It wouldn't solve anything at all. If Dina gets the Attack, that means Grisha dies. And if Dina goes to steal the Coordinate with her Attack, she will ultimately be bound by the Vow Of Renouncing War
I mean, the Owl could probably just save Grisha and Dina, and hand Dina the Attack with the plan to have Dina feed Grisha the Founder to get over the Vow. A bit convoluted, but given what they would have at the moment, a solid plan.
@@jaipandey7142 I would imagine if he could have saved her or if he saw what happened in the future he would have. I bet he knew Dina would eat Erens mum etc. However, if we are talking about a what if, which this is. It would have worked having Grisha use Dina to activate the coordinate
The only flaw in this story is Grisha being alive after Shinganshina. He timed his attack on the royal family around the end of his 13 years and passed the titan to Eren immediately upon his return. So it stands to reason he only had a few days to live at most. Which isn't enough time to destroy Marley since in the original timeline we see a few day/night cycles between the time the rumbling starts and the time it reaches Fort Salta. And Grisha can't just take the Founding Titan away from himself. We know that from Rod Reiss' behavior. Because if the Founder could take away their own powers, he would've taken the powers for himself and given them to somebody else after 13 years. (Also I had a long rant about how the fact there's a private ceremony with white robes to pass down titans both on Paradise and in Marley implies this as well, but this explanation is way shorter.)
Why don't just do the usual Dina eat Bertholdt? Don't get me wrong, this video is amazing! But it's just that we all wanted to see how will Carla and Dina interact with one another. Also, here's my idea: What if Frieda did what Historia did by allowing herself to get knocked up to not becoming the Founding Titan?
Well, it surely would have been interesting to see Carla and Dina interact but, I'm pretty sure Carla doesn't play an important role in this video's scenario since Grisha doesn't marry Carla or have Eren but just keeps the power of the Founder to himself. However, yeah, the Dina eating Bert could have worked! I like the idea you've proposed. You mean, what if Freida rejected inheriting the Founder just like Historia? I think it would either lead to Freida being forced to become a Titan and inherit the Founder or a person from her siblings could inherit it. Worst case, if no one takes the Power, the power would be redistributed to a new Eldian child that could be outside the Royal Family or even outside the Walls. Would love to hear what kind of idea you have on it
I meant to reply and forgot all about it sorry. I don’t think that an interaction between Carla and Dina is all that interesting. Honestly looking at both women we know who is the ruthless one and the one with very strong and right morals. Dina would probably just look down on Carla. Carla in turn would just be like - meh he was better off with me 😅
Actually Dina can just eat Berthtold instead of passing through him giving no chance for Renier to even breach the walls Also does the curse of Ymir disappear or not after the partial rumbling? Also what would Zeke do after finding out about the Rumbling? I imagine Grisha would whip Zeke with the belt as soon as he sees him
That's also one question the anime didn't answer since Grisha clearly crossed his 13 year curse limit in the show as well. So the same logic is applied here, I think
@AnimeAlternateUniverse Inspired? The pose and thumbnail is a literal one to one re-creation of their video. With such strong inspiration surely you could put that in the description? But no you just do it to ride the views
@@yasminejamaliabdelkarim2817 Inspired by Yeagerists, Domain Aniki, Ohara and Turtle Quirk. I put the inspirations in the description. Added Domain Aniki. He is mentioned in other videos.
Would the Rumbling be happening or not?
What if Dina Was given the attack Titan instead of Grisha like if Eren Kruger chose Her instead, How would that effect the story?
It wouldn't solve anything at all. If Dina gets the Attack, that means Grisha dies. And if Dina goes to steal the Coordinate with her Attack, she will ultimately be bound by the Vow Of Renouncing War
Yeap that is the big issue if only a Royal attempts to get the coordinate.
Now then, what if Eren Kruger saved both Grisha and Dina, and gave Attack Titan to Grisha to simply use Dina when other shifters would come
I mean, the Owl could probably just save Grisha and Dina, and hand Dina the Attack with the plan to have Dina feed Grisha the Founder to get over the Vow.
A bit convoluted, but given what they would have at the moment, a solid plan.
@@jaipandey7142 I would imagine if he could have saved her or if he saw what happened in the future he would have. I bet he knew Dina would eat Erens mum etc.
However, if we are talking about a what if, which this is. It would have worked having Grisha use Dina to activate the coordinate
The only flaw in this story is Grisha being alive after Shinganshina. He timed his attack on the royal family around the end of his 13 years and passed the titan to Eren immediately upon his return. So it stands to reason he only had a few days to live at most. Which isn't enough time to destroy Marley since in the original timeline we see a few day/night cycles between the time the rumbling starts and the time it reaches Fort Salta.
And Grisha can't just take the Founding Titan away from himself. We know that from Rod Reiss' behavior. Because if the Founder could take away their own powers, he would've taken the powers for himself and given them to somebody else after 13 years. (Also I had a long rant about how the fact there's a private ceremony with white robes to pass down titans both on Paradise and in Marley implies this as well, but this explanation is way shorter.)
@ailius1520 Thanks for adding this context
Why don't just do the usual Dina eat Bertholdt? Don't get me wrong, this video is amazing! But it's just that we all wanted to see how will Carla and Dina interact with one another.
Also, here's my idea: What if Frieda did what Historia did by allowing herself to get knocked up to not becoming the Founding Titan?
Well, it surely would have been interesting to see Carla and Dina interact but, I'm pretty sure Carla doesn't play an important role in this video's scenario since Grisha doesn't marry Carla or have Eren but just keeps the power of the Founder to himself. However, yeah, the Dina eating Bert could have worked!
I like the idea you've proposed. You mean, what if Freida rejected inheriting the Founder just like Historia?
I think it would either lead to Freida being forced to become a Titan and inherit the Founder or a person from her siblings could inherit it. Worst case, if no one takes the Power, the power would be redistributed to a new Eldian child that could be outside the Royal Family or even outside the Walls.
Would love to hear what kind of idea you have on it
I meant to reply and forgot all about it sorry. I don’t think that an interaction between Carla and Dina is all that interesting. Honestly looking at both women we know who is the ruthless one and the one with very strong and right morals. Dina would probably just look down on Carla. Carla in turn would just be like - meh he was better off with me 😅
Interesting take on Frieda. I would have to think about that one
Good ending unlocked!
Reward:no crying yourself to sleep tonight
No wonder I like Kruger… owls are my favorite raptor
I actually like this story
Yay we appreciate it
This should have a million views. Great video!
@markplayer2618 thanks for the shoutout.
What if everything remained the same and Dina just ate Bert on the day the walls fell
Good work 🎉
Yea yes have Bert intervene when he can’t climb the wall
How would you have done it differently?
Actually Dina can just eat Berthtold instead of passing through him giving no chance for Renier to even breach the walls
Also does the curse of Ymir disappear or not after the partial rumbling?
Also what would Zeke do after finding out about the Rumbling?
I imagine Grisha would whip Zeke with the belt as soon as he sees him
Amazing story idea!
Glad you like it
Dina >> Eren 🗿
Fr fr😊
I'd like to see what if annie betrayed Marley early in season 2
Noted :)
If Grisha was turned into a titan in 830 then how is he still alive in 845?
Oh dear an obvious oversight on my part :P Thanks for pointing it out.
That's also one question the anime didn't answer since Grisha clearly crossed his 13 year curse limit in the show as well. So the same logic is applied here, I think
The is some plot armor applied in the anime for sure.
@@watchamigos1232we don't know the exact year grisha got his power so it was likely at a much later date
Bro u stole the Thumbnail from another youtuber is practically the same thing
We got inspired by Domain Akini's TN.
@AnimeAlternateUniverse Inspired? The pose and thumbnail is a literal one to one re-creation of their video. With such strong inspiration surely you could put that in the description? But no you just do it to ride the views
@@yasminejamaliabdelkarim2817
Inspired by Yeagerists, Domain Aniki, Ohara and Turtle Quirk.
I put the inspirations in the description. Added Domain Aniki. He is mentioned in other videos.
What happened to Zaka
He was not that relevant for this timeline.
o/