I hate it too. But here's the chinese logic: 1. They don't recognize North Koreans as "refugees" or asylum due to their relationship with NK even when the defectors reach SK embassy or consulate they aren't safe. China still deports them to NK. 2. China wants to prevent a scenario where their borders will be flooded with North Koreans fleeing, thats why they facilitate the Kim regime. Although, the defectors are legally citizens of South Korean the Chinese purposely send them back to NK as a deterrent. This is why defectors who leave via China need to reach other Countries that are safe for defectors to claim asylum and whom they know will deport them to south korea. Which are Thailand and Mongolia as they have agreements with South Korea over thid. As they have agreement with South korra that they send them to Sk rather than the NK.
@@wawawoo-24This is the official statement. In fact, the Chinese government's policy towards North Koreans who illegally enter China has gradually changed. People from North Korea went to South Korea to get money, robbed and killed people in China, and used AK47s to engage in gun battles with Chinese troops. Finally, the Chinese government could no longer tolerate it. All illegal immigrants from North Korea were arrested and sent back to North Korea.
Please remember that China does not retain military bases and soldiers on the Korean Peninsula. Think about it, who has military bases and soldiers there?
@@kuan-k4mit is because the Chinese interfered during the war and the Kim family refused Chinese military to remain in the peninsula to maintain closer ties to Soviet Union. so study more you CCP dog.
@@IIIiIiiIiIiiilllllllllII The Korean Peninsula is the appendix of Asia. China and the United States are the masters of the Korean Peninsula. They have granted temporary peace to the Korean Peninsula. Therefore, the appendix should not be inflamed, otherwise it will be removed.
@@kuan-k4myou're an idiot with no sympathy for the many suffering north Koreans who risk their lives just so they could have a better life.....is it not china who deports every North Korean defectors?
China takes in 40 thousand North Korean foreign workers EVERY YEAR! This Aljazeera report purposely didn't disclose that the United Nations Security Council Resolution 2397 demands that all N.Korean defectors be sent back to North Korea. So why make China into a bad guy? China is protecting itself first unlike the US and Europe with its own migrant crisis.
Go live there. See for yourself. Why do u all want to keep living in the west instead of China nord Korea and Russia. Why are their people begging at our border for asylum?
@@randomguy3496he'd better go live in Palestine, not Gaza, and see how people are treated there. After a few days, he'll be begging to enter the gates of Israel.
Turkey's situation is also similar to North Koreans. İ am masters alumni and my English, german languages are advanced stage, i cannot immigrate to Schengen or australia or USA even at the age of 51 years old and being baptist christian. İt is impossible to find decent wage Job in Turkey, we are waiting to die naturally. The pension wage that Turkey gives, never enough to purchase New car in Turkey on New apartment in the country. No girl or women want to marry me because of pension wage's lowness. İt is disgusting to live under terror threats since 1979 and under muslim ezan voices coming from mosques. İ am unemployed for 11 years , my Medical specialist father and mother are unemployed for 20 years after they become pensioners with very low wages.
AJ’s story tried to raise sympathy for the North Korean defectors so they pictured all of their lives in China as being abused, sexually trafficked etc. fact is, there are 50 million living in China as the video says, there’s a reason for that…. Also, of course they ultimately prefer to go to South Korea, because they are the same people, and they’ll have legal status and some money to settle down. But you can not blame a country( and the people in the country) for not taking refugees, I.e, most countries are not taking refugees from Syria, from Palestine etc. plus the famine happened in the 1990s, so I’m not sure now, in 2024, whether there’s still large amount of people leaving North Korea as legitimate refugee, like the super poor Chinese or Vietnam people from rural areas can’t just go to another country without a visa and expect citizen treatment? Where I am in Australia we have super strict border rules too. Of course, having read many stories of defectors they have experienced horrendous hunger and I wish countries around the world had helped with food for humanitarian aids back then. And wish them all a better life now
The main point is that North Korean citizens are struggling. Most of the population still suffer from food insecurity & they have no right to move around freely or to have their own opinions. Many of them are sent to work or concentration camps where they are used as free labor and worked to their deaths. Some cross the river to China and are sold as wives or are forced to work in some form of prostitution. Men are most likely sent back to NK when discovered by Chinese Police knowing what gruesome fate awaits them.
One of the women earlier on said she was treated fairly kindly in China. So people's stories are going to be different. But yes, they want to get out of China because China will typically deport them back, where they are sent to prison camps or executed. That in itself is a crime against humanity. Even if other countries aren't accepting refugees, they don't turn them back over to the government who may execute them. That is a UN crime and China does it
Why is the Western world promoted as free, civilized, democratic, and wealthy, while China, North Korea, and Syria are labeled as autocratic, dictatorial, and poor? You should know that the Western world has provoked 90% of wars and sanctions. Every year, tens of thousands of people die due to lack of assistance due to wars and sanctions. Who is deliberately creating the information cocoon?
I don't think they expect good treatment in the first place, since they always had a bad one. Doesn't matter if there are 50 million or 5 million, bad guys along the NK border know how they can speculate and get money from selling defectors (or snitch to police) and it's hardly possible to avoid those Also, the amount of NK refugees has been dropping tremendously in recent years, so the amount is not large at all
@@trkantiteza Let me tell you why in the China-North Korea border area, Chinese people report people who sneak into China from North Korea. You know, the border between China and North Korea is just a river 50 meters wide and 2 meters deep. It is easy to cross the border in autumn and winter. About ten or twenty years ago, North Korea suffered natural disasters and food shortages. People from North Korea sneaked into China to try to find food. At first, they could get rice, corn and other food from the Chinese by selling labor or begging, and then bring them back to North Korea to share with their families. As the food shortage became serious, more and more people knew this method. Going to China to find food was their only chance to survive. From rice, cooking oil, chickens, pigs, and cows, they wanted to get everything. From begging and selling labor to get food, they finally started threatening, violently robbing, and killing, until a horrific massacre occurred. Many soldiers of the North Korean border guards carried AK-47 rifles into the villages on the Chinese border to rob and kill Chinese people, steal money and food, and engage in gun battles with Chinese troops. The Chinese government protested to North Korea and began to block the border. And tell the Chinese in the border areas not to take in people from North Korea, and report them in time to avoid being harmed. So, from now on, the Chinese will no longer treat people from North Korea with kindness. Because you don't know whether your kindness will be exchanged for kindness or death. Also, after North Korean soldiers massacred dozens of Chinese, the North Korean government apologized, but was only willing to compensate according to North Korean standards, about $500 per person.
most of chinese cannot be trusted instead of helping human in need they will abused you. You pray hard to God when your in a situation no one to rely on but yourself. Let God be your companion for every fears you have.
15:03 I don't think the South Korean pastor really had connections with a random railway police in China, It's more likely that the railway police had sympathy for this North Korean and closed one eye. For the question about how the Chinese government treats North Korean defectors who live in China. What I know is as follows: 1. If a North Korean living in China commit crimes, he/she will be deported back to North Korea. 2. If a North Korean living in China tries to get to South Korea, he/she will be deported back to North Korea. 3. If a North Korean living in China does not commit crimes, and does not try to get to South Korea, he/she will be allowed to live in China and will NOT be deported to North Korea. This is how China balances itself between maintaining its relationship with the North Korean government and taking humanitarian factors into consideration.
So in life you must focus on your goals and be ready for what comes next. Or else you’ll stay stuck at your situation in which you are fighting to get out..
😅You'd better pay more attention to the refugees escaped from mexico to the US through the border rather than those North Korean defectors, which is none of your business
The pastor is truly doing an immense service in helping so many people at such high risk and cost.
This is some "Handmaids Tale" shocking experience ....... May all who help these people escape safely, be rewarded
이 비극적 슬픔을 언제까지 계속해야 하나. 정착한 분들 고생하셨고 행복하십시오.
탈북자문제를 다뤄준 aljazeera 에 감사한다.
Why does China send the North Korean defectors back? That's very evil on their part.
China says that is illegal inmigration.
The CCP IS EVIL! 😅
I hate it too.
But here's the chinese logic:
1. They don't recognize North Koreans as "refugees" or asylum due to their relationship with NK even when the defectors reach SK embassy or consulate they aren't safe. China still deports them to NK.
2. China wants to prevent a scenario where their borders will be flooded with North Koreans fleeing, thats why they facilitate the Kim regime. Although, the defectors are legally citizens of South Korean the Chinese purposely send them back to NK as a deterrent. This is why defectors who leave via China need to reach other
Countries that are safe for defectors to claim asylum and whom they know will deport them to south korea. Which are Thailand and Mongolia as they have agreements with South Korea over thid. As they have agreement with South korra that they send them to Sk rather than the NK.
@@wawawoo-24This is the official statement. In fact, the Chinese government's policy towards North Koreans who illegally enter China has gradually changed. People from North Korea went to South Korea to get money, robbed and killed people in China, and used AK47s to engage in gun battles with Chinese troops. Finally, the Chinese government could no longer tolerate it. All illegal immigrants from North Korea were arrested and sent back to North Korea.
@@wawawoo-24 oh okay
I feel bad for the north Korean people,
After watching this video we know North Korea is still practicing slavery.
You find slavery in the UK, too.
@@Truthseeker371 yes, but no where near the extent as NK. Sadly, it’s still a thing and it breaks my heart no matter where.
So sad that a leader will decide to be a foe to his people. North Korea dictator should be ashamed of himself seeing how impoverishing his people are.
Worst man on this planet indeed.
Dear citizens of the world,
please help Korea to be reunified.
China is using the divided situation of Korea to maximize their national interest.
Please remember that China does not retain military bases and soldiers on the Korean Peninsula. Think about it, who has military bases and soldiers there?
@@kuan-k4mit is because the Chinese interfered during the war and the Kim family refused Chinese military to remain in the peninsula to maintain closer ties to Soviet Union. so study more you CCP dog.
@@IIIiIiiIiIiiilllllllllII The Korean Peninsula is the appendix of Asia. China and the United States are the masters of the Korean Peninsula. They have granted temporary peace to the Korean Peninsula. Therefore, the appendix should not be inflamed, otherwise it will be removed.
@user-yc7nv2qx2n American soldiers are in the south to deter Chinas's buffer state, North Korea from invading the south with help from China.
@@kuan-k4myou're an idiot with no sympathy for the many suffering north Koreans who risk their lives just so they could have a better life.....is it not china who deports every North Korean defectors?
See how amazing and nice the ordinary North Koreans are. so pity them for meeting an evil leader in their lifetime
But why the Chinese are deporting the North Korean defectors. How maan, have some heart nah!
@@leilasimon6081 这是非法移民，当然中国政府也默许了很多朝鲜人从中国借道前往其他国家，否则你认为有那么多的脱北者吗？他们很多都是从中国借道的
They are allies with Kim.China only cares about practical interest.
China takes in 40 thousand North Korean foreign workers EVERY YEAR! This Aljazeera report purposely didn't disclose that the United Nations Security Council Resolution 2397 demands that all N.Korean defectors be sent back to North Korea. So why make China into a bad guy? China is protecting itself first unlike the US and Europe with its own migrant crisis.
Very well done❤
this story reeks of sympathy washing propaganda. if china is so oppressive why don't western countries accept millions of poor Chinese fleeing there.
Why are there so many North Korean bots
After the genocide in gaza. And breaking through so much of the propaganda, im highly skeptical of anything like this.
Go live there. See for yourself. Why do u all want to keep living in the west instead of China nord Korea and Russia. Why are their people begging at our border for asylum?
Meth kills buttercup
@@randomguy3496Vous avez écrit > avant le mot > donc vous me donnez l'impression que vous êtes francophone. 🇺🇸🤝🇨🇦🇫🇷🇧🇪🇨🇭🇱🇺🇲🇨
@@randomguy3496 You do know countries outside of the west, China, Russia and North Korea exist right?
@@randomguy3496he'd better go live in Palestine, not Gaza, and see how people are treated there. After a few days, he'll be begging to enter the gates of Israel.
China sometimes help NORTH KOREAN people who enter their country by giving them temp. homes and then job opportunities that if one is lucky..
Turkey's situation is also similar to North Koreans. İ am masters alumni and my English, german languages are advanced stage, i cannot immigrate to Schengen or australia or USA even at the age of 51 years old and being baptist christian. İt is impossible to find decent wage Job in Turkey, we are waiting to die naturally. The pension wage that Turkey gives, never enough to purchase New car in Turkey on New apartment in the country. No girl or women want to marry me because of pension wage's lowness. İt is disgusting to live under terror threats since 1979 and under muslim ezan voices coming from mosques. İ am unemployed for 11 years , my Medical specialist father and mother are unemployed for 20 years after they become pensioners with very low wages.
There is always a way,you apply for visa's right?I don't think Turkey is that closed down
채규형 김효순 부부 권사님을 통해 방문합니다
If the US had not invaded Korea then they would still be united
Stfu it was the Soviets who occupied the north and the communist allies invaded south korea. That's why there is a division.
Hopefully you are just joking.....
Good sound
its senseless to keep people there if they leave they will send something for their families so is there something to hide?
"Because integrity is foreign idea which doesn't belong in our ancient history" 😂😂😂
same with China. 😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@ytn00b3 Dweeb loser
Al Jazeera! Please, make a documentary about the Peshawar School Massacre in Pakistan in December 2014.
Usual stereotyping documentary.
AJ’s story tried to raise sympathy for the North Korean defectors so they pictured all of their lives in China as being abused, sexually trafficked etc. fact is, there are 50 million living in China as the video says, there’s a reason for that…. Also, of course they ultimately prefer to go to South Korea, because they are the same people, and they’ll have legal status and some money to settle down. But you can not blame a country( and the people in the country) for not taking refugees, I.e, most countries are not taking refugees from Syria, from Palestine etc. plus the famine happened in the 1990s, so I’m not sure now, in 2024, whether there’s still large amount of people leaving North Korea as legitimate refugee, like the super poor Chinese or Vietnam people from rural areas can’t just go to another country without a visa and expect citizen treatment? Where I am in Australia we have super strict border rules too. Of course, having read many stories of defectors they have experienced horrendous hunger and I wish countries around the world had helped with food for humanitarian aids back then. And wish them all a better life now
The main point is that North Korean citizens are struggling. Most of the population still suffer from food insecurity & they have no right to move around freely or to have their own opinions. Many of them are sent to work or concentration camps where they are used as free labor and worked to their deaths. Some cross the river to China and are sold as wives or are forced to work in some form of prostitution. Men are most likely sent back to NK when discovered by Chinese Police knowing what gruesome fate awaits them.
One of the women earlier on said she was treated fairly kindly in China. So people's stories are going to be different. But yes, they want to get out of China because China will typically deport them back, where they are sent to prison camps or executed. That in itself is a crime against humanity. Even if other countries aren't accepting refugees, they don't turn them back over to the government who may execute them. That is a UN crime and China does it
Why is the Western world promoted as free, civilized, democratic, and wealthy, while China, North Korea, and Syria are labeled as autocratic, dictatorial, and poor? You should know that the Western world has provoked 90% of wars and sanctions. Every year, tens of thousands of people die due to lack of assistance due to wars and sanctions. Who is deliberately creating the information cocoon?
I don't think they expect good treatment in the first place, since they always had a bad one. Doesn't matter if there are 50 million or 5 million, bad guys along the NK border know how they can speculate and get money from selling defectors (or snitch to police) and it's hardly possible to avoid those
Also, the amount of NK refugees has been dropping tremendously in recent years, so the amount is not large at all
@@trkantiteza Let me tell you why in the China-North Korea border area, Chinese people report people who sneak into China from North Korea. You know, the border between China and North Korea is just a river 50 meters wide and 2 meters deep. It is easy to cross the border in autumn and winter. About ten or twenty years ago, North Korea suffered natural disasters and food shortages. People from North Korea sneaked into China to try to find food. At first, they could get rice, corn and other food from the Chinese by selling labor or begging, and then bring them back to North Korea to share with their families. As the food shortage became serious, more and more people knew this method. Going to China to find food was their only chance to survive. From rice, cooking oil, chickens, pigs, and cows, they wanted to get everything. From begging and selling labor to get food, they finally started threatening, violently robbing, and killing, until a horrific massacre occurred. Many soldiers of the North Korean border guards carried AK-47 rifles into the villages on the Chinese border to rob and kill Chinese people, steal money and food, and engage in gun battles with Chinese troops. The Chinese government protested to North Korea and began to block the border. And tell the Chinese in the border areas not to take in people from North Korea, and report them in time to avoid being harmed. So, from now on, the Chinese will no longer treat people from North Korea with kindness. Because you don't know whether your kindness will be exchanged for kindness or death. Also, after North Korean soldiers massacred dozens of Chinese, the North Korean government apologized, but was only willing to compensate according to North Korean standards, about $500 per person.
most of chinese cannot be trusted instead of helping human in need they will abused you. You pray hard to God when your in a situation no one to rely on but yourself. Let God be your companion for every fears you have.
Do you know " most of Chinese"? You sound very racist.
@@user-sh3pd5et1nChinese is the most racist guy in the world.
即使你从来没在现实中见过任何中国人
15:03 I don't think the South Korean pastor really had connections with a random railway police in China, It's more likely that the railway police had sympathy for this North Korean and closed one eye.
For the question about how the Chinese government treats North Korean defectors who live in China. What I know is as follows:
1. If a North Korean living in China commit crimes, he/she will be deported back to North Korea.
2. If a North Korean living in China tries to get to South Korea, he/she will be deported back to North Korea.
3. If a North Korean living in China does not commit crimes, and does not try to get to South Korea, he/she will be allowed to live in China and will NOT be deported to North Korea.
This is how China balances itself between maintaining its relationship with the North Korean government and taking humanitarian factors into consideration.
So in life you must focus on your goals and be ready for what comes next.
Or else you’ll stay stuck at your situation in which you are fighting to get out..
All they wanted is to be free to live a simple life in the 21 century, why it’s hard to fulfill?
😅You'd better pay more attention to the refugees escaped from mexico to the US through the border rather than those North Korean defectors, which is none of your business
North Korea Respect
🇰🇷🇮🇱🇺🇸🇺🇳🇹🇼
Kim Jong Un❤
Didn't Saddam Hussein meet American Justice December 30, 2006? 🗽🦅🇺🇸⚖️💪🏻👊🏻✊🏻
Ole saddam lol he met his fate
If you send one million North Korean to the South Korea , then the south would be crying to say enough is enough……
what is your point? Does that Justify Chinese trafficking North korean women under the threat they will be sent back to North Korea?
Pls send them all to south Korea. Always welcome. Don't worry about money and life.
@@sandblue-t1p you have no brain …..
@@ericxu3860 50 cents