Caste System & College Reservations - IAS Officer & BeerBiceps Discuss
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лип 2023
- पूरा Podcast यहाँ देखें:
• Ex-IAS Vivek Atray Exp...
नमस्ते दोस्तों!
आज हमारे साथ जुड़ चुके हैं Ex IAS Officer Vivek Atray जो हैं Motivational TEDx Speaker, Independent Advisor, Mentor, Columnist, Visiting Professor और "Finding Success Within" जैसी Inspirational Book के Author. देश के लिए उनका Dedication और सेवा भाव का कोई जवाब नहीं है। हर USPC Aspirant और IAS Officer के लिए वो एक Biggest Inspiration हैं।
चलिए आज जानते हैं Indian Caste System के बारे में।
#india #system
🎧 सुनिए #TheRanveerShow हिंदी Spotify पर :-open.spotify.com/show/3ptiw7n...
✅ Subscribe To Our Other UA-cam Channels:-
BeerBiceps (English Channel):
/ beerbicepsofficial
Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
/ ranveerallahbadia
TRS Clips (English Podcast Highlights):
/ theranveershowclips
BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
/ @bestoftrs
Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
/ @bestoftrshindi
RAAAZ. :
/ @raaazofficial
RAAAZ Shorts :
/ @raaazshorts
BigBrain Plus :
/ @bigbrain_plus
--
INSTAGRAM : @ranveerallahbadia
/ ranveerallahbadia
FACEBOOK : @ranveerallahbadiaofficial
/ ranveerallahbadiaofficial
TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
/ beerbicepsguy
LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
t.me/beerbicepsguy
SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
About :
The Ranveer Show Clips हिंदी Channel में आप सभी का स्वागत है। इस Channel पर आपको मिलेंगे #TheRanveerShowहिंदी के Podcast Highlights. यहाँ आप Indian History, Ancient India, World History, Hinduism, Personal Finance, Latest Business Opportunities, Top Businessmen In The World, Sports और Bollywood जैसे कई सारे Topics के बारे में जान कर अपने Knowledge के Hunger को Satisfy कर सकते हो।
No surprise that no one is talking about removing caste system, but removing reservation.
Cast is Pride remove cast discrimination
yes, because reservation entrenches the caste system, that is the contradiction which is difficult to solve
@@manvendrasingh2243 Where did you study from? Are you saying it's because of reservation there is caste system? was there reservation 3000 years back? I doubt your common sense and your education (if you are at all)
@@shubhammeshram4734 no I'm not saying that caste system is because of reservation. What I'm saying is that reservation makes people more conscious of their caste thus making it more difficult to destroy the caste system
@@manvendrasingh2243 Yes, that I agree with.
Why Dr. Ambedkar faced discrimination even after having so many qualification?
Why Kanshi ram remain un- noticed?
Why payal tadvi and Rohit vemula were killed?
Periyar and Phule were not poor form their families. Still why they chose come on these lines?
A Black always remain black either he is rich or poor.
The truth is caste hindus will never understand the caste biasness they impose intentionally on deepressed section, and will never recognise the privilege they enjoy.
You're wrong. Society is always divided into rich and poor.
Periyar was Brahmin
Savitribai Phule was financed by Brahmins, her first student was Brahmin !!!
When Dr. Ambedkar was marrying Brahmin woman, he was opposed by his sons & acquaintances cause she was Brahmin. So called caste based discrimination by so called Dalits themselves...
Discrimination is wrong no matter what instead of blaming one part and victimizing the other part, work on real issue why it is still there, why my own thinking is still bothering me think from whole 360° view.
Caste discrimination still exists in India at all levels, even in so called educated people.
No it doesnt.....ever seen MUMBAI LOCALS...do u see any one claiming i wont sit with a Lc guy....its all bull crap
@@19hbytuy Mumbai is not whole India, go to UP,MP,Bihar,Rajasthan,Haryana,Punjab, Chhatisgarh, you will know the reality. It is something else on the face and something else inside the heart
@@Kajal918I HAVE LIVED IN MP RURAL ...... I HAVE HAD MY BRAHMIN BOSS MAKE FOOD FOR ME IN HIS KITCHEN....WE HAVE GONE TO DHABAS WHERE WE SHARED THE SAME TABLE WHERE I ATE CHICKEN AND HE ATE HIS VEG DISHES.....I HAVE HAD BRAHMIN PEOPLE UNDER ME WHO WUD GET ME THERE HOME COOKED FOOD AND COME TO MY PLACE TO HAVE FOOD COOKED BY ME .... I AM OBC....SO LETS NOT GENRALISE ....THINGS AHVE IMPROVED 90%....10% WILL BE ERADICATED IN NEXT DECADE
@@19hbytuy
Payal tadvi had suicide due caste system in Mumbai
@@realityisdifferentr5055brahmin sadhus were lynched in PALGHAR....so wat....i am from a lower caste...i have never faced any discrimination....GROW up....
bring someone who is from lower caste and put his/ her views on your channel.
Reservation ko economic bases pe karna he to.
"Shadi" bhi Economic bases pe karo. Caste system bhi economic bases pe karo. Discrimination bhi economic bases pe karo. Sab kuch economic bases pe karo. "Baad me"reservation ko bhi economic bases pe karo..... Sab log kush. ☺️
Shadi economic basis par to hoti hai😂
Kuchh bhi?
This officer says this generation of kids doesn't know about caste, yet marginalised caste people still get discriminated and excluded from friend circle in college.
A typical caste Hindu agenda.
Thats because of reservations
The college students hate sc st for this reason
@@adarsh_mishra451 You seem to advocate for removing reservations and do not speak boldly to remove caste based discrimination. Many individuals inquire about surnames, caste, ranks, and scores, perpetuating caste-based stereotypes. Marriage decisions are often influenced by caste considerations. Additionally, reserved category individuals face significant mental health challenges in colleges due to these things. What steps have been taken to eliminate this discrimination beyond justifying it? Especially what you have done to remove it?? Reservation should cease only when caste-based discrimination ends.Biggest reason for this discrimination is making education as a tool for getting job. When education will be taken for getting knowledge and job as byproduct, these discrimination will be washed out from our society.
@@jagnoorsingh1087
Caste based discrimination???
Bro they are constantly threatening upper caste just for mere votes
They sometimes target our womens for votes
ua-cam.com/video/q_9J6fM4FyU/v-deo.htmlsi=jBcN53m99Nxku0ID
They have sc st act (search Vishnu tiwari case)
They have all sort of laws to protect themselves
Just get over it 😑
@@jagnoorsingh1087
If Article 14 15 16 17,, reservation
Sc st act and caste based politics subsidy programmes and schemes are not enough to finish discrimination then there is problem in your community not in the society
Why don't people discuss to remove caste based surname system ? Or how to improve intercaste marriage system? You both also just giving ur view on basis of your limited experience but dont think and discuss in the way to remove descrimination
Cast is our pride remove discrimination
Then you should start that by not using surname
Why should I remove my surname for someone else's ancestors failure? Cope and seethe.
@@adityashukla517That's why people want to continue reservation till the caste based surname exist. Once such surnames obliterated, then their is no need of caste based reservation.
@@ManuRai-hd1sp there's no reason to feel pride for a particular caste ...the people who did good whichever caste they were from are pride of the nation ..no need to bring caste
Rather than focusing on Removing Reservation, we should focus on Removing Caste System from our Society
Cast is Pride remove cast discrimination
@@ManuRai-hd1spits delusion.
Yadav's dominate in up and bihar if caste based discrimination exist in those states than yadavs are responsible
@@ManuRai-hd1sppata hain bhai tabhi humne aangrezo ko gulam banaya
Hnn jisko reservation mil raha hain(bina mehnat aur kam mehnat mei sb kuchh) woh ku apna benifit khona chaheiga ,.....@Yash Yadav Isn't it??
If caste is removed from our system, caste based reservation will automatically removed...
And how to remove cast?
@@jinfin221 Caste ko ridiculousness banake (Jo woh already hai) or make caste modifiable/dynamic.
Reserved Caste ki dikkat kya hai: Irrespective of urban/rural area, minor or major (but harmful) discrimination face karte. Mindset hi hai sabka (both GC and RC included). Even if log bolte, we don't have any issues with any caste, professional settings mein snide remarks, ostrasization rehta, ya bas blatant harmful sympathy/mocked up empathy, "Tu chote caste (social hierarchy mentally constructed hai hi sabke dimag mein) ki/ka hai phir bhi mera/meri dost hai". Baaki simple harmful matrimonial statements like "We are progressive people, open to intercaste, caste does not matter (SC/ST please excuse)". Also all this is irrespective of if the socially defined "lower" caste person has used reservation or not. Agar use karega/karegi reservation toh seedha classified "undeserved". Agar nahi use karega/karegi toh "Theek hai sirf tu use nahi karta/karti. Underprivilege hone ka privilege mil raha hai toh use karna". Because everyone knows had they (general) been given a chance to use that (reservation), they would have.
General Caste ki dikkat kya hai: Caste hamara culture define karta hai. Reservation should be banned. Caste sahi hai. Only economic basis pe rehna chahiye. Poor ko do, ye kya SC/ST ko dete ho (without creamy layer provision).
Par due to "Caste birth se decided rehti or as my favourite Swades Dialogue goes: Jo kabhi nahi jaati usi ko jaati kehte hain", woh modifiable nahi hai currently by law. And irrespective of anything, RC discrimination face hi karte rehte later in life. Again in the settings as described earlier - professional, personal and marital settings.
Solution:
Best yahi hai ke jo log reservation ka use karke seat le rahe unhe General category (Decide karlo degree mein hone waale exams aur uske merit basis pe ke kaunsa caste allot karna hai - because #merit-is-everything) mein convert karo legally (by law). Woh bhi chill ho jaenge ke discrimination nahi hoga ab unke saath aage and earlier General waale bhi ke reservation nahi mil paega ab jo ab converted hain. Win win.
Or a mindset change (on an individual level) is: Apni soch badlo regarding caste and casteism. Kitni bhi padhai karlo, moral compass agar individual ka strong na ho na toh reservation based law ki jarurat padegi hi. Works both ways. This is what the end goal of the reservation policy for "lower" caste is. And this policy (constitution forming committee/drafting committee) tries to provide a semi-economic/education reform based solution to a social problem. Reservation diya jaa raha taaki reserved population ka exposure ho paye top-positions of jobs and sab samajh paye "Bhai/Behen ye (SC/ST) toh completely relatable insaan hai mujhse, almost same culturally bhi hai". And that is what the "lower" caste wants - acceptance in the society aka social equality. Toh jaise hi casteist mindset logo ka sahi ho jaega reservation auto-eliminate ho jaega. Agar moral compass nahi change ho paata (which is too much to expect from person given their upbringing), to caste ko dynamic allocation mode pe rakho. Padh lia toh pandit ban gaya irrespective of initial caste, and fail hua exam mein toh dalit. Only then will people realize the ridiculousness of caste, kyunki koi bhi upper caste wants to convert to lower caste taaki reservation mile and "life easy ho", without fully understanding the constant discrimination faced by the RCs. Uppercaste now enjoys social privilege (calling it a privilege because RC doesn't get it at the same level) which should really not be a privilege but a basic right for everyone, irrespective of where they were born.
Ye cast system toh sirf toh ek bahana hai Inko reservation se matlab hai…
@@jinfin221Simple, stop discrimination and if anyone is promoting casteism you should stop it. Since when we stop, they put the banner of reservation without knowing my marks and admission seat type, but if someone who belongs to general like you will try to stop then it will expose them.
On point podcast episode This things need to change and ranveer asked exact question that needs to be asked🔥
Ranveer Bhai i am belong st cast so many general cast people they dislike us . I saw many educated general cast people they behave like we come from other plant . You can't marriage other cast people . I hate cast system . People say say's we never believe cast system but when come topic like marriage , accession our present get angry. General people inherite cast system to there child . It real truth of rural area 👍
Agreed 💯
They dislike you because of reservation
@@swapnilmasurekar5431 To fir aaja, aadivasio ke sath reh 5 din, kasam se agar tune vo 5 din nikal diye na, reservation chod denge.. 😁
@@swapnilmasurekar5431 are bhai... Ek comment se dislike karne laga... Abhi to rehne aana he na.. Fir kya hoga..
@@swapnilmasurekar5431 I know they hate for reservation . They more educated but not try to understand why govt conserve reservation . They saw only apical level not deep dive what reasons behind it . They educated but outer level only . 👍👍
Agar ek time ke baad survey krke reservatiom mey changes nhi laye gaye to fir reservation se hee casteism badhne lagega.
Dear Ranveer.. plz invite Dr. SURAJ YENGDE on your podcast for more detailed and fact based insights on casteism.
He is Harvard scholar and an expert on the subject.
Thank you
Bhai apne sahi kaha
Ranveer is godi media support so he cannot invite the dr Suraj yegde
Vo bikka hua h
Harvard is not friendly to India so people of India should stop sucking Harvard alumni for approval
Have a spine and build one.
Now currently President is Adivasi
PM is OBC
Ex-President is Dalit (Ramnathji)
Any one from so called upper caste opposed?
If no then it is the end now…
Kyuki.. politics mein Inka bus istemal hota hai St SC k votes lene k liye.. tumko politics Shayad pata nahin hai kya sirf kursi ka khel hota hai
Vote ke liye
Upper caste people discussing how caste system is not there now .
Reservation is also based on social backwardness..not only economic
1.People do get reservation in neet pg. Do u think a doctor who has done mbbs and is now going for pg is socially backward???common man grow up.
2.Also if it's so called meant for social backwardness then why do the reserve category people pay half of the fee in many gov colleges???why r they getting economic benefits then?
Towns Cities me bilkul bhi discrimination nahi hota, fir bhi log reservation lete hain.. jinko milna chahiye wo nahi le paate...IAS IPS ke bache bhi leye hain... Bussinessman ke bhi...or sirf marks nahi age, number of attempts, examination fees or to aur promotion me bhi...IPS lagne ke baad log reservation lete hain IAS banne ke liye. Ameer se ameer bhi leta hai...
Army me height ki reservation kyu? Hai? Exam me form ki fees kam kyu hai? Ye economic nahi hai? Tumhe haar baat PE reseva chahiye
@@ug3332 it's a debatable topic. Let's have some argue in this respect.. I'm lawyer by profession so I know legally the applicability of reservation. I'm not saying whether it's right or not..but my point is reservation is based on social backwardness also.. not only economic..
@@Optimistic_mind441 aisa nai hai ki reservation nai hona chahiye. Reservation is necessary evil.. but yes it's applicability must rethink again.. there is a concept called "cremy layer"..which is applicable only on OBCs..and not on SCs STs.. so bss reservation policy m thode changes required hai..
- but reservation hona chahiye ya nai..my answer is- reservation hona chahiye..
Once cast system totally goes away out of india, india become unite and strong, there will be no fight, no violence, no foreigner can divide and invade india,
I hope everyone will think on that and stop fighting🙏
Caste system hasn't gone anywhere since last 2000 years, won't go anywhere now also.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Thank you Ranveer bhai . acha topic uthaya aapne.aap jaise influencer is baare me awareness faila sakte hai.aapka ka jo attitude vo humesha neutral hai aur learning hain.keep up the good work
caste exists in city too,all flats are taken by privileged class where they have access to everything.other castes are living away from center of city where they have travel long distance to get things.
the only thing is discrimination not happening the way its happening in villages.
Just see in punjab village area homes are still divided by casts
which kind of ias he is because govermets own data is showing that there are 3 times more castism in modern india compared to before indipendence
Today intellectuals are just far away from the reality, They thought their perception is popular views but when you visit on ground the realism will hit you so hard that they just turned into mute spectators. Before having discussion on these topic you guys should come with facts and figures.
True , podcasts these days have just become mutual masturbation gor pleasure , thats all
Sit with us bro..we will show you discrimination at ground level.. come once at Meerut UP
@Ranveer I guess, experience gives more knowledge than getting to know by 2nd face of knowing and understanding. If you ever wish to say any comments on SC / ST which could be positive or negative it's been you must reach out and survive yourself to know the pain of everyday life. It won't be that understood able unless you suffering the same causes,
Why do all peeps talk only on the reservation?
1) Why don't you talk about the once-illegal property?
2) how once and still women and men are treated.
3) why there is no equal treatment in all factors like y no political growth, film industry growth, business industry growth, and high professional job?
When you know the population of this cast is more than the rest others.
Man on a serious note: understanding something is different, Living within some unfair threats daily is what peeps like you must look deep into before you spit any sensitive topic.
I can bet you in 1day of spend time, I can show you how worst life is and the deep shit people carry in their life
Who doesn't deserve equality?
Who doesn't wish for it?
Why only the reservation topic is into the spotlight?
If deserving is what matters? Then why only in education or the job system, why not in all equality in all different sectors?
Bro, it's a big subject don't claim what you see in the present comparison with others like deserving and all stuff of words.
Approach me or any peeps who can exactly give clarity of all dust by wake-up calls.
I watch all your shows as much as during any time I get, it has the information to understand what's going on in the pattern but if you claiming it on such a big platform that's not worthy man!
Ranveer, please do some ground research before making any perception about anything. Those who are living with this caste label knows the reality.. whether it be some IAS or some labour of this country. Please ask from some potent people about this caste reality. Whether this surname thing is reality or not..
Sir ne sports advancement ki baat ki to yaad aya ..vo jo sexual harrasment hua tha...top atheletes ka...? Us perception pe kya bolna chahty hai....? Aur caste discrimination ko napne ka yantra bna lijiye....tbhi aap iska idea lga skty hai....otherwise just believe it exists ...aur admission k time PTA chalna chhaiye ki bs general category jo sbse kam hai percentage me...vo poora gher k baithengey to solution kya hona chahiye ..apni car se lekr ...har jagah apna surname flaunt krne k bad agr apni caste k according Gyan ni hai...marks ni la paty to caste change kr le na , krenge ? Last thing bde dukh ki bat hai ... Ki IAS has no knowledge about cast system... He just answered like a layman ...isne koi stats mention ni kiya jisse bhut kuch clear hota hai... reservation is on the basis of social discrimination...which people face even if they are well off ...aur reservation pe in chutia se kya puch rhe....divyakirti sir se kyu ni pucha ?
Mindset & Perspective
Anihilation of caste systems is dream because everything depends on caste admissions promotion employment facilities everything how it possible to annihilation of caste systems?
Marriage same caste bhi mushkil se hoti usme subcaste gotra pta bahut ghoch poch hai
Bring.. Dr. Suraj Yeghede... Watch his podcast with Kunal Kamra....
Ranveer has no Idea what he is talking about. He lived a privileged life in mumbai and it shows pretty well in the interview.
caste ka aur financial condition cannot be compared
vo sab theke lekin ranveeer bhai intro jyda hi jordar kr diya
We always blame to Britishers divide and rule but why we don't think our present politicians why they are not making law for the demolition of cast system this is the sad bitter truth
If we want to make our country great in the world we will have to demolish our domestic conflict one of them biggest obstacle is cast system government should make law and demolish the cast system
Government should stop issuing caste certificates and bring to an end the caste system made by Britishers...... intercaste marriages are good for the health of coming generations as well they won't be discriminated on the basis of caste
Ranveer bhai aap ka thought bilkul shi h
Caste based reservation drop krke financial capacity se reservation milega toh sbke liye best rhega
Wrna mene bhi apne kai deserving doston ko iss wjh se suffer krte dekha h
Later on fir caste system ko hatana best rhega
Cast is pride remove cast discrimination
Abe pehle caste system ko hatao inrercaste marriage promote karo tb reservation hatana
@@mohit19907Abe tu phir financial based biasness ko hata if a general candidate is poor no girl from a his caste or even lower caste will marry him caste based reservation hatao economic based reservation lao
50 percent kam ho jaaega AGAR SC ST MEIN CREAMY LAYER INTRODUCE KARO
bhai mera ek classmate tha stopped talking to me because i was sc
Caste ab ek social muddha na ho kar political muddha ban gaya hai aur isme hum general log hi pis rahe hain. Yeh caste thinking in anything hame aaj divide kar rahi hai. Aur Caste system ke khilaf sabhi samaya ek general ne hi awas uthai hai like Savarkar
bhai dekho Mera bhi Mann nhi karta discrimination karne ka on the basis of caste but baat vahi hai na ki general category ko kuch bhi nhi milta as profit but sc/st/obc walo ko sab milta hai
Mai reservation Dene ke khilaf nhi hu but it should be given to needy people whose annual income is lower than 600000 before tax
But hamare Desh me unko bhi arakshan milta hai Jo full family government job me group A me hai there are several examples
And if in the private sector you see jiska package above 18 lpa hai par government usko bhi reservation deti hai toh ye sab se chid hoti hai
And if general category person is poor still he gets no reservation and have to score highest for selection and if an st/sc/obc scores good marks he is placed in limited seats of general category giving more seats to sc/st/obc and one more thing with reservation there sc/st/obc also get age relaxation whereas general category person doesn't get any of the above things I mentioned so all this leads to this hate
Good, as general (upper caste) person I will leave India soon because living in this country with a competitive disadvantage then what innit for me?
22.3 per cent of the country’s higher caste Hindus own 41 per cent of the country’s total wealth
He is literally one who actually creaked the real issues of general caste too..... Warna aur youtuber hate na mile iss liye aankh band karke reservation ko support krte h.....
0:00 click this several times and see what you get
Urban areas mai bhi caste hota hai.
Ranveer you’re privileged
Please invite sunil chhetri sir....plzzzzzz
varna system should be brought back to make changes on reservation system 😊
For those who are saying thta reservations should be income based let me tell you that one of my friend's dad earns 15LPA but still they have income certificate to get NCL. Another friend is rich too, he has 1 BHK flat in urban area, Laptop, Wifi, always wears proper clothes also never seems he is out of money and guess what still he was able to apply for EWS. So there's no point in Economic based reservation too
When you come to North East you will see 90 percentage of multi storey building are owned by ST SC . 95+ percentage of employees in government offices are them 70-80 percentage in private corporate are same ST SC be it doctor or any services all are them.. more to that they are not even tribes they are Christian. So why they are getting reservation??????????? Have you seen the 12th Movie? It's the condition of many non tribes all over the country who have knowledge and dedication but lack in resources and over that we are restricted with age cut off and fees.
Ye To Wahi Baat Ho Gayi... Bimari Ko Nahi Bimar Ko Hi Jad Se Khatam Kardo...
Caste system is still there..people teach their children about the superiority of their castes and how they are different than others
Underrated fact - 80% of casteism in today's India ( specially the ones in urban and semi-rural regions) is actually BCOZ OF RESERVATION. Belonging to a middle class urban family, I've grown with many friends from both upper and lower castes not even realising all these upper cast and lower cast things. But one fine day, when I come to know that my friend (who actually lives in a Bungalow and his father drives an SUV, but yeah he's SC category) can get admission in a college with 450 marks, whereas another one of my friend will be rejected even if he scores 530 just bcoz of him being upper caste (his father drove a 2nd hand car and they lived in a 2 bedroom flat), that day I start developing questions as to WHY SHOULD THIS HAPPEN TO US? And there begins the URBAN CASTEISM. Jusy gave one example, there are thousands and lakhs of such examples every year in our country.
Every reservation for an undeserving candidate gives rise to a new casteist upper caste.
Digest this truth before blaming on casteism...
Bro ameeri gareebi ka reservation system se koi lena dena nahi hai..
@@Destroyer-ff1vs Aur tumhare comment ka mere comment se koi lena dena nahi hai😅😅😅
@@ritwikghosh7743 kyuki tumhe basic understanding hi nhi hai reservation system ka..
@@Destroyer-ff1vs Toh tum zara do mujhe kuch understanding, dekhta hoon kya understand nahi hai meri.
@@ritwikghosh7743 reservation in education kisika economic background dekh k nahi diya jata (except EWS for generals jo recently aya).
Caste based Reservation hai to caste dekh k diya jata hai. Ameer ho gareeb ho isse koi lena dena nahi.. government intentionally push krna chahti hai stscs ko kyuki unki representation km hai hr field me.. agar population wise dekhe to total population me 30% generals hai jo sbse zyada wealth, jobs, political power hold krte hai. And stsc obc jo 70% honge unki equal representation nahi hai. Reason-whi hai jo past me hua.. sb disproportionately distribute ho chuka hai.. isi ko fix krta hai reservation system extra benefit de k..
And talking about marks,
Sari categories ko jitni seats milti hai wo usi me compete krte hai.. meaning generals sirf generals ki available seats pe compete krenge. There is no need to compare marks, uska sense nahi hai.. wo reserved seat kisi general wale ko nahi milni..
offcourse aap zyada deserve krte honge but jo community caste discrimination k chakkar me piche reh gye the unko same level me laane ki zrurat hai.. its a positive discrimination..
Plus generals me itna competition hai ki 90% laane waalo ka bhi nahi hota.. its just that you need to work even harder..
Problem ye hai ki log government se fight nahi krte instead mock krne lgte hai STSCs ko jo khud victim rhe hai..
aaj agar koi stsc ameer hua hai to sirf reservation system ki wajah se.. even aaj bhi mostly stscs obc ki population poverty me jee rhi hai..
Ajeeb baath hai, we are“ Independent "but not yet with our mindset.
Logon ko Reservation se problem hai toh we can remove it ,but only when other caste people are ready to remove their "caste Surnames "from their names.Kya yeh fair hai?.Caste System has reduced to a little extent only.Jis din kisiko bhi koi bhi caste ka benifit na milega,na surname rakhne ka...etc uss din aap reservation ko hatane ki baate kariye.
.
.
And our generation people who are upset with reservation,why dont we try our kids or next generation be taught to marry anyone they want ,eat,play ,sit with people they want.And teach them to never believe in discrimination.
.
Our Younger generation should understand that its not about people or their caste .Its about how you treat people equaliy as human that matters.
🙏
Creamy Layer lagado SC ST MEIN
SC, ST are discriminated regarding admission to schools, treatment in hospital's, in police station, courts.
To tackle this reservation is necessary.
What if no reservation provision been made in constitution. What would be the future of these communities and india.? They would be educationally, sociall, and economically backward.
Thus leading to frustration, anger anger and thus may lead to violence against Brahmins, Kshatriyas, and vaisyas.
Constitution and reservation prevents backward communities from resorting to violence and to create a stable society.
Bhai 1 baat btaa BRAHMIMS TOH MAHARASHTRA MEIN OBC MEIN HAI AUR VAISHYAS TOH OBC BIHAR MEIN HAI PHIR VIOLENCE KISKE SAATH KAROGE
Manuvadio ke saath
We had caste based reservations since independence and now it is 50% reservations. Why teh system established by Congress did not work and still they are saying no representations from dalit, OBC etc? The reason is it is the same family again and again enjoying reservations, generations after generations. It is same wealthy class among OBC, Dalits who are misusing reservations. Reservations has to be given only one or 2 generations for a family and once they have financial means to educate their children then their children should be considered as general category. Also reservations has to consider financial status. Keeping the current system and increasing reservations above 50% is injustice to the general category and injustice to economically backward people of other casts. Actually casts should not be a factor in reservations and time has proved this since independence
People talking about casteism in the comments section makes me laugh😂😂😂 Reservation is the biggest reason for casteism in today's India. Pura bachpan guzar gaya kabhi pata hi nahu chala ki upper cast hoon😅 na hi koi fayda mila uska. Aur aaj college admission ke time pata lagta hai ki mera bagal waala dost, jo actually mujh se zyada ameer ghar se hai, mere se aadhe marks se college mein admission le raha hai🤣
CASTEISM BEGINS HERE, GUYS. IF RESERVATION WILL END, CASTEISM WILL ALSO END.
Gareebi htane k liye nahi hai reservation system.. backward classes ko equal representation dene k liye hai.. yhi to smjh nahi aata tumhe..
Yess here in India in all levels catse discrimination is exist, even if in metro city.In bhubaneswar before giving rented house they ask about cast.
General category like kare 😅😅😅😅😅
Caste discrimination still persist in urban areas.
Bhai ko samj nhi caste system ki . The caste system is everywhere doesn't matter city or village
hello brother, as per my knowledge I know in any competitive exam or during admission to any university SC /SC seats are fewer as compared to the general seats.
Bhai clg kya desh alg le lo tm...thak gye hn hm bhoj uthate uthate sab logon ka
Are you 10th fail ? 😂 bro reservation means "reserved" seats for a certain group and general means everybody , how you say general have more seats ?
@@powerenergy3480 How many SC ST OBC use general seats? And why would they do that when the cutoffs are already low in their category?
Most of the general seats are used by upper castes
@@robertcraig2662 tum log nhi, hum log utha rahe he tumhara bhoj. Our people even today are forced to work and follow orders from upper castes. Why can't you guys just let us live ?!!
Bhai tere liye toh reservation chahiye hi chahiye kyunki logic toh zero hai tere argument mai par phir bhi admissions lena hai
People saying remove caste system as if it's a government policy
Really 😑
Tou banaya hi kyu aap logo ne..jin log ne se ye caste system bnaya..unhi k dna khoon apme hai..
Aapke parents, friends , society ne apko discrimination karna sikhaya hai..
Ek tarah se never ending chiz hai.
Un logo k galti ka sajah Hume mil rhe h.. tumlog k kya h khul k discrimination karte ho maja aata hai aap logon Ko has k mje lete..
Ham log per Kya bitih hai soch bhi nahin sakte ho..
@@deepamurmu9806
Humne banaya
Tune adopt kyu kiya???
Chhod de apni caste 😑
Sab economic conditions ki taraf divert kr dete h is matter ko jabki asli mudda discrimination h
Kya sc St category Wale ek dusre se discriminate nahi karte hain..🤔🤔
I am from Tripura and I belong to general category.
And my anual family income is 2.5 lac am I rich??
Many of my friends who belong to sc, st and obc their family earn more than us.
obcs of tripura are well to do.
I am not against reservation,
But yes all general category people are not rich
And all sc, st and obc people are not poor.
Reservation should be demographic or economic.
If we talk about humiliation come in our state we will show brotherhood.
But how will you respect a teacher who got his/her job through reservation but he/she can't even teach the subject.
Think once is he/she delivering something to the society??
Just earning money without doing anything.
No offence please try to get the context.
I know many deserving poor general people who are not getting the jobs or say admission in the colleges.
Ok let's say give reservation in schools colleges but why in job sector. One who has got a good education through reservation why can't he/she crack a job??? With the same education if a general category student can crack a job then why can't a student who belongs to the reservation category crack a job???
Being a student from general category I don't want reservation for my self but I want reservation for the the real needy one. In our state the real sc, sts are not even getting their reservations, but the rich from the cities are taking advantages.
I ll suggest you to go to jaipur and ask pundits living there about how they treat low caste people there ..they even dont like to receive water with their hand.
These pundits eat what they earn from their temple cumm business and take chadhava to their home but wont drink water given by them ...
Kindly remove reservation from temples also
All youngsters in these days are selfish
They are just talking about their own
Always have been.
Metro city me sabse jyada jatibad hai, Par maximum SC/ ST aaj bhi Hinduism follow karta hai, shame on them.
Article 14 15 16 17,,sc st act ,,, reservation in jobs education and even in promotions,, caste based politics
And still oppressed??
Ranveer bhai meri help kor do please 🥺 mere papako tantrik balone mardiya😢aur abhi meri maako b marne per tule hain mein kuch nehi kar pa raha apkata bohot se ese logose jan pehechan hai please meri maako bachane main meri modod kor do,mere pitajika jese achanak moot hogya bese mere mataji ke saath na ho plz plz 😂🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Sitting in podcast and discussion with people will not give you reality. It will only give individual perception. You need to visit places to see what casteism is. See your self, experience yourself and then you will in better position to comment on this.
Abolish castism, abolish Caste based reservation, for better India.
All religion have cast where are you living it's work related cast
The SC,ST n OBC make 80% of the population so its their votes that matter. It’s because of this there is reservation. Had anyone given a thought how come just 15-20 % of population has been having all the jobs, admissions in top colleges for years ?
Bhai tu pehle nitin rajput ka video dekhle
Why it should nt be based on financial basis uske videos dekhte ja na teri knowledge badhegi
When discrimination is based on cast basis hw it can be based on financial basis
Jab cast ko dekhe discriminate krte hai log na ki rich hai ya poor hai
Poor uper class cast based discrimination face krega kya ye batao pehle nhi krega lekin
Lower cast vala rich ho ya poor cast based discrimination face krta hai itni si bat samj nhi aati hai logo ko
Cast based discrimination hatao pehle
Main city main rehta hun maine khud face kiya hai mera ek dost tha jab tak meri cast pata nhi thi mere ghar bhi ata tha jab meri cast pata chali mujse bat tak karna band kardi
Sab jagah hota hai bas log muh pe nhi bolte hai bs pit piche sab bolte hai
Nitin rajput ke bolne se facts thodi change honge. Towns Cities me bilkul bhi discrimination nahi hota, fir bhi log reservation lete hain.. jinko milna chahiye wo nahi le paate...IAS IPS ke bache bhi leye hain... Bussinessman ke bhi...or sirf marks nahi age, number of attempts, examination fees or to aur promotion me bhi...IPS lagne ke baad log reservation lete hain IAS banne ke liye. Ameer se ameer bhi leta hai... Ye sab baatein batayi Nitish Rajput ne?
@@Optimistic_mind441 bhai tune maine kya lika hai voh padha kya
Aur video main kya dikhaya hai voh samaj main aaya kya
Tu sab batein ignore krke ye comment kr rha hai tujhe kya bolu ab
Reservation promotes discrimination to a certain extent. Reservation concept should be more flexible and justifiable.
Cast system efficient way maa india ma nahi chal raha haa yaa sirf india ko batt naa kaa kamm kar raha haa mostly india ma middle class yaa lower than middle class people haa tooo 9th ka student koo kuch jadya patta nahi hota ha cast ka bara maa jesa hee voo 10th pass karta haa fir jab vo addmission lena jata haa tabh voo city ka logo koo bhee discrimination maa batt deta haa general valo ka cut off 75 obc ka 69 sc ka 58 st ka 50 yaa difference haa fir yaa discrimination kabhe hatt taa nahi haa mind set saa logo kaa bas yaa chalta chala jata haa ess leya gov koo kuch kar naa chaeya 😌
Best yahi hai ke jo log reservation ka use karke seat le rahe unhe General category (Decide karlo degree mein hone waale exams aur uske merit basis pe ke kaunsa caste allot karna hai) mein convert karo. Woh bhi chill ho jaenge ke discrimination nahi hoga ab unke saath and earlier General waale bhi ke reservation nahi mil paega ab jo pehle reserved the. Win win.
Bhaiya jb gernal cast wala 80% number leke b bhar beth ra h or SC ST cast wala 60% par bhi government Job kr ra h Too khi n khi government bhi divide kr ri h
Didi tum apni ghar me bolo ki cast system khatam karne ki pahl kare aur tumhari sadi sc se kar de phir reservation par baat karna
@@truthkitalash Bhai mere yeha pe sadhi hue hi general aur obc me😊
@@truthkitalashcaste system is not wrong.caste individual ki identity hoti hai bo chahe sc ho ya general mana ki discrimination galat hai but reservation solution nhi hai adidas ke shoe jacket dalke app log agar reservation mngo GE to bo galat hai
Didi pehle caste likhna Sikh lo 🤡 phir 80% leke aana
@@preetyrajput6oo lo aa gyi baat caste system khtm na krne ki... Jab tak caste system rhega tab tak reservation bhi rhega
He is showing his real face slowly 🐍 beef lover
gamdu ranveer talking pure bs
no clue lol
Muje khud ni pta tha ki mai general, bharanan upper caste hu
But i don't care about my caste
#removecastesystem
Narative is right reservation is given to only people who earn less than 8 lakh. Example i dont get reservation but in my hometown my cousin get
He is IAS ...dont know actually reality...dont know data ..strange 😮😮
Bro i am sure that ab bhut saare log ayenge aur negative comments krenge ki aaj se 1000-5000 yrs pehle esa hota tha vesa hota tha bhle hi unhone dekha na ho ,unke saath kbhi discrimination na hua ho but still they would come and victimize themselves and. Mostly apne aap ko caste discrimination ka victim btane wale big cities se hote hai jaha discrimination na kr barabar hota hai even i have a friend from sc category, we never talked about caste and all but ye caste vgerah sb reservation hi btata hai, the young generation has no idea about caste and all but jb tk kuch log dusro ke naam pr apne ko victimize krke reservation lete rhenge tb tk kuch nhi ho skta
Right bro this Reservation shit should end
Ranveer ji... Aap sirf mumbai tak simit ho.. Aap ke najdik palghar bhi nhi ghume ho kya.. St cast log kitne he.. Lifestyle kya he.. Culture kya he.. Cast problem kya he.. Or itni sari bate karna.. Kya yar kis type ka knowledge rakhte ho.. 🙏🙏
Chup lr caste
In bhai sahab lo kuch pata nhi h, relatively privileged, lower caste and other indian aspect ke barey me kuch idea nhi h. He is lucky that show pe guest intelligent atey h otherwise ye agyani ki shreni me hi atey h
jiskaa caste nhii uskaaa identity kyaaa hiiii huyii
Caste ka benefit bhi chahiye aur Caste Free society bhi chahiye.....
What non sense is this??
@@lobhasg Kya benefits he bato jara sir.. Kabhi time mile to jana aadivasio ke ghar dekhne.. Unki life dekhne.. Fir sayad comment me achhe words niklenge..
Discrimination City me hota he ranveer Payal tadvi ne suicide kiya he.IIT Bombay me aik ladk n 2023 ne suicide kiya he
Try to buy/rent/lease flat or houses in tier-2 cities, you'll find another India.
I'm from Gurgaon. Try even here. Lol😂
Mere hisab to reservation haar caste k liye hona chaiye mtlb ki haar ek caste k koi na koi person system m hona chaiye
Sc/st, obc समाज के साथ हजारों सालों से अन्याय हुआ है अब बारी है बहुजन समाज के साथ न्याय करने की इसलिए लम्बे समय तक बहुजन समाज को Reservation मिलना ही चाहिए चाहे थोड़े से मनुवादियों को कितनी ही मिर्ची लगती रहे लेकिन बहुजन समाज के साथ न्याय करने वाला reservetion तो रहना ही चाहिए।
•=
Reservation isn't just about income; it addresses historical caste-based discrimination and unequal opportunities. And the caste based discrimination also exist now.. So reservation is also excited... Tumhe kudke uchhi jti hone pe garv bhi hona hai.... Cast system bhi rakhn na ha on the basis of birth... Tumhe Sare seets bhi chahiye.... Asa thori na hota hai.... Ya to caste system hatao ya reservation rahne do....
It really need, but rural areas many people didn't know about cast reservation
Every one knows people in Bihar are well about reserved seat ... Reservations in school and college although there are not many soo good kind of
General candidates from lower middle class bring 98% marks and get no good education and job seats whereas candidates of rich businessmen and officer fathers of so-called 'backward castes' living in posh bungalows bring 65% marks and get the best education and jobs. The general candidate remains poor and backward just like his father. Most of the unreserved seats are already taken by the 'backward classes' and the remaining seats are exclusively kept reserved for them to ensure 'equality'. This just a reservation which has vengeance in its mind against the general castes instead of a genuine concern for progress. Only removing all reservations and keeping it only for genuinely poor candidates as its sole criteria can be more promotive of social equality, unity and progress of Indian society. Reservation in today's society is a curse to India. It is just like Jinnah who kept crying and using victim card for extra benefits for his particular minority group untill he cut away half of our country. The reservation agenda on caste today is no different than that.
Read more about reservation system. you have wrong notions about how reservation works and why it exists.. in short, reservation did not came to uplift people from poverty.
And your data is completely wrong.. generals still holds most of the wealth, jobs, position in politics..
and there is no vengeance as such. Its just that generals have more competition as they haven’t face any kind of discrimination since past.. If you see population wise of each category, generals are far ahead of stscs.. you are just throwing one example. There are many more stscs who does not even count as lower middle class. They are going through extreme poverty, illiteracy..
And don’t compare yourself with stscs.. you have to study hard.. and if anyone with 98% did not qualify that means there are more people who scored more than that in general category..
@@Destroyer-ff1vs People going through extreme poverty must be given reservation but that should be on economic basis and not on caste and victim card basis.
Also likewise, there are endless number of castes like Ahoms in Assam who were the nobility for centuries prior to the british and even afterwards and they are given reservation owing to their mythical 'backwardness', or the huge land owning Jaats in Haryana for example. Infact all my classmates who got reservation apart from one or two mostly lived in huge houses and had multiple cars and we had a 20 year old scooter in dilapidated rented house. But we were the discrimating class and they were the "backward class".
Reservation is not to help the poor, its just a dirty vote bank politics to divide Indian society. Exactly the same methodology which Jinnah used for his "backward" Muslima and reserved a part of our country for them and cut it away.
Ashoka, Shivaji etc almost 100% of the nobility in India were always from the so-called backward classes. But you guys have a habit of doing r@ndi rona since centuries. And that my fellow citizen is the fact.
@@meltherecafe2394 you are paying for what your ancestors did
@@Destroyer-ff1vs so basically you are saying that its about taking revenge for the narratives of falsely constructed past than actually doing it for equality in India, this type of revenge mentality is exactly how criminals think and operate. thanks for exposing yourself.
But WE will do what our ancestors did not. We will expose you and not let you guys continue with your victim card manipulation and abuse of hardworking deserving citizens. And we will cure your centuries of r@ndi rona. India will see equality and true progress and leave toxic mentalities of revenge and divisive forces in the past. Vande Mataram.
This shows ranveer does not know real India, he is trying to sound knowledgeable but fails
Sad ,that even on caste discrimination the so called upper caste people have more opportunities and platforms to speak on the topic than the oppressed class. A successful outcome of the caste system imposition of course!
Why the lower caste people are not being called on shows to share their experiences. Why the person who was beaten just bcz he wore chappal, or mount a horse , or want to marry a person of different caste gets rejected just bcz of him being allegedly lower caste are not brought in fore and interviewed. Who is responsible for this one sided opinions which still propagate caste in the well educated minds of the urban residents too, not just remote villages! I myself have experienced it in the Modern , IT company of mine with thr sw engineers from very well to do families and living in metropolitan cities!
Caste system has not gone anywhere, but thanks to babasaheb such people are are forced to behave on some level externally,but very often show their true colors.
Give voice to the underprivileged, please dont make the oppressors the spokesperson for them. Please have an elaborate discussion on the caste issues, why not call suraj yengde if you dare face the facts. He speaks with facts and figures. Let the public know of the ground realities, acknowledge their deeds and understand the issue . Elite people don't tell caste to their children ,but thats also a privilege that they can afford! But they surely will tell reservations are bad. Educate them abt the wrongdoings which were worse than the britishers or anybody in the planet. We hate hitler, white people , the invaders of india, the dalit history puts the upper castes in the same category, hence they try to hide it deny it as much as they can.
india is the only country where people wants to become backwards so they can get reservation.
because reserved ones are the ones benefitting from this shithole country called India.
its in your own mind which hinders backward class and lower caste ppl to grow.
but sadly whatever happens will never marry to someone having depreciating mindset instead of growth mindset .
hope you understood why not to marry in lower caste is told by my parents .
Religion, Cast aur state ye bade logonka tool hai public ko iname ulaja rakhe taki satta permanent unke hat mai rahe
Now days religion based reservations present to run country
Bro! One mislead can make you look different, you can pass your comments for sure only when you know the quality of it. Please bhai, it's a respect for you I still could manage to lower my steaming point of mind. Know it, do research dude, kuch b spit karoo mut. You saw a political face of understanding, have you ever seen the dark side?
Did you live it anytime? How much have you experienced the so-called of this darkness and suffering of the cast?
I'm sorry man! I didn't expect this short knowledge from you. Disgusting
No hate! , I wish you need to work on it.
Leave your ground if you need or wish to give progress if you wish for honesty if you wish for deserving.
Full caste discrimination is present in India
If u were lower caste
U won't be doing this video
Because
Then..U have experience of this
Reservation को लेके तुम जैसे infuencer से शायद कुछ ज्यादा logical बाते expect करते है,but तुम्हारे तर्क काफी ओझल थे
Unfortunately aisa agar zada din chalega ... To general caste ka log andolon krna start krdega... Becz we are also suffering since very long time now... Reservation should be stop... Or rhibaat caste system ka wo dhire dhire uth rha h.. Bohot uthbhi chuka h... Bohot sadia hota h ab... Mere ghr m hum 3, 4 sadi hogya general or obc m... Or ab sc st hi zada ameer bhi h... Sab jagah m wolog researved v h ... Or hr government sector k upr zadatar wohi log h... Ab utha lena chahiye..
Ye kari na sahi baat..
instead of mocking stscs, fight with government 🫡
Jatav on top
This is not easy to being a dalit in India