Google Nest vs Amazon Ring Floodlight Cams: Push back the night
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 лип 2024
- We test two high-end outdoor cams with bright floodlights to see which one will work better for the exterior of your home.
Both the Ring Floodlight Cam Wired Pro and the Nest Cam with Floodlight have solid specs, including all the basics you might expect. We compare the finer points, then run them through the gamut with vision and alert tests, both during the day and at night.
We also take a look at the wider smart home fit for each, as Ring works better with Alexa and Nest works better with Google Assistant.
See Ring 👉 bit.ly/3k4kwPU
See Nest 👉 bit.ly/31uAWL2
*CNET may get a commission from these offers.
0:00 Intro
0:51 The Basics
2:48 Motion Alerts Test
5:20 Vision Test
8:18 Smarts
8:44 Conclusion
See CNET's favorite outdoor security cameras: www.cnet.com/home/security/be...
Subscribe to CNET: / cnettv
Like us on Facebook: / cnet
Follow us on Twitter: / cnet
Follow us on Instagram: bit.ly/2icCYYm
Follow us on TikTok: vm.tiktok.com/ZMd2h6yac/ - Наука та технологія
You can see the products featured in this video here 👇
Nest Cam with Floodlight: bit.ly/3EO0xwZ
Ring Floodlight Cam Wired Pro: bit.ly/3nUKLcF
*CNET may get a commission from these offers.
??? Why didnt you point out that the nest is 24/7 live recording??.The ring isn’t!! It’s motion activated! .. that makes a huge difference!
Agreed. Bad review....how could you not get the 24/7. I own both for different purposes but nest is my main
@@AngeloR674 You are right. I own 4 old nest cameras, they record 24/7 without stop. Motion activated ? No sure about that.
Ring wins with the alarm, nest wins with the clearer imaging and 24/7 recording. My neighbors work truck got broken into, their ring only caught the end of it while my nest across the street recorded everything before and after with clear image of plates. This guy probably had bad wifi. My nest cams annoy me with how frequent I get notifications. Sounds, bugs flying by, etc.
Man I wish these guys would work together SMH love my nest and Google assistant but I want some of the neat ring stuff too
Ok but for the vision test are you using optical zoom or digital
7:25 the heck is that behind 😂😂
8:07 lol WTH 😂
I was beginning to wonder if I was the only one to see that lol!!
I love the little squirrel thing in the background
Great job with the video
Thank you for the review
Wonderful insights thanks !!
My question is does the nest one have the magnet operation like the rest of their cameras so you can change the view of the camera? I want to put it on the side of my house facing my gate entrance. Not staring at my neighbors wall.
Lmao … not gonna lie that 👽 freeze shot creeped me out for a second 😂
Can you turn the lights on and off with your phone, or just with motion detection?
Very spooky nighttime tests haha
Great video 👍
Floodlight video cameras need 12MP, and 4K picture quality, 180-degree view, color night vision, a loud siren, and fast alerts with dependable two-way talk that works.
Debating on getting 2 cameras I need one for front and back yard. North side front south side back sun exposure. Ideally leave them inside and plugged in. Suggestions on a brand or brands that would work for my concerns. No lag between movements, leaves blowing creating false alerts, sunlight making the camera unable to see.
Is the camera adjustable via ring app remote
You really can't talk about Google's new Nest products without mentioning that the app itself has transitioned to Google Home rather than the Nest app, which has left earlier adopters of Nest cameras in limbo. Combined with the cancellation of Nest Secure without replacement, I'm pretty disappointed in Google and won't be adding any new Nest devices to my home until I have more clarity about the future of the brand.
Same here! I love the nest cameras. I just don't know what's a great replacement for the security system.. I wonder if I should just switch everything to Ring or just get the Ring security system and keep the nest nest cameras
They did this with TP Link Routers and it has me beyond livid. Hundreds of dollars worth of equipment that cannot be managed by the end of this year. I'm going to just bit the bullet because the google home app is absolutely awesome(pending some annoying moments).
@@Tomnician I am a fan/user of Google’s home/nest products (less so these days). I have both old and new nest cams and I find the new app so janky. It’s slow, clunky, buggy and crashes at times. I’m considering dropping it in favor of something compatible with HomeKit, maybe. Really not sure right now.
Same here. Love the Nest app and earlier cameras that work with the Nest app. I no longer purchase any more Google Nest products because of the awful integration with Google Home app. I'm now considering switching away from the Google ecosystem to Ring because their app is like the Nest app but has more home security products such as mail motion sensor.
I have the same issues with Nest Google cameras. With the present second generation of their cameras, you can't make tailored videos to the real vital events, you only have access to the event clips that the software decides, and you thus miss vital information. Also, you don't have a timeline of events which is vital information for law enforcement officers. Even though I currently have five cameras of Nest at my place, I am instead considering buying the Ring camera for my girlfriend's house.
Thanks this helps
Why wasn't the Ring's superior alarm sound/siren not discussed a little bit more indepth?
Delays in a security system are completely unacceptable. My ADT system is pure crap for this.
Best review on UA-cam 👌
Thanks for posting this, I have the ring flood cam from 2017 and it a POS. Has this pink lens thing that happens wifi fades out its not really dependable. So I was looking at upgrading, I already have a nest door bell so figured the nest floodlight one would be best to pair it with, no more having two subscriptions and two different apps.
Did you get the nest cam floodlight? How do you find the notifications?
go 2 rings replaced. didnt work for me stop working after a week.
The clown mask guy was awesome touch
Ring does’t always detect motion. But i do like that the live option is quicker than nest. Ring cameras have a wider range for camera. Nest not so good range wise.
very interesting and helpful video, going to best buy to get a Ring now, lol
8:07 You scared the shit out of me.
Same lol
Wow beautiful
Debating on getting 2 cameras I need one for front and back yard. North side front south side back sun exposure. Ideally leave them inside and plugged in. Suggestions on a brand or brands that would work for my concerns. No lag between movements, leaves blowing creating false alerts, sunlight making the camera unable to see.
When I had ring it was absolutely terrible. I switched and so did my father in-law and also my brother. Ring would give us an alert but then just sit there and spin before we even could see a picture people would be gone. That happened with 4 cams at my house and then a total of 7 of family members.
If ring would improve video quality to that if nest and add facial recognition it would destroy everything else out there. Love everything about nest but ring is just more reliable security wise
Nest does have racial recognition….. I have it on mine
Eufy flood cam in my favorite
This is great and all but as someone who has had to replace the bulbs in flood lights, I'd like to know if I can do that myself or do I have to go through the hassle of taking it down and sending it to them for service. Also, if it's not a standard bulb size, then how much more will that cost me? LED are supposed to last for a long time, but the reality is much different.
They are led and don’t ever need to be replaced. Our rings are two years old now and no issues with the lights going out. I have one that has leaked inside the light but it still works. Going to attempt to get that replaced soon though. We had nest before all the rings and been happier with rings app and products.
I’m going on 4 years with 5 Ring floodlight cams and they’re holding up well so far. They are LED, so I’m hoping I never have to change them.
@@BillionDollaGil heard the LED bulbs burn out in less than 2 years with the Ring system and are not replaceable. Have you had this issue?
@@judyl.761 I’ve had the same set of flood light cameras since 2017. So far I haven’t experienced that specific issue. The pink discoloration is the only issue I’ve encountered so far. I had some issues with a dead Wi-Fi zone, but that was more due to the router I was using.
0:18
I'm sure the bothers of the night's watch went with Ring!
Going with ring after watching ur video
Come on Ring make the Video Quality Better and you will become the King in Security Space.
I love the nest eco system
Compare these two with the eufy floodlight 360
I would highly recommend the ring flood light camera. The lights alone are so bright at 1600 lumens alone!! The camera quality is great. The coverage is great.
Camera quality is great? Mine is absolutely horrendous.
My favorite has been the Eufy floodlight.
Yeah I'd like to see reviews of off brand stuff.
@@bitplaya7432 eufy win, 4k video 📹, I would call them innovative, and no monthly subscription
Eufy works very well, we have two floodlight cam.
But Chinese Communist Party has all your footages
@@hl3915 Whoop de doo. Believing that you have privacy or any real control over it is naive in this day.
I enjoy this guy. Good video.
Ok that was scary AF
Yeah, if you're a thief, I guess.
Is that lambchop?
you guys switched the links for nest and ring.
Nest all the way! I love my nest floodlight camera
WTF were the scary things in the background nighttime test ? 👻👻👻👻
Right lol
07:24
That actually got me off guard! 😶🌫️
Bro!!!
Pity about the camera not staying charged despite being powered by mains, forums are flooded with the same fault from the US, UK and Europe, seems to be a major floor somewhere where the battery is draining down and goes offline. It ends up just being an expensive floodlight.
I have other Nest Camera products and my issues were a lot like the ones you guys are documenting. No notice or late notice. We need the Nest Cam IQ what good is a grainy image of the porch-pirate’s car?
Id recommend the 4K wired cams from Lorex if you want that level of detail. These wifi cameras will not hold up.
I have nest cameras and I don't experience the issues you are discribing
Is there no two way audio on nest floodlight?
it has it
You cannot replace the bulbs with ring, you have to buy the ENTIRE unit if they go out. Not sure about Nest.
So for someone savvy in home automation systems these cameras are still a big compromised over doing a custom set up with good flood lighting, motion detector and camera. But they are getting better.
I want them
As a security consultant for 25 years what you're failing to recognize is that ring does a better job at deterring the crime with the analytics speed of delivery And siren. If you're looking at purely video quality then yes the nest will win however all you're doing is looking at how sharp the image was when they stoled Whatever it was there trying to get In today's modern world with mass and hoodies good luck I'm getting back what you lost.
Does the Nest have to be mounted on a horizontal surface or could it go under an eve??
The directions show horizontal, but mine is mounted under an eve. The magnet is very strong to hold it in place
Nest all day
Durability is Ring’s downfall. I bought one only to have the microphone fail after one year! Ring’s customer service was a nightmare to receive a replacement and only after calling multiple times did I receive a…refurbished unit that is having microphone issues. I want to see what Nests durability looks like before dropping more money on another crappy camera.
I had the same issue but with the light going out and after I received my replacement, the replacement went out within 1 year of having it.
At the moment my Nest won't do anything. Heating, security.... joy.
Mouse at 7:25?
What this reviewer failed to acknowledge! Is that the nest records 24/7 continuously and the ring is motion activated! That makes a huge difference!. I ! have both!. Line of products ring and nest!.I Also have a eufy 360 degree flooghtlight camera whuch is better then both of these!
Eufy is nice but having no 24/7 recording is a deal breaker for me.
@@adrian8967 no floodlight camera has it all! Right now Siren 24/7 recording.. etc etc
@@AngeloR674 was the eufy 360 updated to have this feature recently? I look at so many other videos and all of them mentioned no 24/7 recording on the eufy
@@adrian8967 no but the eufy 360 has so many advantages over both of these cameras Including 2k vision! Getting a license plate number etc.. that matters!
I put the eufy 360 up 3 days ago and its diabolical, im trying to get eufy to take it back.
Maybe on a large private garden or driveway with all motion turned on it would work but im on a busy road and when i put human only it missed a lot of people, didnt record my son and daughter coming home 2 nights in a row and didn't record me going to work 2 mornings in a row when the sensors saw me and turned the flood lights on.
Tried creating an activity zone to ignore the road and change it to all motion but the activity zones dont work it still goes off for every car that drives past.
Now looking for a replacement which is really disappointing as the light on it is perfect
And next time AWS goes down, ring will not even turn the light on. I am too heavy in Google ecosystem with NVidia TV, Smart TVs, so I will go with Nest.
I love my Nest cameras, Nest Thermostat and Google Nest...Only issue is i want to add a security system to these. What do I get? Ring? Then I can't use my cameras. Any suggestions? I have several cameras and to switch at this point and replace all would be expensive.
i second that!
Did you get security yet? If not, call me. I'm the regional sales manager 😉 lmk and I'll give you my info
The local Best Buy where I live suggest ring over nest so I bought ring, I have a ring pro doorbell for 4 years and no issue..,
yes, best buy employees know best. 🤔 I'd buy ring for the alarm, nest for 24/7 recording and clearer imaging. Motion activation always has latency.
Does ring offer 24/7 recording? That's what's important to a lot of people for a security camera
Was that a sock puppet?!
Has the nest floodcam improved at all since this video? It's now June 2022 by the way lol
I wonder how many peeps noticed the hand poppet.
7:23 sec what was that in the background
Although Ring seems to be a better camera than Nest, I think Amazon and Google should evolve and integrate AI technology such as Nexoptic's ALIIS. Especially for vision tests from 5:38 minutes (Day/Night mode). We are in 2022...
I like that idea! Seems like there’s a lot of AI engineering available. Might as well imbed it with hime security systems.
dont know why camera manufactures leave the power cable out in the open for anyone to cut.
My indoor nest cams have been glitching A LOT lately😳😳
And Anker's?
Should of tried Arlo
👍
The forest? Fam I've had a crackhead try to break into my car on like 5 separate occasions.
You need the floodlight because Ring cameras don’t work in the dark. -Ring camera owner
Nest products are fragmentated. Older Nest products won't work with the Google Home app properly as newer Nest products won't even work with the Nest app.
True but depends on which product, all the thermostats and cameras work with both apps. Google says smoke detectors support should come in 2022 in home app
Oh so we are just going to ignore the ghost in the background?
Where and when
@@markied2873 lol. 9:42
I hate the subscription part. A lot.
The exposure of Nest's cable makes me cringe. It should be protected and tucked away
As of today, you cannot display live feed to Chromecast with the Nest. It is a feature they are still working on with the newer generation cameras.
Any change on that?
Checked just now, and I can gladly report that the Google Cam with floodlight can stream to the CCWGTV.
I hope Google Home products will not be unpopular.
Nest have zones tho for heavy traffic just saying…
Was that a ghost 👻
ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha the back ground at night!!!!!
It's a no brainer. U better give ur data to google than Amazon (governmentS)
Again. We cant get this in Malawi. I can't even upgrade my Google Drive plan. Apparently it's not available. You guys are a global brand you need to do better.
What is up with that dangling cord on the google camera?!
The camera is held in place by magnets, I think that cable is to stop someone from stealing it
@@llamaSHORTS1 lol. A magnet is gonna keep someone from stealing the camera?! By the way, the cable detaches it is also held in by magnets.
Meanwhile in kalifornya (namely cray cray sf) the thieves could care less about either of these... They will also do both night and day without fear...
I hear the Ring LED lights burn out within 2 years and are NOT replaceable. This is a big deal!
Oh god i though that was mario 64 in the thumbnail
CHICLAYO PERU 🇵🇪 💪 💪 CHICLAYO PERU 🇵🇪 💪 💪 CHICLAYO PERU 🇵🇪 💪 💪 CHICLAYO PERU 🇵🇪 💪 💪 CHICLAYO PERU 🇵🇪 💪 💪
Nice puppets?!
You would think clarity and lighting in a camera would hold more weight.
But ring only works on an iphone...isnt that true
Rings WiFi is terrible. My doorbell could never connect quickly
Google Nest:
Ring charges per device.. where as Nest is one fee for multiple devices. So, with doorbell, flood light and another camera.. Nest is cheaper.
I pay RING’s Yearly subscription for unlimited devices…. I have 25 devices…. So what you speak is false.
@@SnaVibe right! I currently use Nest but previously was in the Ring ecosystem. One subscription price. Don’t know where he got that from. 🙄
7:26 🤔 wtf
Unless you have proper facial recognition which works you will get all the false alarms
The Google floodlight camera is attached using nothing but magnets that can be torn off. For those who think it's not possible to not be recognized while doing this, consider using a mask.
I just set up a ring floodlight wire pro. How come the lights were on overnight ?
there's an allen screw from the base power cord to the nest cam to "secure" it, and the ring cam can unscrew just as easy. I'd take 24/7 recording that nest offers over motion activation any day.
Your garage is crooked