Nothing but respect to such an amazing character. He does everything what needs to be done. He is braver than any of us. He is a real Man, a real Hero and a real Leader.
I find it so ironic that the leader who had helped humanity advance more than anyone else, couldn’t care less about said humanity…he was all doing it for his dream. The people who were really doing it for humanity, could never do what Erwin did, because they’d be stopped at every roadblock, and hesitate to make the tough decisions. The only reason why he could achieve feats like no other and progress by leaps and bounds, was because he was able to throw his humanity aside in the face of monsters, something that righteous humanity saviours couldn’t do.
I think you are precisely right. A person who fought with only humanity’s victory in mind, would have tried finding other ways to save as many people as possible. And perhaps that’s why no one was able to advance as far as Erwin. Because he was able to sacrifice more and therefore gain more. Thank you for your insightful comment! I enjoyed reading it :)
while his dream was the main goal, he wasnt out-right selfish. I think he believed his dream was also the best course of action for humanity. If it was solely selfish reasons then he wouldnt have constantly put himself in danger and told his soldiers to ignore him the multiple times he was in danger, he would selfishly be ordering them to keep him alive so he can realize his dream
He himself viewed and acknowledged himself as “bad” though. That’s the very reason why he stopped talking about his dream. While everyone else fought and gave their lives for humanity’s future, he alone fought to prove his father right. He’s led countless hundreds of soldiers to their deaths and cared very little for how many he had to sacrifice to achieve his dream. Achieving his dream was even of more importance than humanity’s victory. He’d literally have let the walls and everyone in them burn if it meant he could find the truth in the ashes. And some part of him hated himself for it.
@@6ixlxrd I dont think he stopped talking about his dream bc he thought oh himself as a bad person. He stopped bc he knew if he kept on talking about it, he would also be killed just like his father
@@dieAlbaKids He knew that from the jump though, yet the very FIRST thing he told everyone around him just as soon as he joined the military was his father’s theory and how he was gonna prove him right. That’s not something you do if you’re worried about being killed, therefore that’s not the reason he stopped. He himself said he came to the realization that everyone but him was fighting for something other than themselves. That quite literally translates to him viewing himself as a bad person. There’s even physical representation of that via him standing a top an entire mountain of corpses each with their eyes set angrily upon him.
@@rallarkarl firstly he didnt say anything like that , secondly even if he did say something like that , its not the actual plain truth , erwin was the best character in every way. and i dont think i need to explain why and how
You did marvellous work, squeezed out the very essence of his troubled soul. The role he had to assume was a heavy burden and his pragmatism was the only useful way of leading his troops. But he suffered. You reflected that subtly, also the loneliness he must have felt. Praise for your effort and thanks for sharing!
@Ian Taakalla you know that the Eldians are the Jews in this situation right 🤔 The only difference is that there is no one to safe them unlike the jews with Europe But they have the power to protect themselves Comprehension is a useful skill to have
@@Granglife Actually the germans during the interwar fits the eldians more than the marleyans. As the germans had felt that the world is out to destroy and eradicate them for ww1 (Of course, the inter-war period is less known and often overlooked but it's just a crucial) And from that combined hatred and will placed Adolf Hitler on top, a soldier who has been in that very war that broke his people and has now the chance to even the score and fight back. Fighting back he did, with his political agenda and soldier experience mixing in this eradicate them or eradicate us mindset which floch has. Of course the jews also fit this equation but not during ww2, but during the cold-war with the numerous wars they've fought and won against their middle eastern neighbors who wanted them eradicated off the map, transforming into this unstoppable force which now strikes fear into it's neighbors. I was only inclined to made this response because I don't like douche-like remarks thrown around the internet because someone feels like their opinion is the "truth",
@Takeback the holyland bro Germans were treated like shit but they never once had the entire world gunning for their eradication, nor were they ever in threat of complete Annihilation Eldians have similarities to both parties yes but I'm just explaining how they lean more into the Jews because they're on the verge of extinction But I explained the difference being that Eldians have the power to fight back unlike Jews But they also don't have the support Jews had We're talking about people who about be eradicated so yh Jews are the closest example And no I'm not being a Douche but when people can't really comprehend a simple character like Floch they need to get their roast
@@takebacktheholyland9306 While Germs are the good European comparison some of these fall flat. "As the germans had felt that the world is out to destroy and eradicate them for ww1" Literally no one was out to destroy the German race. Some Thulean society kind fucks did believe it but its like, fringe people kind of delusions and those that weren't just delusional were explotating Europe refusing to be ruled by germany and the existance of miscegnation(a bit more complex than that but Jews, French and Blacks were accused of it as a tactic to destroy the german race) as the evidence of the eradication of their race. This in no way compares to the actual threat that Eldians face in AoT. It wasn't World hatred that got the Germans on top. The reparations they paid weren't as crippling as people claim, for 1 Weimer germany didn't pay even half of it and Britain forgave some of the reparations to itself. NASI rise relies more on a reaction to the commie revolution attempt in Germany killing alot of people and some peculiarities of German nationalism, especially in Austria-Hungary where the existiance of other ethnic groups as pluralities in that state ensured a resistance to their nationalist goals from other ethnicities. So from communist revolts and mass killings came the anti-communism, from slavic opposition to german nationlism in austria hungary came the anti-slav stuff.
"Hope you enjoy it" Daymn I love it so much and got chills and wanted cry through the vid. Erwin is my absolute favourite character and can't find much fan stuff about him 😍🥲😭❤ Cried so hard when he died
Thank you so much! I’m really happy to hear that you loved it so much ❤️ (I also cried a lot. I’m pretty sure sea levels rose drastically after Erwin’s death)
Those who persist to the very end of this broken world, are those driven by the strongest motivations. Hate and love, epitomized by Eren. Hope and a sincere belief that they’re doing the right thing, exemplified by Zeke. What else could give these weak, human souls the strength to go on marching through hell? Erwin was driven by that insatiable curiosity. That insatiable desire to see his father’s words proved right. It was these self-same motivations that gave them the strength to become monsters. In service of their own vision of the ‘greater good’, they deemed that sacrifices were a necessary price to pay. Attack on Titan has many great lessons on the nature of the human condition, but one of them is made so clear here. Those who make it through hell, to the top of the world, must have beliefs ironclad enough that they are willing to become monsters to see their vision through to the end. Only the truly strong get to survive in this brutal world.
Thank you for displaying my favorite character of all time so incredibly well! You really did an outstanding job and understand and show his complexities at expert level
Erwin and Zeke are two sides of the same coin, in my opinion. I think that is a somewhat enlightening realization. Anyhow, this edit explained Erwin so incredibly well.
0:52 "Then my father's theory became the truth in my heart." This video made me realize Erwin's flaw. A theory has to remain a theory until proven true, and that truth could then sit in someone's heart. Erwin went straight from theory to heart, and he didn't care how he did it until he found the truth. It now makes sense that he didn't know what he'd do after finding the truth out 😭 Secondly, this video was well done!
I haven’t thought about it like that before. It’s pretty sad to think that Erwin never found his own dreams or purpose. He dedicated his heart to his father’s theory instead. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I’m glad you liked my video :)
2:57 на этом моменте я подумала, а какого быть таким человеком, который всё-таки пошёл за Эрвином, поверил в него и в его идеи, поверил в себя, всё это скомпилировалось и вот! В какой-то момент на поле битвы человек может "придти в себя" в значении "стать прежним", тем, кто никогда бы не пошёл на такое, если не встретил Эрвина. Опираясь на название данного видео, "The Devil", можно сказать, что солдаты и правда словно околдованы, словно в какой-то момент неведомая демоническая сила захватила их разум и сердце... Это очень интересно!
Erwin is the polar opposite of Zeke, whereas his dream was the same as his father's. I truly believe he would've been a Yaegerist if he had survived and would've convinced Hange and Levi to side with Eren.
I believe that, had Erwin Smith lived on as the colossal titan instead of Armin, while we may have lost a core cast member, in the end we may have also lost fewer other cast members. Or maybe more of them. But one thing is certain, he would have prevented the Jaegerists, he would not have let Eren take initiative. A lot of major tragedies could have been prevented by him. And he would have been supported by figures like Pixis who wouldn't have had to die. In the end, he was the leader who they needed but didn't deserve.
Yes, if Erwin had been chosen the story would have been completely different. Probably in a lot of good ways. But I just felt so bad for Erwin at the end that I couldn’t bring myself to want him back. He’d been forced to do so much already. But I do still feel bad that he never got to see his dream come true
based and yet somehow unpopular opinion sadly... Erwin Smith, a brilliant commander and leader replaced by a naive pacifist who wanted to "Talk it all out" ... would be interesting to see if Eren let them do their own thing how Armin and Hange would "talk it out" when the United Nations and Marley came to Paradis for a "visit" . At first i was hopeful since Armin was one of my favorites but as soon as i saw him visit the crystal i knew that Levi screwed up hard. If you rewatch the series notice how much Armin was actually influenced by Bertholdt, citing Marleyan spawn of the devil propaganda and generally being a very confusing/conflicting character Spolier warning In the end Armin, thanks to Eren (who he was ready to feed to another) who saved his life god knows how many times, gets with the enemy and holds a leaf, yet as we were shown he wasnt the right choice as Paradis got destroyed in the end. Was the brutal destruction of 80% of population and later the demise of Paradis, an island we called home for years as we followed the series, worth just to save the group of "pretend heroes". No. But hey, our crew is alive right? Sasageyoo! Sad... just sad.. This is just my take whether you agree or disagree with me i still stand on that everything you said is an absolute fact
@@deadlyfemboy4289 This is very true. The 80% destruction was a waste. It should be 100% or not at all. Partial rumbling was always the worst idea because it achieves nothing but death. Paradis could still be standing if it was 100%, or if he did nothing at all, Eldians would be wiped from the Earth, but at least everyone else would get to live.
@@CasualBlueLemon As a big fan of English dubs, I would feel honored to create a dubbed version of it if you don't have the time. I don't need any monetization for it. Please let me know if you're interested. Keep up the great work!
I’m sorry it took me so long to respond. I have thought about if I should make dubs or not (because I have gotten some requests before your) - and maybe I will in the future when I’m finished with all of the AoT characters (sub version). If I change my mind and decide not to make dubs, I’ll definitely get in touch with you. Your offer is very sweet and I appreciate it a lot :)
@@CasualBlueLemon Wow! Thank you for getting back to me and considering my offer. I completely understand your decision to focus on finishing all the AoT characters in sub version before considering making dubs (Looking foward to floch's video). I cherish your willingness to keep me in mind in case you decide not to make dubs in the future. thankz
Hey! It’s been a while, but I wanted to get back to you. I’ve been thinking about your offer since you commented, and if you’re still interested, you’re very welcome to make a dub version of this video. No pressure if you don’t want to - I just wanted to tell you just in case! 💙
I wish they translated this video. Also never call someone who has a strong desire to protect humanity a devil. Erwin may have done horrible things but he did them for the sake of humanity. ( eldia in particular).
Hi! I have English subtitles on all of my videos. My reasoning behind naming this video ‘The Devil’ is that most AoT characters thought of him as a devil. So I decided to make the video from their point of view. Hope that explains everything! Also, thanks for commenting on and watching my video :)
They called him a devil because he sacrificed so many human lives for the sake of his dream, the sequence in where he stands in a pile of bodies describes how much of a burden he carries because he loved his comrades, he's not devoid of humanity but as Armin said: to surpass monsters, you must be willing to abandon your humanity, almost every single character in AOT has blood on their hands at this point because in order to move forward you need to be willing to make sacrifices and put your morals aside.
His complexity doesn't come from his 'strong desire to protect humanity'. It was his strong desire to prove his father's theory in the guise of protecting humanity. He said it himself, 'I alone had dreams of my own'. While people around him was dying for the sake of humanity. But that doesn't mean he's an evil person. His dreams is what made the humanity move forward.
![Erwin Smith | The Devil [Remaster]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PLqtEsg3tF0/mqdefault.jpg)
![Erwin Smith | The Devil [Remaster]](/img/tr.png)
I don't think I've seen another video that so accurately sums up the complexities of his character
Thank you so much!
Erwin smith leader by artagon is also really good. You should check it out
Nothing but respect to such an amazing character. He does everything what needs to be done. He is braver than any of us. He is a real Man, a real Hero and a real Leader.
He’s an amazing character. So glad I will never have to make the decisions he had to. He was the epitome of a great leader :)
I find it so ironic that the leader who had helped humanity advance more than anyone else, couldn’t care less about said humanity…he was all doing it for his dream.
The people who were really doing it for humanity, could never do what Erwin did, because they’d be stopped at every roadblock, and hesitate to make the tough decisions.
The only reason why he could achieve feats like no other and progress by leaps and bounds, was because he was able to throw his humanity aside in the face of monsters, something that righteous humanity saviours couldn’t do.
I think you are precisely right.
A person who fought with only humanity’s victory in mind, would have tried finding other ways to save as many people as possible. And perhaps that’s why no one was able to advance as far as Erwin. Because he was able to sacrifice more and therefore gain more.
Thank you for your insightful comment! I enjoyed reading it :)
while his dream was the main goal, he wasnt out-right selfish. I think he believed his dream was also the best course of action for humanity.
If it was solely selfish reasons then he wouldnt have constantly put himself in danger and told his soldiers to ignore him the multiple times he was in danger, he would selfishly be ordering them to keep him alive so he can realize his dream
That progress has lead them to death and genocide. Ironically they better have followed the will of their king. Or Zeke.
He's a Devil. But it doesn't mean "He's bad". He just born in this world. Just as others
That’s true
PERFECTLY stared.
He himself viewed and acknowledged himself as “bad” though. That’s the very reason why he stopped talking about his dream. While everyone else fought and gave their lives for humanity’s future, he alone fought to prove his father right. He’s led countless hundreds of soldiers to their deaths and cared very little for how many he had to sacrifice to achieve his dream. Achieving his dream was even of more importance than humanity’s victory. He’d literally have let the walls and everyone in them burn if it meant he could find the truth in the ashes. And some part of him hated himself for it.
@@6ixlxrd I dont think he stopped talking about his dream bc he thought oh himself as a bad person. He stopped bc he knew if he kept on talking about it, he would also be killed just like his father
@@dieAlbaKids He knew that from the jump though, yet the very FIRST thing he told everyone around him just as soon as he joined the military was his father’s theory and how he was gonna prove him right. That’s not something you do if you’re worried about being killed, therefore that’s not the reason he stopped. He himself said he came to the realization that everyone but him was fighting for something other than themselves. That quite literally translates to him viewing himself as a bad person. There’s even physical representation of that via him standing a top an entire mountain of corpses each with their eyes set angrily upon him.
erwin is literally the best character in the whole anime , never compare him to the devil
@@rallarkarl no he isnt
@@rallarkarl firstly he didnt say anything like that , secondly even if he did say something like that , its not the actual plain truth , erwin was the best character in every way. and i dont think i need to explain why and how
@@generalkickass9237 Wow man, you really didn't understand this story at all
whatever u say bud@@thelegacyofgaming2928
Such a great character.
Some people move on. But not us. Never gonna forget this man. Great video.
"The end justifies the means"
That's the cost of curiousity. Ultimately he sacrificed everything for that truth, even his own life.
I think ”the cost of curiosity” summarises his character very well
One of the best characters in fiction
You did marvellous work, squeezed out the very essence of his troubled soul. The role he had to assume was a heavy burden and his pragmatism was the only useful way of leading his troops. But he suffered. You reflected that subtly, also the loneliness he must have felt. Praise for your effort and thanks for sharing!
Thank you for commenting! I really appreciate the support :)
I like how floch took the advice "If you can't find your light, be your own light" and became the devil he needed here. It's sort of inspiring
When you become a fascist leader to honor the sacrifices your reasonable and normal leader once made
@Ian Taakalla you know that the Eldians are the Jews in this situation right 🤔
The only difference is that there is no one to safe them unlike the jews with Europe
But they have the power to protect themselves
Comprehension is a useful skill to have
@@Granglife Actually the germans during the interwar fits the eldians more than the marleyans. As the germans had felt that the world is out to destroy and eradicate them for ww1 (Of course, the inter-war period is less known and often overlooked but it's just a crucial)
And from that combined hatred and will placed Adolf Hitler on top, a soldier who has been in that very war that broke his people and has now the chance to even the score and fight back. Fighting back he did, with his political agenda and soldier experience mixing in this eradicate them or eradicate us mindset which floch has.
Of course the jews also fit this equation but not during ww2, but during the cold-war with the numerous wars they've fought and won against their middle eastern neighbors who wanted them eradicated off the map, transforming into this unstoppable force which now strikes fear into it's neighbors.
I was only inclined to made this response because I don't like douche-like remarks thrown around the internet because someone feels like their opinion is the "truth",
@Takeback the holyland bro Germans were treated like shit but they never once had the entire world gunning for their eradication, nor were they ever in threat of complete Annihilation
Eldians have similarities to both parties yes but I'm just explaining how they lean more into the Jews because they're on the verge of extinction
But I explained the difference being that Eldians have the power to fight back unlike Jews
But they also don't have the support Jews had
We're talking about people who about be eradicated so yh Jews are the closest example
And no I'm not being a Douche but when people can't really comprehend a simple character like Floch they need to get their roast
@@takebacktheholyland9306 While Germs are the good European comparison some of these fall flat.
"As the germans had felt that the world is out to destroy and eradicate them for ww1" Literally no one was out to destroy the German race. Some Thulean society kind fucks did believe it but its like, fringe people kind of delusions and those that weren't just delusional were explotating Europe refusing to be ruled by germany and the existance of miscegnation(a bit more complex than that but Jews, French and Blacks were accused of it as a tactic to destroy the german race) as the evidence of the eradication of their race. This in no way compares to the actual threat that Eldians face in AoT.
It wasn't World hatred that got the Germans on top. The reparations they paid weren't as crippling as people claim, for 1 Weimer germany didn't pay even half of it and Britain forgave some of the reparations to itself. NASI rise relies more on a reaction to the commie revolution attempt in Germany killing alot of people and some peculiarities of German nationalism, especially in Austria-Hungary where the existiance of other ethnic groups as pluralities in that state ensured a resistance to their nationalist goals from other ethnicities. So from communist revolts and mass killings came the anti-communism, from slavic opposition to german nationlism in austria hungary came the anti-slav stuff.
キャラクターに命を吹き込む声優さんのお仕事って素敵ですね。
小野さんのエルヴィン、神谷さんのリヴァイ、梶さんのエレン。
皆さんのおかげでより一層作品を楽しめました。
エルヴィンの声優さんとエレンの声優さんはとても上手ですね。来シーズンが楽しみです。(^-^)
3:03 Still one of the craziest scenes in this series. Incredibly underrated
Totally agree! I love that scene so I’m glad I found someone else who appreciates it :)
This video gave me the chills. Amazing job. Erwin would be proud. Shinzo wo sasageyo!
Thank you so much! Shinzo wo sasageyo!
He is a man who will sacrifice everything just to save humanity 🗿
"Hope you enjoy it" Daymn I love it so much and got chills and wanted cry through the vid. Erwin is my absolute favourite character and can't find much fan stuff about him 😍🥲😭❤ Cried so hard when he died
Thank you so much! I’m really happy to hear that you loved it so much ❤️ (I also cried a lot. I’m pretty sure sea levels rose drastically after Erwin’s death)
THIS IS EPIC!!!!!!!!!!!!!
everything is perfectly placed from the start till the very end ...
you deserve more brother....keep doing these
Thank you so much! I’m really glad you liked it :D
Those who persist to the very end of this broken world, are those driven by the strongest motivations. Hate and love, epitomized by Eren. Hope and a sincere belief that they’re doing the right thing, exemplified by Zeke. What else could give these weak, human souls the strength to go on marching through hell?
Erwin was driven by that insatiable curiosity. That insatiable desire to see his father’s words proved right.
It was these self-same motivations that gave them the strength to become monsters. In service of their own vision of the ‘greater good’, they deemed that sacrifices were a necessary price to pay.
Attack on Titan has many great lessons on the nature of the human condition, but one of them is made so clear here. Those who make it through hell, to the top of the world, must have beliefs ironclad enough that they are willing to become monsters to see their vision through to the end. Only the truly strong get to survive in this brutal world.
That’s very true. To some extent, that’s what drives everyone in the real world as well. Thank you for sharing your thoughts! :)
A good start is making sure you do your exercise in the morning.
Thank you for displaying my favorite character of all time so incredibly well! You really did an outstanding job and understand and show his complexities at expert level
I’m glad you think I did your favorite character justice :)
GASSS I GOT GOOSEBUMPS 10/10 EDIT KEEP IT UP
Thank you!
Banger video. I would have added a little something from the “fallen comrades” speech and the mountain of corpses, but this is sooo good
That is a great idea! I plan on making a new Erwin video in the future when I have gotten better at editing- so I will definitely keep that in mind :)
Erwin and Zeke are two sides of the same coin, in my opinion. I think that is a somewhat enlightening realization. Anyhow, this edit explained Erwin so incredibly well.
Thank you! I really like both Erwin and Zeke’s characters. I intend on doing a Zeke edit in the future for sure!
@@CasualBlueLemon I can't wait to see it!
I see more similarities between Erwin and Eren.
Finally a video of my favourite character. Thank you!
I’m glad you liked it!
0:52 "Then my father's theory became the truth in my heart." This video made me realize Erwin's flaw.
A theory has to remain a theory until proven true, and that truth could then sit in someone's heart. Erwin went straight from theory to heart, and he didn't care how he did it until he found the truth. It now makes sense that he didn't know what he'd do after finding the truth out 😭
Secondly, this video was well done!
I haven’t thought about it like that before. It’s pretty sad to think that Erwin never found his own dreams or purpose. He dedicated his heart to his father’s theory instead. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I’m glad you liked my video :)
very good edit underrated.
Erwinka 🥺❤
sick edit dude 🔥
best Erwin Smith tribute right here !!! Subbed!
Thank you so much for subbing. I can’t wait to make more edits for you to enjoy :)
Amazing job stay blessed for making this piece. They did him dirty. UNDERRATED!!
Thank you so much!
"The worthy death of an unworthy life"
Jotaro really trying to imitate his great great grandfather's son
Erwin>>>>>
damn i'm speechless
Great content, you deserve more subs man
Thank you! I appreciate you saying that :)
Erwin should have lived , i still get mad that he wasn't given that injection. Like Erwin against Eren would be on another level
HESHEYO TATAKAEEEEEE!!!
This edit was amazing! 👌🏼🔥
I’m glad you liked it!
2:57 на этом моменте я подумала, а какого быть таким человеком, который всё-таки пошёл за Эрвином, поверил в него и в его идеи, поверил в себя, всё это скомпилировалось и вот! В какой-то момент на поле битвы человек может "придти в себя" в значении "стать прежним", тем, кто никогда бы не пошёл на такое, если не встретил Эрвина. Опираясь на название данного видео, "The Devil", можно сказать, что солдаты и правда словно околдованы, словно в какой-то момент неведомая демоническая сила захватила их разум и сердце... Это очень интересно!
This was beautiful omg, WELL DONE !!
Thank you so much! :)
Fantastic work buddy ❤️
Thanks ❤️
He piled the corpses so that they can conquer the walls
A random dude typing the truth
Erwin and Floch are interesting oppisites i feel. Erwin does good for the wrong reasons while Floch does evil for good reasons.
Please someone make an english dub version! This is hype
Thinking I just might :)
best video about Erwin, nice job.
I'm glad you like it!
excellent video, thank u for this 👑
Thank you for watching and commenting!
Perfect 👌🔥🔥🔥
Thank you! ☺️
Too goood
Thank you!
banger video btw deserves more views
Thank you!
What a masterpiece..... AMAZING VIDEO!!!!!!!
Thank you!
*I HAVE A DREAM!*
extremely underrated channel and content
Thank you! I’m glad you think so. I never expected so many people to see my videos though 😅
my only problem with this video is they forget to add the scene where he says Tatakae!
That’s valid! I added it in my latest Erwin Smith video :)
My soldiers rage
My soldiers scream
3:07 Erwin is Griffith
He's not a Devil, he's a Commander of his own comrades
True, but he is called a devil throughout the show and that's why I thought it was an appropriate name. Because that's how others saw him.
i'm literally him
wow
scout walls Erwin Smith
isn’t that kidnapped cute
did you wanna scout regiment 3:25 battle corps group of island that your life
600th like
Thanks for the support! :)
Erwin is the polar opposite of Zeke, whereas his dream was the same as his father's.
I truly believe he would've been a Yaegerist if he had survived and would've convinced Hange
and Levi to side with Eren.
🙇🏽♀️
I believe that, had Erwin Smith lived on as the colossal titan instead of Armin, while we may have lost a core cast member, in the end we may have also lost fewer other cast members. Or maybe more of them. But one thing is certain, he would have prevented the Jaegerists, he would not have let Eren take initiative. A lot of major tragedies could have been prevented by him. And he would have been supported by figures like Pixis who wouldn't have had to die. In the end, he was the leader who they needed but didn't deserve.
Yes, if Erwin had been chosen the story would have been completely different. Probably in a lot of good ways. But I just felt so bad for Erwin at the end that I couldn’t bring myself to want him back. He’d been forced to do so much already. But I do still feel bad that he never got to see his dream come true
Why would he stop the jaegerist? You think he would protect the rest of the world? Thats not his caracter.
If Erwin was still alive by season 4, eren would probably be as relevant as armin in season 4 with what erwin does
based and yet somehow unpopular opinion sadly... Erwin Smith, a brilliant commander and leader replaced by a naive pacifist who wanted to "Talk it all out" ... would be interesting to see if Eren let them do their own thing how Armin and Hange would "talk it out" when the United Nations and Marley came to Paradis for a "visit" . At first i was hopeful since Armin was one of my favorites but as soon as i saw him visit the crystal i knew that Levi screwed up hard. If you rewatch the series notice how much Armin was actually influenced by Bertholdt, citing Marleyan spawn of the devil propaganda and generally being a very confusing/conflicting character
Spolier warning
In the end Armin, thanks to Eren (who he was ready to feed to another) who saved his life god knows how many times, gets with the enemy and holds a leaf, yet as we were shown he wasnt the right choice as Paradis got destroyed in the end. Was the brutal destruction of 80% of population and later the demise of Paradis, an island we called home for years as we followed the series, worth just to save the group of "pretend heroes". No. But hey, our crew is alive right? Sasageyoo! Sad... just sad.. This is just my take whether you agree or disagree with me i still stand on that everything you said is an absolute fact
@@deadlyfemboy4289 This is very true. The 80% destruction was a waste. It should be 100% or not at all. Partial rumbling was always the worst idea because it achieves nothing but death. Paradis could still be standing if it was 100%, or if he did nothing at all, Eldians would be wiped from the Earth, but at least everyone else would get to live.
He was always selfish. Everything hes done was for himself, to fufill his own dreams.
Song?
The Storm by Secession Studios :)
Erwin should have got the titan
A lot of people in the comment don't know what the job of a commander is lol
Wheres all the dub Tributes bro
I don't personally make dub tributes, but I hope you find them on another channel :)
This show died with Erwin 👿
Can younmake one in English Dub pls
I don’t make dub tributes, but I’m sure you can find them on another channel :)
@@CasualBlueLemon As a big fan of English dubs, I would feel honored to create a dubbed version of it if you don't have the time. I don't need any monetization for it. Please let me know if you're interested. Keep up the great work!
I’m sorry it took me so long to respond. I have thought about if I should make dubs or not (because I have gotten some requests before your) - and maybe I will in the future when I’m finished with all of the AoT characters (sub version). If I change my mind and decide not to make dubs, I’ll definitely get in touch with you. Your offer is very sweet and I appreciate it a lot :)
@@CasualBlueLemon Wow! Thank you for getting back to me and considering my offer. I completely understand your decision to focus on finishing all the AoT characters in sub version before considering making dubs (Looking foward to floch's video). I cherish your willingness to keep me in mind in case you decide not to make dubs in the future. thankz
Hey! It’s been a while, but I wanted to get back to you. I’ve been thinking about your offer since you commented, and if you’re still interested, you’re very welcome to make a dub version of this video. No pressure if you don’t want to - I just wanted to tell you just in case! 💙
I wish they translated this video. Also never call someone who has a strong desire to protect humanity a devil. Erwin may have done horrible things but he did them for the sake of humanity. ( eldia in particular).
Hi! I have English subtitles on all of my videos. My reasoning behind naming this video ‘The Devil’ is that most AoT characters thought of him as a devil. So I decided to make the video from their point of view. Hope that explains everything! Also, thanks for commenting on and watching my video :)
They called him a devil because he sacrificed so many human lives for the sake of his dream, the sequence in where he stands in a pile of bodies describes how much of a burden he carries because he loved his comrades, he's not devoid of humanity but as Armin said: to surpass monsters, you must be willing to abandon your humanity, almost every single character in AOT has blood on their hands at this point because in order to move forward you need to be willing to make sacrifices and put your morals aside.
His complexity doesn't come from his 'strong desire to protect humanity'. It was his strong desire to prove his father's theory in the guise of protecting humanity. He said it himself, 'I alone had dreams of my own'. While people around him was dying for the sake of humanity. But that doesn't mean he's an evil person. His dreams is what made the humanity move forward.