I have never seen an architectural video of this caliber let alone so historic in nature. I wish I've seen your videos 15-20 years ago. It would have helped me on my lectures tremendously. Great job Professor Calder Loth. I'm a fan. ❤️ Love from an American architect lecturing in the Philippines!
Superb. Attention to detail without being boring is what I love about these presentations. Explained perfectly and I love how the connection with ancient words/expressions is described
This series is the best ever. I have a PhD in Comparative Arts and have watched Dr. Loth's videos over and over again. These are THE best lectures on understanding the foundations of Classical Architecture in a concise and deep way. I lived a few blocks away from Loth in the Fan (RVA) and always admired the way he kept his home and garden/alley so original. I could only aspire to emulate the way he taught and applied classicism in his everyday life, work, and career. Calder Loth is an American Treasure.
I took one year of architecture school, 20 years before giving up. Recently I started reading the 600 page architectural history textbook which i had saved all these years since I still love architecture very much. The textbook takes pages after pages of tedious explanation with very crude illustration to cover what you have here beautifully, in a very succinct and easy to follow manner . Thank you very much
UA-cam finally did it right and recommended me this. i had attended a MOOC from Sapienze College of Venice on this particular topic and so i'm absolutely delighted to watch this! Thank you!
I am a Mexican Architect, I have learned History and Theory in Spanish, and this amassing Professor has explained it just like the books I have read, now in US I am studying all over again in English, I am so lucky I have found him, and no, I won't get my License in this country, Its way to complicated and expensive, they don't focus in the basics but futurism which is not my interest! I design, remodel, renovate and build houses. I am fine with this.
Don't give up, I'm also in a contemporary design school where they hate traditional or classical architecture. Learn from old books such as the 4 books on architecture.
I took a history of architecture course once and I loved it. The teacher lady was so engaging explaining the technical aspects in the cultural context and philosophical. My point is, it is very easy to make these kind of lectures extremely dull. It is like the lecture is held by a clerk or an accountant.
i would give anything of the 20 and 21 century has to offer just to be able to live and walk in those wonderfull classical buildings.I was never a fan of history and architecture when i was young but traveling made me realise how much i adore greek and roman buildings and how sad i feel that so few survived...
I'm watching this video because one of my life dreams is to do my best to revive ancient architecture and merge it with modernity in a way that is truly harmonious and beautiful. The beauty, the power, the grandeur, but also the nature. Modern imitations of classical architecture, even when done well, have so little of nature left in them. The nature is extremely tame. Roman/Greek architecture, the nature is still in the stone, I feel. With ancient architecture also has to come ancient symbolism, virtue and geometry. I feel that with modern technology, we should have built something that far outclasses Rome, but we've not figured out how to operate that way yet. Maybe we can start a movement.
@@hellomate639 Wishing you the best of luck to accomplish your goal, we need more people like you. The world needs to remember what was lost (in terms of beauty), and adapt to what has been gained (in terms of technology)!
@@shield543 Thank you for this reply. It's like a reminder of what I need to be aiming at. I have all sorts of pursuits right now centered around building systems in which people can more fluidly collaborate on building amazing projects. Still not sure how to accomplish it. But, whenever I mention it, people seem to light up, as if they never considered that it was a possibility...
As a remodeler of residential structures, I welcome this series, it's integrity assist me with a period correct Architecture to improve obsolete dwellings.
Thank you very much for this lecture series! I have never seen such an elaborate, yet accessible explanation of the rules of classical architecture. Hugely inspiring, and a great incentive to investigate more deeply the ancient traditions of the classical way of building.
Amazing Amazing Bravo Encore. I only knew three as a modest novice. Now I'm fluent. Will watch multiple times and now I want to explore the city and take pictures. This guy needs keys to some cities.
Thank you for your comment. My source for the etymologies of architectural terms is the American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language. It's the best I've found. Calder Loth
Not sure if it’s some deep-seated psychological thing or just me getting older, but seemingly out of nowhere I’ve developed a fascination with architecture, particularly of the classicist variety. Thank you for this awesome video.
I just discovered a new interest that I never knew I was interested in before. And as a bonus, may I say that you Sir look and sound exactly as I would imagine a classical architecture professor to be. (PS: I a almost sure those latin and greek terms will all be in the midterm test.)
THIS is the informative, intelligent, well-presented video on classical architecture that I have been craving....the hour just flew past...thank you Prof and everyone involved in putting this excellent video together...can't wait to watch the other three parts 😊🙌🏛
Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! This is exactly what I have been looking for. Perfect, accessible introductions with all sorts of fascinating "by-the ways" and great humour. My favourite bit of humour was the observation that mummies were wrapped in ribbons and not in tape-worms.
Thank you for your comment. It's really heartening to learn that the series communicates coherently. A primary aim of the series is to help people appreciate the wonderful classical architecture that we find most everywhere, and learn how to read the details on anything from a front porch to a state capitol. Calder
27:37 “Notice in the pediment, the front gable, that the crown molding is not carried across the base of the pediment.” Wait, I’m not getting that. Is that a reference to the crown molding appearing to jut out slightly from where the pediment is (at least the way I see it)? It looks like in the “illiterate building” the crown molding is exactly aligned with the pediment, as shown by the charcoal triangle “outline.” Am I understanding the point correctly?
Jeff, The crown molding is employed here only on the raking (A-frame) angles of the pediment. The crown molding is not seen on top of the fascia, the plain molding at the bottom of the pediment. Look at the portico of the Pantheon or the Supreme Court Building. Perhaps the angle of the photograph exaggerates the effect. Thank you for your comment. Calder Loth
@@calderloth6058 Wow, thank you for your response! Looking at the video again _and_ the pediment of the Pantheon _and_ your detailed ICAA page on “Architectural Etymology,” well, lots of times, with reference to your explanation, I think I finally got it. I’m just a regular person, not anyone with any sort of expertise in architecture, and, before watching your superb series, would not have known, say, my _fascia_ from my _taenia_ 😳- it’s been quite a journey but a delightful one - so I appreciate your careful and kind reply.
And thank you for letting me know you appreciated this video lecture. It's always encouraging to learn when people find classical architecture of interest. I hope you can now see building with a more informed eye. They have much to tell. Calder Loth
The breathing noises were caused by attaching the mike too close to my face. They bothered me too; I just hoped people would consider them as involuntary gestures of enthusiasm. The film editors were able to tone some of them down. Fortunately, they were not a problem in the other three parts of the series.
I taught the subject for years, even led study tours through Italy, but I didn't know the subject in such detail. Still, it's a little like knowing how to properly tie your toga or cure common ailments by letting out blood.
Wonderful! Beauty derives from balanced proportion. You just know when it doesn’t look right yes! Calming like music, + the music needs a place to rest.
What about polychromy in classical architecture ? A BIG point that wasnt mentioned and maybe changes a lot of the explanations. For example the, "showing" of structural firmness could be turned around. Most of these classical buildings were, as the greek ones, painted and veiled in cloth. That could be the act of "covering" the structural/construction elements.
Many of the photographs of buildings and details are my own. Some I found on the net. The images of engravings of architectural forms and details were scanned from pattern books, most of which are available in inexpensive reprints. Since the illustrations are used in the ICAA video lecture, I assume the ICAA would have to approve the use of the illustrations for publication or other such communication. I recommend you contact the ICAA about downloading and reusing any of the images.
It should be noted, when Vetruvius listed the Doric, he listed the Roman Doric. A style which is more similar to Tuscan, practically indistinguishable, than to the Greek Doric.
I like the idea that the Romans added non functional details to their buildings just to give them more character and interest -something that goes completely against the bland functional architecture that probably started with the Bauhaus in the early Twentieth Century.
Dear Professor Loth, ICAA: My name is Romeo Ty. Member of AIA and C1PRC but living in the Philippines. I'm also a classical Lecturer. I would like to be a member of ICAA. How can I become a member? Thank you!
Ok. “Illiterate Building” is officially my new favorite slur. 😂💀
😆
As you see this building is illiterate.
Everybody liked that.
it's hard to understand why these “Illiterate Buildings” simply don't get demolished
And when I next see one, I'll jolly well teach it to read!
So informative and without playing irritating music all the way through.
@@drevilvegan It costs money?
I have never seen an architectural video of this caliber let alone so historic in nature. I wish I've seen your videos 15-20 years ago. It would have helped me on my lectures tremendously. Great job Professor Calder Loth. I'm a fan. ❤️ Love from an American architect lecturing in the Philippines!
Superb. Attention to detail without being boring is what I love about these presentations. Explained perfectly and I love how the connection with ancient words/expressions is described
This series is the best ever. I have a PhD in Comparative Arts and have watched Dr. Loth's videos over and over again. These are THE best lectures on understanding the foundations of Classical Architecture in a concise and deep way. I lived a few blocks away from Loth in the Fan (RVA) and always admired the way he kept his home and garden/alley so original. I could only aspire to emulate the way he taught and applied classicism in his everyday life, work, and career. Calder Loth is an American Treasure.
I took one year of architecture school, 20 years before giving up. Recently I started reading the 600 page architectural history textbook which i had saved all these years since I still love architecture very much. The textbook takes pages after pages of tedious explanation with very crude illustration to cover what you have here beautifully, in a very succinct and easy to follow manner . Thank you very much
What book is it, if you please? Thank you!
UA-cam finally did it right and recommended me this. i had attended a MOOC from Sapienze College of Venice on this particular topic and so i'm absolutely delighted to watch this! Thank you!
So we know that the Ancients knew a lot more about humamity than we know about what they knew. Golden ration is the key to all the beauty. Bravo Prof.
This may be my favorite series of all time. I cannot wait to teach my kids this!
This is education on the highest level. Thank you for this excellent resource!
WHY DID THEY NOT TEACH THIS THINGS IN SWEDISH SCHOOLS? HISTORY IS EVERYTHING, ITS THE KEY TO MOVE FORWARD!
@@RockNRoll-wb8fn Because school nowadays only serves to graduate ignorant people who pride themselves on their stupidity
I am a Mexican Architect, I have learned History and Theory in Spanish, and this amassing Professor has explained it just like the books I have read, now in US I am studying all over again in English, I am so lucky I have found him, and no, I won't get my License in this country, Its way to complicated and expensive, they don't focus in the basics but futurism which is not my interest! I design, remodel, renovate and build houses. I am fine with this.
Hey! Where are you studying architecture? I am very curious to know :)
Don't give up, I'm also in a contemporary design school where they hate traditional or classical architecture. Learn from old books such as the 4 books on architecture.
"Why???"
"Because it looks better that way!"
😂😂👌👌
ahahah yes I like how he says that too
I took a history of architecture course once and I loved it. The teacher lady was so engaging explaining the technical aspects in the cultural context and philosophical. My point is, it is very easy to make these kind of lectures extremely dull. It is like the lecture is held by a clerk or an accountant.
i would give anything of the 20 and 21 century has to offer just to be able to live and walk in those wonderfull classical buildings.I was never a fan of history and architecture when i was young but traveling made me realise how much i adore greek and roman buildings and how sad i feel that so few survived...
I'm watching this video because one of my life dreams is to do my best to revive ancient architecture and merge it with modernity in a way that is truly harmonious and beautiful.
The beauty, the power, the grandeur, but also the nature.
Modern imitations of classical architecture, even when done well, have so little of nature left in them. The nature is extremely tame. Roman/Greek architecture, the nature is still in the stone, I feel.
With ancient architecture also has to come ancient symbolism, virtue and geometry.
I feel that with modern technology, we should have built something that far outclasses Rome, but we've not figured out how to operate that way yet.
Maybe we can start a movement.
@@hellomate639 Wishing you the best of luck to accomplish your goal, we need more people like you. The world needs to remember what was lost (in terms of beauty), and adapt to what has been gained (in terms of technology)!
@@shield543 Thank you for this reply.
It's like a reminder of what I need to be aiming at.
I have all sorts of pursuits right now centered around building systems in which people can more fluidly collaborate on building amazing projects.
Still not sure how to accomplish it.
But, whenever I mention it, people seem to light up, as if they never considered that it was a possibility...
As a remodeler of residential structures, I welcome this series, it's integrity assist me with a period correct Architecture to improve obsolete dwellings.
I’m with ya.
I’m a remodeling carpenter as well
Thank you very much for this lecture series! I have never seen such an elaborate, yet accessible explanation of the rules of classical architecture. Hugely inspiring, and a great incentive to investigate more deeply the ancient traditions of the classical way of building.
I learned a lot just by watching this wonderful video! Thanks for releasing such an amazing content online for free.
Amazing Amazing Bravo Encore. I only knew three as a modest novice. Now I'm fluent. Will watch multiple times and now I want to explore the city and take pictures. This guy needs keys to some cities.
Bravo! Bravissimo Mr. Loth! I was enjoying every minute of your video! The best lecture on architecture I`ve ever heard! Thank you so much!
The etymologies of the architectural terms were super helpful to me. It really helps me remember a word if I can connect it to other words I know.
Thank you for your comment. My source for the etymologies of architectural terms is the American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language. It's the best I've found.
Calder Loth
Extremely engaging and interesting, and packed with knowledge. This was a pleasure to watch!
Excellent. So many life-long questions answered in one video.
Not sure if it’s some deep-seated psychological thing or just me getting older, but seemingly out of nowhere I’ve developed a fascination with architecture, particularly of the classicist variety. Thank you for this awesome video.
No mate, it's a humann thing to love historic and ancient architecture, but some will never get any pleasure from seeing it.
As an amateur builder working in the tropics in some difficulty with making myself understood, I've been enriched by this video treatise.....thanks...
I just discovered a new interest that I never knew I was interested in before. And as a bonus, may I say that you Sir look and sound exactly as I would imagine a classical architecture professor to be. (PS: I a almost sure those latin and greek terms will all be in the midterm test.)
Listened to Dr.Loths lecture on bricks and so glad I heard this one....absolutely amazing! Thank you!
0:52 Learning Objectives
1:10 Classicism (Roman Classicism)
A treasure of profound educational content to inspire all coming artists. Thank you
Thank you, sir, for a very engaging, inspiring and information-rich presentation.
THIS is the informative, intelligent, well-presented video on classical architecture that I have been craving....the hour just flew past...thank you Prof and everyone involved in putting this excellent video together...can't wait to watch the other three parts 😊🙌🏛
Thank you for your positive comments. I hope you will find the other three parts equally informative.
Calder Loth
Thank you for making this teaching available.
Excellent! Very instructive.
27:37 But the crown moulding IS carried across the base of the pediment of that Charleston church. A mistake, surely.
WOW! that was informative. excellent video! good pacing, well constructed, organized, and very interesting
I am blown away. Thank you so much for producing this excellent series!
Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! This is exactly what I have been looking for. Perfect, accessible introductions with all sorts of fascinating "by-the ways" and great humour. My favourite bit of humour was the observation that mummies were wrapped in ribbons and not in tape-worms.
Thank you for your comment. It's really heartening to learn that the series communicates coherently. A primary aim of the series is to help people appreciate the wonderful classical architecture that we find most everywhere, and learn how to read the details on anything from a front porch to a state capitol.
Calder
Outstanding explanation of the classical orders.
At 15:55 is this st. Mary's college of Maryland ??? In st Mary's city?
I can not thank you enough for posting this video
This was so interesting! What a delightful video to stumble on!
What made this more superb was this felt like Albus Dumbledore is giving me lessons on History
What books should I use top study with these videos?
What a wonderful video and beautifully told!
Many thanks for giving the insight on the wooden construction
27:37 “Notice in the pediment, the front gable, that the crown molding is not carried across the base of the pediment.”
Wait, I’m not getting that. Is that a reference to the crown molding appearing to jut out slightly from where the pediment is (at least the way I see it)? It looks like in the “illiterate building” the crown molding is exactly aligned with the pediment, as shown by the charcoal triangle “outline.” Am I understanding the point correctly?
Jeff, The crown molding is employed here only on the raking (A-frame) angles of the pediment. The crown molding is not seen on top of the fascia, the plain molding at the bottom of the pediment. Look at the portico of the Pantheon or the Supreme Court Building. Perhaps the angle of the photograph exaggerates the effect. Thank you for your comment. Calder Loth
@@calderloth6058 Wow, thank you for your response! Looking at the video again _and_ the pediment of the Pantheon _and_ your detailed ICAA page on “Architectural Etymology,” well, lots of times, with reference to your explanation, I think I finally got it. I’m just a regular person, not anyone with any sort of expertise in architecture, and, before watching your superb series, would not have known, say, my _fascia_ from my _taenia_ 😳- it’s been quite a journey but a delightful one - so I appreciate your careful and kind reply.
Can someone tell me what college the library at 15:53 belongs to?
What a beautifully presented video.
Phenomenal content.
Thank you very much
thank you for this masterful series. today more than ever it is important to understand our past which we are losing to ignorance.
I'm whole heartedlly thanking you for this video. THANK YOU SO MUCH
I love this video, what’s super cool is that most of his American examples I’ve driven to and photographed. I love classical architecture.
can anybody explain 27:40 not quite sure as ge didn't explain gable, pediment etc
Love this video, when will the next parts be uploaded?!
www.classicist.org/education/#video
They have part 2, they just haven't uploaded it to UA-cam.
28:00 Doric Order
calder loth is THE MAN
I learned so much from this video!
Absolutely breathtaking!
thank you Mr. Loth
And thank you for letting me know you appreciated this video lecture. It's always encouraging to learn when people find classical architecture of interest. I hope you can now see building with a more informed eye. They have much to tell.
Calder Loth
idk if anyone has watched this recently but, did you hear the weird breathing noises around 35:35 ???
The breathing noises were caused by attaching the mike too close to my face. They bothered me too; I just hoped people would consider them as involuntary gestures of enthusiasm. The film editors were able to tone some of them down. Fortunately, they were not a problem in the other three parts of the series.
@@calderloth6058 it didn't seem to bother anyone else. so I think your good👌
31:43: the "wooden original"
I hope theyll do one about germanic architecture antique medieval
- All roads lead to Rome, or so they say. Not the A57. I drove along it the other day and ended up in Worksop.
I taught the subject for years, even led study tours through Italy, but I didn't know the subject in such detail. Still, it's a little like knowing how to properly tie your toga or cure common ailments by letting out blood.
This is high quality presentation 👍💯
Wonderful! Beauty derives from balanced proportion. You just know when it doesn’t look right yes! Calming like music, + the music needs a place to rest.
What about polychromy in classical architecture ? A BIG point that wasnt mentioned and maybe changes a lot of the explanations. For example the, "showing" of structural firmness could be turned around. Most of these classical buildings were, as the greek ones, painted and veiled in cloth. That could be the act of "covering" the structural/construction elements.
I am too ADHD. I keep coming back here every time I need to do laundry and blast it like I'm at a rave. (I listen to all four parts)
As your new doctor, I suggest putting on the Primus Brown album and blast that instead. 😊
Thank you for this great video!
Good video, shame about the poor sound quality though.
Thank you so much for this video!
What materials are the mass-produced capitals and columns typically made of?
Wonderful lecture thank you
Thank you very much sir for this wonderful lecture
Can a non-US citizen can participate in the quiz and get credit and certification?
Great video, thank you.
Superb Explanation.
Amazing information and even a few jokes if you pay attention (I spotted some around the 24 minute mark)... enjoy :)
Thank you so much for this.
Did they use wood timbers for ceiling rafters?
This is wonderful
Where can we find the images used in this video?
Please help me.
Many of the photographs of buildings and details are my own. Some I found on the net. The images of engravings of architectural forms and details were scanned from pattern books, most of which are available in inexpensive reprints. Since the illustrations are used in the ICAA video lecture, I assume the ICAA would have to approve the use of the illustrations for publication or other such communication. I recommend you contact the ICAA about downloading and reusing any of the images.
This is so interesting! I’m subscribed!
Insanely entertaining
Is there a good app where people can design classical buildings with?
I watch the whole thing wanting to hear this guy say “cool-whip.”
lol
Exceptional teacher
Thanks!! Good job!!
Thank-you very much.
It should be noted, when Vetruvius listed the Doric, he listed the Roman Doric.
A style which is more similar to Tuscan, practically indistinguishable, than to the Greek Doric.
I like the idea that the Romans added non functional details to their buildings just to give them more character and interest -something that goes completely against the bland functional architecture that probably started with the Bauhaus in the early Twentieth Century.
When is the next one ?
www.classicist.org/education/#video
Part 2 is up on their site.
Thank you!!
Brilliant. Second time I'm watching
Many thanks!
2:34 It's "Vicenza" not "Vincenza".
Wow this is amazing thankss!!
3:34 spolia
Very interesting 👍
Dear Professor Loth, ICAA: My name is Romeo Ty. Member of AIA and C1PRC but living in the Philippines. I'm also a classical Lecturer. I would like to be a member of ICAA. How can I become a member? Thank you!
Thank you for your interest in our programs! Please visit our website for more information: www.classicist.org/
You did not answer whether or not the decorative corresponding devices above the centrally spaced columns must also be correspondingly wider!
32:50
Thank you very much