Excellent effort. A few points: A Star Destroyer would be pumping out a lot more fire than that. The X-Wings move faster than that in the SW universe. More Ties would be despatched, not just a small handful. The transport's turret needs to be more active - we saw Leia's Blockade Runner actively trading shots with the Destroyer in the original SW movie, so there's no reason this one wouldn't be doing likewise, even with its X-Wing screen. Still, a great little movie at a good visual level, and the music score was one of the best fan made one I've heard on YT. Keep up the good work!
This is really good stuff! Your space lighting is great. If I could make one suggestion I would say animate the flight paths of the fighters a bit faster and add some movement to them in the graph editor and the tilt function.
It would be cool to see the tie fighters a bit more accurately depicted, their whole design revolves around how they are extremely mobile and very difficult targets to hit, not only would it be more accurate to the lore but it would also make the fight scene more intense, other than that its really great and especially the lightning you had on the ISD made it almost look photo real
Great work, I really mean that regardless of next sentence. Only complaint or notes would be to learn what a “wing” is, as in how many fighters are in a wing and to maybe explain why a star destroyer would only deploy 3 tie fighters to stop a blockade runner with a fighter escort.
But... There are FOUR Tie Fighters... And this matches to the Death Star sending just the couple TIE after the Falcon, right? As usual with Star Wars: We put way more thought and consideration into the logistics and details of that universe, than the creator(s) ever have or will :D
It was good but, would be much better if some rebel scum died. It would be perfect if all rebel scum died but, I know it's part one. Empire fan since 1977.
Wow, the cinematography on this was amazing as well as the animation!!! This is beautiful. You made it feel like you had the film movie feel and it wasn't just a very flat ship moving through a black screen. Awesome job! I hope to get to this level one day!
My favourite touch is the "over exposure" of the ISD - Great realistic lighting, something we haven't seen in star wars before (everything's always "perfectly lit"). It reminds me of the lunar landing - even in shadow the astronauts were well lit due to light bouncing off the dark grey moon, which also looked extremely bright. Great stuff!
crazy brilliant.... Don't you love how star wars film clips outclass the last three 'disney attempt's' by parsecs... job well done team Galactic...and thanks for sharing your talent.. Btw, was this in Blender and/or Unreal Engine?
Pro level graphics/models, truly outstanding! Just a little critique, movement of the ships and especially the laser fire is just a bit slow for pursuit. Also try to adjust travel paths of the fighters to not reflect orientation and speed alone, but accommodate for weight vs momentum. It should take a second for the ships to adjust their paths after heading changes. It all looks beautiful. Hopefully this will get noticed and lead to bigger and better things. I'm looking foreword to seeing more.
Visually, it looks very nice, but in my opinion it lacks... momentum, for a lack of a better word. The ships seem too close to each other, and they _appear_ to barely move - especially that ISD at 0:47. The dogfights also happen at the spitting range, which, considering the amount of laser bolts thrown around, makes the marksmanship of those TIE Fighters utterly comical. But please keep doing those, by all means. Practice makes perfect 🙂
I appreciate seeing the Corvette take a shot; most videos play them lame. However, the Shield Dome shot was maybe a touch overzealous. I also noticed the model tracking on the X-wing as the ships crossed over the star destroyer. Still a very excellent short!
Oh my heart! This is so epic! Hit 02:04 to hear the Imperial March as you've never heard it before. @LuisHumanoide you are amazing and I am subbed to Galactic Cinema too :)
Its a nicely made Movie Project that i really like but i have a little bit of Critic in the Storytelling and Lore part i think that the Shield Generators on an ISD would not explode so fast because an X-Wing fires two or three Shots with its Laser Guns on it.The Executor Generator needed 12 Concussion Missiles and the Fire of multiple Star Ships to Explode clearly an ISD Generator would be less heavily Armored so i think the half firepower would be Enough.And i think that 3 X-Wings outmatch 6-8 TIE Fighters without a loss on the Rebellion Side looks less Dramatic than with some losses.But thats just my Personal point of view.Beside the two Points i think its an Epic Project
alright, this is amazing however.... if you play Tie Fighter, then you know that C-90 packs a lot of heat for Tie Fighters. Would have been nice to see many more lazer strikes from it.
Was a beautioful piece of Art. Just one thing from my personal view. It felt like T-Fighters and X-Wings were way too slow. I think with more speed on those little fighters it would have been more intense.. but thats just my personal view. Anyway.. Outstanding job. Loved this!
Very well done! If I can scratch in two small notes: 1- the flight speed of the X-Wing and TIEs is a bit slow and 2- the scale of the fighters vs the Star Destroyer is a bit off... Both minor points though! This looks amazing! :P
This looks amazing. The only thing that could've marginally improve it would be speeding up the action a little bit, as the fighters look a little sluggish.
Nice content, nice work! Just an advice: make next time also casualties to the Rebels - if there isn't any, it is just Disney-ish, like a video game. Notify just how big casualties the Rebels had in New Hope, Empire strikes back and the Return of the Jedi before the victories.
It was very fun to score this project, that's absolutely crazy!
You never miss, such a diverse track!
the legend himself!
Great music!
I was trying to work out when John Williams wrote this.
GREAT JOB!!!
Excellent effort. A few points: A Star Destroyer would be pumping out a lot more fire than that. The X-Wings move faster than that in the SW universe. More Ties would be despatched, not just a small handful. The transport's turret needs to be more active - we saw Leia's Blockade Runner actively trading shots with the Destroyer in the original SW movie, so there's no reason this one wouldn't be doing likewise, even with its X-Wing screen. Still, a great little movie at a good visual level, and the music score was one of the best fan made one I've heard on YT. Keep up the good work!
Gonna have to wait for the algorithm to pick this up and show it to everyone, then watch the likes counter go nuts.
This is really good stuff! Your space lighting is great. If I could make one suggestion I would say animate the flight paths of the fighters a bit faster and add some movement to them in the graph editor and the tilt function.
Yeah seemed sluggish
I agree
That ISD looks absolutely beautiful
It would be cool to see the tie fighters a bit more accurately depicted, their whole design revolves around how they are extremely mobile and very difficult targets to hit, not only would it be more accurate to the lore but it would also make the fight scene more intense, other than that its really great and especially the lightning you had on the ISD made it almost look photo real
Being picky speed of the star fighters is a bit slow and the destroyed shield generator could of trailed a bit of debris/smoke
Great work, I really mean that regardless of next sentence. Only complaint or notes would be to learn what a “wing” is, as in how many fighters are in a wing and to maybe explain why a star destroyer would only deploy 3 tie fighters to stop a blockade runner with a fighter escort.
But... There are FOUR Tie Fighters...
And this matches to the Death Star sending just the couple TIE after the Falcon, right?
As usual with Star Wars: We put way more thought and consideration into the logistics and details of that universe, than the creator(s) ever have or will :D
@@FunkThompsonmy guy they were letting the falcon go.. just making them think they actually got away
@@Shizlberry97 Eh... again, these things never make sense, except when a rare concurrence happens and they manage to accidentally get things right :D
Galactic Cinema is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be unnatural
an old player of x wing 90's game series here...
THIS IS FANTASTIC !!!!
Cool, that looks so realistic.
ok thats some of the best starship rendering that ive seen ..... period !
Well done!
Again another fan film creating more high quality movie level cgi space battles! Beautiful model work!!!!
It's just so appreciating to see beautiful CR-90 in action.
I'm a huge fan of Star Wars this was a very nice take on the Star wars lore very well made.
GREAT WORK!!! The Star Destroyer is based on the very original prop!!! I love it!!! FANTASTIC!!!
I'm your 500th like! :D
It was good but, would be much better if some rebel scum died. It would be perfect if all rebel scum died but, I know it's part one.
Empire fan since 1977.
Wow this was an incredible short film! It was well choreographed and the effects were top notch!
Wow, the cinematography on this was amazing as well as the animation!!! This is beautiful. You made it feel like you had the film movie feel and it wasn't just a very flat ship moving through a black screen. Awesome job! I hope to get to this level one day!
Love that very subtle screenwipe
Thanks for your Great work 😊👍
AWESOME work👍👍
Loved it. !! Great job and that rogue one cameo. Perfect
My favourite touch is the "over exposure" of the ISD - Great realistic lighting, something we haven't seen in star wars before (everything's always "perfectly lit").
It reminds me of the lunar landing - even in shadow the astronauts were well lit due to light bouncing off the dark grey moon, which also looked extremely bright. Great stuff!
One of the Officers on the ISD Bridge: "Telling Lord Vader the bad news 1, 2, 3 NOT IT!!!"
super impressive VFX work!
Thanks a lot!
@@galacticcinema8906 of course dude!
Its spot on. Lighting is perfect. Better effects than the Acolyte
Brilliant work, very professional and fun to watch. Felt like a proper Star Wars movie.
This was even more one sided than your standard George Lucus film. This couldn't even happen in video games on easy mode.
This was really good quality. Good job.
The only thing I would change, is increase the fighters speed.
This deserves way more likes. I’m being serious when I say that some of the scenes look more realistic then disneys visual effects. Wish you luck!
They’ve obviously used clips and cinematography from Rogue One and merged it with editing.
Actually sick graphics for a fan-made. Well done!
crazy brilliant.... Don't you love how star wars film clips outclass the last three 'disney attempt's' by parsecs... job well done team Galactic...and thanks for sharing your talent.. Btw, was this in Blender and/or Unreal Engine?
Blender!
Good lord this is FANTASTIC!
Looks like the real thing fan made great work
Passion on full display here. Bravo!
Much appreciated!
Not bad! Enjoyable to watch as a fan
Pro level graphics/models, truly outstanding! Just a little critique, movement of the ships and especially the laser fire is just a bit slow for pursuit. Also try to adjust travel paths of the fighters to not reflect orientation and speed alone, but accommodate for weight vs momentum. It should take a second for the ships to adjust their paths after heading changes. It all looks beautiful. Hopefully this will get noticed and lead to bigger and better things. I'm looking foreword to seeing more.
This is what I imagine whenever I look at my lego sets
Great short film and the soundtrack is amazing. May the Force be with you!!!
Fantastic work, the on-board POV's are so good, really immersive!
Glad you like them!
1:17 Nice Rogue One quote!
Very good, but it could need a bit faster animations and more realism in terms of the durability of an star destroyer.. (;
an excellent project if i do say so myself. the music is exceptionally well made as well
Visually, it looks very nice, but in my opinion it lacks... momentum, for a lack of a better word.
The ships seem too close to each other, and they _appear_ to barely move - especially that ISD at 0:47. The dogfights also happen at the spitting range, which, considering the amount of laser bolts thrown around, makes the marksmanship of those TIE Fighters utterly comical.
But please keep doing those, by all means. Practice makes perfect 🙂
Beautiful work...seems like you really got the best balance of cgi and what looks to be practical effects. This is close to ILM in it's heyday!
The lighting is so professional.
This was an amazing ride!
Not too many things can make me sub, but this did the trick! 👍💪
Amazing Work !!!! Thanks for this guys !!! Congratulations !!!!
VERY good result! Well done!
Master Galactic, it was awesome, Great Job. we need more than this. Amazing.
I appreciate seeing the Corvette take a shot; most videos play them lame. However, the Shield Dome shot was maybe a touch overzealous. I also noticed the model tracking on the X-wing as the ships crossed over the star destroyer. Still a very excellent short!
Beautiful animation and a wonderful collab with Luis!!😊❤❤❤
I think so too!
Absolutely amazing fan film the planet looks amazing I hope my short film will be half as good as this
A Beautiful cinematic treat!
Really good. It looks so real
It is amazing what WE ( Fan film makers ) can do now!
1:20 that’s like that x wing in rogue one!
Incredible! Good Job, Thumbs up given!👍🏽
This was amazing. My only issue was some of the shots lacked speed. That being said, that was amazing.
The visuals looked like the old models from the original trilogy. Very cool.
Oh my heart! This is so epic! Hit 02:04 to hear the Imperial March as you've never heard it before. @LuisHumanoide you are amazing and I am subbed to Galactic Cinema too :)
Very good, excellent animation and ship detail!!
The best! a little stiff and slow at times however the angles and FPV and more are still the best and even better than some of the movies!
I want more, but I know I shouldn't. But seriously, my only hiccup is that it was far too short. Do wish more to come from you, thank you!
A+ on Graphics and Music.
Play at 1.25x speed and then it's fun.
I think 1.5x speed looks better again
Best one yet- compose us a 60- minute one please.
Great work, you should add some Y-Wings to the battle.
Very good production value.
NO WAY
ROGUE ONE-ACCURATE TIE-FIGHTERS
damn! incredible work!
Good Animation like from here
Its only problem is that it needs to be longer, excellent start!
Great job!
Fighters could maybe look like they are going a bit faster but other than that this is pretty cool 🎉
I'd rather watch this than anything Disney poops out.
May the Force be with you
A good animation overall but there's no reason the Empire would have sent four out of 72 Tie fighters aboard that ISD for the Rebels
Well, that was amazing! You should be hired to make the new movies than they would be so much better
Its a nicely made Movie Project that i really like but i have a little bit of Critic in the Storytelling and Lore part i think that the Shield Generators on an ISD would not explode so fast because an X-Wing fires two or three Shots with its Laser Guns on it.The Executor Generator needed 12 Concussion Missiles and the Fire of multiple Star Ships to Explode clearly an ISD Generator would be less heavily Armored so i think the half firepower would be Enough.And i think that 3 X-Wings outmatch 6-8 TIE Fighters without a loss on the Rebellion Side looks less Dramatic than with some losses.But thats just my Personal point of view.Beside the two Points i think its an Epic Project
Amazing job.
Thanks!
SUB'ed !!!!
alright, this is amazing however.... if you play Tie Fighter, then you know that C-90 packs a lot of heat for Tie Fighters. Would have been nice to see many more lazer strikes from it.
“Tie fighters, incoming”
* proceeds to shoot literally at the star destroyer *
How is it that I’m able to enjoy this animation more than rise of skywalker?
That was great!
Star Destroyer: "We've got all these guns, why are we only shooting one cannon"?
"Budget, Sir"
Nice work!
Dude!!! This is INSANELY GOOD! Blender?
Yes it was!
So cool
Things went quite well for the Rebellion, didn't they!
Because they're the only ones who can aim.
@@grisom5863why?
so good
Then the granny said to the child "That's right, and evil always loses, and nothing bad ever happens to anyone, no matter what."
Was a beautioful piece of Art. Just one thing from my personal view. It felt like T-Fighters and X-Wings were way too slow. I think with more speed on those little fighters it would have been more intense.. but thats just my personal view. Anyway.. Outstanding job. Loved this!
Very well done! If I can scratch in two small notes: 1- the flight speed of the X-Wing and TIEs is a bit slow and 2- the scale of the fighters vs the Star Destroyer is a bit off...
Both minor points though! This looks amazing! :P
The animation is easily the best I've seen, hell, I saw the destroyer and thought it was IGN movie grade. The rebels winning, little plot heavy.
Very cool! Lighting, sounds and models were top notch, i feel like some of the animations and camera paths were a bit clunky tho.
This looks amazing. The only thing that could've marginally improve it would be speeding up the action a little bit, as the fighters look a little sluggish.
Nice content, nice work! Just an advice: make next time also casualties to the Rebels - if there isn't any, it is just Disney-ish, like a video game. Notify just how big casualties the Rebels had in New Hope, Empire strikes back and the Return of the Jedi before the victories.