shimoda was the core unit cube. Maybe you've already sold it but have you tried putting different cubes in or using different 3rd party dividers? Wonder if the PD cubes can be wedge inside instead.
I've been using the PD everyday + travel backpacks for several years. Great for urban commute but uncomfortable for heavy loads or prolong travel. Instead use hiking specific backpack like Osprey for traveling. Biggest draw about the Shimado is hiking oriented design with adjustable straps/torso. Think it is the only camera bag that does this.
i have not tried other cubes in it! My 2 fave camera bags these days are the: tenba axis V2 24L and the Gura Gear kiboko 2.0 22L at the moment
So interesting to see how tastes vary. I do like the look of the Wandrd although I find the roll up top a little goofy. I really don't like look of the Globetrotter, at least if you're in casual clothes. And obviously the tactical one is ugly as hell. At least seeing it through the screen I'd prefer to be seen in the Urban Access (although I reckon the 13 looks better than the 15, as large backpacks just look kinda goofy in general).
i just used the urban access 13 yesterday, love it!
Hi dear , please suggest me the one bag pack which has got explosion proof material please …😂 …
lol unfortunately i dont think any of these are explosion proof!
The wandrd is a bulky bag just like the tenbas I use the LowePro protactic 350aw II. Looks great steardy not that bulky. I find it odd you talk about sony but put in Canon camera and rf lenses.
the protactic is a great bag!
Did my eyes deceive me or did the Brevite bag fit an R5 with 15-35, 50mm 1.2, and the 70-200 in it? That's my exact kit and I'm looking for a lightweight bag lol
yes that is correct!
Well, I think *The best Backpack" only exists for the person that is making this video! 😇(What you like an other person might dislike and vice versa!)
No F-stop? Tells a lot about your use of backpacks! 😉I cannot even compare other brands because I almost exclusively use Lowepro backpacks (and love them)! 😍
In future I might try an F-stop backpack (though they are really expensive). I'd like to know if F-stop is really as comfortable as many reviewers tell you. 🤔
ATM I don't have a ton of gear I'd like to take with me. Therefore I probably have other requirements for a photo backpack! Yes, I'd love one for dayly use - however until now I haven't found it.
It must be one with removable camera department and I'd like rear access for the camera. 🤔
i actually have the f-stop tilopa! Its very comfortable, however its very big. more like a hiking backpack rather than an everyday carry. i forgot to include that bag in this review!
Hey there, first timer. Besides what someone else mentioned with the timestamp, would be nice if you included pricing with the bags. Good job otherwise 👍🏼
I've never understood the hype with Peak Design. Their dual side access concept seems like it would be aggravating as heck to organize/access equipment. The Wandrd Prvke 2.0 always catches my eye from an aesthetic/functionality standpoint, but I think the Nomatic/McKinnon 25L pack performs the same functions more efficiently and with a sturdier structure (got it from the Kickstarter about a year ago and love it).
nice, i still have yet to get it!
Just bought the Tenba Axis, not the V2. The older version.
You missed the great ThinkTank Airport Essentials.
But from all those backpack, what I ended up keeping is the one you did not review, the Bagsmart at the background. That's the best as a travel backpack/personal item bag for air travel.
Other than that none of the bags shown would be good as a personal item/camera bag for air travel.
ah yes ill have to try that bag out!
You keep all the bags?
most of them lol
i should probably start selling them though!
This video would be great with the UA-cam chapters feature using timestamps.
You don't need to buy a whole new backpack just buy a backpack insert, I got one from B&H for $10 now I can use my regular backpack lighter better built more comfortable
I want to like the Tenba Axis backpack, but the hardest part for me to accept on so many backpacks including this one, is the laptop in the lid. I produce a travel show and will be traveling for six months out of the year through Asia and Africa. Why would I want to throw my laptop on the ground whenever I open the lid. Am I the only one who is so bugged about this design that many companies choose to stay with? It's like the designers never used it in a real-world scenario. Am I overly worried about tossing my laptop around every time I need to access the main compartment? I am curious to hear other people's thoughts.
for the tenba axis the laptop is in the 'middle' section. The front part has space for accessories and thinner items like a jacket. Then there is a separate compartment for the laptop. And then at teh back is where all the camera gear goes!
@@DesmondCheng Thanks for the comment. I’ll take a closer look at the Tenba Axis. I obviously missed that detail. 😋 Other than the laptop concern, I love the look and functionality of the bag.
@@AaronRittenour two other bags that ive been using more of recently is the Gura Gear Kiboko and also the Wotancraft Pilot 18L!
Sorry but Shimoda bags are the MOST comfortable and the BEST well designed! I have NO PROBLEM fitting longer lenses in my bag!
=)
Kinda surprised that you didn't include the Compagnon Element and the Peter McKinnon 25L. They both blow away any of the bags you reviewed here. Appreciate the comparison though.
I'm amazed he owns as many as he does. We probably shouldn't encourage him to hoard any more bags haha
Like how I went into the shop today to find every backpack was black and looked like your carrying camera gear. I will probably end up buying a normal backpack and convert it.
good option!
This is not the first video where I see lenses going into and out of bags without a cap on the front of it. Do you all really store your lenses without lens caps?
i have filters on all of my lenses. i never use lens caps anymore!
I have no idea why anyone would want nineteen bags but ok, I like the Mindshift Backlight the best i'm getting a 36l later this month. I was going to get the Tenba Axis 32l but they're extremely expensive for what they are and in my opinion overpriced. Plus also i've talked to people who have had them and they say they're great rucksacks but the velcro straps are a design flaw because when loaded with quite a bit of gear they have a tendancy to let loose and the straps suddenly fall loose. That is not good at all. I mean what is the point making rucksack that can handle so much equipment then put velcro straps that when under a lot of strain from the weight of the equipment suddenly give way, it's dumb. To be honest I think the best cheap camera rucksacks are the Lowepro Tahoe 150 and Lowepro Photo Classic BP300AW both of which I have. I tired a few bags out and went for those. I upgraded from the Tahoe 150 to the Photo Classic as I got more gear and now my Photo Classic is nearly bursting from all my gear which is why i'm getting a Mindshift Backlight 36l later this month.
Peak Design Backpacks are the biggest trash out there. I still remember putting 6kg of stuff into it and then testing it for 10 minutes and it was so uncomfortable, that it hurt my shoulders and upper back for 3 days straight. What is the point of a camera backpack when it debilitates you. To anyone reading and considering this backpack, dont bother unless you only carry like 2kg or something.
No lens caps 🫣
yeah they just get in the way and i always lose them so i never put them on. But i do have lens filters screwed on!
@@DesmondCheng glad to know you have at least those screwed in! I’ve so many scratched up when I first started lol
Why are camera bags made to carry every bit off equipment you own, where are the backpacks or shoulder bags for just a camera with zoom lens fitted with space for spare batteries , plus with easy access.
the wandrd prvke is probably what u are after! simple! Or the brevite jumper / runner!
I will never buy a #TENBA bag ever again. I spent $300+ on a bag that the casing fell apart within 2 years and TENBA refused to honor it's 5 year warranty. Their reasoning was because the bag was discontinued therefore the warranty was discontinued. Never will buy anything #TENBA again.
thats terrible! Peak Design had EXCELLENT customer service! I had a sling that was discontinued, and they replaced it with a new one!
I bet you find and lose a lot of things having that pany packs
LOL YUP!!!!