Kinda bummed out with more negativity than usual in the the comments today. Yes, it's an extremely expensive palette (this is WTF), and you can totally live without it ... but I test products for a living and I absolutely LOVE it. But the one thing I value more than anything is my credibility with you guys - so I'm never going to put myself out there and say I love something when it's bad. I wasn't paid to make this video, I don't have an affiliate link and my opinion cannot be swayed with free makeup. So I'd really love it if we could steer the conversation back to something positive. Thanks so much for watching and your incredible support. xo's
I know I can never afford these, but I love watching these to see how they perform! You are like the older sister type that tells us what to use and what not!!
Love your videos....and love hearing your views on all products. I watch you because I respect what you say, and 100% believe you would never be swayed by items being given you. Keep shining bright!
Honestly no one will ever understand the amount of product you get and how HUGEEEE the pans are in the palette until you actually purchase the palette and see it in person. In ever video and picture the pans looks pretty small but I promise everyone that when u get any of the palettes in your hands you will be shocked at how huge the pans are just like I was when my big Natasha palettes arrived. After purchasing her two big palettes I went and bought her 10 shadow palette too just so I could own every single color she makes. And I can not wait for this Friday to buy this beautiful star palette 😍😍🙌🏻🙌🏻
yep! and you cant understand until you use it how good it is and then the price goes out the window. I don't use drugstore at all so i guess to me this isn't that much more than I would usually pay.
This palette is so beautiful. I'm not at a place in my life where I can drop $160 on a palette, but I love that I can come to your channel and have fun with makeup even though I don't own it. Love you 😘
I'm sorry, I'm lol-ing at the idea of these names being from Harry Potter... I'm not being mean tho, I swear, because thats the first thing I thought of too when she said the names! but those words were all actual words before they showed up in HP, I promise! "bellatrix" is Latin for "female warrior" and is the name of a star in the Orion constellation... a diadem is a crown, taken from Latin, Greek, and Middle English, etc :) the more ya know! 🌈😊
As a professional makeup artist, I LOVE offering Natasha Denona eyeshadows to my clients. They are superb quality and when you do the math and price them out per pan, they're very reasonably priced as a palette. Looks like this is another ND palette to add to my kit! Can't wait.
Also, in case this helps sway anyone on the fence about these palettes, the pans are magnetic and are easily popped from the palette using a cosmetic spatula. I love doing this when I only want to take a few of her shadows with me onsite or mix and match to create my own palette.
I think that is what people are missing. Not every makeup brand caters to the everyday makeup wearer some of them are strictly thinking of makeup artists in mind. Also isn't fall out with metallic shades just what comes with the territory? I don't think people are comprehending the difference between an eye shadow and a pressed pigment.
nya:węh Fallout definitely comes with the territory with pressed pigments. I like to apply these with my ring finger if I forego glitter adhesive, though you can create such a cool foiled, textured look with adhesive. This is why I LOVE these shadows. I will say the older formula is akin to the MUG foiled shadows, but you're still going to pay $250+ to own all of those! I'm really excited to try these new formulas. And I'll say it again: the ability to pop these pans in and out so easily is a game changer for me. The Purple/Blue palette has no transition shades whatsoever, so I will often pop a few pans out and throw it into a Z-palette to take with me on gigs. Makes it totally worth it.
nya:węh if you arent marketing to the average person, then why send so many to influencers? makeup artists attend trunk shows and shop in pro stores. let's not fool ourselves here
Could you do a brush tutorial all about the eyes and really go in depth with each type of brush you like to use on your eye for different purposes? I am always playing around with different looks on myself and sometimes struggle to find the right brushes. I find it easier to apply eyeshadow to other people but I struggle to feel good about my own eye looks. Thanks!
Tati, i love you, but this was not good. It didn't blend that good, it was patchy, and the foiled shade obviously did not work and looked kinda bad. It wasn't that sparkly once applied. You had fallout all over your cheeks during check ins, and at the end of the day, it was down to a slight shimmer, not a reflective foiled look at all. You usually look a lot better than this. So we know you have the skill. It's the product. I think you really wanted to love this, but it doesn't really seem like a great product.
imakefoodhappen, sadly I agree with everything you said. I did love a lot of the colors when swatched though, but the performance was not that great, as you said. I would like to see a tutorial with some of the other peachy/orange/gold type colors to see if I change my mind.
+imakefoodhappen I was surprised at her rave review. You could see that fallout all over her face in evening. Also, she did not do live swatching. We don't know how much effort she had to put in to make those swatches look that great. I just feel like something is up, giving an over-priced, lackluster product such high marks. I heard some of these gurus are secretly paid to give great reviews. I was hoping she was not one of them, but if she could give this palette a rave review it makes me wonder was she paid to do so - because it is clearly not that good.
imakefoodhappen sadly I agree, I think she wanted to love it but gave it too much credit. Especially the fouled shadow on her lid, it just didn't look good at all.
I agree with all these comments I believe she is being too forgiving and I dont understand why if the video clearly shows this is not a palette worth that kind of money. I am doubting her credibility I hope she is as forgiving with other palettes as well for example the Huda rose gold palette if Tati ever reviews any of her products. I am kind of disappointed.
THEY ARE PRESSED PIGMENTS people. not regular eyeshadows. You people pay $10 a piece for makeup geek foiled shadows and think its a "steal"...well these are less, higher quality, and MORE product. These are meant for makeup artists. Natasha Denona is a world reknown makeup artist and is doing fine without lowering her prices. don't want it, don't buy it but im so over the bitching about the price on every single video and post.... stick with your 10 different cheap ass palettes that you don't even use...it isn't always quantity over quality.
a lot of times the way the camera alters the way it looks on screen. Especially with shimmer eyeshadows it won't catch the color all at the same time making look different than it really does. theres a lot about lighting and screens that just affect the look of the shadows. i think Tati has really built a credibility up on youtube and she loves the pallet, I 100% know its an amazing product. :)
I don't like that it claims that it's a "No Fallout" palette yet it had a TON of it......I was waiting for you to make that point to us. To me, it's HUGE when a company claims that their product is a no fallout palette yet there's so much of it. I don't understand why they would even put those words in writing.
I've haven't seen that anywhere? I can't imagine they would claim that because pressed pigments are different than eye shadows. Pressed pigments are basically a loose pigment that its tightly pressed into a container therefore when you swirl around in them they will become a loose pigment. Think loreal infallible shadows that's why they have those little plastic top inside to keep it pressed down. If you took a knife to it it would eventually just turn into a loose pigment. The mattes were eye shadows and those have no fallout. I don't think people are getting the difference.
If you go to "readysetglamour" (Michelle's) channel, she shows you the card that they claim this on, in her video. I understand that there's fallout and why, the company shouldn't have made that claim.
Relax with the moratorium on Talc. Very few people have any actual sensitivity to it, and no, it doesn't cause cancer. Its unique rating of 1 on the Mohs scale of hardness and ability to absorb oil makes it a valuable addition to any company's formulary arsenal.
Leuca S. I'm not afraid to put talc on my face but I will say that when I checked the ingredients on my favorite eyeshadows none of them had it. it's a cheap filler. I do avoid talc in face powders though, talc based powders are soo dry.
Mira Aguirre it's a very absorbent ingredient, which can be a good thing for some people, like myself, who have very oily skin and benefit from its ability to keep your oily spots in check. Calling it a cheap filler ignores the unique benefits it can have when properly used in a formula.
it's worth calling out. I get cystic acne from talc (when a product is highly concentrated with it) and olive oil and almost nothing else. your opinion might be biased as it benefits your skin, but it hugely damages mine and many others'. not something you absolutely have to avoid, but worth mentioning as a disclaimer for those who are sensitive
It's called Advanced Radiance pressed powder. Mine is 110 creamy natural. It is so smoothing for the fine lines under the eyes. Seriously, I've tried all the expensive setting powder, IT cosmetics, Laura Mercier, etc. But I still go back to this original one I got from Rite Aid lol
I'm always looking out for new under eye powders as I suffer from creasing so I deffo need to check this one out!💕 I have a channel also!☺️🙋🏻 I would love it if you had a second to have a quick look!👏🏼 I have just posted a new video!💕
Tati, you are such a beautiful beauty guru & i lovee your content! i know this wont make the haters stop and not try and get to you, but you are amazing. inside and out. if you are reading this, you are my absolute favorite youtuber to watch, in all aspects of youtube. you are so positive and ik your backgroud and you just built yourself up from nothing and that inspires me. you inspire me to do my makeup everyday bc u made it fun for me! u tought me how to do things seemlessly & its just so much fun to do makeup!
okay im sorry i love tati but this pallet is not good..especially for the price. she had glitter all over her face in the check ins which yes she did say there was fall out but still i mean $169... plus the "earth" brown and the glitter were patchy. of course these are my opinions and obviously i cant see them in person but it does make me a little sad that she is raving when theres really nothing special here or even really that good
Not saying she faked her review...but if that was a Wet and Wild product, it would have gone in her trash! Come on...when was the last time she raved over cheaper items? Back when she used Kiko shadows, probably.
Gotta be honest.. this really didn't look at all worth the price tag. I'm surprised at Tati thoughts and views on it . Not sure how this makes me feel. Conflicted 😐
+Charlene clingan it's worth it if you demand that your matte shades blend to perfection with zero hard work ... the mattes are even better than Tom Ford ... the shimmers have fallout yes - but still gorgeous shades & if I use a glitter primer it would have been no prob. But I get it lol it's a lot of $$$ for one palette
Just seems like a lot of the shades are similar, which is odd. Just looking at the palette if you pause at 1:09 there's three golds, two dark browns, two cranberries, two taupes, two pinky-browns and FOUR peachy/light browns. I get the finishes are different, etc...But for a $169 palette I'd expect far more variety than that.
I safely assume that the ones who said bad comments about the price of this palette, obviously never watch the whole series of Tati's WTF. I mean, it's all about the splurge. Don't mind them Tati, I really like how you were very happy with this palette and I can see that this is worth the splurge :D Now i know which palette i should buy if i have the money ;) Keep doing this! Love your look as usual
ttlovesyou No, these are way better quality than ABH, these shadows are pretty much as good quality as it gets. I'm poor, but if i was rich I wouldn't be mad paying that price, it'd be worth it. But its defo not one for us average folk, I feel like $100 even would be more reasonable, I get it being priced a lot but $160 is very overkill to me. Regardless, amazing palette, wish I had the cash to spend that much and not care haha
my husband got the metal matte for me for a wedding gift. I swatched it the morning of the wedding after opening my gift and set aside my Marc Jacobs gold palette for the KVD to use for my makeup that day. it's seriously the best palette I've gotten. I still love the Marc Jacobs though lol
sigh, it's literally only $9 per shadow(with good quality) and it also comes with a generous mirror. splurge on what you want but it honestly isnt that insane. it's only your preference of color that will matter most..
literally "only" $9+ per shadow. $9 per shadow is NOT cheap. Especially not when it's $9x18. There are so many palettes, even at Sephora, with as many or MORE colors for less money. That's a ton to spend on one eyeshadow palette.
beccaisinvisible of course there are tonsss of places to get more shadows in a lot cheaper of a price, I agree! but you have to remember that you are also paying for the name and quality. if you are feeling a litle extraaaa, go purchase it! if not, there are tons of more affordable and almost equally as great options like you said
jeannie lee my point is that many of the defensive people her are acting like $150 is an amount of money that can be thrown out the window. You can't deny that that IS a lot to spend on a palette and to be quite honest, it's insulting to people who can't afford it to act like it's so casual. It's ridiculously expensive. It can still be worth the price that it is, but that doesn't make the price any less than it is.
I think people need to learn the difference between an eye shadow and a pressed pigment which most foil shadows are. You simply can't get that type of metallic color without some fall out. . Pressed pigments are basically a loose pigment that is tightly pressed into a container therefore when you swirl around in them they will become a loose pigment again because you are loosening the "pressed/packing" and it starts to go back to being a regular loose pigment. Think loreal infallible shadows that's why they have those little plastic top inside to keep it pressed down. If you took a knife to it it would eventually just turn back into a loose pigment. The mattes were eye shadows and those have no fallout. I don't think people are getting the difference. Just like you can't get a super matte liquid lipstick without some dryness or most red shadows without some staining. It just comes with that territory until someone figures it out. Yeah it'd be nice if they were just left loose and in a container but then you wouldn't be able to easily include those metallic colors in a palette who's gonna want a palette with 5 jars of loose pigment on the side. Especially since this is a brand that caters to MUAs and not the average person.
And you can see the glittery ones getting under her eyes at check-ins. I would expect something more if I were to go out and buy something priced like that ;/
+Hazelinka could've possibly been from before when she initially had fallout...cuz ya know glitter is the herpes of the eyeshadow world, can't get rid of it
+Hazelinka also its kind of patchy and didn't even swatch that good on her finger...I mean you could get tons of single eye shadows now in every price range and build a palette according to your custom needs, idk why people are still buying palettes
xxdiscoxxheaven1 I can't either. I mean it's pretty, but doesn't look $169.00 worthy. I can't justify spending almost 200 dollars on one palette. But these companies charge that much because they know people will pay it.
Romi Dá Ponte Hey, no shade, but if paying almost 10.00 bucks a shadow isn't a big deal to you, go ahead and do you. But I know for me, and a lot of other people who work hard for their money...this palette isn't worth the price.
I'm not feeling this palette at all. I see people saying it's basically $10 per shadow but that still doesn't sell me on it. There was too much fallout with that glittery shade and the brown shade used did not blend well in my opinion. I expect quality with a price tag like this, especially when you can get 35 shades in a morphe palette for 23 bucks, and those shadows work well.
Madison Lynn I understand that, but you can still get a smashbox palette talc free for less. So the price isn't really justified for the quality. If you have the money for it, and you like the quality than I suppose it could be a worthy purchase. for some
these are pressed pigments, not eyeshadows so people should stop trying to compare them as such. Pigments have fall out...they are to be applied differently. fall out has nothing to do with quality.
harial no they have two different undertones you can definitely tell, if you are a fan of NikkieTutorials on snapchat you can see the difference those two gold like shades
I agree with devarti's point; undertone of golds make a massive difference because i for example don't suit golds that are warm in tone and are too orange or yellow in tone, and i prefer a neutral gold, which is a slightly bronzed gold.
Let's just talk math for a moment. Just for all of the people who are complaining about the price. This is a HIGH END eyeshadow pallet. It is not meant to be a frugal buy. This is why it is a WTF video. Let's look at Urban Decay single eyeshadows for a moment. They are roughly 19.00. A little more for certain types of shadow. Let assume here that the eyeshadows in this pallet are roughly half the size of the single shadows. Even with cutting the price in half 18 shadows would still cost 171.00 usd. Stop being so negative about it. She isn't saying you have to run out and get this pallet tomorrow. She is giving her honest review on the pallet for fellow makeup enthusiasts such as myself to see if it will be a buy that would be worth it. Now about the fallout, she was honest in saying it had fallout. If she were being dishonest she could have made it seem like there was none. Some of these shadows are pressed pigments that will have fallout no matter what. Stop being so harsh on her for trying to bring something to the table for those of us that care about the more expensive pallets. This is clearly a wtf video. If you want something less expensive go watch the many videos she has of that nature. Keep doing what you are doing Tati. You are incredible and I love watching ALL of your videos.
Zoe Hurt they're out there, my poor husband knows now about primers, undertones in foundations etc cuz he is the one I talk to about makeup and he actually listens, he even motivated me to wear blue lipstick after I bought it if that's what I want, to be creative with my makeup if that makes me happy. I wear makeup for me not for anyone else and he is happy about it.
The plastic paper is part of the palette unless you tear it out, but I always prefer when the name is right under or above the eyeshadows in a palette.
Tati, thank you for ALL the reviews you do regardless of the price. I love to hear your opinions on all and it really nice to have your reviews before I spend the money. I trust what you say, it's too bad you have to deal with all the negative. It's a beautiful palette!
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 I have never doubted your honesty when you are giving us your opinions about products or about anything. I love those colors in that palette and I will definitely buy that palette if I get my hands on it. I love Natasha Denona eyeshadows even though I think they apply best on the lid with using my fingers. I only blend them with brushes. But the colourpigment is great and they stay on the lid whole day. Keep up the good work Tati, I love you💕
loving the new filming area so much. it creates a perfectly echoey sound and the light bounces perfectly without accentuating your imperfections. love you lots girlie and i'm so proud of where you've come❤️✨✨✨✨✨✨✨
Eileen De Luna And the Make Up Geek x Manny MUA palette has the same shade!! I love it. It has a warm purple/brownish base and blue reflects. So interesting.
I just got that wet n wild pallet yesterday. I've never used any eye shadows that the colors that had that much pigment in them. Be super light with the brush lol or you'll be washing it off like I did:) do the eyes before your face too, there's fall out but maybe I put too much on my brush
Wow Tati, I usually love your reviews but this one was not good at all! I don't think the colors blended as smoothly as you wanted everyone to believe & even when applying the foil shadow there was tons of fall out! I don't know if I was the only one that saw this but you had fall out on your cheeks when you checked in EVERYTIME!! I think you were so taken in by the brand name & because a really expensive high end pallete was GIVEN to you for FREE (God forbid we say anything negative). You were trying to hard to only say good things about this pallet & when there was an issue you said it was a fail on your part...trying too hard Tati!! Give me a break, your so hard and honest on other products but you have to kiss ass because it's a Natasha Denova!! It's $169 waaayyyy to expensive for us little people who didn't get it free!!
I agree. She said that the metallics don't work well on their own and that they're supposed to be wet. Umm I have wet n wild shadows that I don't have to wet. For $169 I expect the best quality with no fall out.
who cares if she got it free if you break it down each shade is about $9.50. as for the make ok have your opinion but don't bust her cause she got free stuff atleast she said it was free and she did say it was expensive. it's not like she was trying to hide the fact.
Here's the thing: I don't flinch at the cost of luxury makeup, and dabble in some Marc Jacobs, Charlotte Tilbury, and Tom Ford myself. But watching her rave about a sub-par product just because it's fancy and expensive is brutal. She's so biased.
The colors in this palette is like my dream, rose tones, mauves, golds, and a GUNMETAL shade!!! I'm ordering the Kathleenlights x Morphe palette, waiting for it to arrive, the color range is pretty nice but the 2 greens I'm unsure of, wish there were a few shades of blue instead :(
I just wish Natasha would reduce the quantity and the price by half. A makeup junkie like me would never hit pan on 2g eye shadows....Hence I will pass on it.
katylake212 Sorry, I meant quantity, definitely not quality. Stupid me! What I meant that I don't even hit pan on 1g eyeshadows, let alone the larger ones.
How could anyone really be negative about a video where you and James are so adorable? Watching you guys film stuff together while going about your day is one of my favorite things you do in your videos. It's always a precious little slice of your life together.
Could you try the smaller ones? it would be easier to splurge on one of those but only if the quality is the same!!! I have not seen many people review her line and would love to see more! Great video, Tati!
I have two of the 5 pan palettes and they are amazing in terms of quality and the amount you get. The colour combos are all very well thought out and work amazingly together. They are easily the most expensive eyeshadow palettes I own, based on the amount of colours and price, but also the best in terms of quality. I ordered mine off Beautylish btw.
the five pan ones that I've seen at Sephora have to be a different formula, though, because they do contain talc... that doesn't really bother me tho, so I agree, I'd love to see some of those reviewed!
Sitting here trying to find a way to justify this price to my boyfriend so he doesn't ask me why I need another pallette when I just ordered the Kathleen Lights and Mario Pallette 🙄
I'm a little sick of WTF to be honest. It's getting repetitive and it's not very helpful, at least to me. If I want to splurge on makeup, I would buy a $30-40 product. I'd rather Tati review something that is more applicable to her viewers - not saying she only has to show drugstore, but I much prefer her other videos.
Julia R well wtf is a series that shows makeup so expensive it make you go "WTF?". i honestly wouldn't say $30-40 is a shockingly expensive price. i know that a lot of other channels do videos with not as expensive products!
Julia R the wtf videos are my favourite.. I love her check ins, it's like a mini outing from my lounge room in Australia, lol. I love seeing how the products compare ect to more affordable make up and I'd much prefer to buy one high end eyeshadow pallet than 20 drugstore palettes that are shitty quality.. It's all fun! It gives me a much needed reprieve some days from the serious stuff and I thoroughly enjoy them! I hope you have a great day Hun. X
*coming from a positive place* I don't see myself purchasing this one! Maybe it's just me, but I felt like every time she checked in the eye shadow was faded more? I feel like you get more lasting shimmer from a colourpop super shock shadow, especially if you're just going to be using your finger anyway. My opinion is that if you like any of the colors in this palette, just get a dupe! I mean $9.50 a shade is not TOO bad but you can get a matching shade for cheaper still. :) Thanks for the review, Tati! Glad you will be able to find use out of it.
I like the that the palette has a variety of coordinating colors. Matte, transition, shine and glitter. I have to bounce back and forth through my eye shadows to get this look. I really appreciate you applying the palette for us to see exactly how the shadows will wear. $169 might be too expensive for me (I'm a .99 cent store gal) but I love the colors and the idea of everything you need for a great eye look in one palette. Thank you Tati
I appreciate and trust your authenticity, I remember reading an interview you did saying that was the number one thing you keep in mind for your viewers. I don't doubt your expertise
As a newbie to eyeshadows, I just can't handle the crumbly metallic pigments. Sadly, I don't think this is for me. But I do love my lorac pro, viseart and modern renaissance palettes.
This metallic shadow was way more crumbly than most metallic shadows... If you want some kind of shimmer I would recommend the Stila In The Light palette. Its my favorite palette for shimmers; they are extremely pigmented.
I'm not liking that palette. Usually, Tati reviews are accurate, but I don't understand how during the check in, she didn't see all the fallout on her face. Also that white shimmery eyeshadow looks so patchy. We can see her naked eyelid in some part. Also, I feel I can't trust her swatches as they aren't live swatches. The only one she did live swatch is that burgundy shade and it was patchy. She said that it is probably the best eyeshadow palette. How? I feel she tried to like that palette because it was send to her. After that video I feel I have to be more careful about her reviews..
Missbubblefishy the fallout was already there it wasn't like it wasn't there in the first place she even said the car light was shitty, ontop of that when trying to sweep away fall out not all of it goes away..... don't be so critical like she said she should've used a glitter glue, which most people do use when apply shimmery colors or even press pigments they will use a glitter glue. Why do you people always have something negative to say about Tati..??? If you want the palette and you need it get it, if you want it to add to your collection then get it... if you don't like it then don't get it. Everyone's going to have a different opinion and this one is hers so get over it
Honestly I think through the check ins esp when she was getting coffee with James and said she looks super glittery & she did not purchase it herself, it's somewhat like a hidden message she want us to know that it is not a good product yet she has to say some nice things for the product. I do prefer abh modern renaissance over this palette, price is too high, quality and color choice is just no-no. But srsly why would she say her face looks somewhat glittery unless she want us to get the hint 😂
I don't think you need to question her integrity at all. She gave us full disclosure that it was sent to her. Who is going to rail a "gift", and especially one from another UA-camr. But moreover, haven't you _ever_ had a bias in your life? Wanting to love something so bad you can't see it's not good for you? Loving a movie everyone else thinks is terrible? It's not a credibility issue. It's a load of influencing factors. But she gave you them all so that you can deduce for yourself where the truth lies. She didn't conceal that it was a gift, she was legit about the fallout and the crappy swatch, and that it's more expensive bc there's less product. She gave us full-disclosure, she just wanted to be kind.
The palette was designed so that the user could take any three shades across, down, or diagonal to create a cohesive look. Also, the price is high, yes, but it is also being offered for three installment payments and you receive the palette with the first payment--you don't need to pay it off first. That doesn't make it any less expensive, and making payments on makeup might seem silly, but if you really want this palette and $170 is too much in one chunk, that is an option.
Tati you are amazing, and one of the most honest person in the beauty community. If you down have nothing nice to say don't say it at all. They probably don't even watch every video you post. Please, do a tutorial how you styled your hair here, it looks amazing.
I just got my palette today and am re-watching your video. As a woman of color, I chuckled because you lament the fact that the palette does not have a brow bone color but actually for me "Vega" and "Flesh" are perfect for my brow bone. But still, there is no black. Thank you for your videos!
I own a couple of Natasha's smaller palettes and her eye shadows are beautiful. I bought the smaller ones at separate times when I could afford them because I really wanted to try her product, I just can't afford the big palettes sadly but I'm good with the smaller ones from Beautylish. Although I like her shadows I don't think I would buy the bigger more expensive palettes but I appreciate your review. I always appreciate your reviews even if I can't afford some of the products ;o)
oh by the way I just picked up the lorac pro metal rose gold palette at nordstroms. It was a steal at 28.00 and the shadows are smooth and beautiful, it is only 8 shadows but it's really pretty maybe you would like it ;o)
I agree with you. Honestly price aside I wouldn't get the bigger palettes cuz I ain't no make up artist so I don't use all the colours or will ever run out of any for that matter. The smaller palettes like what you said are amazing. It's worth paying for in my opinion cuz the quality is superb to me.
I totally trust tati's crediblity. She seems very sincere and genuine. I love these colors, I'm going to beg my fiancé for this palette for a Christmas gift!
Honestly, you and James are SOO CUTE!! I need to have my husband watch that part..your makeup is beautiful (opens door) , smiles at you like it's the first time he's ever seen you! Goals!! 😱✨✨
Maya Maxfield well I'm not sure where hers is from but they do have one very similar at Gap! It's a lightweight sweater with that high neck look... when I saw her sweater I noticed it bc I was just in Gap earlier today! lol :)
All these shadows are beautiful. I think it's better that there isn't a black because most people have a favourite black shadow and it means that there's one more amazing shadow in the pallet. Your makeup does look amazing today.
Lol oh yes...he knowsssss you are filming him...such a cutie, loved that he tried to rationalise the price for you. On the other hand it always amuses me how we look at it cost per shade in an expensive palette but not in a NYX or ELF palette as the price per shade would be toooooo small lol
The palette looks gorgeous but I was surprised you didn't comment on the similarity of some of the shadows. The burgundy especially look so similar I can't see why there's any need for them both in the palette
im sorry tati i just dont see how this is justified... while some of the super metallic shadows are unique and maybe 2 shimmers... the rest of these colors can easily be found ANYWHERE lol and with good quality... and im shocked you didnt even mention that the names arent even printed on the packagin... all that money and u still get a plastic sheet? lol just sayin... its pretty by not 100+ pretty in the least lol just sayin
✨✨✨✨✨✨✨ been watching you since you collab'd with Makeup Geek! I love the direction your channel has gone, your channel is only getting better with age babe! Keep doing what you're doing! I love you Tati ✨✨✨✨✨
I love this video! Her look turned out super pretty. I was skeptical first when she used that dark color to her under eye but when she zoomed out, OMG!
Is it just me or was Tati not being critical at all? From the moment she had the package in her hands, it was just like 'omg this is so amazing.' She had a lot of glitter fall out during the check in, and she didn't even mention it.
Thank you for putting yourself out there! You have a massive fan base and people who genuinely love and appreciate you-- even if they have never met you. I know, I'm one of them! Please know that you are wonderful, intelligent, and CREDIBLE! Thank you, Tati. You inspire me. ✨✨✨✨✨✨
did you note or record your browbone and inner corner highlights? no black, no highlight shades and it's really that amazing with that hefty price tag? that seems to me to be at least one big con.
Tati, I don't think I've ever commented on any of your videos before. However, despite all the negative reviews on this video below. I will say one positive thing, you are the 'mother' that we all wish we had, you're the mother of UA-cam. Never stop being you.
If a pallete is as much as my electric bill, it better not have fallout or any other problems. If some people want to spend that much on a pallet I won't judge, but lorac mega pallete is $60 for 32 shadows, just sayin.
I loved your eye look, the lower lash line really made your eyes pop and I didn't think it looked too bright! When I used that color all over my lid it built up nicely and wasn't patchy at all, but I agree, it doesn't swatch the best. Thanks for the tutorial in the video, I LOVED the final look!!! Don't worry about the negativity about the price. Your job is to report the news and the options in makeup and it's up to the view to decide if the product fits the qualities they are looking for and the price point they are willing to spend! XO Laura
I'm so disappointed in Tati lately she's been slamming the drugstore often lately and she's been 'loving' all her new expensive stuff, I love Tati but not been liking her lately
Sadly, I noticed she's been like that ever since she started the WTF series. I don't really trust her reviews anymore, I do however like watching her videos to keep up with new products (even though I rarely wear make up myself).
Amina Ajaj what's wrong with liking a more expensive product? Sometimes a product is worth the money. I don't see her bashing more on drugstore. She seems to like both drugstore and expensive products.
Amina Ajaj we expect her honest opinions on product reviews and 'WTF' is a playlist/theme on her channel where she reviews rediculously overpriced products, i highly doubt shes intentionally liking high end over drugstore lately, we just have to be understanding
Kinda bummed out with more negativity than usual in the the comments today. Yes, it's an extremely expensive palette (this is WTF), and you can totally live without it ... but I test products for a living and I absolutely LOVE it. But the one thing I value more than anything is my credibility with you guys - so I'm never going to put myself out there and say I love something when it's bad. I wasn't paid to make this video, I don't have an affiliate link and my opinion cannot be swayed with free makeup. So I'd really love it if we could steer the conversation back to something positive. Thanks so much for watching and your incredible support. xo's
I know I can never afford these, but I love watching these to see how they perform! You are like the older sister type that tells us what to use and what not!!
Love your videos....and love hearing your views on all products. I watch you because I respect what you say, and 100% believe you would never be swayed by items being given you. Keep shining bright!
Tati I really loove how you are honest with your opinions
Tati you give us honest opinions in every price point. Any subscriber knows that. you're doing great, lady. keep it up
Tati off topic lmao but what color is on your nails?
Honestly no one will ever understand the amount of product you get and how HUGEEEE the pans are in the palette until you actually purchase the palette and see it in person. In ever video and picture the pans looks pretty small but I promise everyone that when u get any of the palettes in your hands you will be shocked at how huge the pans are just like I was when my big Natasha palettes arrived. After purchasing her two big palettes I went and bought her 10 shadow palette too just so I could own every single color she makes. And I can not wait for this Friday to buy this beautiful star palette 😍😍🙌🏻🙌🏻
Xo Makeupjunkie_x3 I'm so excited my boyfriend got me the star eyeshadow palette for Christmas! I'm pumped! It's my first Natasha Denona palette! 😍
yep! and you cant understand until you use it how good it is and then the price goes out the window. I don't use drugstore at all so i guess to me this isn't that much more than I would usually pay.
This palette is so beautiful. I'm not at a place in my life where I can drop $160 on a palette, but I love that I can come to your channel and have fun with makeup even though I don't own it. Love you 😘
Some of the eyeshadow names are from Harry Potter...LOVE
I'm sorry, I'm lol-ing at the idea of these names being from Harry Potter... I'm not being mean tho, I swear, because thats the first thing I thought of too when she said the names! but those words were all actual words before they showed up in HP, I promise! "bellatrix" is Latin for "female warrior" and is the name of a star in the Orion constellation... a diadem is a crown, taken from Latin, Greek, and Middle English, etc :) the more ya know! 🌈😊
As a professional makeup artist, I LOVE offering Natasha Denona eyeshadows to my clients. They are superb quality and when you do the math and price them out per pan, they're very reasonably priced as a palette. Looks like this is another ND palette to add to my kit! Can't wait.
Also, in case this helps sway anyone on the fence about these palettes, the pans are magnetic and are easily popped from the palette using a cosmetic spatula. I love doing this when I only want to take a few of her shadows with me onsite or mix and match to create my own palette.
I think that is what people are missing. Not every makeup brand caters to the everyday makeup wearer some of them are strictly thinking of makeup artists in mind. Also isn't fall out with metallic shades just what comes with the territory? I don't think people are comprehending the difference between an eye shadow and a pressed pigment.
nya:węh Fallout definitely comes with the territory with pressed pigments. I like to apply these with my ring finger if I forego glitter adhesive, though you can create such a cool foiled, textured look with adhesive. This is why I LOVE these shadows. I will say the older formula is akin to the MUG foiled shadows, but you're still going to pay $250+ to own all of those!
I'm really excited to try these new formulas. And I'll say it again: the ability to pop these pans in and out so easily is a game changer for me. The Purple/Blue palette has no transition shades whatsoever, so I will often pop a few pans out and throw it into a Z-palette to take with me on gigs. Makes it totally worth it.
nya:węh if you arent marketing to the average person, then why send so many to influencers? makeup artists attend trunk shows and shop in pro stores. let's not fool ourselves here
I love your look at the beginning of the video when you have no eye makeup on! You looked so fresh and youthful! TFS💗
2012iwanttogohome i agree. she looks like 29
2012iwanttogohome she is naturally beautiful!
2012iwanttogohome she totally does! 😍
+Himmelgrau 34.....
I agree! :)
Anyone who doubts Tati's credibility probably hasn't seen any of her other videos.
Wow I just saw the swatches and the colors are reallllly gorgeous
kate d
zaz amen
zaz for real. she is always very honest about not liking products, no matter what line it is.
Exactly!!!! 👏🏻
Could you do a brush tutorial all about the eyes and really go in depth with each type of brush you like to use on your eye for different purposes? I am always playing around with different looks on myself and sometimes struggle to find the right brushes. I find it easier to apply eyeshadow to other people but I struggle to feel good about my own eye looks. Thanks!
Kristen Berrier oh yess
I would love this too!
Kristen Berrier ++++
yes!!!
Yes Tati I'm new to makeup and would love a video like this!
Tati, i love you, but this was not good. It didn't blend that good, it was patchy, and the foiled shade obviously did not work and looked kinda bad. It wasn't that sparkly once applied. You had fallout all over your cheeks during check ins, and at the end of the day, it was down to a slight shimmer, not a reflective foiled look at all. You usually look a lot better than this. So we know you have the skill. It's the product. I think you really wanted to love this, but it doesn't really seem like a great product.
imakefoodhappen, sadly I agree with everything you said. I did love a lot of the colors when swatched though, but the performance was not that great, as you said. I would like to see a tutorial with some of the other peachy/orange/gold type colors to see if I change my mind.
+imakefoodhappen I was surprised at her rave review. You could see that fallout all over her face in evening. Also, she did not do live swatching. We don't know how much effort she had to put in to make those swatches look that great. I just feel like something is up, giving an over-priced, lackluster product such high marks. I heard some of these gurus are secretly paid to give great reviews. I was hoping she was not one of them, but if she could give this palette a rave review it makes me wonder was she paid to do so - because it is clearly not that good.
imakefoodhappen sadly I agree, I think she wanted to love it but gave it too much credit. Especially the fouled shadow on her lid, it just didn't look good at all.
I agree with all these comments I believe she is being too forgiving and I dont understand why if the video clearly shows this is not a palette worth that kind of money. I am doubting her credibility I hope she is as forgiving with other palettes as well for example the Huda rose gold palette if Tati ever reviews any of her products. I am kind of disappointed.
imakefoodhappen thank you i completely agree not work it in my opinion
THEY ARE PRESSED PIGMENTS people. not regular eyeshadows. You people pay $10 a piece for makeup geek foiled shadows and think its a "steal"...well these are less, higher quality, and MORE product. These are meant for makeup artists. Natasha Denona is a world reknown makeup artist and is doing fine without lowering her prices. don't want it, don't buy it but im so over the bitching about the price on every single video and post.... stick with your 10 different cheap ass palettes that you don't even use...it isn't always quantity over quality.
you seem pressed.
Well, things aren't always as the seem. You'll learn that one day.
Boom! Thank you
Hot or not on the huda beauty palette
27chriii27 please!
27chriii27 yaaas
27chriii27 YASSSSS
Yes Tati please!!!!
27chriii27 yes please!! 😍
I don't know, but in my opinion it looks patchy on the eyes
I agree, the brown looked really patchy to me. I don't see how she didn't see that.
Sofia Aguilar I think it might have just been the video.
a lot of times the way the camera alters the way it looks on screen. Especially with shimmer eyeshadows it won't catch the color all at the same time making look different than it really does. theres a lot about lighting and screens that just affect the look of the shadows. i think Tati has really built a credibility up on youtube and she loves the pallet, I 100% know its an amazing product. :)
agree
I totally agree. I felt that the look isn't very blended. But then again, I am no expert.
I don't like that it claims that it's a "No Fallout" palette yet it had a TON of it......I was waiting for you to make that point to us. To me, it's HUGE when a company claims that their product is a no fallout palette yet there's so much of it. I don't understand why they would even put those words in writing.
Jennifer Dernai-Garavaglia oh I didn't j is. Does it say no fallout about this palette somewhere ?
Yes, there's a card that comes in the palette box that states there's no fallout in this palette.
I've haven't seen that anywhere? I can't imagine they would claim that because pressed pigments are different than eye shadows. Pressed pigments are basically a loose pigment that its tightly pressed into a container therefore when you swirl around in them they will become a loose pigment. Think loreal infallible shadows that's why they have those little plastic top inside to keep it pressed down. If you took a knife to it it would eventually just turn into a loose pigment. The mattes were eye shadows and those have no fallout. I don't think people are getting the difference.
If you go to "readysetglamour" (Michelle's) channel, she shows you the card that they claim this on, in her video. I understand that there's fallout and why, the company shouldn't have made that claim.
nya:węh that actually IS a claim that they make. Sephora and beautylish also have those claims listed.
Relax with the moratorium on Talc. Very few people have any actual sensitivity to it, and no, it doesn't cause cancer. Its unique rating of 1 on the Mohs scale of hardness and ability to absorb oil makes it a valuable addition to any company's formulary arsenal.
Leuca S. I'm not afraid to put talc on my face but I will say that when I checked the ingredients on my favorite eyeshadows none of them had it. it's a cheap filler. I do avoid talc in face powders though, talc based powders are soo dry.
Mira Aguirre
it's a very absorbent ingredient, which can be a good thing for some people, like myself, who have very oily skin and benefit from its ability to keep your oily spots in check. Calling it a cheap filler ignores the unique benefits it can have when properly used in a formula.
Leuca S.
it's worth calling out. I get cystic acne from talc (when a product is highly concentrated with it) and olive oil and almost nothing else. your opinion might be biased as it benefits your skin, but it hugely damages mine and many others'. not something you absolutely have to avoid, but worth mentioning as a disclaimer for those who are sensitive
Leuca S. i agree good for oily lids,
On a side note, that Cover Girl powder compact she is using for a mirror contains the best under eye setting powder I've ever used.
Melissa Elhardt whats the exact name try to google it couldn't find it
It's called Advanced Radiance pressed powder. Mine is 110 creamy natural. It is so smoothing for the fine lines under the eyes. Seriously, I've tried all the expensive setting powder, IT cosmetics, Laura Mercier, etc. But I still go back to this original one I got from Rite Aid lol
Melissa Elhardt please tell me there's no creasing and I'm sold!
is it the true blend compact? Correction I think it is the new age defying radiance powder
I'm always looking out for new under eye powders as I suffer from creasing so I deffo need to check this one out!💕 I have a channel also!☺️🙋🏻 I would love it if you had a second to have a quick look!👏🏼 I have just posted a new video!💕
This looks gorgeous.... if only it weren't so expensive. (Or I weren't a broke college girl, lol!)
Ally M keep working hard Ally, when you get that good paying job you will be able to buy any palette you want! Good luck in school!
Trish150655 Thanks ma'am! I'm doing my best! :0
you look so beautiful with that eye makeup and thqt haurstyle
+Mat Michele Thank You! 💋💋💋
ugh I still can't with your dark hair. LOVE it. I think I'm going to have to get this, it looks beautiful!
✨✨✨✨✨✨
Here, drink some positivi-tea ☕
Haha! Go right ahead :D
Don't forget the secret ingredient! 💕💕
arcoobabyrules you're the best 😂❤️
Omg you're so sweet!!! 😘😘😘
Thank you!!! You are so nice! 😍😍😍
Tati, you are such a beautiful beauty guru & i lovee your content! i know this wont make the haters stop and not try and get to you, but you are amazing. inside and out. if you are reading this, you are my absolute favorite youtuber to watch, in all aspects of youtube. you are so positive and ik your backgroud and you just built yourself up from nothing and that inspires me. you inspire me to do my makeup everyday bc u made it fun for me! u tought me how to do things seemlessly & its just so much fun to do makeup!
okay im sorry i love tati but this pallet is not good..especially for the price. she had glitter all over her face in the check ins which yes she did say there was fall out but still i mean $169... plus the "earth" brown and the glitter were patchy. of course these are my opinions and obviously i cant see them in person but it does make me a little sad that she is raving when theres really nothing special here or even really that good
because it was free and it is expensive!
Sara Arnold I think most was from when she initially applied bc she already had the rest of her face done!
Not saying she faked her review...but if that was a Wet and Wild product, it would have gone in her trash! Come on...when was the last time she raved over cheaper items? Back when she used Kiko shadows, probably.
Gotta be honest.. this really didn't look at all worth the price tag. I'm surprised at Tati thoughts and views on it . Not sure how this makes me feel. Conflicted 😐
+Charlene clingan it's worth it if you demand that your matte shades blend to perfection with zero hard work ... the mattes are even better than Tom Ford ... the shimmers have fallout yes - but still gorgeous shades & if I use a glitter primer it would have been no prob. But I get it lol it's a lot of $$$ for one palette
Tati I LOVE YOU
Charlene clingan I totally agree I think that she might be hyping the palette because it's expensive
+Tati thank u for being honest and mentioning thAt u were gifted this.....this is u I follow u cAuse u r honest if u bought or was gifted a item
Just seems like a lot of the shades are similar, which is odd. Just looking at the palette if you pause at 1:09 there's three golds, two dark browns, two cranberries, two taupes, two pinky-browns and FOUR peachy/light browns. I get the finishes are different, etc...But for a $169 palette I'd expect far more variety than that.
I love how Tati uploads five days a week because it is so relaxing to come home from school and watch a new vid!!!!
I safely assume that the ones who said bad comments about the price of this palette, obviously never watch the whole series of Tati's WTF. I mean, it's all about the splurge. Don't mind them Tati, I really like how you were very happy with this palette and I can see that this is worth the splurge :D Now i know which palette i should buy if i have the money ;) Keep doing this! Love your look as usual
Lovindy Putri Lebalado i agree if it dont apply let it fly
Lovindy Putri Lebalado
Tiffany Hines
noor fatima
noor fatima
For that price they better be perfect!! ABH has better palettes for cheaper
ttlovesyou Even Morphe has better palettes
ttlovesyou I keep saying the same thing. For that price they should apply themselves! 😂😂😂
ttlovesyou theres also less product in abh palettes ! 9$ per palette is not expensiv
ttlovesyou Clearly none of you have tried the natasha denona palletes.
ttlovesyou No, these are way better quality than ABH, these shadows are pretty much as good quality as it gets. I'm poor, but if i was rich I wouldn't be mad paying that price, it'd be worth it. But its defo not one for us average folk, I feel like $100 even would be more reasonable, I get it being priced a lot but $160 is very overkill to me. Regardless, amazing palette, wish I had the cash to spend that much and not care haha
Wow, Natasha Denona must be a fan of Harry Potter... "Bellatrix" "Diadem" "Phoenix" ??? Lol
Totally doesn't seem worth it. Super glad I got the KVD metal matte palette! The metallic shadows are to die for! ❤️
Candi J i love Kat Von D eyeshadow her original one blends like a dream
my husband got the metal matte for me for a wedding gift. I swatched it the morning of the wedding after opening my gift and set aside my Marc Jacobs gold palette for the KVD to use for my makeup that day. it's seriously the best palette I've gotten. I still love the Marc Jacobs though lol
It looks like you were having fall out through out the night...
So I'm not the only one who saw that
Jordana Vargas I noticed that too!!!
Yeah there was some glitter on her face later on
was it maybe highlight? Just asking
Shimmery shade is ugly, and the palette it self just is not impressive!
If I'd ever pay that much for a palette, it'd better had ZERO fallout. Otherwise, I'll just stick with my "100 colors for $20" palette.
sigh, it's literally only $9 per shadow(with good quality) and it also comes with a generous mirror. splurge on what you want but it honestly isnt that insane. it's only your preference of color that will matter most..
literally "only" $9+ per shadow. $9 per shadow is NOT cheap. Especially not when it's $9x18. There are so many palettes, even at Sephora, with as many or MORE colors for less money. That's a ton to spend on one eyeshadow palette.
beccaisinvisible of course there are tonsss of places to get more shadows in a lot cheaper of a price, I agree! but you have to remember that you are also paying for the name and quality. if you are feeling a litle extraaaa, go purchase it! if not, there are tons of more affordable and almost equally as great options like you said
jeannie lee my point is that many of the defensive people her are acting like $150 is an amount of money that can be thrown out the window. You can't deny that that IS a lot to spend on a palette and to be quite honest, it's insulting to people who can't afford it to act like it's so casual. It's ridiculously expensive. It can still be worth the price that it is, but that doesn't make the price any less than it is.
I think people need to learn the difference between an eye shadow and a pressed pigment which most foil shadows are. You simply can't get that type of metallic color without some fall out. . Pressed pigments are basically a loose pigment that is tightly pressed into a container therefore when you swirl around in them they will become a loose pigment again because you are loosening the "pressed/packing" and it starts to go back to being a regular loose pigment. Think loreal infallible shadows that's why they have those little plastic top inside to keep it pressed down. If you took a knife to it it would eventually just turn back into a loose pigment. The mattes were eye shadows and those have no fallout. I don't think people are getting the difference. Just like you can't get a super matte liquid lipstick without some dryness or most red shadows without some staining. It just comes with that territory until someone figures it out. Yeah it'd be nice if they were just left loose and in a container but then you wouldn't be able to easily include those metallic colors in a palette who's gonna want a palette with 5 jars of loose pigment on the side. Especially since this is a brand that caters to MUAs and not the average person.
$169 and two golds are the same, two browns are the same, is natasha joking?
And you can see the glittery ones getting under her eyes at check-ins. I would expect something more if I were to go out and buy something priced like that ;/
carrotsticks word😐
+Hazelinka could've possibly been from before when she initially had fallout...cuz ya know glitter is the herpes of the eyeshadow world, can't get rid of it
***** so i cant criticise makeup products now?
+Hazelinka also its kind of patchy and didn't even swatch that good on her finger...I mean you could get tons of single eye shadows now in every price range and build a palette according to your custom needs, idk why people are still buying palettes
this is so beautiful but I CANT. $169 for eyeshadow??
xxdiscoxxheaven1 I can't either. I mean it's pretty, but doesn't look $169.00 worthy. I can't justify spending almost 200 dollars on one palette. But these companies charge that much because they know people will pay it.
xxdiscoxxheaven1 agreed! 😳
xxdiscoxxheaven1 its not that much when u think about it. It's around 9.3$ a shadow
Romi Dá Ponte Hey, no shade, but if paying almost 10.00 bucks a shadow isn't a big deal to you, go ahead and do you. But I know for me, and a lot of other people who work hard for their money...this palette isn't worth the price.
Romi Dá Ponte 169$ is more than my living expenses for 3 weeks... that's a LOT of money
I'm not feeling this palette at all. I see people saying it's basically $10 per shadow but that still doesn't sell me on it. There was too much fallout with that glittery shade and the brown shade used did not blend well in my opinion. I expect quality with a price tag like this, especially when you can get 35 shades in a morphe palette for 23 bucks, and those shadows work well.
you look gorgeous btw, it's just the palette I'm not a fan of
No Talc in this makes it 90% better
Madison Lynn I understand that, but you can still get a smashbox palette talc free for less. So the price isn't really justified for the quality. If you have the money for it, and you like the quality than I suppose it could be a worthy purchase. for some
these are pressed pigments, not eyeshadows so people should stop trying to compare them as such. Pigments have fall out...they are to be applied differently. fall out has nothing to do with quality.
D pigment or not, it is advertised as not having fallout, which is untrue
Perhaps it looks different in person, to me the blending looks pretty sub-par. Looks muddy and a lot of fallout
and it had faded so much even by the first check in
I completely agree
CharlieStoleMyCookie I agree I have $5 eyeshadow palettes from marshalls that blend better
Patrick Bateman Exactly!
Tati do review the Morphe Kathleenlights Palette :D
Tati - you are seriously a breath of fresh air! So real and incredibly funny. LOVE your channel. Thank you for being YOU!
even if i don't have an amazing day today, hope yall have a fantastic hours to spend.
Rie Takahashi || I LOVE THIS COMMENT
Rie Takahashi Love this comment! I wish hope your day gets better hun! You are so sweet! xo 😘
Rie Takahashi you have a wonderful one!!!! 💜💜💜💜
Those two golds look identical.
harial yes...totally there are a few similar colors
harial no they have two different undertones you can definitely tell, if you are a fan of NikkieTutorials on snapchat you can see the difference those two gold like shades
These undertones are fucking nonsense...I want a rainbow not some different undertones it's 169$
Katharina Kopp actually undertones can make a lot of difference....however still not worth the price
I agree with devarti's point; undertone of golds make a massive difference because i for example don't suit golds that are warm in tone and are too orange or yellow in tone, and i prefer a neutral gold, which is a slightly bronzed gold.
Let's just talk math for a moment. Just for all of the people who are complaining about the price. This is a HIGH END eyeshadow pallet. It is not meant to be a frugal buy. This is why it is a WTF video. Let's look at Urban Decay single eyeshadows for a moment. They are roughly 19.00. A little more for certain types of shadow. Let assume here that the eyeshadows in this pallet are roughly half the size of the single shadows. Even with cutting the price in half 18 shadows would still cost 171.00 usd. Stop being so negative about it. She isn't saying you have to run out and get this pallet tomorrow. She is giving her honest review on the pallet for fellow makeup enthusiasts such as myself to see if it will be a buy that would be worth it. Now about the fallout, she was honest in saying it had fallout. If she were being dishonest she could have made it seem like there was none. Some of these shadows are pressed pigments that will have fallout no matter what. Stop being so harsh on her for trying to bring something to the table for those of us that care about the more expensive pallets. This is clearly a wtf video. If you want something less expensive go watch the many videos she has of that nature.
Keep doing what you are doing Tati. You are incredible and I love watching ALL of your videos.
My goal in life is to find a man like James who compliments me on my makeup XD
Zoe Hurt my gf does - and even buys me makeup that I use in my vids hehe
Zoe Hurt And who is happy to drive to another Starbucks just because you like that specific coffee! He's great 😊
Zoe Hurt I got me one of those! He loved my lime green eyeliner yesterday!
Zoe Hurt they're out there, my poor husband knows now about primers, undertones in foundations etc cuz he is the one I talk to about makeup and he actually listens, he even motivated me to wear blue lipstick after I bought it if that's what I want, to be creative with my makeup if that makes me happy. I wear makeup for me not for anyone else and he is happy about it.
Zoe Hurt my husband compliments mine daily and even buys me makeup (hello KVD metal matte!) these guys really do exist I promise ;)
I just wish they printed the names of the colors onto the palettes!
Katie Marsh yes it will be diffucult if you loose the plastic paper
Katie Marsh right? for $169 you can't do that? just a cheap plastic film lol ridiculous
Sarah Lauer and $169 is a lot of fucking money
The plastic paper is part of the palette unless you tear it out, but I always prefer when the name is right under or above the eyeshadows in a palette.
Tati, thank you for ALL the reviews you do regardless of the price. I love to hear your opinions on all and it really nice to have your reviews before I spend the money. I trust what you say, it's too bad you have to deal with all the negative. It's a beautiful palette!
✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨
Ignore all the haters Tati, you're entitled too your own opinion!!! Love you!!💖💖
✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨
✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨
(Snapchat family)
✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 I have never doubted your honesty when you are giving us your opinions about products or about anything. I love those colors in that palette and I will definitely buy that palette if I get my hands on it. I love Natasha Denona eyeshadows even though I think they apply best on the lid with using my fingers. I only blend them with brushes. But the colourpigment is great and they stay on the lid whole day. Keep up the good work Tati, I love you💕
loving the new filming area so much. it creates a perfectly echoey sound and the light bounces perfectly without accentuating your imperfections. love you lots girlie and i'm so proud of where you've come❤️✨✨✨✨✨✨✨
Hey guys if you like the blue-brown chromatic shade, the wetn'wild comfort zone palette has one that looks almost the same if not the same!
thank you for letting us know :)
Eileen De Luna yaaaas I use comfort zone too and I looove the duo chrome shade 😍
Eileen De Luna And the Make Up Geek x Manny MUA palette has the same shade!! I love it. It has a warm purple/brownish base and blue reflects. So interesting.
I just got that wet n wild pallet yesterday. I've never used any eye shadows that the colors that had that much pigment in them. Be super light with the brush lol or you'll be washing it off like I did:) do the eyes before your face too, there's fall out but maybe I put too much on my brush
Tati you have a great sense of style. Very chic and classy yet edgy. So unique.
Tati, I love the camera angle when you applied the eyeshadows! Thank you!❤️🌹
I agree! Very cool way of letting us see what she is doing.
Wow Tati, I usually love your reviews but this one was not good at all! I don't think the colors blended as smoothly as you wanted everyone to believe & even when applying the foil shadow there was tons of fall out! I don't know if I was the only one that saw this but you had fall out on your cheeks when you checked in EVERYTIME!! I think you were so taken in by the brand name & because a really expensive high end pallete was GIVEN to you for FREE (God forbid we say anything negative). You were trying to hard to only say good things about this pallet & when there was an issue you said it was a fail on your part...trying too hard Tati!! Give me a break, your so hard and honest on other products but you have to kiss ass because it's a Natasha Denova!! It's $169 waaayyyy to expensive for us little people who didn't get it free!!
I agree. She said that the metallics don't work well on their own and that they're supposed to be wet. Umm I have wet n wild shadows that I don't have to wet. For $169 I expect the best quality with no fall out.
Elizabeth Jaime i have the morphe palettes and their shimmery eyeshadows look way better than this😐
who cares if she got it free if you break it down each shade is about $9.50. as for the make ok have your opinion but don't bust her cause she got free stuff atleast she said it was free and she did say it was expensive. it's not like she was trying to hide the fact.
Here's the thing: I don't flinch at the cost of luxury makeup, and dabble in some Marc Jacobs, Charlotte Tilbury, and Tom Ford myself. But watching her rave about a sub-par product just because it's fancy and expensive is brutal. She's so biased.
Angelina Davila
The colors in this palette is like my dream, rose tones, mauves, golds, and a GUNMETAL shade!!! I'm ordering the Kathleenlights x Morphe palette, waiting for it to arrive, the color range is pretty nice but the 2 greens I'm unsure of, wish there were a few shades of blue instead :(
I love when you get super excited about a product because you just GLOW and I think it's beautiful!
Loveeee the colour you put on the lower lash line 😍 so pretty. I wish I was rich as helllll so I can buy all the makeup lmfao
SARAH JESSIE-ANN it was stunning wasn't it! I'm with ya girl.. Those colours! I'm going to have to save up.. I should have enough money by 2018, 😂😂😂😂
Hahah
I just wish Natasha would reduce the quantity and the price by half. A makeup junkie like me would never hit pan on 2g eye shadows....Hence I will pass on it.
Look at the patchiness. If the quality was reduced by half, it'd be a palette of fallout!
katylake212 I have a feeling that she Might've meant quantity 🙈
katylake212 Sorry, I meant quantity, definitely not quality. Stupid me! What I meant that I don't even hit pan on 1g eyeshadows, let alone the larger ones.
I checked again the swatches and there are too many similar shadows. It is not a versatile palette.
Agreed, I wouldn't mind a cheaper palette with less product but the same quality...I probably won't even hit pan on the 1g shadows....R.I.P....
How could anyone really be negative about a video where you and James are so adorable? Watching you guys film stuff together while going about your day is one of my favorite things you do in your videos. It's always a precious little slice of your life together.
Could you try the smaller ones? it would be easier to splurge on one of those but only if the quality is the same!!! I have not seen many people review her line and would love to see more! Great video, Tati!
they are 5 shadow palettes at Sephora for around 50$ :)
I have two of the 5 pan palettes and they are amazing in terms of quality and the amount you get. The colour combos are all very well thought out and work amazingly together. They are easily the most expensive eyeshadow palettes I own, based on the amount of colours and price, but also the best in terms of quality. I ordered mine off Beautylish btw.
the five pan ones that I've seen at Sephora have to be a different formula, though, because they do contain talc... that doesn't really bother me tho, so I agree, I'd love to see some of those reviewed!
Sitting here trying to find a way to justify this price to my boyfriend so he doesn't ask me why I need another pallette when I just ordered the Kathleen Lights and Mario Pallette 🙄
Veronica Aguilar You can say that the Kathleen Lights' so cheap it's almost like you got it for free? I'd totally do that 💨🙈
Veronica Aguilar hahaha my hubby is the same ... he says you've got exactly like that... I'm like that's grounds for divorce lol 😜😜😜xxx
Veronica Aguilar there is no way to justify the purchase beyond materialism and vanity.
Unless you're rich.
Veronica Aguilar ugh I want the Kathleen Lights palette so bad but shipping to Canada is $31 💔
buy it yourself?
I absolutely love this eye look on you. Thank you for all that you do! you're so honest and you keep it real and we appreciate it
I'm a little sick of WTF to be honest. It's getting repetitive and it's not very helpful, at least to me. If I want to splurge on makeup, I would buy a $30-40 product. I'd rather Tati review something that is more applicable to her viewers - not saying she only has to show drugstore, but I much prefer her other videos.
Julia R well wtf is a series that shows makeup so expensive it make you go "WTF?". i honestly wouldn't say $30-40 is a shockingly expensive price. i know that a lot of other channels do videos with not as expensive products!
Julia R it's helpful to me and plenty of subscribers so if you don't like it don't watch and stop sooking :)
it says in the video title how much it is and if you dont think you would be able to spend that kinda money on makeup, then dont watch it
Julia R the wtf videos are my favourite.. I love her check ins, it's like a mini outing from my lounge room in Australia, lol. I love seeing how the products compare ect to more affordable make up and I'd much prefer to buy one high end eyeshadow pallet than 20 drugstore palettes that are shitty quality.. It's all fun! It gives me a much needed reprieve some days from the serious stuff and I thoroughly enjoy them! I hope you have a great day Hun. X
I love wtf and if ou guys don't that's your opinion go watch something else
*coming from a positive place* I don't see myself purchasing this one! Maybe it's just me, but I felt like every time she checked in the eye shadow was faded more? I feel like you get more lasting shimmer from a colourpop super shock shadow, especially if you're just going to be using your finger anyway. My opinion is that if you like any of the colors in this palette, just get a dupe! I mean $9.50 a shade is not TOO bad but you can get a matching shade for cheaper still. :) Thanks for the review, Tati! Glad you will be able to find use out of it.
I like the that the palette has a variety of coordinating colors. Matte, transition, shine and glitter. I have to bounce back and forth through my eye shadows to get this look. I really appreciate you applying the palette for us to see exactly how the shadows will wear. $169 might be too expensive for me (I'm a .99 cent store gal) but I love the colors and the idea of everything you need for a great eye look in one palette. Thank you Tati
Holy coy glitter fallout!
cow*
Can you do a Hot or Not for Clarins products!?
I appreciate and trust your authenticity, I remember reading an interview you did saying that was the number one thing you keep in mind for your viewers. I don't doubt your expertise
As a newbie to eyeshadows, I just can't handle the crumbly metallic pigments. Sadly, I don't think this is for me. But I do love my lorac pro, viseart and modern renaissance palettes.
Jen Sieras makeup geek has great ones too.
Jen Sieras modern renaissance palette is by far the best palette of the year!!!
In my opinion
This metallic shadow was way more crumbly than most metallic shadows... If you want some kind of shimmer I would recommend the Stila In The Light palette. Its my favorite palette for shimmers; they are extremely pigmented.
Tati, I really wished you did a live swatch of the shadows, it adds creditbility to the true swatch pigment of the eyeshadow.
I like this series. I love how Tati gives reviews on high end products so I know which are my preferences when I want to buy.
So glad you reviews this palette!
*reviewed
I'm not liking that palette. Usually, Tati reviews are accurate, but I don't understand how during the check in, she didn't see all the fallout on her face. Also that white shimmery eyeshadow looks so patchy. We can see her naked eyelid in some part. Also, I feel I can't trust her swatches as they aren't live swatches. The only one she did live swatch is that burgundy shade and it was patchy. She said that it is probably the best eyeshadow palette. How? I feel she tried to like that palette because it was send to her. After that video I feel I have to be more careful about her reviews..
Missbubblefishy her integrity is being questioned more and more and it sucks because she has such a kind and happy vibe :(
Missbubblefishy +1 Well Said Missbubblefishy!
Missbubblefishy the fallout was already there it wasn't like it wasn't there in the first place she even said the car light was shitty, ontop of that when trying to sweep away fall out not all of it goes away..... don't be so critical like she said she should've used a glitter glue, which most people do use when apply shimmery colors or even press pigments they will use a glitter glue. Why do you people always have something negative to say about Tati..??? If you want the palette and you need it get it, if you want it to add to your collection then get it... if you don't like it then don't get it. Everyone's going to have a different opinion and this one is hers so get over it
Honestly I think through the check ins esp when she was getting coffee with James and said she looks super glittery & she did not purchase it herself, it's somewhat like a hidden message she want us to know that it is not a good product yet she has to say some nice things for the product. I do prefer abh modern renaissance over this palette, price is too high, quality and color choice is just no-no. But srsly why would she say her face looks somewhat glittery unless she want us to get the hint 😂
I don't think you need to question her integrity at all. She gave us full disclosure that it was sent to her. Who is going to rail a "gift", and especially one from another UA-camr. But moreover, haven't you _ever_ had a bias in your life? Wanting to love something so bad you can't see it's not good for you? Loving a movie everyone else thinks is terrible? It's not a credibility issue. It's a load of influencing factors. But she gave you them all so that you can deduce for yourself where the truth lies. She didn't conceal that it was a gift, she was legit about the fallout and the crappy swatch, and that it's more expensive bc there's less product. She gave us full-disclosure, she just wanted to be kind.
OMG, the way James smiled at you at the coffee place was so freaking adorable! and I love how sparkly the sparkle looked even at night
I've been waiting for this video since her Snapchat video
Belen Rubio Me too! Haha
What's her snapchat??? :-)
The palette was designed so that the user could take any three shades across, down, or diagonal to create a cohesive look. Also, the price is high, yes, but it is also being offered for three installment payments and you receive the palette with the first payment--you don't need to pay it off first. That doesn't make it any less expensive, and making payments on makeup might seem silly, but if you really want this palette and $170 is too much in one chunk, that is an option.
Tati you are amazing, and one of the most honest person in the beauty community. If you down have nothing nice to say don't say it at all. They probably don't even watch every video you post. Please, do a tutorial how you styled your hair here, it looks amazing.
I just got my palette today and am re-watching your video. As a woman of color, I chuckled because you lament the fact that the palette does not have a brow bone color but actually for me "Vega" and "Flesh" are perfect for my brow bone. But still, there is no black. Thank you for your videos!
I own a couple of Natasha's smaller palettes and her eye shadows are beautiful. I bought the smaller ones at separate times when I could afford them because I really wanted to try her product, I just can't afford the big palettes sadly but I'm good with the smaller ones from Beautylish. Although I like her shadows I don't think I would buy the bigger more expensive palettes but I appreciate your review. I always appreciate your reviews even if I can't afford some of the products ;o)
oh by the way I just picked up the lorac pro metal rose gold palette at nordstroms. It was a steal at 28.00 and the shadows are smooth and beautiful, it is only 8 shadows but it's really pretty maybe you would like it ;o)
I agree with you. Honestly price aside I wouldn't get the bigger palettes cuz I ain't no make up artist so I don't use all the colours or will ever run out of any for that matter. The smaller palettes like what you said are amazing. It's worth paying for in my opinion cuz the quality is superb to me.
I love your fresh-faced look in this video! Your videos are so informative but i love how your passion and excitement shines through!
I totally trust tati's crediblity. She seems very sincere and genuine. I love these colors, I'm going to beg my fiancé for this palette for a Christmas gift!
I somehow convinced him to buy it for me early 💙. It's on it's way to me!
.would u be willing to review a at home gel nail polish kit.....that affordable....
ps....with led light?
Honestly, you and James are SOO CUTE!! I need to have my husband watch that part..your makeup is beautiful (opens door) , smiles at you like it's the first time he's ever seen you! Goals!! 😱✨✨
does anyone know where Tati's grey turtleneck sweater is from?? I'm in love with it 💗💗
Maya Maxfield ...it was probably $200-300 tho. 😬
Maya Maxfield well I'm not sure where hers is from but they do have one very similar at Gap! It's a lightweight sweater with that high neck look... when I saw her sweater I noticed it bc I was just in Gap earlier today! lol :)
+Ashley Malone oh thank you so much I'll have to look there!
I love WTF but I think a way to make it even better would be to provide affordable dupes for these super pricey products. thanks for your vids tati
All these shadows are beautiful. I think it's better that there isn't a black because most people have a favourite black shadow and it means that there's one more amazing shadow in the pallet. Your makeup does look amazing today.
I sort of want my own James. What a lucky girl you are to have found your James!
Lol oh yes...he knowsssss you are filming him...such a cutie, loved that he tried to rationalise the price for you. On the other hand it always amuses me how we look at it cost per shade in an expensive palette but not in a NYX or ELF palette as the price per shade would be toooooo small lol
ParchCraftAustralia I wish elf would have a burgandy (fall) pallet.
me too!
James and his "highlight on fleek"! The two of you are so cute!!!
The palette looks gorgeous but I was surprised you didn't comment on the similarity of some of the shadows. The burgundy especially look so similar I can't see why there's any need for them both in the palette
im sorry tati i just dont see how this is justified... while some of the super metallic shadows are unique and maybe 2 shimmers... the rest of these colors can easily be found ANYWHERE lol and with good quality... and im shocked you didnt even mention that the names arent even printed on the packagin... all that money and u still get a plastic sheet? lol just sayin... its pretty by not 100+ pretty in the least lol just sayin
✨✨✨✨✨✨✨ been watching you since you collab'd with Makeup Geek! I love the direction your channel has gone, your channel is only getting better with age babe! Keep doing what you're doing! I love you Tati ✨✨✨✨✨
There is so much glitter fallout on your face in the check-in's
Has anyone tried dip acrylic nail polish? Would you try it for OMG Thursdays?
Powder then coat.
I love this video! Her look turned out super pretty. I was skeptical first when she used that dark color to her under eye but when she zoomed out, OMG!
Is it just me or was Tati not being critical at all? From the moment she had the package in her hands, it was just like 'omg this is so amazing.' She had a lot of glitter fall out during the check in, and she didn't even mention it.
the new filming against the mirror is not my fave. I definitely think things look much better facing the camera.
Thank you for putting yourself out there! You have a massive fan base and people who genuinely love and appreciate you-- even if they have never met you. I know, I'm one of them! Please know that you are wonderful, intelligent, and CREDIBLE! Thank you, Tati. You inspire me. ✨✨✨✨✨✨
Tons of fallout & when you packed the lid shade on wet, it picked itself back up and was patchy.. 🙄
Am i the only one here who appreciates how sweet James is??? THEY'RE SO SWEET TOGETHER
the rocker vibe is real in this video! your hair! the layered necklaces! the tshirt! love it!
did you note or record your browbone and inner corner highlights? no black, no highlight shades and it's really that amazing with that hefty price tag? that seems to me to be at least one big con.
Tati you should do a hot or not on shop miss a ... & maybe possibly a full face makeup look using their products. Everything is only 1$ 🤓
i got a few things off there, they are really not the best
makayla drake and burn her face with crappy products ?
A year late but Tati heard you girl, check out her recents! 😂
Tati, I don't think I've ever commented on any of your videos before. However, despite all the negative reviews on this video below. I will say one positive thing, you are the 'mother' that we all wish we had, you're the mother of UA-cam. Never stop being you.
If a pallete is as much as my electric bill, it better not have fallout or any other problems. If some people want to spend that much on a pallet I won't judge, but lorac mega pallete is $60 for 32 shadows, just sayin.
Wow this is a beautiful palette! Really pricey, but beautiful!
I loved your eye look, the lower lash line really made your eyes pop and I didn't think it looked too bright! When I used that color all over my lid it built up nicely and wasn't patchy at all, but I agree, it doesn't swatch the best. Thanks for the tutorial in the video, I LOVED the final look!!! Don't worry about the negativity about the price. Your job is to report the news and the options in makeup and it's up to the view to decide if the product fits the qualities they are looking for and the price point they are willing to spend! XO Laura
I'm so disappointed in Tati lately she's been slamming the drugstore often lately and she's been 'loving' all her new expensive stuff, I love Tati but not been liking her lately
Sadly, I noticed she's been like that ever since she started the WTF series. I don't really trust her reviews anymore, I do however like watching her videos to keep up with new products (even though I rarely wear make up myself).
Amina Ajaj what's wrong with liking a more expensive product? Sometimes a product is worth the money. I don't see her bashing more on drugstore. She seems to like both drugstore and expensive products.
i know it supposed to be one week drugstore and other one luxury
I haven't seen her slam any drugstore products.
Amina Ajaj we expect her honest opinions on product reviews and 'WTF' is a playlist/theme on her channel where she reviews rediculously overpriced products, i highly doubt shes intentionally liking high end over drugstore lately, we just have to be understanding