I remember watching an interview with Tim Henson, and he said what he would do would basically be take chord progressions from Pop songs and arpeggiate them, and then create melodies and harmony from them as he wants his song’s structure to be simple to digest like pop songs but still melodically interesting and technical proficient.
@@jakehewitt2697 Tim was talking about how he writes songs with chord progressions taken directly from pop and rap songs, and then just solos over them in one of his interviews. he has always acknowledged that his music is not supposed to be anything more than catchy then Pop music with technical guitar playing over the top.
From a guitarist standpoint, this song is incredibly difficult to play and involves a lot of extended technique that most guitarists just haven't mastered.
@@fsmdanimal I'm not a musician, but can appreciate good music when I see it. This is just bland commercial hip/hop. Reminds me of Christina Aguilera or something similar! Probably recorded on a computer!
If you look for Polyphia's old stuff, you'll notice they were already beasts, technically awesome, with fast solos, powerful riffs and perfect execution. But they were just another prog band in the business. They could easily compete with Dream Theater, but they made their best decision: go beyond everything and create their own style, their own techniques. Now, they are a reference and I love it (and them).
I can highly recommend you watching the music video, then you get a sense of how much of virtuosos the members of Polyphia are. Also Ego Death is another great song.
I thought it was interesting that, despite having not seen the music video, she commented that at one point it sounded like the music moved to a different “place”, which is exactly what happens in the video.
I'll be honest I'm glad she's just listening to it. Visuals are a huge part of media & art these days but it's nice she's just taking it as a piece of music in my opinion.
Music is for listening, not for looking with your eyes. Grow dafuq up and stop with that stupid technical sh*t. Playing god is a simple song musically, it’s classic flamenco.
Also watch the Archetype: Tim Henson, a video he did to advertise some guitar effect software. It's an ad but it's some of the best music he's written tbh
@@Immadinosaur92 I just listened to more of their songs. You're absolutely right Most people point out the guitar parts in Polyphia songs, but damn the drums are very technical as well
guitarist not drummer..so dont hear thos like you do. But i see this comment 100 times over on every polyphia video. Ive never heard the adulation for a drummer like this before
I am a 64 year old lifelong musician (Trumpet) and I just happened across this video. It's always fun to see how someone else reacts to a performance that I can't wait to share with friends, especially fellow musicians. Polyphia is one of those rabbit holes you are more than happy to enter. The lead guitarist Tim Henson is a true monster on his instrument. I am somewhat stodgy in the type of music I play on my instrument but I am also proud to say my taste in music is very eclectic and having UA-cam along with all the various Music Streaming platforms enable us to get lost in the music we hold so dear. I look forward to viewing more of your videos, keep up the good work
One aspect that really makes this band what it is, is how the bass plays so well with the drums. The bass is locked into the kick drum and plays whenever it plays. Keeps the whole song grounded instead of it breaking apart.
The most underrated section of the whole song is Scottie's natural harmonic run at 3:10, when he pulls it off in his playthrough video there's this perfect look of satisfaction on his face
@@ethanquirk28 Oh child, what a sad troll you are. I actually mentioned the production video Tim did for her to watch as it's very interesting. Most of these comments, including this one, are just mentioning the Fiver guy. Crawl back into your troll hole and take the L champ. I know you're not very bright, but no reason to keep showing that off to the world.
Fun fact: the section at the end with the crazy arpeggios was originally done on an Omnisphere and Tim himself admits that when he originally wrote that part, he did it under the *assumption* he'd also be able to play it. Needless to say, it's incredibly difficult to play.
O.D. riff was also written by the arpeggiator, and the backing chords heavily inspired by another song. Respect Tim for sharing his philosophy behind making that song, and of course, his ability to play it.
I was looking everywhere for the comment about this section of the video I think the title is specifically to do with the level of technical skill the band needs to execute
Scott LePage doesn't get the accolades that Tim Henson receives though he is also an incredibly adept guitarist, Tim Henson has a special flair though, they do compliment one another very well
Tim definitely is more plugged into a 'pop' taste pallet and looks more 'tiktok trendy' so not surprised he is more popular. They're both insane technically
Polyphia takes extremely simple and recognizable “pop” chord progressions (in this case i-bVII-VI-V7 which is typical Andalusian style) and then melodically embelishes upon that. These embellishments are always incredibly intentional, stimulating, and ridiculously hard to play. Love these guys. They inspire me!
@@Malapropifythat’s a very obtuse way of viewing music. It’s not a chromatic walk, it’s is a descending minor scale and it is one of the oldest chord progressions and melodic motions in western music
Great analysis as ever Amy. In your own time I would highly recommend listening to Moyun's guzheng cover of this piece. Its a truly spectacular rendition and the guzheng is maybe closer to a harp than guitar 😊
My favorite cover of any song ever performed. What incredible talent. I literally shed a tear the first time I saw that. that woman is absolutely incredible
I have been fiending for more content on this song because I'm a layman who cannot fully wrap my mind around how awesome this song is, but can feel it my bones! It was great hearing your interpretation of this song. You also helped me hear part of the song that I wasn't able to recognize before. Thank you.
Excellent analysis! Thank you so much for taking this request. I have to say the quality of analysis is like no other channel out there right now. Please keep doing what you do!
I never noticed it before, but Tim's playing actually does sound like harp like. Probably the nylon strings on the Ibanez. You're at a disadvantage (?) not being to watch Tim playing this piece. It is a masterful performance.
this is really late, but all of their music's "scores" are sold on their website. you get both a PDF and a Guitar Pro file, containing both tabs and the actual sheet music for both guitars. The bass parts are sold separately, but also on their website as well.
Amy, thank you for taking the time to analyze what has become my favorite song of the year! Your ability to delve deeply into a piece of music is unmatched, in my opinion. Love your channel and love Polyphia!
When you watch at 7:25 you start to realize that this girl and Tim are just on another level musically. My poor commoner ears just thinks it sounds good and sophisticated, meanwhile she just breaks down and could literally jam along with this band using the harp! I’m blown away and jealous all at the same time!
whem you dont play you kindof hear the highlights of a song (the reason pop is so comoressed). When you learn an instrument you hear levels of musoc layered over each other. You hear every note and instrument. That's why i think everyone should learn an instrument
@@charlesreid9337 right, with a couple years of practice it's not hard to do what she did: just arpeggiate over the chords, that in this case were quite simple (Em, C, B7)
Regarding the title: As you point out, the song has a delicate touch even in its most intense moments. We can picture the Creator working intently on the intricate pieces of his creation, taking a brief moment at the bridge to survey his cosmos, and then, recognizing it as "good", relaxing into an expansive free-form bossa Nova as the finishing touches are placed. He then walks away whistling with pleasure at what has been wrought. Think of "playing God" as "God at play" But as someone else has already pointed out, it also makes a boastful double entendre about their virtuosity.
Thanks! Very interesting take...just learning about this group and their music recently. The virtuousity is insane but the music somehow clean and light. Cool harmonics on the harp, BTW!
I hope you have gone on to see these guys play. They are very tight performers and they use social media to educate their fans on how they play. They had several guest artists on their most recent album. Polyphia played TO each of their guests styles. The album is very diverse. They come from rock but I think they are really the ultimate pop band.
Such an in depth break down, love your energy and enthusiasm 😊 That harp and your playing is beautiful and you have interesting point of view. I just subscribed, looking forward to check out more of your reactions and music!
"Playing God" is the second track from the album "Remember That You Will Die". Track 1 is "Genesis" and the last track on the Album is "Ego Death". There seems, to me, a Biblical arc to the Album. "Ego Death" features Steve Vai on guitar. Steve has been credited on a 1982 Frank Zappa album for providing "impossible guitar parts". Another hot shot guitar player that plays avant guarde guitar instrumentals is Joe Satriani. Joe taught guitar, Steve Vai and Kirk Hammet (Metallica) were among Joe's students. Joe's album "Surfing with the Alien" is considered a masterpiece. The songs "Always with Me, Always with You" , "Satch Boogie" and "Surfing with the Alien" were praised for the quality of their melodies. 🎸😎
Pretty neat how you can copy and paste a Wikipedia page. Maybe you should try writing something of your own. Noone who knows Polyphia needs your context.
Why so bitter? They were just giving the youtuber context and info for questions she was asking throughout the video… does it really matter that it was copied and pasted?
Great analysis as always Amy! Just a suggestion, song G.O.A.T is song that changed the music of this young people and set the path to new musical experience and growth of this band, consider next time to go with that song. Tim Henson know all David Gilmore, Jimmy Hendrix and Tommy Iommi solos when he was 12 year old, so it is natural for him to evolve beyond and second guitarist Scot Lepage is just half step behind. Started as just another high school guitar shredder band, they evolve musically great if you ask me. Greetings to Kid’o, Vlad and Amy, keep on good work ✌️
The title, playing god, is a double entendre. its meant to convey the difficulty level, and the skill required to play such a piece on guitar. you must be a "playing god," a person of godlike skill on the instrument, to be capable of playing it cleanly and up to tempo. as someone who's played the guitar for 19 years now and is still struggling to play the piece at 140bpm a month into learning it, i would have to say that the first meaning is entirely accurate. The second meaning behind the title, its more literal, like the whole idea of playing as god. doing as you which, making what people think is unfeasible into reality with seemingly no effort. that is how tim appears in the video. playing with his eyes closed most of the time, lounging around a heaven and hell styled luxury mansion/ villa, the scene changes, the outfit changes, the way the video was filtered with effects so that their guitars always have this energetic glow to them. all of it lends a hand in providing that unworldly feel to the video, giving the second meaning a foundation to live upon. He isn't truly god, but he is playing god for the videos sake. an awesome piece of art thats really quite interesting to analyze on such a level. they did the same thing with ego death, wearing all these different outfits, changing the sound qualities and plugins multiple time, in time with how the scene in the music video and wardrobe change. They do so to depict the idea of psychedelics. whether it be mushrooms or acid, ego death is what occurs when you take a large dose, and begin seeing so many different versions of who you are, who you might have been in a past life, who you have the potential to become, that you begin to lose sight of yourself, you lose your ego, and become your purist form temporarily once you let go of it. The music video depicts that concept beautifully, from a dull parking garage, all the way to the heights of luxury, and every position in-between. the clothes change, the sound changes, the style and vibe to it all changes, but the melodic ideas, the pure artistic pursuit, it remains un touched. their discography is just so varied and innovative as well, never heard something so unique and focussed. cant wait to see how they evolve over time.
I think the title kind of fits. This song is a beautiful creation that has some elements of chaos and order intertwined and everything just kind of fits together while other times there's weird syncopations. Everything has it's place within the structure of the song.
Really interesting to hear you speak about it as a harp player. There are many analysis about the song structure and guitar point of view but I found your experiences with harp bringing up some cool ideas. I’m interested in your take from something by Animals as Leaders. Another virtuosic instrumental metal band. Some of my favorites. The Brain Dance, the woven web, Red Miso, the problem of other minds
Till now I didn’t see anybody suggest Steven Wilson yet, suprisingly to me. Lot’s of songs to suggest but maybe something like Drive Home or Luminol is interesting to start with. I didn’t know Polyphia. Guitar reminds me of Al Di Meola.
I asked every in the comments of almost all of Amy's early videos, but I have up when I read in the Channel blurb that you have to pay $125 for a song request. Fair enough, but too rich for my blood. If the unlikely were ever to happen, I would love to see an analysis of Routine (including video, for extra impact) or Refuge, which has the perfect harmonica, guitar, synth section. If course, many of Steven's songs are outstanding, but those two are hard to beat.
Apologies for the terrible English. I use a Kindle, which replaces my words with some bizarre alternatives and doesn't allow for editing once posted. Hopefully, you get the gist.
Hello, Amy! I'm glad to see you reacting to this one. I was addicted to it for several weeks when it released last year. I don't know if you've dipped your toes into jazz or jazz-adjacent music, but I'd like to recommend a tune from my current obsession: Snarky Puppy, a jazz/funk ensemble with heavy world music influences. My recommendation is Outlier, from their "We Like it Here" record, which is their most popular, and many argue that it's also their best. I know you usually focus on the music and don't look at videos, but with such a huge group, I think it would be beneficial to watch the video, as it helps to pinpoint sounds one might not notice otherwise, plus it really helps to get the energy of the track. Cheers!
Great choice. I must say I think you would enjoy the Mahler style Kyrotechnics of In Vantablack by Kyros. Everything from total chaos to breakthrough moment redemption. Treat your ears!
This is really good, great bit of runs after the intro when the song first really kicks in. The guitar playing from 2:50 to 3:10 is beautiful, the stuff I really like listening to, awesome choices and mixing in some chords as well. To me, this is pretty much improv jazz, although it's a bit more repeated, but the modulation, the half step up, and then back down, is very jazz-like. I might have brush stroked the drums too, personal preference. It's always difficult to give a song a name when it doesn't have lyrics.
@@Untoldanimations Interesting. I can't say that I hear Paco de Lucia, Haydn, or Antonio Carlos Jobim in this at all. Prog Rock is probably a good name for it, it defies description somewhat.
I think it's wild that this song was recorded on two guitars playing nylon strings. Like, it just doesn't happen in pop music right now. I think that's a big part of why this song is catchy, it's a sound people don't hear all that much in music right now. I mean, aside from the fact that Polyphia as a band and as individual members are just incredible musicians.
You can do a version where you play along with the song not a cover but like you're a member of the band then you do your part of the song. Adding more colors to a certain song. 😊
Hi Amy, I just love your channel and of course I have subscribed to it. It is very pleasant to hear your reactions to the tracks you choose from the point of view of a virtuoso musician. There is a Chinese woman named Mo Yun on UA-cam who makes covers of Western music playing a Chinese Harp or Guzheng. It would be lovely to hear your reaction to her music and explain from a technical viewpoint how she can play modern 12 tone temperaments and 5 note chords while executing polyphony. It seems to me as a technical nerd that would not be possible yet she does it - could you possibly enlighten me? Keep up the good work!
I interpret the album this song is on (remember that you will die) as essentially a rock opera or musical about how the 2 guitarists' egos nearly destroy the band, but eventually put their egos aside and achieve an even higher level of playing. This song is the second track, the happy times before the storm as they are just beginning the journey of a group with incredibly talented members flexing, playing, and enjoying making music together. Each players instrument is their voice and they speak to each other throughout each song.
I love this realisation. Each member of the band are incredibly talented in their own right. I'm so glad they've managed to find a path to make their own, they've managed to stand out while making sure no one in the band is suppressed and all have their time in the light all at once. Simply amazing.
POLYPHIA apply advanced guitar techniques to simple, accessible chord progressions. Not my definition of Prog Rock. That said, viewing the video you can see how they produce these sounds on their guitars. The technique you emulate at 19:00 is called Palm Muting; you heard a lot of that in METALLICA. The whistling section sounds like the BOSSA NOVA of João Gilberto. At this early point in your journey, I recommend you focus on more deeply understanding Rock and Roll roots, including Blues guitar. If you are interested in Prog, go back to ROUNDABOUT (YES), and CARNEVIL no. 9 (EMERSON L, LAKE, and PALMER).
Thank you, I was racking my brain about the melody it sounded somewhat familiar. And when you mentioned Joao Gilberto, I realized it minded me of The Girl From Ipanema.
I wouls love to see you review old Chicago songs. Like from the first few albums like from the first album called Chicago Transit Authority. The song "Introduction" especially.
Gotta remember, they are still kids in my eyes. Playing God, is a mentor to them that they are able to create out of this world music. Much like we have a higher power we go to. They play music that has never been heard. Im surprised that a harpist hasn't mastered this tune yet to their inrepretation. It's a must for someone to do this.
This was a cool perspective on this song. I like the way you articulate your impression, I have a similar one. There is a making of video of this song if you would like to see some behind the scenes on the creative process/journey of this song. According to the source, those whistles are in fact human whistles!
I heard the original recording of the whistler before they auto tuned the whistle and I was so disappointed that he calls himself a professional whistler. If he’s a pro then I am a whistling God lol
They titled the song playing god because all the techniques they are using are god like in awe and difficulty. especially the last guitar solo which is way more technical when you try to play it than when listening to it.
You have it right in terms of the song works on texture and color. The reason for the name is that it's a bit of a pun. Tim Henson is considered to be a guitar God by many musicians. Tim is able to mix a lot of techniques that very few guitarists have been able to. Without understanding first techniques that came out reference is missing for you. So, Tim is "Playing God" in the sense of his advanced technique.
His technique is only advanced to people who know little about music. His technique is actually quite strict, constricted. There is a substantial amount of vocabulary that he lacks. Considering his age, it's telling that he can't play more loosely.
@@happypuppy-i4kthis has nothing to do with can't and everything to do with choice. If you can play like he does you can play anyway you want. If you've actually watched his playing through the years you'd know his range.
@@Lloocii choice? No. He can't play loose or with spontaneity. Even his intonation, I suppose is the word for it, is very strict or flat or one note. If he could play loose or with a sense of spontaneity, then he would because that is truly playing anyway you want. I've checked out some of his personal takes and his playing is very strict. He can't play anyway he wants. Nothing wrong with that it's just an objective observation.
@@happypuppy-i4k Don't claim objectivity when you're rocking your bias. You have no real clue what he's capable of playing. What he composes and what he can play are two different things and you sit here conflating the two while claiming to be some paragon of objective reason. Sit down child and shush.
What is going on!? I take a break from UA-cam and suddenly your production quality is through the roof! I love it! Great job! You've really come into your own!
About the title "Playing God" i- it's a flex about the skill level of the musicianship. I would not try to interpret it from the usual context of the phrase "Playing God" but as "we are Gods of this genre and styling of music." Rightfully so - I can't imagine stringing together all of the techniques in a single song seamlessly. The harmonics, alternate picking, palm mute sweep picking, slides instead of hammer ons, tapping, etc. They also have a title called "G.O.A.T." from their last album, presumably "greatest of all time" and the final song on this album is called "Ego Death" which features Steve Vai. Playing God is the 2nd track, so in the context of the album it's about a maturing process and going from proud and egotistical to being humbled by being acknowledged by the legendary Steve Vai and experiencing Ego Death from that experience. I watched a live stream from the band on the album release date and Tim revealed the whistling was done by someone he found on the website Fiver.
That was a great professional analysis. I agree with your vision for the song title. The only thing that I would add is that it gave me an Old Testament to New Testament feel. Darker texture in the beginning and lighter at the end. It gave me the feeling of hanging out at Gods house on his day off and just listening to music over time. Keep rocking! I mean harping!😄
![Can I learn GOAT on violin in only 30 minutes? [Polyphia 🎸]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2hu6sQi6TUU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Can I learn GOAT on violin in only 30 minutes? [Polyphia 🎸]](/img/tr.png)
I remember watching an interview with Tim Henson, and he said what he would do would basically be take chord progressions from Pop songs and arpeggiate them, and then create melodies and harmony from them as he wants his song’s structure to be simple to digest like pop songs but still melodically interesting and technical proficient.
Yes, it sounds like a technical exercise.
@@vruz just pure music theory basically but more poppy
I know that Michael Palmisemo said that, is that what you are thinking? Or did Tim actually say that?
I think he said he even uses an omnichord or something
@@jakehewitt2697 Tim was talking about how he writes songs with chord progressions taken directly from pop and rap songs, and then just solos over them in one of his interviews. he has always acknowledged that his music is not supposed to be anything more than catchy then Pop music with technical guitar playing over the top.
From a guitarist standpoint, this song is incredibly difficult to play and involves a lot of extended technique that most guitarists just haven't mastered.
I'm a metal guitarist. This is easy for me to play!!!
@@thevoiceofamerica2389 We are waiting for your video. Something tells me we will be waiting a LONG time.
On nylon stringed acoustic? Let’s see your video.
@@fsmdanimal I'm not a musician, but can appreciate good music when I see it. This is just bland commercial hip/hop. Reminds me of Christina Aguilera or something similar! Probably recorded on a computer!
It sounds that way.
This woman looks and sounds precisely like I would imagine a Harp-playing classic musician to look and sound like and I love it.
would
She looks exactly what discipline looks like. She parts her hair in the same 5min window every day, i think
yesssssssssssssssssssssssssssss
She talks and sounds very simailar to a classically trained jazz harpist that I know haha
If you look for Polyphia's old stuff, you'll notice they were already beasts, technically awesome, with fast solos, powerful riffs and perfect execution. But they were just another prog band in the business. They could easily compete with Dream Theater, but they made their best decision: go beyond everything and create their own style, their own techniques. Now, they are a reference and I love it (and them).
I can highly recommend you watching the music video, then you get a sense of how much of virtuosos the members of Polyphia are. Also Ego Death is another great song.
Yah listening is one thing. But being able to watch takes it up to another level.
I thought it was interesting that, despite having not seen the music video, she commented that at one point it sounded like the music moved to a different “place”, which is exactly what happens in the video.
I'll be honest I'm glad she's just listening to it. Visuals are a huge part of media & art these days but it's nice she's just taking it as a piece of music in my opinion.
Music is for listening, not for looking with your eyes. Grow dafuq up and stop with that stupid technical sh*t. Playing god is a simple song musically, it’s classic flamenco.
Also watch the Archetype: Tim Henson, a video he did to advertise some guitar effect software. It's an ad but it's some of the best music he's written tbh
as a drummer, the drums on this track are underrated in terms of technicality
The drumming is insanely good in this song, along with everything else.
As are most of Polyphia songs. He hits those notes with such precision it almost sounds like samples at times. Very well written band.
@@Immadinosaur92 I just listened to more of their songs. You're absolutely right
Most people point out the guitar parts in Polyphia songs, but damn the drums are very technical as well
guitarist not drummer..so dont hear thos like you do. But i see this comment 100 times over on every polyphia video. Ive never heard the adulation for a drummer like this before
He has to be a beast! As a guitar player, It's hard to get that far.
I am a 64 year old lifelong musician (Trumpet) and I just happened across this video. It's always fun to see how someone else reacts to a performance that I can't wait to share with friends, especially fellow musicians. Polyphia is one of those rabbit holes you are more than happy to enter. The lead guitarist Tim Henson is a true monster on his instrument. I am somewhat stodgy in the type of music I play on my instrument but I am also proud to say my taste in music is very eclectic and having UA-cam along with all the various Music Streaming platforms enable us to get lost in the music we hold so dear. I look forward to viewing more of your videos, keep up the good work
One aspect that really makes this band what it is, is how the bass plays so well with the drums. The bass is locked into the kick drum and plays whenever it plays. Keeps the whole song grounded instead of it breaking apart.
The most underrated section of the whole song is Scottie's natural harmonic run at 3:10, when he pulls it off in his playthrough video there's this perfect look of satisfaction on his face
Fun fact: The whistler is someone from fiver that Tim Henson hired.
Funny I said that hours before lol
@@reactionviewer funny it's pretty well known since tim said it in a video about the making of Playing God. "lol"
@@noahcosijns7318 indeed which is even funnier that multiple people didn’t think that someone else pointed it out first
@@reactionvieweri mean… including you right?
@@ethanquirk28 Oh child, what a sad troll you are. I actually mentioned the production video Tim did for her to watch as it's very interesting. Most of these comments, including this one, are just mentioning the Fiver guy. Crawl back into your troll hole and take the L champ. I know you're not very bright, but no reason to keep showing that off to the world.
Fun fact: the section at the end with the crazy arpeggios was originally done on an Omnisphere and Tim himself admits that when he originally wrote that part, he did it under the *assumption* he'd also be able to play it.
Needless to say, it's incredibly difficult to play.
think it was an omnichord omnisphere is software i believe
Actually, the omnichord was used for the intro. The arpeggios were created by an arppegiator, but the rest you said is true.
It’s only difficult until you get the muscle memory down, then it’s easy
O.D. riff was also written by the arpeggiator, and the backing chords heavily inspired by another song. Respect Tim for sharing his philosophy behind making that song, and of course, his ability to play it.
@@S1LVERflyinSame for every other piece of music in the world. It’s like saying “once you’re able to play it, you can play it.”
I've never heard ANYBODY comment on the title of the song itself as it relates to the musical themes of the song. Love it!
I was looking everywhere for the comment about this section of the video
I think the title is specifically to do with the level of technical skill the band needs to execute
Scott LePage doesn't get the accolades that Tim Henson receives though he is also an incredibly adept guitarist, Tim Henson has a special flair though, they do compliment one another very well
Tim definitely is more plugged into a 'pop' taste pallet and looks more 'tiktok trendy' so not surprised he is more popular. They're both insane technically
The whole band is bananas. Scott just takes a more rhythm position usually.
Polyphia takes extremely simple and recognizable “pop” chord progressions (in this case i-bVII-VI-V7 which is typical Andalusian style) and then melodically embelishes upon that. These embellishments are always incredibly intentional, stimulating, and ridiculously hard to play. Love these guys. They inspire me!
You know strangely lot about theory. Nice one!
@@Malapropify tim henson himself doesn't though, he explained that a couple of times in interviews :D
I checked it and it's nothing crazy really. It's almost a chromatic "walk" .... Almost sounds like an exercise more than music
Yep that’s what makes them unique and surprisingly listenable
@@Malapropifythat’s a very obtuse way of viewing music. It’s not a chromatic walk, it’s is a descending minor scale and it is one of the oldest chord progressions and melodic motions in western music
Great analysis as ever Amy. In your own time I would highly recommend listening to Moyun's guzheng cover of this piece. Its a truly spectacular rendition and the guzheng is maybe closer to a harp than guitar 😊
My favorite cover of any song ever performed. What incredible talent. I literally shed a tear the first time I saw that. that woman is absolutely incredible
I have been fiending for more content on this song because I'm a layman who cannot fully wrap my mind around how awesome this song is, but can feel it my bones! It was great hearing your interpretation of this song. You also helped me hear part of the song that I wasn't able to recognize before. Thank you.
Excellent analysis! Thank you so much for taking this request.
I have to say the quality of analysis is like no other channel out there right now. Please keep doing what you do!
I never noticed it before, but Tim's playing actually does sound like harp like. Probably the nylon strings on the Ibanez. You're at a disadvantage (?) not being to watch Tim playing this piece. It is a masterful performance.
this is really late, but all of their music's "scores" are sold on their website. you get both a PDF and a Guitar Pro file, containing both tabs and the actual sheet music for both guitars. The bass parts are sold separately, but also on their website as well.
Amy, thank you for taking the time to analyze what has become my favorite song of the year! Your ability to delve deeply into a piece of music is unmatched, in my opinion. Love your channel and love Polyphia!
When you watch at 7:25 you start to realize that this girl and Tim are just on another level musically. My poor commoner ears just thinks it sounds good and sophisticated, meanwhile she just breaks down and could literally jam along with this band using the harp! I’m blown away and jealous all at the same time!
whem you dont play you kindof hear the highlights of a song (the reason pop is so comoressed). When you learn an instrument you hear levels of musoc layered over each other. You hear every note and instrument. That's why i think everyone should learn an instrument
You're underrating how Scott here
@@charlesreid9337 right, with a couple years of practice it's not hard to do what she did: just arpeggiate over the chords, that in this case were quite simple (Em, C, B7)
I love watching more classically trained musicians react to polyphia.
Loved the time you put listening to the entire track before making an analysis. Great work keep it real!
I really appreciate when you use the harp in your videos. Since it is something you know so well, I feel more connected.
Loved your breakdown of this one and hearing it on harp was neat!
Great analysis and I love hearing the harp
Regarding the title:
As you point out, the song has a delicate touch even in its most intense moments. We can picture the Creator working intently on the intricate pieces of his creation, taking a brief moment at the bridge to survey his cosmos, and then, recognizing it as "good", relaxing into an expansive free-form bossa Nova as the finishing touches are placed. He then walks away whistling with pleasure at what has been wrought.
Think of "playing God" as "God at play"
But as someone else has already pointed out, it also makes a boastful double entendre about their virtuosity.
The boastfulness is also drawn from their clear Hip Hop influence. They work with pop beat producers on most of their tracks!
This was really well written, a pleasure to read! Thanks!
I never thought of it this way till I saw this video and this comment. It's a very interesting take. Very refreshing and thought provoking!
Beautiful and thoughtful comment! I thought the same thing, a creator of beats and music, doing what they love!
I’m Japanese and wondering the meaning of this title. Thanks to this nice comment.
Thanks! Very interesting take...just learning about this group and their music recently. The virtuousity is insane but the music somehow clean and light. Cool harmonics on the harp, BTW!
It would actually be so freaking cool if you did a Harp cover of this.
There's someone who did this on a Chinese style harp already. It is an awesome cover.
I’ve been waiting for Amy to listen to this song. I was so upset when she ended the rock history videos and didn’t end on this.
Fell in love with this channel when you say "God is a creator entity where he's weaving a tapestry" ...thanks for existing and creating!
I hope you have gone on to see these guys play. They are very tight performers and they use social media to educate their fans on how they play. They had several guest artists on their most recent album. Polyphia played TO each of their guests styles. The album is very diverse. They come from rock but I think they are really the ultimate pop band.
I enjoyed the music, and it was wonderful listening and watching to your analysis. Thank you Amy.
I love that you watched the entire song through once. I liked watching your face as it played without a lot of stopping.
I think a great title for this song would be Crunchy Salad.
This is great stuff!!! Love this format! Spot on with the chords!
Such an in depth break down, love your energy and enthusiasm 😊 That harp and your playing is beautiful and you have interesting point of view. I just subscribed, looking forward to check out more of your reactions and music!
I love the way she describes this song omg, she said so much in such a simple and unique way, well done!!!
"Playing God" is the second track from the album "Remember That You Will Die". Track 1 is "Genesis" and the last track on the Album is "Ego Death". There seems, to me, a Biblical arc to the Album. "Ego Death" features Steve Vai on guitar. Steve has been credited on a 1982 Frank Zappa album for providing "impossible guitar parts". Another hot shot guitar player that plays avant guarde guitar instrumentals is Joe Satriani. Joe taught guitar, Steve Vai and Kirk Hammet (Metallica) were among Joe's students. Joe's album "Surfing with the Alien" is considered a masterpiece. The songs "Always with Me, Always with You" , "Satch Boogie" and "Surfing with the Alien" were praised for the quality of their melodies. 🎸😎
Pretty neat how you can copy and paste a Wikipedia page. Maybe you should try writing something of your own. Noone who knows Polyphia needs your context.
Why so bitter? They were just giving the youtuber context and info for questions she was asking throughout the video… does it really matter that it was copied and pasted?
Great analysis as always Amy!
Just a suggestion, song G.O.A.T is song that changed the music of this young people and set the path to new musical experience and growth of this band, consider next time to go with that song.
Tim Henson know all David Gilmore, Jimmy Hendrix and Tommy Iommi solos when he was 12 year old, so it is natural for him to evolve beyond and second guitarist Scot Lepage is just half step behind.
Started as just another high school guitar shredder band, they evolve musically great if you ask me.
Greetings to Kid’o, Vlad and Amy, keep on good work ✌️
This and GOAT have a very very similar progression and style. The way the song builds and releases tension.
Scott in no way is "behind" Tim. Even Tim admits that Scott can do stuff he couldn't even imagine. They're on different paths of the same Journey.
The title, playing god, is a double entendre. its meant to convey the difficulty level, and the skill required to play such a piece on guitar. you must be a "playing god," a person of godlike skill on the instrument, to be capable of playing it cleanly and up to tempo. as someone who's played the guitar for 19 years now and is still struggling to play the piece at 140bpm a month into learning it, i would have to say that the first meaning is entirely accurate.
The second meaning behind the title, its more literal, like the whole idea of playing as god. doing as you which, making what people think is unfeasible into reality with seemingly no effort. that is how tim appears in the video. playing with his eyes closed most of the time, lounging around a heaven and hell styled luxury mansion/ villa, the scene changes, the outfit changes, the way the video was filtered with effects so that their guitars always have this energetic glow to them. all of it lends a hand in providing that unworldly feel to the video, giving the second meaning a foundation to live upon. He isn't truly god, but he is playing god for the videos sake. an awesome piece of art thats really quite interesting to analyze on such a level.
they did the same thing with ego death, wearing all these different outfits, changing the sound qualities and plugins multiple time, in time with how the scene in the music video and wardrobe change. They do so to depict the idea of psychedelics. whether it be mushrooms or acid, ego death is what occurs when you take a large dose, and begin seeing so many different versions of who you are, who you might have been in a past life, who you have the potential to become, that you begin to lose sight of yourself, you lose your ego, and become your purist form temporarily once you let go of it. The music video depicts that concept beautifully, from a dull parking garage, all the way to the heights of luxury, and every position in-between. the clothes change, the sound changes, the style and vibe to it all changes, but the melodic ideas, the pure artistic pursuit, it remains un touched.
their discography is just so varied and innovative as well, never heard something so unique and focussed. cant wait to see how they evolve over time.
I love your appreciation and attention to sound! Your thoughts on this song were so wonderful and fresh to hear
Just started listening to this band.... And man was I missing out!! Great reaction!
I think the title kind of fits. This song is a beautiful creation that has some elements of chaos and order intertwined and everything just kind of fits together while other times there's weird syncopations. Everything has it's place within the structure of the song.
Has a Mediterranean Sundance quality by Al Di Meola.
Really interesting to hear you speak about it as a harp player. There are many analysis about the song structure and guitar point of view but I found your experiences with harp bringing up some cool ideas.
I’m interested in your take from something by Animals as Leaders. Another virtuosic instrumental metal band.
Some of my favorites.
The Brain Dance, the woven web, Red Miso, the problem of other minds
This was fun. Thanks for the video
Till now I didn’t see anybody suggest Steven Wilson yet, suprisingly to me. Lot’s of songs to suggest but maybe something like Drive Home or Luminol is interesting to start with. I didn’t know Polyphia. Guitar reminds me of Al Di Meola.
DiMeola yes I thought that too.
I asked every in the comments of almost all of Amy's early videos, but I have up when I read in the Channel blurb that you have to pay $125 for a song request. Fair enough, but too rich for my blood.
If the unlikely were ever to happen, I would love to see an analysis of Routine (including video, for extra impact) or Refuge, which has the perfect harmonica, guitar, synth section. If course, many of Steven's songs are outstanding, but those two are hard to beat.
Apologies for the terrible English. I use a Kindle, which replaces my words with some bizarre alternatives and doesn't allow for editing once posted. Hopefully, you get the gist.
I love this woman, reminds me of my high school band director. instantly subscribed... you put musical thoughts into words in a digestible way 🥰
Hello, Amy! I'm glad to see you reacting to this one. I was addicted to it for several weeks when it released last year.
I don't know if you've dipped your toes into jazz or jazz-adjacent music, but I'd like to recommend a tune from my current obsession: Snarky Puppy, a jazz/funk ensemble with heavy world music influences. My recommendation is Outlier, from their "We Like it Here" record, which is their most popular, and many argue that it's also their best.
I know you usually focus on the music and don't look at videos, but with such a huge group, I think it would be beneficial to watch the video, as it helps to pinpoint sounds one might not notice otherwise, plus it really helps to get the energy of the track. Cheers!
I enjoyed your breakdown of the song, especially your ideas and thoughts on the title. Nice video!
I saw them live 5 or so years ago in Greensboro, NC and they were beautiful.
there are 2 guitarist and a bassist actually
loved the video
Yeah, but it's a bass GUITAR. That's why she says it
Great choice.
I must say I think you would enjoy the Mahler style Kyrotechnics of In Vantablack by Kyros. Everything from total chaos to breakthrough moment redemption. Treat your ears!
That was lovely! I loved your take on it ❤
Great breakdown and analysis Amy. I really enjoyed it. They are all very talented musicians.
This is really good, great bit of runs after the intro when the song first really kicks in. The guitar playing from 2:50 to 3:10 is beautiful, the stuff I really like listening to, awesome choices and mixing in some chords as well.
To me, this is pretty much improv jazz, although it's a bit more repeated, but the modulation, the half step up, and then back down, is very jazz-like. I might have brush stroked the drums too, personal preference.
It's always difficult to give a song a name when it doesn't have lyrics.
Jazz if its played in tune
I don’t hear the jazz. All I hear is flamenco, classical and bossa nova
@@Untoldanimations Interesting. I can't say that I hear Paco de Lucia, Haydn, or Antonio Carlos Jobim in this at all. Prog Rock is probably a good name for it, it defies description somewhat.
This is not jazz lmao. It's prog rock. Best I can give you is jazz fusion but it's not jazz fusion.
I've always assumed Playing God was a double entendre also referring to the musicians as "(instrument) Playing Gods".
I do remember someone stating that they (Polyphia)have tabs on their website which includes music sheets
This is the first time I’ve heard you play your harp. I think the Polyphia song is perfect for harp. They should have called you! 😃
I have no idea why, but I love her review style
Just wanna say 3 things.
I love Polyphia
You're an amazing human
21:37 = ASMR
I think it's wild that this song was recorded on two guitars playing nylon strings. Like, it just doesn't happen in pop music right now. I think that's a big part of why this song is catchy, it's a sound people don't hear all that much in music right now. I mean, aside from the fact that Polyphia as a band and as individual members are just incredible musicians.
what's old is new again lol
I saw them live in November and they were amazing.
You can do a version where you play along with the song not a cover but like you're a member of the band then you do your part of the song. Adding more colors to a certain song. 😊
I really love your interpretation of the song's title! And I believe that Polyphia would appreciate the sentiment.
Hi Amy, I just love your channel and of course I have subscribed to it. It is very pleasant to hear your reactions to the tracks you choose from the point of view of a virtuoso musician. There is a Chinese woman named Mo Yun on UA-cam who makes covers of Western music playing a Chinese Harp or Guzheng. It would be lovely to hear your reaction to her music and explain from a technical viewpoint how she can play modern 12 tone temperaments and 5 note chords while executing polyphony. It seems to me as a technical nerd that would not be possible yet she does it - could you possibly enlighten me?
Keep up the good work!
I interpret the album this song is on (remember that you will die) as essentially a rock opera or musical about how the 2 guitarists' egos nearly destroy the band, but eventually put their egos aside and achieve an even higher level of playing. This song is the second track, the happy times before the storm as they are just beginning the journey of a group with incredibly talented members flexing, playing, and enjoying making music together. Each players instrument is their voice and they speak to each other throughout each song.
I love this realisation. Each member of the band are incredibly talented in their own right. I'm so glad they've managed to find a path to make their own, they've managed to stand out while making sure no one in the band is suppressed and all have their time in the light all at once. Simply amazing.
THis is so awesome and it fits the song so well. would love to hear a collab with tim on the guitar and you on the harp!
what you said about how the song seems to be shifting to different places is actually reflected in the music video
oof, yes 7:48 ...this gave me chills. Amazing chord interval...And arp just sounds beautiful. Thanks for this.
POLYPHIA apply advanced guitar techniques to simple, accessible chord progressions. Not my definition of Prog Rock. That said, viewing the video you can see how they produce these sounds on their guitars. The technique you emulate at 19:00 is called Palm Muting; you heard a lot of that in METALLICA. The whistling section sounds like the BOSSA NOVA of João Gilberto. At this early point in your journey, I recommend you focus on more deeply understanding Rock and Roll roots, including Blues guitar. If you are interested in Prog, go back to ROUNDABOUT (YES), and CARNEVIL no. 9 (EMERSON L, LAKE, and PALMER).
Thank you, I was racking my brain about the melody it sounded somewhat familiar. And when you mentioned Joao Gilberto, I realized it minded me of The Girl From Ipanema.
Strange use of caps you got there. Anyways, I was expecting some comment talking about palm muting and Bossa Nova and you deliver. Thank you.
I wouls love to see you review old Chicago songs. Like from the first few albums like from the first album called Chicago Transit Authority. The song "Introduction" especially.
Suggestion for another instrumental: Albatross, by [Peter Green's] Fleetwood Mac.
Ugh that breakdownnnnnnnn. Makes me smell the salty ocean air on a warm night 🌚
Is awesome to see you try it on the harp, that's what im here fore, together with the reaction
ANOTHER ONE YEAAAAAAAAAA
as in another classical musician listening to Playing God yaaaaaaaay
Who is the other one?
@@memeteme99 there’s a few if you search for it
@@memeteme99 oh ok not playing god but other Polyphia songs
Gotta remember, they are still kids in my eyes. Playing God, is a mentor to them that they are able to create out of this world music. Much like we have a higher power we go to. They play music that has never been heard. Im surprised that a harpist hasn't mastered this tune yet to their inrepretation. It's a must for someone to do this.
Love how she is able to keep just a slight smile on her face while listening to this for the first time. Most people smile more. :)
7:00-8:00 was so sick, I’m amazed by how well you know music
In one of their video they mentionned that they hired a professional whistler for the whistle parts when they recorded.
Wow she’s just great. Phenomenal musical vocabulary
Like others have said its nice to see the music video to watch their playing. Also Ego Death.
This was a cool perspective on this song. I like the way you articulate your impression, I have a similar one. There is a making of video of this song if you would like to see some behind the scenes on the creative process/journey of this song. According to the source, those whistles are in fact human whistles!
They actually hired a professional whistler to do the whistling parts lol
I heard the original recording of the whistler before they auto tuned the whistle and I was so disappointed that he calls himself a professional whistler. If he’s a pro then I am a whistling God lol
They titled the song playing god because all the techniques they are using are god like in awe and difficulty. especially the last guitar solo which is way more technical when you try to play it than when listening to it.
You have it right in terms of the song works on texture and color. The reason for the name is that it's a bit of a pun. Tim Henson is considered to be a guitar God by many musicians. Tim is able to mix a lot of techniques that very few guitarists have been able to. Without understanding first techniques that came out reference is missing for you. So, Tim is "Playing God" in the sense of his advanced technique.
His technique is only advanced to people who know little about music. His technique is actually quite strict, constricted. There is a substantial amount of vocabulary that he lacks. Considering his age, it's telling that he can't play more loosely.
@@happypuppy-i4k 🙄
@@happypuppy-i4kthis has nothing to do with can't and everything to do with choice. If you can play like he does you can play anyway you want. If you've actually watched his playing through the years you'd know his range.
@@Lloocii choice? No. He can't play loose or with spontaneity. Even his intonation, I suppose is the word for it, is very strict or flat or one note. If he could play loose or with a sense of spontaneity, then he would because that is truly playing anyway you want. I've checked out some of his personal takes and his playing is very strict.
He can't play anyway he wants. Nothing wrong with that it's just an objective observation.
@@happypuppy-i4k Don't claim objectivity when you're rocking your bias. You have no real clue what he's capable of playing. What he composes and what he can play are two different things and you sit here conflating the two while claiming to be some paragon of objective reason. Sit down child and shush.
What is going on!? I take a break from UA-cam and suddenly your production quality is through the roof! I love it! Great job! You've really come into your own!
There is official sheet music for this, sold directly by the band.
About the title "Playing God" i- it's a flex about the skill level of the musicianship. I would not try to interpret it from the usual context of the phrase "Playing God" but as "we are Gods of this genre and styling of music." Rightfully so - I can't imagine stringing together all of the techniques in a single song seamlessly. The harmonics, alternate picking, palm mute sweep picking, slides instead of hammer ons, tapping, etc. They also have a title called "G.O.A.T." from their last album, presumably "greatest of all time" and the final song on this album is called "Ego Death" which features Steve Vai. Playing God is the 2nd track, so in the context of the album it's about a maturing process and going from proud and egotistical to being humbled by being acknowledged by the legendary Steve Vai and experiencing Ego Death from that experience. I watched a live stream from the band on the album release date and Tim revealed the whistling was done by someone he found on the website Fiver.
Tim Henson needs to watch this and get this woman on his next album.
I mean... this has been covered on literally everything at this point and the chinese harp being one of the most impressive of all.
I would say you definitely need to see the band play.
I guess if there were guitar Gods... they would be the band.
My take is that the band isn't playing at being God, they are manifesting the voice of God. They "play God" as one might "play Bach".
YES . THESE GUYS ARE TOO SMART TO MOCK GOD WHO GAVE THEM THEIR TALENTS
That was a great professional analysis. I agree with your vision for the song title. The only thing that I would add is that it gave me an Old Testament to New Testament feel. Darker texture in the beginning and lighter at the end. It gave me the feeling of hanging out at Gods house on his day off and just listening to music over time. Keep rocking! I mean harping!😄
Im glad i found your channel, good stuff
Being obsessed with sounds is what Prog Rock is all about.
Absolutely beautiful and detailed reaction.
I also LOVE LOVE LOVE how quickly clasiical music players are able to pick it up lol.
... the harp sitting beside her just gives her an even deeper angelic impression.