Flutist reacts to Jethro Tull - Weathercock

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 118

  • @HelineFay
    @HelineFay  Рік тому +12

    Most of the reaction videos are demonetised by the copyright holders. If you'd like to help me keep making these, consider supporting me on Patreon: www.patreon.com/heline
    Or you can buy me a coffee: ko-fi.com/heline

    • @samgranier6735
      @samgranier6735 Рік тому

      ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
      👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖

    • @msb3175
      @msb3175 Рік тому +2

      He uses the "Floating Trill" sound a lot on "Cross Eyed Mary".

    • @MarkoMarco-ei8iw
      @MarkoMarco-ei8iw Рік тому +2

      Heline do you maybe be in Poland or you know somebody from Poland ?

    • @alwilson3204
      @alwilson3204 3 місяці тому

      Nothing personal, though I don't subscribe and stick with channels that often and I float around. Point is, it's so good to see you're delving further with your insightful reactions with more of one of my favorite old bands, Jethro Tull. Thanks a heap for more of this stuff! Here, in more recent years, there is the unfortunate further deterioration of Ian's voice and odd hesitations in his vocal mannerisms. By the way, did you think he had a little, you- know-what on the roof of his house? Lol.

  • @annw291
    @annw291 Рік тому +14

    I can't believe you only have 34.5K subscribers.
    It is such a joy to watch you deconstruct Jethro Tull. There are many reaction videos on UA-cam, but almost none of them are as pure as yours.
    Thank you for the magic.

  • @doubler8684
    @doubler8684 Рік тому +15

    Heavy Horses is one of my favorite albums along with Songs From the Wood where ALL the songs were really good on both albums. What a story teller!

    • @apataye
      @apataye Рік тому +3

      I´ve known the "Heavy Horses" LP since the mid 90´s, and, though I´ve always liked it, I used to feel like it was a LESSER work in comparison to "Aqualung", or "Thick...", but, lately, I have REDISCOVERED IT completely, and it has become one of my FAVOURITES.
      Its Heaviness, its delicate Folkishness, the amazing electric guitar work by Barre, the magical orchestral & keyboard arrangements, Glascock´s beautiful basslines, the intricate, yet Blunt, Barrie´s drumming, plus, of course, Ian´s genius at all the rest, make it a MASSIVELY INTERESTING & FULLFILLING ALBUM, indeed!!

    • @Fuzcapp
      @Fuzcapp 9 місяців тому

      Heavy Horses IS my favourite album of all time. 🙂

    • @alwilson3204
      @alwilson3204 3 місяці тому +1

      @@Fuzcapp Stormwatch is another very good album.

    • @Fuzcapp
      @Fuzcapp 3 місяці тому

      @@alwilson3204 Ta. As is Warchild.

  • @JerryHawkins-rr3ry
    @JerryHawkins-rr3ry Рік тому +5

    You should watch "Budapest" from this same concert. There is a great flute solo in it.

  • @HisDudeness2023
    @HisDudeness2023 8 місяців тому +4

    Since first, watching a video a few days ago on your channel, I’ve been kind of fixated with Jethro, Tulll’s dangling, right pinky.
    Is it possible that an order to do his technique that he developed superior hand and arm strength, such that he did not have to use his right hand support the end of the flute. He needed the freedom to be able to move his fingers in the matter he wanted to.
    Basically, he came up with a completely different way to hold the flute. He modified his grip in order to get the results he wanted.
    I think this is pretty fundamental and set them apart from your style.
    This is fascinating.
    Keep making videos please

  • @marysweeney7370
    @marysweeney7370 Рік тому +3

    I've never seen this live performance, Toward the end of your playing, it did very much sound like Ian. I very much hope that you will get to meet him someday

  • @albertschepis
    @albertschepis Рік тому +2

    The technical curiosity and points are very interesting. It adds to my love of Ians playing. I've noticed Heline that you don't do much, if any commentary about their compositions, about the overall songs, but what you do bring to us is the interesting aspects of his playing the flute. Love it.

  • @Kellen_Quigley
    @Kellen_Quigley Рік тому +5

    Everything from Tull's folk trilogy of albums is great, but I've always had a soft spot for "Heavy Horses." Would love to hear you react to "And The Mouse Police Never Sleeps." It has a pretty fun flute part on it!

  • @ROBERTOSILVA-nq2px
    @ROBERTOSILVA-nq2px Рік тому +6

    👏👏👏👏 Ian Anderson is always a great inspiration to also discover things that can be useful even to a high-level professional artist like you!

  • @Fuzcapp
    @Fuzcapp 9 місяців тому +1

    Love your flute break downs!!!!! Really interesting.

  • @JerryHawkins-rr3ry
    @JerryHawkins-rr3ry Рік тому +2

    You have the cutest accent! Been a great Tull fan since 71'.

  • @realthursty4953
    @realthursty4953 8 місяців тому +2

    The song you are trying to remember at the end is Cross-eyed Mary.

  • @leonazg82
    @leonazg82 Рік тому +3

    One of the best examples of Ian Anderson bending a long note is the very last note of "Strange Avenues" (1989). It's heard best on the studio recording but you can also find a concert video. Also, the concert version of "Farm on the Freeway" features such a bend, also at the very end. It's impressive that Ian Anderson only uses one hand and his mouth for that.

  • @tullfan2560
    @tullfan2560 11 місяців тому +1

    Ian used that flute technique in Cross Eyed Mary, I believe.

  • @leonazg82
    @leonazg82 Рік тому

    Hi Heline. Thank you for that video. Talking about that "supersimple to do" overblown trill, you have seen and heard it in the beginning of "Cross-Eyed Mary", one of the earlier hits.

  • @snapfinger1
    @snapfinger1 Рік тому

    Ian was bemused when he played Columbia, SC & heard the football team were the Gamecocks. Many a weather vane features a rooster.

  • @rockymountboy
    @rockymountboy 11 місяців тому +1

    Why don't you contact him and ask him how he does it? Might lead to an amazing conversation!

  • @JabelldiMarco
    @JabelldiMarco Рік тому

    It would be interesting to compare this to the studio version from the Album.
    Ian's voice deteriorated in that time, but his flute play got more complex and the band performed way more freestyle.

  • @carlwinsleaux5844
    @carlwinsleaux5844 Рік тому +1

    Check out early Chicago, maybe start with "it better end soon" live versions. Would love to see your reaction.

  • @franksavanti3365
    @franksavanti3365 10 місяців тому

    Listen to Jethro Tull’s first album. Stand Up!! Unique flute technique on those tracks. Enjoy!!

  • @BC-ui9yt
    @BC-ui9yt Рік тому +2

    At the end, you mention him doing that technique elsewhere. Was it in "cross-eyed Mary'? That's what it sounded like to me.

  • @thespinner5484
    @thespinner5484 Рік тому +3

    I love the way you analyze music. You give both a technical overview and also your perspective on what you think of the song.

  • @Helliconia54
    @Helliconia54 Рік тому

    Loving your TARDIS coffee mug

  • @meyou-dv8ns
    @meyou-dv8ns 12 днів тому

    There is a teen aged female that plays all Jethro Tull bass lines. on bass guitar to many many Tull songs. she is on you tube, Oh my god she is so great !!!!!!

  • @kennethkirchoff4824
    @kennethkirchoff4824 Рік тому

    Love your TARDIS mug!

  • @englebertmagentaschweiger1447
    @englebertmagentaschweiger1447 Рік тому +27

    The most unfortunate part of this is that Ian can *barely* sing in this performance (and it's from 18 years ago), but he's a better flautist than ever. Never heard a single person do glissandos that smoothly on a flute, and he makes it look completely effortless.

    • @jonathanmercer7109
      @jonathanmercer7109 Рік тому +6

      It's an odd thing. I'm pretty sure he really should have had the nodule surgery back in the 80s after his voice failed in the tour to support Under Wraps. That said, I saw them in 2009 and he was singing really well. In fact, watching this video, it makes me wonder if he doesn't have the mic set a bit too low and if that results in the voice not being so well detected by it and thus dropping out - so it sounds like weaker than it is. Clearly not anything like as strong as in the 70s or early 80s though.

    • @stephenignatz8364
      @stephenignatz8364 Рік тому +3

      I still LOVE Ian but agree is voice had gone. I still enjoy thier music and his flute that I will always be a fan.

    • @albertschepis
      @albertschepis Рік тому

      @@jonathanmercer7109 He kept moving the mic around too, whatever that was about.

    • @englebertmagentaschweiger1447
      @englebertmagentaschweiger1447 Рік тому +1

      @@jonathanmercer7109 Yeah, I've seen performances where he just knocks it out pretty easily despite all, Montreux 2003 comes to mind, and this is not one of those times. He still sounds pretty decent in the studio, but boy should he ever just hire a singer.

    • @henryandlindapazos9465
      @henryandlindapazos9465 11 місяців тому +1

      I’m surprise he can sing at all. “Ian Anderson revealed he is suffering from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), a disease that causes obstructed airflow from the lungs, making it difficult to breathe. In an interview with Dan Rather on "The Big Interview" Wednesday, the Jethro Tull frontman discussed his health struggles.May 14, 2020”

  • @robincarr111
    @robincarr111 5 днів тому

    in a previous video you commented that his fingers are straight and when you play yours appears to be curved. if he is using straight finger is that how he get the half notes easier than you can?

  • @priyangshu01
    @priyangshu01 8 місяців тому

    Probably you meant "Cross eyed Mary" in your comment at the very end! Kiitos😊

  • @rodneygriffin7666
    @rodneygriffin7666 10 місяців тому

    It sounds quite Celtic to me.
    Northen European with a splash or Middle Eastern influence.
    I may be wrong.

  • @Mike-x9h5f
    @Mike-x9h5f 10 місяців тому

    I did not know the orientals were A BNo RMAL

  • @Chef-Chad
    @Chef-Chad Рік тому

    Maybe you could contact Ian before he dies and ask him how he does certain things with the flute so it does not die with him, just a thought.

  • @adolforodolfo6929
    @adolforodolfo6929 8 місяців тому

    I love live music and I like that you use live performances for these reaction videos, but this is one song I suggest you listen to the recorded version. which. musically, is much more interesting than this, if only for John Glascock's wonderful bass playing.

  • @shimwooley
    @shimwooley Рік тому

    Ian claims that he damaged his vocal chords singing on the "Under Wraps" LP ! The oriental sound, I call British folk sound. Reminds me of Steeleye Span.

  • @williambardizian830
    @williambardizian830 Рік тому

    it was Crosseyed Mary. 😀

  • @melissakhalar1842
    @melissakhalar1842 Рік тому +6

    I can understand you having a thought that the song may have a " dirty" meaning because Mr. Anderson does reference "dirty" things in some of his songs and I've seen him do so in interviews as well. I enjoy his humor and innuendo. Lol

  • @darkogregec7503
    @darkogregec7503 8 місяців тому

    I think it is more reneissance music and oriental influence in that kind of music.

  • @gungadin406
    @gungadin406 11 місяців тому +3

    It seems to me that every single expert that tries to decipher and deceminate I. A. techniques. All of them sound very slow and somewhat amauterish by comparison, when they try to reproduce his playing techniques. We must remember that he is playing this live in front of 50,000 +

  • @willwaddington5847
    @willwaddington5847 Рік тому

    Do you need an open whole flute? Is it “double tonguing?”

  • @olafsrensen9578
    @olafsrensen9578 Рік тому

    More of a britianmiddelage tune. You must here the studio album aswell.

  • @thhseeking
    @thhseeking Рік тому

    Is your coffee mug smaller on the outside than it is on the inside?

  • @gordowg1wg145
    @gordowg1wg145 Рік тому

    Since you've a TARDIS mug, must check out your thoughts/reactions to The Who 👍😎

  • @portcullis5622
    @portcullis5622 Місяць тому

    Awesome song; the sound of autumn. Much better to listen to the original album version (or a live version from the late 70s) when his voice was great and the band sounded like they really meant it. In comparison, this is the supermarket version.

  • @CaptainMiserable-gv1ts
    @CaptainMiserable-gv1ts 6 місяців тому

    This was Ian Anderson's Steven Segal period.

  • @Orielzolrak
    @Orielzolrak Рік тому

    He cares the flute now. He describe the flutes the his career.
    "With our first trip to America, my French Selmer flute gave out and was replaced with a US made Artley, a basic student model sturdily made for the school band trade. At one time I owned more than twenty Artleys, in various states of repair (or lack of) and each tour in the seventies started with my finding the best bits to put together to make up three playable instruments for the duration. Having given most away to charity auctions over the years, I retain only a couple, now largely unplayable.
    For a while I switched to 600 series flutes by Pearl, a Japanese company, and then more recently in the early nineties to Sankyo Silversonics and the US-made 2100 and 3100 Powell flutes. I use the Powells for recording and take a Sankyo and a Powell on tour. The intonation and sonority of the Powell is better, but the Sankyo blows more loudly and easily, especially when the player’s lips are fatigued and thus less articulate.
    The Powell has a narrower bore and a more demanding “Q” or “P” headjoint than the free-blowing Sankyo raised shoulder “NSR1” headjoint. My practice, or kitchen, flute is a Yamaha student model, cheapest in the line, and well recommended. I take it on holiday and leave it assembled when at home to pick up and puff on whenever passing. It undoubtedly helped when I gave up smoking, a good few years ago."

  • @mehmetsinangur8907
    @mehmetsinangur8907 Рік тому

    Hi, you must listen to the Northern Anatolian folk music.

  • @postulusml
    @postulusml Рік тому

    I love you.

  • @greatwhitewing
    @greatwhitewing Рік тому

    The man that made that singlehandedly made the flute cool

  • @corawheeler9355
    @corawheeler9355 Рік тому +1

    On the original recording of Weathercock on the album Heavy Horses, there is more drumming of the type that makes it sound like a Scottish marching band. Sadly that's missing in later recordings and this performance. Give that a listen and see if you think of Scottland instead of the Orient.

  • @khanalter6699
    @khanalter6699 Рік тому

    Reacts to Eluveitie please!! :D

  • @williamscoggin1509
    @williamscoggin1509 8 місяців тому

    I think if you can figure out some of those quirks that he does you could really scare the hell out of your first day students. LOL 😅

  • @edigabrieli7864
    @edigabrieli7864 10 місяців тому

    Min 6:00 Don't forget his flute is connected to an amp with a lot of gadgets like sustain, reverb and octave perhaps even auto tune making it sound a lot easier and better on chromatic runs.

  • @rodgarrett5110
    @rodgarrett5110 Рік тому

    Look up "unclassifiable" in the dictionary. Jethro Tull

  • @pablo32-uq6pr
    @pablo32-uq6pr Рік тому

    Budapest plisssssss

  • @BlackTecc
    @BlackTecc Рік тому +1

    Fun song and reaction

  • @asparrow5431
    @asparrow5431 Рік тому

    I think that I would trade my sonic screwdriver for his flute. Yep. *wink wink*
    Incidentally, I don't believe that Ian plays an open hole flute. At least not that I have ever seen, and I am an avid, albeit self taught, flute player too.

  • @keithcarper8809
    @keithcarper8809 Рік тому +1

    Great reaction. You sure picked up on that glissando thing quickly!

  • @jamesjones8482
    @jamesjones8482 Рік тому +1

    Very good reaction! I enjoy your channel. You are a pleasure to watch. I'm by no means musically talented, but I do enjoy good music. Started with rock & roll in the early 1960's, and now moved to primarily classical. At 73 years old, I to listen to music that pleases me. ❤

  • @yuriy_kuzyura
    @yuriy_kuzyura Рік тому

    Amazing thing! One of the best their albums!❤

  • @shimwooley
    @shimwooley Рік тому +1

    Such a shame about Ian's vocals. On Rok Flote he sounds good though !

  • @TheRevjev
    @TheRevjev Рік тому

    Where does flutist come from and when did it start to be used? Because I've always refer to myself as a flautist. I'm not a professional just played for my own enjoyment for about 50 years.

  • @joshuabrande2417
    @joshuabrande2417 Рік тому

    So it’s fair to say you’re learning from Ian Anderson?

  • @cosmicdebris5260
    @cosmicdebris5260 Рік тому +1

    Hi Heline!🦄This song so throws back in time! Wonderful observation on the Oriental influence! Many blessings and thank you🌿

    • @pattyrobinson1458
      @pattyrobinson1458 Рік тому

      It's not oriental it's medieval English you fools

    • @cosmicdebris5260
      @cosmicdebris5260 Рік тому

      @@pattyrobinson1458 I appreciate the input but what's with the fools thing? Kinda rude.🌿

    • @pattyrobinson1458
      @pattyrobinson1458 Рік тому

      @@cosmicdebris5260 kinda stupid to talk about something you know nothing about

  • @alpine1600s
    @alpine1600s Рік тому +2

    I'd say Heline needs to meet Ian.👍

    • @ROBERTOSILVA-nq2px
      @ROBERTOSILVA-nq2px Рік тому +1

      I totally agree with you!! imagine what a moment ... as soon as Heline should see Ian entering in her house for an interview ... I'm sure that Heline smile will light all the room!
      And for us a spectacular video to enjoy!

  • @elvwood
    @elvwood Рік тому

    As someone who has never even tried to play the flute, can I just say your detailed explanations and explorations are really interesting - I would never have guessed that was the hard part of the piece! Lovely flute playing from Ian here, but overall I prefer the original, more up-tempo version of the song. Give it a listen sometime, just for fun.

  • @stuartmcivor2276
    @stuartmcivor2276 Рік тому

    Heline, have you thought about playing the video at half speed when you are trying to analyse it?

  • @thomasmacdiarmid8251
    @thomasmacdiarmid8251 Рік тому

    I can understand your concern that 'weathercock' might be a rude reference. However, the word 'cock' shows up in many nonrude references. Of course, it is another word for rooster. It is suggested by some articles that 'weathercock' come from a sculpure of a rooster often being placed atop them. However, I think that is likely wrong. 'Cock' seems to have a common meaning in something that turns. Hence, there is a stopcock, which is a faucet handle of sorts. A specific type of that is a ballcock, which seems even ruder til you know what it is. When a horse lifts it's tail, the tail is said to be 'cocked'. When a person wears his hat at a sporty angle, the hat is said to be cocked or to have a jaunty cock. When the hammer of a gun is pulled back in readiness for firing, it is said to be cocked. All of these have the common sense of something being turned from one position to another. So, if you come across the term 'cock' in English, you needn't assume it is rude - but then we also like our puns, so people will often have double meanings used regarding words like cock or ball.

  • @ianbennett1491
    @ianbennett1491 Рік тому

    I love watching you concentrating whe Ian starts to play the flute. 🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

    • @pattyrobinson1458
      @pattyrobinson1458 Рік тому

      Fool

    • @ianbennett1491
      @ianbennett1491 Рік тому

      @@pattyrobinson1458 I hope you are not married. God help your husband married to such a bitter twisted woman. 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧🇬🇧

  • @mikehunt-co7hc
    @mikehunt-co7hc Рік тому

    i just found you a week ago and already you are starting to grow on me! i would love to support you but i do not do ANY electronic money. i am strictly cash and checks. if you can figure out a way to make it work, i would be glad to help your channel

  • @kajlennartsson4234
    @kajlennartsson4234 Рік тому +1

    Hello Heline. Have you tried to sing play the flute like Ian Anderson? It's fun to dig into your knowledge about flute and music. Give Ruusa and Sylvi a big hug and hope Alma is coming home soon. 💙💙🎼🎼🎶🎶

    • @HelineFay
      @HelineFay  Рік тому +2

      I've used the singing and playing in warmups but haven't really used it otherwise

    • @kajlennartsson4234
      @kajlennartsson4234 Рік тому +2

      @@HelineFay Thanks for your answer Heline. 🎶🎶 And keep on rocking the flute 🤘🤘

  • @picadilly1408
    @picadilly1408 9 місяців тому

    What you are calling flute is more commonly called the recorder. The other one you demonstrated and called a whistle, is usually referred to as a metal flute. The most common flute in most parts of the world is the bamboo flute - just like your metal flute, but made of bamboo. There are many more variations

  • @DavidTateVA
    @DavidTateVA Рік тому

    The studio version on Heavy Horses is very martial in its sound, with stereotypical military drum cadences and heavy downbeats. Ian's singing in this one deliberately subverted that, with lots of syncopation and anticipated/delayed beats. Personally, I prefer the original sound, but I can understand not wanting to sing everything the same damn way for 40 years...

  • @dennishinkle5010
    @dennishinkle5010 Рік тому +1

    The studio recording does not sound Asian but more of a Scottish sound.

  • @emole9511
    @emole9511 4 місяці тому

    It is not orientel ,but Celtic.

  • @DropAnchor1978
    @DropAnchor1978 Рік тому

    Ian uses that overblowing technique in his song, The Witch's Promise

  • @capokarate7329
    @capokarate7329 Рік тому

    Heline's Jethro Tull reactions are the Best!! Congratulations for your job...Ian says mandolin is sexy??Does Heline is one of sexiest influencers??🤔😎🙏💪🇧🇷🇺🇾🤡

  • @johnroberts3723
    @johnroberts3723 5 місяців тому

    My favourite song on heavy horses unfortunately painful to hear him sing these days.

  • @ianbennett1491
    @ianbennett1491 Рік тому

    Any one wanting to learn the flute is best learning by" not" watching Ian Anderson. He is the best ,but if you try to learn by watching him you will end up throwing the flute out of the window or breaking it in two. Iain Leeds Yorkshire England. 🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

  • @MeStevely
    @MeStevely Рік тому

    Just to let you know, the correct term for a flute player in English English ( proper English, not Americanised bastardised crap) is flautist. The flau sound to rhyme with 'saw' or law'.

    • @yovicta34
      @yovicta34 Рік тому

      Well, Sir James Galway prefers “flutist”, so maybe temper your indignation a bit…

  • @willwaddington5847
    @willwaddington5847 Рік тому

    Normal = “Asian”

  • @thhseeking
    @thhseeking Рік тому

    As someone said below, I think you and Ian should meet up :)

  • @juhajarkkoulvila7041
    @juhajarkkoulvila7041 Рік тому

    Toi Ian ei pysty enää laulamaan niinku ennen 70 luvulla. sääli. ääni pettää. oon käyny Kulttuuritalolla keikan ja se ääni pihisi ja katosi ku vanhempaa matskua soitti ja tää oli 20 v sitte 😭

  • @JerryHawkins-rr3ry
    @JerryHawkins-rr3ry Рік тому

    Ian has you enamored doesn't he? The man is awesome. He has become quite the flautist. Hope I spelled that right?

  • @JimObsolete
    @JimObsolete Рік тому +3

    He has lost most of his singing voice

  • @kenp3615
    @kenp3615 Рік тому

    I'm sorry, but your demonstration of talent with the flute was beyond subpar. For you to rate a magnate such as he is improper.

  • @barneymiller6204
    @barneymiller6204 2 місяці тому

    Too bad Ian's voice has suffered much over the years. COPD doesn't help.

  • @meyou-dv8ns
    @meyou-dv8ns 12 днів тому

    Asian sounding? It is English Irish folk music. lol - He even steals words to the song from a poem from an Irish poet

  • @itsarushinchu
    @itsarushinchu 8 місяців тому

    You got to remember he lost his voice at this point. All the years of touring did the damage. He can no longer sing anymore

  • @jaybefferman2249
    @jaybefferman2249 Рік тому

    Did thats in the beginning of crossed eye Mary. You are pronouncing Jethro wrong. 😮

    • @michaelfrank2266
      @michaelfrank2266 Рік тому +2

      "You are pronouncing Jethro wrong." She knows. Her hard core audience loves the accent so live with it.

    • @thhseeking
      @thhseeking Рік тому

      @@michaelfrank2266 I agree :) I love her accent.