He asked Peter "Do you love me more" because He was reminding him his denial of Him and his unique experience only he had amongst all the others. Peter then, by regreting doing that, had a special unique growth in love no other aposle had. And upon that, Jesus was making him the pope in that moment. He became more experienced....he loved more.
I used to wonder what Jesus meant by, "Do you love me more than these?". Does he mean compared to 'Other disciples or his profession or in general, basic needs like fish, food, etc.? Thanks, Dr. Pitre, for that explanation. It makes complete sense now. On another note, do you have any comments on why Jesus in His first two questions, uses "agape" (self-sacrificial love), while Peter responds with "phileo" (brotherly love). In the third question, Jesus aligns with Peter's response by using "phileo." It sounds as if Jesus was calling Peter to the highest type of love, but when Peter responds with "brotherly love", Jesus settles for that. Additionally, the use of terms like lambs, sheep, and ewes used in the Greek original text was new to me. I'm not entirely sure what is exactly going on, considering the conversations would have originally been in Aramaic, which was written down in Koine Greek when Apostle John wrote the text. Is there any significance here? The Peshitta does not clarify the meaning. English, despite being one of the richest languages, has only one word for love, whereas Greek has multiple terms like "agape," "phileo," "eros" and "storge." I'm sure there are other examples in the Scriptures where the Greek language provides insights that might be less apparent in English translations.
Jesus fed the multitude and the apostles/early Christians with physical food from the miracle of multiplication of the bread (reminiscent of manna from the Exodus) and spiritual food, His teachings. GOD bless you more for your work, Dr. Pitre. ❤
As mentioned it was a big haul of fish, God is clever and it can have more than one meaning, it can also in tandem be a call to reject the material wealth and live like Christ and in so be a more perfect example for His children.
Hi Catholic Productions, which collection is this excerpt by Dr. Brant Pitre taken from? For example, is it "Saint Peter and The Three Stages of the Spiritual Life"? I'm asking because I'd like to subscribe/purchase in order to hear the rest of this recording. Thank you!
Yes said Peter , then said Jesus "Feed my sheep" Now to the question what specifically is the food mentioned ? Does the one who today sits in St.Peters chair, himself know ? No speculations please
I think he meant do you love me more than the fish. It was a way of saying am I comparable to your craft. He then ups the anti from is my love meaning less.
Dear Dr. I fear that like Peter you are missing the important meaning of our Lord's conversation in this passage. It might be helpful to focus on the different words for "love" and their etymology as they are used in this exchange. It might also be helpful to examine Arch Bishop Trench's work entitled Synonyms of the New Testament, where on page forty one he makes a distinction between the usage of agapao and philos that is very helpful in the context being discussed. If you choose to examine this passage more carefully keep in mind that the distinction between these two types of love is not found in the verb, but in the subject of the verb. It might not hurt to consider the different types of sheep being used here also. Have Fun
Please elevate ur mind C the M3nMe is the father n SON Thee at that time was M3 Jesus Me God Son There is only one God and its M3 n Me Son we are one thee son is he and he is me as well Do u c now Do u c now??
Do you love me more than these? Who or what are the "these". The good doctor believes it is the other Apostles. He could be right. But there is just as much case for saying that the "these" refers to the fish. Look at the context. They had returned to their fishing business. They are fishing. They are eating fish. It is all about the fish. So the risen Jesus is asking Peter if he loves him more than his fishing business / material possessions and he is now about to commission the disciples to become preachers and fishers of men.
Ahahahahah Peter, "do you love me" ? Are you riding ?
5 років тому+2
Good stuff dude. However a bit of a stretch to say now Peter is Shepherd over the other apostles. I get the "Feed lamb, tend sheep, feed sheep" thing. But I don't hear "Lord it over the other bishops. Appoint yourself as Christ on Earth." Yeah, I just don't quite hear that. And I really, really don't hear "Kiss Muslim War Lord's feet like a defeated servant for satan" I missed it when Jesus taught that one must kiss Satan's feet, and shame the face of the martyred saints. Yeah, I missed it where Jesus taught that is God's way to defeat evil. Pretty sure God said show evil up, don't bow down it. Ie Moses Second commandment, Daniel and lions den, Elijah resisting the idol worship, Noah witness to evil, Samson defeating evil, David defeating evil... John the Baptist calling out the evil, Oh and Jesus in Luke 4.8..facing off against Satan. The entire early church calling out evil... Never once did they kiss the enemies feet and beg like a dog. NEVER... No, they resisted evil doers. They kissed and washed their Brothers feet. Not Satan's. The Pope is so very very wrong in his capitulation and support of Evil and support of Evil doers. He has confirmed without doubt, The role of "Catholics" will play for these end times.
It's quite apparent you've missed out on the Lord's Beatitudes...and glaringly Luke 6:27-36 27 “But to you who are listening I say: Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, 28 bless those who curse you, pray for those who mistreat you.29 If someone slaps you on one cheek, turn to them the other also. If someone takes your coat, do not withhold your shirt from them. 30 Give to everyone who asks you, and if anyone takes what belongs to you, do not demand it back.Do to others as you would have them do to you. Peace, brother.
@ Yeah, so, I'd say you have issues. Among other things, "...if you say, ‘You fool,’ you will be liable to the hell of fire." (Matthew 5:22) Whatever truth you might have to share, if you "...do not have love, (you are) a noisy gong or a clanging cymbal." (1 Corinthians 13:1)
He never told him to be a leader over the others, Paul wrote more , the fact he asked him three times is just him integrating him because he denied him three times, no Pope ever , James presided the first council in the book of acts
Yashua HaMasshiah: Kephah do you faithfully love me Kephah: Yes Rabbi you know I faithfully love you! Yashuah : Ok then feed my lambs Yashuah: Kephah do you brotherly love me? Kephah: Hmm Lord I brotherly love you. Yashuah: Tend my sheep Yashuah: Shimon ben Yahunnah do you faithfully love me? Kephah: Rabbi you know all things, you know I brotherly love you! Yashua: Feed my sheep. Kephah (now humbled) turned to the Disciple whom Yashuah faithfully loved and asked,"Rabbi, what about this one?" NB: Here Peter was restored as a shepherd. He was not given primacy. He was humiliated to the point he was asking how much better Yahunnah ben Zebedeah was going to be rewarded for his faithful love for Yashuah. It's sad when Roman Catholics read and interpret the Bible as if it has to conform with their doctrine. Rabbi Yakov ben Yahusheff HaNotzrim was the successor to Rabbi Yahushuah Ben Yahusheff HaNotzrim. Sad that the Gospels which make this clear have been suppressed if not lost. A rabbi succeeds a rabbi. Peter was an elder not a rabbi.
But you certainly skips all the facts that Peter correctly identified Jesus as the messiah. And that upon Kephah, Jesus builds His church. Thus, the three questions and three commands to Peter who Jesus also gives the Key of the gate of heaven. As in the old testament, he who holds the key was the prime minister of the king. Jesus is our King of Universe. Peter is His Prime Minister.
@@jamesm5462 as I clearly said rabbi succeeds rabbi. The HaNotzrims were a rabbinical family. The Papal claims are preposterous. If any Bishop has claim to Primacy it will be Jerusalem not Rome of all places. Humility is not the strong point of the Vatican though.
@@jamesm5462 and Yahushuah was clear about position seeking. Prime Minister indeed. When was the appointment made? And Pope Francis deplores clericalism? No wonder some of you declare him a heretic. Christ is the Rock on which the Church is built. You can check the Epistles for cross-references. Even Peter said as much. He never said the Church was built on him.
1 Peter 2:4-5 The Living Stone and a Chosen People 4 As you come to him, the living Stone-rejected by humans but chosen by God and precious to him- 5 you also, like living stones, are being built into a spiritual house[a] to be a holy priesthood, offering spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ.
Dr Pitre, you're the bomb! God bless you!
Very true 👍🏽God bless him. I’m taking notes & explain our treasure( the bible) to my kids & husband 🙂
So touching moment between Jesus Christ and Peter. Thank you so much for explaining this passage Dr. Brant Pitre. May God bless you always.
I am learning from you...
Feed the sheep with Gospel of GOD.. 🙏
Show me where it is in the Bible ?
Wonderful teaching sir ❤️
Still Trust in Jesus Christ and act of mercy all the time.
May God have Mercy on us and world. Amen.
🇮🇩💓🇮🇩
First time I’ve heard this enunciation of Jesus’ meaning - the verb ‘to shepherd’ in the middle of the verb ‘to feed’. Thank you, Dr Pitre.
Thanks!
He asked Peter "Do you love me more" because He was reminding him his denial of Him and his unique experience only he had amongst all the others. Peter then, by regreting doing that, had a special unique growth in love no other aposle had. And upon that, Jesus was making him the pope in that moment. He became more experienced....he loved more.
beautiful video. thank you Dr. Pitre
I used to wonder what Jesus meant by, "Do you love me more than these?". Does he mean compared to 'Other disciples or his profession or in general, basic needs like fish, food, etc.? Thanks, Dr. Pitre, for that explanation. It makes complete sense now. On another note, do you have any comments on why Jesus in His first two questions, uses "agape" (self-sacrificial love), while Peter responds with "phileo" (brotherly love). In the third question, Jesus aligns with Peter's response by using "phileo." It sounds as if Jesus was calling Peter to the highest type of love, but when Peter responds with "brotherly love", Jesus settles for that. Additionally, the use of terms like lambs, sheep, and ewes used in the Greek original text was new to me. I'm not entirely sure what is exactly going on, considering the conversations would have originally been in Aramaic, which was written down in Koine Greek when Apostle John wrote the text. Is there any significance here? The Peshitta does not clarify the meaning. English, despite being one of the richest languages, has only one word for love, whereas Greek has multiple terms like "agape," "phileo," "eros" and "storge." I'm sure there are other examples in the Scriptures where the Greek language provides insights that might be less apparent in English translations.
Jesus fed the multitude and the apostles/early Christians with physical food from the miracle of multiplication of the bread (reminiscent of manna from the Exodus) and spiritual food, His teachings. GOD bless you more for your work, Dr. Pitre. ❤
I would like you to come to my parish and give Bible study classes to my parish priests n bishop ❤❤❤❤❤
Thank you for these videos. 🙂
Thanks for these videos.
Thank you
Good video, again. Thanks, Dr. Pitre.
beautiful
Nice video
Thankyou sir. For the beautiful explanation. God bless you always.
Amen
Papacy is not supremacy he does not impose himself but he is elected by the college of bishops Amen
only jesus
@po18guy hahaha
😊😊😊😊🔑
🙏🙏🙏
As mentioned it was a big haul of fish, God is clever and it can have more than one meaning, it can also in tandem be a call to reject the material wealth and live like Christ and in so be a more perfect example for His children.
Hi Catholic Productions, which collection is this excerpt by Dr. Brant Pitre taken from? For example, is it "Saint Peter and The Three Stages of the Spiritual Life"? I'm asking because I'd like to subscribe/purchase in order to hear the rest of this recording. Thank you!
Yes said Peter , then said Jesus "Feed my sheep" Now to the question what specifically is the food mentioned ?
Does the one who today sits in St.Peters chair, himself know ?
No speculations please
The question is what specifically is the "food" ?
I think he meant do you love me more than the fish. It was a way of saying am I comparable to your craft. He then ups the anti from is my love meaning less.
Dear Dr. I fear that like Peter you are missing the important meaning of our Lord's conversation in this passage. It might be helpful to focus on the different words for "love" and their etymology as they are used in this exchange. It might also be helpful to examine Arch Bishop Trench's work entitled Synonyms of the New Testament, where on page forty one he makes a distinction between the usage of agapao and philos that is very helpful in the context being discussed. If you choose to examine this passage more carefully keep in mind that the distinction between these two types of love is not found in the verb, but in the subject of the verb. It might not hurt to consider the different types of sheep being used here also. Have Fun
Contrast against Ezekiel 34
Simon the son of John take care of my sheep
But the pope just allowed gay marriage opposite of taking care of the sheep
Please elevate ur mind
C the M3nMe is the father n SON
Thee at that time was M3 Jesus Me God Son
There is only one God and its M3 n Me Son we are one thee son is he and he is me as well
Do u c now
Do u c now??
Do you love me more than these? Who or what are the "these". The good doctor believes it is the other Apostles. He could be right. But there is just as much case for saying that the "these" refers to the fish. Look at the context. They had returned to their fishing business. They are fishing. They are eating fish. It is all about the fish. So the risen Jesus is asking Peter if he loves him more than his fishing business / material possessions and he is now about to commission the disciples to become preachers and fishers of men.
Did anyone else think of the Drake song when they saw the thumbnail and just swap 'kiki' for 'Peter'? Or is just me?
Pretty sure it was just you dude.
@@pizzapocket7878 whak up, mate.
I never heard that song, so probably just you
Ahahahahah Peter, "do you love me" ? Are you riding ?
Good stuff dude.
However a bit of a stretch to say now Peter is Shepherd over the other apostles. I get the "Feed lamb, tend sheep, feed sheep" thing.
But I don't hear "Lord it over the other bishops. Appoint yourself as Christ on Earth."
Yeah, I just don't quite hear that.
And I really, really don't hear "Kiss Muslim War Lord's feet like a defeated servant for satan"
I missed it when Jesus taught that one must kiss Satan's feet, and shame the face of the martyred saints.
Yeah, I missed it where Jesus taught that is God's way to defeat evil.
Pretty sure God said show evil up, don't bow down it. Ie Moses Second commandment, Daniel and lions den, Elijah resisting the idol worship, Noah witness to evil, Samson defeating evil, David defeating evil...
John the Baptist calling out the evil, Oh and Jesus in Luke 4.8..facing off against Satan.
The entire early church calling out evil...
Never once did they kiss the enemies feet and beg like a dog.
NEVER... No, they resisted evil doers.
They kissed and washed their Brothers feet. Not Satan's.
The Pope is so very very wrong in his capitulation and support of Evil and support of Evil doers.
He has confirmed without doubt, The role of "Catholics" will play for these end times.
So, when are you converting to the ONE TRUE CHURCH, the CATHOLIC CHURCH?
It's quite apparent you've missed out on the Lord's Beatitudes...and glaringly Luke 6:27-36
27 “But to you who are listening I say: Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, 28 bless those who curse you, pray for those who mistreat you.29 If someone slaps you on one cheek, turn to them the other also. If someone takes your coat, do not withhold your shirt from them. 30 Give to everyone who asks you, and if anyone takes what belongs to you, do not demand it back.Do to others as you would have them do to you.
Peace, brother.
@ Yeah, so, I'd say you have issues. Among other things, "...if you say, ‘You fool,’ you will be liable to the hell of fire." (Matthew 5:22) Whatever truth you might have to share, if you "...do not have love, (you are) a noisy gong or a clanging cymbal." (1 Corinthians 13:1)
@@brblum Yawn.
@ Whatever, brother. In general, I'd advise against yawning at scripture. Let's pray for one another...peace be to you.
He never told him to be a leader over the others, Paul wrote more , the fact he asked him three times is just him integrating him because he denied him three times, no Pope ever , James presided the first council in the book of acts
albusai Dude compare Mt 16 and Isaiah 22.
Yashua HaMasshiah: Kephah do you faithfully love me
Kephah: Yes Rabbi you know I faithfully love you!
Yashuah : Ok then feed my lambs
Yashuah: Kephah do you brotherly love me?
Kephah: Hmm Lord I brotherly love you.
Yashuah: Tend my sheep
Yashuah: Shimon ben Yahunnah do you faithfully love me?
Kephah: Rabbi you know all things, you know I brotherly love you!
Yashua: Feed my sheep.
Kephah (now humbled) turned to the Disciple whom Yashuah faithfully loved and asked,"Rabbi, what about this one?"
NB: Here Peter was restored as a shepherd. He was not given primacy. He was humiliated to the point he was asking how much better Yahunnah ben Zebedeah was going to be rewarded for his faithful love for Yashuah.
It's sad when Roman Catholics read and interpret the Bible as if it has to conform with their doctrine.
Rabbi Yakov ben Yahusheff HaNotzrim was the successor to Rabbi Yahushuah Ben Yahusheff HaNotzrim. Sad that the Gospels which make this clear have been suppressed if not lost.
A rabbi succeeds a rabbi. Peter was an elder not a rabbi.
But you certainly skips all the facts that Peter correctly identified Jesus as the messiah. And that upon Kephah, Jesus builds His church. Thus, the three questions and three commands to Peter who Jesus also gives the Key of the gate of heaven. As in the old testament, he who holds the key was the prime minister of the king. Jesus is our King of Universe. Peter is His Prime Minister.
@@jamesm5462 as I clearly said rabbi succeeds rabbi. The HaNotzrims were a rabbinical family. The Papal claims are preposterous. If any Bishop has claim to Primacy it will be Jerusalem not Rome of all places. Humility is not the strong point of the Vatican though.
@@jamesm5462 and Yahushuah was clear about position seeking. Prime Minister indeed. When was the appointment made? And Pope Francis deplores clericalism? No wonder some of you declare him a heretic. Christ is the Rock on which the Church is built. You can check the Epistles for cross-references. Even Peter said as much. He never said the Church was built on him.
1 Peter 2:4-5
The Living Stone and a Chosen People
4 As you come to him, the living Stone-rejected by humans but chosen by God and precious to him- 5 you also, like living stones, are being built into a spiritual house[a] to be a holy priesthood, offering spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ.
@@jamesm5462 so even Kephah acknowledges Yahushuah is the ish(man in Hebrew)
Gay relationship.
"All love between males is homosexual."
-Some genius, circa 2019
Thank you