What scared me about that was his reason. He didn't call for her execution due to her involvement in the raped & torture of 5 women plus the murder of 4 of them. He called for her death because of the bullying he had experienced because he was her son. 😶
Some people are born as soulless deviants; David and Catherine certainly fit the bill. Catherine is no better than David. Happy Catherine will never be released. Those poor girls & women; I can’t imagine the terror and suffering they experienced prior to their passing. Monsters exist but only in human form. Thank you DC.
I feel terrible for Catherine's son, not only was she non-existent in his upbringing but he's also bearing the brunt of the public's outrage because of her actions
Catherine participated in the murders just as much as David she should absolutely have gotten the exact same sentence as him and she even spat on the grave site were one of the victims was buried proving how vile and twisted she truly is she's every bit as bad as David
You did a great job with pronunciation in this one. I really don't envy the police having to search such a huge, untamed forest that must have very much been a needle in a hay stack situation. Thank goodness for the female cop who believed the victim immediately.
I was living and working in Australia at the time these crimes were committed. The public's outrage was palpable, with many of my coworkers and members of the public calling for a reinstatement of the death penalty. For a long time afterwards, young women would only be out at night with at least one companion. Neither of the two murderers showed any remorse, adding to fury against them. A really tragic case.
You did fix the volume discrepancy. Thank you! I got a LOT of flack for even bringing it up, but I was thinking it was easier for one person to fix than thousands. You or your team fixed it, and I am grateful. I am sorry all those people thought it was better to wake my room mate than ask you to balance the volume. It was so much better today, I might watch the intro 3 times after I watch the whole video. THANK YOU even if it was NOT for me! Blessings upon you! Another EDIT: watched the intro again, then again. It was SO easier on my ears! I don't claim you did it only for me! But for all of us with sensitive ears, thank you! I listen to music at less than half volume, my friends max it all they can...THANK YOU!
Wow, a pair of satan's helpers! RIP to those poor women they murdered I hope she does stay in prison she's depraved. Thank you DC excellent video as usual 👏👏💜
As a born n bred west aussie, this case hits close to home, theres a girl that was a neighbour of mine that was murdered after hitchhiking , i dont feel like many people know about it, well over 25 years unsolved. her name was Kerry Turner. first their son got murdered, and then a few years later , her youngest daughter gone as well, i would dearly love to see what you might be able to dig up on this case, i went to school with them.
I have met Kate, She told me her story. I felt physically ill and wanted to cry so much. I have other connections with the Bernie’s too but I like to focus on meeting the beautiful angel Kate.
Whou! What a charming couple…😳 poor ladies…😢 the Fremantle prison is closed down, you can have a tour in it…i did a midnight tour a couple of years ago! It’s actually very scary, because is a very old prison ( not like today’s modern buildings) …he deserved to be looked up there!
I basically said that to a coworker ( she tried to say something about giving a rapist the benefit of doubt). Nahhh as a sexual assault survivor I couldn’t let that slide by me.
Hi from Perth WA…this was a truly terrifying time. My ex husband was a detective at the time so I heard before it was made public that these two had been caught & who they had murdered (& the spitting on the grave). Absolute cruel monsters. Thank you DC…you told this story very well.
7:24 If Nolene Patterson ran out of gas after work and Those People (I won’t use their proper names they don’t deserve it) just so happened to be there to pick her up, it’s surely because they had siphoned off her gas to manufacture the whole incident. They had probably stalked her since they did the wallpaper for her a few weeks previous.
2 monsters got their just due. Thank God the last victim had the amazing strength & courage, plus miraculous opportunity to escape. Bless all the others who sadly lost their lives.
The Coolbellup Tavern is nowhere near Stirling H'way. They are on different sides of the river. Leech H'way is sort of close to the tavern, but not directly. There's no straight-line route between them. Not in the eighties anyway.
Another case of stunning police incompetence. Who the fuck sees a woman run in begging for help and immediately assumes deception? Lucky one of them actually did their fucking job.
I think I recall Kate (the victim who escaped) pretended to like him a little, in order to stay alive long enough to escape. Perhaps Noelene behaved similarly and the Birnies fell for it.
Do some people (monsters) _deserve_ it? *Absolutely.* Do I trust the State and its institutions with the lawful power to end a human life, in peace-time, when that individual is not an _imminent_ threat to another life? *No.* The abolition of the death penalty in Australia and the UK followed high-profile wrongful convictions that resulted in wrongful executions.
Just awful that some people misuse an act that God intended to be so special, it creates new life. I guess people today look at sex much differently than those who love the Lord. Only when one stands back, can we see how corrupted it's become. I'm so sorry for the women
That guy had to have had some kind of mental condition.. like, how did he so quickly move into fetish like behavior? Maybe he was abused? Very strange, most people have a trigger into madness, or a condition, but maybe this guy was as they say "born evil".
wasn’t mentioned in this vid but i found through another source online that his mother was severely abusive; both parents were alcoholics, and david being the eldest often had to look after the younger children due to the extremely neglectful conditions. when his parents divorced, david’s behavior was already worrying and neither wanted custody. i imagine getting passed from foster home to foster home didn’t help any. i don’t think anyone is born evil. it’s just that trauma can be invisible, subtle, or not immediately obvious in many cases.
The fact that even Catherine's own son was calling for her to recieve the death penalty really does speak volumes
I before e except after c.
@@mikesanders8621Weird.
@cydkriletich6538 that's nice, dear.
What scared me about that was his reason. He didn't call for her execution due to her involvement in the raped & torture of 5 women plus the murder of 4 of them. He called for her death because of the bullying he had experienced because he was her son. 😶
@@bkitteh6295valid reason tbh
Thank goodness the female police officer believed Kate's story and decided to investigate
this is horrific, Kate was so brave, managing to get away
Kate saved many lives.
What a horrifying story. Thank God for Kate she saved many lives.
He got a computer and antidepressants while in prison? Prison is SUPPOSED to be depressing.
Some of the most brutal, heartless murders I've ever heard this channel cover. David and Katherine were monsters.
Yep, I had trouble listening to this one.
Some people are born as soulless deviants; David and Catherine certainly fit the bill. Catherine is no better than David. Happy Catherine will never be released. Those poor girls & women; I can’t imagine the terror and suffering they experienced prior to their passing. Monsters exist but only in human form.
Thank you DC.
I feel terrible for Catherine's son, not only was she non-existent in his upbringing but he's also bearing the brunt of the public's outrage because of her actions
Even worse, she had 6 other children besides him. Imagine knowing your own mother was a monster like that 😢
It's hard enough to imagine such people without understanding how they find each other.
Yes! I always think this when I hear of couples or teams of rapists & murderers.. scarey af
Catherine participated in the murders just as much as David she should absolutely have gotten the exact same sentence as him and she even spat on the grave site were one of the victims was buried proving how vile and twisted she truly is she's every bit as bad as David
13:56 According to what was said, she didn't spit on the gravesite, she spat on the victim's body when it was uncovered.
@@reginafowler3517even worse! 👹😡
You did a great job with pronunciation in this one. I really don't envy the police having to search such a huge, untamed forest that must have very much been a needle in a hay stack situation. Thank goodness for the female cop who believed the victim immediately.
Catherine spat on the body when the police recovered it?! It's a shame some people (apparently) attacked her son because of her actions...
I hope her son is doing okay, today. ❤️🩹
It's wild how hitchhiking used to be a normal way for a lot of people to get around every day.
It's still pretty common. Not as an everyday mode of transport but I still see people doing it now and then.
My Granny and I hitchhiked together in the 60’s to a market 3 miles away from their home.
I was living and working in Australia at the time these crimes were committed. The public's outrage was palpable, with many of my coworkers and members of the public calling for a reinstatement of the death penalty. For a long time afterwards, young women would only be out at night with at least one companion. Neither of the two murderers showed any remorse, adding to fury against them. A really tragic case.
What a gruesome story, very well told. Thank you.
Ugh calling this horrific seems like a vast understatement
How brave of Kate …. As a sexual assault survivor I know that feeling of doing what you gotta do to survive.
How do these people find each other and how does this come up in conversation? Baffles me.
Thank you for your stories! Seattle ❤
You did fix the volume discrepancy. Thank you! I got a LOT of flack for even bringing it up, but I was thinking it was easier for one person to fix than thousands. You or your team fixed it, and I am grateful. I am sorry all those people thought it was better to wake my room mate than ask you to balance the volume. It was so much better today, I might watch the intro 3 times after I watch the whole video. THANK YOU even if it was NOT for me! Blessings upon you! Another EDIT: watched the intro again, then again. It was SO easier on my ears! I don't claim you did it only for me! But for all of us with sensitive ears, thank you! I listen to music at less than half volume, my friends max it all they can...THANK YOU!
Wow. U really need to get out more
Booooooooo
@@jinxUKBKI’m sure they go out plenty, don’t you worry about it. Giving feedback is now equated with having no life?
Sometimes the music does come loud compared to the narration. Ignore those who disagree with you.
@@Dontmind8 while your giving feedback. Hhhmmm
Once again thanks for your video.
The Fred & Rose West of Australia
JUST TOOK THE WORDS RIGHT OUT OF MY 👄, MY FRIEND ✊🏽✊🏽🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸 🇨🇴🇨🇴🇨🇴🇨🇴🇨🇴🇨🇴
@@JenSmyreyes!! Mine too!!!
Wow! So sad!😢
a friend of mine worked in the prison Birnie was in as a psychologist. She said is a pure psychopath and was highly manipulative.
Come on guys, let’s start making a trend of subscribers amounts matching the likes 👍🏻 ratio. Let’s support our favourite channels.
Wow, a pair of satan's helpers! RIP to those poor women they murdered I hope she does stay in prison she's depraved. Thank you DC excellent video as usual 👏👏💜
Not even satan would be that evil
Putting him in solitary to protect him from harm? He should've been in the general population.
He ended up harming himself
These sound eerily similar to the moors murderers Ian Brady and Myra Hindley especially with their murder method and the profile of their victims
Or Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka in Canada- very similar.
@@horrortackleharrythe fact she’s free is disgusting 😬 what she did was beyond evil
@@iamsherlocked345She’s not free. The story says her incarceration has been marked NEVER RELEASE.
@@RevLeigh55I assume commenter was referring to Homolka, who is free
@@feelthejoy yes that’s who I was referring too
Thanks
It’s always weird to hear the name of my hometown and the names of suburbs I drive through every day. I even study at university in Fremantle.
As a born n bred west aussie, this case hits close to home, theres a girl that was a neighbour of mine that was murdered after hitchhiking , i dont feel like many people know about it, well over 25 years unsolved. her name was Kerry Turner. first their son got murdered, and then a few years later , her youngest daughter gone as well, i would dearly love to see what you might be able to dig up on this case, i went to school with them.
"why does Moorhouse ring a be-"
'The Birneys'
"Oh. Oh no"
Love this channel
I have met Kate, She told me her story. I felt physically ill and wanted to cry so much.
I have other connections with the Bernie’s too but I like to focus on meeting the beautiful angel Kate.
When I was a teenager me and my mates always ran about that area of perth alone at night, I’m amazed we never these freaks
Never met these freaks *
One of those: not good folks when apart & even worse when together!
Australian inmates can have computers? Shits wild
Whou! What a charming couple…😳 poor ladies…😢 the Fremantle prison is closed down, you can have a tour in it…i did a midnight tour a couple of years ago! It’s actually very scary, because is a very old prison ( not like today’s modern buildings) …he deserved to be looked up there!
The term brave and courageous get thrown around a lot these days, but what kate did is the pure definition of those words.
How awful 😭💔
That people like the Burney’s exist…. reminds me to be wary of strangers and not give the benefit of doubt.
I basically said that to a coworker ( she tried to say something about giving a rapist the benefit of doubt). Nahhh as a sexual assault survivor I couldn’t let that slide by me.
Hard to imagine the torture their victims were subjected to. Such despicable people to do all that they did. He got off easy. Unfairly.
Hi from Perth WA…this was a truly terrifying time. My ex husband was a detective at the time so I heard before it was made public that these two had been caught & who they had murdered (& the spitting on the grave). Absolute cruel monsters. Thank you DC…you told this story very well.
These people are pure evil.
7:24 If Nolene Patterson ran out of gas after work and Those People (I won’t use their proper names they don’t deserve it) just so happened to be there to pick her up, it’s surely because they had siphoned off her gas to manufacture the whole incident. They had probably stalked her since they did the wallpaper for her a few weeks previous.
Is exhibitionism a fancy way of saying beastality out of interest
Nah- just exposing yourself. Though I'm sure he tried a bit of the other as well...
No, Google it 😊
...seriously?
That’s an odd question….
there is a very good movie of this called Hounds of Love.
I was first! I’m never first! Can I just say horrific this story was?
Good grief! What sick barstewards.
Sick!
大卫波尼？澳洲犯罪调查经典案例
2 monsters got their just due. Thank God the last victim had the amazing strength & courage, plus miraculous opportunity to escape. Bless all the others who sadly lost their lives.
Pinjarra is south of Perth :).
Gosh, this case reminds me of Fred and Rose West who tortured and killed young women in the UK . Monsters ‼️
The Coolbellup Tavern is nowhere near Stirling H'way. They are on different sides of the river.
Leech H'way is sort of close to the tavern, but not directly. There's no straight-line route between them. Not in the eighties anyway.
There’s a movie on this and it messed me up when I was a young teen aged
A likeness means to look like someone. You mean a liking.
😮 Oh! Wicked wicked people! Oh!
The Willagee house they had was up for rent not long ago
Australians can be so vicious haha
Another case of stunning police incompetence. Who the fuck sees a woman run in begging for help and immediately assumes deception? Lucky one of them actually did their fucking job.
Gerald and Charlene Gallego
The. Hangmen. Must be. Turning. In. There grave. With all. Killers. Just. Getting. Jail time. )!?
The woman looks like Maxine Carr
I wonder why he took a liking to noelene Patterson?
I think I recall Kate (the victim who escaped) pretended to like him a little, in order to stay alive long enough to escape. Perhaps Noelene behaved similarly and the Birnies fell for it.
@@snazzy19 that sounds right. Thank u
Come on. Yall have to miss the death penalty sometimes.
💯
In this case, definitely.
Do some people (monsters) _deserve_ it? *Absolutely.*
Do I trust the State and its institutions with the lawful power to end a human life, in peace-time, when that individual is not an _imminent_ threat to another life? *No.*
The abolition of the death penalty in Australia and the UK followed high-profile wrongful convictions that resulted in wrongful executions.
Duress words, with GPS such as it is
Just awful that some people misuse an act that God intended to be so special, it creates new life. I guess people today look at sex much differently than those who love the Lord. Only when one stands back, can we see how corrupted it's become. I'm so sorry for the women
First comment! Yay me!
the woman was punished less harshly than the dude. Why did no feminists demand equal
treatment?
That guy had to have had some kind of mental condition.. like, how did he so quickly move into fetish like behavior? Maybe he was abused? Very strange, most people have a trigger into madness, or a condition, but maybe this guy was as they say "born evil".
wasn’t mentioned in this vid but i found through another source online that his mother was severely abusive; both parents were alcoholics, and david being the eldest often had to look after the younger children due to the extremely neglectful conditions. when his parents divorced, david’s behavior was already worrying and neither wanted custody. i imagine getting passed from foster home to foster home didn’t help any. i don’t think anyone is born evil. it’s just that trauma can be invisible, subtle, or not immediately obvious in many cases.
Whereas in America, you get out early for good behavior even tho your crime was unthinkable.
The US has much harsher sentencing than Australia.
I guess everybody needs a hobby . . . .