Sonos Roam Review - Hard To Justify

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 110

  • @chrisredmayne
    @chrisredmayne 3 роки тому +7

    I guess it depends on the usage, the main things I'm getting it for are to be able to play Bluetooth things to it and share that sound with the rest of my sonos system... and for the summer I can have the same music playing in the kitchen, conservatory and garden so when I'm going inside for a drink or making food for the pizza oven the music will always be around, I wouldn't want anything too loud for outside so I'm not annoying the neighbours so this seems perfect for me. If you have a more private space then the move would be better I think. I doubt I would really take the roam anywhere else very often, maybe just hotel rooms so I can Bluetooth music there while I'm getting ready. Also it'll probably be handy taking in the bathroom where you don't need a big sound speaker too that'll just connect straight away. When you mentioned the android users as well Spotify connects to sonos without the sonos app so it's really easy to just pick up and play

  • @oliproulx1881
    @oliproulx1881 3 роки тому +20

    I don't know man... I don't think this is a good or fair comparison... I get were you're coming from in term of price, the JBL, for the price, could be a better pick. but i feel like in term of categories the real comparison would be the sonos roam vs the JBL flip 5 since they are around the same size. As we all know size does matter when we're talking about speaker since bigger speakers often offer better/more resonance which make for a bigger range of frequency and often meaning a better sound. That being said The JBL charge 5 is significantly bigger than the Roam. Also the size of the Charge 5 can arguably make it less portable than the roam or the flip 5. That's why I think this is not a good comparison.
    As for the flip 5 vs the Roam even though the Flip 5 as more bass it also seems to fall flat at high volume just like the Sonos Roam (over 80% volume). That being said, i feel like the roam offer a sound that is a lot more full around 80% volume were we have resonable bass and crisp mids and highs while the JBL speakers have ok mids and highs and try to make up for it with more bass which i found is something we can often see in lower quality headphones and speakers ( not saying this is necessarily the case here). Also i feel like the JBL flip 5, at lower volume, is drowning the mids and highs in bass were the Sonos have a more balanced sound.
    that being said, at the end of the day i feel like both brands try to reach very different customers. JBL speakers, to me, would be more attractive for younger people, since their product are pretty affordable, or the bass heads since their speakers often include passives radiators which are providing them with a lot a bass. As for the Sonos speakers i think they would attract older people (since price $$) that are looking for good and balanced sound. That's my opinion.

    • @pupper2054
      @pupper2054 3 роки тому

      This 👆👏

    • @crk140
      @crk140 3 роки тому +3

      The flip 5 is better hands down and is half the price.

  • @collinm.2408
    @collinm.2408 3 роки тому +8

    Seems like SONOS is really flexing their “premium brand” and “ecosystem” muscles, thanks for a detailed and honest review!

  • @TheAscendedTechNinja
    @TheAscendedTechNinja 3 роки тому +33

    4:00 He felt pretty good talking about his wifi setup 😂

    • @SirPablo2Pablo
      @SirPablo2Pablo 3 роки тому

      He said “if you have a pretty sick…”

  • @KOKOBC
    @KOKOBC 2 роки тому +4

    The sound quality on the charge 5 is so much better than either of the other speakers

  • @antimatter65
    @antimatter65 3 роки тому +6

    Nice to see a review that just doesn't go for the hype, it's definitely a lot smaller and not as good sound quality as was expecting. One thing you really missed thought the Sonos ecosystem is a massive feature and you can just hotspot your phone for WiFi but I know that is hassles so I get the point. You still have to mention that JBL have problems linking up to, as the new product from JBL don't work with the old ones I have a Xtreme 2 and wanted an Xtreme 3 to go with it but no dice, I am now looking to get another Xtreme 2 that is stupid position to be in. At least most of Sonos speakers from the last 5 to 10 years work with each other.

    • @hixnada8278
      @hixnada8278 3 роки тому

      I bought a Sonos MOVE and while it sounds great, having to use the Sonos app is a deal killer. I want a Bluetooth speaker, not something that needs an app. God only know what data they are syphoning from us and selling.

    • @JoshLStuff
      @JoshLStuff 3 роки тому +1

      @@hixnada8278 you can use it as a bluetooth speaker? also Sonos speakers were originally fully app based, that is their primary function. Bluetooth is only secondary to the main WiFi app experience

  • @PointWithin
    @PointWithin 3 роки тому +16

    The main thing for me is Airplay 2. There’s no other portable speaker with that

    • @robgerety
      @robgerety 3 роки тому +4

      I think this fellow does not ascribe as much value to airplay as apple folks do. Airplay is huge.

    • @simonconquest
      @simonconquest 2 роки тому

      Yeah having Airplay is excellent. But primarily- it’s a Sonos speaker first.

  • @PerfectoKiss
    @PerfectoKiss Рік тому +1

    Tried the Roam and ended up getting the JBL. To me, I enjoy the deeper sound from the JBL.

  • @JairLevi
    @JairLevi 3 роки тому +17

    Regards the price this ain’t a good comparison, you should have compared it to the Marshall Emberton, JBL Flip 5 maybe even the Wonderboom 2, or even the Tribit Maxsound plus or Stormbox, hell put an Anker Soundcore flare 2 in there because these are all small speakers. But in the end we agree, the Roam is overhyped and although its highs and mids are great the bass is off. Normally I really like your videos, but you should not only compare speakers in price, but also size and usage (indoor/outdoor/pool/party etc); this will help people choose the best one for them.

    • @Evelyn-oq4ym
      @Evelyn-oq4ym 3 роки тому +1

      exactly what i was thinking

    • @MatejaMaric
      @MatejaMaric 3 роки тому +5

      Right. Heck, if size isn't a factor then let's bust out the big ol' Sonos Move and let's see how they compare.

    • @crk140
      @crk140 3 роки тому +1

      I have the tribit MaxSound and the flip 5. I prefer both to the sonos, especially when considering the price. I can buy 3 tribits for the price of one roam

    • @evolution227
      @evolution227 Рік тому +1

      JBL=Loud,
      Sonos =forward sounding and detail.
      He also failed to mention that the Sonos Roam has a selectable feature to adjust its sound output to the space it’s in.
      The roam is a great speaker, and cost justified. Go listen to the JBL and. Roam and get a clearer picture.
      This video does not give an accurate sound depiction

  • @alexyu4549
    @alexyu4549 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you for putting the summary at the start. Too many UA-camrs nowadays try to got watchtime at the expense of video quality.

  • @igorstef
    @igorstef 3 роки тому +12

    Sonos Rome is something to consider if you already have Sonos speaker. That is whole point of it. I like your reviews but you failed to emphasize most important point. Been able to seamlessly integrate in to a Sonos system and allowing for music from the Bluetooth source to be shared with other Sonos speakers is for some Sonos users priceless. If you are in a market for good portable Bluetooth speaker there are definitely much better solutions price and sound wise.

    • @simonconquest
      @simonconquest 2 роки тому +2

      This is a poor review. Misses the fact that this is a Sonos speaker first and a Bluetooth / Airplay speaker second.

  • @happytime2781
    @happytime2781 3 роки тому +3

    After watching comparisions to Mebaboom 3 and Sonos I definetly staying with JBL Charge 5. Gona buy it today from local Currys shop and use already at work :)

    • @MoNeYMlKE420
      @MoNeYMlKE420 3 роки тому

      Just got the charge 5 2 days ago I’m loving it .frickin loud and sounds amazing 🤩 🤩🤙🏼🤙🏼

    • @crk140
      @crk140 3 роки тому

      The JBLs sound way better and in the case of the flip 5, it costs half as much

    • @MoNeYMlKE420
      @MoNeYMlKE420 3 роки тому

      @@crk140 yeah I agree. The ue speakers by Logitech are not bad I tried a few in target but jbl sounds better ,look better and are much more durable . Plus usb c

    • @crk140
      @crk140 3 роки тому

      @@MoNeYMlKE420 agree on all points. I previously owned the UE boom 3 and liked it just fine but it can't compete with the JBL in terms of sound quality

    • @stargazerxdd
      @stargazerxdd 2 роки тому

      Ues are horrible. Jbls are average. Bose are kinda impressive ( as they have bass compensation for low volumes and a consistent sound signature across all their speakers ). Vifas are benchmark. Also there are budget brands like soundcore and tribit which even outperform JBLs in different categories of speakers. So i hate when kiddies say jbls are the best!

  • @MissJess123
    @MissJess123 3 роки тому

    I previously own the Charge 3 but started getting battery issues so decided to upgrade. Saw a lot of videos saying sound is similar to previous generations I totally disagree this charge 5 is an amazing speaker and the bass is ridiculous for the size. I can fill my entire house with music just from this speaker, believe me this one JBL got right.

  • @ronniegeiser8538
    @ronniegeiser8538 3 роки тому +4

    As a owner of sonos speakers I not think you understand the sonos system enough . I do not own the the roam , I do not know if I will add it to my system or not yet. I will say if your wi-fi is that weak where a sonos speaker gives it problems you need to work on your wi-fi at home. I have 6 sonos speakers and no wi-fi problems.

    • @simonconquest
      @simonconquest 2 роки тому

      Absolutely. He’s reviewing it as just another Bluetooth speaker - instead of a Sonos speaker.

  • @jackson._.goulding
    @jackson._.goulding Рік тому

    I have a a bunch of these Bluetooth speakers and picked up a roam because my household is already fairly integrated with Sonos and I was curious. I can honestly say it’s a great speaker for its size but not for its price. Also quite durable; it’s survived some serious drops from a longboard. Really though the only way I could justify purchasing it is if you already have a Sonos system and want to use features like AirPlay. If you just need something that sounds good and can take a beating grab a flip or a charge.

  • @AJ-wf1vh
    @AJ-wf1vh 3 роки тому +3

    I think it's meant to be an Amazon Echo with a battery.
    So you can leave it plugged in a room always and use it like you would an Amazon Echo while being able to pick it up and take it to other areas of the house/pool/garden/shower. I don't think it's meant to be a portable bluetooth speaker.

  • @cabdluv1
    @cabdluv1 2 роки тому

    Best review ever. Exactly what I was looking for. Tnx.

  • @ngala204
    @ngala204 2 роки тому

    Nice job! Thanks for putting this high quality review. I have been vacillating for days as it has been hard to find a meaning review. JBL is is

  • @Art-yn5dh
    @Art-yn5dh 2 роки тому

    Do you recommend the jbl charge 5 or the Bose sound link revolve plus2? Which has better bass?

  • @coolsquad7428
    @coolsquad7428 3 роки тому +3

    You should do a jbl flip 5 vs sony xb23 vs sonos roam

  • @ajanssen4905
    @ajanssen4905 3 роки тому +2

    Sonos it will be!

  • @whatfreedom7
    @whatfreedom7 Рік тому

    I’m curious about the UE having dual speakers. Is it stereo and how’s the sound on it vs the charge?

  • @JaguarJuanDavid
    @JaguarJuanDavid 6 місяців тому

    Gymcaddy your cool 😎. When on Bluetooth does it handle sbc or aac codec or ldac codec?

  • @Jiggy609
    @Jiggy609 3 роки тому +5

    Soundcore motion + still king

    • @luisignaciogarciaguarda6626
      @luisignaciogarciaguarda6626 3 роки тому +1

      motion boom now is the king.. gym dont review soundcore.. its madness.. that sonos speaker is HORRRIBLE!!!!!!!!

    • @Jiggy609
      @Jiggy609 3 роки тому

      @Saad Bhatti yes sirrr

    • @dylanwhisnant6772
      @dylanwhisnant6772 3 роки тому

      @@luisignaciogarciaguarda6626 motion boom is bass king, motion + is clarity and vocal king

  • @nourhanbalian3294
    @nourhanbalian3294 Рік тому +1

    comparing apples to apples, Charge 5 destroys the Sonos, but Sonos has a ecosystem to back it up, so yeah.

  • @easports48
    @easports48 3 роки тому +1

    You mentioned that there’s no headphone/aux input on this guy. Have you tested either the Roam or Charge 5 with a USB-C to headphone adapter? Wondering if that’ll work

  • @shinkencarlos
    @shinkencarlos 3 роки тому

    Love your reviews. Thanks

  • @hardcorehouse
    @hardcorehouse 3 роки тому +1

    Good comparisons I thought. Thanks. I think the other ones are at least as good. Sonos should be bigger to properly compete

  • @IaMBatman9000
    @IaMBatman9000 2 роки тому

    Main reason I’m looking at it is Airplay. Also just want something nice for the pool area

  • @impatrickt
    @impatrickt 3 роки тому +1

    I can’t believe the HomePod Mini sounds better than this thing.

  • @csrs247
    @csrs247 3 роки тому +4

    i was debating on getting the roam, but got the charge 5 instead. That now turns out to have been the right call

    • @frozengamer3030
      @frozengamer3030 3 роки тому +1

      The roam has more features right

    • @csrs247
      @csrs247 3 роки тому

      @@frozengamer3030 I know. But all i want is the better sound quality. I also don't use the smart features that much

    • @frozengamer3030
      @frozengamer3030 3 роки тому +1

      @@csrs247 ok. The sonas looks more appealing to me

    • @MoNeYMlKE420
      @MoNeYMlKE420 3 роки тому

      For 10$ more it’s a no brainer.. 👍 good choice 👍

  • @hartleyjr
    @hartleyjr Рік тому

    To be clear: you can only take this to the beach OR a camping trip.

  • @morrish044
    @morrish044 2 роки тому

    I like how only the sound from the charge 5 moves my xtreme 3 passive radiator

  • @stevem6963
    @stevem6963 2 роки тому +1

    The JBL wins by a mile with sound quality

  • @Knewl
    @Knewl 3 роки тому

    I like the use of JBL for comparison. Do you have any recommendations of a good speaker similar to Charge 5 with Bluetooth/wireless and powered from wall outlet?

    • @MoNeYMlKE420
      @MoNeYMlKE420 3 роки тому

      Just got the charge 5 and I’m loving it. I was also looking for a bt wireless speaker that stays plugged in but there really aren’t that many. I got 2 HomePod minis paired in stereo which sound great for the size. But other plug in speakers on the market seem to be those BOSE 500,300 speakers which have mediocre reviews ..then your generic google home,Amazon echos etc

    • @bencherven
      @bencherven 3 роки тому

      Klipsch The One II

  • @woodfranklin4377
    @woodfranklin4377 3 роки тому +6

    Fair enough review, but you didn't even hit on the main benefits of this speaker. The selling point is not ONLY the portable speaker aspect but the ability to connect to existing Sonos systems. Bad review for not even mentioning this strong point. Having a Sonos system already in my house, this provides the ability to extend the linked sound system to the back patio or other rooms while being portable. This is something NONE of the other speakers you mentioned can do and something that adds to the price point.

    • @TemujinScott80
      @TemujinScott80 2 роки тому

      Agreed. It’s always good to watch multiple reviews because it’s truly about taste & preference. Not everyone wants to carry around a bigger speaker.

  • @royeastham5277
    @royeastham5277 2 роки тому

    Does Roam have Siri too?

  • @suuus12
    @suuus12 3 роки тому

    Thanks for the honest review! I did not like having to sign in and create an account with Sonos but the worst part for me is the power button being used for everything, it is hard to press and not intuitive to turn off/on and access the bluetooth on it. If I’m trying to connect the speaker to a new device I always have to look up instructions on how to do it. (My memory sucks) but not really easy to figure out. Don’t like having to have to watch and read info for a wireless speaker

  • @coolsquad7428
    @coolsquad7428 3 роки тому +1

    The sonos roam is just a disappointment for me imma wait until the xb24 comes out this summer

  • @christiancruz6649
    @christiancruz6649 3 роки тому +1

    please review tribit stormbox pro

  • @yobanijimenez4589
    @yobanijimenez4589 3 роки тому

    Uboom ?

  • @jeffbarner1747
    @jeffbarner1747 3 роки тому

    The best and honest review I’ve seen so far. I feel exactly the same. We paid a premium for design and features and it hurts my soul knowing the sound quality could’ve been better. It’s ok though, if I want thumping bass We can bring along the Move I guess.
    The things I really hate though is if ou have it plugged in it turns itself in over WiFi. Also sleep mode doesn’t save much battery. You have to hold and sprain your finger to turn it off completely.

  • @TheQuark6789
    @TheQuark6789 2 роки тому

    Seems like it's designed as a smart speaker that you occasionally take with you. Is that something people want? Only time will tell.

  • @mfblackburn1980
    @mfblackburn1980 Рік тому

    It’s clearly inferior to the charge 5 which is a great speaker. The Flip 6 is more comparable in size and from what I’ve seen the Flip 6 smokes the Sonos. I do see the major value in Wi-Fi but for this price you would think it could reach Flip 6 level sound quality.

  • @cinah.9484
    @cinah.9484 3 роки тому +1

    Jbl charge 5 👍

  • @twistacatz
    @twistacatz Рік тому +1

    We've got a lot of hurt Sonos fan boys in the audience....

  • @truenewsglobal
    @truenewsglobal 3 роки тому

    For features, it’s the Roam. For sound, it’s the JBL. The sound is very underwhelming and disappointing. I was expecting more from it when I opened it.

  • @HenryDR
    @HenryDR 3 роки тому

    Great video

  • @crk140
    @crk140 3 роки тому

    Do not buy the sonos hype. The flip 5 and tribit MaxSound are way better values and both have a fuller, richer sound than the roam

  • @DjayXx3446
    @DjayXx3446 3 роки тому +1

    You should listen to Hardstyle music

    • @MoNeYMlKE420
      @MoNeYMlKE420 3 роки тому

      I never knew this was a genre lol. After googling and finding playlists …These songs are dope !!! Thank U

  • @gianlucaalessia5538
    @gianlucaalessia5538 2 роки тому

    You should never have anything play n'sync or nickelback. The awful music could break the device

  • @demikaperis5888
    @demikaperis5888 3 роки тому

    Sonos roam vs flip 5 ♥️♥️♥️♥️

  • @WillAH956
    @WillAH956 Рік тому

    Forget it I will get a jbl speaker
    sick of the privacy breaches just to use a product

  • @vittoriofiorente7197
    @vittoriofiorente7197 3 роки тому

    The charge 5 and Sonos sent comparable other then there price

  • @giclee101
    @giclee101 3 роки тому

    I think the Sonos was better than the JBL. But I thought the UE sounded the best. If the sonos was as big as the megaboom I think it would be better.

    • @ioumore
      @ioumore 3 роки тому

      You were careful to say “to me” before giving your opinion. I appreciate that. I would like to present how the speaker is “to me”. Personally, as someone who has had JBL speakers who crapped out after a year, and sounded like that beforehand, I am happy to pay a bit more to get the sound quality and longevity I want and expect. Yes, it was a pain (for me) to set up. But the Sonos app made up for that. (Hint from a traveler….no VPN needed.) And the sound….I have never heard such quality from a speaker that size. The fact that the speaker is available on wifi or bluetooth without extra steps, that the assistant is incredibly responsive (even half way around the world), that the packaging is perfect for travel…(to me) the price is more than justified. Let me just say also…you can use the same qi wireless charger for it as for your phone, if you want. No added expense. The flexibility to tweak it to sound the same regardless of what in space you listen…amazing.
      Everyone has different priorities. I understand it. I just wanted to present an alternative view from someone who has different criteria than yours.

  • @Evelyn-oq4ym
    @Evelyn-oq4ym 3 роки тому

    compare it to wonderboom

  • @noupot
    @noupot 2 роки тому +1

    Sonos best in class

  • @thomaspirola3384
    @thomaspirola3384 3 роки тому

    WGAF about registering your account to use the product?? Dude sounds like he just doesn’t like apple. Bad wifi making AirPlay 2 dodgy? That’s your fault. Not apples/Sonos

  • @2312dean
    @2312dean 3 роки тому +1

    Your review might be fair.... if you had emphasized that you were ONLY comparing it as a like for like portable bluetooth speaker. The Roam is FAR more than that for existing Sonos users. When you actually take into account what it adds to an existing (or future) Sonos setup the review becomes so way off the mark.

  • @平和-v1z
    @平和-v1z 3 роки тому +1

    Not only is it hard to justify, it's also very privacy invading with the smart assistant integration. The optional wireless charging pad is a ripoff as well, it should be able to charge faster via cable.
    And another reason to avoid Sonos is their anti Right to Repair behavior...

  • @musiconvinylisbetter.1449
    @musiconvinylisbetter.1449 Рік тому

    I have three Devialet speakers. Those are much better.

  • @TemujinScott80
    @TemujinScott80 2 роки тому +1

    The Charge 5 is a bigger speaker. The Roam is much smaller. Not a fair comparison.

  • @edwininnocent23
    @edwininnocent23 2 роки тому

    Jbl❤️

  • @JaguarJuanDavid
    @JaguarJuanDavid 6 місяців тому

    Roam is wifi much superior sound

  • @dvgamer1623
    @dvgamer1623 3 роки тому

    I wont trust the ip67 on the sonos cause theres no pr (passive radiators) so if it doesnt have were and how will the driver pamke pressure??? maybe it can swallow water somehow but its strange i wouldnt not use it next to water only if the music was on pause

  • @zamfully
    @zamfully 2 роки тому

    JBL

  • @simonconquest
    @simonconquest 2 роки тому +1

    What a rubbish review. Totally misses the point that this is a Sonos speaker first and a Bluetooth / Airplay speaker second. The Sonos app is considered to be the best in class due to it’s easy of use and integrations to pretty much every stream service.

  • @alexthegreat1689
    @alexthegreat1689 3 роки тому

    It’s should have been called stay not Rome

  • @mrtakooo1
    @mrtakooo1 2 роки тому

    Good luck turning it on and off. Poorly designed.

    • @GYMCADDY
      @GYMCADDY  2 роки тому

      I also had this issue.... I did not want to elaborate on it because I felt people were going to attack me for being too critical. given that I was already bashing the roam. Sonos is all hype

  • @Whowhatwherewhy
    @Whowhatwherewhy 3 роки тому

    Overpriced, overhyped crappola made worse by S2 Sonos crap App. Checkout the app reviews in the iOS App Store before you buy this expensive paperweight.
    No wonder Best Buy doesn’t stock this in store. They can’t demo a product that doesn’t work.

    • @GYMCADDY
      @GYMCADDY  3 роки тому +1

      And yet people get mad at me cause I said I didn't like it either

    • @Whowhatwherewhy
      @Whowhatwherewhy 3 роки тому

      @@GYMCADDY thanks for your honest review. While others suck up to their viewers just for thumbs up, you stuck to an honest message. Respect

    • @ioumore
      @ioumore 3 роки тому

      Best Buy DOES stock the Sonos Roam. That is where I got mine, and I just checked their website and it is still available. I have owned the JBL and the Roam, and much prefer the Roam. Yes the price is high, but the sound quality is awesome-far better than the JBL, in my opinion, Yes, I had one-time problems with the app, wifi setup, and don’t like the power button. But in addition to the superior sound quality of the Sonos, the battery in the JBL has been a constant problem-having been returned to JBL 3 times for repair. JBL also does not offer the Sonos wifi music choice, which carries a host of benefits. In my opinion, you get what you pay for usually-and I am totally pleased with what I got for my money with the Roam.

  • @darklinggolem
    @darklinggolem 3 роки тому

    First