आचार्य है या अचार है इनको यह तक नहीं पता कि मनुस्मृति को महाभारत काल मे युधिष्ठिर ने न्याय के रूप में मनुस्मृति को स्तंभ मानकर न्याय किया था। जहां दंड के परिणाम का ज्ञात होने के बाद भी दंड करना, और जिसे ज्ञान ना हो या अल्प ज्ञान होना पर अलग-अलग दंड की व्याख्या करती है मनुस्मृति जोकि व्यक्तियों के वर्ण के हिसाब सुनाई जाती है। यह तो पोंगा पंडित है इससे आचार्य को कुछ नहीं पता bs दुकान चल रही है और कितनी बड़ी दुकान कर लेगा इसको इसकी चिंता है बस
अगर मनुस्मृति की कमियों पर प्रकाश डालोगे और उसे कम अहमियत दोगे जो कि उतनी अहमियत देने लायक है भी नहीं फिर भी ,जिन्हें हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों से ही दिक्कत है वो गीता या रामायण को पकड़ लेंगे।🤷🏼♂️🤦♂️ जो कि हम देख ही चुके हैं।😂
@@princerajput3864 Common Sense Ki Baat Hain. श्लोक: चातुर्वर्ण्यं मया सृष्टं गुणकर्मविभागशः। तस्य कर्तारमपि मां विद्ध्यकर्तारमव्ययम्।।4.13।। Hindi: BG 4.13: मनुष्यों के गुणों और कर्मों के अनुसार मेरे द्वारा चार वर्णों की रचना की गयी है। यद्यपि मैं इस व्यवस्था का सृष्टा हूँ किन्तु तुम मुझे अकर्ता और अविनाशी मानो।
@@princerajput3864 ये जीतना भी भेद भाव हैं। वो सब पावरफुल लोगों के स्वार्थ के कारण हैं। और ये सब आज भी चल रहा हैं, अमीर लाख क्राइम के बाद भी बेल पर बाहर और गरीब छोटे जुर्म पर जेल में सड़ रहा हैं।
@@Mashroom423 unki photo hi jaka sakte ho unki jaise kam ti tum jaise dhram ki tekhdar kabhi kar nahi sakte bas dhram ki harakhori kar skte ho aur stupid to tum jaise log hote ho jo ek maa ki kala katne vala ko bhagvan aur samaj mai kuch karne vale lo disrespect karnia tum jaise ghatiya log ki adat hoti hai dhramik kitab ki Ghulam se zyda kuch nahi ho tum aaj tunhare ghatiya comments padke pata lag geye
as a woman, books like Manusmriti was the reason I started feeling ugly about my religion and mentally I was never hindu. This man has turned the definition of hinduism upside down for me. Thank you sir.
manusmriti is just one book and there are things that are not practical and completely absurd but thats the beauty of our beliefs we dont have to follow things we dont agree with manusmriti was used by many people to exploit life of others we must criticize those texts
Read Manusmriti, you will find all different things that you have heard about it. In British times there were many misstranslations & misinterpretations of Manusmriti had been done so we needs to re-examine it. Manusmriti is a good book & there is nothing bad in it what these so called scholars are talking about. There are many bad things about Women & Non believers in holy books of Abrahamic religions but they don't dare to talk about it but propagating false information about Manusmrit.
@@priyankavasist7894 bro, Hinduism includes both monotheism & polytheism. U can be a hindu even if u believe in one god or in 1000 gods. People says there is no murti puja is vedas but this wrong, There is nature worship or murti puja in vedas. U will find some verses in it where it mentions that there is one god but we don't understand it's meaning. Hinduism is the collection of different philosophies & beliefs.
Hindusim is a monotheistic polymorphic multilevel way of life the universal consciousness, which is infinite ...is one , ....u can give that consciousness a thousand names.....this is the idea . So gods r thousand . But the essence is really just one ....
मनुस्मृति पर खुलकर बात होनी चाहिए - agar Kerala story , Kashmiri pandito पर फिल्म बन सकती है तो फिर दलितों पर हुए अत्याचारों को सरकार क्यो छुपाना चाहती है 🧐🧐🤔🤔🤔🤔
All religion, either it is islaam, Christianity, budha, sikh etc are made by divine forces to establish human religion and dharm, but due to kaliyug all are contaminated and conflict created between all religion, the kaliyug not only killed Raja parikshit but also used religion only against the religion, only real dharmik people can understand that all dharma are made for goodness by divine but kaliyug the devil contaminated all of them by bad concept like zihaad, so it's time to inform that we all are dharmik just we are fighting with each other instead of fighting with Adharm kaliyug
Because Hindus are open to criticism, add the fact that Manusmriti isn't even such an important text in Hinduism. Quran is the basis of Islam, on the other hand most Hindus don't even know "Manusmriti"
Manusmriti can't define sanatan padhna hai to Vedas , ramayan and Mahabharata jaise scriptures padho Baki discrimination duniya ke her religious books me h
The hesitation in his words truly depicts "the Freedom of speech and expression" threatened by the extremist ruling party. Thanks Dr. B.R. Ambedkar for leading and building a true foundation for equality. Also thanks to Acharya Prashant for this podcast.
Not sure why hesitation in his words should depict "the Freedom of speech and expression" threatened by the extremist ruling party?? It could simply be him trying to find the right words to answer the question. In any case, your response seems to give lie to the notion of the freedom of speech and expression is being threatened in any way.
@@mayur3127 All religion, either it is islaam, Christianity, budha, sikh etc are made by divine forces to establish human religion and dharm, but due to kaliyug all are contaminated and conflict created between all religion, the kaliyug not only killed Raja parikshit but also used religion only against the religion, only real dharmik people can understand that all dharma are made for goodness by divine but kaliyug the devil contaminated all of them by bad concept like zihaad, so it's time to inform that we all are dharmik just we are fighting with each other instead of fighting with Adharm kaliyug
i honestly feel good that we can openly criticize our literature and improve our thought process fearlessly, that is the only way to move forward. when you dont have that freedom in a belief system, it stops making sense.
Anyone can openly criticize their religion as you can see in Christianity and Buddhism or zudaism....they literally criticize their own religion and scripts....and please don't take name of one religion and i know which one because i don't have any answer for that but you can look at other religions too Except that one
@@一デPhoenixデ一i changed my self but i dont have power or right to force others There are some white people in western countries who doesnt like black people now also You cant change everyone just accept that and live your life
We are sorry for everything that happened/happening to our Dalit brothers/sister in the name of cast. * Consider it as apology from my family/ancestors * We have come a long way since independence, it is diminishing in urban life hope it ends soon in rural life also. * Soon in coming days we will see India without cast biased/atrocities.
@@pravin9524 As a socity where there is no place for cast based atrocities/discrimination , we have come long way and soon we will end it completely. It's just reflection of that.
Dude in 1700/1600 there were discrimination everywhere in this entire planet. It was like this 1800 time. But Hindus are extremely targeted instead of moving on finding the solution we are still stuck in the past
Yes, that was universal. It happened everywhere in the world. Women, kids and marginalised sections suffer not because of religion but because of society. Otherwise why would a culture that worships Saraswati, Durga, Lakshmi and Kali suppress women? It is because of social conditioning
@@naveenkumar9615 i still remember a Shloka from manusmriti which I personally love the most ' yatra naari pujyante tatra ramante devta ' it means God lives there,where women is worshipped
@@naveenkumar9615 आसमुद्रात्तु वै पूर्वादासमुद्रात्तु पश्चिमात् । तयोरेवान्तरं गिर्योरार्यावर्त्त विदुर्बुधाः ।। And this one I forgot the exact translation but It's like 'The region situated between the Himalayas and Vindhyachal from the Eastern Sea to the Western Sea is known by learned men as 'Aryavarta'' and good thing is that it's from manusmriti
Acharya Prashant is actually very right .....this is a fact now whenever politics enters into religion it makes it unpious .....very progressive mind already said ...for a progressive society politics must be kept apart of religion ..!
@@Nope2810 yeah !I'm sure basically sanatan dharma is also a way of life discribed in veds & upnishad ,but today how many of us live up to that ?just because born in certain family does not makes us hindu ....to be a sanatan we must live certain principal ...that what acharaya also says ,also we must not follow any religion or its text blindly ,for example manuscript which was being created just to divide society in certain ways ..which was not originally texted in veds or upnishad ... anyways none of religion teaches inhuman behaviour or violence o.,it's it's certain corrupted followers who manipulate it for their selfish ideology !which is wrong ...!
@@poraon2494 ya...your also right,but i am not saying that we should live like the Sadhus,i only saying that the teachings, how to live a life, etc and the things which are essential to live a life is taught to us by our culture and religion. So following religion will give you peace of mind, spiritual growth and help you in many aspects.
@@poraon2494 All religion, either it is islaam, Christianity, budha, sikh etc are made by divine forces to establish human religion and dharm, but due to kaliyug all are contaminated and conflict created between all religion, the kaliyug not only killed Raja parikshit but also used religion only against the religion, only real dharmik people can understand that all dharma are made for goodness by divine but kaliyug the devil contaminated all of them by bad concept like zihaad, so it's time to inform that we all are dharmik just we are fighting with each other instead of fighting with Adharm kaliyug
" DIDN'T KNOW "===> " DO NOT KNOW " . . .. . " जानते थे " और " जानते हैं "- में अंतर जानते हैं आप ?? ( " DIDN'T KNOW "= " जानते थे " . . . . और . . . . "DO NOT KNOW = " जानते हैं ".
@@webmace sorry yaar my mistake. Ksm sae Hindi medium wala student Raha hu ... Aabhe Mae English seekh Raha hu. Next time sae dhyan Mae rakhunga in mistakes ko.😉
ब्राह्मण जब तक अपनी पुत्री या बहन का विवाह उसी के द्वारा घोषित शुद्र जाति के युवक से नहीं करता तब तक वह घृणा का पात्र है व उससे कोढ़ी मनुष्य जैसा व्यवहार उचित है जैसे पुराने समय में कोढ़ ग्रसित रोगी से होता था ।
As a hindu i don't believe to follow all the scriptures blindly i believe to work on behalf of my heart and that's the hindu soul say don't hurt anybody ❤
@@_nitin__pandit_ okayyyyy so u are saying to follow anything blindly??... don't u kn how things have been manipulated in our scriptures...and what about history that is also manipulated...so a wise man shouldn't trust anything out of logic
For those who say varna was not by birth but by karma etc or believe such lies First question is why is there a need to divide people and restrict flow of knowledge? Will society be harmed or will benefit if every one gained spiritual and military skills or whatever trading skill they like?! It's such a waste of human potential! Still RSS and other right wingers call it scientific and useful!! Here: Well vedas : rigveda gives definition of four varna, yajurveda mentions definition of chandal and nishadha which is proof of birth based varna system and discrimination (Google what it means), mahabharat has many stories about birth based varna system ( check what " sut" in sutputra karna means. Its not sudra like most believe) , Bhagwat Gita is just part of mahabharat so in that context it does believe in birth based discrimination right there. When Krishna says women become impure due to war is because this varna system gets corrupted by women marrying outside of varna system!! He does consider it as corruption of religion! The guna and karma that Krishna uses are past life karma and gunas are assumed according to the which ever varna person was born into ( bhagwatGita 4:13). bhagwat Gita talks about paap yoni ( even women and vaishya are called paap yoni) etc and says one must do work of varna he was born into no matter how bad he was at it, and never do work of other varna no matter how good he is at it, (bhagwatGita 18:47).... If you read 4:13 along with 18:47 this will be crystal clear!! with this context all Gita is actually trying to implement birth based varna system and discrimination out of which caste system originated. In Valmiki krut ramayana Ram is called protector of varna system which is called varna dharm!! So from vedas to mahabharat, ramayana, puranas , all smritis including manusmriti are all talking about birth based discriminatory varna system out of which caste system originated!! So caste discrimination is a religious problem that needs to be addressed. No one wants to do that because whole edifice of religion comes down with it.
सही मायने में सम्मान तो कोई नही करता किसी का भी । वो तो डर है शासन प्रशासन का, सजा का इसलिए मानना पड़ता है सब को।😃 बाकी सम्मान करना है संविधान का तो कोई असंवेधानिक कार्य करो ही मत चाहे कोई देखे ना देखे चाहे आप पकड़ में आए ना आए।
@@sid.7146ये भी सही कहा। न्याय लेने में गरीब और मिडिल क्लास को बहुत चप्पले घिसना पड़ती है समय इतना लगता है कि आदमी को जन न्याय मिलता है वो बूढ़ा होके मर जाता है। न्याय व्यवथा सुधरनी चाइए।
@@sid.7146😂😂 इसीलिए गधे हो आज तक केसेस पेंडिंग संविधान की वजह से नही ipc crpc की वजह कही जा सकती है । कोर्ट में सबसे ज्यादा ब्राह्मण जज हैं । रिक्रूटमेंट बहुत कम होता है । कोर्ट की संख्या बढ़ाई नही जाती ।
विश्वरत्न, बोधिसत्व, परमपूज्य, महामानव डॉ बाबासाहाब आंबेडकर जी जैसे दुनिया के सबसे काबिल, पढ़े-लिखे, ज्ञानी व्यक्ति ने यदि "मनुस्मृति" का दहन किया हैं.... तो ये कोई मामूली बात तो नहीं हो सकती...क्यूँकि वे खुद इतने पुस्तक प्रेमी थे उसके बावजूद भी उन्होने एक पुस्तक "मनुस्मृति" का दहन किया था तो ये बात साफ़ कर देती हैं की वह पुस्तक मानवता के कल्याण के बारे में तो बिलकुल ही नहीं हो सकती यदि मानवता के कल्याण के बारे में उसमें जरा सी भी कोई अच्छी बात होती तो डॉ बाबासाहाब आंबेडकर जी जैसे "कायदा पंडित" ने उसे संविधान में जरूर शामिल किया होता. जो चीज़ संविधान के विरोध की विचारधारा रखती हो वो तो हमेशा से ही controversy में ही रहेगी.
@@jaisanatan3054 में तेरे सवाल का जवाब जरूर देता पर तू आदमी ही नकली हैं तो में kyun तुझे जवाब दू ? तेरा youtube account ही नकली हैं,उसपर तेरा असली फोटो उप्लोडेड नहीं हैं, उसपर तेरा असली नाम लिखा हुआ नहीं हैं. IT cell की रोटी तोड़कर, सिर पर केंद्र में बैठे अपने बापो का आशीर्वाद होने के बावजूद ऐसी नामर्दी जैसे अपनी खुदकी पहचान छुपाकर अगर सवाल पूछोगे तो कैसे चलेगा, be men, be real, be genuine, be what you are ? क्यूँकि नकली नक़ाब पोश दल्ले ही तो हमेशा भगोड़े और चाटु ही कहलवाए जाते हैं.
Manusmriti is totally based on untouchability and vast caste difference. Dr. B R Ambedkar had done very right burning Manusmriti and making new constitution toh give a social equality and a big thing to treat women equal to men.
@HarshitYadav-pk2jb I agree but if something is going wrong infront of your eyes how can you tolerate it? In the same way Dr. B R Ambedkar also toke a stand to save the peoples on which the wrong laws are applied which are mentioned in manusmriti.
@@Myself.282 I also see that some of the teachings and rules in the Quran are wrong, but that doesn't mean I can burn it in public. I am tolerating those things.
@@Myself.282 I agree that manusmriti is qrong but you cant judge hunduism on manusmriti . In vedas , women ate given political power , 50% role in family decision , financial decision and property rights as well as kingdom control
Manusmriti is a "Hindu" Book, If Lord Of The Rings is a "Christian" Book, I mean come on guys, we know the real hindu scriptures are Ramayana, Mahbharat, Vedantas and Upnishads. Ek aadmi batao jo manusmirit pe sogandh leta hai.
अगर मनुस्मृति की कमियों पर प्रकाश डालोगे और उसे कम अहमियत दोगे जो कि उतनी अहमियत देने लायक है भी नहीं फिर भी ,जिन्हें हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों से ही दिक्कत है वो गीता या रामायण को पकड़ लेंगे।🤷🏼♂️🤦♂️ जो कि हम देख ही चुके हैं।😒
@@sk....3049 bro..my ancestor was nishad raj ( friend of Ramji)... that's we use our surname raj...else we are also OBC..but i wanna say that you are brainwashed by someone (these days, manipulating videos are circulating about Many religion with no fact, only conspiracy theory are there).. अगर कोई एकजुट कर रहा है तो उससे आपको क्या दिक्कत है, भूलो मत दुनिया का सबसे पुराना Rleigion सनातन धर्म है, किसी कारण वस कुछ गलत लोगो के हाथो में लग गया जिन्होंने जात पात किया, वरना हमारा Samkhya Darshan नाम का दर्शन पूरे कुरान को हिला के रख देगा, भागवत गीता तो दूर की बात
@@sk....3049 जात पात हर Religion में है जैसे इस्लाम में अहमदिया, बोहरा, शिया, सुन्नी से आधा Middle East disturb रहता है Buddiism में बुराकुमीन बुद्ध को अछूत माना जाता है बात ये है, की कोई अपना लोग Stand ले रहा है की नहीं। सनातन में भी बहुत लोगो ने जाति खत्म करने का जीमा उठाया।
@@trueRationalThinker ganta 😆 ..Islam ya Buddhist kisi book mein shudar acchut nhi likha h aur tumne kuch nhi kra SAMVIDAN JO KI EK SHUDAR NE LIKHA H USNE KRA H
@@nikhildubey294shivji Maharaj ki mout ki baad maratha Empire Brahmin ne continue kia tha peshva bajirao 2 shyad is time pe dalit pe in Brahmin restriction laga dia the dr Ambedkar sab jante the ye sab
This is how the history was changed and will keep changing. Idiots like this acharya speak anything from their mind and people like you think it is true lol. Bharat ka nukshan Mughals se pehle hua hi nahi tha.
BHAI HUMNA APNA DHARAM KA BARE MA KNOWLEDGE HA CAST SYSTEM KUCH NAHI HA VARNA SYSTEM THA PAR TUMHE PATA HA KALIYUG HA JAB BHARAMIN NA GRANTH PADNA CHOD DIYA USS SAMAY SE HI EK SUPERIORITY AA GYI UNME AUR FIR KYA DISCRIMINATION SHURU ZYADA AAG BRITISHERS NA LAGAI... YA THA BHAI ...
kahan padhi manusmriti...jo manusmriti ke baare me tum yeh sab keh rhe ho wo manusmriti angrejo ne banayi hai ..asli manusmriti rishiyon ke saath chale gayi
@@technological-ke3fm tb kyu mirchi lag ri jab manusmriti jalaya ja ra to??? Bhaiya ko manusmriti follow krke casteism bhi Krna h aur kuchh bol do to manusmriti angrezo ne bnae h keh k apne ku karmo se puchha bhi chhudwana h
शूद्रों (जो आज की अनुसूचित जातियां, अनुसूचित कबीले और पिछड़ी श्रेणियां हैं) के विषय में शंकर के विचार इस से भी ज्यादा गए बीते हैं. अपने भाष्य में उन्होंने लिखा है कि शूद्र को न वेद सुनने का अधिकार है और न पढ़ने का, न उस के अर्थ समझने का अधिकार है और न उस के अनुसार अनुष्ठान (यज्ञ आदि) करने का. यदि वह (शूद्र) वेद पढ़ने वालों के पास जा कर उसे (वेद को) सुन ले तो उस के दोनों कानों में सीसा (रांगा) और लाख पिघला कर भर देनी चाहिए. शूद्र चलताफिरता श्मशान होता है, अतः उस के समीप वेद नहीं पढ़ना चाहिए. वेद का उच्चारण करने पर शूद्र की जीभ काट देनी चाहिए और वेद को सुन कर कंठस्थ कर लेने पर उस का शरीर चीर देना चाहिए. शूद्र को ज्ञान नहीं देना चाहिए: अद्वैतवाद वेदश्रवणप्रतिषेधो, वेदाध्ययनप्रतिषेधस्तदर्थज्ञानानुष्ठानयोश्च प्रतिषेधः शूद्रस्य स्मर्यते. श्रवणप्रतिषेधस्तावत् अथास्य वेदमुपशृण्वतस्त्रपुजतुभ्यां श्रोत्रप्रतिपूरणमिति पयु ह वा एतच्छ्मशानं यच्छूद्रस्तस्माच्छूद्रसमीपे नाध्येतव्यमिति च. भवति च वेदोच्चारणे जिह्वाच्छेदो धारणे शरीरभेद इति. न शूद्राय मतिं दद्यात् - ब्रह्मसूत्र 1/3/38 पर शंकरभाष्य. Ye hain tumhare dharm granth ki sacchai 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
चांद से चांदनी लो धब्बे नहीं । वेदांत में बहुत सी बातें लगभग 99.99 प्रतिशत आदमी को सुधारने के लिए, उसे ऊँचा उठाने के लिए कही गई हैं उनको मानों अपवाद को नहीं। आपके सुदंर शरीर में गुदाद्वार भी होता है मुझे उससे क्या करना? आपके ज्ञान से मतलब है। सार सार को गहि रहे थोथा देय उड़ाय। - साहब कबीर।
@@thededro3352 Ved aur Upnishad hi sacred text hai hinduism manusmruti nahi vo bahut baad Mai dala Gaya hala ki mai Manta hu ki manusmriti ko likhne Wale aur usko follow karne wale Hindus kehlame k layak nahi hai.
@@unknownuser5718 par ved aur upnishad me bhi gandagi ki bharmar hai science journey channel dekho. Aur koi bhi sanatani Jo debate ke liye aata khud ko defend bhi nhi kar pata haar maan ke aur accept kar ke jaata hai ke ved aur upnishado me gandagi hai
@@DarkKnight-or1ck He is an Unapologetic Sanatani!.....Hinduism has become a misnomer for Pagan worship,Crores of dieties,and Social evils masquerading as morality(The Latter is done more in Abrahamic cults)...!...
चांद से चांदनी लो धब्बे नहीं । वेदांत में बहुत सी बातें लगभग 99.99 प्रतिशत आदमी को सुधारने के लिए, उसे ऊँचा उठाने के लिए कही गई हैं उनको मानों अपवाद को नहीं। आपके सुदंर शरीर में गुदाद्वार भी होता है मुझे उससे क्या करना? आपके ज्ञान से मतलब है। सार सार को गहि रहे थोथा देय उड़ाय। - साहब कबीर।
After reading manusimitri, I realised it is the most toxic and acidic thoughts I ever read. Only a psychopath, sick mentality person can think like this and write in a book. It should be introduced to psychological literature to find traumatic studies. The writer doesn't leave anything so brutal towards humanity and animals as well.
@@cannibalisticvegitarian. the most inhumane and terror practice I ever come across, that leads to untouchability..The worst aspect of the caste system was untouchability. The untouchable suffered from various social, economic, political and religious disabilities. In the name of religion, they were thoroughly exploited in the most inhuman manner. It doesn't even stops there caste system give birth to Provoke Undemocratic practice, No Vertical Mobility, Encouraged Untouchability that Created a Class of Idlers. Oppression of Low Caste People Encouraged Conversion largely as result to Budhaism, Sikhism, Jainism, Islam, Charistianity and now atheism.. It is Against Integrity of Nation, gives people a False Sense of Superiority and Inferiority.
@@Nitinmishra.6565 if I give you then will you change in your belief system and your mindset ? No 🤣 The things you cannot turn around .. 1. Bhakt 2. Time 3. Truth You have eyes, you only use them to get pleasure not see the reality. You see discrimination around you trillions of times, you never ask yourself why they are like this, why so much discrimination. You see and ignore everyday poor unprivileged child begging and sleeping on the roads, but you are asking for authenticity. There are news for discrimination, crime, rape based on caste and class, you need authenticity. You don't require authenticity, you need to use your eyes 👀..
इन्होंने अपनी सारी जिंदगी हम जैसे छोटे लोगों के लिए त्याग दिया , 10 मिनट का वीडियो देख के इनको समझे गए क्या ? थोड़ा सोच समझ के बोलो जो भी बोल रहे हो । रही बात छुआ छूत की तो मैने अपने नीचे वर्ग में छुआ छूत देखा है ।
One thing we all should remember that Manusmriti is highly interpolated, just like this gentleman said that Women are thought to be as Devi in Manusmriti then again on the same book Women's level is shown below Men's, How two complete opposite thing exists in one book, it's because it was edited later, may be by the same people of India or may be the invaders, who knows? We don't know, We were under the rules of Barbaric Invaders-Islamic and British.
Again Blaming Muslims and Britishers.. Brahmins and all varnas existed even before the advent of Islam..... Always blaming others when you and your own ancestors interpolated and played with the scriptures...
@@jawwadahmad4483 you are saying as if the indoctrination of Hindu scriptures is close to remote during Islamic or british invasion period...if the largest ever library can be burned down by a Mohammedan...then we can speculate what other things people from your community did to the inhabitants of this land...I agree muslims were straight forward.... straight on killings, beheadings and all those stuffs but the british were cunning...they distorted the whole spiritual essence of Bharat...and blaming everything on the Varna system whose fabricated version still rots the mind of people is laughable...nowhere in vedanta it is mentioned that Varna system was based on birth...nowhere ..
Through you Acharya ji I have got to know about how deep & great our Sanatan Dharma is. Thankyou for taking us to Vedant(Upanishads) & Geeta 🙏 Today I am #Vegan for Animals & Minimalist for Environment too.
To all the youngsters, follow Vedanta philosophy and take help from Rani Sivan’s answers on Vedanta to get a perfect nuanced understanding about Hinduism. Casteism has no place in our rich philosophy and nothing apart from Vedanta which is the essence of Hindu dharma and has been summarised in Geeta will give you the true picture of Hindu dharma. PS : Rani Sivan ji was a Jew and then he took up studies of Dharma to explore the divinity in Dharma.
@@hardikgupta9105 or aaj ki conditions me Jo manusmriti ki copy available hai vo 300 sal se jyada purani nhi hai. Jabaki vedo ki 3500 sal purani copy London k British museum me available hai.
The biggest contradiction to manusmriti is Manu rishi himself,he was born Kshatriya and changed his varna to brahmins by acquiring knowledge and wisdom.
@@TenGreats04 tuze itni de sakta hoo... Gaali jiski hadd nahi.. Pata hai... Wohi kitab muze rok rahi hai... Warna... tere samaz nahi Aayega... Hazaro saal se jo dalit pr atyachar ho rha tha naa... Isi kitab ne bachaya hai...
Please also note that Manu smriti or any other ancient text has become adulterated now. So need to be careful reading any such text. Some people thanking BR Ambedkar that he burnt Manu smriti but same guy didn’t dare to burn Bible or Quran. He also said Vedas should be burnt without even knowing even a word of Vedas. Vedas which was not only applauded by Saints and sages but also modern day quantum physicist like Heinsberg, Erwin, Neil Bohr, Oppenheimer, Einstein etc.
Vedas old ved is rigveda but by doing carbon dating its age came as 1400 AD whihc menas its just 600 years old Just this much its very new and we should not learn anything from vedas also you can verify from the unesco website that oldest rugveda in unesco website and then check indias nomination form you will see ASI mentioned that its is just from 1400 AD
@@utkarshsrivastava5576 Bhai kuch bhi woh Jo likha hua hai uski baat kar rahe hai hamare yah saalo Sai ved bol bol kar pass on hue hai generation to generations so pls don't spread misinformation
@@M-Nitin20 bhai I understand ki vedo ko verbally transfer kiyaa gya haj saalon see theek h par ye to inhi books me likha hia naa udka koi proof nahi and one more thing bro at that time even buddhas and there people were writing scriptures and even everywhere all other religion are there they were also writing there literatures pr. Hindu log kyu nhi likh rhe the jab puri duniya likh rhi thi to hm log kyu nhi likh rhe the aur agar aisa thaa mana jata tha ki ved ko likhne se uska essence khatam ho jaegaa to usko likhaa kyu gyaa baad mee. Aur tabhi likhaa kyu gyaaa jab writable language aa gyi thii. Kyunki jo scriptures hai saare vo devnagri me hi hai aur aisaa koi bhi proof nahi mila hai jisse saabit hoo. Ki jo kaahaniya books me likhi hai. Vi sach hai ek aur example deta hu. As per rd lal ASI ke the vo jo india ke ayodhya and other paces ko excavate kiya thaa. Ye saabit krne ke liye vaha pe kuch thaa pahle jaise ayodhya ka pura sheher Par unko ek bhi aise proofs nhi mile jinse saabit ho cha log bhi the kabhi itne bade mehel thee agar vha ayodhya me to kuch to sabut milna chahiye thaa kuch bhi nahi mila aur apni report me submit kiya last me kii. Ayodhya me shayad aaj se 900 saal phle koi rhnaa shuru kiyaa hogaa jis time ki rig veda ki carbon dating hai bhai proofs saaamne hai aap ek baar dekho too.
से निकाल दे। (मनुस्मृति, 10/95) 3. किसी भी आयु का ब्राह्मण पितातुल्य होता है। सौ वर्षों का वृद्ध क्षत्रिय भी 10 वर्ष के बालक ब्राह्मण को पिता बराबर ही समझे। (मनुस्मृति, 2/138) 4. शूद द्वारा अर्जित घन को ब्राह्मण निर्भीक होकर ले सकता है, क्योंकि शुद्र को धन रखने का अधिकार नहीं है। (मनुस्मृति, 8/416) 5. बिल्ली, नेवला, चिड़िया, मेढक, गधा, उल्लू और कौवे की हत्या में जितना पाप लगता है, उतना ही पाप शूद्र (अनुसूचित जाति, जनजाति एवं पिछड़ा वर्ग) की हत्या में है। (मनुस्मृति, 11/131) 6. ब्राह्मण दुश्चरित्र भी पूजनीय है और शूद्र जितेंद्रिय होने पर भी पूज्य नहीं। (पराशर स्मृति, 8/33) 7. जो शूद्र अपने प्राण, धन और स्त्री को ब्राह्मण को अर्पित कर दे, उस शूद्र का भोजन करने योग्य है। (विष्णु-स्मृति, 8/33) 8. चाहे वह खरीदा गया हो अथवा नहीं, लेकिन शूद्रों से सेवा ही करानी चाहिए, क्योंकि शूद्रों की उत्पत्ति ब्रह्मा ने ब्राह्मणों की सेवा के उद्देश्य से ही की है। (मनुस्मृति, 8/412) 9. इन शूद्रों को श्मशान, पहाड़ और उपवनों में ही अपनी जीविका के कर्म 10 करते हुए निवास करना चाहिए। (मनुस्मृति, 10-49) . इन नीची जाति वालों के लिए कफन ही इनका वस्त्र है, फूटे बर्तनों में ये भोजन करें, इनके आभूषण लोहे के हों और वे सर्वदा भ्रमण करते रहें तथा एक स्थान पर बहुत दिनों तक ना रहें। (मनुस्मृति, 10-51) 1. धर्माचरण करने वाला मनुष्य इन नीच जाति बालों के साथ बातचीत न करे तथा उन्हें ना देखे। (मनुस्मृति, 10/52) *. यदि नीची जाति का व्यक्ति ब्राह्मण अथवा गाय के लिए अपने प्राण त्याग दे, तो वह उच्च पद को प्राप्त होता है। (मनुस्मृति, 10/61) यदि किसी कारणवश यज्ञ पूरा ना हो रहा हो तो उसकी पूर्णता के लिए वैश्य के यहाँ से धन ना मिलने पर शूद्र के यहाँ से धन ले सकता है, क्योंकि शूद्र का यज्ञ से कोई संबंध नहीं होता। (मनुस्मृति, 11/13) जिस ब्राह्मण ने शूद्र का वध किया है, उसे छः माह के व्रत तथा एक बैल तथा ग्यारह गायें दूसरे ब्राह्मण को दान में देनी चाहिए। (मनुस्मृति, 11/130; पराशर स्मृति, 6/16) वर्ण-व्यवस्था के जनक और शूद्र / Ye hai manusmriti 😂😂😂 Esliye sb Ko Bolta hu pdhai kro jo pdh na B hai svidhan ko pdho ladkiyo ko tao sb se jyda Bolta hu me ne puri ki puri manusmriti pdh rkhi hai
Manusmruti is probably about societal laws of a kingdom at one point of time. There are so many other smritis as per time . The laws can always be altered, ammended or altogether dumped accordingly to time and place. It is not like Ten commandments written on stone. Laws are always subject to changes as per needs
ये प्रशांत जो है कभी ओशो नही बन सकता है क्योंकि वह खुद हिलता रहता है apne mind ko control nahi kar pata hai apni apni परसिध्धि ke liye bol sahi Raha hai apar iske andar प्रोरवगर vahi hi। Isko ye Shanti nahi aur ma milegi Osho nahi ban paygea 😅😅😅😅😅😅
अरे यही बात तो कब से कह रहे है कि मनुस्मृति को बेवजह हवा दे दी है। किसी के घर में नहीं मिलेगी। किसी ने एक श्लोक भी नहीं पढ़ा होगा। किसी ने आज तक इस्तेमाल भी नहीं की होगी। बस इसके नाम का धुआं उठा रखा है।
Bhai sahab jitne famous slok agar koi manch par tali batorne k liye krte hai wo sb manusmriti me hi diya hua hai Har chiz k do pahlu hai Manusmriti ko totally darkinar nhi kar skte
Manusmriti was written just by some random guy 300 year ago and it does not represents hinduism,ved, vedant,geeta,ramayana , Mahabharata are core and old books of hinduism.(although manusmriti doesn't have any discrimination , misunderstanding is only due to wrong English translation by Max Muller)
भारत में मनुस्मृति को मानने वाले ब्राह्मण बहुत कम मिलेगे पर हाँ भीमटो के लिए ये पवित्र ग्रंथ जरूर हैं क्यू ना हो उनका राशन जो मनुस्मृति के विरोध से ही होता है। हिन्दू तो भूल भी जाए मनुस्मृति पर भीमटे ना भूलने देंगे 😂😂
अगर मनुस्मृति की कमियों पर प्रकाश डालोगे और उसे कम अहमियत दोगे जो कि उतनी अहमियत देने लायक है भी नहीं फिर भी ,जिन्हें हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों से ही दिक्कत है वो गीता या रामायण को पकड़ लेंगे।🤷🏼♂️🤦♂️ जो कि हम देख ही चुके हैं।😒
सच ये है कि अब किताब कोई पढ़कर follow नही करता है बल्कि मानसिकता ही वैसी बन गई है जैसे स्त्री पुरुष से निचले स्तर की होती है, लड़की का जन्म होना पाप है, पत्नी का काम पति की सेवा है, गरीब कमजोर का शोषण करो, ऊंच नीच रखो, जिसकी लाठी उसकी भैंस आदि। इसपर मैंने बहुत अध्धयन किया है कि किस तरह मनुस्मृति और अन्य धंर्मिक ग्रंथो ने हमारे देश की संस्कृति को ही विकृत बना दिया है। ये सबकुछ लोगो के दिमाग मे भीतर तक घुसा दिया है। और ऐसी मानसिकता वाला किसी भी समाज का व्यक्ति हो सकता है ।
kam batao taki logo ko lage ki zyada nahi tha, jabki sach itna zyada discrimination hota tha ki dhang se saas bhi Lena mana tha. jis jagah se sc/st chale toh vahan bura bola jata hai
1. मनुस्मृति अध्याय 4 श्लोक 80, "शुद्र को बुद्धि नही देना चाहिए, न हवन का बचा हुआ भाग और न उसे धर्म का उपदेश दे तथा उसे व्रत का भी उपदेश न दे।" 2. आर्य स्मृति 19 व अग्निस्मृति 191 " यदि शुद्र जप तप होम आदि शुभ कर्म करे तो राजा उस राज्य नाशक शुद्र को कठोर दण्ड दे। 3. वशिष्ठ 18 - 9 शुद्र शमशान के समान अपवित्र है इससे शुद्र के समीप वेद न पढ़े। 4. पराशर स्मृति 8 - 33 ब्राम्हण चाहे दुष्चरित भी हो तो भी पूजनीय है। शुद्र जितेंद्रिय होकर नही। 5. मनुस्मृति 2 - 31 एवं विष्णु स्मृति 27 - 69 " ब्राम्हण का नाम मंगलकारी क्षत्रिय का नाम शक्तिमय वैश्य का नाम धनमय, तथा शुद्र का नाम निंदामय हो। 6. मनुस्मृति 10 - 125 शुद्र से तो सेवा ही कराए चाहे वह खरीद कर आया हो या बिना खरीदे। शुद्र को यदि कोई छुड़ा भी ले तो भी उसे अपने स्वामी को नही छोड़ना चाहिए और उनकी सेवा करनी चाहिए क्योंकि ब्रह्मा ने शुद्र को ब्राम्हणों की दासता करने के लिए ही उत्पन्न किया है। शुद्र को जूठा अन्न पुराने कपड़े, अन्न की पसोदन और पुराना बर्तन भाड़ा देना चाहिए। 7. मनुस्मृति 11 - 13 यदि यज्ञ के दो या तीन अंग अपूर्ण रह जाए तो इनकी सिद्धि के लिए धार्मिक शुद्र का धन बलपूर्वक चोरी से ले आवे। 8. मनुस्मृति 8 - 417 ब्राम्हण को चाहिए कि निर्भय होकर शुद्र का द्रव्य लेवे क्योंकि शुद्र का अपना कुछ नही। 9. मनुस्मृति 8 - 281 यदि शुद्र उच्च जातियों के साथ एक आसन पर बैठने की इच्छा करे तो राजा उसकी कमर दाग कर देश से निकाल दे अथवा उसके चूतड़ कटवा दे। 10.आपस्तंब धर्म सूत्र प्र 2 पटल 10 खंड 27 सूत्र 8,9 शुद्र स्त्री के साथ व्यभिचार करने वाले द्विज पुरुष को देश से निकाल दिया जाय पर जो शुद्र किसी द्विज स्त्री से व्यभिचार करे तो उसे प्राण दंड दिया जाय। 11.आपस्तंब धर्म सूत्र 2- 1/2/8 जिस प्रकार चांडाल को छूना पाप है उसी प्रकार इससे (शुद्र) बोलना और उसे देखने से पाप होता है इसके लिए प्रायश्चित का विधान है। 12. मनुस्मृति 8 - (270-272) शुद्र यदि द्विजाती को लगने वाली बात कहे तो उसकी जीभ काट डाली जाए क्योंकि वह जघन्य स्थान से नीच से उत्पन्न हुआ है। 13. गौतम धर्म सूत्र 12 - 8 - 13 द्विज यदि एक दूसरे को गाली दे तो दंड की विधान है किंतु द्विज किसी शुद्र को गाली दे तो कोई दंड नहीं। 14. मनुस्मृति 11-131 बिल्ली नेवला चिड़िया मेंढक कुत्ता गधा उल्लू और कौवा मार डालने पर जितना पाप होता है उतना ही शुद्र को मार डालने पर होता है। 15. गौतम धर्म सूत्र 12 - 4 व शंकराचार्य का ब्रम्हम सूत्र अध्याय 1 पाठ 3 अधिकरण 9 सूत्र 38। शुद्र यदि वेद को सुन पावे तो उसके कानो में पिघला हुआ शीशा और लाख भरवा देनी चाहिए। यदि वेद का उच्चारण करे तो उसकी जिह्वा कटवा देनी चाहिए। यदि वेद का स्मरण करे तो उसको मरवा डालना चाहिए।
Ave kha arth ka anarth kr rhe ho bhai esa to koi anpadh bhi nhi bolega bo to akhir hm sb k margdarsak the kisi ne apko Galt arth btaya h ..phle log pdhte nhi the lekin ap to padhe likhe ho bhai don't be influenced by adharmis.
@@Prathambharangar123 मैने भी जांचने का प्रयास किया, और मैने श्लोको को भी इसी भाषा में लिखा हुआ पाया, पढ़कर दुख हुआ, मुझे सनातन ज्ञान प्रिय है और मुझे लगता है कि ये नगण्य है क्योंकि मैंने उच्च स्तर की किताबे पढ़ी है, जिसमे यह सब कोई माईने नही रखता। यहां लिखने का अभिप्राय केवल यही है की इस वीडियो में इन्ही किताबो के इन्ही विवादित श्लोको के बारे में बात किया गया है। सभी को जय सतनाम🙏
Sir , let’s take corporate world , is everyone treated with same respect ? What we need to highlight whatever discrimination happened, they are happening all over the world and many times more . Just highlighting manu smriti is foolishness. In any Hindu scriptures there was no discrimination and all they told are duties of varnas. And it was mentioned all 4varnas are needed for society and all are treated with equal respect.
If you go deep inside Hinduism.. You'll realize the manusmriti that we are reading today is not original one... There is concept called " प्रक्षिप्त " Where we can change it's verses (it gives permission to do that) coz manusmriti is not scripture.. It's like constitution..... You'll get to know those things if u go through manusmriti by yourself.... Our's is the most diverse and truthful "धर्म" Among all, everyone should be proud of it.. ☺🚩🇮🇳
Bhaisahab, ager log true Hinduism ko follow krte toh fir itni discrimination kyun horhi hoti Aaj v ?? Your defence on manusmriti will always fail till you don't come up with a proper explanation and remedy of casteism ...
@@2020soumya nobody has proofs who started castism.(1) ... Secondly, what do u think, how many people knows the real meaning of Hinduism, real meaning of dharma..hardly 1-2% people....... Coming to manusmriti.... If you knows, B R ambedkar burns manusmriti, was written in 9 th century AD... But in several upnishad mentioned manusmriti... Think, how can a book written in 9th century quoted/mentioned in scriptures those were written more than 5000 years ago?????? 😁...... Think about that....
@@mayur5138 I don't care what manusmriti or hindu literature tell in real sense, but what matters is why is casteism so prevalent, despite the biggies in religion claim that there is no such thing written. You still aren't able to address the point i raised.. I know you can't ever, nobody can. That's why I am saying, stop this glorification of religion when you, yourself following the same still discriminate people based on caste..aur logically sochein toh mujhe caste discimination nhi krne kliye kisi manusmriti ya hindu literature padhne ki zaroorat nhi hai, yeh toh koi v sensible bnde ko pta hogi...
@@professor__7000contribution of what reserved land resources and use them became established and make other slaves is that your contribution to the humanity
Because they were more intelligent then chamars😂😂chamar loog hi angrezo ke talve chaat te the unko freedom fighter ki mukhbiri karte the dediya tune apne chamar hone ka saboot
@@professor__7000 you contributed in history? Read Manu smruti then come here, sc st were not even allowed to go to school. You are not a proffesor you are a shameless fellow.
I am in the first chapter of manusmriti, so far so good, dont know what I will encounter, but I will definitely inform you after I complete reading the whole book.
Thats a great thing you are reading it directly than taking a said about opinion from anyone else. At first i also thought it to be a primitive book, then i read some opinion of greatest western philosophers like Fredrick Neitschze and Carl Jung, F.N said, " We need to abandon the Bible and adopt the Manav Dharmashastra(Manusmriti) for the western world to progress." C.J said, "Manusmriti is the most liberal produce of Mankind". And i was like, HOLY SHIT, i was completely blown. So i got a translation in Hindi(never a Max Muller version), i am still to start it, but will now, for sure.
Pahle mai kattar Aastik tha fir galti se sab religion ko pad liya science vigyan or baba sahab ko ab Nastik ho gaya hu or dharam k thekedaro ki band bajata hu 👊😁😂
श्री मान जी ने ये बात कही की " खुद को victim कहने में अच्छा लगता है" इस बात पर और विचार करने की आवश्यकता है। कौन इंसान खुद को भेदभाव में मरते रहना पसंद करता है आप ही बताओ कितने लोग होंगे जो खुद को victim कहलवाना पसंद करेंगे
Haan ess baat par vichaar karne ki avyeshakta hai, victim card term suna hai??? Ye vo card hai jo log fek dete hai jab vo badnaam hote hai, ek example ye hai ki kai cases mai ladki ladko se galt behave kar deti hai jab ladka palat k jawab dete hai tho victim card ye nikal k aata hai ki mai ladki hu aur tum mere saath aisa nhi kar skte, theek vaise hi card muslim khelta hai poori duniya mai ki jab vo atankwadi aur jihadi wali harkat krta hai aur jab usko palat k jawab milta hai tho kehta hai hum minority hai hamare saath galt ho rha hai. Usse tarah ka card sc st community khelti aayi hai, aadhe se zyada st sc ko abhi tak reservation k baarein mai nhi pata hai bhai, aisa kyu??? Tumhare neta tumhe hi gawar apnpad banaye rakhna chahe hai taaki unki satta bana rahe aur tum log unko hero maano, vo ye division aur bhedbaav khatam nhi karna chahte agar kar denge tho satta gayab. Bhim rao ambedkar k baad tum logo k liye koi leader aaya hi nhi hai jo tumhare liye kaam kiya ho tumhe aage badhane k liye ulta apna agenda aur propaganda felate hai
We are sorry for everything that happened/happening to our Dalit brothers/sister in the name of cast. * Consider it as apology from my family/ancestors * We have come a long way since independence, it is diminishing in urban life hope it ends soon in rural life also. * Soon in coming days we will see India without cast biased/atrocities.
@Harry A उस समाज को ही अपने आप पर शर्म आना चाहिए जंहा उसी के धर्म का कोई आदमी समाज में अपनी जाति बताने पर शर्माए। आखिर समाज ने ही उसे उसके जाति के लिए शर्मसार किया होगा, इसीलिए वो शर्म कर रहा है। अभी भी समय है, जाति के नाम पर बिखर कर, ऊंच/नीच वाली बाते/कार्य बंद कर एक बन जाओ, मेरे प्यारे साथियों।
@Harry A tujhe lagta hai yeh sab itna asaan hai. Tuh bol raha hai casteism ko khatam kyu nahi kiya, par ise toh jaativadiyon ne hi bacha ke rakha. Apne political gains ke liye. Tuh dil pe haath rakh ke bol, agar tera koi behen ya ristedaar ki koi ladki, lower caste ladke se shaadi karna chahe tu openly support karega? Reservation toh ek dhaal hai. Jinko mandir me ghusne nahi diya jaata, jinke saath baith ke khana nahi khaya jata just because of their caste, kya guarantee hai ki unko kaam se banchit rakha nahi jayega unke identity ke karan. Kindly if you can answer my questions. ☮️
अगर मनुस्मृति की कमियों पर प्रकाश डालोगे और उसे कम अहमियत दोगे जो कि उतनी अहमियत देने लायक है भी नहीं फिर भी ,जिन्हें हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों से ही दिक्कत है वो गीता या रामायण को पकड़ लेंगे।🤷🏼♂️🤦♂️ जो कि हम देख ही चुके हैं।😒
पूरा Podcast यहाँ देखें:
ua-cam.com/video/C7c1_UEgbbc/v-deo.html
Please bring J Sai Deepak on your podcast
आचार्य है या अचार है इनको यह तक नहीं पता कि मनुस्मृति को महाभारत काल मे युधिष्ठिर ने न्याय के रूप में मनुस्मृति को स्तंभ मानकर न्याय किया था। जहां दंड के परिणाम का ज्ञात होने के बाद भी दंड करना, और जिसे ज्ञान ना हो या अल्प ज्ञान होना पर अलग-अलग दंड की व्याख्या करती है मनुस्मृति जोकि व्यक्तियों के वर्ण के हिसाब सुनाई जाती है।
यह तो पोंगा पंडित है इससे आचार्य को कुछ नहीं पता bs दुकान चल रही है और कितनी बड़ी दुकान कर लेगा इसको इसकी चिंता है बस
अगर मनुस्मृति की कमियों पर प्रकाश डालोगे और उसे कम अहमियत दोगे जो कि उतनी अहमियत देने लायक है भी नहीं फिर भी ,जिन्हें हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों से ही दिक्कत है वो गीता या रामायण को पकड़ लेंगे।🤷🏼♂️🤦♂️ जो कि हम देख ही चुके हैं।😂
read vishudh manusmriti
@@ashishkushwaha1 ye sala nashedi. H
धन्यवाद बाबा भीम राव आंबेडकर जी का जिन्होंने हमें जीने का हक दिलवाया ! जय भीम ♥
@@rozzz3056 log kese krlete hai itni chutiya baatein 😂
@@rozzz3056 Binaa congress ka baba saheb savidhaan nhi baana paata jisma ke jaada tar usma pandit he tha .
@@rozzz3056 jab ramu kaka mar kr chle gye to, insaan ki kya aukat... Mandbuddhi log modi ji ko bhi sher bolne pr unhe janwar smjh lenge..
उसी ओरिजिनल संविधान के प्रथम पृष्ठ पर भगवान राम की चित्र भी बाबासाहेब अम्बेडकर ने लगाई है
What's your insta id ?
मनुस्मृति से आजादी दिलाने के लिए बाबा साहेब को धनयवाद🎉🎉
But manusmriti was never used for governance, then how you got independence from it?
@@ahumanwithcommonsense to fir caste system kha se aya? Bol do ye bhi muslim and anrezo ki den b
@@princerajput3864
Common Sense Ki Baat Hain.
श्लोक: चातुर्वर्ण्यं मया सृष्टं गुणकर्मविभागशः।
तस्य कर्तारमपि मां विद्ध्यकर्तारमव्ययम्।।4.13।।
Hindi: BG 4.13: मनुष्यों के गुणों और कर्मों के अनुसार मेरे द्वारा चार वर्णों की रचना की गयी है। यद्यपि मैं इस व्यवस्था का सृष्टा हूँ किन्तु तुम मुझे अकर्ता और अविनाशी मानो।
@@princerajput3864
ये जीतना भी भेद भाव हैं।
वो सब पावरफुल लोगों के स्वार्थ के कारण हैं।
और ये सब आज भी चल रहा हैं, अमीर लाख क्राइम के बाद भी
बेल पर बाहर और गरीब छोटे जुर्म पर जेल में सड़ रहा हैं।
@@princerajput3864 caste system dimag ka upach hain
तभी Dr आंबेडकर ने मनुस्मृति जलाई थी
Woh Manu wali manusmriti nhi thi lmde
@@piyushdevnath293 yes bro ...that was Translated by Maxmuller 👍
Sabse behtar kaam Kiya tha unhone
@@84s_h_a_r_a_d19 hum b ambedkar ka poster jlayegey
how stupid of him
@@Mashroom423 unki photo hi jaka sakte ho unki jaise kam ti tum jaise dhram ki tekhdar kabhi kar nahi sakte bas dhram ki harakhori kar skte ho aur stupid to tum jaise log hote ho jo ek maa ki kala katne vala ko bhagvan aur samaj mai kuch karne vale lo disrespect karnia tum jaise ghatiya log ki adat hoti hai dhramik kitab ki Ghulam se zyda kuch nahi ho tum aaj tunhare ghatiya comments padke pata lag geye
Himmat chahiye galat ko galat bolne ke liye... #respect for u 💯
हिन्दू तो बोलता आया है, इतिहास पढ़ लेना, परमहंस/विवेकानंद/सावरकर/अम्बेडकर/राममोहन और पता नही कितनो ने!
बिल्कुल साफ बात , कोई घुमाव नहीं ।
धन्यवाद् 🙏
भाई मेरे बिल्कुल भी साफ बात नहीं कही एकदम कंपलीटली घुमाव है
@@KrishnaKumar-p2x9lAccha unse Jayda gyaani ho kya . You know who is he? .. jao vha Jake Acharya ji se debate kro itne budhimaan ho to.
as a woman, books like Manusmriti was the reason I started feeling ugly about my religion and mentally I was never hindu. This man has turned the definition of hinduism upside down for me. Thank you sir.
manusmriti is just one book and there are things that are not practical and completely absurd but thats the beauty of our beliefs we dont have to follow things we dont agree with manusmriti was used by many people to exploit life of others we must criticize those texts
Read Manusmriti, you will find all different things that you have heard about it.
In British times there were many misstranslations & misinterpretations of Manusmriti had been done so we needs to re-examine it.
Manusmriti is a good book & there is nothing bad in it what these so called scholars are talking about.
There are many bad things about Women & Non believers in holy books of Abrahamic religions but they don't dare to talk about it but propagating false information about Manusmrit.
@@priyankavasist7894 bro, Hinduism includes both monotheism & polytheism.
U can be a hindu even if u believe in one god or in 1000 gods.
People says there is no murti puja is vedas but this wrong, There is nature worship or murti puja in vedas.
U will find some verses in it where it mentions that there is one god but we don't understand it's meaning.
Hinduism is the collection of different philosophies & beliefs.
Hindusim is a monotheistic polymorphic multilevel way of life
the universal consciousness, which is infinite ...is one , ....u can give that consciousness a thousand names.....this is the idea .
So gods r thousand . But the essence is really just one ....
Yatra Narayastu Pujyante Ramante Tatra Devta
Where Women are honoured, divinity blossoms
A shlok from Manusmriti
हर साल मनुस्मृतिदहन होना चाहिये, सभी महिलांए, SC, ST & OBC के मूक्ती का राष्ट्रीय तौहार है l📖🔥
मनुस्मृति पर खुलकर बात होनी चाहिए - agar Kerala story , Kashmiri pandito पर फिल्म बन सकती है तो फिर दलितों पर हुए अत्याचारों को सरकार क्यो छुपाना चाहती है 🧐🧐🤔🤔🤔🤔
Absolutely
Vaise bani to hai Jai bheem. One of the best movies about the Justice system.
@@abhishekdalvi1276 yes
और कुराण पे बात होनी चाहिये या नही
@@anirudhakutre4920Quran pe baat karni h to ajao mufti Yasir Nadeem ki stream par
Manusmriti is criticized infinite times more than Kuran. And we all know how much criticism the latter deserves
All religion, either it is islaam, Christianity, budha, sikh etc are made by divine forces to establish human religion and dharm, but due to kaliyug all are contaminated and conflict created between all religion, the kaliyug not only killed Raja parikshit but also used religion only against the religion, only real dharmik people can understand that all dharma are made for goodness by divine but kaliyug the devil contaminated all of them by bad concept like zihaad, so it's time to inform that we all are dharmik just we are fighting with each other instead of fighting with Adharm kaliyug
@@rahulprakaash3350 all religions are terrible. All blind belief is chaotic
@harrya3979 exactly brother, he is taking something 😆🤣
@@rahulprakaash3350
Tu hilake so jaaa Bhai.
Because Hindus are open to criticism, add the fact that Manusmriti isn't even such an important text in Hinduism. Quran is the basis of Islam, on the other hand most Hindus don't even know "Manusmriti"
Manusmriti has listed DISCRIMINATIONS on WOMEN & LOWER CASTE. 😡
Quran
Shlok do
What about quraan
Manusmriti can't define sanatan padhna hai to Vedas , ramayan and Mahabharata jaise scriptures padho
Baki discrimination duniya ke her religious books me h
Veda is full of science , nature, dharm😊😊
B.R Ambedkar ji was a true person....
The hesitation in his words truly depicts "the Freedom of speech and expression" threatened by the extremist ruling party. Thanks Dr. B.R. Ambedkar for leading and building a true foundation for equality. Also thanks to Acharya Prashant for this podcast.
Not sure why hesitation in his words should depict "the Freedom of speech and expression" threatened by the extremist ruling party?? It could simply be him trying to find the right words to answer the question. In any case, your response seems to give lie to the notion of the freedom of speech and expression is being threatened in any way.
Rightly, u r a child..jise non stop bina soche smjhe bolna freedom of speech lgta h..moonchild😂
@@sdasgupta1950right words dhundhna aur gale mein haddi fas jane mein antar hota hai na dost
😂😂
Sach ko sach bolne ki himmat hindu karta hai aksar
Yup
Isiliye zada tar hindu ye batane pe lage hai ki jati vyavastha angrezo ne layi or aurto ki jaga boht upar thi 😂😂😂
Agar pata ho to like Acharya Prashant
@@mayur3127 chup... Libranduo law#a
@@mayur3127 All religion, either it is islaam, Christianity, budha, sikh etc are made by divine forces to establish human religion and dharm, but due to kaliyug all are contaminated and conflict created between all religion, the kaliyug not only killed Raja parikshit but also used religion only against the religion, only real dharmik people can understand that all dharma are made for goodness by divine but kaliyug the devil contaminated all of them by bad concept like zihaad, so it's time to inform that we all are dharmik just we are fighting with each other instead of fighting with Adharm kaliyug
i honestly feel good that we can openly criticize our literature and improve our thought process fearlessly, that is the only way to move forward. when you dont have that freedom in a belief system, it stops making sense.
मैं आपकी बातों से पूरा समर्थन करता हूं सत्य वचन।
Anyone can openly criticize their religion as you can see in Christianity and Buddhism or zudaism....they literally criticize their own religion and scripts....and please don't take name of one religion and i know which one because i don't have any answer for that but you can look at other religions too Except that one
You can only criticize but cannot change
Athism
@@一デPhoenixデ一i changed my self but i dont have power or right to force others
There are some white people in western countries who doesnt like black people now also
You cant change everyone just accept that and live your life
We Hindu needs to admit that there was and are injustice at some point of time towards lower caste amd women.
We are sorry for everything that happened/happening to our Dalit brothers/sister in the name of cast.
*
Consider it as apology from my family/ancestors
*
We have come a long way since independence, it is diminishing in urban life hope it ends soon in rural life also.
*
Soon in coming days we will see India without cast biased/atrocities.
@@Agyani786 The most positive comment I have ever received
@@pravin9524 As a socity where there is no place for cast based atrocities/discrimination , we have come long way and soon we will end it completely.
It's just reflection of that.
Dude in 1700/1600 there were discrimination everywhere in this entire planet. It was like this 1800 time. But Hindus are extremely targeted instead of moving on finding the solution we are still stuck in the past
Yes, that was universal. It happened everywhere in the world. Women, kids and marginalised sections suffer not because of religion but because of society. Otherwise why would a culture that worships Saraswati, Durga, Lakshmi and Kali suppress women? It is because of social conditioning
galat ko galat bolne ke liye bhi himmat chahiye
Today i got confirmation while listening to acharya ji.. Manipulated version of Manusmriti need to be avoided strictly to save india.. 🙏🏻
Have u ever read Manusmriti. Avoid speech of this joker who smokes while in foreign and calls him saint .
Nahi Karna Avoid Kuchh V
@@naveenkumar9615 I was talking About the pure one obviously
@@naveenkumar9615 i still remember a Shloka from manusmriti which I personally love the most ' yatra naari pujyante tatra ramante devta ' it means God lives there,where women is worshipped
@@naveenkumar9615 आसमुद्रात्तु वै पूर्वादासमुद्रात्तु पश्चिमात् । तयोरेवान्तरं गिर्योरार्यावर्त्त विदुर्बुधाः ।। And this one I forgot the exact translation but It's like 'The region situated between the Himalayas and Vindhyachal from the Eastern Sea to the Western Sea is known by learned men as 'Aryavarta'' and good thing is that it's from manusmriti
Acharya Prashant is actually very right .....this is a fact now whenever politics enters into religion it makes it unpious .....very progressive mind already said ...for a progressive society politics must be kept apart of religion ..!
Bro religion only guides us to right path. Don't forget this, even if you disagree with it ,but it's the facts and the truth
@@Nope2810 yeah !I'm sure basically sanatan dharma is also a way of life discribed in veds & upnishad ,but today how many of us live up to that ?just because born in certain family does not makes us hindu ....to be a sanatan we must live certain principal ...that what acharaya also says ,also we must not follow any religion or its text blindly ,for example manuscript which was being created just to divide society in certain ways ..which was not originally texted in veds or upnishad ... anyways none of religion teaches inhuman behaviour or violence o.,it's it's certain corrupted followers who manipulate it for their selfish ideology !which is wrong ...!
@@poraon2494 ya...your also right,but i am not saying that we should live like the Sadhus,i only saying that the teachings, how to live a life, etc and the things which are essential to live a life is taught to us by our culture and religion. So following religion will give you peace of mind, spiritual growth and help you in many aspects.
@@poraon2494 All religion, either it is islaam, Christianity, budha, sikh etc are made by divine forces to establish human religion and dharm, but due to kaliyug all are contaminated and conflict created between all religion, the kaliyug not only killed Raja parikshit but also used religion only against the religion, only real dharmik people can understand that all dharma are made for goodness by divine but kaliyug the devil contaminated all of them by bad concept like zihaad, so it's time to inform that we all are dharmik just we are fighting with each other instead of fighting with Adharm kaliyug
@@Nope2810 not religion only Dharma and core value rest are bullshit like manusmriti
It's totally true and sad reality that in today's modern era people do not know the difference between caste/ vernas or profession.
Rigveda period Tak varnas ka karm ka aadhar pa hota tha but later Vedic ma wahi caste ban gya
" DIDN'T KNOW "===> " DO NOT KNOW " . . .. . " जानते थे " और " जानते हैं "- में अंतर जानते हैं आप ??
( " DIDN'T KNOW "= " जानते थे " . . . . और . . . . "DO NOT KNOW = " जानते हैं ".
@@webmace sorry yaar my mistake.
Ksm sae Hindi medium wala student Raha hu ... Aabhe Mae English seekh Raha hu.
Next time sae dhyan Mae rakhunga in mistakes ko.😉
@@rishijha2610 B.O.L.
ब्राह्मण जब तक अपनी पुत्री या बहन का विवाह उसी के द्वारा घोषित शुद्र जाति के युवक से नहीं करता तब तक वह घृणा का पात्र है व उससे कोढ़ी मनुष्य जैसा व्यवहार उचित है जैसे पुराने समय में कोढ़ ग्रसित रोगी से होता था ।
मनुस्मृति गलत ही है .... #जयभीम
gay bheem
Hame to job mil jayegi bcoz of bhim , Kangi stand becho bikhari 😂 @@SHOBHATIWARITHECREATOR
Landram@@SHOBHATIWARITHECREATOR
आचार्य जी सादर प्रणाम आपको हर झूठ से सदेंह से पर्दा उठा दिया आपने सादर प्रणाम आपको
Thanks to B. R. Ambedkar Sir
Why, where is other 299 people 😂
@@roshan_gupta30 299 ???
Abe pr dalito ke liye dr Ambedkar ne hi na kiya tha@@roshan_gupta30
@@roshan_gupta30anpadh aa gaya. Ek ne hi hila dala tum jaise crore ko 🤣
@@varun9373Ek manu tum arbo Chamaro ko aukaad dikhadi thi 😂
As a hindu i don't believe to follow all the scriptures blindly i believe to work on behalf of my heart and that's the hindu soul say don't hurt anybody ❤
ha bhai q ki tum un rishiyon aur apne sabhi purvajon se jada buddhiman ho
@bishnoi10 - please bhai don't read and don't follow any book of Hindu culture, but please follow Quran & Bible.
@@vineetrodge4099 quran yeh whi book h naa jo atankwadi padhte h...aurat ko sex slave smjhta h
@@vineetrodge4099 I'll rather like to be an atheist
@@_nitin__pandit_ okayyyyy so u are saying to follow anything blindly??... don't u kn how things have been manipulated in our scriptures...and what about history that is also manipulated...so a wise man shouldn't trust anything out of logic
मनुस्मिर्ति का नाम राजनितिक कारणों से ज्यादा हि उछाला जाता है। हज़ारो किताबे है पर उसी किताब का नाम लिया जाता है।
इसके अलावा कुछ आता ही नही है 😂😂😂😂 इनको
@pradeepkalkee9541varn system tumhare grath mai hai samjha cow worshipper
Koi rajneeti nahi ye kitab is desh mai kuch varg ki log ki liya banai gai thi jo iski pairavi karte hai
Quran pr bhi charchaa honi chaiye
For those who say varna was not by birth but by karma etc or believe such lies
First question is why is there a need to divide people and restrict flow of knowledge? Will society be harmed or will benefit if every one gained spiritual
and military skills or whatever trading skill they like?!
It's such a waste of human potential! Still RSS and other right wingers call it scientific and useful!!
Here:
Well vedas : rigveda gives definition of four varna, yajurveda mentions definition of chandal and nishadha which is proof of birth based varna system and discrimination (Google what it means),
mahabharat has many stories about birth based varna system ( check what " sut" in sutputra karna means. Its not sudra like most believe) ,
Bhagwat Gita is just part of mahabharat so in that context it does believe in birth based discrimination right there.
When Krishna says women become impure due to war is because this varna system gets corrupted by women marrying outside of varna system!! He does consider it as corruption of religion!
The guna and karma that Krishna uses are past life karma and gunas are assumed according to the which ever varna person was born into ( bhagwatGita 4:13).
bhagwat Gita talks about paap yoni ( even women and vaishya are called paap yoni) etc and says one must do work of varna he was born into no matter how bad he was at it, and never do work of other varna no matter how good he is at it, (bhagwatGita 18:47)....
If you read 4:13 along with 18:47 this will be crystal clear!!
with this context all Gita is actually trying to implement birth based varna system and discrimination out of which caste system originated.
In Valmiki krut ramayana Ram is called protector of varna system which is called varna dharm!!
So from vedas to mahabharat, ramayana, puranas , all smritis including manusmriti are all talking about birth based discriminatory varna system out of which caste system originated!!
So caste discrimination is a religious problem that needs to be addressed. No one wants to do that because whole edifice of religion comes down with it.
इस समय भारत का संविधान इसकी सबसे बड़ी स्मृति है उसका सबको सम्मान करना चाहिए
6 crore cases pending hai. Justice mile ne mai 20 50 saal lag rahe hai. 10 bis 20 churaye tho jail 1000 crore chrali ye tha bail
सही मायने में सम्मान तो कोई नही करता किसी का भी । वो तो डर है शासन प्रशासन का, सजा का इसलिए मानना पड़ता है सब को।😃
बाकी सम्मान करना है संविधान का तो कोई असंवेधानिक कार्य करो ही मत चाहे कोई देखे ना देखे चाहे आप पकड़ में आए ना आए।
@@sid.7146ये भी सही कहा। न्याय लेने में गरीब और मिडिल क्लास को बहुत चप्पले घिसना पड़ती है समय इतना लगता है कि आदमी को जन न्याय मिलता है वो बूढ़ा होके मर जाता है। न्याय व्यवथा सुधरनी चाइए।
@@sid.7146😂😂 इसीलिए गधे हो आज तक
केसेस पेंडिंग संविधान की वजह से नही ipc crpc की वजह कही जा सकती है ।
कोर्ट में सबसे ज्यादा ब्राह्मण जज हैं
।
रिक्रूटमेंट बहुत कम होता है ।
कोर्ट की संख्या बढ़ाई नही जाती ।
@@sid.7146Bilkul esliye judge ko hatane ki jarurat hai brahmnao ne desh ko barbad kr diya hai
Big thanks to TRS and Ranveer for bringing this topic. i searched everywhere about manusamriti finally i found something here.
read vishudh manusmriti
पाहन पूजे हरि मिले , तो मैं पूजूं पहार
याते चाकी भली जो पीस खाए संसार। ।
विश्वरत्न, बोधिसत्व, परमपूज्य, महामानव डॉ बाबासाहाब आंबेडकर जी जैसे दुनिया के सबसे काबिल, पढ़े-लिखे, ज्ञानी व्यक्ति ने यदि "मनुस्मृति" का दहन किया हैं.... तो ये कोई मामूली बात तो नहीं हो सकती...क्यूँकि वे खुद इतने पुस्तक प्रेमी थे उसके बावजूद भी उन्होने एक पुस्तक "मनुस्मृति" का दहन किया था तो ये बात साफ़ कर देती हैं की वह पुस्तक मानवता के कल्याण के बारे में तो बिलकुल ही नहीं हो सकती यदि मानवता के कल्याण के बारे में उसमें जरा सी भी कोई अच्छी बात होती तो डॉ बाबासाहाब आंबेडकर जी जैसे "कायदा पंडित" ने उसे संविधान में जरूर शामिल किया होता. जो चीज़ संविधान के विरोध की विचारधारा रखती हो वो तो हमेशा से ही controversy में ही रहेगी.
अम्बेडकर साहब को संस्कृत आती थी?
@@jaisanatan3054 wo techer ko Sanskrit me baat karte the
@@abwcreater5704 कौन टीचर?
@@jaisanatan3054 ambedkar saheb ke teacher
@@jaisanatan3054 में तेरे सवाल का जवाब जरूर देता पर तू आदमी ही नकली हैं तो में kyun तुझे जवाब दू ? तेरा youtube account ही नकली हैं,उसपर तेरा असली फोटो उप्लोडेड नहीं हैं, उसपर तेरा असली नाम लिखा हुआ नहीं हैं. IT cell की रोटी तोड़कर, सिर पर केंद्र में बैठे अपने बापो का आशीर्वाद होने के बावजूद ऐसी नामर्दी जैसे अपनी खुदकी पहचान छुपाकर अगर सवाल पूछोगे तो कैसे चलेगा, be men, be real, be genuine, be what you are ? क्यूँकि नकली नक़ाब पोश दल्ले ही तो हमेशा भगोड़े और चाटु ही कहलवाए जाते हैं.
Manusmriti is totally based on untouchability and vast caste difference. Dr. B R Ambedkar had done very right burning Manusmriti and making new constitution toh give a social equality and a big thing to treat women equal to men.
How can he burn other's religion books . He has no right to do so
@HarshitYadav-pk2jb I agree but if something is going wrong infront of your eyes how can you tolerate it?
In the same way Dr. B R Ambedkar also toke a stand to save the peoples on which the wrong laws are applied which are mentioned in manusmriti.
@@Myself.282 I also see that some of the teachings and rules in the Quran are wrong, but that doesn't mean I can burn it in public. I am tolerating those things.
@@Myself.282 I agree that manusmriti is qrong but you cant judge hunduism on manusmriti . In vedas , women ate given political power , 50% role in family decision , financial decision and property rights as well as kingdom control
Manusmriti is a "Hindu" Book, If Lord Of The Rings is a "Christian" Book,
I mean come on guys, we know the real hindu scriptures are Ramayana, Mahbharat, Vedantas and Upnishads.
Ek aadmi batao jo manusmirit pe sogandh leta hai.
Propaganda bhai ignorant Hindus ko convert krne ka.
Savage bro💀💀
True ek choti si baat inko samjh na aati hai saale manusmriti jalane se saari books khatam thodi hogi 😂
True afterall yeh sabhi fiction hi h... Lmao
अगर मनुस्मृति की कमियों पर प्रकाश डालोगे और उसे कम अहमियत दोगे जो कि उतनी अहमियत देने लायक है भी नहीं फिर भी ,जिन्हें हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों से ही दिक्कत है वो गीता या रामायण को पकड़ लेंगे।🤷🏼♂️🤦♂️ जो कि हम देख ही चुके हैं।😒
लोग कह रहे कि वर्ण व्यवस्था में कर्म आधार था, लेकिन सवाल ये है कि जरूरत ही क्या था वर्ण में विभाजित करना। बीमारी तो वही से पैदा हुई है।
Happy manusmriti dahan diwas
Thanks Dr.B.R.Ambedkar ✨🙇💙🙏
Thanks to Dr, B.R ambedkar for converting varna system into caste system.
Thanks to baba saheb for giving reservation to sc st people@@iamgar6age
@@HimanshuPawar-pf9mm thanks baba saheb for first spitting on face then wiping with tissue paper.
Kuch nehi kia usne ❤
@@iamgar6age accha hua tum jaatiwadiyo ke saath
ye isss thinking ki wajse mai acharya ji ko bhot follow karta hu... ❤
I salute Acharya Tripathi for his honesty.
Lol ..he rejected his surname publicly...
@@trueRationalThinker krna prega Bhai Saab kynki brahmanical dhong log samjh chuke h ...
@@sk....3049 bro..my ancestor was nishad raj ( friend of Ramji)... that's we use our surname raj...else we are also OBC..but i wanna say that you are brainwashed by someone (these days, manipulating videos are circulating about Many religion with no fact, only conspiracy theory are there)..
अगर कोई एकजुट कर रहा है तो उससे आपको क्या दिक्कत है, भूलो मत दुनिया का सबसे पुराना Rleigion सनातन धर्म है,
किसी कारण वस कुछ गलत लोगो के हाथो में लग गया जिन्होंने जात पात किया, वरना हमारा Samkhya Darshan नाम का दर्शन पूरे कुरान को हिला के रख देगा, भागवत गीता तो दूर की बात
@@sk....3049 जात पात हर Religion में है जैसे इस्लाम में अहमदिया, बोहरा, शिया, सुन्नी से आधा Middle East disturb रहता है
Buddiism में बुराकुमीन बुद्ध को अछूत माना जाता है
बात ये है, की कोई अपना लोग Stand ले रहा है की नहीं। सनातन में भी बहुत लोगो ने जाति खत्म करने का जीमा उठाया।
@@trueRationalThinker ganta 😆 ..Islam ya Buddhist kisi book mein shudar acchut nhi likha h aur tumne kuch nhi kra SAMVIDAN JO KI EK SHUDAR NE LIKHA H USNE KRA H
बाबा जी खुल के बोलो डरो नहीं...जो सही है वो सही है और जो गलत है वो हमेशा गलत है। ऐसे गंदे किताबो का जिक्र भी नही करना नही चाहिए जो भेदभाव सिखाएं।।
Ye baba bs add Dene ka kam krta hai nakli baba hai ye
He is not a baba.sachai bola inka kaam h.geeta vedant ki bharat m dobaara lane ka kaam Kar Rahe h
Baba nahi hai o unke aur video dekho aap ko pata chal jayaga
Munna reservation lekr bhi tu itne exam nhi nikal payega jitna unhone waise hi nikal diye hai samjha
Baba g ko app bataoge ki kya bolna hai kya nhi
The only Book in The entire world is " Shrimadh Bhagwata Gita "
😊😊
पेशवाई राज्य मे मनुस्मृति का ही कायदा चालता था।।।शुद्र ओर दलित का शोषण करते थे।।।
Absolute right sister 🤝
Peshvai kab chala tha
@@nikhildubey294shivji Maharaj ki mout ki baad maratha Empire Brahmin ne continue kia tha peshva bajirao 2 shyad is time pe dalit pe in Brahmin restriction laga dia the dr Ambedkar sab jante the ye sab
This is how the history was changed and will keep changing. Idiots like this acharya speak anything from their mind and people like you think it is true lol. Bharat ka nukshan Mughals se pehle hua hi nahi tha.
Angrez bhi manusmriti se shasan chala rha tha😂😂😂😂😂
आखरी का स्टेटमेंट मनुस्मृति इस काल में कोई काम की नही है इस काल में समानता,बंधुता और न्याय सिर्फ संविधान दे सकता है।
Kaha de raha hai 😂😂😂
Jai Bheem 💙 and Love you to those people those have thoughts to not differentiate humans on the basis of their caste ❤
jai chota bheem
@@spreaderofhatredso you are a casteist?
@@bhumijarishi1875 yep, a strong one too.
Jay bhim 🙏🏻🌷💙
BHAI HUMNA APNA DHARAM KA BARE MA KNOWLEDGE HA CAST SYSTEM KUCH NAHI HA VARNA SYSTEM THA PAR TUMHE PATA HA KALIYUG HA JAB BHARAMIN NA GRANTH PADNA CHOD DIYA USS SAMAY SE HI EK SUPERIORITY AA GYI UNME AUR FIR KYA DISCRIMINATION SHURU ZYADA AAG BRITISHERS NA LAGAI... YA THA BHAI ...
He is speaking fearful 60 %
I was expecting Acharya Prashant to be honest on Manusmruti.
In one sentence Manusmriti is very biased😊
Specific for particular community, hope everyone understand
Hope you get some knowledge
@@gksquad2024 you need to watch the video again and then connect to my comment, you will find the same
kahan padhi manusmriti...jo manusmriti ke baare me tum yeh sab keh rhe ho wo manusmriti angrejo ne banayi hai ..asli manusmriti rishiyon ke saath chale gayi
@@technological-ke3fm tb kyu mirchi lag ri jab manusmriti jalaya ja ra to??? Bhaiya ko manusmriti follow krke casteism bhi Krna h aur kuchh bol do to manusmriti angrezo ne bnae h keh k apne ku karmo se puchha bhi chhudwana h
@@technological-ke3fmkaha gayi bhai 😂...use dundho,mujhe sapne me Nazar aati hai 😆
शूद्रों (जो आज की अनुसूचित जातियां, अनुसूचित कबीले और पिछड़ी श्रेणियां हैं) के विषय में शंकर के विचार इस से भी ज्यादा गए बीते हैं. अपने भाष्य में उन्होंने लिखा है कि शूद्र को न वेद सुनने का अधिकार है और न पढ़ने का, न उस के अर्थ समझने का अधिकार है और न उस के अनुसार अनुष्ठान (यज्ञ आदि) करने का. यदि वह (शूद्र) वेद पढ़ने वालों के पास जा कर उसे (वेद को) सुन ले तो उस के दोनों कानों में सीसा (रांगा) और लाख पिघला कर भर देनी चाहिए. शूद्र चलताफिरता श्मशान होता है, अतः उस के समीप वेद नहीं पढ़ना चाहिए. वेद का उच्चारण करने पर शूद्र की जीभ काट देनी चाहिए और वेद को सुन कर कंठस्थ कर लेने पर उस का शरीर चीर देना चाहिए. शूद्र को ज्ञान नहीं देना चाहिए:
अद्वैतवाद
वेदश्रवणप्रतिषेधो, वेदाध्ययनप्रतिषेधस्तदर्थज्ञानानुष्ठानयोश्च प्रतिषेधः शूद्रस्य स्मर्यते. श्रवणप्रतिषेधस्तावत् अथास्य वेदमुपशृण्वतस्त्रपुजतुभ्यां श्रोत्रप्रतिपूरणमिति पयु ह वा एतच्छ्मशानं यच्छूद्रस्तस्माच्छूद्रसमीपे नाध्येतव्यमिति च. भवति च वेदोच्चारणे जिह्वाच्छेदो धारणे शरीरभेद इति. न शूद्राय मतिं दद्यात् - ब्रह्मसूत्र 1/3/38 पर शंकरभाष्य. Ye hain tumhare dharm granth ki sacchai 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
चांद से चांदनी लो धब्बे नहीं । वेदांत में बहुत सी बातें लगभग 99.99 प्रतिशत आदमी को सुधारने के लिए, उसे ऊँचा उठाने के लिए कही गई हैं उनको मानों अपवाद को नहीं।
आपके सुदंर शरीर में गुदाद्वार भी होता है मुझे उससे क्या करना? आपके ज्ञान से मतलब है।
सार सार को गहि रहे थोथा देय उड़ाय। - साहब कबीर।
NAMO BUDDHA 💙
जरूरत शिक्षित होने की है न की किसी की चापलूसी करने की
Sare Jai Bhim wale is comment section me aa chuke hai sirf ek book k liye pure Sanatan Dharm ko gali dene🙃
Sanatan dharm agar sachcha hai to usme ye gandagi hai hi kyu???
@@thededro3352 Ved aur Upnishad hi sacred text hai hinduism manusmruti nahi vo bahut baad Mai dala Gaya hala ki mai Manta hu ki manusmriti ko likhne Wale aur usko follow karne wale Hindus kehlame k layak nahi hai.
@@unknownuser5718 par ved aur upnishad me bhi gandagi ki bharmar hai science journey channel dekho. Aur koi bhi sanatani Jo debate ke liye aata khud ko defend bhi nhi kar pata haar maan ke aur accept kar ke jaata hai ke ved aur upnishado me gandagi hai
Pandito ki tho jalege hi saach sun kaar
Manusmriti mein milawat Max Muller ek ithas kar hey unhe logo ne kiya hey apne hisab se
You may hate him but This guys is brilliant❤
I dont hate him at all. He is a scholar and guru
He is a hindu apologetic ...
@@mishapillai9414 weed wala molana shrabi charsi
@@DarkKnight-or1ck He is an Unapologetic Sanatani!.....Hinduism has become a misnomer for Pagan worship,Crores of dieties,and Social evils masquerading as morality(The Latter is done more in Abrahamic cults)...!...
He is a hypocrite "पाखंडी"
गलत बातों और असमानताओं की बात करने वाली हर book को जला देना चाहिए,, ताकि नकारात्मक बातों का प्रसार रोका जा सके।।👍
Isi liye tum sanwidhan bhi jalaao jo 7 logo ke dwara likha gya tha aur 299 logo ne sign kiye the
चांद से चांदनी लो धब्बे नहीं । वेदांत में बहुत सी बातें लगभग 99.99 प्रतिशत आदमी को सुधारने के लिए, उसे ऊँचा उठाने के लिए कही गई हैं उनको मानों अपवाद को नहीं।
आपके सुदंर शरीर में गुदाद्वार भी होता है मुझे उससे क्या करना? आपके ज्ञान से मतलब है।
सार सार को गहि रहे थोथा देय उड़ाय। - साहब कबीर।
देश की बरबादी में पंडितो बड़ा योगदान हैं 😂😂
Sahi bola
Abad kiya hai unhone. Pandito ne hi base bnaya hai desh ka.
Pandit nhi brahman
Jiska tu video dekh Raya voo bhi pandit hi hai prasant tiwari Brahmin 😂
Arakshan wala bhikari hai ye 😂 confirm
After reading manusimitri, I realised it is the most toxic and acidic thoughts I ever read. Only a psychopath, sick mentality person can think like this and write in a book. It should be introduced to psychological literature to find traumatic studies. The writer doesn't leave anything so brutal towards humanity and animals as well.
Do u know what a Brahim ksatriya vaishya and shudra is ?
@@cannibalisticvegitarian. the most inhumane and terror practice I ever come across, that leads to untouchability..The worst aspect of the caste system was untouchability. The untouchable suffered from various social, economic, political and religious disabilities. In the name of religion, they were thoroughly exploited in the most inhuman manner. It doesn't even stops there caste system give birth to
Provoke Undemocratic practice, No Vertical Mobility, Encouraged Untouchability that
Created a Class of Idlers.
Oppression of Low Caste People Encouraged Conversion largely as result to Budhaism, Sikhism, Jainism, Islam, Charistianity and now atheism..
It is Against Integrity of Nation, gives people a False Sense of Superiority and Inferiority.
Please give reference 2ith authenticity.
@@Nitinmishra.6565 if I give you then will you change in your belief system and your mindset ? No 🤣
The things you cannot turn around ..
1. Bhakt
2. Time
3. Truth
You have eyes, you only use them to get pleasure not see the reality. You see discrimination around you trillions of times, you never ask yourself why they are like this, why so much discrimination. You see and ignore everyday poor unprivileged child begging and sleeping on the roads, but you are asking for authenticity. There are news for discrimination, crime, rape based on caste and class, you need authenticity. You don't require authenticity, you need to use your eyes 👀..
@@cannibalisticvegitarian. Already knew that
पुरे भारत में आचार्य प्रशांत जी जैसे महान व्यक्ती नही है.....❤❤
मनुस्मृति एक कला कानून है जिसे ब्राम्हण लागू करके हमारे ऊपर अत्याचार करते आ रहे हैं ये प्रशांत भी वही इसलिए ये उसकी बुराई नही कर रहे है😢😢😢
इन्होंने अपनी सारी जिंदगी हम जैसे छोटे लोगों के लिए त्याग दिया , 10 मिनट का वीडियो देख के इनको समझे गए क्या ? थोड़ा सोच समझ के बोलो जो भी बोल रहे हो ।
रही बात छुआ छूत की तो मैने अपने नीचे वर्ग में छुआ छूत देखा है ।
@@Shiva14082 भाई या तो तुम आर्य हो या फिर तुमने इतिहास नही पढ़ा है बात एक विडियो की नहीं है हर क्षण ये लोग अपनी घिनौनी चाल चलते रहते हैं ।
क्या दिक्कत है भाई तुम्हें बुराई करना जरूरी है क्या
उन्होंने जो कहना था वह कह दिया
खाना पीना खाओ काम करो in sab me kyo padte हो खुस rahoge@@Ghazipur_up61_up32
One thing we all should remember that Manusmriti is highly interpolated, just like this gentleman said that Women are thought to be as Devi in Manusmriti then again on the same book Women's level is shown below Men's,
How two complete opposite thing exists in one book, it's because it was edited later, may be by the same people of India or may be the invaders, who knows?
We don't know, We were under the rules of Barbaric Invaders-Islamic and British.
Finally a sensible comment
That's what Andrew tate is doing. Manu was Andrew tate of his times
Again Blaming Muslims and Britishers..
Brahmins and all varnas existed even before the advent of Islam.....
Always blaming others when you and your own ancestors interpolated and played with the scriptures...
@@gagadonim3354shut the hell up...I know what are you implying here....want to compare a religious text with a baboon ?
@@jawwadahmad4483 you are saying as if the indoctrination of Hindu scriptures is close to remote during Islamic or british invasion period...if the largest ever library can be burned down by a Mohammedan...then we can speculate what other things people from your community did to the inhabitants of this land...I agree muslims were straight forward.... straight on killings, beheadings and all those stuffs but the british were cunning...they distorted the whole spiritual essence of Bharat...and blaming everything on the Varna system whose fabricated version still rots the mind of people is laughable...nowhere in vedanta it is mentioned that Varna system was based on birth...nowhere ..
Sach Ko sach kahna katai galat nahi hai salute u sir
Manusmriti ❌ Shreemad bhagwad gita ✅🙏🏻
Through you Acharya ji I have got to know about how deep & great our Sanatan Dharma is.
Thankyou for taking us to Vedant(Upanishads) & Geeta 🙏
Today I am #Vegan for Animals
& Minimalist for Environment too.
self proclaimed and politically challenged sanatanis will call you a "woke"
Bohot badiya bhai
@@erwinsmith5796 🙏 please aware others too about Animal cruelty brother.
& please put a bucket of water outside your house for Stray Animals 🙏💧
@@CEarthling i cant compromise with taste brother
😇😇😇😇
@@ALT-GERO apni ungli kat ke kha ja fir
मनुस्मृति बाबासाहेब जी ने जलाई है तो ओ किताब कितनी जहरीली होगी जो की बाबासाहेब किताबो से कितना प्यार करते थे ...।
उसी ओरिजिनल संविधान के प्रथम पृष्ठ पर भगवान राम की चित्र भी बाबासाहेब अम्बेडकर ने लगाई है
Dr Ambedkar kitab nahi jala sakte jab unhone ye pada hoga ki agar ved koi pad le uski chib kat do to unka khoon khul geye hoga
Every human being should have thoughts like this really valuable
Great person great quality discussion focussing not behave of Hinduism
एक शिक्षित व्यक्ति हमेसा सही और गलत में अंतर कर पाता है पर बड़ी शर्म की बात है की कुछ लोग कमेंट ऐसी कर रहे है की वो खुद भी मनुस्मृति पढ़ कर आ गए हो
To all the youngsters, follow Vedanta philosophy and take help from Rani Sivan’s answers on Vedanta to get a perfect nuanced understanding about Hinduism.
Casteism has no place in our rich philosophy and nothing apart from Vedanta which is the essence of Hindu dharma and has been summarised in Geeta will give you the true picture of Hindu dharma.
PS : Rani Sivan ji was a Jew and then he took up studies of Dharma to explore the divinity in Dharma.
Aacharya Prashant is covering Bhrahmnism propaganda
Wo tere jaise chhote maan k nhi hai
Manusmriti : the constitution of Brahmins
Bharat has "Constitution of India" by Ambedkar
Indian constitution me last 75 years me itane correction ho chuke hai to kya 10300 years me Manusmriti me Milawat / Correction kyo nhi hua hoga??🤔??
Manusmriti 10000 saal purani thodi hai😂
Tum apni school book padho, Kitne saal purani hai?
@@hardikgupta9105 Bhai search krk dekh lo ya wo bata dijiye.
@@hardikgupta9105 first time original manusmriti 10300 year ago us time ki conditions k liye Aaj k constitution ki trh hi likha gya tha.
@@hardikgupta9105 or aaj ki conditions me Jo manusmriti ki copy available hai vo 300 sal se jyada purani nhi hai. Jabaki vedo ki 3500 sal purani copy London k British museum me available hai.
The biggest contradiction to manusmriti is Manu rishi himself,he was born Kshatriya and changed his varna to brahmins by acquiring knowledge and wisdom.
I am always against manusmriti 😡😡😡😡😡😡🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
Acharya always deserve ♥️❣️
I hope in next life ambedkar will born as muslim girl and do the same thing with Qur'an that he did with manusmriti.
| You can also do this thing! All the Best
He was not coward he critised muslim also if varn vyavastha is percent in Quran also he does the same thing
Kisi gandi chij se Quraan ko mat jod...
Pehle pad... Phir bol.. Aur kisi scholar se jake puchh... Nahi samze toh
@@amirpatel1145 abe itni gandi hai ki bol bhi nai paunga. Tension mat le.
@@TenGreats04 tuze itni de sakta hoo... Gaali jiski hadd nahi.. Pata hai... Wohi kitab muze rok rahi hai... Warna... tere samaz nahi Aayega...
Hazaro saal se jo dalit pr atyachar ho rha tha naa... Isi kitab ne bachaya hai...
Please also note that Manu smriti or any other ancient text has become adulterated now. So need to be careful reading any such text. Some people thanking BR Ambedkar that he burnt Manu smriti but same guy didn’t dare to burn Bible or Quran. He also said Vedas should be burnt without even knowing even a word of Vedas. Vedas which was not only applauded by Saints and sages but also modern day quantum physicist like Heinsberg, Erwin, Neil Bohr, Oppenheimer, Einstein etc.
True bhai
Vedas old ved is rigveda but by doing carbon dating its age came as 1400 AD whihc menas its just 600 years old Just this much its very new and we should not learn anything from vedas also you can verify from the unesco website that oldest rugveda in unesco website and then check indias nomination form you will see ASI mentioned that its is just from 1400 AD
@@utkarshsrivastava5576 Bhai kuch bhi woh Jo likha hua hai uski baat kar rahe hai hamare yah saalo Sai ved bol bol kar pass on hue hai generation to generations so pls don't spread misinformation
@@M-Nitin20 bhai I understand ki vedo ko verbally transfer kiyaa gya haj saalon see theek h par ye to inhi books me likha hia naa udka koi proof nahi and one more thing bro at that time even buddhas and there people were writing scriptures and even everywhere all other religion are there they were also writing there literatures pr. Hindu log kyu nhi likh rhe the jab puri duniya likh rhi thi to hm log kyu nhi likh rhe the aur agar aisa thaa mana jata tha ki ved ko likhne se uska essence khatam ho jaegaa to usko likhaa kyu gyaa baad mee. Aur tabhi likhaa kyu gyaaa jab writable language aa gyi thii. Kyunki jo scriptures hai saare vo devnagri me hi hai aur aisaa koi bhi proof nahi mila hai jisse saabit hoo. Ki jo kaahaniya books me likhi hai. Vi sach hai ek aur example deta hu.
As per rd lal ASI ke the vo jo india ke ayodhya and other paces ko excavate kiya thaa. Ye saabit krne ke liye vaha pe kuch thaa pahle jaise ayodhya ka pura sheher
Par unko ek bhi aise proofs nhi mile jinse saabit ho cha log bhi the kabhi itne bade mehel thee agar vha ayodhya me to kuch to sabut milna chahiye thaa kuch bhi nahi mila aur apni report me submit kiya last me kii. Ayodhya me shayad aaj se 900 saal phle koi rhnaa shuru kiyaa hogaa jis time ki rig veda ki carbon dating hai bhai proofs saaamne hai aap ek baar dekho too.
@@utkarshsrivastava5576 bro oldest remains in ayodhya was from 600 BCE - ua-cam.com/video/FzCRJ8BJ4bk/v-deo.html
से निकाल दे। (मनुस्मृति, 10/95)
3. किसी भी आयु का ब्राह्मण पितातुल्य होता है। सौ वर्षों का वृद्ध क्षत्रिय भी 10 वर्ष के बालक ब्राह्मण को पिता बराबर ही समझे। (मनुस्मृति, 2/138)
4. शूद द्वारा अर्जित घन को ब्राह्मण निर्भीक होकर ले सकता है, क्योंकि शुद्र को धन रखने का अधिकार नहीं है। (मनुस्मृति, 8/416) 5. बिल्ली, नेवला, चिड़िया, मेढक, गधा, उल्लू और कौवे की हत्या में जितना
पाप लगता है, उतना ही पाप शूद्र (अनुसूचित जाति, जनजाति एवं पिछड़ा वर्ग) की हत्या में है। (मनुस्मृति, 11/131) 6. ब्राह्मण दुश्चरित्र भी पूजनीय है और शूद्र जितेंद्रिय होने पर भी पूज्य नहीं। (पराशर स्मृति, 8/33)
7. जो शूद्र अपने प्राण, धन और स्त्री को ब्राह्मण को अर्पित कर दे, उस शूद्र का भोजन करने योग्य है। (विष्णु-स्मृति, 8/33)
8. चाहे वह खरीदा गया हो अथवा नहीं, लेकिन शूद्रों से सेवा ही करानी चाहिए, क्योंकि शूद्रों की उत्पत्ति ब्रह्मा ने ब्राह्मणों की सेवा के उद्देश्य से ही की है। (मनुस्मृति, 8/412)
9. इन शूद्रों को श्मशान, पहाड़ और उपवनों में ही अपनी जीविका के कर्म 10 करते हुए निवास करना चाहिए। (मनुस्मृति, 10-49) . इन नीची जाति वालों के लिए कफन ही इनका वस्त्र है, फूटे बर्तनों
में ये भोजन करें, इनके आभूषण लोहे के हों और वे सर्वदा भ्रमण करते रहें तथा एक स्थान पर बहुत दिनों तक ना रहें। (मनुस्मृति, 10-51) 1. धर्माचरण करने वाला मनुष्य इन नीच जाति बालों के साथ बातचीत न करे तथा उन्हें ना देखे। (मनुस्मृति, 10/52)
*. यदि नीची जाति का व्यक्ति ब्राह्मण अथवा गाय के लिए अपने प्राण त्याग दे, तो वह उच्च पद को प्राप्त होता है। (मनुस्मृति, 10/61) यदि किसी कारणवश यज्ञ पूरा ना हो रहा हो तो उसकी पूर्णता के लिए वैश्य के यहाँ से धन ना मिलने पर शूद्र के यहाँ से धन ले सकता है, क्योंकि शूद्र का यज्ञ से कोई संबंध नहीं होता। (मनुस्मृति, 11/13) जिस ब्राह्मण ने शूद्र का वध किया है, उसे छः माह के व्रत तथा एक बैल तथा ग्यारह गायें दूसरे ब्राह्मण को दान में देनी चाहिए।
(मनुस्मृति, 11/130; पराशर स्मृति, 6/16)
वर्ण-व्यवस्था के जनक और शूद्र /
Ye hai manusmriti 😂😂😂
Esliye sb Ko Bolta hu pdhai kro jo pdh na B hai svidhan ko pdho ladkiyo ko tao sb se jyda Bolta hu me ne puri ki puri manusmriti pdh rkhi hai
Manusmruti me milawat hui hai
Kaun sa sanvidhan oo jo pure SC aur St ko kahta h ki tum dalit( achhut )ho
Biggest fan of acharya prasant
From Bangladesh
Manusmruti is probably about societal laws of a kingdom at one point of time. There are so many other smritis as per time . The laws can always be altered, ammended or altogether dumped accordingly to time and place. It is not like Ten commandments written on stone. Laws are always subject to changes as per needs
ये प्रशांत जो है कभी ओशो नही बन सकता है क्योंकि वह खुद हिलता रहता है apne mind ko control nahi kar pata hai apni apni परसिध्धि ke liye bol sahi Raha hai apar iske andar प्रोरवगर vahi hi।
Isko ye Shanti nahi aur ma milegi Osho nahi ban paygea 😅😅😅😅😅😅
I love this man! Thanks Ranveer for inviting him on your show.
अरे यही बात तो कब से कह रहे है कि मनुस्मृति को बेवजह हवा दे दी है। किसी के घर में नहीं मिलेगी। किसी ने एक श्लोक भी नहीं पढ़ा होगा। किसी ने आज तक इस्तेमाल भी नहीं की होगी। बस इसके नाम का धुआं उठा रखा है।
Bhai sahab jitne famous slok agar koi manch par tali batorne k liye krte hai wo sb manusmriti me hi diya hua hai
Har chiz k do pahlu hai
Manusmriti ko totally darkinar nhi kar skte
Proud To Be Indian Atheist/Nastik ⚛️✊😇❤️
Is Desh me nastik nahi rehete
Call yourself charvak...
And BJP wants to re-establish Manusmriti back
किसने बोला 😂😂😂😂😂
@Krishnaradhe424 ley andhbhakt go and listen to BJP leader's speech in UP
Link de, dekhta hu @@CelestialEcho
पहले जब वर्ण व्यवस्था थी तभी कोई बेरोजगान नहीं था पर आज तो बेरोजगार की कोई कमी नहीं है।
Manusmriti was written just by some random guy 300 year ago and it does not represents hinduism,ved, vedant,geeta,ramayana , Mahabharata are core and old books of hinduism.(although manusmriti doesn't have any discrimination , misunderstanding is only due to wrong English translation by Max Muller)
Source?
@Amber-mt3nvlol wikipedia😂
@@flyingjett5211 trust me bro 😂
Then why the hell condition of dalit were some miserable
that was english version what about hindi version that was written by hindus
Acharya Prashant🌺🌺🌺
ये बंदा कभी भी साफ साफ नहीं बोलता है बड़ा ही सोफ्ट हिंदू डिफेंडर है ये अचार परेशान बाबा है l 1:09
Very straightforward, Jai Bheem
भारत में मनुस्मृति को मानने वाले ब्राह्मण बहुत कम मिलेगे पर हाँ भीमटो के लिए ये पवित्र ग्रंथ जरूर हैं क्यू ना हो उनका राशन जो मनुस्मृति के विरोध से ही होता है। हिन्दू तो भूल भी जाए मनुस्मृति पर भीमटे ना भूलने देंगे 😂😂
दुखती रग पर हाथ रखे है भीमटो ने
😂😂😂😂😂😂
अगर मनुस्मृति की कमियों पर प्रकाश डालोगे और उसे कम अहमियत दोगे जो कि उतनी अहमियत देने लायक है भी नहीं फिर भी ,जिन्हें हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों से ही दिक्कत है वो गीता या रामायण को पकड़ लेंगे।🤷🏼♂️🤦♂️ जो कि हम देख ही चुके हैं।😒
सच ये है कि अब किताब कोई पढ़कर follow नही करता है बल्कि मानसिकता ही वैसी बन गई है जैसे स्त्री पुरुष से निचले स्तर की होती है, लड़की का जन्म होना पाप है, पत्नी का काम पति की सेवा है, गरीब कमजोर का शोषण करो, ऊंच नीच रखो, जिसकी लाठी उसकी भैंस आदि। इसपर मैंने बहुत अध्धयन किया है कि किस तरह मनुस्मृति और अन्य धंर्मिक ग्रंथो ने हमारे देश की संस्कृति को ही विकृत बना दिया है। ये सबकुछ लोगो के दिमाग मे भीतर तक घुसा दिया है। और ऐसी मानसिकता वाला किसी भी समाज का व्यक्ति हो सकता है ।
broo 💀
bhimte log gajput
bhim ke gaand ke bhante log ko kya bole
1:38 mehatva nahi raha toh sir samaj mai jati pratha aur sati pratha kyu prachalit hui?? Mahatva nahi tha toh
kam batao taki logo ko lage ki zyada nahi tha, jabki sach itna zyada discrimination hota tha ki dhang se saas bhi Lena mana tha. jis jagah se sc/st chale toh vahan bura bola jata hai
1. मनुस्मृति अध्याय 4 श्लोक 80,
"शुद्र को बुद्धि नही देना चाहिए, न हवन का बचा हुआ भाग और न उसे धर्म का उपदेश दे तथा उसे व्रत का भी उपदेश न दे।"
2. आर्य स्मृति 19 व अग्निस्मृति 191
" यदि शुद्र जप तप होम आदि शुभ कर्म करे तो राजा उस राज्य नाशक शुद्र को कठोर दण्ड दे।
3. वशिष्ठ 18 - 9
शुद्र शमशान के समान अपवित्र है इससे शुद्र के समीप वेद न पढ़े।
4. पराशर स्मृति 8 - 33
ब्राम्हण चाहे दुष्चरित भी हो तो भी पूजनीय है। शुद्र जितेंद्रिय होकर नही।
5. मनुस्मृति 2 - 31 एवं विष्णु स्मृति 27 - 69
" ब्राम्हण का नाम मंगलकारी क्षत्रिय का नाम शक्तिमय वैश्य का नाम धनमय, तथा शुद्र का नाम निंदामय हो।
6. मनुस्मृति 10 - 125
शुद्र से तो सेवा ही कराए चाहे वह खरीद कर आया हो या बिना खरीदे। शुद्र को यदि कोई छुड़ा भी ले तो भी उसे अपने स्वामी को नही छोड़ना चाहिए और उनकी सेवा करनी चाहिए क्योंकि ब्रह्मा ने शुद्र को ब्राम्हणों की दासता करने के लिए ही उत्पन्न किया है। शुद्र को जूठा अन्न पुराने कपड़े, अन्न की पसोदन और पुराना बर्तन भाड़ा देना चाहिए।
7. मनुस्मृति 11 - 13
यदि यज्ञ के दो या तीन अंग अपूर्ण रह जाए तो इनकी सिद्धि के लिए धार्मिक शुद्र का धन बलपूर्वक चोरी से ले आवे।
8. मनुस्मृति 8 - 417
ब्राम्हण को चाहिए कि निर्भय होकर शुद्र का द्रव्य लेवे क्योंकि शुद्र का अपना कुछ नही।
9. मनुस्मृति 8 - 281
यदि शुद्र उच्च जातियों के साथ एक आसन पर बैठने की इच्छा करे तो राजा उसकी कमर दाग कर देश से निकाल दे अथवा उसके चूतड़ कटवा दे।
10.आपस्तंब धर्म सूत्र प्र 2 पटल 10 खंड 27 सूत्र 8,9
शुद्र स्त्री के साथ व्यभिचार करने वाले द्विज पुरुष को देश से निकाल दिया जाय पर जो शुद्र किसी द्विज स्त्री से व्यभिचार करे तो उसे प्राण दंड दिया जाय।
11.आपस्तंब धर्म सूत्र 2- 1/2/8
जिस प्रकार चांडाल को छूना पाप है उसी प्रकार इससे (शुद्र) बोलना और उसे देखने से पाप होता है इसके लिए प्रायश्चित का विधान है।
12. मनुस्मृति 8 - (270-272)
शुद्र यदि द्विजाती को लगने वाली बात कहे तो उसकी जीभ काट डाली जाए क्योंकि वह जघन्य स्थान से नीच से उत्पन्न हुआ है।
13. गौतम धर्म सूत्र 12 - 8 - 13
द्विज यदि एक दूसरे को गाली दे तो दंड की विधान है किंतु द्विज किसी शुद्र को गाली दे तो कोई दंड नहीं।
14. मनुस्मृति 11-131
बिल्ली नेवला चिड़िया मेंढक कुत्ता गधा उल्लू और कौवा मार डालने पर जितना पाप होता है उतना ही शुद्र को मार डालने पर होता है।
15. गौतम धर्म सूत्र 12 - 4 व शंकराचार्य का ब्रम्हम सूत्र अध्याय 1 पाठ 3 अधिकरण 9 सूत्र 38।
शुद्र यदि वेद को सुन पावे तो उसके कानो में पिघला हुआ शीशा और लाख भरवा देनी चाहिए। यदि वेद का उच्चारण करे तो उसकी जिह्वा कटवा देनी चाहिए। यदि वेद का स्मरण करे तो उसको मरवा डालना चाहिए।
भाईसाहब हम सब शुद्र हैं। और हमें ब्राह्मण बनना है ।
जन्मना जयते शूद्र : कर्मणा द्विज उच्यते
।
@@travellingtechno जी मुझे भी परमगति की अभिलाषा है🙏
Translated by max muller.
Ave kha arth ka anarth kr rhe ho bhai esa to koi anpadh bhi nhi bolega bo to akhir hm sb k margdarsak the kisi ne apko Galt arth btaya h ..phle log pdhte nhi the lekin ap to padhe likhe ho bhai don't be influenced by adharmis.
@@Prathambharangar123 मैने भी जांचने का प्रयास किया, और मैने श्लोको को भी इसी भाषा में लिखा हुआ पाया, पढ़कर दुख हुआ, मुझे सनातन ज्ञान प्रिय है और मुझे लगता है कि ये नगण्य है क्योंकि मैंने उच्च स्तर की किताबे पढ़ी है, जिसमे यह सब कोई माईने नही रखता। यहां लिखने का अभिप्राय केवल यही है की इस वीडियो में इन्ही किताबो के इन्ही विवादित श्लोको के बारे में बात किया गया है।
सभी को जय सतनाम🙏
Jai bheem ❤jai constitution 🔥
That's why I'm ex Hindu 👍
Sir , let’s take corporate world , is everyone treated with same respect ? What we need to highlight whatever discrimination happened, they are happening all over the world and many times more . Just highlighting manu smriti is foolishness. In any Hindu scriptures there was no discrimination and all they told are duties of varnas. And it was mentioned all 4varnas are needed for society and all are treated with equal respect.
Manusmriti ka aag lagne wala ek he ek insaan wo hai DR br ambedkar the legend.
Manusmruti carries no importance. Thanks.
Ranveer : Kya manusmriti me yeti ke baare me koi niyam h?
Yeti nahi heemdanav
Manusmurti desh ke liye boht ghatk thi isliye dr baba sahab ne jalaya tha
If you go deep inside Hinduism.. You'll realize the manusmriti that we are reading today is not original one... There is concept called " प्रक्षिप्त " Where we can change it's verses (it gives permission to do that) coz manusmriti is not scripture.. It's like constitution..... You'll get to know those things if u go through manusmriti by yourself.... Our's is the most diverse and truthful "धर्म" Among all, everyone should be proud of it.. ☺🚩🇮🇳
Bhaisahab, ager log true Hinduism ko follow krte toh fir itni discrimination kyun horhi hoti Aaj v ?? Your defence on manusmriti will always fail till you don't come up with a proper explanation and remedy of casteism ...
@@2020soumya nobody has proofs who started castism.(1) ... Secondly, what do u think, how many people knows the real meaning of Hinduism, real meaning of dharma..hardly 1-2% people.......
Coming to manusmriti.... If you knows, B R ambedkar burns manusmriti, was written in 9 th century AD... But in several upnishad mentioned manusmriti... Think, how can a book written in 9th century quoted/mentioned in scriptures those were written more than 5000 years ago?????? 😁...... Think about that....
@@mayur5138 I don't care what manusmriti or hindu literature tell in real sense, but what matters is why is casteism so prevalent, despite the biggies in religion claim that there is no such thing written. You still aren't able to address the point i raised.. I know you can't ever, nobody can. That's why I am saying, stop this glorification of religion when you, yourself following the same still discriminate people based on caste..aur logically sochein toh mujhe caste discimination nhi krne kliye kisi manusmriti ya hindu literature padhne ki zaroorat nhi hai, yeh toh koi v sensible bnde ko pta hogi...
@@2020soumya casteism is prevalent because, today every single caste is responsible for it...
@@mayur5138 why do you think Dalits are responsible for this ?
Today general cast cry for reservations but they forget they use to have 100 % reservation in history
Not reservation..we contributed in history ok
@@professor__7000contribution of what reserved land resources and use them became established and make other slaves is that your contribution to the humanity
@@Hitler-v1hmade maths contribution like all numbers zero trigonometry integration baudyana madhava susuruta ramanujan aryabhatta brahmagupta etc all brahmin cry bhimte 😂😂😂
Because they were more intelligent then chamars😂😂chamar loog hi angrezo ke talve chaat te the unko freedom fighter ki mukhbiri karte the dediya tune apne chamar hone ka saboot
@@professor__7000 you contributed in history? Read Manu smruti then come here, sc st were not even allowed to go to school. You are not a proffesor you are a shameless fellow.
I am in the first chapter of manusmriti, so far so good, dont know what I will encounter, but I will definitely inform you after I complete reading the whole book.
Thats a great thing you are reading it directly than taking a said about opinion from anyone else. At first i also thought it to be a primitive book, then i read some opinion of greatest western philosophers like Fredrick Neitschze and Carl Jung, F.N said, " We need to abandon the Bible and adopt the Manav Dharmashastra(Manusmriti) for the western world to progress." C.J said, "Manusmriti is the most liberal produce of Mankind". And i was like, HOLY SHIT, i was completely blown. So i got a translation in Hindi(never a Max Muller version), i am still to start it, but will now, for sure.
Manusmriti is not a spiritual book , it's social book
chapter 10 will change your mind.
Bro I also want to read this book.
From where can I buy this book.
Pls suggest me.
Why u guys always take references from foreigners....don't we Indian people have enough brain nd heart to understand the things....
Pahle mai kattar Aastik tha fir galti se sab religion ko pad liya science vigyan or baba sahab ko ab Nastik ho gaya hu or dharam k thekedaro ki band bajata hu 👊😁😂
लेकिन आरक्षण पर आपके विचार बाबा साहेब डॉ अम्बेडकर से बिलकुल अलग है
Acharya Prashant is right . I got to learn so much about real vedant from him
That's why you must read Vishuddh Manusmriti. 😊
हट्ट love❤de
@@Bankelal_Modi420 sir aapki kyu jal gayi😂
@@Bankelal_Modi420 ye anus h toh iske dimaag m bhi sirf gaand hi hoga na XD
Chlo hadees pdhte hai? Madina wale verses
श्री मान जी ने ये बात कही की
" खुद को victim कहने में अच्छा लगता है" इस बात पर और विचार करने की आवश्यकता है।
कौन इंसान खुद को भेदभाव में मरते रहना पसंद करता है आप ही बताओ
कितने लोग होंगे जो खुद को victim कहलवाना पसंद करेंगे
Haan ess baat par vichaar karne ki avyeshakta hai, victim card term suna hai??? Ye vo card hai jo log fek dete hai jab vo badnaam hote hai, ek example ye hai ki kai cases mai ladki ladko se galt behave kar deti hai jab ladka palat k jawab dete hai tho victim card ye nikal k aata hai ki mai ladki hu aur tum mere saath aisa nhi kar skte, theek vaise hi card muslim khelta hai poori duniya mai ki jab vo atankwadi aur jihadi wali harkat krta hai aur jab usko palat k jawab milta hai tho kehta hai hum minority hai hamare saath galt ho rha hai.
Usse tarah ka card sc st community khelti aayi hai, aadhe se zyada st sc ko abhi tak reservation k baarein mai nhi pata hai bhai, aisa kyu???
Tumhare neta tumhe hi gawar apnpad banaye rakhna chahe hai taaki unki satta bana rahe aur tum log unko hero maano, vo ye division aur bhedbaav khatam nhi karna chahte agar kar denge tho satta gayab.
Bhim rao ambedkar k baad tum logo k liye koi leader aaya hi nhi hai jo tumhare liye kaam kiya ho tumhe aage badhane k liye ulta apna agenda aur propaganda felate hai
We are sorry for everything that happened/happening to our Dalit brothers/sister in the name of cast.
*
Consider it as apology from my family/ancestors
*
We have come a long way since independence, it is diminishing in urban life hope it ends soon in rural life also.
*
Soon in coming days we will see India without cast biased/atrocities.
@Harry A उस समाज को ही अपने आप पर शर्म आना चाहिए जंहा उसी के धर्म का कोई आदमी समाज में अपनी जाति बताने पर शर्माए।
आखिर समाज ने ही उसे उसके जाति के लिए शर्मसार किया होगा, इसीलिए वो शर्म कर रहा है।
अभी भी समय है, जाति के नाम पर बिखर कर, ऊंच/नीच वाली बाते/कार्य बंद कर एक बन जाओ,
मेरे प्यारे साथियों।
@Harry A tujhe lagta hai yeh sab itna asaan hai. Tuh bol raha hai casteism ko khatam kyu nahi kiya, par ise toh jaativadiyon ne hi bacha ke rakha. Apne political gains ke liye. Tuh dil pe haath rakh ke bol, agar tera koi behen ya ristedaar ki koi ladki, lower caste ladke se shaadi karna chahe tu openly support karega?
Reservation toh ek dhaal hai. Jinko mandir me ghusne nahi diya jaata, jinke saath baith ke khana nahi khaya jata just because of their caste, kya guarantee hai ki unko kaam se banchit rakha nahi jayega unke identity ke karan.
Kindly if you can answer my questions. ☮️
अगर मनुस्मृति की कमियों पर प्रकाश डालोगे और उसे कम अहमियत दोगे जो कि उतनी अहमियत देने लायक है भी नहीं फिर भी ,जिन्हें हिंदू धर्मग्रंथों से ही दिक्कत है वो गीता या रामायण को पकड़ लेंगे।🤷🏼♂️🤦♂️ जो कि हम देख ही चुके हैं।😒