India has smart engineers and scientists. Why not secretly reverse engineer it. I mean who knows? Maybe they are already doing it secretly, but it takes time
BMD's part-- Pad prithvi air defence and Aad-- advance/Ashvini air defence system Are the example that we can create Airdefense more then capable of S400. Search Swordfish radar system.
@@f9658 we are developing such systems, for example we have developed and deployed MRSAM with co- development of Israel of range of 150 km , AKASH NG (90 km ) and now we are developing XRSAM of range of 350 km
A few points - 1) This representation of drawing a circle of 400 km is not exactly right. You are not going to place entire unit of S400 at the same location. 2) Furthermore, Indian S400 won't operate in isolation. They will be part of the entire air defense system. 3) Detection range also depends on the size of the object. For smaller drones, the range will be lesser (around 200-250 km). 4) Introduction of S400 will somewhat take off pressure of reaching 42 squadrons magic number. The extra time could be well utilized to concentrate on desi jet programs (and perhaps buy 36 more Rafale).
Many customers of S300 and S400 have brought Pantsir or Tor short range systems to protect these systems from kamakazie uavs and terrain hugging cruise missiles. India should think about protecting these assets with close in defence and network these assets with rest of the radar network so that the radars can be kept off (protecting it from jamming) till the right momemt( till the target enters no escape range). No escape range is far lesser than the theoretical maximum range of the missile.
No need. India has lrsam, Akash and Spyder all integrated into one system. The Indian layered defence will be one of the best, if not the best in the world. AAD/PAD for pure BMD, then s400 with all it's missiles, then lrsam, then Akash, then Spyder. All protected by point defence fighters. Good luck to any air force trying to breach that.
We are also signatory to Missile Technology Control Regime (MTCR) which China cannot join because of us. So, our defence systems are continuously upgraded. Pakistan is going to be history in 5-6 years. so chill maro :)
I am sure that India is also developing such system at home. It would be much interesting if 'Simply Nitin' can do a presentation on such systems and on India's potential missile power be it the agni, bhramos or any thing else
Most importantly, the system counter balances the shortages of fighter aircrafts which India has. The fighters now can be used for offensive roles and will be released from defensive role as S400 will give the cover.
In terms of range, we already had SwordFish radar during IAF/PAF shoot out as well, didn't we? SwordFish also has a detection range of 600km. Yeah we dont have any missile with engagement range of S400.
Dear nitin and your team I wish to let you know that an average citizen will forever be indebt to such wonderful and condensed bits of news now defence nerds may find it boring but for us all this is the best defence news portal..... Best wishes in days to come team strategic news global...
Incoming objects from Pakistan cannot be detected the moment they take off. There is something called line of sight that no radar can overcome. The Indian air force desperately needs some more AWACS to ensure that low flyers are detected early.
High-quality video. Kudos to your production team. It is definitely not like those we see these days on other channels which are just crappy Zoom quality with bad lighting and audio, which hurts our eyes and ears even though the content is good.
We had major concern in the Punjab border where the supply of illegal drugs through drones could not be identified. Now we have the survellience system to keep them at check.
Is it possible to assess the requirements of such air defense systems to fully secure our air borders. How many such units are required. Is 5 battalion which India has bought from Russia sufficient or should we go for more such systems to further strengthen our air defense systems, especially in view of swarm attacks as happened in Isreal.
Both 40N6E and 48N6E missiles are SARH using PESA radars. In this day of age, I am not sure how that combination will be effective. Especially against countries with significant EW capabilities such as China.
Only issue with any SAM batteries are Geography. That's the topography in our east & north produces lot of ground clutters which in turn Guiding the SAM seamlessly makes harder. To mitigate it we need AWACS to provide consistent jam proof guidance towards the target.
Sir @3:05 you say, "Detect object taking-off at 600 kms range ...". Really? The S-400 radars are ground based. If they can detect objects taking off i.e. at ground level, why do we need AWACS?
We need AWACS Because they can move and provide the location of the moving aircraft to the fighter jets and may guide the air to air missile by data link connecting fighter jet to AWACS.
Hi, could you please elaborate what is the position of our country for ammunition manufacturing? Are we still importing it in huge numbers, is there any private players or is it still our highly efficient OFB.
Insightful as always. I can tell you are passionate about your work. Could a future topic be about strategic oil reserves and how much do they really help if a real war breaks out ?
Thanks for the insight and significance of the new air defence system S-400. Please explain about the truth of the usage of Chinese parts in the S-400 and how the rumour that Chinese can counter the S-400 systems easily or significantly.
Thank you very much Nitin Ji for, as always, an excellent informative narration on the new acquisition of S-400s but the PLA has already got the very same S-400s from Russia. How much of an advantage is this S400 to India then, not withstanding that it would have been a great disadvantage without it. JAI HIND.
these are highly mobile systems, can hide under the dense jungles of north east and easily moved. And as for pakistan, they have no such early detection systems in space.
India must develop stronger long range radars and integrate and make synchronous its network with the s400 and put multiple more number of radars so that there is no hole through which the enemy may enter undetected .
Indian Airforce has already shared it had detected and travked Pakistani fighters taking off from its bases on tge 27th of February 2019. Still IAF was unable to defend its airspace. The problem lies elsewhere, not in the range of India's air defdnce radars. That capability has existed for decades.
Nitin Sir simple and very informative about S400 it was awesome.. I had few questions 1. Why India cannot develop systems like S400 and others especially using TOT route. 2. Once these missiles are used can India produce them within India or we have to procure from Russia?Can you please talk about the same.
These systems are developed by nations who fought war outside of their border but india barely protect its own border so dont expect india producing such weapons because it requires change of mindset in political and military attitudes
If we have data of when they take off then we should use ML to figure out their patterns of operations, it will prove to be seeing into future when there is conflict. But maybe this is already being carried out.
Such high value SAMs will not be stationed close to the border, they may be good against aircraft and missiles but keeping them close to the enemy will make them vulnerable to artillery(tube and mlrs) and drone saturation. Also the small number of Spyder system is not sufficient for point defense of the S-400, we need to speed up the deployment of QRSAM with the help of Israel for this
The Govt MoD just declared today the location of deployment (Punjab Sector). May be its for deception. In any case, I had a question that whether Triumph can be used merely for its advantageous tracking capabilities? Can it be synchronised with over-all ecosystem for taking down adversarial projectiles through other other assets that IAF has? What is its level of integration with other SAM systems?
If enemies sent very older jets against s400 radar range, s400 's canister will fire interceptor missle towards older fighter jets and the interception cause a loss of missle for low value target.after emptied all interceptor missles enemy sends the 4th gen fighter or a striking missle towards us what is use of s400 in this situation?
Aftermath of balakot strikes , our Air defense establishment have learned lots of lessons and hope they have solved problems and Improve a lot , and will not repeat the mistake they did.
"Simply" Good Coverage Nitin! Probably that's "Simply Nitin!" Clear and Simple in Description! And, deserves Maximum Subscription! Keep up the Great Work Nitin! We'll all applaud "Simply Superb Nitin!" 😊👍😊👍😊👍
Sir, maybe we should "canonize" him! Deification seems in order, sir! The man is never wrong, always right, a blessing to our people, beyond Confucious! "Nitin is better."
What if an adversaries, simply kept firing barrage of dummy missiles,drones etc targeted at main land, will s400 manage to shoot all of them ? If yes then it's very expensive proposition,if not then s 400 itself is vulnerable to enemy's fire too.like in recent karabak war.Even the best defence system of Israel recently had problems in determining them and neutralising, if continuous barrage of cheap dummy missiles and drones fired at such defence systems.Though undermining s 400 is not possible,but in real war scenario, one has to be better prepared for unexpected situations.
You are assuming that india will only defend from enemy missiles but enemy knows india will also atrack enemies assets, so if enemy wants to commit an act of suicide then its a different matter
@@utubetruthteller of you see past responses of India,it's always reactive not proactive.so considering Armenian defeat in the recent karabak war to cheap Turkish drones is lesson that needs to be studied ,thorough .Had India proactively acted in the past or now many of border issues with both countries have been solved long back..
What if quantity of air born threats are more, I mean if it come to kill our s-400 system and they send about 50 low flying ( Kamikaze) like drone with bomb , does it help us
thanks for your thought @gokul krishnan. you can support us through several platforms: stratnewsglobal.com/support-us/ and subscribe to premium comtent on our website: stratnewsglobal.com/sng-premium-content/
He is not any defence analyst. He is just a journalist. Don't insult the hard working defence analyst who are much more knowledgeable than Nitin. Do you even understand the meaning of analysis ?? Nitin can't even tell anything about S-400 without looking at that piece of paper.
S 400 will finally go unscathed under CATSAA but the real issue is - will India be able to upgrade to S500, as and when available? Also, what deal we will have with US for not imposing sanction is another issue to be looked at. what price we pay for it! Good video by Nitin, as usual.
S-400 is definitely a game changer for us but we need to focus more to develop such defence systems in India.
India has smart engineers and scientists. Why not secretly reverse engineer it. I mean who knows? Maybe they are already doing it secretly, but it takes time
BMD's part-- Pad prithvi air defence and
Aad-- advance/Ashvini air defence system Are the example that we can create Airdefense more then capable of S400.
Search Swordfish radar system.
@@f9658 we are developing such systems, for example we have developed and deployed MRSAM with co- development of Israel of range of 150 km , AKASH NG (90 km ) and now we are developing XRSAM of range of 350 km
India is already into quantum systems in defense - generational change is coming
@@dhotrearvind No India isn't into quantum, India isn't China.
Get your poor out of poverty before ever believe that India can become a superpower!
Serious and unbiased experience...as always Nitin Sir rocks
❤️ Rajsthan
A few points -
1) This representation of drawing a circle of 400 km is not exactly right. You are not going to place entire unit of S400 at the same location.
2) Furthermore, Indian S400 won't operate in isolation. They will be part of the entire air defense system.
3) Detection range also depends on the size of the object. For smaller drones, the range will be lesser (around 200-250 km).
4) Introduction of S400 will somewhat take off pressure of reaching 42 squadrons magic number. The extra time could be well utilized to concentrate on desi jet programs (and perhaps buy 36 more Rafale).
Many customers of S300 and S400 have brought Pantsir or Tor short range systems to protect these systems from kamakazie uavs and terrain hugging cruise missiles. India should think about protecting these assets with close in defence and network these assets with rest of the radar network so that the radars can be kept off (protecting it from jamming) till the right momemt( till the target enters no escape range). No escape range is far lesser than the theoretical maximum range of the missile.
No need. India has lrsam, Akash and Spyder all integrated into one system. The Indian layered defence will be one of the best, if not the best in the world. AAD/PAD for pure BMD, then s400 with all it's missiles, then lrsam, then Akash, then Spyder. All protected by point defence fighters. Good luck to any air force trying to breach that.
@@ussspirit4812 badhia likha bhai, thanks for the info :)
We are also signatory to Missile Technology Control Regime (MTCR) which China cannot join because of us. So, our defence systems are continuously upgraded. Pakistan is going to be history in 5-6 years. so chill maro :)
Simply Fantastic. All the finer points were explained so nicely. Please continue to do more such episodes on high tech weaponry
absolutely thirst quenching explanation, brilliant. Live long and serve Mother India every moment, Nitin Dada.
I am sure that India is also developing such system at home. It would be much interesting if 'Simply Nitin' can do a presentation on such systems and on India's potential missile power be it the agni, bhramos or any thing else
We have prithvi air defence (PAD) and advanced air defence (AAD) bro. Our radars are co-develped with Israel, so the best in business :) chill maro
Most importantly, the system counter balances the shortages of fighter aircrafts which India has. The fighters now can be used for offensive roles and will be released from defensive role as S400 will give the cover.
Do whatever, slavery on the way.
Hindus just right make to number their heads
In terms of range, we already had SwordFish radar during IAF/PAF shoot out as well, didn't we? SwordFish also has a detection range of 600km. Yeah we dont have any missile with engagement range of S400.
in 2019 we may not had long range SAMs or might not have installed in J&K region particularly. today the scenario has changed to betterment .
We will change 350KM range XR-SAM by 2024.
Dear nitin and your team I wish to let you know that an average citizen will forever be indebt to such wonderful and condensed bits of news now defence nerds may find it boring but for us all this is the best defence news portal..... Best wishes in days to come team strategic news global...
This is important info explained in very simple words. Excellent.
Very good information. Factual, unbiased and non political. Best defence news for a seeker.
Lots of love and praise to simply nitin & stratnewsglobal . Wonderful job as always.
Incoming objects from Pakistan cannot be detected the moment they take off. There is something called line of sight that no radar can overcome. The Indian air force desperately needs some more AWACS to ensure that low flyers are detected early.
High-quality video. Kudos to your production team.
It is definitely not like those we see these days on other channels which are just crappy Zoom quality with bad lighting and audio, which hurts our eyes and ears even though the content is good.
We had major concern in the Punjab border where the supply of illegal drugs through drones could not be identified. Now we have the survellience system to keep them at check.
Is it possible to assess the requirements of such air defense systems to fully secure our air borders. How many such units are required. Is 5 battalion which India has bought from Russia sufficient or should we go for more such systems to further strengthen our air defense systems, especially in view of swarm attacks as happened in Isreal.
Tell us something that we don't know....same information is available in any random UA-cam channel.
Excellent analysis ..truly unbiased and candid. Liked it very much. God bless
Both 40N6E and 48N6E missiles are SARH using PESA radars. In this day of age, I am not sure how that combination will be effective. Especially against countries with significant EW capabilities such as China.
Only issue with any SAM batteries are Geography.
That's the topography in our east & north produces lot of ground clutters which in turn Guiding the SAM seamlessly makes harder.
To mitigate it we need AWACS to provide consistent jam proof guidance towards the target.
Excellent. This is my favourite channel and go-to channel for authentic information. Thank you very much Nitin Sir. Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Number of anti aircraft batteries must also be increased sufficiently so no excuse can be made for any enemy aircraft to enter .
Sir @3:05 you say, "Detect object taking-off at 600 kms range ...". Really? The S-400 radars are ground based. If they can detect objects taking off i.e. at ground level, why do we need AWACS?
We need AWACS Because they can move and provide the location of the moving aircraft to the fighter jets and may guide the air to air missile by data link connecting fighter jet to AWACS.
Amateur expert !!
Hi, could you please elaborate what is the position of our country for ammunition manufacturing?
Are we still importing it in huge numbers, is there any private players or is it still our highly efficient OFB.
Thank you Sir, for your time and presentation ❤️🙏
Insightful as always. I can tell you are passionate about your work. Could a future topic be about strategic oil reserves and how much do they really help if a real war breaks out ?
Bang on🤘🏻🙌🏻
🤙 S-400 🇮🇳🚀 !
Thanks for the insight and significance of the new air defence system S-400. Please explain about the truth of the usage of Chinese parts in the S-400 and how the rumour that Chinese can counter the S-400 systems easily or significantly.
Thank you very much Nitin Ji for, as always, an excellent informative narration on the new acquisition of S-400s but the PLA has already got the very same S-400s from Russia. How much of an advantage is this S400 to India then, not withstanding that it would have been a great disadvantage without it. JAI HIND.
Absolutely right, PLA has the system for longer and in much higher numbers
INSTEAD OF S400 India needs to strengthen and make its offensive capabilities fail proof and precise and more letha.l
Excellent Platform and very informative 👍
Reaction Video: 60 Minutes
ua-cam.com/video/pJBVukP0c64/v-deo.html
We would like to see more of these.
Satellite of adversary has the potential to detect or pin point the location of s-400. Please educate us on this point please 🙏
these are highly mobile systems, can hide under the dense jungles of north east and easily moved. And as for pakistan, they have no such early detection systems in space.
@@ousofrancis1783 well said , and also we have anti satellite missiles.
There are other air defence systems that will guard the S400.
It will be a network of air defence systems.
Good Analysis and summarization !!
Nitin Sir, it is Very Professional / Stretegic topic.
India must develop stronger long range radars and integrate and make synchronous its network with the s400 and put multiple more number of radars so that there is no hole through which the enemy may enter undetected .
Excellent analysis, as is usually the case with Nitin Gokhale. But it's a bit late in the day. I have already seen many videos on this topic.
Good for you India
What is the status of India made BMD system? Please do a program on it, Sir.
that can be integrated with S400's radar
One more weapon added to our army. #Jai hind!
Very informative and hopeful.
4:15 does this mean it would have destroyed all thier aircraft automatically 10 at a time as soon as they were detected taking off?
S-400 really a game changer 👍
Need more AWACS.
Do, radar accompanying the S400 is on the same truck which is mounted with this missile?
Can the Radars of S400 be jammed by the enemy ?
You should do a comparative study of all similar systems.
Thanks 👍
This will be helpful for India
There are ways to go undetected in radar one of which is flying low. Could you please elaborate/advise on this?
Indian Airforce has already shared it had detected and travked Pakistani fighters taking off from its bases on tge 27th of February 2019. Still IAF was unable to defend its airspace. The problem lies elsewhere, not in the range of India's air defdnce radars. That capability has existed for decades.
Great explanation. Thank you.
Nitin Sir simple and very informative about S400 it was awesome.. I had few questions 1. Why India cannot develop systems like S400 and others especially using TOT route. 2. Once these missiles are used can India produce them within India or we have to procure from Russia?Can you please talk about the same.
These systems are developed by nations who fought war outside of their border but india barely protect its own border so dont expect india producing such weapons because it requires change of mindset in political and military attitudes
If we have data of when they take off then we should use ML to figure out their patterns of operations, it will prove to be seeing into future when there is conflict. But maybe this is already being carried out.
Many inaccuracies in this commentary.
Indian S400 is more potent than the chinese S-400. China won't get 400km range missile as MTCR restricts missile exports to
Who is going to verify, do you think Russian and Chinese follow rule book.
AWESOME NITIN !! #JaiHind
The best among U tube presentations
isn't drdo working on desi s400 or xrsam as well ??????
Wah modiji 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Such high value SAMs will not be stationed close to the border, they may be good against aircraft and missiles but keeping them close to the enemy will make them vulnerable to artillery(tube and mlrs) and drone saturation. Also the small number of Spyder system is not sufficient for point defense of the S-400, we need to speed up the deployment of QRSAM with the help of Israel for this
The Govt MoD just declared today the location of deployment (Punjab Sector). May be its for deception. In any case, I had a question that whether Triumph can be used merely for its advantageous tracking capabilities? Can it be synchronised with over-all ecosystem for taking down adversarial projectiles through other other assets that IAF has? What is its level of integration with other SAM systems?
Thank you SIR JI ❤️🙏
Query what were the AWACS doing during Abinandann time, cudnt they pick up?
If enemies sent very older jets against s400 radar range, s400 's canister will fire interceptor missle towards older fighter jets and the interception cause a loss of missle for low value target.after emptied all interceptor missles enemy sends the 4th gen fighter or a striking missle towards us what is use of s400 in this situation?
He has good knowledge and understanding
Hellos from Algeria 🇩🇿 ✌️
superpower, game-changer are the two words which being misused on daily basis by indian media
Sir I love the way you have explained the S400
Great experience sir shot and sweet sir Jai hind
Kudos to Nitin sir and team.
We have our own air defense system like Akash based or PAD. How will it be used in conjunction with S400?
it can be integrated with any rader system be it isreali or russians because of its modular designs
The S 400 will be a game changer for India
Amazing analysis
Don't you know that China has already received S-400 in 2019 from Russia ??
Thank you Nitin Sir!
Great acquisition and news Nitin ji.🙏 Good lucid explanation. How does it fare against 5th generation jets like F35 etc. Please explain as well.
Aftermath of balakot strikes , our Air defense establishment have learned lots of lessons and hope they have solved problems and Improve a lot , and will not repeat the mistake they did.
"Simply" Good Coverage Nitin!
Probably that's "Simply Nitin!"
Clear and Simple in Description!
And, deserves Maximum Subscription!
Keep up the Great Work Nitin!
We'll all applaud "Simply Superb Nitin!"
😊👍😊👍😊👍
Sir, maybe we should "canonize" him! Deification seems in order, sir! The man is never wrong, always right, a blessing to our people, beyond Confucious! "Nitin is better."
Great insight 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Correction S400 version of US is THAAD and not Patriot missiles.
(S-400) game changer.
(Rafael) game changer.
(______) game changer.
Fill in the blanks changes everytime but the game never does
What if an adversaries, simply kept firing barrage of dummy missiles,drones etc targeted at main land, will s400 manage to shoot all of them ? If yes then it's very expensive proposition,if not then s 400 itself is vulnerable to enemy's fire too.like in recent karabak war.Even the best defence system of Israel recently had problems in determining them and neutralising, if continuous barrage of cheap dummy missiles and drones fired at such defence systems.Though undermining s 400 is not possible,but in real war scenario, one has to be better prepared for unexpected situations.
You are assuming that india will only defend from enemy missiles but enemy knows india will also atrack enemies assets, so if enemy wants to commit an act of suicide then its a different matter
@@utubetruthteller of you see past responses of India,it's always reactive not proactive.so considering Armenian defeat in the recent karabak war to cheap Turkish drones is lesson that needs to be studied ,thorough .Had India proactively acted in the past or now many of border issues with both countries have been solved long back..
@@alwynjohndsouza4261 i agree past Indian leadership is sheepish but i trust in modi leadership, he will give befitting replies to enemies
You mentioned that the missiles can travel at 17k KMPH which might be an error. This will mean nearly Mach 17 hypersonic missile.
What if quantity of air born threats are more, I mean if it come to kill our s-400 system and they send about 50 low flying ( Kamikaze) like drone with bomb , does it help us
Very educative
Great video sir
Jai Hind Sir 🙂🙏
Yes its a nice piece of kit made by a superpower and paid for by India. Much smarter than a all hype THAAD.
India Should build Lasers connected Air defence system like a shield dome
Good explanation !!
Thanks a lot
Jai jawan
Thanks sir 👍👌
I just now read that S 300 and S 400 couldn't target Israeli jets F16 bombing Iranian weapons storage dumps in Syria
Do you have subscription that we can pay?
thanks for your thought @gokul krishnan. you can support us through several platforms: stratnewsglobal.com/support-us/ and subscribe to premium comtent on our website: stratnewsglobal.com/sng-premium-content/
Mmmmm I thought you will bring something more about S-400 than what is already in the public domain...
Great...but sir what happened to our indigenous akash and prithvi missile air defence systems?
Funny part is China already has 6 of the S400 systems they procured in 2018. It would be interesting to know how they will act n counter act
Their system is inferior to ours. The range is lower than ours.
@@kantizx1 I have a hard time believing that
Best defense analyst in India
He is not any defence analyst. He is just a journalist. Don't insult the hard working defence analyst who are much more knowledgeable than Nitin. Do you even understand the meaning of analysis ?? Nitin can't even tell anything about S-400 without looking at that piece of paper.
S 400 will finally go unscathed under CATSAA but the real issue is - will India be able to upgrade to S500, as and when available? Also, what deal we will have with US for not imposing sanction is another issue to be looked at. what price we pay for it!
Good video by Nitin, as usual.
We probably won't need S-500 by that time, because DRDO's XR-SAM will be ready by then.
@@rajasmr156 Oh yes. That is in the pipeline.
सटीक विश्लेषण