How come the unicorns can't use their magic, but the pegasi can fly? I'm sensing the "no unicorn magic" thing was just made up on the spot by the Mayor to mess with Twilight.
If Ponyville was started by earth ponies, the only ones that actually need the snow and rain, how would they make it? The episode shows you need pegasi to move the clouds so did earth ponies just starve because of dead crops until pegasi got there?
OMG YES I NOTICED THAT TOO! How come it says "started by earth ponies" because HONESTLY!? Thats just racist against unicorns. Also did NO ONE NOTICE THAT IF UR AN EARTH PONY WHO LEVITATES U DONT NEED PEGASI IN THE FIRST PLACE? XD
If ponies don't die of old age, then what happened to Applejack's parents? I think I'll let the MLP Wiki speak for itself. "The whereabouts of Applejack's parents are touched on in the episode Apple Family Reunion. At the end of the episode, the shot fades to a view of Sweet Apple Acres as two shooting stars fly through the sky. The shooting stars are meant to represent Applejack's parents according to storyboard artist Sabrina Alberghetti. Lauren Faust had previously mentioned that the whereabouts of Applejack's parents has not been planned, and that the show is unlikely to mention that they've passed away. Faust stated she wanted that to be the case."
You forgot one: Twilight says that for hundreds of years they haven't used magic, that would mean Granny Smith is hundreds of years old sense she was there when ponyville was formed.
Cinemare Sins: I swear Pinkie Pie knows we're watching! Me: True, and it would be funny if Twilight got into danger and Applejack says, "We gotta save Twilight, she might die!" And Pinkie says, "Oh silly, Twilight can't die! The viewers would hate us!" Staring at the camera. And later she presses her face up to the camera and says hello.
my fav fourth wall break from her is when after hearing someone is going to "buy all the cake" she turns to the camera, grabs it, shakes it while shouting "he's buying all the cake!" one of my two or three most fav fourth wall breaks
+Doctor Whooves ^^ Lyra's quest to see hands led her to study many a cursed and forbidden tome of dark magic, until she began to see beyond reality itself.
+LittleshyFiM An added sin for you, sir: -The tradition of Winter Wrap Up partially means using no magic, when magic could've done the job in about HALF THE TIME. But I get that it's tradition, but the first Winter Wrap Up could've, once again, been done in half the time had they used magic, hence changing the tradition. +1 -Also, shouldn't the whole Winter Wrap Up thing only be done by the Weather Pegasi? They are responsible for the weather, after all
46# if earth ponies started winter wrap up.....howed they clear the sky? And if the pegesi were flying almost the hole episode isn't that breaking the tradition!?!?!?!?
I was kinda thinking it was more of a sibling relationship, since they were both really young when they met and grew up together Now the question remains, how is Spike still considered a baby?? Like, Twilight was an elementary kid at most when spike was born, and she's an adult now... So how is Spike still a baby?!
Just for the hell of it I went on Google translate and put the lyrics of Winter Wrap-up through Japanese, Russian, Swahili, Greek, and Hindi and then translated them back to English. This is What I ended up with: Three months and the cold winter break Wonderful. We are playing warm and time hoofsies work at home. However, we are so many options we can grow cold and the food would be safe. I am too old for that, but I love the shoes. I have come to welcome spring And all the heat and the green Farewell, then, whenever he came We cleanse this winter. How can I do? I am new. If you want to pony? How to include any magic? I do not know! Short winter wrapped in winter! To finish off our hearts Short winter wrapped in winter! This spring, for tomorrow! This spring, for tomorrow! project "Pegasus begins All purpose cleaning dark sky The sun shines! We snow white clouds melting will increase. Sun, light, beauty and feel the heat before! Short winter wrapped in winter! To finish off our hearts Short winter wrapped in winter! This spring, for tomorrow Chemical summary of the cold winter! This spring, for tomorrow This spring, for tomorrow! Hibernate MO Ice and snow, according to the. Everyone sleepyhead wakes I like a mouse, quiet! We help them collect food, I can fix the house down. We southern birds welcome back So I will build their families! Short winter wrapped in winter! To finish off our hearts Short winter wrapped in winter! This spring, for tomorrow Short winter wrapped in winter! This spring, for tomorrow This spring, for tomorrow! It is not easy to clear land; Small plant our seeds. And you, good service, Any comments on it. Stem, apples, carrots and celery flower color! Need a lot of work for us; Just do it! Short winter wrapped in winter! To finish off our hearts Short winter wrapped in winter! This spring, for tomorrow Short winter wrapped in winter! This spring, for tomorrow! This spring, for tomorrow! Now I'm sure you all know, You need to find my place And I support with all my heart, I was faced with a difficult job. How I can do anything magic For pony country? I should be Today, I try to Today, I try to Short winter wrapped in winter! To finish off our hearts Short winter wrapped in winter! This spring, for tomorrow Short winter wrapped in winter! This spring, for tomorrow This spring, for tomorrow This spring, for tomorrow!
This day Aria: [Queen tubes] This day will be perfect Once, I dreamed of when I was a kid, Editing gather 'Round Tell me, please, my clothes look good You do not know what is wrong! [Princess Cadance] On this day, would be perfect Once, I dreamed of when I was a kid, But instead of cake All my friends are celebrating Wedding bells I can call me ...... [Queen tubes] I'm not very concerned about the dress I will not enter into any cake Oath, I lied when I said anytime I want Nevertheless, I do not like it at all No, I love the groom In my heart there is a place But again I want to have all my [Princess Cadance] You must escape before it's too late Find a way to save the day I hope that I will if I have to lie "I'm afraid I can not lose For those who want to use it I do not care, love and care every day. " In the end, I love these two OH groom All my thoughts are consumed Oh, beautiful shining armor, I will have in the near future [Queen tubes] Finally, the time has come For me it is a happy wife [Princess Cadance] Oh, and not a wedding Eventually marriage fraud Looking'll ... [Queen CHRYSALIS] ... my, my. [This evil laughs]
Regarding the sin with the bell and rope system they devised in the end of the episode for animal waking... sure, it probably would've taken some time to make it up (more than waking the animals would), but it means they can use it for the next winters; a mere pull of the rope would be enough to finish the task, now that the system is already established.
Yes, I can believe Twilight organizes her twigs that fast. On another episode, to get Twilight's attention from her book, she pushed an inkwell that was across the room one inch out of place. Even as they spoke, Twilight walked over, and nudged it back.
olivia cook Spike, At Your Service. Spike goes to tell Twilight he'll be working for Applejack from now on, and she gives him an "uh huh" without looking up. Rarity comes by later, figures out Twilight's in her own world, and nudges an inkwell out of place to get her attention. As Rarity and Twilight talk about what's going on, Twilight trots over to the other desk, pushes the inkwell back, and trots back. Absolutely adorable.
@@pinkajou656 I've been away from this fandom for years. You replied to a comment I posted when I was a middle school child brony - I'm now 19 and I might just re-watch this series just for nostalgia, thank you. It's been far too long.
0:09 is that supposed to be a flower pot? 0:12 you can see twilight's fore-mane sticking out of her head. 0:15 floating scarves. 0:21 the third scarf disappears but reappears at 0:29. 0:29 the water in the painting doesn't reflect well at all you can't make out anything except the tree and the butterfly. 0:31 ponies wings are on her legs ( the pony flying by raindrops) 0:42 nightmare fuel. 0:54 her eye brow disconnected from her eye a bit. 0:59 grey ponies face,other colt's faces. 1:02 It probably also doesn't help you mood much to have a false cutiemark and prosthetic LIMBS. 1:18 rarity's aura. 2:30 that bird reminds me of the poke'mon swanna. 2:33 daisy is a frozen ice skater. apple bumpkin decided to help ponyville's winter wrap up.
As a HUGE fan of Cinema Sins, and a slight fan of the show, I really have to congratulate you on a spot-on parody! Everything about this, from the sound effects, the counters, and the "feel" of it feels like a legitimately high quality parody.
i've got one more. you said Rarity is using magic and breaking tradition, right? well, that's not even her own magical aura! Rarity's magic is blue, not purple. purple is Twilight's. Maybe she WAS using magic after all!
Oh, of course, and I remember that being pretty prevalent in Static Shock at least once (man, I loved that show). It's just that this is kinda downplayed in this episode as "Oh, unicorns can't use their magic because tradition. ...Oh well, I guess?" They do sort of accept it in-universe, though, and still manage to have fun with the clean-up, so it's probably not that bad at all...just really, really fascinating to look into.
I always like to think they gave Pinkie the pointless task of "breaking up the ice" so that it would keep her out of the way and not cause havoc while they were working.
This episode makes no sence. Is snow unable to melt in equestria..or does everyone really hate snow and dont have patience to wait for it to melt. If I had to go outside and clean up winter I would probably get a cold or some kind of sickness. Also spike only gets sick when he falls in the cold icy water. How did he not get a cold for being outside in the snow for a whole day? Also no one gived a buck if he got sick because they found it funny..
Did you not recall that episode of Chowder? "Would I?!" "Wold you?" "Would I?!" "Wold you?" "Would I?!" "Wold you?" "Would I?!" "Wold you?" "...Would I what?" And I don't remember the rest of the conversation
Here's a sin (or two) that you missed. Spiked called Twilight "Not mommy" and "Sister" in this episode. They are both a not subtle hint to how Spike really sees Twilight.
I knew that you had to point out at least a couple of flaws that Buc Brony pointed out (only you paraphrased them), and I seriously didn't expect those other flaws coming.
As I mentioned before other cartoons in the past have discussed discrimination in some form or another (Static Shock, Teen Titans, The Sneetches, Courage the Cowardly Dog, etc.) and it does here as well, if a bit nonchalant. Everyone can use their own naturual abilities, except for Unicorns. Magic IS natural to Unicorn, it's their talent as to raw power is an Earth Pony's and flight is a Pegasi's. It's like forbidding one kid to enter a competition just because he's better then the other kids.
Or they could’ve used magic to tie up all the belles in ten seconds flat so it would be quicker and more efficient considering Rarity had no problem using magic to lift things.
At Applejacks part of the song, she does a Nazi salute, and when Rarity uses magic on the basket, she has Twilights purple magic aura, Rarity uses blue magic.
They said that spring starts the next day in the beginning of the episode but then they work all night and into the next day so they didn’t actually get ready for spring in time
2:25 I love how everyone picks on the Mayor for not being humble yet don't bat an eye when Dash isn't XD maybe he was just really proud of her speech haha
There should be a sin at the beginning because technically twilight isn't cleaning up, she's just putting on clothes so she could use use magic for that.
Dude, when the camera zoomed in on Pinkie's face (I was a little bitty Twinkie Pinkie) that should have been sinned. There was no dramatic music with it!
I'm so glad I took bible class this year, or the fiddler on the roof reference would have gone right over my head. That's one of my favorite movies now. :-)
How come the unicorns can't use their magic, but the pegasi can fly? I'm sensing the "no unicorn magic" thing was just made up on the spot by the Mayor to mess with Twilight.
MichaelSar12IsBack Rarity used her magic to lift a basket... she broke the--- TRADITIONNNN TRADITION!
IKR I noticed that too :P
If Ponyville was started by earth ponies, the only ones that actually need the snow and rain, how would they make it? The episode shows you need pegasi to move the clouds so did earth ponies just starve because of dead crops until pegasi got there?
OMG YES I NOTICED THAT TOO! How come it says "started by earth ponies" because HONESTLY!? Thats just racist against unicorns. Also did NO ONE NOTICE THAT IF UR AN EARTH PONY WHO LEVITATES U DONT NEED PEGASI IN THE FIRST PLACE? XD
MichaelSar12IsBack wut 1:29
If Ponyville has been around for "hundreds of years", when how did Granny Smith basically "found" it?
Earth ponies probably have much longer lifespans.
Sentence: wrecking ball
Just reading that whole conversation made me laugh X3
If ponies don't die of old age, then what happened to Applejack's parents? I think I'll let the MLP Wiki speak for itself. "The whereabouts of Applejack's parents are touched on in the episode Apple Family Reunion. At the end of the episode, the shot fades to a view of Sweet Apple Acres as two shooting stars fly through the sky. The shooting stars are meant to represent Applejack's parents according to storyboard artist Sabrina Alberghetti. Lauren Faust had previously mentioned that the whereabouts of Applejack's parents has not been planned, and that the show is unlikely to mention that they've passed away. Faust stated she wanted that to be the case."
Balloon Boy And what about the Sirens? they are alive more than 1000 years (in the Human world)
You forgot one: Twilight says that for hundreds of years they haven't used magic, that would mean Granny Smith is hundreds of years old sense she was there when ponyville was formed.
Not to mention she was a young adult at the time
@@yurigacha-san1367 more like a teen
If magic is prohibited because it was Earth ponies that started tradition, how come pegasi can fly? Isn't that break of tradition, too?
Pretty sure Buc Brony's CinemaSins version of this episode brings that up.
No. It's a break of *TRADITIOOOOOOON*
maybe pinkie and lyra should team up to study human viewers, since pinkie has the sight, and Lyra has the science. it would be perfect
YESSSSSSSS
Cinemare Sins: I swear Pinkie Pie knows we're watching!
Me: True, and it would be funny if Twilight got into danger and Applejack says, "We gotta save Twilight, she might die!" And Pinkie says, "Oh silly, Twilight can't die! The viewers would hate us!" Staring at the camera. And later she presses her face up to the camera and says hello.
Pinkie: well, if you guys want me to
*giggles*
Hello part is too much
And then appleacks says, "Uhhh, ok...?" And rarity interrupts to say twi needs help rn, so they forget the pinkie thing
my fav fourth wall break from her is when after hearing someone is going to "buy all the cake" she turns to the camera, grabs it, shakes it while shouting "he's buying all the cake!" one of my two or three most fav fourth wall breaks
@@okami2389 I do pinkie!
PINKIE KNOWS WERE WATCHING XD
Best pony and best background pony team up? Sign me up!
+Doctor Whooves ^^ Yes! Must. be. a. thing.
+TheHeavenlyBuddy derpy is best background pony but I couldn't agree more with best pony, dash tied with party horse
+Rainbow Shy I thinks everybody knows by now
Were
^'
Be honest...
Everyone remembers “Winter Wrap-up” as one of the best songs
Not me
Fr
Of course Pinkie knows we're watching!!! SHE COULD BREAK THE FOURTH WALL!
+Doctor Whooves ^^ Lyra's quest to see hands led her to study many a cursed and forbidden tome of dark magic, until she began to see beyond reality itself.
then one day she would completely shatter it
@@raptorzeraora2632 She already has
Pinkie pie is the strongest pony i know. She is capable of breaking the forth wall, AND she is capable of breaking the laws of physics
OH NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
If I had any talent, patience, or a decent voice, I'd do a Cinema Sins of your Cinemare Sins. Unfortunately I have none of those.
But that's exactly how I feel on a regular basis yet here I am.
+LittleshyFiM Half of the bronies I know, including myself, have no talent. The other half doesn't really care.
+LittleshyFiM An added sin for you, sir:
-The tradition of Winter Wrap Up partially means using no magic, when magic could've done the job in about HALF THE TIME. But I get that it's tradition, but the first Winter Wrap Up could've, once again, been done in half the time had they used magic, hence changing the tradition. +1
-Also, shouldn't the whole Winter Wrap Up thing only be done by the Weather Pegasi? They are responsible for the weather, after all
+Ender Legends I forgot to put the +1 on the end, soooo...
+1
+Ender Legends no the plus 1 is there
46# if earth ponies started winter wrap up.....howed they clear the sky? And if the pegesi were flying almost the hole episode isn't that breaking the tradition!?!?!?!?
No, the tradition was no MAGIC from unicorns, flying is normal. I agree on the first statement though
Claire Chan Magic is normal too if you born with it... Therefore that’s all bias
At the beggining Spike says to Twi...
"Mommy? You're not mommy..."
Like... she kind of is... or who is then?
I was kinda thinking it was more of a sibling relationship, since they were both really young when they met and grew up together
Now the question remains, how is Spike still considered a baby??
Like, Twilight was an elementary kid at most when spike was born, and she's an adult now... So how is Spike still a baby?!
@@lord__pasta i can only assume dragons age differently
@@lord__pasta dragons age really slow but I still think twilight is his mommy
Just for the hell of it I went on Google translate and put the lyrics of Winter Wrap-up through Japanese, Russian, Swahili, Greek, and Hindi and then translated them back to English. This is What I ended up with:
Three months and the cold winter break Wonderful.
We are playing warm and time hoofsies work at home.
However, we are so many options we can grow cold and the food would be safe.
I am too old for that, but I love the shoes.
I have come to welcome spring
And all the heat and the green
Farewell, then, whenever he came
We cleanse this winter.
How can I do? I am new.
If you want to pony?
How to include any magic?
I do not know!
Short winter wrapped in winter!
To finish off our hearts
Short winter wrapped in winter!
This spring, for tomorrow!
This spring, for tomorrow!
project "Pegasus begins
All purpose cleaning dark sky
The sun shines!
We snow white clouds melting will increase.
Sun, light, beauty and feel the heat before!
Short winter wrapped in winter!
To finish off our hearts
Short winter wrapped in winter!
This spring, for tomorrow
Chemical summary of the cold winter!
This spring, for tomorrow
This spring, for tomorrow!
Hibernate MO
Ice and snow, according to the.
Everyone sleepyhead wakes
I like a mouse, quiet!
We help them collect food,
I can fix the house down.
We southern birds welcome back
So I will build their families!
Short winter wrapped in winter!
To finish off our hearts
Short winter wrapped in winter!
This spring, for tomorrow
Short winter wrapped in winter!
This spring, for tomorrow
This spring, for tomorrow!
It is not easy to clear land;
Small plant our seeds.
And you, good service,
Any comments on it.
Stem, apples, carrots and celery
flower color!
Need a lot of work for us;
Just do it!
Short winter wrapped in winter!
To finish off our hearts
Short winter wrapped in winter!
This spring, for tomorrow
Short winter wrapped in winter!
This spring, for tomorrow!
This spring, for tomorrow!
Now I'm sure you all know,
You need to find my place
And I support with all my heart,
I was faced with a difficult job.
How I can do anything magic
For pony country?
I should be
Today, I try to
Today, I try to
Short winter wrapped in winter!
To finish off our hearts
Short winter wrapped in winter!
This spring, for tomorrow
Short winter wrapped in winter!
This spring, for tomorrow
This spring, for tomorrow
This spring, for tomorrow!
This day Aria:
[Queen tubes]
This day will be perfect
Once, I dreamed of when I was a kid,
Editing gather 'Round
Tell me, please, my clothes look good
You do not know what is wrong!
[Princess Cadance]
On this day, would be perfect
Once, I dreamed of when I was a kid,
But instead of cake
All my friends are celebrating
Wedding bells I can call me ......
[Queen tubes]
I'm not very concerned about the dress
I will not enter into any cake
Oath, I lied when I said
anytime
I want
Nevertheless, I do not like it at all
No, I love the groom
In my heart there is a place
But again I want to have all my
[Princess Cadance]
You must escape before it's too late
Find a way to save the day
I hope that I will if I have to lie
"I'm afraid I can not lose
For those who want to use it
I do not care, love and care every day. "
In the end, I love these two OH groom
All my thoughts are consumed
Oh, beautiful shining armor, I will have in the near future
[Queen tubes]
Finally, the time has come
For me it is a happy wife
[Princess Cadance]
Oh, and not a wedding
Eventually marriage fraud
Looking'll ...
[Queen CHRYSALIS] ... my, my. [This evil laughs]
XD
I'm too old for that, but i love the shoes!
*****
How can I do? I am new.
lol, if you want to pony.
Who wants to pony?
TRADITION
I got excited too. I'm in Fiddler and I Was all Like "hey!!"
Ethan Nelson Screw tradition! I'll use all the magic I want!
I think I figured out how Pinky can keep brutally violating the fourth wall like she does. She doesn't know what a fourth wall is.
Its spelled pinkie
Darien Hilmerson I would change it (especially since it's irritating me now), but that would be dishonest.
OK......
how about the fact pinkie is on the weather team and twilight cant be?
yes but doesn't even go to the clouds really she is just skating to clear the lake
She asks about helping with the clouds specifically.
2:01
Suddenly Applejack forgot what she was supposed to wear in the bitter cold
*****
YEAAAAAAA
+Kelsey Key thx for noticing
I love how you put subtitles in english as well so people that can't hear it very well can understand :D
Regarding the sin with the bell and rope system they devised in the end of the episode for animal waking... sure, it probably would've taken some time to make it up (more than waking the animals would), but it means they can use it for the next winters; a mere pull of the rope would be enough to finish the task, now that the system is already established.
Yes, I can believe Twilight organizes her twigs that fast.
On another episode, to get Twilight's attention from her book, she pushed an inkwell that was across the room one inch out of place.
Even as they spoke, Twilight walked over, and nudged it back.
which episode
olivia cook
Spike, At Your Service.
Spike goes to tell Twilight he'll be working for Applejack from now on, and she gives him an "uh huh" without looking up.
Rarity comes by later, figures out Twilight's in her own world, and nudges an inkwell out of place to get her attention.
As Rarity and Twilight talk about what's going on, Twilight trots over to the other desk, pushes the inkwell back, and trots back.
Absolutely adorable.
Bill lupin it wasn't rarity it was applejack
Yep, went back and looked. My mistake, going from memory here.
ok it happens
And you perfected the series, not only because you have better material and stuff but also you have better arguments why everything is wrong!
Am I the only one who laughed so hard at
TRADITIOOON!!!
(TRADITION!)
Matt Holbaev TRAAAADITIIIIIIOOOOOONNNN!!!!!!
@@pinkajou656 I've been away from this fandom for years. You replied to a comment I posted when I was a middle school child brony - I'm now 19 and I might just re-watch this series just for nostalgia, thank you. It's been far too long.
Matt Holbaev oh. Wow. That’s amazing. I’m so happy for you! You’re very welcome.
I really hope I'm not the only one who knows what that "Would you?" Joke is from :P
Chowder
Cool :P
***** Would I!
***** Would I!
***** Awwwwwwww
i have had winter wrap up stuck in my head for the past four weeks! it causes me great happiness.
can you do everything wrong with 'Winters F***ed Up' by AnimatedJames...?
If you haven't already.
I don't think he would considering he never does videos with curse words in them
oh, okay.
I love seeing Jordan's work in educating the viewers
0:09 is that supposed to be a flower pot? 0:12 you can see twilight's fore-mane sticking out of her head. 0:15 floating scarves. 0:21 the third scarf disappears but reappears at 0:29. 0:29 the water in the painting doesn't reflect well at all you can't make out anything except the tree and the butterfly. 0:31 ponies wings are on her legs ( the pony flying by raindrops) 0:42 nightmare fuel. 0:54 her eye brow disconnected from her eye a bit. 0:59 grey ponies face,other colt's faces. 1:02 It probably also doesn't help you mood much to have a false cutiemark and prosthetic LIMBS. 1:18 rarity's aura. 2:30 that bird reminds me of the poke'mon swanna. 2:33 daisy is a frozen ice skater. apple bumpkin decided to help ponyville's winter wrap up.
Man i love this dude its so funny to watch what mistakes are in these episodes that i would of probley never known lol
As a HUGE fan of Cinema Sins, and a slight fan of the show, I really have to congratulate you on a spot-on parody! Everything about this, from the sound effects, the counters, and the "feel" of it feels like a legitimately high quality parody.
Saw it already, but nice to see it in glorious HD!
Also that ending will always get a laugh out of me.
1:14
Is nobody gonna talk about how rainbow dashes cutie-mark is gone ._.
JUST NOTICED THAT
(Insert sin sound here)
Without this, I couldn't have know that Lyra was jumping in that way during this episode. She looks really nice and funny with that expression XD
At 0:35 lemon heart was a unicorn a frame ago & next an earthpony again
Oh and she has a recolor right next to her in the same posision
I would love a longer version of this videos, with more time to show everything more clear.
i've got one more. you said Rarity is using magic and breaking tradition, right? well, that's not even her own magical aura! Rarity's magic is blue, not purple. purple is Twilight's. Maybe she WAS using magic after all!
Oh, of course, and I remember that being pretty prevalent in Static Shock at least once (man, I loved that show). It's just that this is kinda downplayed in this episode as "Oh, unicorns can't use their magic because tradition. ...Oh well, I guess?"
They do sort of accept it in-universe, though, and still manage to have fun with the clean-up, so it's probably not that bad at all...just really, really fascinating to look into.
I swear Pinkie Pie knows were watching XD
I always like to think they gave Pinkie the pointless task of "breaking up the ice" so that it would keep her out of the way and not cause havoc while they were working.
Then Granny Smith founded Ponyville - how old IS Granny Smith?
Sin: Setting the bar for music so high and then never again quite reaching it.
Lol I swear pinkie knows we're watching
You missed the part where they changed Ditzy Doo's (aka Derpy Hooves) hair from yellow to purple when she brought back to southern birds.
This episode makes no sence. Is snow unable to melt in equestria..or does everyone really hate snow and dont have patience to wait for it to melt. If I had to go outside and clean up winter I would probably get a cold or some kind of sickness. Also spike only gets sick when he falls in the cold icy water. How did he not get a cold for being outside in the snow for a whole day? Also no one gived a buck if he got sick because they found it funny..
exactly
***** yes, snow is snow just because weather has to be controlled and the sun and the moon need to be raised doesn't mean snow cant melt..
something i was suspicious about. if the pegasi control the weather, why create storms? geez...
I had a MLP ad before this video. Coincidence? I THINK NOT!
maxandsyd14 I think it was a coincidence
that's kinda how advertising works
2:44 anyone else notice two Doctor Whooves?
well he IS a time lord after all
booyah344 but the paradox would be horrible! all of time will collapse on itself!
Jacob Fidler
Tell that to the 50th Anniversary episode.
1:02 I heard that theme...
GHOSTBUSTERS!
2:01 What happened to AppleHorse's Team Ves- Oh never mind, its the hat all over again
You definitely forgot about all the inconsistencies in the song, all the recolors, and things like that.
1:37 WOULD YOU
...Would I what?
its a inside joke
between my friend and i
you wont unterstand
Did you not recall that episode of Chowder?
"Would I?!"
"Wold you?"
"Would I?!"
"Wold you?"
"Would I?!"
"Wold you?"
"Would I?!"
"Wold you?"
"...Would I what?"
And I don't remember the rest of the conversation
yes
ShTHfan 1 the rest was: RADA RADA!
This is probably my favorite one of these so far.
OMGGG pinkie and lyra ARE WATCHING UUSSS
Both of them make sense if you think about it. Lyra is an obsessive anthropologist and Pinkie is Pinkie
xD true ,,
pinkie knows everything she just acts likk she doesnt know anything so she can still be behind twighlight
1:56 I literally jumped
"Winter Wrap Up" is stuck in my head until the end of time
No to mention that the song introducing "Winter wrap up" takes up like a quarter to a third of the episode ._.
It's certainly not a third.
I may or may not have become slightly addicted to this...
The humans are watching?!?!?!?!
She sees you when your sleeping, she knows when you awake, she knows when you've been bad or good so be good for Pinkies Sake!
No words for the intro. The music is so catchy
I'd also add a sin for Spike urging Twilight to break the "No Magic" tradition, then reversing his position as soon as it backfires.
Thank you for knowing of "Fiddler on the Roof". It's rare to find someone who knows it these days
This was my dad’s favorite episode, he used the song as the animal crossing town theme every time.
I thought you knew by now? Pinkie. Knows. EVERYTHING.
with how many you've seen I'm almost convinced some were put there on purpose to see what watchful person would see them.
Here's a sin (or two) that you missed. Spiked called Twilight "Not mommy" and "Sister" in this episode. They are both a not subtle hint to how Spike really sees Twilight.
You missed the fact that if snow doesn't melt on its own, the snow would build up all winter, and be ridiculously high.
ITS BEEN 6 YEARS AND IM STILL HERE-
0:27 "Never mind, the snow melted on IT'S own"
*DING* ?
Spike probably got out of the snow by breathing fire but probobl got a message for twilight at the same time ._.
greatest....name....ever
Spitfire Pie It is naturally maggiedog300 but I had to delete it ._.
oh...bu still...BEST PREVIOUS NAME EVER!
I knew that you had to point out at least a couple of flaws that Buc Brony pointed out (only you paraphrased them), and I seriously didn't expect those other flaws coming.
I didn't even realize Rarity used magic. Talk about breaking the rules for using magic in winter wrap up.
Rarity used Twilight's magic color when using the basket
I find it funny how he only spots nothing but the negatives with good reasons
2:28 that grey pony with the dark blue mane has a different cutie mark this time
As I mentioned before other cartoons in the past have discussed discrimination in some form or another (Static Shock, Teen Titans, The Sneetches, Courage the Cowardly Dog, etc.) and it does here as well, if a bit nonchalant.
Everyone can use their own naturual abilities, except for Unicorns. Magic IS natural to Unicorn, it's their talent as to raw power is an Earth Pony's and flight is a Pegasi's. It's like forbidding one kid to enter a competition just because he's better then the other kids.
1:07
"Pfft, screw gravity"
Isn't that from asdf movie?
Winter wrap up winter wrap up! Let's finish our holiday cheer!
*they say holiday even tho they are literally working*
I think the reason why they had the ice cut the way it did was so that it could melt a lot faster.
I'm surprised he didn't point out the fact Fluttershy wasn't bothered by the skunk smell while Spike was plugging his nose
You missed an important one:
Derphorse's eyes were blue and un-crossed during the end of the winter wrap up song
here is another sin squirrels don't hibernate
I didn’t even look at the sin counter and I just think “45” on beat and there’s actually 45 sins wtf lol .
You forgot the fact that Rarity's horn glow color turns purple while she is dumping the basket.
It actually takes snow longer to melt when you pile it up
Derpy's hair changes color when she's guiding the birds to their homes. This happens while the instrumental is playing.
Pinkies job for the weather team is that she cuts the ice *FOR* the pegasi.
I'm surprised at the lack of similar sins to Buc Brony. Kudos!
Or they could’ve used magic to tie up all the belles in ten seconds flat so it would be quicker and more efficient considering Rarity had no problem using magic to lift things.
At Applejacks part of the song, she does a Nazi salute, and when Rarity uses magic on the basket, she has Twilights purple magic aura, Rarity uses blue magic.
They said that spring starts the next day in the beginning of the episode but then they work all night and into the next day so they didn’t actually get ready for spring in time
That elaborate bell system has always bugged me
This was the first epoisode I watched before fully becoming a pegasister
She has always had her own episodes, just proportionally more in Season 3.
2:25 I love how everyone picks on the Mayor for not being humble yet don't bat an eye when Dash isn't XD maybe he was just really proud of her speech haha
There should be a sin at the beginning because technically twilight isn't cleaning up, she's just putting on clothes so she could use use magic for that.
I sware down that your horn glows the same colour of their eyes and rairities (idk how to spell) was glowing a light blue purplish colours.
'everything Wrong With Winter Wrap up'
we offically broke the W counter
whenever i get into an arguement i say" and then i said oatmeal, are u crazy?" when it's really quiet
Dude, when the camera zoomed in on Pinkie's face (I was a little bitty Twinkie Pinkie) that should have been sinned. There was no dramatic music with it!
I'm so glad I took bible class this year, or the fiddler on the roof reference would have gone right over my head. That's one of my favorite movies now. :-)