ACTIVE Speakers vs PASSIVE Speakers || Which is Right For You??

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 228

  • @WineLad
    @WineLad 5 років тому +58

    you pointed it out... i cannot stop staring at it. Y U DO DIS!!!? XD

    • @KirbyMeetsAudio
      @KirbyMeetsAudio  5 років тому +2

      STOP LOOKING AT MY IMPERFECTIONS!!!! 🖤

    • @antontrubadur299
      @antontrubadur299 5 років тому +4

      I didn’t see until he pointed it out! 🤣 can’t stop looking either

  • @terryhatziieremias
    @terryhatziieremias 2 роки тому

    best video in the category

  • @ipmanoo9250
    @ipmanoo9250 5 років тому +68

    Kirby’s a genius when it comes to speakers, yet still forgot that toilet paper should only be used for his passive speaker.

    • @KirbyMeetsAudio
      @KirbyMeetsAudio  5 років тому +1

      🤣 Thanks for watching!

    • @ipmanoo9250
      @ipmanoo9250 5 років тому

      Kirby Meets Audio for real though love your videos! I’m an aspiring DIY speaker builder and have been following you for some time. Keep it up and lmk if I win best comment so I can finally put together my own speaker with flames or lasers or something 😜

    • @Jmoneysmoothboy
      @Jmoneysmoothboy 4 роки тому

      @@ipmanoo9250 Kirby doesn't know shit about speakers bro...

    • @ShowInTheDark
      @ShowInTheDark 3 роки тому

      @@Jmoneysmoothboy What's the best resource to learn diy speaker building?

  • @JazzyMuggle
    @JazzyMuggle 5 років тому

    I'll be honest, I've been confused on this for a while for the stupidest reason and you've just cleared it up for me! Thanks for the video!

  • @realpdm
    @realpdm 5 років тому

    I didn't notice the white stuff until you pointed it out, now I can't unsee it! It is like those old Sony Trinitron lines. Thanks for sharing as always.

  • @GarrettCrosgrove
    @GarrettCrosgrove 5 років тому +3

    Killing it Kirby!!! I like these videos where you share and explain knowledge to the "newbies" of speakers. Today I learned what the difference between passive and active speakers and I will forever sound smarter talking to my friends about speakers. Haha.
    -Ps. If you send me a kit I will built it!!!

  • @ricomeierringrose2794
    @ricomeierringrose2794 5 років тому +1

    Hi I’m from Denmark.
    Really Like your videos, I’ve really learned a lot from watching them. Keep up the good work 👍🏼

  • @boominc0420
    @boominc0420 5 років тому +4

    I consistently like your vids and haven't missed one in a long time. Keep up with the good videos.

  • @JonathanSias
    @JonathanSias 5 років тому +1

    I love where this is going! Can we get more visual cues of what the heck you are talking about? People like me need them.

  • @grupoaranzamusic
    @grupoaranzamusic 3 роки тому +1

    I've considered switching over to active speakers, but just to think about all the extra time it would take me to set up by hooking up more electrical cords and extension cords, it just doesn't seem convenient to me. My current system is pretty old fashioned but is much quicker to set up, so if I'm ever 5 minutes late to a gig, it won't be much of a stuggle.

  • @peterjmcgee4680
    @peterjmcgee4680 5 років тому +1

    enjoyed the show doing my own speaker building repair work for many years now I like the way you explained things from normal people can understand you have to be a high-tech engineer to understand a lot of people just go on and on and on but you are precise and you explained very quickly which I like

    • @KirbyMeetsAudio
      @KirbyMeetsAudio  5 років тому

      Thanks! I try to do just that. Thanks for watching!

  • @ELMtreeProductions
    @ELMtreeProductions 5 років тому +1

    Your channel first introduced me to the concept of DIY audio 2 years ago, and now I'm about to design my 4th pair of speakers

    • @KirbyMeetsAudio
      @KirbyMeetsAudio  5 років тому

      That’s amazing! Thanks so much for watching!

    • @ELMtreeProductions
      @ELMtreeProductions 5 років тому

      @@KirbyMeetsAudio Thanks for the great videos! I've always wondered, what's that little bundle of white cloth looking stuff you always use to apply finish?

  • @sprig6043
    @sprig6043 4 роки тому

    Learnt something within the first 2mins. Love the straight talking.

  • @UtkarshAmitabhSrivastava
    @UtkarshAmitabhSrivastava 5 років тому +3

    Just realized that you are so close to 200K subs, been following your since I watched your cube speaker video.

    • @KirbyMeetsAudio
      @KirbyMeetsAudio  5 років тому +1

      Dang! That was a long time ago! Thanks so much for watching 🙏

  • @rodneycottrell7750
    @rodneycottrell7750 4 місяці тому

    Thank you Kirby! This video was perfect; just what I needed. I'm building a vinyl collection and trying to decide on turntable and speakers. Looking forward to more of your informative videos! RC in Tennessee!

  • @michaelporter4669
    @michaelporter4669 5 років тому

    I find your videos very professional also no one comes close to your information.

  • @misael2649
    @misael2649 4 роки тому

    This guy is a gem. I'm glad for the find

  • @steelpaladin
    @steelpaladin 5 років тому +1

    Keep the content coming! I look forward to seeing your videos pop up in my feed!

  • @catlord69
    @catlord69 4 роки тому +1

    TLDR was awesome

  • @siniteanrazvan3298
    @siniteanrazvan3298 2 роки тому

    This did more trouble than good, thanks

  • @fnkyfreak
    @fnkyfreak 5 років тому +5

    love your vids.
    only suggestion i have for this one is that a couple of diagrams or flow charts may have helped.
    look forward to the next one :)

  • @TheBdm106
    @TheBdm106 5 років тому +3

    Love your speaker insight and want to see some more builds as you have time!

    • @KirbyMeetsAudio
      @KirbyMeetsAudio  5 років тому +1

      Thanks! Builds are in the workz. Thanks for watching!

  • @tylercall358
    @tylercall358 5 років тому

    I feel like you have become what I wish I could have been, I love the videos. Its inspirational on a level I cant describe. Thank you for taking the time to be so giving too.

  • @mrezuniga80
    @mrezuniga80 4 роки тому +2

    Kirby! New Subscriber here! Thank you for all the good info!

  • @JamesEscobar
    @JamesEscobar 5 років тому

    Came across a channel trying to explain the mysteries of the DAC! It was boring, lackluster and the guy was trying to hard. I recommended your take which is quick to the point and much more entertaining, and mentioned they may want to pick up some of your speakers!

  • @willbrink
    @willbrink Рік тому

    Active speakers are the future. Some audiophiles resist that reality, but matching the amp(s) to the drivers will yield the best audio.

  • @davidperry4013
    @davidperry4013 3 роки тому +1

    I love my Q Acoustics 3020i. The performance is just amazing for the price. I prefer speakers that require external amplification because I am willing to sacrifice convenience to get a more natural warmer sound from the ability to control the amplification. I have a vintage early 1980s receiver and when I hooked it up to the pair of q acoustics 3020is, I got a sound that is quite accurate yet, warm and rich. Someday, I would probably get Q acoustics concept 500s and a Primaluna vacuum tube integrated amplifier. Then play some offbeat psytrance music on the new system.

  • @monsterGLL
    @monsterGLL 4 роки тому +1

    You didn't mention that good active speakers have the crossover before the amps. Which gives you much more control over the drivers. And most good active speakers have one amp per driver.

  • @DVZNMedia
    @DVZNMedia 5 років тому +1

    I've done the tp thing before and didn't realize I had it in my beard through a whole video, as for the video...great work as always.

  • @davidperry4013
    @davidperry4013 4 роки тому

    I love my passive speakers specifically the Q Acoustics 3020i paired with my vintage Pioneer A9 non-switching integrated amplifier. I love my vintage Pioneer class AB integrated amplifier and it's staying with me for life. Such a blissfully warm and natural sound with visceral bass and sparkling crisp highs with my current setup. Playing "Trappin in Japan 16" on that setup gave me a very immersive and euphoric music listening experience.

  • @justins.1283
    @justins.1283 5 років тому +1

    I like my passive speakers because I'm always switching them out depending on my source material my mood and what I'm listening to at the time

  • @daddydominguez7822
    @daddydominguez7822 3 роки тому

    Thanks got some info now very helpful

  • @meltedfusitediy6625
    @meltedfusitediy6625 5 років тому

    You know us to well, just kidding, i find your build videos therapeutic.

  • @TruckerGlass
    @TruckerGlass 4 роки тому +1

    Don't forget noise with powered speakers. I think powered speakers are good for stand alone purposes studio work and live bands. Passive for everything else.

  • @gabrielrios7466
    @gabrielrios7466 5 років тому

    This really help me making some choices

  • @jotasgasco
    @jotasgasco 5 років тому

    i´m learning to build speakers and you are the one that got me inspired!

  • @stephenbrowne33
    @stephenbrowne33 5 років тому +1

    I wonder how practical a set of active tower speakers would be? Not sure there are components available to do one but it would be cool.

    • @scottlowell493
      @scottlowell493 5 років тому +1

      There are active towers out there and painfully expensive. ATC, Meridian etc.

    • @KirbyMeetsAudio
      @KirbyMeetsAudio  5 років тому +1

      I'm thinking of making some towers with active subs for my home theater mains. Thanks for watching!

  • @FriedGames
    @FriedGames 5 років тому

    I had to pause the video at the beginning when you said "never connected" with the picture of the Sonos speaker. I was laughing my head off. 😁🤣👍

  • @argelatlarge
    @argelatlarge 2 роки тому

    Thanks. Very informative.

  • @tonytiger2004
    @tonytiger2004 5 років тому

    Great video quick and simple explanation. But informative. Keep them coming!

  • @dannydessert5147
    @dannydessert5147 5 років тому +6

    An interesting video would be on preamps for active speakers that lack Bluetooth, DAC...

  • @marcelkress1355
    @marcelkress1355 5 років тому

    Really nice video! Nice to get all the pros and cons up against each other!

  • @charlesmchenry4738
    @charlesmchenry4738 2 роки тому

    Thanks for the information

  • @salamelvisual6270
    @salamelvisual6270 5 років тому

    working with hk audio L5 115 active and the plug'n'play is realy cool when you dont have time to install

  • @dalem444
    @dalem444 5 років тому

    Great video. You answered a lot of questions I had.

  • @HongKongGhost
    @HongKongGhost 5 років тому

    can you talk about evaluating the sound from home built speakers? I made some ported passive speakers but I would like an objective evaluation of their sound.

  • @joshuasagraves9594
    @joshuasagraves9594 5 років тому +1

    This is a wonderful video explanation. Thank you!

  • @gregorijs3kivi
    @gregorijs3kivi 5 років тому

    The 4 way speakers you mentioned (and showed a picture of) are the radiotehnika s400m. They are made in Latvia. Radiotehnika used to be the best speaker manufacturer un the ussr. I have the older s400 (with diferent speaker baskers and surroumds) and they are simply awesome speakers for the money.

  • @NicholasGreenwood
    @NicholasGreenwood 5 років тому

    One thing that I don't see people talking about is that some (how many? I don't know) active/powered speakers have "anti-shock" glue slathered all over the amplifier's PCB so the components don't move with the vibration of the enclosure. However, the stuff can break down over time and become conductive (!!!), shorting out components and causing burnout/failure. This is EXACTLY what happened with my Mackie CR5BT monitors.
    Check out "EEVblog #1072 - KRK Rokit 6 Studio Monitor Speaker Repair" to see what this looks like. Horrifying to think that you could spend $500+ on active monitors with a kiss of death inside.

  • @xerogear
    @xerogear 5 років тому +2

    Cool video 👍. Learned a lot. I think I would go with an active speaker w/Bluetooth and rechargeable battery, so I can take with me.
    Keep up the good work and look forward to your next video.

  • @andrei5897
    @andrei5897 3 роки тому

    Awesome dude as always very informative

  • @JonathanRansom
    @JonathanRansom 5 років тому +2

    Why can't we have both? Maybe passive to active with the flip of a switch?

    • @JonathanRansom
      @JonathanRansom 5 років тому +1

      PS: You have a few dingle berries on your face.

    • @asunavk69
      @asunavk69 5 років тому +1

      Some PA speakers now have in the back panel for bluethooth and other active things in the back and still maintain their passive for inputs also

  • @MaykTime
    @MaykTime 3 роки тому

    Thank you bro for the knowledge that you shared.

  • @MrJMagoo
    @MrJMagoo 5 років тому +1

    Kirby needs TP for his port hole!

  • @penguinmonk7661
    @penguinmonk7661 7 місяців тому

    Thank you, this was a lovely video and precisely answered my questions concisely, I won't subscribe since I only don that for channels I serial watch or friends channels, but I want you to know how much you helped me, have a great day :3.

  • @laala9147
    @laala9147 3 роки тому

    Can you put some research resources into the info box pls? Xx

  • @jakedodd5000
    @jakedodd5000 5 років тому +1

    I love your videos ever since the first one hope to see more good content 👍

  • @Skyprey
    @Skyprey 3 роки тому

    I would love a diy Build I could order from you with floor speakers one for each side of my tv 😊

  • @jakob1379
    @jakob1379 5 років тому

    love your speakers, would love more intriguing designs like the geometric cnc'ed one!

  • @jaredmonsen3770
    @jaredmonsen3770 5 років тому

    Excellent video, keep up the great work!

  • @mortagom
    @mortagom 5 років тому

    Great explanation. I do 99% of my listening on my computer, so Active Sub/Monitors is what I use.

  • @dunbarad
    @dunbarad 5 років тому

    Didn’t even notice the toilet paper. Thanks for the refresher on speaker basics.

  • @theElderberryFarmer
    @theElderberryFarmer 5 років тому

    Good info, Kirby! Thanks for sharing.

  • @vasileiostsalkos6174
    @vasileiostsalkos6174 5 років тому +1

    The problem is that YOU mentioned the problem with the paper on your face. Personally I didn’t notice it at all. BUT...
    Do not ever forget: you can wipe the paper pieces of your face, but you CANNOT wipe the passion for the speakers off your face.
    This is why we are all here subconsciously. Trust me on that.
    An excellent video once more. Thank you for reminding us that we are not alone in this planet. There are others like us who truly CARE about sound...

  • @bradisley517
    @bradisley517 5 років тому

    What about partially active speakers using active bass and passive mid and high frequency?

  • @GustavCarl17
    @GustavCarl17 5 років тому +1

    Hi, I’m here for the toilet paper giveaway.
    Great vids 👍Keep the content coming

  • @rk47_beats
    @rk47_beats 3 роки тому +1

    Wow I literally made a beat with the same sample in the background 😂😂😂

  • @sunwukong8069
    @sunwukong8069 7 місяців тому

    now I cannot unsee it

  • @babyflurryheart9114
    @babyflurryheart9114 5 років тому +1

    You ar the best

  • @LilyTequila008
    @LilyTequila008 4 роки тому

    Thanks explains a lot man appreciate it

  • @t1mm3h
    @t1mm3h 5 років тому

    Kirby got out of bed. But little did he realize before filming his clip of the day that the bed bugs had an orgie on his face.
    The clip turned out nice, but the tp was the shining star this time!

  • @ej-mo5xz
    @ej-mo5xz 5 років тому +1

    Here's some more love for ya brother, also have you thought of making a passive sound bar that would take up both channels on an amp with 2 full range woofers and a tweeter on each side?

  • @gurratell7326
    @gurratell7326 4 роки тому

    Fyi, the definition of an active speaker is that it have active crossover. That's it. Thou in fairness that mostly leads to that it also have built in amps, but amps till don't have anything to do with it being active or not :)

  • @bentleyalder5492
    @bentleyalder5492 4 роки тому

    This was great thank you for the information!

  • @colinw2093
    @colinw2093 5 років тому +1

    You should start doing speaker reviews, like the newer Bluetooth speakers and maybe like towers or something great video btw👍

  • @isaacdelgado5169
    @isaacdelgado5169 3 роки тому

    I am an 18 year old DJ and have 2 non powered loudspeakers 800 watts peak. Also have a 3000 watt amplifier and I am looking into 1000 watt JBL EON 610s. I dont have a subwoofer right now with my 2 non powered loudspeakers. Would it be better to just get new JBL EON 610s to replace my current speakers or just get one subwoofer to be with my loudspeakers?

  • @lawrencemaithyamutie4013
    @lawrencemaithyamutie4013 4 роки тому +1

    Do a turntable setup one day

  • @richarddegannes2928
    @richarddegannes2928 4 роки тому

    Kirby, Which is better ATC SCM 100SL Active or SCM passive 100SL vs Harbeth 40.2 40th anniversary speaker?

  • @nayyyythan
    @nayyyythan 5 років тому

    Great video mate

  • @crowcore
    @crowcore 4 роки тому

    Is an internal PC sound card like the Asus Essence STX II considered being an amp, that can therefore drive passive speakers?

  • @beardington3rd
    @beardington3rd 5 років тому

    Kirby re-enacting his acne years, you said on Insta you wanted a roast...this is the best I could think of.

  • @trobolina2
    @trobolina2 5 років тому

    Free stuff for a comment? sure!
    Great videos btw

  • @diebackmischung503
    @diebackmischung503 2 роки тому

    I want to buy those wharfedale diamond 12.2s but idk what av receiver I need Also Ill use them with my tv which has an optical port aux and hdmis ofc lol

  • @Cheechmmksl
    @Cheechmmksl 5 років тому +1

    Whats your favorite speaker brand, mine are JBL and harman/kardon

    • @simonb.1962
      @simonb.1962 5 років тому +1

      B&W or AR, for amplifiers Quad or NAD

  • @umbertofurlan501
    @umbertofurlan501 4 роки тому

    are there any speaker that are passive and active at the same time? i would like to have speakers that i can connect to my tube preamplifier and either that i can use in bluetooth mode when i need to listen them in other places

  • @bonzaimolly
    @bonzaimolly 4 роки тому

    Answered questions I was thinking about, cheers 👍👍.. keep it up. What do you think of the tannoy 635 D50's? Iv been rocking a set for the past 10 years and love them! Smooth warm sound.

  • @seandoherty2067
    @seandoherty2067 5 років тому

    Hey Kirby, was wondering if you could review the SOUNDBOKS 2 or 3. They’re expensive and wondering what you’re expertise has to say about the product. Thanks!

  • @aikonomic
    @aikonomic 5 років тому +7

    Hmm. So, isn't it possible to combine both active and passive? Take an active speaker, design it such that with the flick of a switch (or two), disconnect the drivers from the internal components and connect them to external amps. And just like that, bada-bing bada-boom, you've got yourself some Pactive Speakers. I call dibs on that name. Pactive®™

    • @Billy123bobzzz
      @Billy123bobzzz 5 років тому +1

      They have been making Pactive speakers for years⛔️

    • @aikonomic
      @aikonomic 5 років тому

      @@Billy123bobzzz I see what you're doing.

  • @nofacenoid2367
    @nofacenoid2367 5 років тому

    Hey Kirby, nice work Bro :)

  • @redrum666
    @redrum666 3 роки тому

    same brand speakers - whats louder? passive or active???

  • @DMonZ1988
    @DMonZ1988 5 років тому +2

    thanks for the advice Kirby. i've got some beautiful active speakers that i love, but you've been inspiring me to build some for a long time now. there's just one thing i need... :-D
    have you ever tried building sound optimised speakers using exciters? i bought some after watching tech ingredients' video but then he went and changed the plans and i didn't buy the additional drivers....and been hoping to make some kind of hybrid setup since then.
    it would be really really interesting to see your take on it, or exciter project in general.

    • @KirbyMeetsAudio
      @KirbyMeetsAudio  5 років тому +1

      I haven’t done much with exciters yet. I know Nick over on 123Toid has done a few projects with it. Maybe I’ll look into it! Thanks for watching!

  • @darensweeney5925
    @darensweeney5925 4 роки тому

    Nice video, Kirby. I really like your approach to your videos. You provide knowledge without pomposity or blathering on and on and on about irrelevant things. ) BTW, would you consider making some videos about tricks to using your equipment? For example, If I have an amp that doesn't have a 'sub out," and a sub that has RCA inputs but no speaker inputs, how can i hook up the amp and the sub? Alternatively, are there amps that are 2.1 and completely separate the frequencies that go to satellites and those going to the sub? (Is this what they mean by "low pass filter?) thanks. )

  • @SvEnNeR1988
    @SvEnNeR1988 5 років тому

    great video

  • @janeth4943
    @janeth4943 2 роки тому

    Help me! I bought an HCD-MX500i because it has a CDs and an iPod input already built in, but now I need speakers ( didn’t come with any). I figured I could buy some later. I have never seen these types of connections for the speakers. What kind of speakers go with a 4.2 mm connection?

  • @Porokai
    @Porokai 3 місяці тому

    Hey kirby it's been 4 years. how are you doing?

  • @marusoplays
    @marusoplays 4 роки тому

    I love speakers!

  • @lilyvaneersel8222
    @lilyvaneersel8222 4 роки тому

    If i buy an active subwoofer like the HS 8S, what kind of speaker should i plug it on it? Active or passive and why please? I REALLY need to know that =x

  • @johnbiggs9561
    @johnbiggs9561 2 роки тому

    For me the biggest benefit of active speakers is the sound quality. If you take passive speakers and convert them to active with decent amplifiers and crossover, the sound improvement is extraodinary. This was done a lot back in the 80's. Drums and cymbals have an attack I have never heard in a passive speaker. Sure, cheap active speakers use cheap components and cheap amps. But get a decent pair (like Meridian), with quality inbuilt amps and the sound is amazing. But even with Meridians my preference is for non-digital crossovers as I am analogue fan.

  • @963prince
    @963prince 4 роки тому

    great videos Kirby always check what you have to say first then surfing the internet, one question though, might sound a bit silly. drivers from active speakers can be used with different more modern amplifiers boards right. and same withe the passive speaker..thank you

  • @arvestigen53
    @arvestigen53 5 років тому

    Great video, Kirby! I got a pair of Focal CMS50, active studio monitors, with 5'' woofers. They are great mid-low budget speakers for studio-setups. They come with å built in high-pass filter, shelving and notch aswell. They tend to be a liiiittle bright some times though.
    As for your toilet paper face:
    I would recomend air condition or a fan as a passive way to prevent sweat.
    If there is no way out but active removal, I would recomend a towel for this job.
    Towels absorbe the sweat and does not leave leftover-towel on you face.
    If you are on a budget you might wanna use your hand, but the result may vary as there are no absorbtion in the hand. It could even have the opposite effect.
    There are many other ways to remove sweat, so do your research before buying sweat removal gear.
    Have a niiiiiice day!! :)