I'm pretty sure the implication is that Nuibaba sacrificed Tatiana like all the other girls. Let's be real, they were probably planning to sacrifice her anyway and just make Zeke THINK she's still alive to protect by being loyal. At latest, she would've done it as soon as she got word that Zeke had been killed in battle. No more reason to keep her alive at that point, after all.
The funniest thing is, I actually had no idea I had to get Tatiana before fighting Zeke and Berkut. Fortunately (In this case) I actually lost to Zeke the first time so I went back to Nuibaba's route to grind, figuring she must be easier and when I found Tatiana, I was shook that I came this close to missing her and Zeke. That would have been depressing.
Jesus. I mean I understand they lost Ezekiel but they had no idea that Zeke was being forced to fight till the battle had happen. oh well but this is still interesting
This only makes me wish there was a special battle music that played when you fought a character you could potentially save. As in: -Deen -Sonya -Delthea -Zeke
i will elaborate this a bit more for you. if you visit the ezekiel map before going to nuibaba's abode, retreat from battle and THEN head to nuibaba's abode, tatiana will also be nowhere to be found. So it's not an event that is triggered by ezekiel's death per se. it's triggered by going left before going right. edit: nvm, just don't kill jerome before going right.
E. Salsbach Yeah, I'm pretty sure I went left first because I wanted to walk into the trap later rather than sooner, but then I saw how stacked Zeke and Jerome were and noped on out of there.
great game design right there; having you fight a recruitable character and not telling you what his deal is or how to recruit him until he's already dead. shouzou kaga was truly a genius.
I didn't even knew that Leon is actually that fragile as people says. In my hard/classic gameplay, he survived that battle with more than half hp, so... maybe just RNG thing. By the way, hi Swan! :D
I found Nuibaba way too challenging so I went this path first... worst decision of my life. When I went back and watched other people's gameplay I saw Taitiana and I was just thinking "woah is she dlc?!"
I killed this guy like I killed Tharja in Awakening, to which I had no idea I could have recruited in the first place in my first playthrough, interesting. Looks like I'm going to play it again.
tfw some people in the village mention the dragon's maw but alm isn't trapped in it despite the whole village wanting him and his party to die to necrodragons
At 2:13, the woman on the right next to Mathilda, when I caught a glimpse of hers I thought she was Princess Zelda for a moment... then realised we were in Valentia...
So during my first run I had no idea I was supposed to go save Tatiana first. After I realized that I had just killed zeke. So I ereased that save file and started all over. Worth it.
ReineDeLaSeine14 oh,i see. the mission was pretty hard for me too and i was playing on normal :'D archer tobin and cleric faye with the resshield did much of the work and it took looooooong
Nuibaba was hell but thanks to Naga I had a cleric which could summon dreadknights (or what ever they are called in english) I just watched them kill their entire group °L°
.midival_Minstrel Actually it's more like Nuibaba sacrificed Tatiana while Alm fought Zeke. The time you used to fight Zeke could have been the time you used to save Tatiana.
Seismic Swan She doesn't know about it. She only wishes that he would not remember his past and actually feels awful for wishing so. She's not a bad person.
Seismic Swan Umm wtf are you talking about. She hopes that his memories won't come back, because she's afraid he'll leave her. She knows nothing about his past.
O.... ow. Zeke and Tatiana are my favorite Echoes units (and my One True Pairing), so this hurts big time. ;A; Thanks for the video anyway. Keep up the good work.
Look at the description for the "What if Mathilda dies?" video. He put an update saying that nothing happens afterwards between alm and clive for saving delthea but not Mathilda
In my first blind play through, I thought I had to get Zeke first to get Tatiana. And since I was also scared of Nuibaba, I fought Jerome first to get Exp. And then when I went to the Village I saw all those people cursing Alm and all. And I thought they said that no matter what. It's not like I didn't clear the game without him though. I just... miss him.
plus,its not bad for anything.celica was defeated on my playthrough....which is technicly not logical at all if i think about it. i guess i know now what that "the princess who refuses to die" actually means xD lol
what if tatiana got killed before alm could get to her and zeke says oh good because he sees her in the after life either way this is darker than most fe games i like it
Robin The Master tactician I dunno, I find it hard to believe that Tatianna would be able to find something to kill herself with in a prison cell... I also I don't think she'd be the type to kill herself at all.
@@qazentro4444 One sadness can be their greatest weapon to kill oneself. There's a viable weapon your forgetting. The walls and bars of the cell. Should she consistently do it, she can give herself a pretty nasty would from blunt force trauma and likely bleed out to death.
If you kill Zeke, basically what happens is they don't need Tatiana anymore cuz Zeke is dead, so Nuibaba is allowed to sacrifice Tatiana to Duma, cuz what else are they gonna do with her?
Well celica had deen and sonya recruitable but wasn't tricky like alm with zeke lol when you beat sonya you get yourself deen and alm beat dread fighter and still have to fight zeke but not kill him but i actually didnt know that i should not kill zeke and now i didn't recruited him 🙁
i did this💔 i didnt meaned to kill him, i just thinked that he will join us and he can deafet nuibaba with us ;-; i killed 3 people in alm's route now;-;
What if during the sluice gate mission you kill delthea instead of saving her, would Luthier leave the party? Better yet, You Fail to save Mathilda but save delthea?
I will have a Delthea video coming up next week, but here's what I can tell you. Even if Mathilda dies, Clive's dialogs do not change. Luthier stays in the party even if he kills his own sister.
Collector Togami I wish that Nuibaba had some dialogue to allude to this. Something like "...And I feel in top form today, too. It's a shame. She was almost as beautiful as I am.".
J Slick Zeke is obeying Alm because that was Rudolf's Will. But Rudolf couldn't look sentimental in that battle and can't talk with him. I find it logic
The Thing i love about the special Dialogue is how everyone is insulting you and Alm is smiling like its nothing on the Bottom Screen.
Young Woman: I hope you ROT in the belly of a Necrodragon!
Balm: "This is fine."
Alm: Fools... Your insults only make me stronger!
0:45 "keep walking you dastards!"
alm:"ok :D" xD
+Seismic Swan I see what you did there, you dastard.
''Don't care, still got exp''
Well, damn. Nice to see they add in these little touches that really make this game unique.
Best part is that this was in the original Gaiden too.
Ocsttiac Yeah, but gaiden had so little dialouge and it almost did not feel present.
ninja gaiden?
Fire Emblem Gaiden, Washburn. Y'know, the original version of Shadows of Valentia? God I hate dumbasses.
Except I didn't say any of that or act as such. Nice try at a comeback, but you only failed.
I'm pretty sure the implication is that Nuibaba sacrificed Tatiana like all the other girls. Let's be real, they were probably planning to sacrifice her anyway and just make Zeke THINK she's still alive to protect by being loyal. At latest, she would've done it as soon as she got word that Zeke had been killed in battle. No more reason to keep her alive at that point, after all.
As somone who always loved Camus, this was hard to watch...
Camus you mean sirius right
hibiki847 you mean Xander right?
What was i thinking of course its xander although maybe selina xander might be a trap
Eldigan?
Are you asking who eldigan is cause he is a camus archetype
I ones killed Zeke before going to Nuibaba and then i realized i did something wrong
So i restarted the whole game :-)
You did the right thing.
You are a good person
Magically Clueless I did the same, im still in progress to getting back to where i was, im dreading the grinding i have to do all over again
Magically Clueless you're a legend
Magically Clueless At least you did the Correct thing in the end.
"Have you ever seen a drocoshield before"
*Alm holding one on his arm.*
"What? You don't want a dracoshield?"
You can never have enough Dracoshields!
The funniest thing is, I actually had no idea I had to get Tatiana before fighting Zeke and Berkut. Fortunately (In this case) I actually lost to Zeke the first time so I went back to Nuibaba's route to grind, figuring she must be easier and when I found Tatiana, I was shook that I came this close to missing her and Zeke.
That would have been depressing.
oh no
Mr. Krabs
oh
ok
rip the chances of Tatiana eating cheese in this playthrough
TheDark Reshiram that's the worst part
Jesus. I mean I understand they lost Ezekiel but they had no idea that Zeke was being forced to fight till the battle had happen. oh well but this is still interesting
Seismic Swan fair point
once a camus always a camus
This only makes me wish there was a special battle music that played when you fought a character you could potentially save. As in:
-Deen
-Sonya
-Delthea
-Zeke
i will elaborate this a bit more for you. if you visit the ezekiel map before going to nuibaba's abode, retreat from battle and THEN head to nuibaba's abode, tatiana will also be nowhere to be found. So it's not an event that is triggered by ezekiel's death per se. it's triggered by going left before going right.
edit: nvm, just don't kill jerome before going right.
James Levison curious. Mb, I didn't retreat immediately. I killed jerome and then retreated from the battle, leaving ezekiel alive.
E. Salsbach Yeah, I'm pretty sure I went left first because I wanted to walk into the trap later rather than sooner, but then I saw how stacked Zeke and Jerome were and noped on out of there.
E. Salsbach I did that. No Tatiana. Instant reset
great game design right there; having you fight a recruitable character and not telling you what his deal is or how to recruit him until he's already dead. shouzou kaga was truly a genius.
What if you free Tatiana, and then Zeke dies?
But he's a Green Unit, meaning he can die.
There is the use of cheats, however. It's not like he hasn't used them before in his videos.
I've heard that it's nearly impossible for Valbar to die, and yet he showed it off in a video.
I didn't even knew that Leon is actually that fragile as people says. In my hard/classic gameplay, he survived that battle with more than half hp, so... maybe just RNG thing.
By the way, hi Swan! :D
Exactly. But more specifically, ft.Mangs facebook page.
Szymon's my name. Maybe you recognise me. :D
Zeke turning against the enemy is probably one of the best moments in Echo's though.
Well... that means Princess Nyna stays posessed by Medeus and Marth will not get the best ending
I found Nuibaba way too challenging so I went this path first... worst decision of my life. When I went back and watched other people's gameplay I saw Taitiana and I was just thinking "woah is she dlc?!"
Broke "OMG you monster you killed Ezekiel"
Woke "Berkut is such a hunk!!"
Trust me I made that mistake save file are important.
I killed this guy like I killed Tharja in Awakening, to which I had no idea I could have recruited in the first place in my first playthrough, interesting. Looks like I'm going to play it again.
What happens if you recrude Est without Palla and Catria, but then she dies before speaking with them.
Or what if either Palla, Catria, or both die before you rescue Est?
I may or may not be working on that
Spare ur time. I acidentally didnt recruit palla/catria and est just had her normal recruitment but the 3 sisters thing taken out.
Hector4President that's not the same as them dying.
I tried it, nothing happens.
I accidentally killed zeke my first run so i know all about this
Sajan Patel did u restart the game?
tfw some people in the village mention the dragon's maw but alm isn't trapped in it despite the whole village wanting him and his party to die to necrodragons
At 2:13, the woman on the right next to Mathilda, when I caught a glimpse of hers I thought she was Princess Zelda for a moment... then realised we were in Valentia...
So during my first run I had no idea I was supposed to go save Tatiana first. After I realized that I had just killed zeke. So I ereased that save file and started all over. Worth it.
Giancarlo Bedolla why would one do that tho? xD do all of you guys dont like to sidequest?
LPFan I couldn't beat Nuibaba so I went to Zeke first
ReineDeLaSeine14 oh,i see. the mission was pretty hard for me too and i was playing on normal :'D archer tobin and cleric faye with the resshield did much of the work and it took looooooong
Nuibaba was hell
but thanks to Naga I had a cleric which could summon dreadknights (or what ever they are called in english)
I just watched them kill their entire group °L°
VenTheKeybladeMaster | Let's Plays lame tactics ._.
...I didn't even know I could get this guy. Welp, my mistake. Still gonna carry on with the playthrough.
I actually did this on my first run ;_; I knew he could be recruited but I didn't know I had to rescue Tatiana first
Alm looks so cool with a Draco Shield!
2:24 Wait. Is the game implying that Tatiana. . .killed herself? Because if so, that is not okay.
.midival_Minstrel
Actually it's more like Nuibaba sacrificed Tatiana while Alm fought Zeke. The time you used to fight Zeke could have been the time you used to save Tatiana.
Seismic Swan She doesn't know about it. She only wishes that he would not remember his past and actually feels awful for wishing so. She's not a bad person.
Seismic Swan Umm wtf are you talking about. She hopes that his memories won't come back, because she's afraid he'll leave her. She knows nothing about his past.
Seismic Swan Tatania founded Zeke at the shores, she doesn't know where he actually came from.
.midival_Minstrel if she did, it doesn't. Make sense. How would she know he died? She's in a cell
O.... ow. Zeke and Tatiana are my favorite Echoes units (and my One True Pairing), so this hurts big time. ;A;
Thanks for the video anyway. Keep up the good work.
What if Mathilda dies, and you end up recruiting delthea. Or what if delthea dies.
venawartmander :3 he did the mathilda one
% Mieu % I think he means "what if you recruit Delthea in the same playhtrough in which you let Mathilda die?".
how come you're so helpful outside the fort?
If Dealthea Dies, her brother will scream at you but will still stay on your team anyway
Look at the description for the "What if Mathilda dies?" video. He put an update saying that nothing happens afterwards between alm and clive for saving delthea but not Mathilda
In my first blind play through, I thought I had to get Zeke first to get Tatiana. And since I was also scared of Nuibaba, I fought Jerome first to get Exp. And then when I went to the Village I saw all those people cursing Alm and all. And I thought they said that no matter what. It's not like I didn't clear the game without him though. I just... miss him.
When I was at the split, I went after Jerome & Zeke, saw how much I had to fight and was like, F THIS I'M OUT. I'm glad I listened to myself
What if one of the kids die in the prologue?
They retreat.
plus,its not bad for anything.celica was defeated on my playthrough....which is technicly not logical at all if i think about it. i guess i know now what that "the princess who refuses to die" actually means xD lol
JulianLulz then Gray becomes the leader of Alms story
I would actually like that.
@@eevee1583 lol imagine if you kill all of them and the credits roll
You'd think they'd at least be a little happy Jerome being gone. Whiny Fire Emblem NPCs.
My guess as why Tatiana isn't there is because she heard that zeke was killed in the line of battle and went to go join him in the afterlife
I think Tatiana just....
offed herself if so then that is just depressing
ready to meme Actually, since they were only holding her to control Zeke, it's more likely Nuibaba just killed her once Zeke was dead.
AKA: What happens when you somehow forget to go into Nuibaba's lair and have no idea Tatiana even exists.
what if tatiana got killed before alm could get to her and zeke says oh good because he sees her in the after life either way this is darker than most fe games i like it
What if Catria and Palla die while Est survives the battle?
I know the result is just a monologue on the battleresult screen but.. man it hurts
Pillars of modern warfare such as Sugar coating has no place in Valentia.
To be fair, I didn't know saving Tatiana was an absolute requirement before facing Zeke...Nuibaba is so difficult.
I turned left because i recognised zeke's sprite and thought i could talk to him :(
GAME OVER/TIME PARADOX. "Alm, what have you done?! You created a time paradox! You cant go changing the future like that!"
They probably killed Tatiana when they found out Zeke died. They must of thought there was no use for her. That’s what I think happened.
you can probably assume that becuase you were too busy fighting zeke
Tatiana was taken away afterwards to be made a witch
Nah, it's implied by Alm in this video that it is most likely she killed herself.
And thus, Yumina and Yubello died in 2 years.
Assuming Ogma is incompetent and weak.
I was too stubborn to turn down a chance to spar with Camus... So I killed him.
Well duh how they explain Mystery emblem Siriusly
Tbh I almost accidentally did this, if it weren't for Alm dying and me having to start over, he would've been dead.
Ummm.....I think I might've created a time paradox
I think it's safe to assume Tatiana's absence might imply she was killed... maybe...
SigmaXVII_ or she killed herself.
Robin The Master tactician I dunno, I find it hard to believe that Tatianna would be able to find something to kill herself with in a prison cell... I also I don't think she'd be the type to kill herself at all.
@@qazentro4444 One sadness can be their greatest weapon to kill oneself. There's a viable weapon your forgetting. The walls and bars of the cell. Should she consistently do it, she can give herself a pretty nasty would from blunt force trauma and likely bleed out to death.
zeke cant die. once you hurt him he will shift into the beast titan....... wait what? wrong zeke?!
I was going to fight Zeke, then fight Nuibaba when I got stronger. Turns out, that was a horrible idea.
If you kill Zeke, basically what happens is they don't need Tatiana anymore cuz Zeke is dead, so Nuibaba is allowed to sacrifice Tatiana to Duma, cuz what else are they gonna do with her?
I never fought Nuibaba so this is how things went down for me
What If Zeke Dies......you restart the game.
Well celica had deen and sonya recruitable but wasn't tricky like alm with zeke lol when you beat sonya you get yourself deen and alm beat dread fighter and still have to fight zeke but not kill him but i actually didnt know that i should not kill zeke and now i didn't recruited him 🙁
I'll always regret not going to fight Nuibaba first
This was my first playthrough lol
Zeke's death sfx sounds epic tbh
i did this💔 i didnt meaned to kill him, i just thinked that he will join us and he can deafet nuibaba with us ;-; i killed 3 people in alm's route now;-;
Togami, stop tempting me to do an Extreme Fuckup playthrough...
no
This is why I can't get myself to kill characters
Hey, could you do what if Delthea dies?
Kevin Chen I did that. Nothing really happens.
Alm really got Sirius
What if during the sluice gate mission you kill delthea instead of saving her, would Luthier leave the party? Better yet, You Fail to save Mathilda but save delthea?
I will have a Delthea video coming up next week, but here's what I can tell you. Even if Mathilda dies, Clive's dialogs do not change. Luthier stays in the party even if he kills his own sister.
What if you recruit Tatiana, but Zeke dies in battle against Gerome?
hmm he shouldnt be possible to die since he appears in new mystery of the emblem
I feel like if you kill Jerome then Zeke should just surrender and join you anyway
What happens if you can't save Palla and Catria? I remember that Catria almost died on me.
How do you recruit him do you go to his girl first or do you go to him
Well it looks like I'm restarting Echoes YET AGAIN :)
What if Zeke dies after recruiting Tatiana? (I.e. he dies while being an ally, but before you recruit him)
Same as the rest of the video, villagers still get pissed
Thing is I killed zens on accident I thought Tobin wasn't gonna kill him.I didn't even get Mathilda or Tatiana, I'm such a good Echoes player :).
Tatiana or at i like to think someone told her of Zeke's death and she killed herself
So is this implying that by you going to fight and kill Zeke first, Nuibaba had time to sacrifice Tatiana?
Basically yeah
Collector Togami I wish that Nuibaba had some dialogue to allude to this. Something like "...And I feel in top form today, too. It's a shame. She was almost as beautiful as I am.".
You'll created a time paradox!!!
And everyone in the village hates you and you are severely punished for it.
I did it on my first playthrough.
I started an entirely new play through cause of this damn mistake
Zero Basssoul smart choice
Zero Basssoul same I realized to late and saved on accidently knowing that I made a mistake sucks back to grinding
i would have liked to see Tatiana cursing Alm for killing Zeke... =(
I went towards the town first cause I thought I would get quests to knock off to the left, but I messed up. I killed him.
So since Tatiana is of no more use Nuibaba sacrifices her? WTF.
So what if you already recruited Tatiana and she dies in this very mission?
My guess is they no longer had any use for her so they killed her.
Ninten Star12 Nah she killed herself. implied by alm.
This shit happened to me...
WHAT HAVE YOU DONE?
This might be a spoiler question for late act 4 but is there dialogue if you attack Rudolf with Zeke?
wow that's disappointing
ikr
J Slick Zeke is obeying Alm because that was Rudolf's Will. But Rudolf couldn't look sentimental in that battle and can't talk with him.
I find it logic
What if Clair dies before you meet Clive?
Seems like Nuibaba killed Tatiana, because since Zeke died she was no more useful alive.
Shsl Sadistic Tatiana is an amazing healer so idk how you came to that conclusion
Nah dude, with Nuibaba gone tatiana was just stuck in jail. Its implied by alm in this video that perhaps tatiana killed herself.
What if you recruit Tatiana, but she dies before or during the chapter where Zeke is recruited?
You get the same scene as if you refuse to let her join I think
I've never killed or lost Zeke in my playthroughs. This is really sad though.
What happens if you dont recruite tatiana by saying no and then fighting zeke
I think he won't join you but I am not sure
therealsanic Zeke only sides with you if she is present so I'd assume you'd still have to fight and kill him.
Shit! Now I have to start all over again!
Never used Zeke cuz I'm not a fans of Cavs in this game, but I'd be salty asf to get locked out of the best healer in the game over this.
What if you leave only Zeke alive on this map, then go rescue Tatiana?
The moment you reach Zeke's map, Tatiana can no longer be obtained. So this is not applicable sadly
Aw, I guess the programmers didn't think of that possibility. BTW, love these "What if..." vids. Keep'em coming, thanks.
That I shall. There is more to come for sure lol
Just leaves the peddlers in the prison... Hahaha
go back to akenaia, camus.
Perhaps she was sacrificed
I killed Zeke the first time i played the game cuz I thought we could just talk to him like in fates or awakening guess not lmao
The day citizens turned their backs on you.