@@little7redify oh yes. Carlyle has openly spoke about the differences not just between Gold & Rumple, but Rumple in different realms. He indicated that the writers/director/producers gave him free reign to improvise the different personas and nuances. A wise choice as he did them all so well.
Robert Carlyle was brilliant in this show. His exuberance when playing Rumple and then switching to a more controlled temperament as Mr. Gold. And Regina was just absolutely stunning and sexy.
I love how Wish Rumple doesn't miss a beat. He realizes Regina isn't Wish Regina, and instantly starts manipulating her without a second of hesitation. She knows he's playing her, but that's the beauty of Rumple. He has something that she needs, and there is literally no other way then to let him manipulate her. She tries to get the info she needs without releasing him, but he always has a plan B. They really did waste Wish Rumple. He could've been great.
This Rumple failed to get Regina to cast the Dark Curse, so he could never get to a World without Magic to save Baelfire. Plus, he never knew what became of Belle. Afterward, we find out that the Wish Realm Regina had let her starve to death in her castle.
He played her like a fiddle. The second he saw her he knew that he was getting out. He knew exactly which buttons to push, when to press, when to let off, when to be desperate, and when to be in control. She really should've known better. What's the harm in letting a not real him out of a not real prison into a note real world? Everything! He's Rumple-goddamn-Stiltskin Regina. He spent two hundred years trying to find a way into a different world, did you really think that he'd just stay where you left him?
this rumple spent over 30 years in that cage most of the time by himself. he is also way past the point RW runmple had the darkness pulled out because his heart was going to go full dark. so its likely WR rumple is fully dark and crazy
2:00 Rumple walks out of prison / cage idk Rumple: At last 2:08 Rumple: "sniffs" it smells just as dank outside Me: what did you expect your only three steps away
Damn right! But I don't think Robert will ever get an Oscar for any role. He has clearly expressed his opinion on Hollywood. And if you don't kiss the ass of the studio bosses (who certainly have a say in nominating/awarding the Oscars), you hardly have a chance. Hollywood doesn't care about you as an actor, Hollywood cares about how they can market you.
can we just talk about how good roberts acting was? Like its rumple but you can tell he is not himself, since he is so eager to get out but not too eager because thats not who he is i love it
what do you mean? I love his character so much in this scene and I wish there was more of it, but what do you mean? That they haven't shown enough of his acting talent?
oh but he did play her to let him out and to eventually get wish Henry to hate her for killing his grand parents leading to what is happening now in season 7 he planed it all along, remember he can see the future
You know wish realm is weird cause for one Henry should not exist as Emma would never of met Nael in this also if Wish Realm is real then shouldn't the Heroes & Villains universe also be real?
@@DgardsGaming Honestly at this point I think it was just bad writing Season 7 wasn't supposed to be the last season but they didn't have enough money to make an 8th so they rushed it. If you asked me Season 6 had a better conclusion to the story and they should have just ended it there.
That's so true! And sometimes I wish there hadn't been a 7th season, everything was perfect at the end of season 6. Sure, one could ponder the Dark One's immortality and Belle's mortality. But why... 🤔😊 On the other hand, if we hadn't seen the wonderful and sad scenes of Belle and Rumpel's deaths, it makes me cry every time I see it.
Re-watching this scene after seeing 'Homecoming' How did Wish Rumple know about Storybrooke? Is that why he stayed so long in his cage? so he could meet Real Regina? Real Rumple had squid ink and could leave anytime he wanted and I thought it was weird that Wish Rumple didn't use the squid ink to escape and make a new plan when he realized that wish Regina wasn't casting the curse. But if his plan was to meet real Regina in order to get to Hyperion Heights
NightStar he knew about Storybrooke because he looked into the future to see what he needed to do to find Neal. Basically everything up to Zelena's arc is part of his vision
that was always a question mark and a hole they never got into how did emma get with neal. the only difference between WR and RW was the dark curse being cast.
There's a reason this Rumpelstiltskin was locked up. So that was a big mistake Regina made letting him out. Especially when he brought up the name Storybrooke. Regina should have hounded him more on why he knew that knowledge. As we see season 7 WR Rumpelstiltskin creates everyone's own personal story book. The OR Rumpelstiltskin sacrifices himself to Stop WR Rumpelstiltskin.
The episodes with the wish realm rumple don't make sense. His son was already in the same realm but rumple wanted to cast the curse to find him bc he couldn't find a magic bean b4 now all of the sudden he can. It makes no sense
I think in the Wish realm "Villains" dont get happy endings and only heroes, but in real realm both villain and hero get the happy ending, okay it so like alternate universe
After rewatching OUAT I’m curious as to why Rumple is still in prison. In season 2 he had squid ink in his cell and Emma used it to destroy the bars. So why didn’t escape when wish Regina failed?
Don't forget this is the wish realm, so the curse not happening was the alternate of the original realm, same with the squid ink, and we seem to forget that WR rumple is in a different cell in the WR, Most likely moved there, the they must have found the ink to move him or he didn't have the ink with him
There's one logical loophole here: Wishrealm turned real. Wish Realm Snow and Charming are just as much Emma's parents as Storybrook Snow and Charming. Emma is the link between the worlds, but the moment the portal opened, both became real. Especially, when we take the author and the multiple realms into consideration. So, Regina killed Snow and Charming. Not any fake, just not her story's version.
I have so many mixed feelings seeing Rumple is later seasons. Robert Carlyle was incredible at playing the character but the writing just seems so convenient and plain. Remember at the begging when tracking between realms was the hardest thing to do and magic beans were the rarest thing the world. Now they spring up like weeds exactly when the characters need them. Seasons 6 and 7 just feel so reduced compared to even season 4
I stopped watching the show in S5 and only kept up with the show through youtube clips... But did they ever explain how WR Rumple knew about Storybrooke? I mean Rumple is one of my favorite characters and it always felt like he could pull anything off.. But I wanna know if they ever actually explained this part
Should have watched to season 6. Season 6 Should have been the real ending. Season 7 most if not all think that season 7 was way rushed. We want to watch after the second or third episode but i think it was just exciting enough to keep watching. Lure you in and such. Like how they give Regina a good ending and how Hook with Emma have a child of their own, but they should've just done it as a bonus episode of season 6 if they knew season 7 be way too rushed and not exciting enough. Where Regina becomes the Queen of realms, emma and hook have their baby, Rumple could be with Belle and have a chance to be with their child like a fresh start cuz he did became a baby in the end. All of that would be all happy ever afters for them all.
The wish realm was created on a wish the evil evil queen made she just used the existing characters, to make a prison for Emma, so the actual story does not matter. Its not an alter universe, its a recreation of a present one with changes made to keep Emma as a damsel i distress
Wait is even baelfire rumple's son in this realm because he just found a magic bean in a day while the other rumple spend such a long time trying to find one to be able to reunite with his son
I'm not sure but Rumple didn't need just a magic bean but also a way to still have his magic in a land without magic so he could use it to find his son.
Okay so Wish Hook went to the New Enchanted Forest and was seduced by Gothel and had a daughter only to return to the Wish Realm. So if Hook was able to get out of the realm he’s real and so is the Wish Realm which must mean that somewhere out there the Heroes and Villains realm must be real. It’s like they simply took over the space of those people from those alternate realms. Yet it doesn’t explain how Henry can exist in the Wish Realm. I mean the Wish Realm follows the path of the original Enchanted Forest until the point where Regina cast the curse. And the curse failed. This means that Rumple lost his son and that his son would still have ended up in the world without magic, but because the curse wasn’t cast neither Emma nor Pinocchio would be sent through meaning that Henry wouldn’t exist because Emma and Neal wouldn’t have met and wouldn’t have had intercourse to produce Henry. It makes no sense....
@@Backup_Plan and let's not forget belle, belle was the only piece of love that this rumple still had, once she was gone nothing kept the darkness from getting through
![OUAT - 5x11 'You're the Dark One again?!' [Emma & Rumple]](/img/n.gif)
Robert Carlyle is clearly having fun with this character. I love watching him play Rumple.
although this Rumple is different than the real Rumple from the enchanted forest.
that laugh never gets old HIIHEIHEHEHEHIEHEHUHUHUH
@@Daemon1995_ Agreed.
@@Daemon1995_ It reminds me of a character from X-Men(?)
@@little7redify oh yes. Carlyle has openly spoke about the differences not just between Gold & Rumple, but Rumple in different realms. He indicated that the writers/director/producers gave him free reign to improvise the different personas and nuances. A wise choice as he did them all so well.
Robert Carlyle was brilliant in this show. His exuberance when playing Rumple and then switching to a more controlled temperament as Mr. Gold. And Regina was just absolutely stunning and sexy.
Check out his performance in Ravenous (1999), astonishing...
I love how Wish Rumple doesn't miss a beat. He realizes Regina isn't Wish Regina, and instantly starts manipulating her without a second of hesitation. She knows he's playing her, but that's the beauty of Rumple. He has something that she needs, and there is literally no other way then to let him manipulate her. She tries to get the info she needs without releasing him, but he always has a plan B. They really did waste Wish Rumple. He could've been great.
Is it just me, or is WR Rumplestiltskin more crazy than Main Rumplestiltskin?
This Rumple failed to get Regina to cast the Dark Curse, so he could never get to a World without Magic to save Baelfire. Plus, he never knew what became of Belle. Afterward, we find out that the Wish Realm Regina had let her starve to death in her castle.
To be fair, the wish realm regina was kind of killed/banished. Not a lot she could do.
Because this Rumple is still season 1 Rumple
Hmm I wounder what would happen if this Rumple met his storybrooke counterpart.
This rumple has been locked up alot longer because the curse was never casts
I can’t imagine any other people playing these characters, especially rumple and Regina. Such good acting.
He played her like a fiddle. The second he saw her he knew that he was getting out. He knew exactly which buttons to push, when to press, when to let off, when to be desperate, and when to be in control. She really should've known better. What's the harm in letting a not real him out of a not real prison into a note real world? Everything! He's Rumple-goddamn-Stiltskin Regina. He spent two hundred years trying to find a way into a different world, did you really think that he'd just stay where you left him?
This Rumple is crazy like not "evil manipulable crazy" but like "he is nuts crazy". How many years the not real one spend in that cave.
this rumple spent over 30 years in that cage most of the time by himself.
he is also way past the point RW runmple had the darkness pulled out because his heart was going to go full dark. so its likely WR rumple is fully dark and crazy
"Not this sniveling pathetic deluded creature i see before meeh..." - hahaha. that was gold
Lalique Homophoenix no, that was wish-rumple
No miss Jessy, what i mean is the Line and delivery is gold. Well executed...
Lalique Homophoenix i know, i was just trying to be funny, didnt work, sorry 😅
TheJessy8888 🤣
So, we finally see the repercussions of this scene in the series finale.
One of the many things I love about Rumpelstiltskin is that the characters know that he's playing them but they need him
2:00 Rumple walks out of prison / cage idk
Rumple: At last
2:08 Rumple: "sniffs" it smells just as dank outside
Me: what did you expect your only three steps away
Damn Robert deserves an Oscar for this role. ❤️
Damn right!
But I don't think Robert will ever get an Oscar for any role. He has clearly expressed his opinion on Hollywood. And if you don't kiss the ass of the studio bosses (who certainly have a say in nominating/awarding the Oscars), you hardly have a chance. Hollywood doesn't care about you as an actor, Hollywood cares about how they can market you.
You'd struggle dearly to get an Oscar for a television role. An Emmy, sure.
I must say, wish Rumple was always my favorite version. He always made me smile.
I love his reaction to the dress
Gave me the chill every time. Robert is simply too good.
I absolutely love rumplesiltskin he is so funny the best character in the show Regina is also amazing too
can we just talk about how good roberts acting was? Like its rumple but you can tell he is not himself, since he is so eager to get out but not too eager because thats not who he is i love it
This scene really put into perspective how much the writers had wasted Robert Carlyle over the seasons.
what do you mean? I love his character so much in this scene and I wish there was more of it, but what do you mean? That they haven't shown enough of his acting talent?
@@AntonConstanti Precisely, this scene showcases the extensive range that he has and the last few seasons have used him for very little of value.
True.... Especially in the last seasons... In season 1&7 he was epic
too much of anything, even a good thing can be detrimental.
@@Shiirow true
Rumple is totally playing her..
oh but he did play her to let him out and to eventually get wish Henry to hate her for killing his grand parents leading to what is happening now in season 7 he planed it all along, remember he can see the future
When is he not?
Like always
Omg this scene is so goodddd
BleedingGirl dont you mean it's so gold? 😏
Gabriel Louis Pelareja that's right deariee
In Regina's vase, even villains need saving. Which is another way of expressing redemption.
Rumplestilskin: What's the harm in letting a not real me into a not real world?
SPOILER ALERT!!!!
Season 7 says otherwise.....
Lol exctly 😂💜👍
Yeah I never undrstood that part, from what we see from season 7,the wish realm is actually a real world? not a not-real world?
You know wish realm is weird cause for one Henry should not exist as Emma would never of met Nael in this also if Wish Realm is real then shouldn't the Heroes & Villains universe also be real?
@@DgardsGaming Honestly at this point I think it was just bad writing Season 7 wasn't supposed to be the last season but they didn't have enough money to make an 8th so they rushed it. If you asked me Season 6 had a better conclusion to the story and they should have just ended it there.
Chania J. I agree, season 7 was pushing it. It had some good moments like Rupple’s sacrifice which I liked but overall just was unnecessary.
WR Rumple that giggle haha
And she looks amazing as the evil queen...
He totalky conned her into killing WR Snow and David!
1:40 I need that laugh😂
I wish we could have seen more wish rumple. This had so much potential and it was wasted
Amber Griffin we get to see more of him now! Lol
Regina is amazing as the evil queen or hero or mayor😛😀😛😀
Lets be honest, crazy Rumple is funny Rumple
Rumpelstiltskin is the only character who deserves a happy ending more than anyone
....
That's so true!
And sometimes I wish there hadn't been a 7th season, everything was perfect at the end of season 6. Sure, one could ponder the Dark One's immortality and Belle's mortality. But why... 🤔😊
On the other hand, if we hadn't seen the wonderful and sad scenes of Belle and Rumpel's deaths, it makes me cry every time I see it.
When he smells the air 😆
So much wasted potential with the wish realm
Until the series finale
ralfcrunch this comment was made almost a year ago so why try to be a smartass and correct him
true !
except the fact that Henry should not exist as Nael and Emma would've never happened
Honestly, it should have been a whole season, could have been nice swap of season 1.
This is what I'm now like, stuck in lockdown
I laughed way too hard.
Still brilliant.
2:44 I don't know why but this reminds me of Gollum from lotr
my preciousss
2:55 I love Regina ❤️
love this scene :-)
Re-watching this scene after seeing 'Homecoming' How did Wish Rumple know about Storybrooke? Is that why he stayed so long in his cage? so he could meet Real Regina?
Real Rumple had squid ink and could leave anytime he wanted and I thought it was weird that Wish Rumple didn't use the squid ink to escape and make a new plan when he realized that wish Regina wasn't casting the curse. But if his plan was to meet real Regina in order to get to Hyperion Heights
NightStar he knew about Storybrooke because he looked into the future to see what he needed to do to find Neal. Basically everything up to Zelena's arc is part of his vision
But in this realm Neal was in the enchanted forest as at the start you see his painting of him as an adult
that was always a question mark and a hole they never got into how did emma get with neal. the only difference between WR and RW was the dark curse being cast.
Rumple make the first curse.. And he look to the future to See who's the savoir.. Idk😅😅
plot hole?
I just LOVE rumple sooo much❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
It’s basically the once upon a time version of Gollum.
Yes but more sneaky and manipulative
There's a reason this Rumpelstiltskin was locked up. So that was a big mistake Regina made letting him out. Especially when he brought up the name Storybrooke. Regina should have hounded him more on why he knew that knowledge. As we see season 7 WR Rumpelstiltskin creates everyone's own personal story book. The OR Rumpelstiltskin sacrifices himself to Stop WR Rumpelstiltskin.
U underestimate how smart Rumpelstiltskin is he would of known what she would of been doing and would of got even more information out of her
The episodes with the wish realm rumple don't make sense. His son was already in the same realm but rumple wanted to cast the curse to find him bc he couldn't find a magic bean b4 now all of the sudden he can. It makes no sense
Rumple might've wanted to cast the curse for different reasons in this realm. The writers said that since it's the Wish Realm, anything goes.
Thank you I thought I was the only one who noticed his son was in this realm
Ironic considering considering didn't rumple have squid ink in his cell. That in the real world Emma and Snow used to get out of the cell in season 2.
I love rumpled so much.
I think in the Wish realm "Villains" dont get happy endings and only heroes, but in real realm both villain and hero get the happy ending, okay it so like alternate universe
That laugh at 1:40 😂😂😂😂😂 weakkkk!!!
After rewatching OUAT I’m curious as to why Rumple is still in prison. In season 2 he had squid ink in his cell and Emma used it to destroy the bars. So why didn’t escape when wish Regina failed?
Don't forget this is the wish realm, so the curse not happening was the alternate of the original realm, same with the squid ink, and we seem to forget that WR rumple is in a different cell in the WR, Most likely moved there, the they must have found the ink to move him or he didn't have the ink with him
He was right where he wanted to be.
@@ryukthegodofdeath5906 true! It’s a different prison (in the evil queen’s castle). Why did they move him then? We’ll never know
If regina did not let rumple escape the cell he would have not be in the season 7
Not true, he had means to get out in real enchanted forest with the squid ink remember. its safe to say this one did too and it still be their.
I think Rumple has a little crush on Regina in her Evil Queen form. lol
There's one logical loophole here: Wishrealm turned real. Wish Realm Snow and Charming are just as much Emma's parents as Storybrook Snow and Charming. Emma is the link between the worlds, but the moment the portal opened, both became real. Especially, when we take the author and the multiple realms into consideration.
So, Regina killed Snow and Charming. Not any fake, just not her story's version.
Yep and Wish Realm Rumpel knew that
He really tried to manipulate her lmao
Ain't no try he did
I have so many mixed feelings seeing Rumple is later seasons. Robert Carlyle was incredible at playing the character but the writing just seems so convenient and plain. Remember at the begging when tracking between realms was the hardest thing to do and magic beans were the rarest thing the world. Now they spring up like weeds exactly when the characters need them. Seasons 6 and 7 just feel so reduced compared to even season 4
So wish rumple completely lost his mind
s w a n q u e e n
queenxthief i s t o x i c
I stopped watching the show in S5 and only kept up with the show through youtube clips...
But did they ever explain how WR Rumple knew about Storybrooke? I mean Rumple is one of my favorite characters and it always felt like he could pull anything off.. But I wanna know if they ever actually explained this part
Should have watched to season 6. Season 6 Should have been the real ending. Season 7 most if not all think that season 7 was way rushed. We want to watch after the second or third episode but i think it was just exciting enough to keep watching. Lure you in and such. Like how they give Regina a good ending and how Hook with Emma have a child of their own, but they should've just done it as a bonus episode of season 6 if they knew season 7 be way too rushed and not exciting enough. Where Regina becomes the Queen of realms, emma and hook have their baby, Rumple could be with Belle and have a chance to be with their child like a fresh start cuz he did became a baby in the end. All of that would be all happy ever afters for them all.
Please tell me the actor for Rumple got an Emmy.
that evil queen get up is 😛🥵
The wish realm was created on a wish the evil evil queen made she just used the existing characters, to make a prison for Emma, so the actual story does not matter. Its not an alter universe, its a recreation of a present one with changes made to keep Emma as a damsel i distress
Wait is even baelfire rumple's son in this realm because he just found a magic bean in a day while the other rumple spend such a long time trying to find one to be able to reunite with his son
I'm not sure but Rumple didn't need just a magic bean but also a way to still have his magic in a land without magic so he could use it to find his son.
Thank you for answering my question, I really appreciate it
In this realm Emma met Neal and gave birth to Henry, so Rumple likely wasn't trying to find his son elsewhere but willing to destroy many realms.
Now, that is scary...
Okay so Wish Hook went to the New Enchanted Forest and was seduced by Gothel and had a daughter only to return to the Wish Realm. So if Hook was able to get out of the realm he’s real and so is the Wish Realm which must mean that somewhere out there the Heroes and Villains realm must be real. It’s like they simply took over the space of those people from those alternate realms. Yet it doesn’t explain how Henry can exist in the Wish Realm. I mean the Wish Realm follows the path of the original Enchanted Forest until the point where Regina cast the curse. And the curse failed. This means that Rumple lost his son and that his son would still have ended up in the world without magic, but because the curse wasn’t cast neither Emma nor Pinocchio would be sent through meaning that Henry wouldn’t exist because Emma and Neal wouldn’t have met and wouldn’t have had intercourse to produce Henry. It makes no sense....
I'm kinda disappointed of how Rumple's make up has changes through the seasons..
In what way?
they do change on purpose too, depending on how dark he has been lately
But if rumple could find a magic bean, so why didn't he use the bean in the first place to get to bae ?
Why Rumplstlkin Locked
If it’s that easy to find a magic bean why didn’t he do it in the first place
Golden Eggshells Gone Spider out for fish xbuzzer Cancel
Rumpel couldn't find the bean if he could why didn't he get back to his son?
@@Backup_Plan and let's not forget belle, belle was the only piece of love that this rumple still had, once she was gone nothing kept the darkness from getting through
But how THE FUCK he knew about Storybrooke?
Madness qunic gin Curse Ed|Stimulation Thugs Mastro Emount cancel
why did they make those teeth so gross? 🤢🤮