Hi I have a 100 gallon fish tanks and I loved the video but I don’t like that girl that always talks I like when you talk and also when you say don’t do this but your doing it to your fish tank to tell people
I literally did this yesterday..............................................................smh........................Wooohoo! Another tank.... Have excuse to purchase more fish! ( and stuff ).......
Me too.. I've changed my hobby since the lockdown. No more makeup tutorials.. And now I'm into aquariums hahaha Ive given him a nice list for possible Xmas gifts.. Hehehe. This hobby is so cool.
Lisa, I have to tell you something... Over a year ago when I was still lurking, you were the first person who inspired me on UA-cam with bettas! You were also where I learned that you could keep a betta sorority. I started off watching one or two videos before I found you guys, Prime Time Aquatics, and so many more!! Y'all's videos are what got me going in this community! I love your collection of beautiful bettas!! By the way, Did I ever tell you thank you? Well...Thank you!!🙏🌱🐟🌱
I set up an aquarium in my bedroom & every morning I'd sit up & look at it & lay back down. One morning as l lay back down it clicked & I was up like a shot, I had lots of baby guppies .I certainly didn't sleep after that, I was 2 excited. 👍💕🇦🇺
The only "designer" nano tank that I've used and liked, and would recommend for someone who just wants a cute simple 5 gallon for a betta and some low maintenance plants is the marineland portrait 5 gallon aquarium. The built in filter and light is sufficient for the aforementioned setup and only requires a heater to be added; I like the pet supplies plus heater for this. Add some fluval stratum, a piece of dragonstone or driftwood, some plants and you're good to go. Of course there are better lights and filters and everything when you do it custom, but for a tank for a desk or similar situation it is a good option!
That's the one I just set up. So far no fish, but it seems to be a perfect size and look for the bookcase. I'm thinking betta....but i have a few weeks to decide.
And suddenly, I subscribed upon hearing Breaking Benjamin. Thank you for putting together this video, it's helping me with choosing out what tanks to get at the moment.
If you don’t like the sponge filter taking up room on the substrate you could always buy the sponge filter that has suction cups that stick to the back of the tank I run one in my 6 gallon betta tank and I lost no space in planting and hardscaping and plus the filtration is great and my betta buddy jewel loves it. Just for anyone that wants a sponge filter but don’t want it on the ground in the background!
You should do a video on fish and the vertical water water column for example like a 75 gallon vertical tank and how to pick out fish that would swim above in the middle of the bottom dwellers. Love the vids keep up the good work.
I stsrted with a 5 Gal Guppy Aquarium and upgraded to 10. As time goes by we should become more conscious that just like birds need space to fly and not be in cages, fish need space to swim, hide, and go about their business :) Thank you for the video!! you guys helped me a lot!!!
I loved this video! I’ve been watching a lot of these top ten videos and this one is probably up there as one of the best ones you’ve made yet! I’d love to see more iterations of the video for other common tank sizes, like 10 or 20 gallons. Really nice to have such quality, concise information in one video!
aquariums are addicting and you grow out of them fast 🤣 I went from a 3 to a 5 to a 15 and now I’m working on a 75 🤣🤣❤️❤️❤️ I love the live plant hobby 😻😻😻
I started with succulents.. then house plants, hummingbird feeders, then got sold 4 gold fish for my 6.5 gallon tank.. now I have a 20g for 2 goldfish and am purchasing a 30g for the other 2 ! And now I have water plants too! Help me!
I’ve recently set up a small aquarium in my bedroom (ran outta room in the lounge room lol) and I’m putting in some emerald green guppies which should arrive any day. So thanks guys once again for all your advice and ideas on set ups for small tanks. Stay safe and love from Australia
Thanks to your videos ive now got my first fish! A feisty little doubletail halfmoon betta i picked up today. Thanks for teaching newbies like me how to best care for our fishie friends!
I just set up a 5 gallon tank to play around with the Dutch style aquascape. The plants are doing great. I want to add shrimp and snails at some point. Thanks so much for this timely video!
i came for the fish info (new i this whole thing cause my daughter thought it would be something easy to take care of..... oh boy) and got punched with a plug for breaking benjamin ... now excuse me but torn in two is AMAAAAAAAAZING! cant wait for these guys to tour again (darn covid....)
I use the Fluval Nano 3.0 on my 5 gallon and it works great. Bought it new for $75. It dims and it's fully programmable. Just thought I'd throw that out there since you said a dimming one would cost $200+. I've also been able to grow pretty high-light demanding plants such as Ludwigia Pantanal Amd AR Mini with it.
I just got some ember tetras for my 10 gallon tank. I LOVE them! I was thinking about putting them with Chili Rasboras and shrimp but I am enjoying these little guys so much I might just end up having all embers!
Thank you for doing this video. OMG ai am so doing a Beta 5 or maybe 10 gallon aquarium. I so appreciate that you link your website and products for purchase. You make this so easy and I realllllly appreciate it. I'm a newbie and need all the help I can get. I love your beta's Lisa ♥
Love the Sicce Micron! I put one in the 10 gallon betta tank I set up for my housemate, and have the Micron Nano in one of my 5 gallon tanks. One caveat though, at least that I've noticed: because it's a motor running inside the tank, it does add warmth in a 5 gallon. Watch the temperature and adjust your heater accordingly, especially if the tank is in a warm room, has lighting geared to medium or high-light plants, or is tightly covered.
Im super new to fishkeeping but have experience with photography, a tip if you have led light with out a dimmer feature, use thin material to filter out the strong light, i personally use a simple tissue paper and you can add more layers to dim the light more
My first fish were two bettas gifted to me by someone who just couldn't be bothered any more. They were both in a tank that was not even a full gallon (about 0.8 gallons), with a divider. There was some substrate, but nothing else in the tank. These fish were kept like this for an entire year. I didn't know anything about owning fish, but I was quite sure that was an unsatisfactory situation, so I immediately went and bought some one gallon tanks so they could each have their own space with at least a little bit of decoration. I would then graduate them to 2.5 gallon tanks, and finally 10 gallon tanks. So now I have some 1 and 2.5 gallon tanks sitting around unused. The 1 gallon tanks have proved useful for highly temporary purposes like epsom salt baths and for quarantining and medicating a fish for a spell, but I have so many tanks that I would like to do something more with them. You start here with 5 gallon tanks, but is there anything that can be done with even smaller tanks, other then keeping them handy as temporary holding tanks when needed?
I plan to be a rebel 😁 I will soon start my 8 gallon tank, and the fish that got my attention the most of the ones that might thrive there, is the ember tetra. We have them in the store where I work, and once I started looking at them, I really started to like them. They're both cute and beautiful!
Perfect timing!!! I just got my sister a 6.5 G for her birthday (b-day is Halloween) for a shrimp tank. She wants live plants. So these are wonderful suggestions.
This is perfect! I have a 1.5 gal tank that I got from a friend, but I knew it wasn't safe or big enough if I wanted to try aquascaping with a beta fish!
if you ask me the worst thing about any tank below ten gallons is a lid... They just straight up don't make lids for most sizes that small. And if they do they are legit a pane of glass with a handle (which good luck getting an airtube in or a filter)
I'm planning on doing a volcano theme for my new Betta when I get him. DEFINITELY going to cycle, use a sponge filter for filtration and a python hose for ease of water changes, I'm not losing another buddy!
Man, i just got into fishkeeping and love your videos! I was so hype to find out yall were in Va too, and i was gonna come see the shop then found out it closed 😔
hi forever fish lover, new-by fish keeper w/ a 5.5 gal who ALSO LOVES BREAKING BENJAMIN (ember tour specifically changed my life) & i WILL be beginning my tank with ember tetras & abiding by ur rules
I have 2 5.5g tanks that each house 1 male betta. I use Tetra HOB filters for them and have good luck. I also have 20 something Ember tetras in quarantine for my 29g. I love the 5.5g tank size.
I have several Aqueon 5 gallon mini-bow's. They are really nice aquariums for the price. I "hot-rodded' the filter systems & the inhabitants are fairly heavily stocked. Interestingly enough, some of the mini-bow aquariums of mine are actually among the most stable in water parameters, in comparison, even with my other larger aquariums. Great video, John & Lisa. 👍
what do you guys think about box filters? i hear almost noone talk about these. they are basicly the exact same concept than a sponge filter yet you can put whatever media in there you want. you could even put some sponge on the inlets and then have some other media inside to have sponge filter that also has another level of filtration on top. and they hook to the airpump just the way a spongefilter will. on paper, they are basically ''a spongefilter, but better'' yet almost noone talks about good old box filters
I have a pre-set heater for my 10 gallon tank, but the only issue that I have been noticing is that it doesn't really properly keep my tank heated. It says that it should occasionally switch itself off to prevent over-heating, however, I've noticed that mine is mostly switched off instead of being on and keeping my water heated. Normally, when I go to feed my guppies and other fish, I stick my hand into the tank so that the food can easily be spread across the whole tank, but the water rarely ever feels warm to the touch. I have been looking for other heaters (as I've had this issue with at least 3 different brands), so I am hoping that the next one will keep my water at a comfortable temperature for my fishies.
You seem very pro 5 gallon for beginners. A lot of other people on youtube say bigger is better for beginners and the small tanks aren’t good because of the fluctuating water parameters. Is that your mindset too or no and why not?
*Check out our brand new website and shop for all of your aquarium supplies and fun merch!*
keepfishkeeping.com
How many female betta i can put in my 25 gallon tank
@@SAGARSANJOY They usually say 5 for 20 gal sorority, so I'm guessing 6... Good luck!
Love the video you guys should try a guppy video where you breed them. I would love to see what you breed.
.
Hi I have this 10 liters tank and there is no heater available.. i was looking for small heaters but none are available here. what should i do?
Hi I have a 100 gallon fish tanks and I loved the video but I don’t like that girl that always talks I like when you talk and also when you say don’t do this but your doing it to your fish tank to tell people
Who else doesn’t have a small tank but is still watching this for no reason
me,,lol
Me too
I have no fish tank 😢
I don't have a small tank, but my friend does, and she was like "too bad I can't plant mine", so I'm gathering ideas for her.
me lol
I don’t need another tank, I don’t need another tank, I don’t need another tank..
*buys a 5 gallon tank*
I literally did this yesterday..............................................................smh........................Wooohoo! Another tank.... Have excuse to purchase more fish! ( and stuff ).......
Pete Zingy it’s such an addiction lol
Pete Zingy I might go overboard on my birthday on 2021 with coral beauty angelfish and a 75 gallon and live rock and corals
@@lishspetlife OMG... I know!!! I have it too.... MTS - Multi-tank-syndrome.... hahaha....
Pete Zingy we’ve been infected lol
I was diagnosed with MTS... Multi Tank Syndrome... I started with one... Now I have tons!
I can understand I have 12 tanks in my room:) I have a frog and a dog and a cat. My landlord in Taiwan is a very considerate man.
I have six outside and 3 inside my room 🤣🙃
@@jeffdjmeren4913 lol.. Salty or freshy? Me personally, I like to mix it up...
Haha same it's not my room it's the fishes
@@samcloud1213 lol, I walk into my local pet store like "I need a fix" It's an addiction for sure 🤪
My boyfriend hates when I watch these videos because I just keep buying more and more aquarium things.
Stay calm
And buy more fish
Me too.. I've changed my hobby since the lockdown. No more makeup tutorials.. And now I'm into aquariums hahaha Ive given him a nice list for possible Xmas gifts.. Hehehe. This hobby is so cool.
you need a new boyfriend
Yeah. Fish keeping is so addictive! HAHAHA! 😂🤣
im my gfs bf and i felt that.
Lisa, I have to tell you something... Over a year ago when I was still lurking, you were the first person who inspired me on UA-cam with bettas! You were also where I learned that you could keep a betta sorority. I started off watching one or two videos before I found you guys, Prime Time Aquatics, and so many more!! Y'all's videos are what got me going in this community! I love your collection of beautiful bettas!! By the way, Did I ever tell you thank you? Well...Thank you!!🙏🌱🐟🌱
I just got a beautiful little 5.5 gallon aquarium for my female Betta fish named Lana. I couldn't be happier.
Fish *and* Breaking Benjamin?!
I have found my people.
Lol I’m just hoping Ben accepts my invitation!!
Get him in the hobby!
very true about seeing baby guppies for the first time
I set up an aquarium in my bedroom & every morning I'd sit up & look at it & lay back down. One morning as l lay back down it clicked & I was up like a shot, I had lots of baby guppies .I certainly didn't sleep after that, I was 2 excited. 👍💕🇦🇺
The only "designer" nano tank that I've used and liked, and would recommend for someone who just wants a cute simple 5 gallon for a betta and some low maintenance plants is the marineland portrait 5 gallon aquarium. The built in filter and light is sufficient for the aforementioned setup and only requires a heater to be added; I like the pet supplies plus heater for this. Add some fluval stratum, a piece of dragonstone or driftwood, some plants and you're good to go. Of course there are better lights and filters and everything when you do it custom, but for a tank for a desk or similar situation it is a good option!
That's the one I just set up. So far no fish, but it seems to be a perfect size and look for the bookcase. I'm thinking betta....but i have a few weeks to decide.
@@amuseinthecraftroom6257 I have a female betta in mine, but you have a few options 😊
@@lifewithabiologist5471 I'm trying to wait until Lisa has some babies to sell....but I may not have the patience lol
@@amuseinthecraftroom6257 Awe I would love one of hers one day
I really like the style of the plants you had in the video. I thinks it's very pretty when they grow all over the place, it feels natural.
And suddenly, I subscribed upon hearing Breaking Benjamin.
Thank you for putting together this video, it's helping me with choosing out what tanks to get at the moment.
After losing my betta recently, I just got ember tetras for my 10 gallon yesterday. They're so sweet!
If you don’t like the sponge filter taking up room on the substrate you could always buy the sponge filter that has suction cups that stick to the back of the tank I run one in my 6 gallon betta tank and I lost no space in planting and hardscaping and plus the filtration is great and my betta buddy jewel loves it. Just for anyone that wants a sponge filter but don’t want it on the ground in the background!
More ideas for a 5 gallon
- pea puffer
- dwarf orange crayfish
- African dwarf frog
- 4-5 pygmy corydoras
- planted only (looks nice on office desks)
pygmy corys need a bigger tank. at least 10g
I've got some of the African dwarf frogs in my 29 gallon.
I bought supposed male guppies a few years back. After a couple of months, I had little baby guppies swimming around :)
Absolutely, I need a heater in my 5 gallon because I keep my house at 62°-65°.
It is pretty chilly even for my dogs.
Bettas are what got me started Lisa love those guys
My guppies having babies HOOKED me and my wife to this hobby
You should do a video on fish and the vertical water water column for example like a 75 gallon vertical tank and how to pick out fish that would swim above in the middle of the bottom dwellers. Love the vids keep up the good work.
Red Cold River is fire!!
I stsrted with a 5 Gal Guppy Aquarium and upgraded to 10. As time goes by we should become more conscious that just like birds need space to fly and not be in cages, fish need space to swim, hide, and go about their business :) Thank you for the video!! you guys helped me a lot!!!
That feeling when u see the 1st baby tho
It was soo cool to see my 1st baby moly for my 30g
thanks to you, I got a 5 gallon tank and bot a betta and put it on my desk!
I loved this video! I’ve been watching a lot of these top ten videos and this one is probably up there as one of the best ones you’ve made yet! I’d love to see more iterations of the video for other common tank sizes, like 10 or 20 gallons. Really nice to have such quality, concise information in one video!
aquariums are addicting and you grow out of them fast 🤣 I went from a 3 to a 5 to a 15 and now I’m working on a 75 🤣🤣❤️❤️❤️ I love the live plant hobby 😻😻😻
I started with succulents.. then house plants, hummingbird feeders, then got sold 4 gold fish for my 6.5 gallon tank.. now I have a 20g for 2 goldfish and am purchasing a 30g for the other 2 ! And now I have water plants too! Help me!
Me 🔔
The breaking Benjamin reference is wild ❤
I’ve recently set up a small aquarium in my bedroom (ran outta room in the lounge room lol) and I’m putting in some emerald green guppies which should arrive any day. So thanks guys once again for all your advice and ideas on set ups for small tanks. Stay safe and love from Australia
I have two Amber tetras in my shrimp tank and they're doing amazing ✅
Thanks to your videos ive now got my first fish! A feisty little doubletail halfmoon betta i picked up today. Thanks for teaching newbies like me how to best care for our fishie friends!
I just set up a 5 gallon tank to play around with the Dutch style aquascape. The plants are doing great. I want to add shrimp and snails at some point. Thanks so much for this timely video!
i came for the fish info (new i this whole thing cause my daughter thought it would be something easy to take care of..... oh boy) and got punched with a plug for breaking benjamin ... now excuse me but torn in two is AMAAAAAAAAZING! cant wait for these guys to tour again (darn covid....)
Feed the wolf is a great track - cheers!
This guy is basically Kenny Jo, but for aquariums
I use the Fluval Nano 3.0 on my 5 gallon and it works great. Bought it new for $75. It dims and it's fully programmable. Just thought I'd throw that out there since you said a dimming one would cost $200+. I've also been able to grow pretty high-light demanding plants such as Ludwigia Pantanal Amd AR Mini with it.
I just got some ember tetras for my 10 gallon tank. I LOVE them! I was thinking about putting them with Chili Rasboras and shrimp but I am enjoying these little guys so much I might just end up having all embers!
Love the 5 gallon
Just listened to breaking penjamin and it changed my life thanks G 🙏🏼
Thank you for doing this video. OMG ai am so doing a Beta 5 or maybe 10 gallon aquarium. I so appreciate that you link your website and products for purchase. You make this so easy and I realllllly appreciate it. I'm a newbie and need all the help I can get. I love your beta's Lisa ♥
Love the Sicce Micron! I put one in the 10 gallon betta tank I set up for my housemate, and have the Micron Nano in one of my 5 gallon tanks. One caveat though, at least that I've noticed: because it's a motor running inside the tank, it does add warmth in a 5 gallon. Watch the temperature and adjust your heater accordingly, especially if the tank is in a warm room, has lighting geared to medium or high-light plants, or is tightly covered.
Im super new to fishkeeping but have experience with photography, a tip if you have led light with out a dimmer feature, use thin material to filter out the strong light, i personally use a simple tissue paper and you can add more layers to dim the light more
I'm convinced shrimp don't die. My amanos have gone through so much trauma cause of a faulty filter and they are still alive and well
The tips about the lighting are really smart. Thanks!
Love this video😃
I love sponge filters makes it so easy to cycle new tanks and hospital tanks
I admit -- I've been living under a rock. I've never heard of those little shrimp until I started watching videos about natural freshwater tanks.
My first fish were two bettas gifted to me by someone who just couldn't be bothered any more. They were both in a tank that was not even a full gallon (about 0.8 gallons), with a divider. There was some substrate, but nothing else in the tank. These fish were kept like this for an entire year. I didn't know anything about owning fish, but I was quite sure that was an unsatisfactory situation, so I immediately went and bought some one gallon tanks so they could each have their own space with at least a little bit of decoration. I would then graduate them to 2.5 gallon tanks, and finally 10 gallon tanks.
So now I have some 1 and 2.5 gallon tanks sitting around unused. The 1 gallon tanks have proved useful for highly temporary purposes like epsom salt baths and for quarantining and medicating a fish for a spell, but I have so many tanks that I would like to do something more with them. You start here with 5 gallon tanks, but is there anything that can be done with even smaller tanks, other then keeping them handy as temporary holding tanks when needed?
I ove to know, that you are a breaking benjamin fan. :D this was the soundtrack of my youth.
Thank you John it really helps on how to maintain a 5 gallon tank. Love you :)
Me watching this with a 12 dollar light that dims: 😎😎😎
My bettas love the fast flowing water. I have a massive tank with dead spots for them everywhere but they love to challenge the flow of the water.
I love that you love BB! BB is in my top 5 bands. Frigging love them!
If I saw you walking down the street I would never guess you have a UA-cam channel about fish
You are one of the best guides for keeping fish on youtube thank you for what you do bud.
I plan to be a rebel 😁 I will soon start my 8 gallon tank, and the fish that got my attention the most of the ones that might thrive there, is the ember tetra. We have them in the store where I work, and once I started looking at them, I really started to like them. They're both cute and beautiful!
so helpful
Great video guys i been thinking about getting a 5 gallon fish tank for my kitchen I agree lisa I love bettas too
Plenty of options for that smaller aquarium, and nice little mention of breaking benjamin, cracking band 👍
It's an addiction i have a tiny 17L tank it's amazing
Perfect timing!!! I just got my sister a 6.5 G for her birthday (b-day is Halloween) for a shrimp tank. She wants live plants. So these are wonderful suggestions.
This is perfect! I have a 1.5 gal tank that I got from a friend, but I knew it wasn't safe or big enough if I wanted to try aquascaping with a beta fish!
Thanks for the Breaking Benjamin recommendation!! Awesome stuff!
KG Tropicals u got a new sub
Love Breaking Benjamin also!
You should make a breaking Benjamin inspired tank
You just became one of my favorite fish channels
This is the exact information I was looking for, thank you so much!
Great man 👍😍
if you ask me the worst thing about any tank below ten gallons is a lid... They just straight up don't make lids for most sizes that small. And if they do they are legit a pane of glass with a handle (which good luck getting an airtube in or a filter)
I'm planning on doing a volcano theme for my new Betta when I get him. DEFINITELY going to cycle, use a sponge filter for filtration and a python hose for ease of water changes, I'm not losing another buddy!
Did you get him or is he still alive?
Man, i just got into fishkeeping and love your videos! I was so hype to find out yall were in Va too, and i was gonna come see the shop then found out it closed 😔
hi forever fish lover, new-by fish keeper w/ a 5.5 gal who ALSO LOVES BREAKING BENJAMIN (ember tour specifically changed my life) & i WILL be beginning my tank with ember tetras & abiding by ur rules
Thanks for the ideas! I was just thinking about getting an additional nano tank!
I loved watching that little school of fish at 2:25
10:30 yeah, i buy 6 molly from local store and at 3 days, i have some baby molly at my tank
I use those hang overs on my 20 gallons. They work amazing wonders. Definitely reccomend those
True with the guppies.. i bought 2 females and 4 males around march 2020 and now i have so many i cant even count them hahahah
Never heard of breaking benjamin before, wish i did sooner.
Great video, thanks
I HAVE TO GET AN AQUARIUUMM I’ve wanted one for so lonngg
you guys do a really good job at explaining things for dummies like me. 😂
Thank you! This was very helpful❤️
I have 2 5.5g tanks that each house 1 male betta. I use Tetra HOB filters for them and have good luck. I also have 20 something Ember tetras in quarantine for my 29g. I love the 5.5g tank size.
I love Breaking Benjamin!
I have several Aqueon 5 gallon mini-bow's. They are really nice aquariums for the price. I "hot-rodded' the filter systems & the inhabitants are fairly heavily stocked. Interestingly enough, some of the mini-bow aquariums of mine are actually among the most stable in water parameters, in comparison, even with my other larger aquariums. Great video, John & Lisa. 👍
Could you make a video showing how to set up an aquaponic tank with the correct plants to feed bettas.
what do you guys think about box filters? i hear almost noone talk about these. they are basicly the exact same concept than a sponge filter yet you can put whatever media in there you want. you could even put some sponge on the inlets and then have some other media inside to have sponge filter that also has another level of filtration on top. and they hook to the airpump just the way a spongefilter will.
on paper, they are basically ''a spongefilter, but better'' yet almost noone talks about good old box filters
Plus the air pumps do go out pretty quick
Breaking Benjamin fan here. Thumbs up!
I have a pre-set heater for my 10 gallon tank, but the only issue that I have been noticing is that it doesn't really properly keep my tank heated. It says that it should occasionally switch itself off to prevent over-heating, however, I've noticed that mine is mostly switched off instead of being on and keeping my water heated. Normally, when I go to feed my guppies and other fish, I stick my hand into the tank so that the food can easily be spread across the whole tank, but the water rarely ever feels warm to the touch. I have been looking for other heaters (as I've had this issue with at least 3 different brands), so I am hoping that the next one will keep my water at a comfortable temperature for my fishies.
I wanna have a bubba-gump shrimps
I have had no issues with un heated aquariums containing tropical fish.
Your videos are amazing! Thanks to your education, I've been saving up enough money to get my own betta! ❤️
I love this video, could you guys do a similar one but for 50ish gallon tanks? Keep up the great content!
I've been thinking about getting a 5 gallon just to grow up fry and possibly keep shrimp because they don't stay alive very often
I have 6 ember tetras and they are the best little fish I have.
Thanks for the heads up, loved the ember album!
Nice video again! Aquascape/ Bettas/ Nano Tanks/ Thanks!
Those shrimp look delicious
You seem very pro 5 gallon for beginners. A lot of other people on youtube say bigger is better for beginners and the small tanks aren’t good because of the fluctuating water parameters. Is that your mindset too or no and why not?