Great video. This helped me decide to invest all my saved general scrolls into Mu Guiying. I know many players make a big deal about Siege HP. This is mostly relevant in big siege surviving a defending Siege attack. Otherwise, I think attack is still a very important factor. One other thing to take into consideration. I think Pallas is a little underrated (when compared to Hunyadi and Kleos) because players are overlooking those Siege HP Debuffs. If you are attacking a player with T11 siege, The siege debuffs will affect their T13 and above siege much greater than an equivalent attack increase on your general. Just my thoughts.
It also depends on your sub city generals, if you're debuffing the enemy siege attack fully the extra HP and defense will give you more bang for your buck. Or if you debuff the enemy defense then your attack stat will be more important.
I'd value HP and Defense higher than what you mentioned only because it's EXTREMELY difficult to debuff. Most people using siege will be debuffed in half for attack, so the delta between net attack (buff - debuff) won't be too drastic compared to the defender unless the keep levels are drastically different.
Mu NOT taking the attack book is a deal breaker for me. QUESTION: I thought I knew the answer, but now am questioning myself. In a typical MAIN and ASSISTANT combination, does a skill book on one general apply the same buff to the other general? I think the answer is yes, so you end up building an entire "PACKAGE" using the buff slots from both Main and Assistant generals. Let me know please.
I don't understand the question. The main and assistant generals buffs are applied to the army. So you can have a main generals skill, x3 skill books on them, assistant general skill, x3 skill books on them, and those buffs are applied to the troops. If you put your main and assistant generals on the wall you can see if any of the skills books or debuffs are inactive, or you could also use this website evonyguidewiki.com/en/assistant_general-en/
My Siege preference (though I'm not a huge user because I'm not really experieced with Siege compared to the other troop types) is *Gunther* (with _Behemoth King_ to fully activate his special skill) with Mu Guiying* Assist. I'm not sure *Gunther* was launched at the time of the video (I think he came out in the same Event or a few weeks after *Mu Guiying*
I did some testing and the only scenario I could confirm leading the army to attack skills weren't active was when defending the main city, I couldn't test it for reinforcing so maybe it doesn't work there. I don't think the universal buff is enough to save him tbh
I’m fairly new to the game… I have zucca, I was wondering about Isabella 1 for her 10% march size in specialties? She does have like a 60 attack, as an assistant, she is not able to use her dragon so I don’t think that 10% will count. But even so with Zucca’s 20% that is a 30% march size. What do you think?
So there's a few things, first is that realistically you won't be able to get zucca to the full five red stars without spending some serious $$$. Isabella isn't very good and I would definitely avoid her. If I was you I would try to get Ulysses S Grant (from the tavern) and farm him. For assistant you could use Zucca until you get someone better for assistant.
I use Grant for Siege. He's maxed out on Sprcialty including Battle Testing 10. I have his power at 5.8 mil, Plantagenet gear 3 pieces. 3 stars. He's is really great.
I'm not going to do the calculations for every scenario with every amount of money spent, that would take way to long. Instead you get the best premium general with unlimited $$$ and the best free general with no $$$, for the in between my tools are available for anyone to use.
Covenant is really easy to complete for free.. get the stones in daily activity and the corresponding generals cultivation. Maybe for new players but over time you will have at least 1 copy of most general in the game.
Great video. This helped me decide to invest all my saved general scrolls into Mu Guiying. I know many players make a big deal about Siege HP. This is mostly relevant in big siege surviving a defending Siege attack. Otherwise, I think attack is still a very important factor. One other thing to take into consideration. I think Pallas is a little underrated (when compared to Hunyadi and Kleos) because players are overlooking those Siege HP Debuffs. If you are attacking a player with T11 siege, The siege debuffs will affect their T13 and above siege much greater than an equivalent attack increase on your general. Just my thoughts.
It also depends on your sub city generals, if you're debuffing the enemy siege attack fully the extra HP and defense will give you more bang for your buck. Or if you debuff the enemy defense then your attack stat will be more important.
Great video! Thank you. I received 310 fragments from the last event of the new siege general so this was very helpful. I will use her.
Mu pairs with Teach also. Which makes a very solid 2 way rein/attk general combo
She’s the new Historical General Summoning General, with the Glory Tokens.
Mu as main and kleos as assistant are untouchable when it comes to siege pairs because of Mu’s covenant
I'd value HP and Defense higher than what you mentioned only because it's EXTREMELY difficult to debuff.
Most people using siege will be debuffed in half for attack, so the delta between net attack (buff - debuff) won't be too drastic compared to the defender unless the keep levels are drastically different.
that's true
new siege gen from the current event you can get with both glory & premium tokens.
Mu NOT taking the attack book is a deal breaker for me.
QUESTION: I thought I knew the answer, but now am questioning myself. In a typical MAIN and ASSISTANT combination, does a skill book on one general apply the same buff to the other general? I think the answer is yes, so you end up building an entire "PACKAGE" using the buff slots from both Main and Assistant generals. Let me know please.
I don't understand the question. The main and assistant generals buffs are applied to the army. So you can have a main generals skill, x3 skill books on them, assistant general skill, x3 skill books on them, and those buffs are applied to the troops. If you put your main and assistant generals on the wall you can see if any of the skills books or debuffs are inactive, or you could also use this website evonyguidewiki.com/en/assistant_general-en/
My Siege preference (though I'm not a huge user because I'm not really experieced with Siege compared to the other troop types) is *Gunther* (with _Behemoth King_ to fully activate his special skill) with Mu Guiying* Assist. I'm not sure *Gunther* was launched at the time of the video (I think he came out in the same Event or a few weeks after *Mu Guiying*
I have a newer video with his stats
Thank you very much for your videos and sharing your spreadsheets they are very informative. Are you going to also share the sieges Gen spreadsheet?
Here's the link: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1eA8MLlXp72pxQyuxn1cCK_wJELMJE0kUbk10Gi_2Muc/edit?usp=sharing
How does Gunthur compare to Mu? Will you provide an update on this anytime soon? Thanks in advance. I love your channel. :)
I'm working on that right now, should be a few hours
Hi. Any update on the Gunther comparisons?
@@555holg Here's the video for it ua-cam.com/video/JjMnIjGDSjk/v-deo.html\
You can’t get Mason Weaver anymore
Teach has a universal buff, not just attack. He’s versatile
I did some testing and the only scenario I could confirm leading the army to attack skills weren't active was when defending the main city, I couldn't test it for reinforcing so maybe it doesn't work there. I don't think the universal buff is enough to save him tbh
I’m fairly new to the game… I have zucca, I was wondering about Isabella 1 for her 10% march size in specialties? She does have like a 60 attack, as an assistant, she is not able to use her dragon so I don’t think that 10% will count. But even so with Zucca’s 20% that is a 30% march size. What do you think?
So there's a few things, first is that realistically you won't be able to get zucca to the full five red stars without spending some serious $$$. Isabella isn't very good and I would definitely avoid her. If I was you I would try to get Ulysses S Grant (from the tavern) and farm him. For assistant you could use Zucca until you get someone better for assistant.
I use Grant for Siege. He's maxed out on Sprcialty including Battle Testing 10. I have his power at 5.8 mil, Plantagenet gear 3 pieces. 3 stars. He's is really great.
Left out Dragon attached.
Hey I think the new guy siege general from today and the girl assistant are the current best. Can you confirm please.
I'll run their stats in a few days, currently I'm busy with finals for college
How about Ghengis Kahn as assistant because of his overall 31% march size increase?
I wouldn't recommend him, his damage would be fine, but once you add a march size book into the mix he falls off.
I see that you have Mu Guiying with 5% march size but if you max her covenant, you get an additional 5%. Do you take that into account?
She has 13% total march size. 8% from her 8th star, and 5% from her covenant. Look at the "Skill 5" and "Coven + Skin" rows on my spreadsheet.
i have pallas and mu ...for now.
So, Skill Books buffs and debuffs don't work on assistant general rolls?
😢😢😢
I how I'm wrong!
Skill books, base skill, covenant, skins, and specialty are all active for assistants
Mu and Hunyadi aren’t compatible. Hunyadi and Pallas are compatible.
Well compare with Theodosius I .. now .. i think he is one of the strongest
Don't go for theoretical possible best with unlimited money to spend. Like completing the covenant is very difficult
I'm not going to do the calculations for every scenario with every amount of money spent, that would take way to long. Instead you get the best premium general with unlimited $$$ and the best free general with no $$$, for the in between my tools are available for anyone to use.
Covenant is really easy to complete for free.. get the stones in daily activity and the corresponding generals cultivation. Maybe for new players but over time you will have at least 1 copy of most general in the game.
There should be at least 2 version, one for free to play, one for whale. Between everything will be cover
@@rubelleo my original siege video covers both scenarios. For free to play Ulysses is the best.
Mu can't take the attack book