The attention for detail in this review is impressive. Your channel is better than the average motorcycle magazine. One can tell that a lot of time went into this video. Well done. When will you do the best racing helmets?
Excuse me for the question but, loving your channel, I was wondering : don't you envision a change in your procedure since it depends exclusively on your particular setting which is not universal at all : driver, bike with it's fairing... Why not begin a new series on a naked bike ? Wouldn't it be truer to the helmets essential qualities which is related to it's conception ? Best regards.
Great tests, but did you ever consider doing the tests on a naked bike? From my experience the wind shield changes everything, e.g. a GT Air2 is very quiet behind a windshield, but quite loud on a naked bike.
Thank you for your comment. We actually got this comment before. In all honesty it doesn't hold a lot of validity. Sure your naked would give more wind, but this (dis)advantage would still be the same for all helmets. You're absolutely right if you'd say it wouldn't make sense to test one helmet on this bike and the other on another bike. But all helmets are tested under similar conditions on the same bike with the same screen. So the (dis)advantage of a windscreen wouldn't/shouldn't play a role in any of these helmets as they are all experiencing the same conditions. Hope this makes sense to you as well.
@@Championhelmets Well, to be honest from my experience this is not correct, E.g. the HJC RPHA11 is loud behind a windshield and relativ quiet on a nakedbike- So from my experience it is not possible to carry over the results from one bike with a windshield to another bike with or without a windshield. But the result on different nakedbikes would be the same, as long there is no other influence.
@@ChrisAkAxTr3Me well we can't really say much about your anecdotal proof based on your personal experience. All we can say is that all helmets are subjected to the exact same bike, same shield, same conditions. If you believe that one helmet is getting an advantage out of this, all we can really say is we disagree based on factual data. We hope you could still learn anything from the video.
@@Championhelmets Of course the conditions are the same for each helmet and it is right to do so. I dont suggest to test one helmet on a naked bike and the other on the BMW GS and then compare the results. But you can compare the result of a GT-Air2 on a naked bike and on the BMW GS. Just try it, you will see the difference. But whatever, it doesnt not seem that you are interested in this comparison so never mind, it was just a suggestion 🙂
If you wonder why ppl say that certain helmets are louder despite measuring lower dB, you should check the phon unit (unit for loudness). At the same dB level different frequencies will be perceived differently by our brain.
Can you do a road test on a naked bike because im getting alot of different opinions. Like shoei gt ait2 seems quiet with windscreen and super noisy on a naked
i cant believe ( literally ) that any adventure helmet should be quieter than say the C5, they have way more openings and agressive wind blocking additions on the outer shell wich also produce a lot of volume E2, LS2. I feel there is something wrong with those results since its not logical theoretically that those helmets are quieter. Atleast i cant imagine how they should be. Anyways they are way out of my price range for a helmet (400) to test it myself. Maybe a test with a powerful Ventilator and a test head with built in microphone would be a better way to make some objective results wich cant be wrong due to windshields, daily conditions, microphone placement of the rider, angle of the head ect. You dont need a wind channel, just a room with a powerful 250-300mm Fan blowing air at the helmet through a tube so the ventilator noise is not interfering with measurements. A test setup like that would be like 500€ and way more objective, calculate or measure windspeed, tweak it and lets go. Would expect something like that from "THE helmet channel"
I have the Scorpion EXO1400. I bought it for the weight, but later read that carbon helmets tend to be louder than other materials. Its super comfortable but I cant get rid of all the noise. I wear earplugs. I ride a quiet Honda ST1300. It sounds like Im sitting next to a jet taking off all day long. I have no idea what to do about it
Scorpion Exo tech owner here. Extremely loud helmet! I got massive tinnitus / hearing damage from this helmet while I ALWAYS wear hearing protection. Shopping for a Shoei now and never again buying a Scorpion.
@@motodrone84 I had this same experience you've mentioned with hearing damage and tinnitus but from a Shoei RF-SR. Stoopit loud even with ear plugs. I replaced it with a AGV-K6 which made a huge difference but I'd still like to get quieter. I've read numerous places the Schuberth C3 Pro is quieter than the C5 tested here. I wonder if it was in the line up for comparison here?
@@dustytriumph I tried the C3 on in the store. It felt good but havent tested it on the bike. It has a good reputation though. I ended up buying a Shoei Hornet ADV and it is a huge improvement compared to my Scorpion. The fit is exceptional and it's way more quiet. I recommend getting custom earplugs fitted. I got mine delivered a week after getting the Shoei and with the new helmet and the earplugs I now am super comfortable sound wise.
@@motodrone84 I saw my ENT audiologist a little over a year ago for custom molded earplugs since no conventional earplugs will stay in my ears even before putting on my helmet. She tried to make molds but I have a really bad case of something called 'collapsing ear canal disease' which means no custom molded earplugs. Even if they were made I'd never get them in. My ears hurt like hell for 3 days after she removed the molds. I was lucky my eardrums were not damaged. I found soft mold-able silicone putty on Amazon that I use with a skull cap over ears under my helmet and that works half decent. Even still....the difference between riding that way with my AGV vs Shoei is like thunder.
Glad you enjoyed it! The RPHA 91 is more than able to hold it's own, it placed third in our top 10 modular helmets of 2023. I'd recommend watching that video to get a better idea of how it compares to it's competitors!
If anyone disagrees, it’s likely because helmet fit makes a huge difference in perceivable noise. An improper fitting helmet allows much more wind to enter the helmet. The best helmet is the one that fits.
The Rpha 91 is a cold/cool weather helmet only. It’s interior materials don’t allow any ventilation, despite having them. Also, they’re very round shaped (inside).. so most (oval) heads won’t fit well.
I had Scorpion exo r1 carbon. I used it on a sportbike and it got windy about 90mph, but was not disturbing at all. It clwas comfortable for about 3hrs. Ventilation is working really well.. in colder temperature i opened and closed it to see if the difference noticable. This helmet is more user friendly if used in warm weather. Visor is beyond great. Never fogged up once. Also came with tinted visor too. Cardo system fits inside perfectly. Overall is nice helmet
Hi, wasn't the shoei adv hornet x2 good enough for ranking on the adv sector? I'm planning to get one till I saw this video. Where does it stand on the adv ranking? Thanks!
Quietest helmet I've ever put on my head was a $100 AGV Q3R way back in the early 90's... nice tight fit for a few rides then perfection.. I'm talking stupid quiet that I'll bet money these helmets come nothing close to.. Sadly every one has gone to putting dumbass ear pockets in their helmets now which equals LOUD.... 😢
Agreed, there's more to a helmet than just the sound. These are all high-end helmets, meaning that they should be comfortable with glasses. To be sure, make sure you know what type of helmet shapes fit you best.
I have the LS2 Explorer Carbon. It is the loudest, noisiest, screeching, squeeking helmet on the face of the planet, wearing nothing is better. I was looking at this video to find a replacement and you put it at the top?
Tgank you for sharing your opinion. Please feel free to find a better helmet than you have now. Enlighten us if your numbers come out entirely different.
I don’t like my gt air II either. I find it to be really loud buffeting. Looking for other options now already even though I just spent $1k on that helmet with the Sena.
@@slothmarathonpromotions2470 The problem is probably related to your bike/windscreen and your height, that is where the buffeting comes from. Try higher or lower windscreen and you will see the difference.
Same issue with me. It is the first helmet I have owned but I can't ride without ear plugs. Feels like a lot of air gets in from the neck/cheeks. Might just be a head shape issue, but it really is loud with me.
Appreciate it! You can definitely use it on-road. Generally speaking, adventure helmets are like standard touring helmets, just with all the features you need if you do decide to go off-road.
What is meant by helmets not making the list because of their average star rating? I just want to know what helmet is the quietest. It could get one star in every other category for all I care, I just want to know which had the lowest decibels.
I’ve had a Scorpion exo R1 for 2 years. Not a quiet helmet at all. Granted I don’t have the carbon version and I ride naked bikes, but my ears will ring just from the wind noise.
It is, according to our test rider. It has an oval fit, be sure to check what type of fit matches your head shape, as the comfort of a helmet tends to differ per person!
Yep - for reference, the agv k3 I think was measured at 102db? Upper limit id generally reccomended to be 90 for shorter periods I believe and decibel scale is logarithmic so "just" 12db louder is insane
Why do you measure the noise on a faired bike with a windscreen?? The results will be complete different for different bikes! Please use a naked bike before you do such recommendations!
Good question! I guess it's down to personal preference. Though I'd recommend looking at some full face alternatives to be sure! Maybe check out our Sport-Touring guide!
Appreciate the effort this channel puts into applying some actual science into such a subjective topic. However, the variable is the bike. Notice the wind deflectors on the test bike. Purpose is to limit the wind coming up under the helmet. Those deflectors aren’t available for my bike and that’s where my biggest issue is with wind noise. Ever helmet should come with a chin curtain, imho. Or, it’s 2023, should be able to incorporate noise canceling technology into helmets. May be a high end option but I’d take it.
Just got back from the shop and a 40 min ride at a 100Kph in the HJC RPHA 91, the cross winds were loads quieter than in my previous HJC FS-GT helmet, I was able to listen to my music at a lot lower volume as I didn't have to compensate for the wind, and, the bass in the music was not killed by the wind. All in all happy with the helmet after 1 ride. I hate the chin strap, it is really annoying that there is no DDs...:((
@@jamesm5192 Hoihoi! So, this is the story: I've used the Qudelix 5k Bluetooth thingy with Meze Solo and Ikko OH-10 Obsidian... Meze Solo had better physical sealing, but prefer the OH-10 for sound quality... Then Changed to the FiiO UTWS3 and later 5 Bluetooth adapters - you can stick your IEMs on them making them true wireless... The buttons are on the sides of these, and sometimes they get pushed by the helmet turning them off, making them louder etc..., but a lot less times as the helmet is flip-up, so you can put the helmet over them and not pull it through with regular full faced helmets. I am wearing glasses, and my glasses basically prohibits me to use the UTWS5 adapters because they are getting squeezed into my skull by this helmet with the help of my glasses... So... Back to the wire... I bought the great FiiO BTR7 and bought the DUNU SA6 MK2 awesome warm and bassy IEM, which comes with a brilliant silicon tip that makes a fucking awesome seal!!! I can listen to music at low volume so I won't screw up my hearing meanwhile all the details are still there and not getting lost thanks to the noise in the helmet. I love the combo of the BTR7 and the SA6 MK2 for the bike, and I listen to the SA6 MK2 with the UTWS5 at work. The BTR7 would need a power bank attached to it for longer rides though! 3+ hours... The UTWS5 could last 5+ hours... Even more, because when you stop for refueling or for a toilet break, you just shove them back in the case that would charge them while you're doing stuff off the bike. You can find some good deals for the DUNU SA6 MK2 on head-fi. I think there are 2 for sale at the moment. I got my FiiO things from Wifimedia. Oh, I ride an FJR1300 with windscreen extension, so that too helps to keep the helmet quiet. I need it as I am 193cm. You can find reviews of the BTR7, UTWS5 & DUNU SA6 MK2 on the channels Z Reviews and In-Ear Fetish. We have similar taste and I don't regret buying anything based on his reviews. I bought about 10 items by now... I hope this helps.
@@himangshumahanta5398 I don’t own one bit I guess since the Motogp champion is wearing one they should be ok-ish 😁 I was hoping for a comparison to know exactly how they are.
I'm sorry but we hope you don't mind that we think our professional sound measurement equipment is more reliable than your hearing. Thank you for your friendly comment though
@@Championhelmets I highly recommend conducting another test utilizing professional sound measurement equipment positioned precisely at the ear level. This additional evaluation will enable you to fully comprehend the extent of the noise produced by the Scorpion Exo R1 Carbon Air helmet. It is evident that this helmet stands out as one of the loudest options available.
The attention for detail in this review is impressive. Your channel is better than the average motorcycle magazine. One can tell that a lot of time went into this video. Well done.
When will you do the best racing helmets?
Our Top 10 Racing Helmets is releasing this sunday! Be sure to hit that notifications bell so you're updated as soon as it's uploaded!
What sucks is several of these helmets don't appear to be designed to work with a Cardo communicator. I guess you can use the stick on mount.
Excuse me for the question but, loving your channel, I was wondering : don't you envision a change in your procedure since it depends exclusively on your particular setting which is not universal at all : driver, bike with it's fairing... Why not begin a new series on a naked bike ? Wouldn't it be truer to the helmets essential qualities which is related to it's conception ? Best regards.
Agreed! Different seating positions affect the wind/noise.
Great tests, but did you ever consider doing the tests on a naked bike? From my experience the wind shield changes everything, e.g. a GT Air2 is very quiet behind a windshield, but quite loud on a naked bike.
Thank you for your comment. We actually got this comment before. In all honesty it doesn't hold a lot of validity. Sure your naked would give more wind, but this (dis)advantage would still be the same for all helmets. You're absolutely right if you'd say it wouldn't make sense to test one helmet on this bike and the other on another bike. But all helmets are tested under similar conditions on the same bike with the same screen. So the (dis)advantage of a windscreen wouldn't/shouldn't play a role in any of these helmets as they are all experiencing the same conditions. Hope this makes sense to you as well.
@@Championhelmets Well, to be honest from my experience this is not correct, E.g. the HJC RPHA11 is loud behind a windshield and relativ quiet on a nakedbike- So from my experience it is not possible to carry over the results from one bike with a windshield to another bike with or without a windshield. But the result on different nakedbikes would be the same, as long there is no other influence.
@@ChrisAkAxTr3Me well we can't really say much about your anecdotal proof based on your personal experience. All we can say is that all helmets are subjected to the exact same bike, same shield, same conditions. If you believe that one helmet is getting an advantage out of this, all we can really say is we disagree based on factual data. We hope you could still learn anything from the video.
@@Championhelmets Of course the conditions are the same for each helmet and it is right to do so. I dont suggest to test one helmet on a naked bike and the other on the BMW GS and then compare the results. But you can compare the result of a GT-Air2 on a naked bike and on the BMW GS. Just try it, you will see the difference. But whatever, it doesnt not seem that you are interested in this comparison so never mind, it was just a suggestion 🙂
@@Championhelmetswell wind noise test should be made on a naked bike if i’m honest
If you wonder why ppl say that certain helmets are louder despite measuring lower dB, you should check the phon unit (unit for loudness). At the same dB level different frequencies will be perceived differently by our brain.
this is too advanced for the non-scientific brain
It's my understanding that the Schuberth C3 Pro is quieter than the C5 tested here. Was the C3 Pro part of this test line up?
Are your noise tests done with all the vents closed? Would be very useful if you test the noise inside the helmet with the vents closed and open.
Yes. All vents are open on all helmets.
What causes the wind noise, fittings on the helmet like vents and visor disturbing the airflow?
Shoei GT air 2 has lots of wind noise,not a quiet helm at all. -3 year owner
Sounds like it doesn't fit you properly
Mine fits perfect and I think it’s loud also?
Same as the Scorpion exo 1400 hahaha it’s so loud
Mine was very quite..with the ear plugs on 📏🤣
WHAT? WHAT?? SPEAK UP!!
Can you do a road test on a naked bike because im getting alot of different opinions. Like shoei gt ait2 seems quiet with windscreen and super noisy on a naked
Question: where would the Shoei RF-1400 land? Is it even quieter?
It’s the NXR2 is the same as the 1400. Google it
@@davidc3943 yep The Shoei NXR II, also known as the RF-1400
I know this video is too recent, but shoei gt air 3 and neotec 3 just camed out. Could you please add them to the test? Thanks!
i cant believe ( literally ) that any adventure helmet should be quieter than say the C5, they have way more openings and agressive wind blocking additions on the outer shell wich also produce a lot of volume E2, LS2. I feel there is something wrong with those results since its not logical theoretically that those helmets are quieter. Atleast i cant imagine how they should be. Anyways they are way out of my price range for a helmet (400) to test it myself. Maybe a test with a powerful Ventilator and a test head with built in microphone would be a better way to make some objective results wich cant be wrong due to windshields, daily conditions, microphone placement of the rider, angle of the head ect. You dont need a wind channel, just a room with a powerful 250-300mm Fan blowing air at the helmet through a tube so the ventilator noise is not interfering with measurements. A test setup like that would be like 500€ and way more objective, calculate or measure windspeed, tweak it and lets go. Would expect something like that from "THE helmet channel"
Is there a noise difference between the EXO-R1 EVO CARBON AIR and the EXO-R1 EVO AIR?
Wich would you recomend for riding a z900 ?
I use a shark helmet on a naked bike. After 70 km/h it's super noisy. I believe earplugs will solve the problem on naked bikes.
I have the Scorpion EXO1400. I bought it for the weight, but later read that carbon helmets tend to be louder than other materials. Its super comfortable but I cant get rid of all the noise. I wear earplugs. I ride a quiet Honda ST1300. It sounds like Im sitting next to a jet taking off all day long. I have no idea what to do about it
Same. I would like to try a Windjammer 2 and see if it helps. I get slightly better results when wearing a Revit balaclava.
Scorpion Exo tech owner here. Extremely loud helmet! I got massive tinnitus / hearing damage from this helmet while I ALWAYS wear hearing protection. Shopping for a Shoei now and never again buying a Scorpion.
@@motodrone84 I had this same experience you've mentioned with hearing damage and tinnitus but from a Shoei RF-SR. Stoopit loud even with ear plugs. I replaced it with a AGV-K6 which made a huge difference but I'd still like to get quieter. I've read numerous places the Schuberth C3 Pro is quieter than the C5 tested here. I wonder if it was in the line up for comparison here?
@@dustytriumph I tried the C3 on in the store. It felt good but havent tested it on the bike. It has a good reputation though.
I ended up buying a Shoei Hornet ADV and it is a huge improvement compared to my Scorpion. The fit is exceptional and it's way more quiet.
I recommend getting custom earplugs fitted. I got mine delivered a week after getting the Shoei and with the new helmet and the earplugs I now am super comfortable sound wise.
@@motodrone84 I saw my ENT audiologist a little over a year ago for custom molded earplugs since no conventional earplugs will stay in my ears even before putting on my helmet. She tried to make molds but I have a really bad case of something called 'collapsing ear canal disease' which means no custom molded earplugs. Even if they were made I'd never get them in. My ears hurt like hell for 3 days after she removed the molds. I was lucky my eardrums were not damaged. I found soft mold-able silicone putty on Amazon that I use with a skull cap over ears under my helmet and that works half decent. Even still....the difference between riding that way with my AGV vs Shoei is like thunder.
Aside from the noise and looking at the specs, would you still recommend the RPHA 91 over the other helmets? And great review
Glad you enjoyed it! The RPHA 91 is more than able to hold it's own, it placed third in our top 10 modular helmets of 2023. I'd recommend watching that video to get a better idea of how it compares to it's competitors!
If anyone disagrees, it’s likely because helmet fit makes a huge difference in perceivable noise. An improper fitting helmet allows much more wind to enter the helmet. The best helmet is the one that fits.
My GT Air 2 is not quiet at all, has a loud whistling noise that I cant seem to get rid of.
My Shoei GT Air 2 is not quiet either.
We can assure you that it doesn't get a lot quieter than the gt air 2 unfortunately. It is not quiet, true, but most other helmets are louder.
I hate mine.
Well disappointed with mine, soooo noisy.
The Rpha 91 is a cold/cool weather helmet only. It’s interior materials don’t allow any ventilation, despite having them. Also, they’re very round shaped (inside).. so most (oval) heads won’t fit well.
I had Scorpion exo r1 carbon. I used it on a sportbike and it got windy about 90mph, but was not disturbing at all. It clwas comfortable for about 3hrs. Ventilation is working really well.. in colder temperature i opened and closed it to see if the difference noticable. This helmet is more user friendly if used in warm weather. Visor is beyond great. Never fogged up once. Also came with tinted visor too. Cardo system fits inside perfectly. Overall is nice helmet
Hi, wasn't the shoei adv hornet x2 good enough for ranking on the adv sector?
I'm planning to get one till I saw this video.
Where does it stand on the adv ranking? Thanks!
Nice video! How do these manufacturers make sure their helmets are able to insulate the noise?
Glad you liked it! It's usually a combination of the outer shell construction and it's pairing with the inner liner.
@@Championhelmets Plus chin curtain and a thick continuous neck roll that seals off and fits snugly around base of skull, neck and jaw line near ear.
Quietest helmet I've ever put on my head was a $100 AGV Q3R way back in the early 90's... nice tight fit for a few rides then perfection.. I'm talking stupid quiet that I'll bet money these helmets come nothing close to.. Sadly every one has gone to putting dumbass ear pockets in their helmets now which equals LOUD.... 😢
Sweet, massive thanks!
The noise is one part, but which one of these helmets can be worn comfortable with glasses?
Agreed, there's more to a helmet than just the sound. These are all high-end helmets, meaning that they should be comfortable with glasses. To be sure, make sure you know what type of helmet shapes fit you best.
Im confused. Everyone that I ask about the scorpion exp r1 evo carbon says, it’s super loud with wind noises.
Numbers don't lie. That is exactly why we do our reviews the way we do. Hope you were able to take away some learnings from is.
Nope. Its loud.@@Championhelmets
I have the LS2 Explorer Carbon. It is the loudest, noisiest, screeching, squeeking helmet on the face of the planet, wearing nothing is better. I was looking at this video to find a replacement and you put it at the top?
Tgank you for sharing your opinion. Please feel free to find a better helmet than you have now. Enlighten us if your numbers come out entirely different.
The Schuberth C3 pro is still excellent with the advantage you can fit any third party comms system.
I have a Shoei GT Air 2 It seems very loud to me.I guess I need some better ear plugs.Thanks for this video : )
Thank you for your comment. If you try out the other helmets, you'll appreciatr your gt-air more 🙂.
I don’t like my gt air II either. I find it to be really loud buffeting. Looking for other options now already even though I just spent $1k on that helmet with the Sena.
@@slothmarathonpromotions2470 The problem is probably related to your bike/windscreen and your height, that is where the buffeting comes from. Try higher or lower windscreen and you will see the difference.
Same issue with me. It is the first helmet I have owned but I can't ride without ear plugs. Feels like a lot of air gets in from the neck/cheeks. Might just be a head shape issue, but it really is loud with me.
@@EfferusZangetsu - I ride a naked bike. Triumph Street Triple 765. I am considering a aftermarket windscreen though.
As always well done on your video! Will there be a best-of affordable / entry level helmet list this year?
Non carbon versions of these helmets louder or quieter?
why are agv helmets recommended so rarely ?
Great video. Is it worth using the Explorer Carbon in normal on-road conditions?
Appreciate it! You can definitely use it on-road. Generally speaking, adventure helmets are like standard touring helmets, just with all the features you need if you do decide to go off-road.
Asphalt is hard on the normal road as on the track.
Great review! Which of the helmets out of this video is 22.06 certified?
Thanks for watching! Every helmet apart from the Shoei GT Air 2 is 22.06 certified!
Hahaha I'm looking for a quiet helmet and I have a scorpion exo R1 carbon. I still get a lot of wind noise.
My Shoei GT Air 2 has a lot of wind noise. As someone already suffering with tinnitus I’m not impressed.
I have the same issue with my Shoei GT Air 2.Its very loud.
@@MotoMarko i noticed its more from the top vent than anything else. Visor closed or cracked open makes almost no difference.
Same. It sucks. I also have tinnitus too. Waste of money. Not sure what helmet to try next.
I’m in the severe T club also.
Let us all know if you find any solutions to noisy helmets.
Will you make another entry level top 10 this year?
Hey Arjen, yes we are! It's releasing within the next 2 to 3 weeks! Be sure to keep that notifications bell on so you don't miss it!
I have a GT Air 2 since 2021 and is loud as hell
are the vents all closed on testing or are they all open?
The vents are open.
wow thanks for the vital info! love this channel@@Championhelmets
What is meant by helmets not making the list because of their average star rating? I just want to know what helmet is the quietest. It could get one star in every other category for all I care, I just want to know which had the lowest decibels.
I’ve had a Scorpion exo R1 for 2 years. Not a quiet helmet at all. Granted I don’t have the carbon version and I ride naked bikes, but my ears will ring just from the wind noise.
Is the RPHA comfortable to wear?
It is, according to our test rider. It has an oval fit, be sure to check what type of fit matches your head shape, as the comfort of a helmet tends to differ per person!
Can wearing a rather loud helmet over long periods of time really affect your hearing?
Absolutely, like every loud sound
Yep - for reference, the agv k3 I think was measured at 102db? Upper limit id generally reccomended to be 90 for shorter periods I believe and decibel scale is logarithmic so "just" 12db louder is insane
Love the comparison! Testing those helmets must be a fun job to have?
Without a doubt, thanks for watching!
Why do you measure the noise on a faired bike with a windscreen?? The results will be complete different for different bikes! Please use a naked bike before you do such recommendations!
The RPHA is very appealing, but I don’t think I’d ever use the chin-bar. Would it still be worth getting?
Good question! I guess it's down to personal preference. Though I'd recommend looking at some full face alternatives to be sure! Maybe check out our Sport-Touring guide!
Fantastic comparison 👍👍👍
And what about naked bikes? I think results won't be the same...
Ruroc?
No arai??
I have an Arai Quantum X it is loud! Seattle to Bend Ore. - Bend to Seattle, my ears still hurt
Shoei RF 1400 ?
Shoei RF 1400 is the NXR 2 in the list. Its called NXR 2 in some countries.
Appreciate the effort this channel puts into applying some actual science into such a subjective topic.
However, the variable is the bike. Notice the wind deflectors on the test bike. Purpose is to limit the wind coming up under the helmet. Those deflectors aren’t available for my bike and that’s where my biggest issue is with wind noise.
Ever helmet should come with a chin curtain, imho.
Or, it’s 2023, should be able to incorporate noise canceling technology into helmets. May be a high end option but I’d take it.
scorpion helmets as quiet ? 😬
Just got back from the shop and a 40 min ride at a 100Kph in the HJC RPHA 91, the cross winds were loads quieter than in my previous HJC FS-GT helmet, I was able to listen to my music at a lot lower volume as I didn't have to compensate for the wind, and, the bass in the music was not killed by the wind. All in all happy with the helmet after 1 ride. I hate the chin strap, it is really annoying that there is no DDs...:((
What did you find was the best way to listen to music? A particular pair of IEM (in ear monitors)?
@@jamesm5192 Hoihoi! So, this is the story:
I've used the Qudelix 5k Bluetooth thingy with Meze Solo and Ikko OH-10 Obsidian...
Meze Solo had better physical sealing, but prefer the OH-10 for sound quality...
Then Changed to the FiiO UTWS3 and later 5 Bluetooth adapters - you can stick your IEMs on them making them true wireless...
The buttons are on the sides of these, and sometimes they get pushed by the helmet turning them off, making them louder etc..., but a lot less times as the helmet is flip-up, so you can put the helmet over them and not pull it through with regular full faced helmets.
I am wearing glasses, and my glasses basically prohibits me to use the UTWS5 adapters because they are getting squeezed into my skull by this helmet with the help of my glasses...
So... Back to the wire... I bought the great FiiO BTR7 and bought the DUNU SA6 MK2 awesome warm and bassy IEM, which comes with a brilliant silicon tip that makes a fucking awesome seal!!!
I can listen to music at low volume so I won't screw up my hearing meanwhile all the details are still there and not getting lost thanks to the noise in the helmet.
I love the combo of the BTR7 and the SA6 MK2 for the bike, and I listen to the SA6 MK2 with the UTWS5 at work.
The BTR7 would need a power bank attached to it for longer rides though! 3+ hours...
The UTWS5 could last 5+ hours... Even more, because when you stop for refueling or for a toilet break, you just shove them back in the case that would charge them while you're doing stuff off the bike.
You can find some good deals for the DUNU SA6 MK2 on head-fi. I think there are 2 for sale at the moment.
I got my FiiO things from Wifimedia.
Oh, I ride an FJR1300 with windscreen extension, so that too helps to keep the helmet quiet. I need it as I am 193cm.
You can find reviews of the BTR7, UTWS5 & DUNU SA6 MK2 on the channels Z Reviews and In-Ear Fetish.
We have similar taste and I don't regret buying anything based on his reviews. I bought about 10 items by now...
I hope this helps.
what about cheap ones that are quiet? under 200 prefferably
Hjc i91?😮 warning! Noise sittning on 1250gsa or standing the same. Old scorpion mush better
We always test the helmet in sitting position so we can compare apples with apples. Thank you for your comment. Don't forget to subscribe.
I just bought the HJC RPHA 91, it’s noisy as all hell! Very disappointed, I much prefer my Schuberth C5 and my Forcite MK1S
1/3 of a video and talking nothing about the helmets. If you want to talk that much, do a longer video
Have you guys ever heard of a brand called SUOMY?! 🙄
How good are their helmets?
@@himangshumahanta5398 I don’t own one bit I guess since the Motogp champion is wearing one they should be ok-ish 😁
I was hoping for a comparison to know exactly how they are.
Jesus, they can't get these more quiet? Why can't we have something that's at least in a not damage your hearing range.
Exo r 1 not worth the money it is not quite and and felt like it was going to pull off my head, at least on a naked bike
Sorry but I call bullshit.. I have a shark spartan and a scorpion exo carbon air
and the scorpion is WAAAY LOUDER than my shark spartan..
I'm sorry but we hope you don't mind that we think our professional sound measurement equipment is more reliable than your hearing. Thank you for your friendly comment though
@@Championhelmets I highly recommend conducting another test utilizing professional sound measurement equipment positioned precisely at the ear level. This additional evaluation will enable you to fully comprehend the extent of the noise produced by the Scorpion Exo R1 Carbon Air helmet. It is evident that this helmet stands out as one of the loudest options available.