AVOID DISASTER! Remote vs Canister Top Camping Gas stove. Fire Maple Polaris.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 45

  • @drytool
    @drytool Місяць тому +1

    I'm digging the Polaris canister top with the Petrel pot but love me a remote canister stove. Right now I'm using a blade 2 for that. I'd love for Fire Maple to make both Polaris stoves in titanium!

  • @genelucky4002
    @genelucky4002 11 місяців тому +2

    You comment that pressure regulated stoves are the future I found interesting. The MSR Windpro 2 with canister inverted seems to offer the benefits of a pressure regulator for low fuel pressure. I confess to have never used a presure regulated stove. As I avoid 20*F for outdoor cooking I suppose this subject is mainly academic rather than practical in my case. Enjoying your videos. Thank you Dave

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  11 місяців тому

      Thank you my friend and I appreciate your comment. ATB Dave

    • @drytool
      @drytool Місяць тому

      I suspect the pressure regulator stove might leave a little fuel in the end while the inverted canister set up uses every drop, but you have to weigh using every drop of fuel with efficiency, because using the canister inverted comes at the price of decreased efficiency along with the fact of lesser flame control which means the stove has less efficiency even when used upright. Also, inverting the canister increases the risk of flare up which can be catastrophic if you have to cook in your tent. I would recommend starting your stove with the canister upright then flipping it over outside the tent then moving it in if you have to.

  • @grahamswildcamping
    @grahamswildcamping Рік тому +2

    Informative video. I think it largely comes down to a choice between the lightness and simplicity of a canister top stove or the superior stabilty of a remote stove. My stove of choice by far is the Soto Windmaster. Very simple and well designed and no need for a wind shield even in quite strong breezes. In the summer and for lightnest I sometimes use a titanium meths burner with a light weight wind shield. Thanks for the video, ATB, Graham 👍

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому +1

      Hey Graham, great to hear from you, aye, as you say, personal choice. Have a look at the upcoming soto vs fire maple. Might sway you!

    • @grahamswildcamping
      @grahamswildcamping Рік тому

      @@Fellmandave1 I’ll look forward to it 👍

  • @davidpearce6831
    @davidpearce6831 Рік тому +1

    I've been looking for remote stove recommendations, very useful. I will definitely add the Polaris to my list! Thanks David.

  • @northumberlandmountainhopper
    @northumberlandmountainhopper Рік тому +2

    Hi and just found your channel so will sub been watching tunnel tent comparison,
    As for the cookers, I love my Soto, it is higher but so much better knowing your hose is not going to fail,
    So remote is better in a vestibule but I will stick to canister top stoves
    Cheers
    Adrian

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому

      Thanks Adrian, I will have a look at your channel too.

  • @fp4man542
    @fp4man542 Рік тому +1

    I must admit that I prefer the greater stability of a remote canister stove.
    At present, my stove of choice is the Primus Gravity iii. It can handle quite a decent sized pot, and the burner can go down to a gentle simmer.

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому

      Good choice!

    • @fp4man542
      @fp4man542 Рік тому +1

      @@Fellmandave1
      Or as an "old school" alternative, I've got an Optimus 8R. It's not as powerful as some modern stoves, but solidly built and very reliable.

  • @cornelius.budianto
    @cornelius.budianto Рік тому +1

    for the wind test, perhaps both stove should be placed on the same height level to be fair

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому

      Hi Cornelius, I had the wind at the same level though eh? Thanks for watching.

  • @MancOutdoors
    @MancOutdoors Рік тому +1

    Great video Dave , I use the jetboil mini mo which is great inside the vestibule and the MSR deluxe with the low down adapter that makes it super safe 👍

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому

      Oh yes, I forget about the low down adapter, they look like a brilliant idea.

    • @Four_Furry_Paws
      @Four_Furry_Paws Рік тому +1

      I have the deluxe as well. Love my MSR gear and like the idea of the lowdown. I’m not an ultralighter by any means, but the weight of it, plus the weight of the deluxe stove to attach to it is a bit off putting. Especially when you compare to the fire maple on test here the remote adapter is nearly as much in weight and cost as the Polaris stove on its own. Lots of food for thought here thanks again Dave.

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому

      @@Four_Furry_Paws nowts the bother!

  • @johnpatterson5744
    @johnpatterson5744 Рік тому +1

    Just treated myself to a Crud x Trangia 100th year anniversary special edition.had a Trangia in my youth many fond memories along with my old canvas 2 person tent.but it sadly disappeared,my brother probably snaffled it.👍

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому +2

      Nice one John. One of my videos soon will feature my Dad's primus that I have had for 45 years.

    • @drytool
      @drytool Місяць тому

      I think the Trangia system is pretty versatile because you can use it with the meths burner OR remote canister burner. This is important to me because most summers here in Colorado, alcohol stoves are illegal to use in the backcountry due to fire bans. When we have a fire ban we can only use a stove where the fuel is completely contained and you can turn off with a switch. You might get away with a carbon felt type alcohol stove with a lid or you might not. You never get away with a stove that can tip over and spill fuel.

  • @Four_Furry_Paws
    @Four_Furry_Paws Рік тому +1

    Very informative. Thank you. I do think you’re a bit light on the tunnocks wafers though, could definitely be an issue. 😉

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому

      What is the recommended and maximum safe dose Sean? 🤔

    • @Four_Furry_Paws
      @Four_Furry_Paws Рік тому +1

      @@Fellmandave1 🤔 Well, it’s very subjective but I think you’d want at least a couple in your pack. 1 is just going to be lonely. 😉

  • @xjessukx
    @xjessukx Рік тому +2

    I prefer a remote stove when cooking in the vestibule it somehow feels safer

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому +1

      Further away from the tent fabric too. I can only agree. Thanks for commenting.

  • @GeekfromYorkshire
    @GeekfromYorkshire Рік тому +1

    Thanks for the video. I was drawn to the "self contained" nature of a canister with stove in pot and so got a tiny stove, BUT the canister is so robust it doesn't need protecting, anything like as much as my teabags, porridge, etc. The remote stove only adds 37g by the time you factor the canister stabiliser.
    Does a pressure regulator help when you have a pre-heat tube on an inverted canister. The pressure is less variable when it's inverted so liquid to the stove?

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому +1

      You know, I don't know, they only seem to do one or the other. The soto stormbreaker that I am testing seems to have both. testing to come for that in the winter.
      Thanks for you comment.

  • @nattydred2593
    @nattydred2593 Рік тому +1

    I've destroyed 2 Fire Maple remote canister stoves by using a large pot and windshield, and having the hose melt and release from the stove end. One was a titanium similar to the blade 2, the other was similar without the regenerator.
    Don't know how to get spares.

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому +1

      Have you tried fire maple directly? I have seen hoses and spare parts on aliexpress. I have also sent a direct enquiry. Do you feel this is a weakness of the stove itself? Not a problem I have had, do you think the hose got in the flame?

    • @nattydred2593
      @nattydred2593 Рік тому

      @@Fellmandave1 I can't find contact information for support at fire maple. I tried leaving a review on the blade 2, but nothing came of it.
      I suspect all of these remote canister stoves use a similar hose, namely a rubber hose with a brass barb end, and brass cap crimp.
      If the hose gets too hot the rubber melts and the barb fitting can pull out or leak.
      Or possibly the rubber O ring at the generator fails and starts leaking gas, and once that ignites the hose is damaged. I don't know whether there's an issue with with the O-ring or hose materials, or the design doesn't allow them to stay sufficiently cool, or I was running them too hot for too long with too large a pan and too much wind screen.
      My hunch is the design needs more heat shielding to allow the hose end to stay cool.
      It's a pity because I like the stoves themselves. As you say, they're stable, support a big pot and are easily shielded from the wind. Very nice features.
      If I get a new hose I'll try dashing a tiny heat reflector and just plop it on top of the hose end.

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому +1

      Right Natty. I have had a response from fire maple. They say that they usually have hoses in stock on aliexpress but they are out. If you send delivery information to me, I will forward it and they will send you a new blade 2. fellmandave@gmail.com

  • @drytool
    @drytool Місяць тому +1

    In general, do you think a preheating tube or regulator works better for cold weather performance? Altitude performance? Do you know of any stoves that have both, or is that impossible?

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Місяць тому

      Never known them have both DT. In my limited experience, regulated works better, but preheat with white gas for really cold.

    • @drytool
      @drytool Місяць тому +1

      @@Fellmandave1 My experience tells me you're right concerning white gas. On Aconcagua we had to switch to white gas at 19000 feet. We couldn't get the canister stove to work. That was 1999, so I don't remember if it had a regulator or a preheat tube and flippable canister set up. We didn't have the old school copper wire through the burner/around the canister set up either because we planned on making the stove switch anyway.

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Місяць тому

      @drytool cool! I have bought some fancy winter gas to try though. Out tomorrow night, looks to be about -2c

  • @thegeordiefellwalker8878
    @thegeordiefellwalker8878 Рік тому +1

    one pot cook system for me with titanium canister top burner & msr cannister support 👍 little tip water boils slightly quicker without lid on 😉do i detect a slight geordie accent? just subbed👍

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому

      Hey mate
      From North Staffordshire originally but have lived and worked in Newcastle/Whitley Bay for 30 years. Thanks for the sub!

  • @Martycycleman
    @Martycycleman Рік тому +1

    You boiled the water for over 3 min' of course. I've noticed gas burners now don't seem have gas warmer tubes?

    • @Fellmandave1
      @Fellmandave1  Рік тому +1

      Ho Marty, have a look at my VERY LONG remote canister test. Pre heat tubes are around, but the pressure regulator negates the need it seems.

    • @Martycycleman
      @Martycycleman Рік тому

      I did wonder about the pressure reg. So how does it pre heat the gas/ liquid. Cheers for that

  • @OldNavajoTricks
    @OldNavajoTricks Рік тому +1

    Tunnocks cara, subbed 😂