Ms. Brittany. There are a lot of people that have commented on the true meaning of the title track on this Album. I can only tell you what I know is true. As a veteran of 38 years, this song was released when I was in my first enlistment. Since first hearing this, I have held it a one of the greatest songs ever written. I have had to experience the loss of my brothers and sisters in arms and every time it happened, I would play this song as part of my healing process. In order to let you better understand what the actual meaning of the lyrics are, here is an excerpt from an interview with Bill Flanagan and Mark Knopfler. Mark was the gentleman singing and playing the lead guitar. This entire song was written over the Falkland War. In an interview with Bill Flanagan, Knopfler spoke about the need to get inside the character as a songwriter to do the story justice. “’Brothers in Arms’ is sung by a soldier who is dying on the battlefield,” he said. “You can’t just write off the top of your head; you have to dig deep to get those things. You have to experience, if a thing is really going to be realistic, if you’re gonna try and get whatever you feel across. So, in a sense you’re an outsider, but you’re also digging inside to do it properly. I don’t think you can get away scot-free with these things; otherwise, it’s just not going to work. If you stay outside of these experiences, they’re just not going to translate to people.” The following is how Mark explained it. (These mist-covered mountain, are a home now for me. But my home is the lowlands, and always will be) The lyric begins, contrasting that with the lowlands where he grew up and where he is, the mist covered mountains where he is laying terminally wounded on a battlefield. (Some day you'll return to your valleys and your farms. And you'll no longer burn to be brothers in arms) He foresees his death and a time when the war will be over and when those who survive the combat will leave the battlefield and return to their valleys and their farms, a fate he won’t enjoy. He also admires and cherishes his fellow soldiers’ bravery amidst the war’s chaos and tumult. Yet knowing there will come a time when the bond they have will fade and they will live their separate lives. (Through these fields of destruction, Baptisms of fire, I've witnessed your suffering. As the battle raged higher and though they did hurt me so bad. In the fear and alarm, you did not desert me, my brothers in arms). This is how he described the bonding of soldiers who were fighting next to each other, seeing their friends being injured and killed. The lyrics switch to the individual soldier once again. As he realized he has been seriously wounded and his buddies came to his aid and did not just leave him to die alone on the battlefield. (There's so many different worlds, So many different suns. And we have just one world, But we live in different ones). Mark said, "that we can be neighbors and yet never share anything in common." He went on to say that most humans want the same things in life even though we all live in different places on the earth. (Now the sun's gone to hell, And the moon's riding high. Let me bid you farewell, every man has to die). The sun has set and the moon is up, as the soldier knows he is about to pass. But he wants to convey to his buddies, that they shouldn't feel bad because of his death. (But it's written in the starlight, and every line in your palm. We're fools to make war, on our brothers in arms). He described how destiny has been written, using the stars and the individual as examples. He went further to say: that in fact, we all have a destiny, yet we never take the time to yield to our fragility and how short our lives are. That most people take life for granted and fail to cherish everything that they are blessed with. This final lyric was a direct statement sent to soldiers. Saying that when politicians decide to go to war, that politicians should be the ones who are forced to fight the battles and soldiers are foolish to fight other soldiers for political gains. All the while, Knopfler’s allows his emotional and lyrical guitar to release the emotion pent up by the moody musical atmosphere and his controlled vocal. This gorgeous contrast makes the song a durable choice for movie and television soundtracks. I hope this helps you understand how the song was developed, the meaning of the lyrics and Marks intent for all who listen.
You can never have the feeling unless you've been there. Unless you've seen mates die for politicians ego's. We were young full of hope for the future, but foolish enough to trust the world's leadership.
I was in the Army when this came out and there was an old Master sergeant, serving out the rest of his 30 years who was a Vietnam vet. I'll give you his interpretation: It's starts off with him talking about leaving his home to go fight in some war and meeting people from all over his country that were going to fight as well. Those became his brothers in arms. They then go off to fight and he talks about being injured and hurt and yet his brothers in arms did not desert him. The bond between them has become unshakable. Then it progresses to thinking about their enemies and that they too are just brothers in arms. "We have just this one world, but we live in different ones." and at the end he realizes that we're all brothers in arms and we're fools to make war on each other. It's the only time I ever saw the guy choke up and I've pretty much gone with that interpretation ever since.
That is very close to Mark‘s interpretation of a diary from a UK Soldier who fought in this war. Mark spent most of the Album income to soldiers with PTSD.
I love that song. As an Argentinean, it touches me closely because of the war that took place in 1982, no matter which side you were on, they always be, "brothers in arms",
Same here, brother. That war inspired this song. And it makes me sad when people (mostly Americans, I'm afraid) miss the message of this song. It has the best message possible, antiwar, and, no matter the side, we are in same s..t, we are brothers (hopefully, without arms).
Hi Brittany, this song is about a soldier dying on a mountain top thousands of mile s from home, in the pointless Falklands war in 1982, whether he was Brit (British) or an Argie (Argentinian) is neither here nor there. So poignant now in the troubled times we live in. albeit the lyrics are more that 40yrs old. Peace for all
Brit This is a story of a man dying on the battlefield, surrounded by his fellow soldiers as his last breath of life leaves his body. It’s his final conversation with his brothers in arms. It was written as a tribute to the soldiers who fought in the Falkland war in the early 80s. Although that’s the basis of the song, it’s a universal theme about the futility of all wars and all the brothers in arms who get caught up in them. I think this song is a masterpiece written by one of the greatest guitarist/songwriters of the last and current century. And you are spot on with your description that his guitar is weeping. Mark Knopfler is probably the most emotive guitar players alive. He doesn’t play a guitar, he makes love with his guitar and we are fortunate enough to get to listen in. Here’s a link to the official video. It helps lay the groundwork for the song. I highly recommend it. You’ll be richly rewarded if you take the time to watch it. ua-cam.com/video/jhdFe3evXpk/v-deo.html
British Army Veteran here. I was to young to be involved in the Falklands War from which this song was written in reference of. However in latter years I did get to serve in the Army in an Infantry Regiment that has seen plenty of operational deployments in modern times, four years of that I was part of. this song always makes me remember those brothers from another Mother that never returned from those various theatres where we all gave our blood, sweat and tears.... some their lives. Gone but never forgotten.
Agree Mark Knopfler is a true genius on the guitar, and it's completely true when Mark plays his guitar you feel it is a human voice reaching out to you, but his lyrics are also masterpieces as you hear in this song... the way he truly deeply honors and respect those have fought and died while calling out the awful loss and waste war causes us is simply breathtaking
This song came out almost 40 years ago and I still cannot listen to it without crying. For me, the entire song sets up the guitar solo at the end that just feels like it reaches inside of me and violently yanks something out. It's visceral.
In 2007, a new version of this track featuring Mark Knopfler was released to commemorate the 25th anniversary of the Falklands War. Proceeds from the sale of the single went to a program that brought British veterans back to the site of the war in an effort to help them deal with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.
Mark Knopfler is perhaps the most technically skilled guitarist on the planet right now. Other guitarists might be more emotive, but no one beats Knopfler for sheer skill. This song always makes me think of something a soldier named Darryl Powers (better known as "Shifty" Powers)) once said. Speaking of the Germans he fought in World War II, he said, "Those guys and I might have had a lot in common. Under different circumstances we might have been good friends. But we had to to what we had to do, and they had to do what they had to do." Its the realization that the enemy you are fighting aren't demons but are just as human as you that gets to me.
Mark Knopfler is one of the purest guitarist players to ever pick up a guitar. He uses a 3 finger picking style with no pick. Their biggest hit is Sultans of Swings which is a must listen.
Thanks for the swift response Bill. Have you heard "Brothers in Arms" played at the Nelson Mandela concert at Wembley Stadium? Eric Clapton playing rythm guitar and Mark Knopfler wiping tears from his eyes.. A truly emotional and wonderful rendition of this classic song.
no, but I'll check it out. Have you ever listened to the album Neck and Neck he did with Chet Atkins? Some of the most amazing guitar work ever put on record.
@@simonashworth8825 just watched it. What is so amazing about both Clapton and Knopfler while technically their song may not be the most difficult to play the raw feeling they put into each note is nearly impossible to do. I can play Sultans pretty much note for note even using a 3 finger-picking style but it still doesn't come anywhere near sounding as good.
The ingenuity of the lyrics lies in the double meaning of "Brothers in Arms". Usually, this phrase would be used for the men fighting alongside you (your comrades, a bond forged in battle, yada-yada). But the song changes it to the meaning that we are all brothers (living in this one world), so that when we fight each other in war, we fight against our own "Brothers in Arms".
Brothers In Arms was the first CD I ever purchased. I had an in car CD player and a very powerful sound system and I often had to stop my car just to listen to this track really loudly so I could experience the emotion to its fullest effect! I’m 65 now and a bit deaf!
It is about the Falkland war, between Great Britain and Argentina. About the islands off shore Argentina. He belongs to the top guitarists and his fingerpicking style is unique. He is a genius in songwriting and painting pictures with his music. As many fans of him, i would consider you to listen to „Sultans of swing, alchemy live“. Stay safe and thank you for your reactions and work you put in to it!
Mark makes the guitar sing everytime he plays. He is one one the most emotive lyricists of our time. This song is held very dear by all UK serving and former military personnel. It is played at many service funeral or memorial.I have had it locked in,for when my time is up too. This is the story of a soldier during the 1982 Falklands war, he is laying there breathing his last surrounded by his mates, it's about the futility of war.
As an Air Force veteran this hits hard. I worked with and met many combat veterans. No matter the branch we all feel the loss when we lose a brother or sister. Thank you to all who serve and to those who paid the ultimate sacrifice.
I feel you, bro. Former Air Force MP K9 officer and now still in security industry. This song has been played and will be played in too many funerals of brothers.
This song has always touched my soul. As a soldier and a sailor, I see this song as a salute to all those who have born the mantle of war and the deep price paid by both the dead and those who came home.
Knopfler said the song is from the perspective of a mortally wounded soldier on a battlefield far from home who realizes he is dying...... "These mist-covered mountains are a home now for me......" Great perceptive reaction!
Once you've written, composed, recorded and performed a song like brothers in arms, there's nothing left to do. This song scratches the surface of just how incredible Dire Straits were and particularly Mark Knopfler. He is a virtuoso and his music will be ringing through the airwaves until the end of time. I love someone new discovering Mark Knopfler and Dire Straits. Top tier and great reaction of course 😀
This wasn't really the music video, but this is THE best live version of this song. It has me in tears, every single time, when the guitar screams out in pain after the pedal steel guitar solo.
I just listened to your react video like a week ago. And again just now. This specific live version is particularly evocative. Tearing up s second time. You chose well. My mom loved Dire Straits so I listened to the Brothers In Arms album when I was like 8 on.
You will not believe how Home Free does a cover of this in a deep bass. It is an A cappella masterpiece. Whereas Mark, who wrote the song, focused heavily on his guitar playing acumen, HF focused on the lyrics in a very sobering and emotional performance. This was about the needless war between the UK and Argentina over the control of the Falkland Islands in the South Atlantic. Argentina invaded the Falklands in 1982 and the British had governed it for nearly 150 years. The UK successfully defended their control of the islands and still governs them today.
Also, if you'd like to hear another tear jerker, Romeo and Juliet by Dire Straits is a masterpiece. Such a beautiful love song. I guess what I'm saying is, this band is amazing.
I believe the person singing/speaking the lyrics is a soldier far from home. He is mortally wounded and knows that he will never see his homeland again but he is comforted by the comradeship of his "Brothers in arms". He also questions the futility of fighting the brothers in arms on the other side. This was written by Mark Knopfler at the time of the Falklands War.
I'm a 60 yo combat veteran and this song speaks to me in a way that few songs do. Dire Strait's wrote "Brothers in Arms" as a anti war song but it's become so much more as it speaks to the lost me and my Brothers in Arms feel for the lost of friends and the lost of soul and self one feels after coming home. It's the closets thing to explaining the empty feeling I have here in the US after being in combat.
Perfectly said...and Mark Knopflers lyrics I think are so powerful because he deeply appreciates the courage and loss our military men and women face and at the same time remind us of the terrible losses created in wars...Sherman had it right "war is hell" and we all better never forget it...
@@fifi23o5I think a lot more of us in the US understand this song than you give us credit for, but that's understandable. There is a vocal segment of the population, especially on the right, which glorifies combat and war. But a lot of us who are old enough - I'm 66 myself - have lost family members in war, or had family come back from war altered by the experience. My father fought in Korea, and he didn't talk about it much, but he was proud to have served alongside fellow Marines, even though he sometimes jumped at loud noises and could barely tolerate the fireworks when he took us kids to 4th of July celebrations. He watched with sadness as the Vietnam War dragged on and on, seeing history repeat itself for no good reason. I think of him every time I hear this song. Tomorrow (August 16 2023) marks the 10th anniversary of his passing, and I watched this reaction in his honor. Semper Fi, dad.
Yes, but check out the "Band Of The Royal Marines" version. The young woman who sings it is a serving soldier and has served in Afghanistan. Check the emotion on her face when she sings, "you did not desert me my brothers in arms."
Great reaction Britt! I’ve known this song for nearly 40 years but this is the first time I’ve really understood the words. You are a very good teacher.
I’m glad that you pulled up the lyrics. The best way to hear this song is to watch the official video. I beleave that this song was written at the time, when The Falkland war had just finished.
Het Britt. It really meant a lot that you liked the song. Maaaany years ago I did audio for Knofler/Straits. I love how you got it. I think it used to be about past wars, I don't thing so much now. It's about all wars and those who are the same but die. It holds up as much today as it did 35 years ago. :)
Love that you tend to react to the live performances. Sultans of Swing from the Alchemy tour is a great one, so much energy and togetherness in this band.
Mark Knopfler is one of the best rock guitarists out there and it's all finger picking. He's a very talented singer/songwriter as well. He wrote and played the soundtrack for the movie "Princess Bride". If you're into hard driving rock, check out "Sultans of Swing" live from the Alchemy tour. Also, "Romeo and Juliette" any version.
One of my favorite songs. So beautiful. Lyrics and music. Mark knoffler one of the goats of guitar. This band is legendary, Worth discovering more of their songs. Lots of funky rock stuff as well. So much swag and style. Great choice. I like that you looked into the powerful words as well!
Here I am, a near-70-year old in rural Ireland, and I wanted to say how much I appreciate your reactions to some of the favourite songs from my past, and respect for pulling up the lyrics to songs when you can't quite get the UK accents. LOVE your vids.
Mark Knopfler plays guitar so tastefully and this song is so unusual in the way that it looks at war from the perspective of both sides. Another song about soldiers who become brothers that I'm sure you would love is Billy Joel's "Goodnight Saigon". It will break your heart. Nice reaction.
I now live in Nashville, TN. In my church there are 2 tall brass candlesticks on the alter. They were dedicated to our church by the family of a man who served in Vietnam. He commanded Vietnamese troops, and he was so beloved that his troops collected a huge amount of brass bullet casings to create these 5 Ft. tall candlesticks. So inspiring!
Miami Vice was HUGE back in the day. They got some top-flight music in the show, and they had a very memorable scene with this song as the soundtrack. Mark Knopfler's guitar has a voice all its own. One of those great songs that few people ever try to cover; I don't think people think they can add anything to it. American Songwriter has a great breakdown on this song - written from the perspective of a dying soldier.
Dire Straits were superb. They had such a variety of songs, and told such great stories. Another awesome song, among many, is Private Investigations, from the perspective of a P.I. There are many more to discover, and we would love to enjoy the journey with you.
When I went through my law enforcement academy we had to come up with a graduation motto. Our motto was - We all go home at the end of our shift.Brothers and sisters all wearing the badge. We stood together.
Every goddamn time. Yes, i have that same experience every time i listen to this. Possibly the greatest piece of guitar ever written. It seems so simple but the depth he puts into it. You can almost feel his soul breaking.
Nobody plays guitar like mark knopfler and and a great voice, i grow up with this super band, i love that awsome sound. The first LP was absolutly outstanding, new sound, sultens of swing 👑♥️🌹💫
It's all and every war. Its a song about the people sent to fight them. Its about the soldiers. We are all the same. If given the choice we wouldn't fight our brothers who have the same lines on our palms...but we sign up to fight for our country which, when you come down to it, means killing people in another life we would've called friends.
As others have said here, this is Mark's tribute to British soldiers fighting the Falklands War in 1982 - but of course soldiers of all nations immediately relate to it, and quite rightly so. Heartbreaking lyrics, and that's just from his guitar!
I was a 21 yo exchange student from USA in Aarhus Denmark when this album broke. Everyone stopped to listen when this song played. I felt a small sense of the depth of WW2 still casting its shadow. I wondered if Danes were forced to choose, to make war on their brothers.
I was serving in the army when the war this song is about (The Falkands War) was in full flow. I have a really hard time listening to it and not choking up. "Deeply moving" doesn't even scratch the surface.
My mother survived the bombing of London in World War II she mentioned she mentioned what I know of in high school never thought about it but she said like this is like my brother in arms from Canada my mom was a war right but still British makes you think right now I got a little bit of a tear God bless moms
I've loved this song since they released it in 1985, and while I love so many Dire Straits songs, this has always been my favorite of theirs. Since Mark Knopfler explained in an interview that this song are the final words of a dying soldier, I imagine, JUST as you explained, the guitar is his cry, weeping, and the "explosion" like drums/bass are the air strikes falling around them, as he succumbs to the last, big blast. Now, having heard this one, you MUST listen to your new friends, HOME FREE's rendition of this song, in acapella... A true master piece!
Mark Knopfler performed this song during his solo tour in my home town years ago and we felt it was the pinnacle of the show. The band waved good-bye, they walked off the stage. Then the keyboards of Money For Nothing started to play and hell was unleashed in the audience:)
One of the greatest songs ever. I'm retired military and lost so many Brothers In Arms over the years and now at 71 years old. I'm losing Brothers (and Sisters) in Arms almost daily ! You can say you understand the song but in all honesty, if you have not served and lost Your Brothers in Arms... you will never feel in your sole and being, the true loss of "Brothers in Arms"
Great reaction (as usual) 😁My favourite piece of music from any generation. As a 55yr old former soldier, I agree with the other veteran's comments regarding the meaning of the song. If you've served, you not only understand this song, you feel it. Huge respect to all who've served, and those who still continue to serve- stay safe 😊
The song was used in the Miami Vice episode "Out Where the Buses Don't Run" about a retired Vice cop who has an obsession with a failed investigation from years ago. He draws Crockett and Tubbs into his obsession and his descent into madness, grief and guilt. The aching sadness of the song eerily narrates the surreal ending. An iconic moment in cinema.
Mark Knopfler is one of my favorite guitarists. Love Dire Straits, but Mark’s solo work is wonderful too. His album Golden Heart is a favorite❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
It was a commentary on the Falklands War. They even re-recorded it on the 25th anniversary of the war, to raise funds for veterans still affected by their involvement in it. The song is one of the most iconic, and Mark Knopfler's guitar solos in it are generally regarded as among the best in the history of music. Knopfler is also known as one of the greatest guitarists ever. You can hear more of his prodigious play in "Money for Nothing" and "Walk of Life," or the entire "Brothers in Arms" album.
I still have the original Brothers In Arms album. Love the Home Free version for the clarity of the lyrics while maintaining the depth of feeling Mark gifts us.
Diane, that's so true... In Mark Knopfler's music we are easily overwhelmed by artistry of his guitar and music, but his lyrics are just as stunning when you hear them clearly, live recordings in large venues never do his lyrics justice... I've heard the Home Free Acappella version and you're so right, the lyrics hit you with incredible emotional power!
A couple things: 1. You love flute? Check out a guy named Ian Anderson and his band, Jethro Tull. 2. I believe this song was a response to The Falkland Islands War between the U.K. and Argentina. 3. The front side of the album had the hits, but the back side of the album is just sublime.
There are some really beautiful words written below. Thank each and every one of you for sharing your perspective and histories. They add so much and allow each of us to get a glimpse through your eyes. Britt, I want to tell you something about all this - and this gig you've bravely taken on. Getting other's perspectives is the whole reason we enjoy these reactions, but you should feel free to give your perspective, too. An important lesson about art is that once the artist shares with one other, they lose to right to tell that person how to interpret it. They can certainly share what they were thinking and intended, but each person has the right - the responsibility - to consider their own meaning. Please share your perspective with others. There will probably be trolls who will criticize. Whatever. We're here because we like your reaction and part of that is your perspective. "The meaning" comes from you.
This song is very special and emotional for soldiers, fire fighters and law enforcement officers. Anyone that had someone cover your back in the worst of situations. Where we've lost brothers or sisters on the job. It's the intense pain we carried/carry in the danger of the moment and the memories of those fallen that once stood by our side. 💔
First time I’ve heard this version; yes Mark wrote in in response to the Falklands war in the early 1980’s. So good, thanks for playing it. All they did was excellent; check out all the songs on Alchemy Live!
I love this song, It's my favorite Dire Straits song. It's so emotional, and sounds so great when cranked up and sitting in the dark. There is another couple songs that hit me the same way, Funkadelic's song Maggot Brain is one of them. The producer told the lead guitarist to play as if he had been told his mother had died. The other one is also a great story of soldiers and war from Frank Marino - Stories of a Hero. Such a great story that makes you appreciate even more the sacrifice that men and women give to protect their country ( any and all ).
I am a veteran and was once a part of a group of people that all depend upon each other to accomplish a certain goal. In some circumstances if one guy doesn't do what everyone is trained to do people can suffer unduly. If done right and everyone does their job you go home to live another day.
The official video to this amazing and powerful tune tells the story of what the song is all about. The genius of Mark Knopfler never fails to astonish me.
Hey Brit, I loved your instant recognition of what this song can mean - very perceptive of you. I admire the ease of your communicative ability, whether it be with an expression, or words. For some reason, I just felt compelled to share my thoughts with you. You don't have to read it, but here goes: I was a mere lad of 11 when I first heard this offering. I was at my desk in my bedroom getting on with my homework, when my attention was zapped and I quieted everything to sit up and listen to the radio. I could not understand why this concoction of instruments, poetry and melody drew tears out from my soul. All I knew was that this was one of those special moments in time, which doesn't come by too often - somehow, I knew this, even at my young age. As I listened, the lump in my throat stiffened and my breathing shallow-ed. The accompanying lyrics to this haunting melody, instantly transported me into a vision of the strife and chaos which dances with conflict! How could this be? I thought. I had never been in the midst of such an environment, yet my chest tightened and began to spasm with a sadness, hither to unknown. The tears coursed down my cheeks and I was filled with utter despair. How could something so randomly beautiful evoke such melancholy? Perhaps, I shall never understand.... The song ended and I remained transfixed and still sobbing. It was then, I knew I had to find and bring this song closer to me. I broke out the change from my piggy-bank and would head over to the music store at my earliest opportunity. I eagerly rummaged around in the store and found the album, 'Brothers in Arms.' I snatched the cassette album, paid for it and headed straight home to listen..... That was many years ago and I have since owned that particular album through all of its incarnations, from Vinyl to CDs. The album and that song in particular, existed with me in every vehicle and iPod I have ever owned. I will let others enlighten you on the era and conflict it was created for. Needless to say, it doesn't matter which war it was written for, as it slots into before, during and the aftermath of all strife. The ultimate sacrifice for what makes us noble. Mark Knopfler is known for his guitar skills and is very well respected. He is truly one of the Masters. (along with SRV!) Though not being the best of singers, the music speaks for itself. I still choke up every time I hear this song and when left alone to enjoy, I invariably have tears wrung from my very soul. There are many songs which resonate with others, but this one always stops me dead in my tracks, allowing me to be grateful for its cleansing, in this little corner of the Universe. I will never understand fully, the peace which fills me after such soul-searching... God Bless!
Knopfler seems to have a direct connection to warriors. This tune, along with his "Piper Till The End" and "Done With Bonaparte" are simply brilliant stories about human existence during chaos. Your reaction was on target.
Hi Britt Firstly, I absolutely loved your reaction including your articulation of your emotions. Thank you!! Mark wrote this in the wake of the Falklands war between Britain and Argentina in 1982. For me this is the greatest anti war song ever written. You are so right when you talk about Mark's guitar weeping. Mark is my all time favourite guitarist and an absolutely brilliant songwriter and storyteller. You are getting to know genius!! If you explore them further I might suggest continuing to watch them live, particularly their Alchemy live tour of 1983. Some of their performances include Sultans of Swing, the absolutely mesmerising Telegraph Road, the beautiful Romeo and Juliet and the dark and mysterious Private investigations. You won't regret it!! Take care and warmest wishes from the UK.
Martin, Mark Knopfler is one of the greatest musical artists I've ever heard, but the marriage of his heart rending guitar WITH the brilliant lyrics that honor the courage and sacrifice of our armed forces while gently get us all to honestly remember the terrible loss and waste of life wars cause brings this song to genius level.
Ms. Brittany. There are a lot of people that have commented on the true meaning of the title track on this Album. I can only tell you what I know is true. As a veteran of 38 years, this song was released when I was in my first enlistment. Since first hearing this, I have held it a one of the greatest songs ever written. I have had to experience the loss of my brothers and sisters in arms and every time it happened, I would play this song as part of my healing process. In order to let you better understand what the actual meaning of the lyrics are, here is an excerpt from an interview with Bill Flanagan and Mark Knopfler. Mark was the gentleman singing and playing the lead guitar.
This entire song was written over the Falkland War.
In an interview with Bill Flanagan, Knopfler spoke about the need to get inside the character as a songwriter to do the story justice. “’Brothers in Arms’ is sung by a soldier who is dying on the battlefield,” he said. “You can’t just write off the top of your head; you have to dig deep to get those things. You have to experience, if a thing is really going to be realistic, if you’re gonna try and get whatever you feel across. So, in a sense you’re an outsider, but you’re also digging inside to do it properly. I don’t think you can get away scot-free with these things; otherwise, it’s just not going to work. If you stay outside of these experiences, they’re just not going to translate to people.”
The following is how Mark explained it.
(These mist-covered mountain, are a home now for me. But my home is the lowlands, and always will be)
The lyric begins, contrasting that with the lowlands where he grew up and where he is, the mist covered mountains where he is laying terminally wounded on a battlefield.
(Some day you'll return to your valleys and your farms. And you'll no longer burn to be brothers in arms)
He foresees his death and a time when the war will be over and when those who survive the combat will leave the battlefield and return to their valleys and their farms, a fate he won’t enjoy. He also admires and cherishes his fellow soldiers’ bravery amidst the war’s chaos and tumult. Yet knowing there will come a time when the bond they have will fade and they will live their separate lives.
(Through these fields of destruction, Baptisms of fire, I've witnessed your suffering. As the battle raged higher and though they did hurt me so bad. In the fear and alarm, you did not desert me, my brothers in arms).
This is how he described the bonding of soldiers who were fighting next to each other, seeing their friends being injured and killed.
The lyrics switch to the individual soldier once again. As he realized he has been seriously wounded and his buddies came to his aid and did not just leave him to die alone on the battlefield.
(There's so many different worlds, So many different suns. And we have just one world, But we live in different ones).
Mark said, "that we can be neighbors and yet never share anything in common." He went on to say that most humans want the same things in life even though we all live in different places on the earth.
(Now the sun's gone to hell, And the moon's riding high. Let me bid you farewell, every man has to die).
The sun has set and the moon is up, as the soldier knows he is about to pass. But he wants to convey to his buddies, that they shouldn't feel bad because of his death.
(But it's written in the starlight, and every line in your palm. We're fools to make war, on our brothers in arms).
He described how destiny has been written, using the stars and the individual as examples. He went further to say: that in fact, we all have a destiny, yet we never take the time to yield to our fragility and how short our lives are. That most people take life for granted and fail to cherish everything that they are blessed with.
This final lyric was a direct statement sent to soldiers. Saying that when politicians decide to go to war, that politicians should be the ones who are forced to fight the battles and soldiers are foolish to fight other soldiers for political gains.
All the while, Knopfler’s allows his emotional and lyrical guitar to release the emotion pent up by the moody musical atmosphere and his controlled vocal. This gorgeous contrast makes the song a durable choice for movie and television soundtracks.
I hope this helps you understand how the song was developed, the meaning of the lyrics and Marks intent for all who listen.
Well written. Thank you and peace be with you.
You can never have the feeling unless you've been there. Unless you've seen mates die for politicians ego's. We were young full of hope for the future, but foolish enough to trust the world's leadership.
Brilliant explanation , thank you !
Thank you so much for your service, and explanation Sir. Perfectly put.
Thank you and may God be with you always.
I was in the Army when this came out and there was an old Master sergeant, serving out the rest of his 30 years who was a Vietnam vet. I'll give you his interpretation: It's starts off with him talking about leaving his home to go fight in some war and meeting people from all over his country that were going to fight as well. Those became his brothers in arms. They then go off to fight and he talks about being injured and hurt and yet his brothers in arms did not desert him. The bond between them has become unshakable. Then it progresses to thinking about their enemies and that they too are just brothers in arms. "We have just this one world, but we live in different ones." and at the end he realizes that we're all brothers in arms and we're fools to make war on each other. It's the only time I ever saw the guy choke up and I've pretty much gone with that interpretation ever since.
I think that Master Sargent hit the nail on the head.
I thank God that I was not old enough for Vietnam , I'm 62 . lost a few family members
That is very close to Mark‘s interpretation of a diary from a UK Soldier who fought in this war. Mark spent most of the Album income to soldiers with PTSD.
@@waligerber9410 Did not know that, but it makes sense.
About the Falklands war
I love that song. As an Argentinean, it touches me closely because of the war that took place in 1982, no matter which side you were on, they always be, "brothers in arms",
Brit here, I got your back.
It's sad that so many died on both sides but conscripts is terrible.
Same here, brother. That war inspired this song. And it makes me sad when people (mostly Americans, I'm afraid) miss the message of this song. It has the best message possible, antiwar, and, no matter the side, we are in same s..t, we are brothers (hopefully, without arms).
Amen brother, all boys. Sadly missed .
ive heard it said,
war is old men talking, and young men dying,
Hi Brittany, this song is about a soldier dying on a mountain top thousands of mile s from home, in the pointless Falklands war in 1982, whether he was Brit (British) or an Argie (Argentinian) is neither here nor there. So poignant now in the troubled times we live in. albeit the lyrics are more that 40yrs old. Peace for all
Brit
This is a story of a man dying on the battlefield, surrounded by his fellow soldiers as his last breath of life leaves his body. It’s his final conversation with his brothers in arms. It was written as a tribute to the soldiers who fought in the Falkland war in the early 80s.
Although that’s the basis of the song, it’s a universal theme about the futility of all wars and all the brothers in arms who get caught up in them.
I think this song is a masterpiece written by one of the greatest guitarist/songwriters of the last and current century. And you are spot on with your description that his guitar is weeping. Mark Knopfler is probably the most emotive guitar players alive. He doesn’t play a guitar, he makes love with his guitar and we are fortunate enough to get to listen in.
Here’s a link to the official video. It helps lay the groundwork for the song. I highly recommend it. You’ll be richly rewarded if you take the time to watch it. ua-cam.com/video/jhdFe3evXpk/v-deo.html
Mark's guitar is his other voice.
British Army Veteran here. I was to young to be involved in the Falklands War from which this song was written in reference of.
However in latter years I did get to serve in the Army in an Infantry Regiment that has seen plenty of operational deployments in modern times, four years of that I was part of. this song always makes me remember those brothers from another Mother that never returned from those various theatres where we all gave our blood, sweat and tears.... some their lives. Gone but never forgotten.
One of the best anti-war songs ever written. I still choke up after 30 years of hearing it, and Mark Knopfler on guitar is without peer.
Agree Mark Knopfler is a true genius on the guitar, and it's completely true when Mark plays his guitar you feel it is a human voice reaching out to you, but his lyrics are also masterpieces as you hear in this song... the way he truly deeply honors and respect those have fought and died while calling out the awful loss and waste war causes us is simply breathtaking
one of the best songs ever written period
Every great song about war, is anti-war. I can't agree more with your statement. Mark's guitar sings louder than any lyric ever could.
@raymondcarver476 That guitar tone is incredible.
Only Dire Straits and Pink Floyd can paint such incredible soundscapes, and evoke such emotion from their audiences, both live and watching
I’d like to add Genesis, they also definitely can do that.
You took the words out of my mouth. I thought of Pink Floyd straight away & swore Roger Waters could have come up with some of these lyrics..
This song came out almost 40 years ago and I still cannot listen to it without crying. For me, the entire song sets up the guitar solo at the end that just feels like it reaches inside of me and violently yanks something out. It's visceral.
I'm a 54 years old grown man, but everytime i hear that song i have tears in my eyes.
Same age, same feels. My alltime favourite song.
always
In 2007, a new version of this track featuring Mark Knopfler was released to commemorate the 25th anniversary of the Falklands War. Proceeds from the sale of the single went to a program that brought British veterans back to the site of the war in an effort to help them deal with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.
I'm a vet and this song brings a tear to my eyes ever time I listen to it.
Mark Knopfler is perhaps the most technically skilled guitarist on the planet right now. Other guitarists might be more emotive, but no one beats Knopfler for sheer skill.
This song always makes me think of something a soldier named Darryl Powers (better known as "Shifty" Powers)) once said. Speaking of the Germans he fought in World War II, he said, "Those guys and I might have had a lot in common. Under different circumstances we might have been good friends. But we had to to what we had to do, and they had to do what they had to do." Its the realization that the enemy you are fighting aren't demons but are just as human as you that gets to me.
This was written after the Falklands war, and it's from the perspective of a mortally wounded soldier..
Mark Knoffler wrote about the British war in the Falkland Island. He’s the guy singing and playing guitar!
Mark Knopfler is one of the purest guitarist players to ever pick up a guitar. He uses a 3 finger picking style with no pick. Their biggest hit is Sultans of Swings which is a must listen.
Yes, Sultans of Swing. But I hope it's the Alchemy Live version; that's one of those absolutely epic performances!
Yes Bill. One of the most lyrical, truly musical guitarists of all time. And a very modest, humble man as well.
Thanks for the swift response Bill. Have you heard "Brothers in Arms" played at the Nelson Mandela concert at Wembley Stadium? Eric Clapton playing rythm guitar and Mark Knopfler wiping tears from his eyes.. A truly emotional and wonderful rendition of this classic song.
no, but I'll check it out. Have you ever listened to the album Neck and Neck he did with Chet Atkins? Some of the most amazing guitar work ever put on record.
@@simonashworth8825 just watched it. What is so amazing about both Clapton and Knopfler while technically their song may not be the most difficult to play the raw feeling they put into each note is nearly impossible to do. I can play Sultans pretty much note for note even using a 3 finger-picking style but it still doesn't come anywhere near sounding as good.
The ingenuity of the lyrics lies in the double meaning of "Brothers in Arms". Usually, this phrase would be used for the men fighting alongside you (your comrades, a bond forged in battle, yada-yada). But the song changes it to the meaning that we are all brothers (living in this one world), so that when we fight each other in war, we fight against our own "Brothers in Arms".
Brothers In Arms was the first CD I ever purchased. I had an in car CD player and a very powerful sound system and I often had to stop my car just to listen to this track really loudly so I could experience the emotion to its fullest effect! I’m 65 now and a bit deaf!
Fun fact for ya: Brothers In Arms is actually the first ever album that released on the CD format, 1985
It is about the Falkland war, between Great Britain and Argentina. About the islands off shore Argentina. He belongs to the top guitarists and his fingerpicking style is unique. He is a genius in songwriting and painting pictures with his music. As many fans of him, i would consider you to listen to „Sultans of swing, alchemy live“. Stay safe and thank you for your reactions and work you put in to it!
Mark makes the guitar sing everytime he plays. He is one one the most emotive lyricists of our time.
This song is held very dear by all UK serving and former military personnel. It is played at many service funeral or memorial.I have had it locked in,for when my time is up too.
This is the story of a soldier during the 1982 Falklands war, he is laying there breathing his last surrounded by his mates, it's about the futility of war.
Band of the Royal Marines does a brilliant version, check it out if you haven't already.
@@bobknightfolk they do indeed, probably the best cover of B.I.A.(the Lass sings with passion)
As an Air Force veteran this hits hard. I worked with and met many combat veterans. No matter the branch we all feel the loss when we lose a brother or sister. Thank you to all who serve and to those who paid the ultimate sacrifice.
I feel you, bro. Former Air Force MP K9 officer and now still in security industry. This song has been played and will be played in too many funerals of brothers.
This song has always touched my soul. As a soldier and a sailor, I see this song as a salute to all those who have born the mantle of war and the deep price paid by both the dead and those who came home.
Knopfler said the song is from the perspective of a mortally wounded soldier on a battlefield far from home who realizes he is dying...... "These mist-covered mountains are a home now for me......" Great perceptive reaction!
Once you've written, composed, recorded and performed a song like brothers in arms, there's nothing left to do. This song scratches the surface of just how incredible Dire Straits were and particularly Mark Knopfler. He is a virtuoso and his music will be ringing through the airwaves until the end of time. I love someone new discovering Mark Knopfler and Dire Straits. Top tier and great reaction of course 😀
This wasn't really the music video, but this is THE best live version of this song. It has me in tears, every single time, when the guitar screams out in pain after the pedal steel guitar solo.
IMAO THIS is the best version:
ua-cam.com/video/Z3_HTGdLXL4/v-deo.html
Live in Nimes'92, I believe.
Mandela 88 is better
I just listened to your react video like a week ago. And again just now. This specific live version is particularly evocative. Tearing up s second time. You chose well.
My mom loved Dire Straits so I listened to the Brothers In Arms album when I was like 8 on.
You will not believe how Home Free does a cover of this in a deep bass. It is an A cappella masterpiece. Whereas Mark, who wrote the song, focused heavily on his guitar playing acumen, HF focused on the lyrics in a very sobering and emotional performance. This was about the needless war between the UK and Argentina over the control of the Falkland Islands in the South Atlantic. Argentina invaded the Falklands in 1982 and the British had governed it for nearly 150 years. The UK successfully defended their control of the islands and still governs them today.
100%! HOME FREE knocked this out of the park- it is sooo haunting and Tim's bass was incredible. They own this song over Dore Straits.
A must listen
This was my favorite song on that album. I am a sucker for weeping guitars and the lyrics. 🥰
Also, if you'd like to hear another tear jerker, Romeo and Juliet by Dire Straits is a masterpiece. Such a beautiful love song. I guess what I'm saying is, this band is amazing.
I believe the person singing/speaking the lyrics is a soldier far from home. He is mortally wounded and knows that he will never see his homeland again but he is comforted by the comradeship of his "Brothers in arms". He also questions the futility of fighting the brothers in arms on the other side.
This was written by Mark Knopfler at the time of the Falklands War.
Britt. Thank you for pointing out the poetry in the music you review
I'm a 60 yo combat veteran and this song speaks to me in a way that few songs do. Dire Strait's wrote "Brothers in Arms" as a anti war song but it's become so much more as it speaks to the lost me and my Brothers in Arms feel for the lost of friends and the lost of soul and self one feels after coming home. It's the closets thing to explaining the empty feeling I have here in the US after being in combat.
Perfectly said...and Mark Knopflers lyrics I think are so powerful because he deeply appreciates the courage and loss our military men and women face and at the same time remind us of the terrible losses created in wars...Sherman had it right "war is hell" and we all better never forget it...
Deepest respect! You get the point of this song, your fellow countrymen usually don't.
@@fifi23o5I think a lot more of us in the US understand this song than you give us credit for, but that's understandable. There is a vocal segment of the population, especially on the right, which glorifies combat and war.
But a lot of us who are old enough - I'm 66 myself - have lost family members in war, or had family come back from war altered by the experience.
My father fought in Korea, and he didn't talk about it much, but he was proud to have served alongside fellow Marines, even though he sometimes jumped at loud noises and could barely tolerate the fireworks when he took us kids to 4th of July celebrations. He watched with sadness as the Vietnam War dragged on and on, seeing history repeat itself for no good reason.
I think of him every time I hear this song. Tomorrow (August 16 2023) marks the 10th anniversary of his passing, and I watched this reaction in his honor. Semper Fi, dad.
Home frees cover of brothers in arms is hauntingly beautiful
Yes, but check out the "Band Of The Royal Marines" version. The young woman who sings it is a serving soldier and has served in Afghanistan. Check the emotion on her face when she sings, "you did not desert me my brothers in arms."
It’s a glorious celebration of humanity, and the utter waste of war…..glorious, beautiful, somber, sad, ……sheer brilliance
Great reaction Britt! I’ve known this song for nearly 40 years but this is the first time I’ve really understood the words. You are a very good teacher.
I cry every time I hear this song. I know all too well what this song is about. Many of you do too.
I feel like this was written for my muckas 1982 all forgotten. 😢
I just love what goes around in your head and your reflection of songs.
Dire Straits is musically one of the best bands in music history, do more reactions to their live performances
I’m glad that you pulled up the lyrics. The best way to hear this song is to watch the official video. I beleave that this song was written at the time, when The Falkland war had just finished.
I've played this song every rememberance day since it came out. Beautiful tribute to fallen soldiers. Nice reaction on your part...
Brothers in arms, the bond soldiers , fire fighters, police, those who sever beside you willing to die for each other
I've heard this song many times, but this performance makes me cry!
Het Britt.
It really meant a lot that you liked the song. Maaaany years ago I did audio for Knofler/Straits. I love how you got it. I think it used to be about past wars, I don't thing so much now. It's about all wars and those who are the same but die. It holds up as much today as it did 35 years ago. :)
Love that you tend to react to the live performances. Sultans of Swing from the Alchemy tour is a great one, so much energy and togetherness in this band.
I'm a veteran, I can't listen to this without tears...... I play it every Anzac day for my boys who are no longer here......
RIP my brothers.
Those lyrics...
& Knopfler coaxing those mournful notes...
sure promotes a bit of extra hydration to the ol' eyeballs.
Your reactions are priceless. Everyone is so honest and comes from the heart. I could listen to you instead of the song. You're special.
Mark Knopfler is one of the best rock guitarists out there and it's all finger picking. He's a very talented singer/songwriter as well. He wrote and played the soundtrack for the movie "Princess Bride". If you're into hard driving rock, check out "Sultans of Swing" live from the Alchemy tour. Also, "Romeo and Juliette" any version.
He also wrote the theme for the movie Local Hero.
This song and Romeo and Juliette are my fav 2 DS songs.
Yep dire straits music always takes me somewhere else. It is magical.
One of my favorite songs. So beautiful. Lyrics and music. Mark knoffler one of the goats of guitar. This band is legendary, Worth discovering more of their songs. Lots of funky rock stuff as well. So much swag and style. Great choice. I like that you looked into the powerful words as well!
A beautiful song, written and performed by a master ... Mark's guitar work is up there with the very, very best .... fabulous live as well.
Every person who has been to war has a special reverence for this song.
It's certainly about the futility of war.
Agreed.
Here I am, a near-70-year old in rural Ireland, and I wanted to say how much I appreciate your reactions to some of the favourite songs from my past, and respect for pulling up the lyrics to songs when you can't quite get the UK accents. LOVE your vids.
Mark Knopfler plays guitar so tastefully and this song is so unusual in the way that it looks at war from the perspective of both sides. Another song about soldiers who become brothers that I'm sure you would love is Billy Joel's "Goodnight Saigon". It will break your heart. Nice reaction.
This was the first album ever to be released on the new fangled compact disc format in 1985. This may or may not be true.
I now live in Nashville, TN. In my church there are 2 tall brass candlesticks on the alter. They were dedicated to our church by the family of a man who served in Vietnam. He commanded Vietnamese troops, and he was so beloved that his troops collected a huge amount of brass bullet casings to create these 5 Ft. tall candlesticks. So inspiring!
Miami Vice was HUGE back in the day. They got some top-flight music in the show, and they had a very memorable scene with this song as the soundtrack. Mark Knopfler's guitar has a voice all its own. One of those great songs that few people ever try to cover; I don't think people think they can add anything to it. American Songwriter has a great breakdown on this song - written from the perspective of a dying soldier.
He also talks about the highlands and lowlands, and don't forget that he is from Scotland. There was a lot that happened in Scotland.
Dire Straits were superb. They had such a variety of songs, and told such great stories. Another awesome song, among many, is Private Investigations, from the perspective of a P.I. There are many more to discover, and we would love to enjoy the journey with you.
The lyric is a beautifully sad plea from a dying soldier ,heartbreakingly enhanced by Marks weeping guitar .
Absolutely! Try Sultans of Swing
When I went through my law enforcement academy we had to come up with a graduation motto. Our motto was - We all go home at the end of our shift.Brothers and sisters all wearing the badge. We stood together.
Every goddamn time. Yes, i have that same experience every time i listen to this. Possibly the greatest piece of guitar ever written. It seems so simple but the depth he puts into it. You can almost feel his soul breaking.
Dire Straits is an iconic band!! This is one of my favorite songs of all time. May I suggest trying "So Far Away".
Nobody plays guitar like mark knopfler and and a great voice, i grow up with this super band, i love that awsome sound. The first LP was absolutly outstanding, new sound, sultens of swing 👑♥️🌹💫
It's all and every war. Its a song about the people sent to fight them. Its about the soldiers. We are all the same. If given the choice we wouldn't fight our brothers who have the same lines on our palms...but we sign up to fight for our country which, when you come down to it, means killing people in another life we would've called friends.
As others have said here, this is Mark's tribute to British soldiers fighting the Falklands War in 1982 - but of course soldiers of all nations immediately relate to it, and quite rightly so. Heartbreaking lyrics, and that's just from his guitar!
I was a 21 yo exchange student from USA in Aarhus Denmark when this album broke. Everyone stopped to listen when this song played. I felt a small sense of the depth of WW2 still casting its shadow. I wondered if Danes were forced to choose, to make war on their brothers.
Loved this 30 years ago, love it still.
I was serving in the army when the war this song is about (The Falkands War) was in full flow. I have a really hard time listening to it and not choking up. "Deeply moving" doesn't even scratch the surface.
My mother survived the bombing of London in World War II she mentioned she mentioned what I know of in high school never thought about it but she said like this is like my brother in arms from Canada my mom was a war right but still British makes you think right now I got a little bit of a tear God bless moms
I've loved this song since they released it in 1985, and while I love so many Dire Straits songs, this has always been my favorite of theirs.
Since Mark Knopfler explained in an interview that this song are the final words of a dying soldier, I imagine, JUST as you explained, the guitar is his cry, weeping, and the "explosion" like drums/bass are the air strikes falling around them, as he succumbs to the last, big blast.
Now, having heard this one, you MUST listen to your new friends, HOME FREE's rendition of this song, in acapella... A true master piece!
Mark Knopfler performed this song during his solo tour in my home town years ago and we felt it was the pinnacle of the show. The band waved good-bye, they walked off the stage. Then the keyboards of Money For Nothing started to play and hell was unleashed in the audience:)
One of the greatest songs ever. I'm retired military and lost so many Brothers In Arms over the years and now at 71 years old. I'm losing Brothers (and Sisters) in Arms almost daily ! You can say you understand the song but in all honesty, if you have not served and lost Your Brothers in Arms... you will never feel in your sole and being, the true loss of "Brothers in Arms"
Great reaction (as usual) 😁My favourite piece of music from any generation. As a 55yr old former soldier, I agree with the other veteran's comments regarding the meaning of the song. If you've served, you not only understand this song, you feel it. Huge respect to all who've served, and those who still continue to serve- stay safe 😊
The song was used in the Miami Vice episode "Out Where the Buses Don't Run" about a retired Vice cop who has an obsession with a failed investigation from years ago. He draws Crockett and Tubbs into his obsession and his descent into madness, grief and guilt. The aching sadness of the song eerily narrates the surreal ending. An iconic moment in cinema.
This song always makes me cry. Every single time.
"Sultans of Swing" by them is a masterpiece. Look for the Alchemy Live version of it
Mark Knopfler is one of my favorite guitarists. Love Dire Straits, but Mark’s solo work is wonderful too. His album Golden Heart is a favorite❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
It was a commentary on the Falklands War. They even re-recorded it on the 25th anniversary of the war, to raise funds for veterans still affected by their involvement in it.
The song is one of the most iconic, and Mark Knopfler's guitar solos in it are generally regarded as among the best in the history of music.
Knopfler is also known as one of the greatest guitarists ever. You can hear more of his prodigious play in "Money for Nothing" and "Walk of Life," or the entire "Brothers in Arms" album.
I still have the original Brothers In Arms album. Love the Home Free version for the clarity of the lyrics while maintaining the depth of feeling Mark gifts us.
Diane, that's so true... In Mark Knopfler's music we are easily overwhelmed by artistry of his guitar and music, but his lyrics are just as stunning when you hear them clearly, live recordings in large venues never do his lyrics justice... I've heard the Home Free Acappella version and you're so right, the lyrics hit you with incredible emotional power!
A couple things:
1. You love flute? Check out a guy named Ian Anderson and his band, Jethro Tull.
2. I believe this song was a response to The Falkland Islands War between the U.K. and Argentina.
3. The front side of the album had the hits, but the back side of the album is just sublime.
A good place to start with Jethro Tull is "Locomotive Breath".
The guitar is everything in this song. It wails, cries and moans telling the story
There are some really beautiful words written below. Thank each and every one of you for sharing your perspective and histories. They add so much and allow each of us to get a glimpse through your eyes. Britt, I want to tell you something about all this - and this gig you've bravely taken on. Getting other's perspectives is the whole reason we enjoy these reactions, but you should feel free to give your perspective, too. An important lesson about art is that once the artist shares with one other, they lose to right to tell that person how to interpret it. They can certainly share what they were thinking and intended, but each person has the right - the responsibility - to consider their own meaning. Please share your perspective with others. There will probably be trolls who will criticize. Whatever. We're here because we like your reaction and part of that is your perspective. "The meaning" comes from you.
Inspired by the British army v Argentina in the Falklands War ! Marks guitar is doing the singing, while Mark is Narrating
This song is very special and emotional for soldiers, fire fighters and law enforcement officers. Anyone that had someone cover your back in the worst of situations. Where we've lost brothers or sisters on the job. It's the intense pain we carried/carry in the danger of the moment and the memories of those fallen that once stood by our side. 💔
You need to hear Home Free's version of this song
Its the falkland war.. but we are all brothers all across the world.. and fools to make war with any..beautiful song
First time I’ve heard this version; yes Mark wrote in in response to the Falklands war in the early 1980’s. So good, thanks for playing it. All they did was excellent; check out all the songs on Alchemy Live!
Now you need to listen to the Home Free version because it drives home what the song is about.
I love this song, It's my favorite Dire Straits song. It's so emotional, and sounds so great when cranked up and sitting in the dark. There is another couple songs that hit me the same way, Funkadelic's song Maggot Brain is one of them. The producer told the lead guitarist to play as if he had been told his mother had died. The other one is also a great story of soldiers and war from Frank Marino - Stories of a Hero. Such a great story that makes you appreciate even more the sacrifice that men and women give to protect their country ( any and all ).
I am a veteran and was once a part of a group of people that all depend upon each other to accomplish a certain goal. In some circumstances if one guy doesn't do what everyone is trained to do people can suffer unduly. If done right and everyone does their job you go home to live another day.
The official video to this amazing and powerful tune tells the story of what the song is all about. The genius of Mark Knopfler never fails to astonish me.
Hey Brit, I loved your instant recognition of what this song can mean - very perceptive of you. I admire the ease of your communicative ability, whether it be with an expression, or words.
For some reason, I just felt compelled to share my thoughts with you. You don't have to read it, but here goes:
I was a mere lad of 11 when I first heard this offering. I was at my desk in my bedroom getting on with my homework, when my attention was zapped and I quieted everything to sit up and listen to the radio. I could not understand why this concoction of instruments, poetry and melody drew tears out from my soul. All I knew was that this was one of those special moments in time, which doesn't come by too often - somehow, I knew this, even at my young age.
As I listened, the lump in my throat stiffened and my breathing shallow-ed. The accompanying lyrics to this haunting melody, instantly transported me into a vision of the strife and chaos which dances with conflict! How could this be? I thought. I had never been in the midst of such an environment, yet my chest tightened and began to spasm with a sadness, hither to unknown. The tears coursed down my cheeks and I was filled with utter despair. How could something so randomly beautiful evoke such melancholy? Perhaps, I shall never understand....
The song ended and I remained transfixed and still sobbing. It was then, I knew I had to find and bring this song closer to me.
I broke out the change from my piggy-bank and would head over to the music store at my earliest opportunity.
I eagerly rummaged around in the store and found the album, 'Brothers in Arms.' I snatched the cassette album, paid for it and headed straight home to listen.....
That was many years ago and I have since owned that particular album through all of its incarnations, from Vinyl to CDs. The album and that song in particular, existed with me in every vehicle and iPod I have ever owned.
I will let others enlighten you on the era and conflict it was created for. Needless to say, it doesn't matter which war it was written for, as it slots into before, during and the aftermath of all strife. The ultimate sacrifice for what makes us noble.
Mark Knopfler is known for his guitar skills and is very well respected. He is truly one of the Masters. (along with SRV!) Though not being the best of singers, the music speaks for itself.
I still choke up every time I hear this song and when left alone to enjoy, I invariably have tears wrung from my very soul.
There are many songs which resonate with others, but this one always stops me dead in my tracks, allowing me to be grateful for its cleansing, in this little corner of the Universe.
I will never understand fully, the peace which fills me after such soul-searching... God Bless!
Hi, Britt thnk you for this reaction video. Love this song so much. Has a deep meaning to me . All the love to you. Love from Portugal
If you’re a combat vet, you get it.
The best episode of Miami Vice had this at the at the end with the thunder rolling…incredible to watch
Do you know the title of this episode? Thank you in advance….
@@semperveritas3 Where the buses don’t run
@@7777shayna Thank you!
Knopfler seems to have a direct connection to warriors. This tune, along with his "Piper Till The End" and "Done With Bonaparte" are simply brilliant stories about human existence during chaos.
Your reaction was on target.
Hi Britt
Firstly, I absolutely loved your reaction including your articulation of your emotions. Thank you!! Mark wrote this in the wake of the Falklands war between Britain and Argentina in 1982. For me this is the greatest anti war song ever written. You are so right when you talk about Mark's guitar weeping. Mark is my all time favourite guitarist and an absolutely brilliant songwriter and storyteller. You are getting to know genius!! If you explore them further I might suggest continuing to watch them live, particularly their Alchemy live tour of 1983. Some of their performances include Sultans of Swing, the absolutely mesmerising Telegraph Road, the beautiful Romeo and Juliet and the dark and mysterious Private investigations. You won't regret it!! Take care and warmest wishes from the UK.
Martin, Mark Knopfler is one of the greatest musical artists I've ever heard, but the marriage of his heart rending guitar WITH the brilliant lyrics that honor the courage and sacrifice of our armed forces while gently get us all to honestly remember the terrible loss and waste of life wars cause brings this song to genius level.
@@markhilliard4037 Totally agree Mark!!