DO NOT USE Logic Pro Mastering Assistant: DO THIS INSTEAD

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 91

  • @planetmullins
    @planetmullins 7 місяців тому +3

    Logic's assistant has a long way to go before it could come close to matching your ears man. Cool video.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому +1

      Yeah, I think this is the next thing in long line of pro-sumer decisions that have been made in the last decade of updates of Logic and frankly, it is a disservice to the unsuspecting users who just want to sound professional. I appreciate your comment on this - thank you!!

    • @planetmullins
      @planetmullins 7 місяців тому

      @@GGabrielMusic for sure man. this started way back when apple was pushing garage band for iPhone so hard and you probably remember how our pro community suffered through all that right? i remember then thinking to myself "wow, the only respected guys who will still work are the mastering engineers". I purposefully didn't update to Logic 10.8 because I didn't want more apple "help." it does take years of experience working in radio tv and film to get "the sound" that works in those fields and you've obviously mastered that. I'm happy they didn't name the mastering assistant Kyle, Kayliegh, or Connor like they did with the logic drummers lol.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому +1

      LOL - you have me cracking up here. So funny, ...'Do you want your track mastered by Dez or Nikki...' too funny man. Thanks for making me laugh out loud and smile for 2 minutes straight....

    • @planetmullins
      @planetmullins 7 місяців тому

      @@GGabrielMusic yeah man, i remember commenting about "bias" when you were talking about tape machines in another video....always good seeing your content man.

  • @superschaap3000
    @superschaap3000 4 місяці тому +4

    just a quick correction for the Mastering Assistant:
    Turning on and of the EQ of the mastering assistant goes via the fader on the left.
    The knob you used to turn it on and off is for the custom EQ you can adjust yourself.
    If you want to use the mastering assistant without its EQ , turn the fader completely down.
    You will then see the EQ flat.
    Great video!

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  4 місяці тому +1

      Yes - you are correct and I knew that, but misspoke in the video. I appreciate the correction!

  • @Darkest_of_Winter
    @Darkest_of_Winter 6 місяців тому +3

    Good video, but the "Custom EQ" button enables you to make changes to the suggested EQ - not a bypass.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  5 місяців тому

      Yes, thank you for clarifying - I misspoke. Appreciate the clarification!

  • @normjones6916
    @normjones6916 7 місяців тому +4

    I use it (assistant) all the time now. You can also adjust the mastering assistants eq very handy, great tune, great playing on those tracks :)

  • @DonnyNSN
    @DonnyNSN 5 місяців тому

    Thanks George. That makes a lot of sense to me. I tried the quick and easy Mastering Assistant on a couple of tracks, but quick and easy very rarely makes it better. I'll stick with your way. Cheers.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  4 місяці тому

      Thanks for the comment! Yes, trust your ears and use the tried and true methods versus the nebulous ones - that is always a better route! Thanks for commenting!!

  • @Steve-br7wt
    @Steve-br7wt 4 місяці тому +1

    I love the simplicity of your chain. Do you ever use a saturation plugin on the master? If so where in the chain would it go?

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  4 місяці тому

      I don't use a saturation plugin and if I wanted to use one, I'd either place it after the compression before the EQ or after the EQ. Thanks for the question!

  • @jstew512
    @jstew512 7 місяців тому +2

    I've been pleasantly surprised by how well it works. I mix in subgroups as much as possible like you described in your TABS method stuff.Then bounce to 24 88.2 and import that into my mastering template. I have a mastering chain I really love (very similar to yours) that I can also tweak quickly and the mastering assistant isn't as good as that but it's solid IMO.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому

      Sounds like you have a good method! Thanks for weighing in!

  • @joshualee8448
    @joshualee8448 7 місяців тому

    This was a great video! I was so excited when Mastering Assistant came out, but I’ve struggled to make it sound good as well. Liked/sub’d/looking forward to diving into your past vids. Keep up the great work!

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому

      Thanks!! Glad you are liked the video (and understand your sentiments about the MA not being all that great!) Lots more to come!

  • @JonScores
    @JonScores 7 місяців тому +1

    Great advice dude! Love this.

  • @lenimbery7038
    @lenimbery7038 4 місяці тому +2

    Mastering Assistant is a great starting point. I use it then tweak according to my ears. It's actually very close right out of the box

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  4 місяці тому

      Glad it works for you! Thanks for the comment.

  • @MrSkunky2009
    @MrSkunky2009 5 місяців тому

    Agree Absolutely...... AI simply not a pair of ears.... We simply can`t replace them... Great video !!!

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  5 місяців тому +1

      Exactly! AI - shmay-I... Thank you for commenting!

  • @StratsRUs
    @StratsRUs 5 місяців тому +1

    Great guidance.Thank you !

  • @0519petercap
    @0519petercap 7 місяців тому +1

    Very helpful. Thanks! Question… what would happen if you didn’t follow your prescribed plug-in chain sequence (multipress, EQ, adaptive limiter). Also I saw someone use the linear phase EQ instead of the channel EQ. What’s the difference when mastering?

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому

      Good question - The linear phase EQ is helpful when you are EQ'ing with bigger extremes to preserve phase, in this case the channel EQ is just lightly kissing the track with some pump and air. You could use either but the channel EQ is a little more apparent in what it does.
      As far as the order of the plugs, that is personal preference. I like to compress first the overall track, then adjust the EQ, then limit because limiting is a top down compressor (it just compresses the peaks) so with that, I don't like to have the compressor and limiter next line to each other.
      Thanks for your question!!

  • @loonymatikk
    @loonymatikk 3 місяці тому

    A tutorial on mixing and mastering a full rap song would be amazing !! Your videos are very helpful 💪

  • @ZenLizardTV
    @ZenLizardTV 7 місяців тому +5

    I think Mastering Assistant is helpful as a reference, but your mastering is clearly better.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому +1

      Great point! It really is just a reference - but why bother to use a reference when you can do it yourself and hand craft the mastering to the details of your track. Thanks for commenting!

    • @ZenLizardTV
      @ZenLizardTV 7 місяців тому

      @@GGabrielMusic That’s actually why I’m watching your content. I’d like to know exactly what I’m doing, but I still have things I need to learn and understand

  • @TimmoMcGinn
    @TimmoMcGinn 7 місяців тому +1

    I agree that you shouldn’t settle for mastering assistant although I gather you don’t have a silicon chip and so miss out on the other MA options. Also I thought the main difference between the 2 outcomes was the brutal high cut on the MA EQ. You could have adjusted that part of the Eq. I would like a better understanding of correct use of multipressors if you can help with that. The other question I have is about mastering in the project vs exporting and mastering the wave file??

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому +3

      I am on a iMac Pro, so you are correct about my chip. But, I have a sneaking suspicion that the two other options would provide more of the same. I know you can adjust with the 3 band EQ, but it would be much better if they put edit points on their EQ curve and you could manually adjust the whole thing. Just adding a high or low shelf really doesn't do the trick.
      I always master directly in the project - Reason is, once I put the mastering chain in, if I need to adjust the compression or EQ on the bus or even track tweaks can be done to overall improve the final output. You don't have that luxury if you are just masting a single stereo file.
      As far as the multi-pressor - perhaps I should just do a video on that??
      Anyway - thanks so much for commenting!!

  • @awesomebandhub
    @awesomebandhub 3 місяці тому

    Hey, I'm a Logic user since before Apple bought the German company Emagic (remember? “Emagic Logic Audio Platinum”)
    When it comes to mix enhancement, that is, mastering, I use external equipment, not plugins. I agree with this video. I don't think that a really laborious task like the mastering process can be solved in a moment by inserting an “assistant” or a wizard.
    Greetings from Hamburg, Germany.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  3 місяці тому

      Thanks for commenting! Yes, I remember good ‘ol Emagic - I started using Logic in 1994 when they had a serial dongle to use it. I too used to use external equipment to master, but since I work in TV, I had too many mixes that I had to recall and had to start taking pictures of my gear to get back to what it was on that mix. I was using a Manley Massive Passive EQ and an SSL G-Series compressor - when UAD came out with those plugs, I ditched the real gear for the plugs. I will say, even though the plugs are great, nothing compares to real gear. I appreciate you weighing in! Come back for more. I will launch a much greater effort in the coming months as I have just moved and I am setting up my new studio, so stay tuned!! Thanks!!

  • @pq1151
    @pq1151 6 місяців тому

    You're mastering sounded much clearer. Liked!

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  6 місяців тому

      Thanks! Yeah - I feel it is much better to have control over it all instead of rely on some nebulous plugin that I can only minimally tweak... Thanks for commenting!

  • @RWKirby-gk7mk
    @RWKirby-gk7mk 5 місяців тому +1

    Great Video Cheers

  • @totalpkgproductions2797
    @totalpkgproductions2797 6 місяців тому

    I think you are right. Thanks for the awesomely amazing breakdown. 💯%.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  6 місяців тому +1

      Thank you!! Appreciate you weighing in!

  • @loonymatikk
    @loonymatikk 5 місяців тому +1

    Can you make one on how to download and install plug ins on logic , I can't find any videos on it

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  5 місяців тому

      I sure can - what are you trying to install? Give me some more info....

    • @loonymatikk
      @loonymatikk 5 місяців тому

      @GGabrielMusic I was trying to figure out how to get "wider" and some "vocal doubler" but I ended up figuring it out just had to re start my computer and check the plug in manager 👍 thanks for the response though ! Can't wait 4 your next video 💯

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  5 місяців тому +1

      @@loonymatikk Check out Logic's sample delay plug in. Just delay one side by a couple of hundred samples and you'll get a widening effect. Let me know what you think after trying it.

    • @loonymatikk
      @loonymatikk 5 місяців тому

      @@GGabrielMusic I will try that out tonight! Appreciate the response 💪

  • @michaelsteenmeijer36
    @michaelsteenmeijer36 7 місяців тому

    More great tips, again. Thanks, I'll give it a go!

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому

      Do it! I think you'll be happier in the end!

  • @Mr.harden
    @Mr.harden 7 місяців тому +5

    The problem I have with all of you guys get on here and try to explain mixing and mastering you doing it with rock ‘n’ roll and heavy metal. I need to see how you do it with R&B and soul music when somebody come out would have to mix and master R&B and soul musicgrab them to me then I will subscribe but until then I’m not feeling then y’all guys are saying

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому +2

      I hear you - it just so happens that in the next week I will be mixing and mastering a song in the R&B genre from a former student of mine and releasing it as a video. Also, in the near future I will also be offing to mix and master one of my subscribers tracks too - maybe yours??

  • @robbe4711
    @robbe4711 7 місяців тому

    Thank you for sharing. You do a great job!
    The mastering plugin also sounds a bit dull in the end.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому

      Thanks!! Yeah - dull is a good description. I agree! Thanks for commenting!

  • @therealDadeMurphy
    @therealDadeMurphy 6 місяців тому

    Honestly, they both sound good. but, it helps the 1k drop which sounds over saturated in the vocals. you could also change the clean to punch and other settings. plus it sounds better with it on compaired to the pre master at least on my DSP here in my studio when listening to your video. Nice video explaining how to master in other ways too. which takes a good ear.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  5 місяців тому +1

      Thanks for commenting! Yeah - it definitely takes a good ear which takes time to develop. I think part of the problem is, people first need to be trained in what sonic excellence is in recordings. The newer generation has been spoon-fed over-modulated and loudness-saturated music, and that has become their norm. Listen to an Earth Wind and Fire song like 'September' and then you get to hear how amazing those engineers were back in the day to get a sonic clarity you can touch. Anyway, thanks for weighing in!

    • @therealDadeMurphy
      @therealDadeMurphy 5 місяців тому

      @@GGabrielMusic that's an amazing song for sure vocals on that are crystal clean drums sound crisp as well as the shaker. very rich song indeed.

  • @Mezzomusicltd
    @Mezzomusicltd 7 місяців тому

    did I notice you going through the general punch, transparent, etc settings?
    This was a thoughtful video. But the song was a bit hard to stay with.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому

      Thanks! I know about the song...lol... But no, I do not have an M1 processor but I suspect more of the same. The bottom line is, mastering is not meant to be dealt with via an algorithm or a one-click solution but rather done the tried and true way: carefully discerning each mastering element's effect on enhancing, balancing and maximizing the loudness of the track - that, in a sense, was my greater point of the video.
      I'll be doing a lot more mixing and mastering videos with other genres in the near future, plus I will be offering to mix and master some subscriber tracks too soon. Stay tuned! Also, thanks for commenting!! :)

  • @loonymatikk
    @loonymatikk 7 місяців тому

    My new mastering technique 🔥🔥

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому +1

      Excellent! You'll be doing yourself a far better service with all the controls in YOUR hands! Thanks for commenting!

  • @jeremevr6
    @jeremevr6 Місяць тому +1

    Doesn’t explain the values he’s changing 11:45

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  29 днів тому +1

      Hey - thanks for pointing this out. I need to do a more extensive video on exactly how to tweak each parameter and what each parameter does. Thanks for the comment - I'll add this to the list!

  • @silvansky
    @silvansky 7 місяців тому

    Wanna go quick and easy? MA - why not? Pretty good results most of the time. Nice for demos and quick takes.
    Wanna sound better and make a release? Use multipressor, EQ, limiter, stereo spread, exciter, matching EQ, etc...

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому +1

      I just end up saving a channel strip setting on my stereo out that has my generic mastering chain that can work for quick mixes and demos. In the end, I think that is still faster and yields better results than MA. Maybe I'm old school, but I just want to be able to make the small adjustments on the individual aspects of the chain. I've never been a huge fan of the one-knob plugs that will 'make your mix sound better' LOL.... Thanks for commenting!!

    • @silvansky
      @silvansky 7 місяців тому

      Hmm, gonna try out the strip settings way. Most of the time all I need from quick mastering is multipressor with "smile" settings, simple or matching EQ and a limiter. But I also use spread feature of MA sometimes. Not sure if it is similar to Stereo Spread plugin.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому +1

      Channel strip setting is the way to go for quick multi-plug chains - I have about a half dozen or so mastering chains for different situations.
      Also, be careful of using any kind of ‘spread’ plugin - it can increase the chance of phasing and mix imbalance.

  • @tjw52x
    @tjw52x 6 місяців тому +2

    This is great if you know what you're doing, but for most of us mere mortals who are not sure what is going to make something sound better, whether it's a compressor or an EQ, it's just watching someone messing around with a track!

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  6 місяців тому +2

      Yeah - such is the composer / engineering life. Mess with stuff until it sounds good, learn by your mistakes, try again, fail again, learn by your mistakes, repeat... There is a time however when everything just clicks and you level up. But it is like those annoying apps when you keep leveling up, but there is no end to the levels...😂

  • @johniebeats
    @johniebeats 7 місяців тому

    It reminds me of sitcom theme songs❤

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому +1

      Yeah - it does have that kinda vibe huh? I think that was the idea when were wrote the track. Thanks for commenting!

  • @MrPaultheguitar
    @MrPaultheguitar 7 місяців тому

    To be honest I think it's the kings new clothes. year ago hardly anything like this existed and it sounded better without fuss

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому

      Agreed!! Sometimes the 'new thing' is just another fad - I am always skeptical of the idea of 'this one thing will fix all of your problems' - At the end of the day, we go back to the tried and true methods that have always worked.

  • @mateuszjachym
    @mateuszjachym 5 місяців тому +1

    With MA sound better ;)

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  5 місяців тому

      Ha! I guess is depends on what you're looking for.... Thanks for commenting!

  • @bucurgabriel6319
    @bucurgabriel6319 7 місяців тому +1

    I don't use Mastering assistant ...I don't like it !I make my own master with ADAPTR Metric A/B ...& the plugins !

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  7 місяців тому +1

      Yes - it is not very likable! Wise choice to master using plugs you know best. I use UAD plugs for my mastering (Shadow Hills Mastering Compressor, Brainworx Mix EQ, and Precision Maximizer as my limiter.) In this video I wanted to showcase that stock Logic plugs are a far better path to mastering than the new Mastering Assistant. Thanks for sharing!!

    • @allsurf
      @allsurf 7 місяців тому

      Very helpful. Sometimes I think assistant does a decent job but I prefer your method. Ozone also does a good job in my opinion. I suppose it varies from song to song. Dang, now your song is stuck in my head!

  • @TracingFlares
    @TracingFlares 5 місяців тому

    i would not recommend using logic in the first place. Reaper is a far more versatile Tool with capabilities that logic isnt even dreaming of.. the workflow is impressive! i would say by a high factor more stable and fluid.. further it handles big projects in a much much better ways. It has customizable actions (literally 1000s of useful things. The ideal tool for creativity and great to show projects to clients. The downside: you have to learn and customize it. Reaper also beats Cubase in nearly any aspect! if you own already good 3rd party plugs you could just moove over.. i found so many missfunctions and stupudly aarranged workflows in logic so i looked for a solution. All my projects now are flowing in a much better, faster and creative way. Logic as for now is pretty outdated. Hey.. dont get ne wrong here. its the man behind the daw what matters... but if you are spending hours and hours on Sessions.. why not have a really good tool?😊

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  5 місяців тому +2

      I hear you. Reaper is like the best open source DAW - but you kinda need to have a programmers mind for that - it’s not for the masses

    • @gparkerarkerdoo
      @gparkerarkerdoo 2 місяці тому

      I used a lite version of Pro Tools for over a dozen years then thought I’d try Cubase. So frustrating. So many windows and options and illogical icons. Powerful and professional yes but LOGICal? No.
      Logic and Apple make sense to me 😊

  • @justincusack8137
    @justincusack8137 2 місяці тому

    Bro, you’re just mad that you’re going to be out of a job. You clearly don’t know how to use the plug-in. As a self taught amateur musician, my mixes have been taken to the next level with mastering assistant. I have song’s i wrote and recorded using a cheap $100 Boss mini guitar amp and a directional mic, that sound better than professionally produced song in that style, if mastering Assistant is doing for me I’m cool with it

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  Місяць тому

      Thanks for commenting! Nah, I won't be out of a job, I know how to use the plugin and I have no doubt this improved your mixes taking them to the next level as an amateur. That said, when you look to recording from a holistic perspective using the tried and true techniques that all of the major records are using today (from recording to mixing and mastering), and getting a hold of those techniques, you can take yourself out of the amateur standing to a whole other level. Keep commenting and watching!

  • @scottellis7573
    @scottellis7573 Місяць тому

    Based on how sibilant your mic for this video is, I can't trust your advice on anything.

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  Місяць тому

      Well alright then - you are certainly entitled to your opinion. I don't equate my podcast mic dynamics to my nearly 30 years of experience creating music that hundreds of millions of people have heard. Perhaps you can move past the sibilance of the mic and actually listen to what I am presenting in the content and then comment. I'd love for you to do that and come back to me for a dialog. Thanks for commenting!

    • @scottellis7573
      @scottellis7573 Місяць тому

      @@GGabrielMusic And you're welcome to keep piercing listeners ears because you can't hear that any more

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  Місяць тому

      Will do!

  • @bonafontciel
    @bonafontciel 6 місяців тому

    Anyone decent at making music is not going to use any of the Logic assistants or AI BS

    • @GGabrielMusic
      @GGabrielMusic  6 місяців тому

      Amen, amen! AI is all over Logic Pro 11 - it's now turned into GarageBand Ultra....Oy!!