Glenn Greenwald: Why privacy matters
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 жов 2014
- Glenn Greenwald was one of the first reporters to see - and write about - the Edward Snowden files, with their revelations about the United States' extensive surveillance of private citizens. In this searing talk, Greenwald makes the case for why you need to care about privacy, even if you’re “not doing anything you need to hide."
TEDTalks is a daily video podcast of the best talks and performances from the TED Conference, where the world's leading thinkers and doers give the talk of their lives in 18 minutes (or less). Look for talks on Technology, Entertainment and Design -- plus science, business, global issues, the arts and much more.
Find closed captions and translated subtitles in many languages at www.ted.com/translate
Follow TED news on Twitter: / tednews
Like TED on Facebook: / ted
Subscribe to our channel: / tedtalksdirector - Наука та технологія
" he who does not move, does not notice his chains" a very powerful quote
H Mo
he doesn't know whether there are chains or not, because he doesn't venture far away from the norm. Kind of like Schrödinger's chains - they're both there and not until you start moving around :P
H Mo
You lost me.
Doesn't sound like something a socialist would say.
Who said this? You? It's great
@@doodelay It was a quote from the video.
Finally someone who could articulate what I have been thinking all this time. Bravo!
I will use this talk as a response to anyone in the future who are in denial about this problem.
I just watched it and I'm not convinced.
TheCakeAintNoLie Give me you real name phone number, e-mail accounts, bank account password and username. I'm sure you won't be convinced.
TheCakeAintNoLie
So just because "your government" aren't using the information they get from you NOW, means that it's okej to do a mass surveilance on it's people? He is telling you all that in this presentation, i don't think you've even listened to it cuz if you have you would have understood what it ment.
Also listen to this one, it's better explained for people with a slow brain. www.ted.com/talks/mikko_hypponen_how_the_nsa_betrayed_the_world_s_trust_time_to_act
Day What part of 'I DON'T FUCKING CARE' don't you understand?
I don't care that they *can* know what I'm talking about with my friends, I don't care that they *can* know what i bought online. I don't care that they *can* take money from my bank account.
My brain is too slow to understand why I should care. Maybe you could help me out.
Day
Yes, I'd be fine with that because it's exactly the same thing.
Also, nobody is manipulating me.
Every time I watch Glenn Greenwald I learn something. I love this man.
Vitor Ribeiro Your paragraph doesn’t make any sense
Such a smart guy
Luiz Costa Bro this is a youtube comment section, stop judging other people’s english skills dumbass, not everybody speaks english as their main language and far less people here are english teachers like you. I honestly would never expect to find an english teacher judging other people on a comment sections
Same
just digging in on this amazing communicator. What a drive and admirable life. Someone to continually watch.
For all who value freedom, this is well worth your time to consume. Excellent work.
Before watching the video, I was one of those people who felt that “only if you do bad acts do you need privacy”. However, after the multiple valid points the speaker has brought up, I can safely say that privacy is truly needed and that today’s society does lack the minimal amount of privacy that every human should be entitled to; I agree with the speaker. Every single person deserves to have a certain amount of privacy in their lives. As the speaker said, “all of us have things to hide”. These things need not be bad things. It could simply be things that we are not comfortable sharing with others. However, with the internet, nothing is private. Using certain tools, anybody can find out anything about anybody. As long as that person uses the internet in some way, he will have released some information about him. I feel that this is both good and bad. It is bad as it violates the basic amount of privacy one should have but at the same time it is good as it keeps ‘bad’ people in check. Thus, the status quo of privacy on the internet can and should be improved on.
200 words, Ahmad Uibaidillah, CMM/TB04
I give this 95%, Ahmad. Great, well-rounded thoughts on the situation. Please come to my office if you'd like to discuss this further.
:P :P :P
Ahmad Uibai Every time you call someone, every time you search the internet, every time you take a picture on a phone or computer, it's added to your file. Whenever you do something one an internet accusing device, it is added to the data the government and corporations keep on you. The only safe way to talk these days is via snail mail.
Thank you for posting that Slate article. It's brilliant!
Ahmad, privacy is the base condition for freedom. It seems freedom doesn't matter to you. A state should not collect private details about non-suspects. That's what we're talking about. It's not about fighting crime.
You trust your government. That scares me.
I've never had more of my opinions changed in 20 minutes.
lol
Welcome to the true world.
Certainly a compelling a case, as the moderator mentioned :) Look up theintercept.com and Greenwald and Scahill et.al. as guests on Democracy Now for more straight talk
@@korben4340 I was just doing some research on privacy where the upcoming Toronto smart city by Google is concerned and had just been picking apart an article on TheIntercept for good info, just before I came here to learn more about online privacy... then read your comment. I followed your link and realized I was just at that site. It's a good one! Thanks for reinforcing it for me.
It didn't change my mind at all. I still don't care about my privacy. I don't have anything to hide
116 NSA workers thought this was troubling.
Powerful hurrah at the end. What an intelligent man.
Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.
Benjamin Franklin. Nice ;)
Korean Jesus yup.
+Vaibhav Gupta 911 inside job
Vaibhav Gupta +
Another #vacuous comment, thanks
From beginning to end this was a FANTASTIC TED talk! Definitely stowing this one away in my favorites.
Absolutely. Everything he said is why Startpage - the world's most private search engine exists! www.startpage.com/
I want my privacy - at all costs.
ME TOO !!!!!!!!!!!!!
+DianeDi get VPN Asia and you'll get it
you and I both. For obvious reasons
Don't just want it, demand it. Make it non negotiable.
DianeDi +
I've seen easily over 200 (or maybe more) ted talks, and although so many of them are so incredible and mind opening, this one honestly has to be my #1 favorite. I strongly hope that this becomes one of Ted talks most viewed videos, because it's a video I wish every American could see.
Absolutely agree! Americans can take back their privacy by using a private search engine like Startpage. www.startpage.com/
Same to me.
14:28 "... the measure of how free a society is is not how it treats its' good, obedient, compliant citizens, but how it treats its' dissidents and those who resist orthodoxy." What a strong, great quote. So true.
"... the measure of how free a society is,is not how it treats its' good,obedient,complieant citizens,but how it treate its' dissidents and those who resist orthodoxy."- Punchline.
He's an absolute legend. We owe the government nothing. They owe us everything.
+savedfaves In a democratic society the government is supposed to serve the people. I really do not believe most people in the USA would agree that the USA government serves them very well.
@@rickjones2509 That can be said about any government around the world, not just the U.S.
It’s not only the government this applies to All forms of surveillance
How much snooping do we engage in and why
Do we violate other’s privacy
Do we protect our own ?
After I look at myself and my accountability then I can address the government
“The measure of how free a society is not how they treat it’s good obedient compliant citizens, but how it treats its dissidents and those who resist orthodoxy”
Aaaaa
He sees you when you're sleeping, he knows when you're awake!
Exactly what I though of too lol
More Powerful and Timely than EVER
It's about being respectful of someone's space and acknowledging everyone has a right to privacy. Respecting people's boundaries 👌💪💞
I wasn't expecting this, but this is one of the best talks on the topics i've seen so far!
LeCaissie +
He is about to be jailed because of conspiracy against Sergio Moro a judge here in Brazil
Privacy rights are human rights. Thank you Glenn.
that ending was GLORIOUS!
Thanks . I needed a way to articulate why this matters
I've been telling people similar things for years. I always get the "If the government wants to watch my boring life, then go ahead?" but what they don't realize is even the smallest amounts of information en mass can create things like extreme market advantage, or social engineering cues, and even more.
Thank god something interesting!!
ΙF this privacy issue goes on for decades, the world will probably look like a huge prison.
We wont even be able to understand how messed things will be, because
in time we ll get used to it.
Slavery.
I unsubscribed from Big think a week ago because 9 out of 10 or their videos were misleading and dangerous.
dangerous?
TheCakeAintNoLie There were economists sharing ideas about education.
Their approach to business,money making, seems to go with everything.
Now there was a P minister of a eu country talking about economics once .
The lies he spilled out of his mouth were so provoking made the video come down from the flags he got.
Now imagine someone that doesnt know this guy or his sinister past ( the name is papandreou btw) taking what he said as facts or as serious.
( i would say roughly 5/10 of their videos are linked to profit, macro-economics,monetary systems or someting else with an economic approach)
When we are born and get older we started to wear clothes,we go to school and do almost everything which other humans are doing.Why do you think we all behave the same way as other people's do...mostly because we are born in a society a place for educated peoples so in a way we are already born in a artificial social prison we already have all the given options/choices we need to make with our life.
Summit Gomez " and do almost everything which other humans"
Primates and man learn and behave by mimicking others.
Nothing is already decided before we actually do it. We make "us" ,we are trully free if we choose to.
Although society throught conformity
(using methods like shaming and others)
instills priotities or influences,
we still can against it and face the consequences to certain degree.
Now in a " jail" situation the idea is that someone took care of that escape exit. You cant go anywhere.
The sun rises and sets by his rules.
rurounisld
wouldn't unsubscribing mean you just put your fingers in your ears and went LALALALALALAALAAAA
if you KNOW that they are propagating you should be able to see trough it and learn something from it.
I've been noticing lately that privacy is becoming cool again and it's refreshing to see. More and more people are getting aware of how important it is and why they should care.
I agree with what Glenn Greenwald has said about privacy being important, and is not just for the “bad people”. In the past, I used to think that people should not be afraid of others invading their privacy if they did not have a guilty conscience.
However, what I’ve really learnt is that everyone actually needs privacy in their lives. An example of people needing privacy is when they lock the door when they are in the bathroom. Almost everyone who goes to the bathroom lock the door, but is there anything wrong that? Most the time, the answer is no. The reason why people lock the door is because they do not want others to see the things they are doing, even though those things are not wrong.
As human beings, it is a natural instinct to crave for privacy. Whenever we know we are being watched by someone, we are at our best behaviour, trying to paint the image that we are “good”. However, if we are constantly watched, this result in the lack of freedom as “mass surveillance creates a prison in the mind”. Thus, privacy is really important because it is the roots of our freedom.
(200 words, Isaac Mak, CMM/TB02)
I can't tell you how much this video is needed today.
Agree! Do you use a private search engine like Startpage now? www.startpage.com/
This is one of the greatest talks I've ever heard. Glenn Greenwald nailed it. Thank you for this, Mr. Greenwald.
This presentation pretty much explained all of the contents from this journal article which I have spent 4 hours reading, in less than 20 minutes lol.. thank you.
Great talk. This is one if the most important issues facing us in the 21st century. We all need to care about this if we are going to remain a free and open society.
Excellent talk. Glen Greenwald, along with Jeremy Scahill, are two of the most courageous and effective journalists on the current international stage and they are doing what journalists are supposed to do - informing the masses about important stuff that affects them and holding power to account. They have my maximum respect.
Glenn is an excellent speaker.
Perfectly said....and it should be the challenge we all need to help take on.
04:50 - 05:30 - I love that part :D
+saladbarthief -- "A government isn't going to be malicious with your email, spread rumors about you, and use your email to talk to your friends."
You don't know this for a fact. If the govt. wants to intimidate someone, or frame someone, or paint them in a bad light, they will do so. Just look at what the IRS did to conservatives political advocacy groups applying for 501(c)(3) status. They poked into aspects of the groups that had nothing to do with the stated goals of those groups.
*+saladbarthief* The government consists of _people_ (_individuals_).
Nuff said.
finally someone USEFUL and worth the ideas and evidence / on Ted.
The last bit was amazing!
If you watch nothing else of these almost 21 minutes, I recommend 18:47 thru the end. Stellar and so true. Thank you, Mr. Greenwald -- wonderful TED Talk, and so important.
Best talk I've ever listened to. So concise.
This needs more views
A really insightful video. Thank you for your presentation.
Great topic to cover so please continue coverage on this topic in the future
This TED talk is very similar to an argument ***** made in his great book "No Place to Hide" which is well worth purchasing, both for its description of the content and impact of the Edward Snowden revelations and for its indictment of the mainstream media.
Thanks for this video! :-)
For the people who vote this down, they should read 1984
Hard to imagine anyone NOT wanting privacy except for those who want to spy on us! Even they want their own privacy and are usually the most hard to find anything personal about online as he says!
This was such an important and timely conversation. And it was filmed 7 years ago!
You can tell this was unique in the way the moderated engaged with Glen after his presentation
I have nothing profound to add to this video , but man have I read some fantastic comments, and deeply erudite musings on what Glenn said . I have only this… Glenn’s understanding , and empathy towards the human condition is tear inducing in its simplicity and beauty . Glenn is a very important person saying extremely important things❤️
What a brave and intelligent man.
Downloading and saving this video on my hard drive. Just in case this is removed in future.
Fantastic articulation of a challenging topic!
Awesome last quotes !
10:09 - 15:21 Is a great summation of this talk and why we should care about mass surveillance and how it affects our ability to find our own private thoughts and actions
Love this. I have watched 5 times.
this was amazing - I remember watching this back in the day. Greenwald was an amazing person. I look at the things he says now and I try to understand what went so wrong…
In my country, people like to ask personal questions and peeking at your personal stuffs. In the cafes or restaurants, people like to stare at strangers and sometimes even hear their conversation. I never see those things when Im visiting another countries.
One of the most eloquent TED talks I have ever heard! He nailed it!!
Great talk. I can really relate to this...Thank you Glenn Greenwald.
Privacy in today’s society is very important. Privacy invasions/breaches can place a limit on your “personal power”. The more someone knows about us, the more power they can have over us. Privacy is about respecting individuals. If a person has a reasonable desire to keep something private, it is disrespectful to ignore that person’s wishes without a compelling reason (just cause) to do so. Privacy enables people to manage their reputations. How we are judged by others affects our opportunities, friendships, and overall well - being. People establish boundaries from others in society. These boundaries are both physical and informational. We need places of solitude to retreat to, places where we are free of the gaze of others in order to relax and feel at ease. Breaches of these boundaries can create awkward social situations and damage our relationships. In relationships, whether personal, professional, governmental or commercial, we depend upon trusting the other party. Privacy has a big influence in “controlling over one’s life”. Personal data is essential to so many decisions made about us, from whether we get a loan, a license or a job to our personal and professional reputations. Privacy is key to freedom of thought / speech. A watchful eye over everything we do, read or watch can chill us from exploring ideas outside the mainstream. Privacy helps protect our ability to associate with other people and engage in political activity. A key component of freedom of political association is the ability to do so with privacy if one chooses. Privacy provides us with the ability to change and have second chances. Many people are not static; they change and grow throughout their lives. There is a great value in the ability to have a second chance, to be able to move forward beyond a mistake, to be able to reinvent oneself. Privacy nurtures this ability. The most important reason why privacy matters is not having to explain or justify oneself. We may do a lot of things which, if judged from afar by others lacking complete knowledge or understanding , may seem odd or embarrassing or worse and can have a damaging effect on one’s health. It can be a heavy burden if we constantly have to wonder how everything we do will be perceived by others and have to be at the ready to explain…
What inherent incentive do private institutions and governments have to respect the rights of the individual?...
Amazing talk really informative and the way he delivers it is so engaging
Beautifully done.
i have not had complete privacy for at least 3 years.not even a room. true story.
Volcanic, powerful speech! Thank you for your work, Mr Greenwald. Thank you for telling us the truth!
EXCELLENT presentation !!
Thank you.
Thank you...!
I hope any kid hears that message and grows up knowing that "this is not a crime to protect his privacy, but a must".
Kids who are told that privacy doesn't matter are more likely to be the next [monsters] or start forcing others to give up their privacy; or they become the most manipulated, paranoid, fearful and vulnerable persons... I'll fight to protect mine and tell my kids to do so!
Glenn Greenwald is so articulate!
Some great points, and I will definitely start using the "email me your passwords" tactic.
Great talk, very articulate.
Brilliant talk!
I like my privacy. There's a reason I taped over most of the cameras in my computers and cellphone. I live alone, so I don't really need to shut my phone down or store it in a metal box. I'm not talking much.
Thank you so much, this helped me with my English speaking language GCSE exam
having privacy changes the way we interact with eachother. we spend energy on building trust worthy relationships so we can choose who to share our personal info with. in a world without privacy relationships dont have quality.
Walls in my school are made of glass. I feel really uncomfortable knowing that anyone walking by is watching what I do....
really?
Gonna put this on loop for the rest of my life
Faith in humanity restored
Every time I realize that there are a lot of other smart people out there who care.
Thank you for the truth god bless you and your work,
Should've gotten a standing ovation IMHO.
One of the best TED presentations. Actually useful and insightful.
This man says the why i regret to have a facebook account and another social media sites, bad i was too young to get the importance of privacy.
Very well said.. im enlightened
I agree with Glenn Greenwald. I remember this thing I saw online once, that certain stores in malls had mirrors in their changing rooms that were actually two-way mirrors, so as to prevent or catch people who attempt to steal. I definitely found this unnerving and to this day, I still am paranoid and make it a point to check whether it truly is a mirror, by using a finger to touch the glass in which I am supposed to observe a gap between the finger and the mirror. Now, I do understand the security risks that the companies face, but like Greenwald mentioned, aren’t they just exploiting our privacy by assuming everyone is a bad person? Wouldn’t we in return feel at risk, since literally anyone could be viewing us? We, in return, would feel the risk in our security. Someone could use the footage of our most private moments to blackmail us and in this case, I think we can assume that the person who holds the authority to view the surveillance could be a bad person, since we, the public are assumed to be bad.
188 words, Elizabeth Mascrinhas, CMM/TB03
It all starts being imprinted in our brains with Santa Claus...."He sees you when your sleeping, he knows when you're awake......"
I agree with what Glenn Greenwald had said in this video. It is wrong to say that you have a guilty conscience just because you want privacy. Privacy is a right that everyone deserves since day one and something that everyone should respect.
Glenn Greenwald’s words about surveillance being “prison in the mind” is true. Surveillance will only take away the freedom of the citizens and nothing else. The government should not take advantage of what they have to spy on people without them knowing and come up with a ridiculous theory that the people have done something shameful if they desire privacy. People are only “obedient and compliant” because the surveillance will instil fear in the people, causing them to be more cautious of their own behaviour. It is scary to think that you are constantly being watched because there will not be any way to express your own creativity and freedom.
153 words, Val, TB03/CMM
beautiful. beautiful presentation. would have loved to be in the audience
Thanks for this Glenn. The Focault reference really made sense.
When you say “Disclose government secrets” don’t you mean crimes?
This completely changed my mind on this matter! Great job Glenn Greenwald!
Good points made here, etc. to say the very least.
I absolutely Loved this, thank you.
I agree with Glenn Greenwald view on the importance of privacy. That the world has become an “unprecedented zone of mass indiscriminate surveillance”. Mass surveillance in itself is something that everyone should be weary of. As humans, we all crave privacy. Hence the phrase “only people who are engaged in bad acts have a reason to want to hide something”. I do not agree with this statement. The word “bad” is used very loosely in this phrase as is isn’t defined what is actually considered bad. Additionally, everyone, even someone “good” has the right to privacy.
Like Glenn Greenwald said, when someone knows that they are being surveyed, it forces them to become conformed and abide by the rules because they know they have no other choice. Hence, this shows that humans in itself, can never behave like they truly want to when they know they are being watched. Thus this proves that as people, we all need and crave privacy.
164 words, Jia Hui, CMM/TB02
"mass surveillance creates a prison in the mind"
it's really good thing that some people are doing something to change peoples mind cause most of the people around thinks the same thing that they have nothing to hide they havent done anything wrong.
Love the end!!!
Thank you Glenn!! For those who don´t know, this great journalist is responsible for a series of reports which was ultimately responsible for the release of a political prisioner, ex-president Lula, from jail in Brazil. His resilience and courage for what he went through with his work (threat of much violence) is worth many, many prizes.
Thank you so much for what you´ve done in my country, we all love you... And as a journalist myself, you´re my greatest inspiration.
And helped install a dictator, Bolsanaro. Who is selling off, and burning the Amazon forest faster the a mcmansion complex in Florida.
@@black_sheep_nation How did help install Bolsanaro?
Lula is not a good guy.
If we are to accept the notion that the only check on a government's power is the displeasure of its citizens, then conditions must be such that political dissidence can not only exist but thrive. Otherwise, we as a people are screwed.
This is really something to think about.
Very well researched!!
Congratulation Glenn Greenwald for doing a serious jornalism, just in the interest of people.
Couldnt agree more. As a person who does music I still believe we deserve privacy. After a while Its a peace of mind thing. It can cause physiological matters. You have to respect a persons inner space/personal life. Just because its not brought to attention doesnt mean you should still overhear or witness.
Such as like Convos and Masturbation etc right.
+Rico Gz Right. Sometimes ppl come in at wrong times and then release unauthorized private info about them. Which could put them in a False light. Hacking can also be a form.
Understood. Its Unsettling to even think about how many are/were invading privacy and where its being Leaked to w/o consent.
Agree. UNRESTRICTED SURVEILLANCE MEANS THE STAGNATION OF ALL FUTURE PROGRESS. The biggest problem with surveillance is that it will inhibit any future change for the better. Most of the great revolutionaries and people who made a change for the better would now be called terrorists. If 500 years ago the World had had the kind of surveillance we have today we would still have the Inquisition as a form of law and the people in power would be the same.
Powerful.
I appreciate the issues discussed here. There are many valid points in it.
This man is brilliant
Excellent talk. I may not be doing anything wrong or illegal, but what I do is still my business and nobody else's. And that IS the point. It's not about having anything to hide. It's about that my lawful thoughts, feelings, and activities are NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS and I reserve the right to share these with whomever I want and for whatever reason I want, be it an arbitrary reason or not. And as for the reasons? Those too are MY BUSINESS. Privacy matters, people.
Exactly. It’s not a secret it’s just not your business.
Brilliant talk! Thanks
Thx for ur Work Mr. Greenwald its very important.