there is no right wing in India. If you want to compare Indian parties with European standards then BJP becomes far right, not right. Far right parties are considered extreme and are not liked by conservative parties.
@36:30 the lawyer killed the anti-CAA/NRC argument.. She accepted that everything is based on assumptions.. As a lawyer, she should know that national wide NRC cannot be same as Assam NRC as Assam NRC was done with a cutoff date of March1971.. Such thing cannot be applied for pan India NRC.. Rahul understood her shallow argument and quickly diverted the topic.. wah!! What a moderator
Just loved the way Rahul Kanwal steered the debate and not let it turn into a fish market. This is how an healthy debate should take place where no matter whichever side you are leaning towards, you have a fair chance to put forth your point and also give a quick rebuttal if needed.
Miss Indira, please give him/her (vc) a slack, as this person has to cater to the needs of students, institution (JNU), and government who is the main funder.
Whoever voted to the current government must be regretting right now......... .. And you can not ignore the fact that people are full of fear they know what is right and wrong but they do not want to comment . I am neither an anti - CAA person nor i support it for the moment but i think we have other great issues to be resolved yet . There was no need to bring CAA and NRC .
@ dcx .. Its good to be a patriotic, I'm too but that doesn't mean we should only follow a single ideology..... That's not democracy my friend.. Its India... Not a Pakistan.
You can love ur country without having to love ur govt. ~ Pualo C. But when anyone voices against the govt. , Andh bhakts will rise up...And will blame them as anti-nationalist 👏
So do you think to talk about free kashmir is meaning against the govt but not the unitity of india ? I don't know you are fellow indian or pakistanis .😎
@@gobibo2355 haha ...I don't care what u think about my citizenship...Coz it doesn't matter ...😎 To talk about free kashmir ...Bro u r writing this cmnt coz u have access to Internet... Imagine u r not having internet for months... They r in fear .. govt should try to remove that fear ..Govt knows better how to do that...I'm no one to tell them...
Initially the opposition agitated against CAA simply for the reason that the Muslim votes cannot be risked. Then this protest was started blindly based on rumours that Muslims will lose citizenship and once the lies are busted they tried to find other reasons but in vain. If the continued students protest is justified, why don’t the opposition parties fuelling the protests go and debate the act in the parliament. If the opposition ask a question on this act and If govt don’t respond, then whole country will corner the govt. Govt has said already that they are ready to debate but the protesters simply don’t have any valid points to make and see no option as they just are not able to go back in shame!
I can't believe ABVP spokesperson said "Police didn't took action on masked men because they were thrashed on social media" 😂 Another ABVP spokesperson on another channel said that they "carry ACID for self defence" 😂
Police was shouted at by this very channel when they barged into JMI by saying, "How the hell did the police get inside a college of students when they were *not summoned* ?" In JNU, when this channel asked the police, "Why you are not going inside ?", the police said, "There is an internal security. We are not supposed to go in without being requested." Unfortunately they have become the punching bag to show the anger on BJP for winning elections & ruling the country. I wish you go through the same fate.
@@Iamlatha All wishes are not granted 😂 u may keep wishing... Coming to the point I know the reason very well, why police did not enter the campus... I just said that I can't believe that ABVP spokesperson said such thing
@@Iamlatha your comment about how "the police can't enter the University without being requested" is absolutely ridiculous, ill-informed and logically poor. The Police is supposed to control violence anywhere among the common citizens within the country. If a murder were to take place in the colony you live or if a violent physical assault were to happen in your colony or your college & if the police were called, they would have to take some action to prevent a killing or something violence like that. The Police will not wait for request from the authorities of your colony. Because the Police are not answerable or accountable to authorities of such private or public places. They are only answerable to the law, the protocols & the regulations set for them. Besides, you have no proof that the Police Department of Delhi even got any such request. From what I know and if I'm not wrong, I will say that I've heard plenty of times that the police cannot arrest without warrants.
Who ever is protesting and saying it's discriminatory with muslim will they agree to take the Muslims of these three countries and why only India there are 30 Islamic countries in the world why are they not accepting
India is secular country which has to refrain itself from mentioning religion, if there is no religion mentioned then no ruckus, you are in a boat and you see one is hindu and another muslim both are drownin but you only save hindu and says that sorry I will not save you there are 30 islamic boats far away which will come and save you? When you do a great dee you don't see religion!
This is CAA is discriminatory as per bu United Nation and is condemned by all western countries because they don't have such refugee policy and all of them are secular.
@@exposethetruth5781: India is not the only secular country in the world, In North America and Europe, many of these secular countries get to decide who they want in and who they want out according to the budgetary constraint.
A mind-blowing argument where educated students mention of BJP as a fascist government! Individuals in a country like India have rights and limitations, please bear in mind.
@@dangerous_ideas16: definitely not - review the meaning of fascism and compare BJP as a democratically elected majority ruling within a coalition of parties.
"Secular" Hindu students at JNU eat beef around Hindus, but do not eat pork around Muslims. In my opinion, eating all meat is unethical, and all forms of oppression should be condemned. However, they pick and choose issues to suit their narrative, and display selective outrage: They attacked Myanmar (Aung San Suu Kyi) for its treatment of Rohingyas, attacked Israel for its treatment for Palestinians, attacked Trump for his stance on illegal immigrants, but were silent on Kashmir's treatment of pandits, on Pakistan's treatment of Sikhs, on the illegal immigration issue in West Bengal. Conclusion: They are ISLAMIC APOLOGISTS!
I don't know who won left out right.. But Rahul, you lost by not organising a fair debate.. You cut Siddharth whenever he's finding faults with the anti CAA/NRC argument..
CHANDRAGUPTA MAURYA- was also a YOUTH and he sacrificed his life to UNITE India. ALEXANDER of GREECE- was also a YOUTH when he built a strong kingdom, a strong nation. BHAGAT SINGH, SUBAS BOSE were also YOUTHS when they fought for Independence. But, see in INDIA now! A big shame! IT`S TIME FOR THE NATIONALIST INDIAN YOUTHS (FROM WHICHEVER PARTY, RELIGION, COMMUNITY THEY BELONG)TO COME TOGETHER & DEFEAT SUCH ANTI-NATIONAL FORCES WHO ARE DREAMING TO DIVIDE INDIA!
Soorya told a malayalam channel that she vacated the house on her own, as she thought the place is not safe. She was indicating as no one told her to vacate...
She was asked to vacate right at that moment as she said. Things cooled down after some 4-5 hours. She/her father had complained to the police. Police controlled things and told them that they can stay there if they want, the landlord had agreed to that. THAT IS WHEN SHE DECIDED NOT TO STAY THERE FOR SAFETY REASONS. Clear?
Sorry I can't stop laughing at the girl who claims her fingers were injured in the violence. In the meantime Aishe Ghosh had iron rods slammed onto her head and could have easily been killed. Just my little observation. 😂🤣😂
@@AzamKhan-ht7wx I understand now.. however the incident was a reaction to what happened to ABVP guys a day before. They were beaten up first and since they dont have larger presence in JNU they called people from outside. This time other folks got beaten up more and someone seriously injured. This appalling to see such thing happening in a reputed university. I only hope things get back to normal and students start respecting other opinions and not resort to violence.
She is lying. her land lord wanted to her to evict. she went to the police station and police assured that she doesn't need to evict. she still is living in the same place. they are bunch of lies trying to get 2 min fame.
@@unknownbrokie Good observation Sir... She will stay or leave as per the rent agreement . She is a lawyer , she knows her rights. Tell the gunda gang that their threats will not work..
@@PremChand-sb3lz for sure all party worker gundas should be dealt with strictly. But If she had told the Bjp workers are voilent and they don't like desent against their leader that would have been a completely fair statement. I find it hard to believe her intentions are right when she directly blames Govt for this and stereotypes the whole event. Not to forget she is the one who started it. People underestimate the power of the politicians. I am not legitimizing that they should abuse their power.. But if someone decides to absue his or her political power, this girl wouldn't be in a position to come and sit talk so openly on a national TV. All this seems exaggerated emotions just to show their hate againt current leaders.
@@unknownbrokie You have the right to your opinion Sir... The Constitution of India gives you that right of opinion .. Even the lady has the same right ...no bully can force you or her from respectfully giving an opinion ..
@rulia ram Respected Ram ji, you definitely seem to be very well read .Can you pl explain why persecuted Tamil migrants including HINDUS from Sri Lanka are not given the same welcome as Hindus from the 3 other countries as per CAA?
generally Rahul manages the debates reasonably well but this one leaves room for improvement. Also, some people who come frequently on TV have by now learned how to place their microphones so their voices are loud to viewers while others have yet to learn the art :-)
Anima ji- u r absolutely right. Narendra cannot control everyone’s mind. Do u understand that. Thts the best part of mind. Sorry for you - u don’t have one still Narendra controls you.
No-one, not even Rahul Kanwal pointed out that the CAA is only for the minority refugees from the three neighbor-countries (who for some reason could not/did not migrate during the Partition) who are already inside India now for decades and living in a state of limbo in refugee camps. It is not meant for anyone coming into India as refugees in the future!!! However, India does have a robust asylum system, which operates in accordance with the UN guidelines. Pakistani and Bangladeshi Muslims Adnan Sami and Tasleema Nazreen have got asylum in India. Not something the unholy anti-CAA/NRC mahasangathan will want to talk about.
Govt should install voice recording cameras in every university and if anyone found chanting anti india slogans or doing anti india activity must be sent to jail. Whoever it is.
@@nitinnegi4986 if you have even iota of economic understanding , then you wouldn't have blamed modi , economy has cycles , and during crest and trough parts of economic cycle there is always carry over from each cycle , so successive governments have to bear the burnt of whats been done in previous governments . Now you talk about Statue of unity , go and ask people who have got jobs as well tourism that have increased !!
Finally Delhi police is now act according to social media only, and not to the degree of violence and lawlessness unfolded in front of their very eyes!!!! This is the "erudite" opinion of Sangh Parivar activist in this debate. Do we weep or laugh, it is left to you!
An ABVP worker says that she was tortured by masked goons. The truth is she was actually attacked by masked goons of her own ABVP and this to put blame on other students organisations. This is the one of the cheap methods practiced by Saffronists
I am aghast at the stupidity of this Stephanian girl's argument. She says that CAA says all except Muslims would be given citizenship and in the same breath she is saying that Muslims would lose citizenship. Is she nuts!!!??? How ludicrous is that argument!! A law which grants citizenship to non-indians is being tied to a law not in existence yet to reach a completely baseless conclusion. Both Modi and Shah have on numerous occasions said that no Indian Muslim would lose citizenship....disappointing and shameful is the girl
And, for the government, BJP won majority votes in Assam, and the whole of Assam is protesting against them. So it's not ki non-BJP parties are brainwashing the public, its the public, the common people waking up. I voted for BJP, a decision I regret today.
Marriage Jihad and Atrocity done on me by MIM MLA Mumtaz Khan and Party Gang Members. Bribe taken and No action done by Police and since 5 years in Aurangabad Maharashtra and Hyderabad.
Rahul's so-called debate rules: No one will interfere while other is speaking {but immunity to NSUI (congress)}. Ms Lawyer sounds more unbiased and will be the best anchor.
भारत का युवा वर्ग आज अपने आपको मोदीजी से सबसे ज्यादा ठगा हुआ महसूस कर रहा है याद कीजिए छह साल पहले इस मोदीजी ने युवाओं को कितने सपने दिखाए थे लेकिन एक भी वादा पूरा नहीं किया युवा चाहे किसान मजदूर और पढ़ा लिखा बेरोजगार हो सबने मोदी पर विश्वास किया था लेकिन सबको ठगा अब उसने सोच लिया है कि मोदी को पीएम बना सकता है तो उतार भी सकता है
The problem with debates in India, nobody comes prepared with their homework done, young or old, in position or on the streets. Indian society is no where near a developed society and therefore any kind of deviation from economic growth due to religious/social/regional crisis is dangerous and sad.
The irony of surya rajappan statement , she wants government to address the citizens concerns and when government comes to her doorstep, she cries go back...funny
@@lingunite : Sir, as far as i know, shah was there to explain about the CAA... but we can draw any insinuations based upon our political ideology.. not giving a chance to explain a stand and just crying "GO back" .seems fascism and funny too... thank you for calling me funny...
Some soldiers should be there in jnu campus.. Proper Survilence should be arranged.... If any slogan raises against the country than guilty should not be spared..
Ek chronology aur samjh lijiye 1.first be a victim 2. Then don't allow others to be in that area 3.then demand a small area for creating mini Pak 4.atankwaad 5.islamic state Thanks Smajhdaar ko ishara kaafi
CAA law which came into force on 10th January of 2020, will affect a minuscule of population. 1.3 Billion Indians. 0.1 million Illegal immigrants, out of which 90% get Citizenship. that leaves 10% of illegal immigrants who form 100,000 people might not get India citizenship, might be still given a refugee card, and all the benefits. CAB was introduced in biggest panchayat of India, passed in both houses, stamped by President of India. Now it is a law. To imagine that all these students are coming out and doing agitation for the Pakistani Muslim Illegal immigrants on their own, well- It is difficult to believe. As of today CAA is the law, NRC was ordered by Supreme court of India in Assam only, NRC was NOT even talked about regarding the feasibility, and NPR is another name for census- with a couple of questions more than what was asked during the last census. All the hell that broke lose regarding only CAA - and people insisting on Non-existent NRC (as of today) - ofcourse it is politically motivated. Only naive and innocent would think otherwise.
India Today, students should be banned from joining polical parties despite their age allowing them. However the AVBP leaders here are not allowing the others to speak proving their arrogance.
Leftist : we will talk about CAB And free Kashmir. We are secular. Also leftists : but we won’t talk about Kashmiri pandits because they are Hindus. We gotta secure that Muslim vote bank ;)
@@rp3875 Caste is every where. Brahminism wants to hijack Bahujan ideology and they cleverly project upper caste people as leaders using cultural space.
PRAKASH RAJ What are you talking about? This country got rid of its caste system from government policy and education system a long time ago now. More than 70 years have passed and although the things are not perfect yet, the prevalence is mostly experienced in the marriage space for all practical purposes. Sure, we still have a lingering problem in villages but I believe the only oppressed are the absolutely lowest castes, the poor and the Dalits. Their oppressors are from all the non- Dalit castes and creeds. I beg you sincerely to try to use your brain and reasoning to understand that the Elites in Urban India are totally caste agnostic. India suffers from a ‘class’ problem not a caste problem. I am defining ‘Class’ as the upper middle class and the rich who have been lucky to be English speaking and move in a close circle. It’s offensive when you use the term Brahmins as if you are living in the Middle Ages of India and you are oppressed and victimized because you are a non-Brahmin. It’s absolute rubbish! A surname does not open doors for you in today’s India. It did not even in the 70s. That was 2 generations ago. My friend, please recognize that this is a political slogan. It is being deliberately used to divide the ‘vote banks’ into micro segments and finer lines. First they divided us on Religious lines, Hindu-Muslim-all other minority religions. Then they further subdivided Muslims into Shia-Sunni. And subdivided Hindus into ‘other backward classes’, Dalits and All others. Now it’s time for the next division of this ‘All other Hindu group’ - Brahmins and the non Brahmins. Don’t get fooled. Vote and critique on issues and not on these lines. All Indians have common problems like: Corruption; access to clean running water; access to education; access to opportunity to improve ones life; Value for life; Law and order; social justice for the common man. It does not matter whether you have a certain religion or caste. It’s irrelevant. Hold the politicians (and their media besties) accountable for progress, don’t let them fool you with simplistic narratives. Please, please think for our country’s future and stop getting manipulated by the actual privileged - the political elite and established power centres. I hope you will see my point and stop listening to these slogans and start asking the tough questions that matter to us all.
Ms Rajappan is the only one with grey cells.,and is spot on about a common citizens right to protest . The rest is all pure babble,especially the youth wing of the ruling dispensation.
Mr sunny the student should realise that blocking of internet in Kashmir is a national security and safety issue .How can you explain blocking of internet at the University by the students is comparable .??? This explanation by mr sunny is buzz are .
*DO U THINK ALL INDIANS ARE LEFT OR RIGHT? THATS YOUR BIGGEST MISTAKE IN YOUR LIFE IF ANYONE THINKS*
@Samam Srivastava wat is right ideology
there is no right wing in India. If you want to compare Indian parties with European standards then BJP becomes far right, not right. Far right parties are considered extreme and are not liked by conservative parties.
@Samam Srivastava but that's wrong
@Samam Srivastava OK sir
@@mdi8164 there is no left also who are telling left are urban naxels
@36:30 the lawyer killed the anti-CAA/NRC argument.. She accepted that everything is based on assumptions.. As a lawyer, she should know that national wide NRC cannot be same as Assam NRC as Assam NRC was done with a cutoff date of March1971.. Such thing cannot be applied for pan India NRC..
Rahul understood her shallow argument and quickly diverted the topic.. wah!! What a moderator
Thank you for pointing that out. I noticed the same about the moderator when he diverted attention from her before she could expose herself!
The debaters thinks they're in Republic TV
ONE SPEAKER AT A TIME...
Dr kanhayya sir is not available that's why debate has not happened amazing
Why don’t Media investigate who is behind these protests or the political angle.
Adam LB, He is saying exactly that. If you can't understand sarcasm, shut up.
Bro, that girls voice crack. Her voice adds a little more fun to this debate 😂😂
I was secular and left before but after this debate and some analysis from my side i favour right this time
Just loved the way Rahul Kanwal steered the debate and not let it turn into a fish market. This is how an healthy debate should take place where no matter whichever side you are leaning towards, you have a fair chance to put forth your point and also give a quick rebuttal if needed.
The right won and Siddarth Yadav is really amazing, I want to see him in Indian politics
Plz go through the comment section 😂😂😂😂
@@hanuchandran6861
He cant read.😂
@@hanuchandran6861 yes comment section represent the whole country 😂
Chronology samajh lijiye
@Adam Balleyballey that is what you are. You are a bhakt of another left gods
@Adam Balleyballey you are also one bhakt of another left wing God
The vc of JNU needs to go, he is not supportive of students which is his job.
Miss Indira, please give him/her (vc) a slack, as this person has to cater to the needs of students, institution (JNU), and government who is the main funder.
VV K1, The leftists who took the college to ransom for so many days should've been rusticated long ago. We have become a spineless country.
Dr. Reshmi Das a JNU alumnae and a student leader of the university do not agree with you.
Criminology samjhle Pehele CCA ayega phir NRC ayega phir Shah jail jayega
Whoever voted to the current government must be regretting right now......... .. And you can not ignore the fact that people are full of fear they know what is right and wrong but they do not want to comment .
I am neither an anti - CAA person nor i support it for the moment but i think we have other great issues to be resolved yet . There was no need to bring CAA and NRC .
@@chotabheem9725 only regretting is your kind and Pakistan.
@ dcx .. Its good to be a patriotic, I'm too but that doesn't mean we should only follow a single ideology..... That's not democracy my friend.. Its India... Not a Pakistan.
100% mitro
Sure
You can love ur country without having to love ur govt. ~ Pualo C.
But when anyone voices against the govt. , Andh bhakts will rise up...And will blame them as anti-nationalist 👏
So do you think to talk about free kashmir is meaning against the govt but not the unitity of india ? I don't know you are fellow indian or pakistanis .😎
@@gobibo2355 haha ...I don't care what u think about my citizenship...Coz it doesn't matter ...😎
To talk about free kashmir ...Bro u r writing this cmnt coz u have access to Internet... Imagine u r not having internet for months...
They r in fear .. govt should try to remove that fear ..Govt knows better how to do that...I'm no one to tell them...
Initially the opposition agitated against CAA simply for the reason that the Muslim votes cannot be risked. Then this protest was started blindly based on rumours that Muslims will lose citizenship and once the lies are busted they tried to find other reasons but in vain. If the continued students protest is justified, why don’t the opposition parties fuelling the protests go and debate the act in the parliament. If the opposition ask a question on this act and If govt don’t respond, then whole country will corner the govt. Govt has said already that they are ready to debate but the protesters simply don’t have any valid points to make and see no option as they just are not able to go back in shame!
Students should just study and she is the secretary of abvp - they are mocking themselves
I can't believe ABVP spokesperson said "Police didn't took action on masked men because they were thrashed on social media" 😂
Another ABVP spokesperson on another channel said that they "carry ACID for self defence" 😂
Police was shouted at by this very channel when they barged into JMI by saying, "How the hell did the police get inside a college of students when they were *not summoned* ?" In JNU, when this channel asked the police, "Why you are not going inside ?", the police said, "There is an internal security. We are not supposed to go in without being requested." Unfortunately they have become the punching bag to show the anger on BJP for winning elections & ruling the country. I wish you go through the same fate.
@@Iamlatha All wishes are not granted 😂 u may keep wishing... Coming to the point I know the reason very well, why police did not enter the campus... I just said that I can't believe that ABVP spokesperson said such thing
@@Iamlatha your comment about how "the police can't enter the University without being requested" is absolutely ridiculous, ill-informed and logically poor. The Police is supposed to control violence anywhere among the common citizens within the country. If a murder were to take place in the colony you live or if a violent physical assault were to happen in your colony or your college & if the police were called, they would have to take some action to prevent a killing or something violence like that. The Police will not wait for request from the authorities of your colony. Because the Police are not answerable or accountable to authorities of such private or public places. They are only answerable to the law, the protocols & the regulations set for them. Besides, you have no proof that the Police Department of Delhi even got any such request. From what I know and if I'm not wrong, I will say that I've heard plenty of times that the police cannot arrest without warrants.
@@Iamlatha You are the stupid and an idiot. Hats off to your stupid logic 😂😂
Who ever is protesting and saying it's discriminatory with muslim will they agree to take the Muslims of these three countries and why only India there are 30 Islamic countries in the world why are they not accepting
India is secular country which has to refrain itself from mentioning religion, if there is no religion mentioned then no ruckus, you are in a boat and you see one is hindu and another muslim both are drownin but you only save hindu and says that sorry I will not save you there are 30 islamic boats far away which will come and save you? When you do a great dee you don't see religion!
This is CAA is discriminatory as per bu United Nation and is condemned by all western countries because they don't have such refugee policy and all of them are secular.
Omg cowdung eater........escapeeee
Because they are Indians n not from any of those countries. Y should an Indian go anywhere, unless they feel like migrating to other country.
@@exposethetruth5781: India is not the only secular country in the world, In North America and Europe, many of these secular countries get to decide who they want in and who they want out according to the budgetary constraint.
ABVP : students should study
OTHERS : toh jake pado debate meh math ana .
Lol.
A member of the youth wing of a known political organisation exhorting students to study and stay out of politics.!
A mind-blowing argument where educated students mention of BJP as a fascist government! Individuals in a country like India have rights and limitations, please bear in mind.
So you are telling that BJP is not fascist?
@@dangerous_ideas16: definitely not - review the meaning of fascism and compare BJP as a democratically elected majority ruling within a coalition of parties.
I'm surprised that it is surprising to you.
Best line 'police was thrashed on social media'.. Hence they didn't act my highlight of the topic😂😂
I have seen Sidharth Yadav in some other programs,,,
He is so fluent with honest logic, like him,,,
Oh come on Rahul you know who is on the fact and who is on "may be could be"😌😌😌
With lots of respect, if someone has such a bad throat, must avoid debate and let some one else participate.
The girl on the far right is so dull, she says CAA will take away the citizenship. Those who pretend to sleep, you can not wake them up.
Citizenship is a non issue if you are not a minority.
You continue to sleep well ,people will continue with their protest.
I liked Surya Rajappa's points a lot.
"Secular" Hindu students at JNU eat beef around Hindus, but do not eat pork around Muslims. In my opinion, eating all meat is unethical, and all forms of oppression should be condemned. However, they pick and choose issues to suit their narrative, and display selective outrage: They attacked Myanmar (Aung San Suu Kyi) for its treatment of Rohingyas, attacked Israel for its treatment for Palestinians, attacked Trump for his stance on illegal immigrants, but were silent on Kashmir's treatment of pandits, on Pakistan's treatment of Sikhs, on the illegal immigration issue in West Bengal. Conclusion: They are ISLAMIC APOLOGISTS!
Siddharth Yadav is far far better on the facts than rest
@Ujjwal Joshi. The whole world is Vasudev Kutumbakam if you recognise someone sensible then why you make nonsensical statement about him
I don't know who won left out right.. But Rahul, you lost by not organising a fair debate.. You cut Siddharth whenever he's finding faults with the anti CAA/NRC argument..
Agree
Anima ABVP were silent on fee hike. Don't lie please.
siddharth yadav is quite a well balanced guy in this debate..good to know
That's bjp attitude
They won't allow you to speak
What about the male speaking on behalf of the opposition?
As they don't have facts..
CHANDRAGUPTA MAURYA- was also a YOUTH and he sacrificed his life to UNITE India. ALEXANDER of GREECE- was also a YOUTH when he built a strong kingdom, a strong nation. BHAGAT SINGH, SUBAS BOSE were also YOUTHS when they fought for Independence. But, see in INDIA now! A big shame! IT`S TIME FOR THE NATIONALIST INDIAN YOUTHS (FROM WHICHEVER PARTY, RELIGION, COMMUNITY THEY BELONG)TO COME TOGETHER & DEFEAT SUCH ANTI-NATIONAL FORCES WHO ARE DREAMING TO DIVIDE INDIA!
Anyways i still have a lot of faith in you and you are in my opinion the best journalist(intellectually and neutral) we have.
*jai Young India*
*Jai India* ❤️
Soorya told a malayalam channel that she vacated the house on her own, as she thought the place is not safe.
She was indicating as no one told her to vacate...
She was asked to vacate right at that moment as she said. Things cooled down after some 4-5 hours. She/her father had complained to the police. Police controlled things and told them that they can stay there if they want, the landlord had agreed to that. THAT IS WHEN SHE DECIDED NOT TO STAY THERE FOR SAFETY REASONS. Clear?
Sorry I can't stop laughing at the girl who claims her fingers were injured in the violence. In the meantime Aishe Ghosh had iron rods slammed onto her head and could have easily been killed. Just my little observation.
😂🤣😂
How about the argument that ABVP people broke her finger.. that doesnt make you laugh?
@@atulsingh8010 I don't know who broke her finger. But I was simply pointing to the comparative absurdity. 😂🤣😂
@@AzamKhan-ht7wx I understand now.. however the incident was a reaction to what happened to ABVP guys a day before. They were beaten up first and since they dont have larger presence in JNU they called people from outside. This time other folks got beaten up more and someone seriously injured.
This appalling to see such thing happening in a reputed university. I only hope things get back to normal and students start respecting other opinions and not resort to violence.
@@atulsingh8010 they were beaten up by the teachers also ??
@@nakulninama9347 I dont know. But in the first beating by the left team, some teacher also got beaten up.
Siddarth is like a joker. Felt sorry for him.
Im sorry I voted for Modi And I regret that so much.we were given Bangladeshi cm for voting modi.
I vote for Modi next time
I am from jammu and Kashmir.. And I support internet resistrictions because things are getting normalised in kashmir very keenly and good
43:04 has this girl gone crazy or is she out of her mind. Can't believe she is a leader (must have learnt from her seniors)
Eviction for holding a placard?? How low can the top goons go??? Targeting that too a young lady ??
She is lying. her land lord wanted to her to evict. she went to the police station and police assured that she doesn't need to evict. she still is living in the same place. they are bunch of lies trying to get 2 min fame.
@@unknownbrokie Good observation Sir... She will stay or leave as per the rent agreement . She is a lawyer , she knows her rights. Tell the gunda gang that their threats will not work..
@@PremChand-sb3lz for sure all party worker gundas should be dealt with strictly.
But If she had told the Bjp workers are voilent and they don't like desent against their leader that would have been a completely fair statement.
I find it hard to believe her intentions are right when she directly blames Govt for this and stereotypes the whole event. Not to forget she is the one who started it.
People underestimate the power of the politicians. I am not legitimizing that they should abuse their power.. But if someone decides to absue his or her political power, this girl wouldn't be in a position to come and sit talk so openly on a national TV. All this seems exaggerated emotions just to show their hate againt current leaders.
@@unknownbrokie You have the right to your opinion Sir... The Constitution of India gives you that right of opinion .. Even the lady has the same right ...no bully can force you or her from respectfully giving an opinion ..
@rulia ram Respected Ram ji, you definitely seem to be very well read .Can you pl explain why persecuted Tamil migrants including HINDUS from Sri Lanka are not given the same welcome as Hindus from the 3 other countries as per CAA?
generally Rahul manages the debates reasonably well but this one leaves room for improvement. Also, some people who come frequently on TV have by now learned how to place their microphones so their voices are loud to viewers while others have yet to learn the art :-)
this is call a debate. not arnab shouting
4-5 girls started hitting valentina bharma and she is now sab changa si...
Ghanta 1 university k political bache dharne par kya beth gye youth angry ho gya 😂 chutey left wing waale
Anima ji- u r absolutely right. Narendra cannot control everyone’s mind. Do u understand that. Thts the best part of mind. Sorry for you - u don’t have one still Narendra controls you.
No-one, not even Rahul Kanwal pointed out that the CAA is only for the minority refugees from the three neighbor-countries (who for some reason could not/did not migrate during the Partition) who are already inside India now for decades and living in a state of limbo in refugee camps. It is not meant for anyone coming into India as refugees in the future!!! However, India does have a robust asylum system, which operates in accordance with the UN guidelines. Pakistani and Bangladeshi Muslims Adnan Sami and Tasleema Nazreen have got asylum in India. Not something the unholy anti-CAA/NRC mahasangathan will want to talk about.
All India DSO Jindabad... Student unity jindabad
Govt should install voice recording cameras in every university and if anyone found chanting anti india slogans or doing anti india activity must be sent to jail. Whoever it is.
Bhai proof kese karoge fake news bhi bahut spread hoti hai
Those from ABVP are making sensible points..
Some Against Modiji
No Matter What !!!
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Really
Tell me for what Modi needs to be Supported
@@ednfra5172 for abrogating 370. outlawing triple talaq. That is worthy of support.
@@SC-yj7fc and for gdp and wasting money on statues and increasing inflation and selling govt. Assets
@@nitinnegi4986 if you have even iota of economic understanding , then you wouldn't have blamed modi , economy has cycles , and during crest and trough parts of economic cycle there is always carry over from each cycle , so successive governments have to bear the burnt of whats been done in previous governments .
Now you talk about Statue of unity , go and ask people who have got jobs as well tourism that have increased !!
Finally Delhi police is now act according to social media only, and not to the degree of violence and lawlessness unfolded in front of their very eyes!!!! This is the "erudite" opinion of Sangh Parivar activist in this debate. Do we weep or laugh, it is left to you!
Thanks a lot Rahul sir. You are Great anchor.
Ya country know very well..... ABVP good
An ABVP worker says that she was tortured by masked goons. The truth is she was actually attacked by masked goons of her own ABVP and this to put blame on other students organisations. This is the one of the cheap methods practiced by Saffronists
Rich privileged indians diverting poor Indian students
I am aghast at the stupidity of this Stephanian girl's argument. She says that CAA says all except Muslims would be given citizenship and in the same breath she is saying that Muslims would lose citizenship. Is she nuts!!!??? How ludicrous is that argument!! A law which grants citizenship to non-indians is being tied to a law not in existence yet to reach a completely baseless conclusion. Both Modi and Shah have on numerous occasions said that no Indian Muslim would lose citizenship....disappointing and shameful is the girl
And, for the government, BJP won majority votes in Assam, and the whole of Assam is protesting against them. So it's not ki non-BJP parties are brainwashing the public, its the public, the common people waking up. I voted for BJP, a decision I regret today.
This was a JNU issues debate, with NO LEFT representative. How bizarre, AND how STUPID of Rahul Kanwal (who's bright, normally)
Dont turn it into a fish house ...win through the power of your arguement....
Marriage Jihad and Atrocity done on me by MIM MLA Mumtaz Khan and Party Gang Members. Bribe taken and No action done by Police and since 5 years in Aurangabad Maharashtra and Hyderabad.
Siddhartha was more sensible with facts but he dint get a chance to put it accross!!
If these are the students, god save the country
Subtitles are confusing 😂 whom I for subtitling 😂
Rahul's so-called debate rules:
No one will interfere while other is speaking {but immunity to NSUI (congress)}.
Ms Lawyer sounds more unbiased and will be the best anchor.
Who's ms lawyer
भारत का युवा वर्ग आज अपने आपको मोदीजी से सबसे ज्यादा ठगा हुआ महसूस कर रहा है याद कीजिए छह साल पहले इस मोदीजी ने युवाओं को कितने सपने दिखाए थे लेकिन एक भी वादा पूरा नहीं किया युवा चाहे किसान मजदूर और पढ़ा लिखा बेरोजगार हो सबने मोदी पर विश्वास किया था लेकिन सबको ठगा अब उसने सोच लिया है कि मोदी को पीएम बना सकता है तो उतार भी सकता है
The problem with debates in India, nobody comes prepared with their homework done, young or old, in position or on the streets. Indian society is no where near a developed society and therefore any kind of deviation from economic growth due to religious/social/regional crisis is dangerous and sad.
The irony of surya rajappan statement , she wants government to address the citizens concerns and when government comes to her doorstep, she cries go back...funny
do you think Shah came for discussion with people, or rather he came to garner support from sure-shot supporters' houses? You are funny man!
@@lingunite : Sir, as far as i know, shah was there to explain about the CAA... but we can draw any insinuations based upon our political ideology.. not giving a chance to explain a stand and just crying "GO back" .seems fascism and funny too... thank you for calling me funny...
Some soldiers should be there in jnu campus.. Proper Survilence should be arranged.... If any slogan raises against the country than guilty should not be spared..
Ek chronology aur samjh lijiye
1.first be a victim
2. Then don't allow others to be in that area
3.then demand a small area for creating mini Pak
4.atankwaad
5.islamic state
Thanks
Smajhdaar ko ishara kaafi
Madum ne ek debate mey kaha tha JNU fees hike is solved . And this his how they solved . Or kitna strangi jhut bolegi ye madum
They're mad because there's left right and no center.
ABVP why you interrupt. That is yours party habit.....
We are not violent you are misusing power.
CAA law which came into force on 10th January of 2020, will affect a minuscule of population. 1.3 Billion Indians. 0.1 million Illegal immigrants, out of which 90% get Citizenship. that leaves 10% of illegal immigrants who form 100,000 people might not get India citizenship, might be still given a refugee card, and all the benefits. CAB was introduced in biggest panchayat of India, passed in both houses, stamped by President of India. Now it is a law. To imagine that all these students are coming out and doing agitation for the Pakistani Muslim Illegal immigrants on their own, well- It is difficult to believe. As of today CAA is the law, NRC was ordered by Supreme court of India in Assam only, NRC was NOT even talked about regarding the feasibility, and NPR is another name for census- with a couple of questions more than what was asked during the last census. All the hell that broke lose regarding only CAA - and people insisting on Non-existent NRC (as of today) - ofcourse it is politically motivated. Only naive and innocent would think otherwise.
Exam on WhatsApp 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂wow India wants to become WORLD GURU......
Nitin Parmar
Hahahahahaha
India Today, students should be banned from joining polical parties despite their age allowing them. However the AVBP leaders here are not allowing the others to speak proving their arrogance.
6:30
haha that's what happens when u use only volume without substance.
Leftist : we will talk about CAB And free Kashmir. We are secular.
Also leftists : but we won’t talk about Kashmiri pandits because they are Hindus. We gotta secure that Muslim vote bank ;)
ABVP comes under BJP. isn’t it? But you’re saying there s no politics. Just finger cross question
Yes and NSUI under Congress and other union under CPI
Yes and nsui under Congress
Clear bias by Anchor.. AVBP not given equal chance.. shut down by Anchor..
Left and Right are Brahmin dominated and Brahminical ideology.
Becaus brahmins are ready to fight with brahmins for ideology, you can keep hating us.
@@gunjannaithani8545 In Democracy power should be shared equally by their proportion of Caste as India is a Caste Republic.
PRAKASH RAJ What are you talking about? Another slogan, eh! How does caste come into this?
@@rp3875 Caste is every where. Brahminism wants to hijack Bahujan ideology and they cleverly project upper caste people as leaders using cultural space.
PRAKASH RAJ What are you talking about?
This country got rid of its caste system from government policy and education system a long time ago now. More than 70 years have passed and although the things are not perfect yet, the prevalence is mostly experienced in the marriage space for all practical purposes. Sure, we still have a lingering problem in villages but I believe the only oppressed are the absolutely lowest castes, the poor and the Dalits. Their oppressors are from all the non- Dalit castes and creeds.
I beg you sincerely to try to use your brain and reasoning to understand that the Elites in Urban India are totally caste agnostic. India suffers from a ‘class’ problem not a caste problem. I am defining ‘Class’ as the upper middle class and the rich who have been lucky to be English speaking and move in a close circle.
It’s offensive when you use the term Brahmins as if you are living in the Middle Ages of India and you are oppressed and victimized because you are a non-Brahmin. It’s absolute rubbish! A surname does not open doors for you in today’s India. It did not even in the 70s. That was 2 generations ago.
My friend, please recognize that this is a political slogan. It is being deliberately used to divide the ‘vote banks’ into micro segments and finer lines. First they divided us on Religious lines, Hindu-Muslim-all other minority religions. Then they further subdivided Muslims into Shia-Sunni. And subdivided Hindus into ‘other backward classes’, Dalits and All others. Now it’s time for the next division of this ‘All other Hindu group’ - Brahmins and the non Brahmins.
Don’t get fooled. Vote and critique on issues and not on these lines. All Indians have common problems like: Corruption; access to clean running water; access to education; access to opportunity to improve ones life; Value for life; Law and order; social justice for the common man. It does not matter whether you have a certain religion or caste. It’s irrelevant. Hold the politicians (and their media besties) accountable for progress, don’t let them fool you with simplistic narratives.
Please, please think for our country’s future and stop getting manipulated by the actual privileged - the political elite and established power centres. I hope you will see my point and stop listening to these slogans and start asking the tough questions that matter to us all.
Looks like Rahul Kanval is there only to interrupt Right side.
anima sonkar disappoints , not given answer which were asked to her.
She is always a great disappointment.. Kind of idiot she is
Abvp is talking about education other than religion 😂😂😂
It's like Crow is white ...So Abvp.....
I wonder why left isn't about tudke tudke.
@@joydeepbose6980 it's was jumala created by bjp
Divide and rule policy
ABVP representative can't condemn violence because they are perpetuating violence to student at jnu. Temple of learning. Sad really.
Ms Rajappan is the only one with grey cells.,and is spot on about a common citizens right to protest .
The rest is all pure babble,especially the youth wing of the ruling dispensation.
Youth are angry ?
You are looking at only crying child
There are million of children who are happy
They don’t count ?
I don't understand why is she mentioning kashmir internet shutdown..by due respect ma'am Its Jammu and Kashmir nt only kashmir
youth of India is not just jnu and jamia students.
Anima jii & Siddharth g absolutely right
Valentinna tera juth pakda gaya
5:52 to 6:03 ; true.
This lady from ABVP must watch the home minister statement in parliament and on his road shows, he calls people termites.
This discussion will not bring anything solidly.
Open your ears budhau.
Now bjp should hand over police to state government.
Mr sunny the student should realise that blocking of internet in Kashmir is a national security and safety issue .How can you explain blocking of internet at the University by the students is comparable .??? This explanation by mr sunny is buzz are .
He says he's mad at this one man so what's that got to do with the right students
When you are young you shouldn't take side. Sadly all of them are indoctrinated since childhood🙏
Final comment very funny,social medea toomuch insult Delhi policeman, so they don't caring brutal attacking in JNU.
This aazadi slogan is shame for our country. We are democracy why you want aazadi from anything. You can change it with power of democracy