I like that Santos, former military, asks first about the deployment of troops; Vinnick, career diplomat, asks who they're talking to at the Kremlin. There is a reason Santos chose Vinnick to be his SoS.
I also noticed that Vinick, focused on cutting taxes above all else, insisted on cost estimates that would make deficit reduction & tax cutting mutually exclusive, while Santos, who prioritized social reform, was more concerned with losing time towards his goals.
I'm really happy that the first thing Santos and Vinick do is go into President mode and brainstorm scenarios instead of focusing on their own campaigns. Also, Leo saying "Yeah" was John Spencer's last line in the series before he died.
I've always loved the way Bartlett leaves them in the Oval Office - he doesn't dismiss them beforehand and remain, and he doesn't walk out with them - he just leaves. So, we get this great, very brief moment of Santos and Vinnick standing there just looking around, and the Oval Office just seems so empty, hollow, and lonely. More like a prison than a prize. It's a great moment.
Yeah its also very symbolic to the outgoing president addressing situation he has to deal with but will be unable to finish it within this term and looking to the 2 possible successors laying his cards on the table and walking away leaving it up to them because like it or not this will be their War.
Flashback to Season 5, when Walken was speaking with Debbie Fiderer. He comments that the oval is a weird looking room,to which Debbie says that Truman called it the crown jewel of the federal penal system
It's why you (generally) see a surprising amount of communication between former presidents even of different parties. In most jobs, you can seek advice from others who do the same work you do. Doctors talk to doctors, lawyers to lawyers, servers to servers, etc. Presidents really only have former presidents. Each of them will have crises and hard decisions where the costs can be billions or trillions and lives lost in the thousands or even millions. Also, as CiC and head of the executive branch, there's really no one to stop you. Advisors can advice, you may care about public opinion, but if you give the order, it's an order. The weight of that responsibility is tremendous. It's a deeply isolating and alienating experience and no wonder they look to age about 20 years in a matter of 4-8.
I was thinking the same things while watching this. Its a strong theme in the show that people get subtly dismissed by the President from the Oval Office after spirited discussions, with tip of their head and a "thank you Mr. President". Its Bartlett's trump card as the President. To see him deviate from that here is powerful and jarring. Great show!
(0:24) The last time we see John Spencer on screen as Leo McGarry. This brief scene is all too brief, with his last line a short "Yeah." While his character lived on in off-screen references until the Election Day episode, this was the final time we saw him. RIP John Spencer.
How are you How are you How are you doing How are you doing How are you DOing How are you How are you How are you doing How are you doing How...... Are....... You..... Doing DOING Just repeat that for 10 hours. That's my life song.
West Wing knew how to give us great, nuanced, smart characters on both sides, without making it feel like "Democratic good, Republican bad". Even some of the "villains" you could clearly see why they believed the way they did. Reality needs better writers. :p
Or Vinnick as President and Santos as Secretary of State! With having these two actors ply their craft in the first rate way they do, it's a win win deal!
Ended up being true. Santos dropped hints that he would be much more hawkish as president which got Russia and China back to the negotiation table with Bartlett before the election.
@@Pflameslinger Bartlet didn't have a CHOICE! You'd rather have China and Russia go to war with each other? Do you realize how much damage a war between to nuclear super powers would do to the USA much less then PLANET? As soon as Chinese soldiers shoot the first bullet or lob the first bomb at Russian troops (or visa versa), it would be an all out nuclear exchange between Russia and China. The USA would see major radioactive fallout within weeks after both nations wipe themselves off the map.
@@blastermasterguy Not really understanding the logic presented in, "if two nuclear powers go to war..." Iran was involved with both Iraq and Afghan...yet not a single nuclear bomb used. If you think Pakistan and India are not fighting on their border...we as another nuke power and one of the only real "super power" nations do not have to intervene or "stand in the middle".... every country with nuke capabilities understand the ramifications if they are used....great writing, great acting and an incredible series....
@@blastermasterguy It's not going to be an exaggeration that the US would not give a damn if Russia and China mutually cancelled each other out in nuclear hellfire. It'd remove the two biggest challengers to American global power in a single stroke.
That moment at the end of the scene, with both Vinick and Santos staring at the President's desk, fully understanding the terrible weight of that office. Presidential ambition is one thing, but the burden of BEING President... is it worth it?
Four years of impossible choices and in-fighting, even in my own party, and the knowledge that no matter what I do or say, at least a third of the country will hate my guts? Hard pass.
Which simply begs the question: why would ANY responsible voting amerikan put an incompetent, irresponsible, clueless, buffoon like trump in the office of the U.S. presidency? That's like putting a toddler in charge of a nuclear missile silo.
The scene ending with Bartlett saying "I don't have one. (An exit strategy)." He then walks out of the Oval Office; leaving the two presidential candidates glaring at the President's desk. The scene itself has moments of chillingly deafening silence.
You left out the best part, just before this scene. Debbie tells Vinick: "Make yourself comfortable", then under her breath says "But not too comfortable."
This scene is always chilling and compelling to me… best part, adults with completely different view points actually talking, reasoning, and little wrestling with each other--about a gravelly serious situation-- with enormous implications and ramifications-without it going straight to pure bickering and blame…. That comes later lol
It feels like a meeting between three gods. True statesmen. I love Bartlet so much, he’s such a legendary figure. The showrunners really made a wise decision to pivot the show in the 6th and 7th season to an ailing Bartlet and his up-and-coming replacements.
Its that moment when the reality strikes home up until now it's been theorizing about what the job would be for them now they get a taste of the reality of the job they are competing for.
It also is so ering that with one situation both of their domestic agenda they campaigned are is no longer feasible and this is before any of them are elected to
I really like how in the later seasons how Bartlett became more of a statesman but politically less powerful. He's got all of this knowledge and ability but is constrained by circumstance. It's very moving.
"What's YOUR exit strategy?" This is how you can tell it wasn't written by Aaron Sorkin, because he would have had Bartlett say, "The 22nd Amendment." (term limit. :P)
Not sure that he would have said that, unless he was going for a humor effect. This scene is not funny. He is sitting these men down so they can see the full extent of what their next four years will be about.
I’m 8 years late to the party, but absolutely not. President Bartlet would not say something like that when the stakes are this high. Look at the episodes with the assassination of Qumari Defense Minister Shareef for reference as to how he would handle something like this in the Sorkin years.
You do realize the DEMOCRAT president is committing us to a war without any idea of how we get out of it, right? That's the very thing you leftists always criticize republican presidents for.
Michael Rochen Josiah Bartlet may be a Democrat on paper, but he’s a moderate that would have a very hard time getting elected today. By the same token an Arnold Vinnick would have zero chance to win the Republican nomination in today’s political climate. There seems to be little room for moderates these days but, in my opinion, a moderate is just what we need. In this storyline, Bartlet is just reacting to other stimuli - in this case superpowers Russia and China coming close to war over leadership in Kazakhstan which happens to be right between the two. It’s not unilateral involvement like so many previous Presidents of both parties have done in the past. Republicans have been the most recent culprits, but let’s not forget LBJ and Vietnam.
@@seamus1956 A moderate is just what we DON'T need! There's a reason they can't get elected today. It's the moderates and the neocons who fucked everything up. They rig the primaries, they start the wars, and they kiss the asses of the corporations while screwing over the working class. Chuck Schumer said they would pick up two moderate Republicans for every blue collar Democrat they lost. That's what these moderate Democratic assholes stand for. The sad thing is that their failures allowed a faux populist con man like Trump swoop in and win the presidency.
This is a superb depiction of the complexity of world politics and our role in those politics. I feel pretty strongly that we have been involved in way too many wars, but this fictitious scenario sounds so similar to many of the "actions" that the U.S. has taken in the last few decades. And boy, are we hard on our presidents!
You may not know this but Arnold Vinick was originally scripted to WIN the election. Unfortunately John Spencer passed away while Season 7 was still being filmed and the writers had to fit that tragic event in to the story. As a result they decided that having Leo die AND Matt Santos losing the election was simply too much of a 'down' ending to the show so they rewrote the last five episodes. As a result Arnold Vinick became the Secretary of State to President Santos. Personally I think the writers handled it about as well as it could be handled. I would have liked to see a follow up at some point to see how that relationship worked and whether or not Sam Seaborn ever made it to the White House as President but I doubt in today's political climate such a show could now be made.
Yeah, there were some in the writers' room that were toying with the idea of a Vinick win, but the idea didn't have a whole lot of traction. Spencer's death merely put that idea to bed for good. It wasn't the full course reversal that some people believe it was.
You're using the sentence "purged" with regards to a president of a democratic nation... YIKES! That's mildly terrifying. Pick a better word. Stalin purged. Democracies don't purge.
When I see this, I can't help but remember Martin Sheen as Robert E. Lee in the movie Gettysburg. He so well portrays an old warrior, highly educated and a natural born leader. But still reluctant to fight until it is forced. He is truly a fantastic actor.
Here's another example of the great cinematography, the National Security Meeting from above. To me it symbolizes two things: One, that this thing is looming over them like an ominous cloud and two it reminds me of a surgery scene in a film with them looking over the body. It shows how precise this must be.
this scene is so well played out, thwest wing was really good about making you hope the people that run the country are this courteous, intelligent and focused. thanks for uploading this.
I think the point here folks is that no matter your ideological beliefs, the world is a messy place filled with situations that have no "right" answer. Sometimes, we humans just have the do the best we can in a very complicated evnironment with limited information, all the while knowing the other guy may do something totally unexpected. If you don think this is true just consider the last time you had in your mind a conversation with your spouse, and it went in a completly different direction then how you envisioned it.
There is a brief glimpse of him in the hotel during the celebrating of Santos' win. Scenes are often shot out of order, but it makes me wonder how they planned to use that bit, since Santos' was intended to lose before Spencer's death.
Jay Azathoth It was his photo or video, it wasn't him in person. his last episode was halfway through the season. most dramas air the episodes in the order they were filmed. no way would he have been in original footage.
Patrick Hardin My mistake, it was the polling numbers in episode The Cold, not the election itself: www.dailymotion.com/video/x5499qe_the-west-wing-season-7-episode-13-the-cold_tv?start=174
How fitting that the last 2 ppl that leo talked to on screen was the president and josh. If margaret could only have been the thrid, it would have been very cool.
Matt Santos was a great character but this was one of those scene where I was rooting for Vinick to win the election. Santos was talking about effects on the election and their administrations but Vinick was interested in the bigger picture.
They were never going to let a republican win that election, even though two consecutive Dem administrations fly in the face of the last 80 years of US history.
@@randolphkersey5155 Actually originally Vinick was going to win. But the death of John Spencer made them alter it feeling that both the death of Leo and losing would be too cruel to the fans.
When I was in high school, my AP US History teacher told us that a common theme across many presidents throughout the years has been foreign affairs getting in the way of domestic agendas.
@MikeJames6 He wasn't going to originally, but John Spencer died, and they felt from a story perspective it would be too cruel for him to lose and his VP pick to die.
It's a subtle nuance, but I like the way that Santos and Vinnick don't share each other point of view and still acknowledge the validity of each other's points. Like when Vinnick asks about the costs and Santos says it doesn't matter. Vinnick persists, the President drops the price tag and Santos gets a look on his face that says, "Yeah, that matters."
This is probably what planted the seed in Santos' head about Vinnick becoming Secretary of State. Vinnick looks astute and intelligent on foreign policy, which is hard to say about most Republicans.
3:58 “I suggest you both start giving it some thought.” Oh wow, yep, thanks, good advice, not sure either of us would've got there on our own. 🤣🤣 Master of understatement
I love The West Wing but it’s hard to watch it now since it is so very far from reality. The world where politicians like Bartlett, Santos and Vinnick could even theoretically exist has long passed. Yea I know it’s fiction but in 2020 the actions and motivations behind policies of people the show presents us doesn’t even seem remotely possible anymore. Vinnick saying goodbye to his tax cut for example. If this happened today, He would still cut taxes and send in the troops. He wouldn’t feel conflicted about it at all. This show for the most part portrays both Democrats and Republicans as having some sort of moral and ethical foundation from which their policies emanate. Today, it’s all grift for profit and rank hypocrites.
"...and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth." ... The last words of President Lincoln's Gettysburg Address in 1863. I agree that the quality of character exhibited by a lot of those now in the Federal government is down so low. But I don't believe it's necessarily gone forever. Per Lincoln's words, it's up to us to do what it takes to get it back.
Actually, watching the West Wing twice in the last 4 years because sometimes it paralleled reality. I know we don't get a Bartlet anywhere in the real world, but some of the politics were so convincingly close to present day, I watched it all the way through twice at the start and end of Trump's Presidency. My husband and I would chuckle at the stuff that went on (including the biological attack in the White House vs COVID) because it was so damn close.
You say you know it's fiction and then go on to say it's not even close to reality. Well no kidding. Do you also watch movies about the civil war and then go on to complain that we don't fight that way anymore? How about WW2 when we had battleships out fighting. We don't have any now so that's another fallacy I suppose.
The two candidates are confronted with the reality of the choices facing a President. Sometimes there are no easy fixes or happy solutions. The world is a messy place filled with compromises, least bad options and grey areas. It certainly is not a reality show.
I was never a fan of Jimmy Smits, but he does better than I thought he would. As for Alan Alda, that was a great choice, & as always, he's a pro. Watching this for the 1st time, was utterly engaging, & all too believable. -------------------MJL, 75 y/o
Watching this scene makes it obvious that the reality TV star that is now our president-elect is in way, WAY over his head. Do you think that The Donald could even name a "former Soviet central Asian republic?" I don't think so. Maybe he can get someone to tweet him the answer. We're screwed.
I don't debate your general sentiment, but don't forget that the President has made millions in a couple of those former Soviet central Asian republics.
@@WilliamPitcher Which makes him beholden to the oligarchs that run said former Soviet central Asian republics and therefor a security risk and unfit to be president.
@@blastermasterguy If he's already made the money, however many years before he took office, how would he still be beholden? Also, as a registered Democrat, I'm actually glad Trump is previously wealthy in one sense: it removes a vector for corruption that has before and doubtless again will affect other Presidents of the Republic.
this is a conversation that never would happen. I wish we had a president that could do this. The hand over of power with a real understanding of what is going on in the world.
I really miss this show. I wish they’d gone a couple more seasons. It would’ve been interesting to see how Pres. Santos and Sec. Vinnick would work together.
The writers missed an opportunity here to show the candidates in a different light. Imagine this scene if Vinnick asked the military question and Santos followed with the diplomatic question. It would have showed that both candidates understanding that they couldn’t ignore the other side argument in situations like this.
Having watched both this series and Netflix's House of Cards a few years later, I'm struck at the contrast in how both shows present similar subject matter. The West Wing presents a very optimistic view of politics, where people often disagree on the approach but are still working toward the same goal and can work together, or at least be civil toward one another. Meanwhile, House of Cards presents a far darker and more cynical view of politics, where everyone is ruthless and the only rule is, as Frank Underwood put it, "hunt or be hunted."
The Netflix House of Cards was based on the UK House of Cards featuring Francis Urquhart and his rise to power after the Thatcher years. It was released in 1990 and based on a book from '89. The dark, cynical version of politics came first.
It still seems a fantasy to expect our politicians to act in noble, ethical and altruistic ways, but that is not the way of our world. I wish Sorkin's dream was reality.
@Jim Dandy ... Though that didn't happen it is literally the President's job to ensure that the country isn't handed over to a criminal. If there was such an investigation we wouldn't be in the mess we are in now with a dangerously unstable known criminal and his crime family occupying the White House.
The problem with anything military is there is no guarantee we will win especially in the ward's we fight now. Take the GWOT it's still on going Iraq and Afghanistan may have largely ended but the war still goes on in different places.
@@bridgecross 22 trillion was the total cost I'm talking about over period of about 20 years 70 billion is the right trajectory every fiscal year conservatively to make 2 trillion not including other contingency spending on a case by case basis.
Try as I might, it's very hard to imagine Trump having a conversation like this with a republican successor and a democratic opponent. This was statesmanlike and realistic. Politics were off the table and it was what are we going to do and which one of us is going to have to do it. Why can't we elect fictional characters? Because I would take Santos, vinick, or Bartlett any day of the week over what we have now
Man, a timeline where you have to choose between Franklin “Hawkeye” Pierce or Bail Organa for President of the United States really doesn’t sound so bad.
Alan Alda has been various characters in the White House so many times you would think he has past experience in politics. The President in Canadian Bacon. Chief of Staff in Murder at 1600. Senator in West Wing.
I like that Santos, former military, asks first about the deployment of troops; Vinnick, career diplomat, asks who they're talking to at the Kremlin. There is a reason Santos chose Vinnick to be his SoS.
Isn’t Santos an active duty National Guardsman?
In the election he was usmc or USN reserve pilot, I think f18?
100%
It’s a minor detail, but it makes sense. The soldier asks about the soldiers, the diplomat asks about what channels they have open. Nice touches.
I also noticed that Vinick, focused on cutting taxes above all else, insisted on cost estimates that would make deficit reduction & tax cutting mutually exclusive, while Santos, who prioritized social reform, was more concerned with losing time towards his goals.
I'm really happy that the first thing Santos and Vinick do is go into President mode and brainstorm scenarios instead of focusing on their own campaigns.
Also, Leo saying "Yeah" was John Spencer's last line in the series before he died.
😭😭😭
His acting was splendid though! You could feel there was way more weight behind the..... yeah!
Thanks for pointing that out about John. Really missed him.
Once again, Alan Alda finds himself unwillingly involved in a land war in Asia....
Arden Vida underrated comment
Inconceivable.
Great comment. Agreed, underrated.
Cause suicide is painless.....
My greatest regret is that I can only give one like to this post.
I've always loved the way Bartlett leaves them in the Oval Office - he doesn't dismiss them beforehand and remain, and he doesn't walk out with them - he just leaves. So, we get this great, very brief moment of Santos and Vinnick standing there just looking around, and the Oval Office just seems so empty, hollow, and lonely. More like a prison than a prize. It's a great moment.
Yeah its also very symbolic to the outgoing president addressing situation he has to deal with but will be unable to finish it within this term and looking to the 2 possible successors laying his cards on the table and walking away leaving it up to them because like it or not this will be their War.
Flashback to Season 5, when Walken was speaking with Debbie Fiderer. He comments that the oval is a weird looking room,to which Debbie says that Truman called it the crown jewel of the federal penal system
It's why you (generally) see a surprising amount of communication between former presidents even of different parties. In most jobs, you can seek advice from others who do the same work you do. Doctors talk to doctors, lawyers to lawyers, servers to servers, etc. Presidents really only have former presidents. Each of them will have crises and hard decisions where the costs can be billions or trillions and lives lost in the thousands or even millions. Also, as CiC and head of the executive branch, there's really no one to stop you. Advisors can advice, you may care about public opinion, but if you give the order, it's an order. The weight of that responsibility is tremendous. It's a deeply isolating and alienating experience and no wonder they look to age about 20 years in a matter of 4-8.
"Y'all sure you still want this job...?"
I was thinking the same things while watching this. Its a strong theme in the show that people get subtly dismissed by the President from the Oval Office after spirited discussions, with tip of their head and a "thank you Mr. President". Its Bartlett's trump card as the President. To see him deviate from that here is powerful and jarring. Great show!
Everyone here is great, but Alda is absolutely fantastic here. One of television's greatest actors, for sure.
I agree. I think it's because we see his character held up to our image of Hawkeye Pierce.
Well... From Hawkeye to socialist-Republican!
He's a unicorn-griffin!
🤷🏼♂️
T.V: Gotta love it!
😜👍✊❤🦄
He should have won the election
Superb
(0:24) The last time we see John Spencer on screen as Leo McGarry. This brief scene is all too brief, with his last line a short "Yeah." While his character lived on in off-screen references until the Election Day episode, this was the final time we saw him. RIP John Spencer.
I think Vinick was the best character addition to The West Wing in the entire series (not counting the original members).
From his very first scene polishing his shoes with Josh he was electrifying. Made the entire last season-and-a-half work, brilliant.
Ainsley Hayes. Then alan Alda.
@@williammassey8514 ainsley was by far the best but inick was good too. i wished ainsley could have become a main cast member
How are you
How are you
How are you doing
How are you doing
How are you DOing
How are you
How are you
How are you doing
How are you doing
How...... Are....... You.....
Doing DOING
Just repeat that for 10 hours. That's my life song.
West Wing knew how to give us great, nuanced, smart characters on both sides, without making it feel like "Democratic good, Republican bad". Even some of the "villains" you could clearly see why they believed the way they did. Reality needs better writers. :p
Notice how both Santos & Vinnick seem to be on the same page. Not fighting with each other. Both having respect.
They agreed with each other on foreign policy, Santos admitted as much in the final episode.
Who wished there was one more episode where we actually got to see Vinnick as Santos’s Secy. of State 🙏🏾
I wanted to see several more seasons!
5 more seasons!
Or Vinnick as President and Santos as Secretary of State! With having these two actors ply their craft in the first rate way they do, it's a win win deal!
@@timothypeck3640 Santos was not the diplomat that is needed for the Secretary of State. DOD maybe.
I would’ve rather seen vinnick as president and santos as secretary of Defense
Santos: "What's *your* exit strategy?"
Bartlett: "In five months, I walk out that door and take Marine One to my farm in New Hampshire"
Basically
Santos: What is your exit strategy?
Bartley: One of you.....
Bekins.
Since Santos makes Vinick secretary of state, actually its two for one.
Sir-------his name is Bartlett ----------NOT " Bartley "
"The twenty-second amendment."
Ended up being true. Santos dropped hints that he would be much more hawkish as president which got Russia and China back to the negotiation table with Bartlett before the election.
They kept Bartlet, Vinnick, and Santos separate for so much of the final season and their best scenes were always together.
These armies are marching towards each other and someone must stand in the middle.That line gives me CHILLS.
Yeah because it's awful foreign policy
@@Pflameslinger Bartlet didn't have a CHOICE! You'd rather have China and Russia go to war with each other? Do you realize how much damage a war between to nuclear super powers would do to the USA much less then PLANET? As soon as Chinese soldiers shoot the first bullet or lob the first bomb at Russian troops (or visa versa), it would be an all out nuclear exchange between Russia and China. The USA would see major radioactive fallout within weeks after both nations wipe themselves off the map.
@@blastermasterguy Not really understanding the logic presented in, "if two nuclear powers go to war..." Iran was involved with both Iraq and Afghan...yet not a single nuclear bomb used. If you think Pakistan and India are not fighting on their border...we as another nuke power and one of the only real "super power" nations do not have to intervene or "stand in the middle".... every country with nuke capabilities understand the ramifications if they are used....great writing, great acting and an incredible series....
@@blastermasterguy It's not going to be an exaggeration that the US would not give a damn if Russia and China mutually cancelled each other out in nuclear hellfire. It'd remove the two biggest challengers to American global power in a single stroke.
@@gyleake Iran wasn't a nuclear power.
That moment at the end of the scene, with both Vinick and Santos staring at the President's desk, fully understanding the terrible weight of that office. Presidential ambition is one thing, but the burden of BEING President... is it worth it?
Four years of impossible choices and in-fighting, even in my own party, and the knowledge that no matter what I do or say, at least a third of the country will hate my guts? Hard pass.
Which simply begs the question: why would ANY responsible voting amerikan put an incompetent, irresponsible, clueless, buffoon like trump in the office of the U.S. presidency? That's like putting a toddler in charge of a nuclear missile silo.
The scene ending with Bartlett saying "I don't have one. (An exit strategy)."
He then walks out of the Oval Office; leaving the two presidential candidates glaring at the President's desk.
The scene itself has moments of chillingly deafening silence.
Not total silence. There was that ticking clock.
@Jim Dandy This is the a comment board on the internet. How about switching it off and reading a book?
This scene shows just how perfect, as far as foreign policy is concerned, these two are. What ultimately ended up happening was perfect in my eyes
You left out the best part, just before this scene. Debbie tells Vinick: "Make yourself comfortable", then under her breath says "But not too comfortable."
I don't care what your politics are the writing in this show was off the charts.
This scene is always chilling and compelling to me… best part, adults with completely different view points actually talking, reasoning, and little wrestling with each other--about a gravelly serious situation-- with enormous implications and ramifications-without it going straight to pure bickering and blame…. That comes later lol
It feels like a meeting between three gods. True statesmen. I love Bartlet so much, he’s such a legendary figure. The showrunners really made a wise decision to pivot the show in the 6th and 7th season to an ailing Bartlet and his up-and-coming replacements.
Once Bartlett leaves
Santos: Would it be inappropriate to say I really need a drink?
Vinick: I know a great place just three blocks from here
Mavakor Starts with an H.
Or Vinick could say that he has a still that can make martinis.
I know a great place. It’s called The Swamp. They make great homemade martinis 🍸 there, fresh out of the still. 😋
Leo’s last spoken word is “yeah”..😢
And it is to the question, "Is everything alright?" That's what gets me.
That look both men give to the Resolute Desk at the end is so meaningful. “Oh crap, do I Really want the job?”
Its that moment when the reality strikes home up until now it's been theorizing about what the job would be for them now they get a taste of the reality of the job they are competing for.
It also is so ering that with one situation both of their domestic agenda they campaigned are is no longer feasible and this is before any of them are elected to
I really like how in the later seasons how Bartlett became more of a statesman but politically less powerful. He's got all of this knowledge and ability but is constrained by circumstance. It's very moving.
My favorite part of this scene is when Bartlett leaves the room, Vinnick and Santos are left standing there looking at the Resolute Desk.
What great actors. Wish all three would do something again.
"What's YOUR exit strategy?"
This is how you can tell it wasn't written by Aaron Sorkin, because he would have had Bartlett say, "The 22nd Amendment."
(term limit. :P)
Not sure that he would have said that, unless he was going for a humor effect. This scene is not funny. He is sitting these men down so they can see the full extent of what their next four years will be about.
I don't know. That's a little too flippant, considering the circumstances. I don't think Bartlet would have said it.
I’m 8 years late to the party, but absolutely not. President Bartlet would not say something like that when the stakes are this high. Look at the episodes with the assassination of Qumari Defense Minister Shareef for reference as to how he would handle something like this in the Sorkin years.
Well Sorkin had left the show like three years earlier so there wasn't much doubt on that count.
One thing about this scene is looking at Martin Sheen and wondering just how OLD he got during this series. Even being a fake President can age you.
You do realize that was makeup, right?
I don't look the same as I did seven years ago, either.
Funny as well that he looks more like Trump towards the end of the show, but obviously acts the opposite.
@@SmallLab129 He'd have to gain 200 pounds to look like Trump.
@@JStarStar00 You think Trump is 370 pounds? You're just an idiot.
Funnily enough both of them inherited the situation Santos the military strongarm and Vinick the diplomatic voice of reason
Santos tapping Vinnick as his Secretary of State was a masterstroke. Vinnick would be the one with the carrot; Santos would be the one with the stick.
God, how I wish Republicans would act like Vinick.
Some do they just get silenced and crushed by the American taliban
You do realize the DEMOCRAT president is committing us to a war without any idea of how we get out of it, right? That's the very thing you leftists always criticize republican presidents for.
Michael Rochen Josiah Bartlet may be a Democrat on paper, but he’s a moderate that would have a very hard time getting elected today. By the same token an Arnold Vinnick would have zero chance to win the Republican nomination in today’s political climate. There seems to be little room for moderates these days but, in my opinion, a moderate is just what we need.
In this storyline, Bartlet is just reacting to other stimuli - in this case superpowers Russia and China coming close to war over leadership in Kazakhstan which happens to be right between the two. It’s not unilateral involvement like so many previous Presidents of both parties have done in the past. Republicans have been the most recent culprits, but let’s not forget LBJ and Vietnam.
@@seamus1956 A moderate is just what we DON'T need! There's a reason they can't get elected today. It's the moderates and the neocons who fucked everything up. They rig the primaries, they start the wars, and they kiss the asses of the corporations while screwing over the working class. Chuck Schumer said they would pick up two moderate Republicans for every blue collar Democrat they lost. That's what these moderate Democratic assholes stand for. The sad thing is that their failures allowed a faux populist con man like Trump swoop in and win the presidency.
They do, Trumps Ant-War, but it doesn't hurt to flex your muscles from time to.time
I enjoyed the final season more than I thought I would.
I do like how Vinnick at 3 minutes in admits that both his AND Santos's big plans each went up in smoke.
This is a superb depiction of the complexity of world politics and our role in those politics. I feel pretty strongly that we have been involved in way too many wars, but this fictitious scenario sounds so similar to many of the "actions" that the U.S. has taken in the last few decades. And boy, are we hard on our presidents!
I felt for Vinnick. A rational and thinking Republican- a dying breed these days.
You may not know this but Arnold Vinick was originally scripted to WIN the election. Unfortunately John Spencer passed away while Season 7 was still being filmed and the writers had to fit that tragic event in to the story. As a result they decided that having Leo die AND Matt Santos losing the election was simply too much of a 'down' ending to the show so they rewrote the last five episodes. As a result Arnold Vinick became the Secretary of State to President Santos. Personally I think the writers handled it about as well as it could be handled. I would have liked to see a follow up at some point to see how that relationship worked and whether or not Sam Seaborn ever made it to the White House as President but I doubt in today's political climate such a show could now be made.
That's an urban legend. Santos was always going to win.
Yeah, there were some in the writers' room that were toying with the idea of a Vinick win, but the idea didn't have a whole lot of traction. Spencer's death merely put that idea to bed for good. It wasn't the full course reversal that some people believe it was.
Ayup. He actually advocated for separation of religion from politics and state. A dying breed indeed.
You're using the sentence "purged" with regards to a president of a democratic nation... YIKES! That's mildly terrifying. Pick a better word. Stalin purged. Democracies don't purge.
Great acting by 3 Great actors
"I can say goodbye to my tax cut" back when Republicans gave a damn about the budget.
Repubs only care about the budget when a Democrat is in Office.
How is cutting taxes caring about the budget? It increases the deficit.
@@radix4400 I'm sorry. I misspoke. I meant deficit instead of budget.
When I see this, I can't help but remember Martin Sheen as Robert E. Lee in the movie Gettysburg. He so well portrays an old warrior, highly educated and a natural born leader. But still reluctant to fight until it is forced. He is truly a fantastic actor.
An amazing show right to the end!!
Here's another example of the great cinematography, the National Security Meeting from above. To me it symbolizes two things: One, that this thing is looming over them like an ominous cloud and two it reminds me of a surgery scene in a film with them looking over the body. It shows how precise this must be.
this scene is so well played out, thwest wing was really good about making you hope the people that run the country are this courteous, intelligent and focused. thanks for uploading this.
Sorkin might have missed a line here... Bartlett saying "Are you sure you still want this job??"
3:51 That moment when everyone in the room realizes just how horribly wrong it's all gone.
Just absolutely the best show ever.
When talking of exit strategy, Alan Alda seems to still have a hint of Hawkeye in him.
I think the point here folks is that no matter your ideological beliefs, the world is a messy place filled with situations that have no "right" answer. Sometimes, we humans just have the do the best we can in a very complicated evnironment with limited information, all the while knowing the other guy may do something totally unexpected. If you don think this is true just consider the last time you had in your mind a conversation with your spouse, and it went in a completly different direction then how you envisioned it.
...Don't go to bed angry!
🤷🏼♂️ Just sayin'.
I love how you can see them both staring at that desk going, "Oh man." Also, I'm a dem and I love Secretary Arnold Vinick so much!
You would. He's a liberal republican.
John Spencer's last on-screen appearance...
There is a brief glimpse of him in the hotel during the celebrating of Santos' win. Scenes are often shot out of order, but it makes me wonder how they planned to use that bit, since Santos' was intended to lose before Spencer's death.
Jay Azathoth It was his photo or video, it wasn't him in person. his last episode was halfway through the season. most dramas air the episodes in the order they were filmed. no way would he have been in original footage.
Patrick Hardin My mistake, it was the polling numbers in episode The Cold, not the election itself: www.dailymotion.com/video/x5499qe_the-west-wing-season-7-episode-13-the-cold_tv?start=174
How fitting that the last 2 ppl that leo talked to on screen was the president and josh.
If margaret could only have been the thrid, it would have been very cool.
@@jayazathoth8530 Is that written somewhere? I'd like to read it ... :)
@commodorekyle Vinnick was an 'ideal' republican, just like Bartlett was an 'ideal' democrat
Matt Santos was a great character but this was one of those scene where I was rooting for Vinick to win the election. Santos was talking about effects on the election and their administrations but Vinick was interested in the bigger picture.
Makes me wonder if this moment is what Santos recalled when considering Vinick for his Cabinet
They were never going to let a republican win that election, even though two consecutive Dem administrations fly in the face of the last 80 years of US history.
@@randolphkersey5155 Actually originally Vinick was going to win. But the death of John Spencer made them alter it feeling that both the death of Leo and losing would be too cruel to the fans.
When I was in high school, my AP US History teacher told us that a common theme across many presidents throughout the years has been foreign affairs getting in the way of domestic agendas.
Excellent television... I miss those days...
It was in that room, that Santos knew who his Secretary of State would be
@MikeJames6 He wasn't going to originally, but John Spencer died, and they felt from a story perspective it would be too cruel for him to lose and his VP pick to die.
It's a subtle nuance, but I like the way that Santos and Vinnick don't share each other point of view and still acknowledge the validity of each other's points.
Like when Vinnick asks about the costs and Santos says it doesn't matter. Vinnick persists, the President drops the price tag and Santos gets a look on his face that says, "Yeah, that matters."
This is probably what planted the seed in Santos' head about Vinnick becoming Secretary of State. Vinnick looks astute and intelligent on foreign policy, which is hard to say about most Republicans.
Vinick has ZERO interest in foreign politics!
...Not saying that's a bad thing. But it's a choice.
🤷🏼♂️
3:58 “I suggest you both start giving it some thought.” Oh wow, yep, thanks, good advice, not sure either of us would've got there on our own. 🤣🤣 Master of understatement
I love The West Wing but it’s hard to watch it now since it is so very far from reality. The world where politicians like Bartlett, Santos and Vinnick could even theoretically exist has long passed. Yea I know it’s fiction but in 2020 the actions and motivations behind policies of people the show presents us doesn’t even seem remotely possible anymore. Vinnick saying goodbye to his tax cut for example. If this happened today, He would still cut taxes and send in the troops. He wouldn’t feel conflicted about it at all. This show for the most part portrays both Democrats and Republicans as having some sort of moral and ethical foundation from which their policies emanate. Today, it’s all grift for profit and rank hypocrites.
That's because in 2020 the President would be going to war just for the satisfaction of screwing over his successor.
Nailed it...sadly.
"...and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth." ... The last words of President Lincoln's Gettysburg Address in 1863.
I agree that the quality of character exhibited by a lot of those now in the Federal government is down so low. But I don't believe it's necessarily gone forever. Per Lincoln's words, it's up to us to do what it takes to get it back.
Actually, watching the West Wing twice in the last 4 years because sometimes it paralleled reality. I know we don't get a Bartlet anywhere in the real world, but some of the politics were so convincingly close to present day, I watched it all the way through twice at the start and end of Trump's Presidency. My husband and I would chuckle at the stuff that went on (including the biological attack in the White House vs COVID) because it was so damn close.
You say you know it's fiction and then go on to say it's not even close to reality. Well no kidding. Do you also watch movies about the civil war and then go on to complain that we don't fight that way anymore? How about WW2 when we had battleships out fighting. We don't have any now so that's another fallacy I suppose.
Senator Organa(?)
Yep. At least he didn't Bail 😄
Still want this job, gentlemen?
Fuck That!!!! LOL!!!!
It sure as fuck isn't for the timid.
I love the shot at the very end of them staring at the President's desk, pretty much asking themselves that question...
4:22
"1, 2, 3...NOT PRESIDENT!!!"
lol
Best comment on here.
Wait! Do it again! I wasn't ready.
This scene makes the Secretary of State offer really seem like it could work.
Later on
Vinnick: "The fact that we both want this job makes us nuts right?"
Santos: "Absolutely"
Is that a quote?
0:32 The last line John Spencer gave.
Vinick was the best. Period.
I never got a close look. Did they use a version of the Resolute Desk on the show?
Love the whip-cracking dialogue in this scene.
The two candidates are confronted with the reality of the choices facing a President. Sometimes there are no easy fixes or happy solutions. The world is a messy place filled with compromises, least bad options and grey areas. It certainly is not a reality show.
Can almost feel the weight of the office in this scene...
I was never a fan of Jimmy Smits, but he does better than I thought he would. As for Alan Alda, that was a great choice, & as always, he's a pro. Watching this for the 1st time, was utterly engaging, & all too believable. -------------------MJL, 75 y/o
Watching this scene makes it obvious that the reality TV star that is now our president-elect is in way, WAY over his head. Do you think that The Donald could even name a "former Soviet central Asian republic?" I don't think so. Maybe he can get someone to tweet him the answer. We're screwed.
Libtard cry baby.
I don't debate your general sentiment, but don't forget that the President has made millions in a couple of those former Soviet central Asian republics.
@@WilliamPitcher Which makes him beholden to the oligarchs that run said former Soviet central Asian republics and therefor a security risk and unfit to be president.
@@DT-hp8de that's your response? Well, you sure persuaded me.
@@blastermasterguy If he's already made the money, however many years before he took office, how would he still be beholden?
Also, as a registered Democrat, I'm actually glad Trump is previously wealthy in one sense: it removes a vector for corruption that has before and doubtless again will affect other Presidents of the Republic.
this is a conversation that never would happen. I wish we had a president that could do this. The hand over of power with a real understanding of what is going on in the world.
As far as I know all the presidents in recent history(except Nixon) have offered help/advice to the presidents elect.Most accepted,even Trump.
Candidates of both parties get security/intelligence briefing before the general election day
I really miss this show. I wish they’d gone a couple more seasons. It would’ve been interesting to see how Pres. Santos and Sec. Vinnick would work together.
This is a series that deserves a reboot
Considering the disaster in Afghanistan this past year we now know what a political exit strategy resembles.
“Thanks for coming in”. How many times did Jimmy Smits say that to other characters in NYPD Blue? Interesting to see it relayed to him.
Wish this series continued with Jimmy Smits and Alan Alda.
The writers missed an opportunity here to show the candidates in a different light. Imagine this scene if Vinnick asked the military question and Santos followed with the diplomatic question. It would have showed that both candidates understanding that they couldn’t ignore the other side argument in situations like this.
Having watched both this series and Netflix's House of Cards a few years later, I'm struck at the contrast in how both shows present similar subject matter. The West Wing presents a very optimistic view of politics, where people often disagree on the approach but are still working toward the same goal and can work together, or at least be civil toward one another. Meanwhile, House of Cards presents a far darker and more cynical view of politics, where everyone is ruthless and the only rule is, as Frank Underwood put it, "hunt or be hunted."
The Netflix House of Cards was based on the UK House of Cards featuring Francis Urquhart and his rise to power after the Thatcher years. It was released in 1990 and based on a book from '89. The dark, cynical version of politics came first.
Alda was definitely a great addition, I wish WW had kept on
What a magnificent acting scene
It still seems a fantasy to expect our politicians to act in noble, ethical and altruistic ways, but that is not the way of our world. I wish Sorkin's dream was reality.
This scenario has nothing whatever to do with Sorkin. He left the show three years earlier.
@Jim Dandy ... Though that didn't happen it is literally the President's job to ensure that the country isn't handed over to a criminal. If there was such an investigation we wouldn't be in the mess we are in now with a dangerously unstable known criminal and his crime family occupying the White House.
i just noticed that as Bartlett is leaving, both Santos and Vinnick are just staring at his desk…
The best TV ever, my brain just can’t cope with the thought of Trump sitting amongst these characters
Vinnick is brilliant
*_"There goes my tax cut."_*
Most unrealistic line ever.
Wish we had leaders like this in real life..
Santos making Vinick his Sec of State was brilliant.
The thumbnail for this looks like it caught Bartlett mid shit.
He's played president elect Santos, Amy's dad in B99, but to me he'll always be Miguel Prado from Dexter...
"70 billion, there goes our priorities!"
That's hilarious. We spent that much every 8 months in Afghanistan for 20 years, and it bought us nothing.
and yet every time the democrats try to accomplish anything meaningful, they get wrecked by the moderates and the republicans who cry deficit...
Well times inflation rates because that's 90s or early 2000s money today it alot more
The problem with anything military is there is no guarantee we will win especially in the ward's we fight now. Take the GWOT it's still on going Iraq and Afghanistan may have largely ended but the war still goes on in different places.
@@808INFantry11X yeah but even with inflation 70 billion doesn't become 2 trillion. Not even close.
@@bridgecross 22 trillion was the total cost I'm talking about over period of about 20 years 70 billion is the right trajectory every fiscal year conservatively to make 2 trillion not including other contingency spending on a case by case basis.
"First 12 months: $70 billion..." Let that sink in for a moment
I would have Voted for Arnie Vinick
This conversation got Vinick Secretary of State
I like that in the last shot they both look like "Suddenly I don't want to have that job anymore..."
No matter a candidate's politics, everything changes when they sit down behind THAT desk.
Predicting the future now?
This is the first moment Vinick realises that he could be part of a Santos administration
It's also the moment Santos knows Vinick must be part of his Administration
Try as I might, it's very hard to imagine Trump having a conversation like this with a republican successor and a democratic opponent. This was statesmanlike and realistic. Politics were off the table and it was what are we going to do and which one of us is going to have to do it. Why can't we elect fictional characters? Because I would take Santos, vinick, or Bartlett any day of the week over what we have now
Try as I might, it's very hard to imagine Trump having a conversation.
If I was one of them "man, you can have it" and then it would turn into a fight about who should lose the election.
Man, a timeline where you have to choose between Franklin “Hawkeye” Pierce or Bail Organa for President of the United States really doesn’t sound so bad.
The Star Wars Election.
And the Democratic ticket is the "L.A. Law" ticket.
His name is Benjamin Franklin "Hawkeye" Pierce.
Alan Alda has been various characters in the White House so many times you would think he has past experience in politics.
The President in Canadian Bacon.
Chief of Staff in Murder at 1600.
Senator in West Wing.
Also a Senator in The Aviator.
you see how he just left the presidential candidates in the oval office?