I have been listening to them for 30 years. A dear old friend they are, along with my depression. It never gets better, only life goes on until it doesn't....
It is nearly impossible to listen to anything else after this. It is so emotionally draining. There couldn't have been a better closing track for Closer.
I agree friend it truely is emotionally draining too listen to anything else to get to the state this song puts you in an exeptence of darkness as a beauty
a journey that leads straight to hell. I try to stop listening to this extraordinary album before getting to Decades because of the effect it has on me. Crying.
13 when I got into Joy Division my interest was stoked listening to the John peel Sessions another legendary person then I got to see them supporting Buzzcocks at the Rainbow Theatre in London then later they did a small gig at the High Wycombe Town Hall supported by my Killing Joke. I even hustled money in the street to get a friend in I absolutely loved that band . absolutely pissed over everything that was going on at the time way too dark for most people but absolutely legend . Ethereal aesthetic combined with Ian curtis's crazy dancing very abstract and intense reading of n m e e and sounds magazine I bawled my eyes out when I found out out about his suicide. I think by then I was 14 or 15 then I stopped buying my usual music magazines however always find myself coming back to their tunes watching drum covers some of them done very artfully done . got proper cult status hall of fame Legends
This song was with me through one of my many depressive episodes, and I don't listen to it pretty often bc of the bad memories But is such a beautiful song, and once I play it is like traveling in time
@@Happyradio1234 I related strongly to Ian and joy division throughout 1979 - 1981. They were an essential and special part of our generation (gen-x). It was a traumatic time for me, and their music was inimical to my feeling and the experiences I was going through. JD were unique and special. When Ian committed suicide I was devastated. I remember clearly what went through my mind. Why Ian? Why not me? And I felt guilt because I had sensed his mental torture throughout the Unknown Pleasures and the Closer albums, and feared for him in the months before his death. If only I had acted before it was too late. I guess the rest of the band must have felt it the most. Ian represented my own desolation and I miss him like he was the brother that I never had.
the perfect Joy Division song... each skeletal element arriving piecemeal as the song proceeds...the synthesizer that sounds like it was dropped on its head at birth... and when the real drums come in... one of the Great Moments in Recorded Sound... there's nowhere else to go after that song ends...
@@Varonno More precisely, a free reed instrument with buttons for the early models before being declined with a keyboard. They have a very spottable sound between harmonica and accordions. One famous post-punk/goth rock band having used it for a solo was Bauhaus in She's in Parties (Hohner melodica soprano).
@ Per chance, I have a couple of melodions and a theremin. Prefer the ancient whistles-clay etc. But I’m paring my life down. Want an Eventide H-9000. Can’t afford duplication space. Ergonomics and GUI is important,more. The human element acoustic instrumentation. The era of synthetics in my compositions has run its course has much I can help. There’s plenty of synthetics after in the digital realm! Have fun!
Quelle puissance ténébreuse déployée . Je n'ose imaginé quelles chansons Ian nous aurez gratifié si il serait toujours parmi nous . Vraiment une masterpiece . R.I.P Ian 🙏
My favorite band of all the time is the The Doors and my favorite musician is Bach. And believe me, I really love music and I have listened almost everything, from Classic Music to World Music. Rock, Pop, Soul, RB, Funk from 60, 70, 80,90 and so on. Soft, hard and heavy. One thing Ive discovered, Ian Curtis is the most important lyric writer of all times. Too much for the rest. He was the lyrics Bach.
I recently discovered the Great War poet Wilfred Owen was Commissioned into the Manchester Regiment in 1916. His poems often detail the horrors of his experiences of the war, including the deaths of the young men in his battalion. All Manchester lads, many from Salford. Around 1,000 or more of his comrades were killed in that war, probably most of them from the Manchester area. It must have been a huge blow to their families and the whole of Manchester. All those decades later, when I hear Ian Curtis sing ‘decades’, it is almost as if he is channeling the suffering, the loss of all those soldiers and the grief of their families. “Here are the young men, well where have they been?” Our own generation also are grateful for Ian because he articulated how many of our own lost generation felt in the late seventies.
😊My best school friend and me were listening that song when we were 17. Now , ten years passed and that your favorite song again, Oleg. We are so far away one from each other but every times when im listening jd i cried about you.
So eerie at the end, Ian asks over and over, "Where have they been " as if he's waiting on an answer that never comes, his voice slowly fades away as if resigned. RIP Ian 🖤
I went through a depressive episode almost a year ago. When i tried to commit suicide i put this song as a way to say goodbye. Right now i don't listen this song very often but when i do it doesn´t hurt anymore :')
I'm happy that you're better now. I was diagnosed with severe depression when I was a kid, I lost my father to suicide when I was eight years old. When I was 14 I drank for the first time, when I was 15 I smoked weed for the first time and after that I started to experiment with DXM cough syrup and pregabalin and other stuff. At some point I started with codeine and got addicted to iv subutex when I was like 20. I had already tried methylphenidate and amphetamine intravenously before that. I tried to commit suicide when I got drunk a few times, alcohol really worsened my depression and anxiety. Now I'm on suboxone treatment, and will be switched to methadone this fall. I'm 10 or 11 months sober from alcohol now. 🙂 Hang in there! Things will get better. I have ADHD too and maybe bipolar, but they haven't been able to sort out if I have bpd because I haven't been able to stay sober for long enough. There is a lot of bipolar on my fathers side of family. I also have OCD, but I don't know if it's been diagnosed. Things are going better for me now. 😊
I saw new order play at heaton park this Friday, and they played this just before they finished with love will tear us apart. One of the most mesmerising moments of my life. I can’t fathom what it’d be like back when they played this as joy division.
Ends with a summary of religions, his last words in this album. For all our wanderings "slammed in our face". There was no chance of any salvation, for him.
Encontré a este banda inglesa de joy división ❤ me puse a oir sus rolitas e kedado fascinada en cada una de ellas Ian curtis refleja su sentir y sus hemociones
"Decades" es de una hermosura abrumadora. Descubrì el "Closer" de Joy Division cuando saliò. Yo tenìa 16 años. Durante 20 años no he podido escucharla por la tristeza que me embargaba. Si pudiese elegir, serìa la ùltima canciòn que oyese en mi vida
No song has the thaumaturgical power to make you feel like JD's Decades inside Ian Curtis' grave. Then I realize how it is one of the most beautiful songs written by the Man, and I rise up immanently.
I remember first time listening to this properly age 13 on my Walkman and tape i nabbed from my mom. night in the rain in a real bad time in my life. I hear it now and still takes me there. makes me feel amazed and grateful that lil man pulled through
"Closer" found me at one of the lowest points in my life. It felt like God was "rubbing salt into the wound". A work of profound emptyness and brilliance, "Decades" took it to another level.
A song that stays with you during your life time.
I have been listening to them for 30 years. A dear old friend they are, along with my depression. It never gets better, only life goes on until it doesn't....
and beyond
Sure does.
So true. I haven't heard it for years but got irresistibly drawn back to it today.
Listening to the Closer album is an event that you plan for. You settle into your darkness and feel.
The last 2 minutes of this song are, for me, the 2 most beautiful minutes of music ever recorded.
This song blurs the line between beauty and pain.
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
@@stormfromxmen3701 Shut up please
Yessss😢
WORD😌
@@stormfromxmen3701 In what possible universe is this song underrated???
This is definitely the best song written in history since the world began to exist ...
Sure one of the better
It is nearly impossible to listen to anything else after this. It is so emotionally draining. There couldn't have been a better closing track for Closer.
It’s like church music played in hell
@@StringSun Good way to put it. There's a preachy, ominous and cathartic element to this song.
Agree
@@polderdebanjan thik ble6is bhai
I agree friend it truely is emotionally draining too listen to anything else to get to the state this song puts you in an exeptence of darkness as a beauty
An absolute masterpiece ❤.
I agree here 🖤🌹
Over 40 years later now and it still makes me ...can't find words for it..an everlasting moment in time
Joy Division had an authenticity that has been unparalleled before or since.
a masterpiece
Exactly
Just Quality
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
Yes.
X@@morningstarrssThis music was The frist i've heaŕd from JD AND SOMETHING AWAKE ISIDE OF ME!!!
These guys were in their early twenties when they wrote this magical ever lasting beauty of a song. Incredible.
Martin Hannet gives it that oomph factor as well
The most beautiful, haunting song ever made.
40 plus years of listening to this beautiful music. They were quite simply a great band.
So dark, so beautiful ... such an outstanding song.
Breathtaking! RIP Ian Curtis, great Poet!
Best lyricist in rock history.
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
@@internazionaleronaldo1941 Can’t argue with that was a poet genius.
More than 40 years on and still none better.
.
Best song ever
Closer is not an album of songs, it is a journey
It's a Poetry Compilation in Motion
But a journey to where? Unfortunately we know the answer. RIP Ian Curtis.
@@camillab7 For some people, life is hell, and salvation is another world. There is no death, we just continue elsewhere.
a journey that leads straight to hell. I try to stop listening to this extraordinary album before getting to Decades because of the effect it has on me. Crying.
No, it's an album of songs. When did everything start to be a 'journey'?
Closer (adjective): nearer. Closer (noun): finished.
This song's melody is beautiful.. it's dark and gloomy and sad.. I love it..
I love it
HI listen to this song -
isolation by the impures
@@stormfromxmen3701 no
Joy Division Are Like Being in Another Dimension... Unreal Brilliance 💋
This track is beautiful,when the keyboard kicks in ,just gorgeous.
How can a 20 something Englishman come up with these lyrics? Absolutely beyond his generation, RIP Ian.
Totally astonishing.....
These genius come, send a message and vanish
Intelligence and suffering
Alma antiga!
Being lost in the void .
My favourite song. By anyone ever. Pure genius. Has made me cry 1000 times
So dark, but ethereal and beautiful. Feel the same here.
Head of his time, I was 21 when this song came out. Still a classic
maybe even my favorite. But I try not to listen to her so I don't cry.
This song is so haunting, it gives me chills and a feeling of foreboding. What a master craft
There are songs that aren't simply songs, but something else far more powerful, that's why this band's so unique.
One of my fave bands ever, RIP Ian❤
What a song, what ending, absolute masterpiece
The first song I ever heard with Joy Division (I was eleven years old). Knocked me out completely. Still in love!
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
Did you understand any of the lyrics ? I mean being from Sweden
GREATEST band of all time. Peter hook and Ian curtis are legands. Rip ian
don’t forget morris’ amazing drumming skills and sumners great riffs.
13 when I got into Joy Division my interest was stoked listening to the John peel Sessions another legendary person then I got to see them supporting Buzzcocks at the Rainbow Theatre in London then later they did a small gig at the High Wycombe Town Hall supported by my Killing Joke. I even hustled money in the street to get a friend in I absolutely loved that band . absolutely pissed over everything that was going on at the time way too dark for most people but absolutely legend . Ethereal aesthetic combined with Ian curtis's crazy dancing very abstract and intense reading of n m e e and sounds magazine I bawled my eyes out when I found out out about his suicide. I think by then I was 14 or 15 then I stopped buying my usual music magazines however always find myself coming back to their tunes watching drum covers some of them done very artfully done . got proper cult status hall of fame Legends
Barney is so underrated one of the greatest songwriters ever with New Order
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
You forgot Martin Hannett - no Hannett, no Joy Division.
Just a total classic
Im from Brazil. Ian is so special, many people from Brazil love Joy Division.
4:01 that incredible synthesiser. Things just got even more serious...
I think few, if any other, moments in music have struck me with awe like that.
This song may be simple in structure but it's like a requiem in depth.
That, my friend, is the sound of Ultimate Despair.
I’m not sure who came up with that part, either Barney or Hannett but it is incredible
ARP Omni-2 : ua-cam.com/video/seCDZ8zhfYY/v-deo.html
a fitting end to closer. what a great album.
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
prob my fav song by these guys
Me too.
Best ever song scary listen to the lyrics
This song was with me through one of my many depressive episodes, and I don't listen to it pretty often bc of the bad memories
But is such a beautiful song, and once I play it is like traveling in time
Same. It also not only a travelling in the bad times of your life, but also a travelling to the mediaeval Europe or ancient Greece
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
Same
I listened to this song after a suicide attempt and just felt so understood. I wish I could save this man as he had saved me.
@@Happyradio1234 I related strongly to Ian and joy division throughout 1979 - 1981. They were an essential and special part of our generation (gen-x). It was a traumatic time for me, and their music was inimical to my feeling and the experiences I was going through. JD were unique and special. When Ian committed suicide I was devastated. I remember clearly what went through my mind. Why Ian? Why not me? And I felt guilt because I had sensed his mental torture throughout the Unknown Pleasures and the Closer albums, and feared for him in the months before his death. If only I had acted before it was too late. I guess the rest of the band must have felt it the most.
Ian represented my own desolation and I miss him like he was the brother that I never had.
I wish I could discover joy division again for the first time, my absolute favorite band of all time 🖤🖤🖤
JD lyrics are so inspiring, they are the most elegant and beautiful lyrics, forever. My soul will pick them up in my next life
the perfect Joy Division song... each skeletal element arriving piecemeal as the song proceeds...the synthesizer that sounds like it was dropped on its head at birth... and when the real drums come in... one of the Great Moments in Recorded Sound... there's nowhere else to go after that song ends...
It’s Ian’s melodica. It’s a wind instrument with a keyboard not unlike an accordion
@@Varonno More precisely, a free reed instrument with buttons for the early models before being declined with a keyboard. They have a very spottable sound between harmonica and accordions. One famous post-punk/goth rock band having used it for a solo was Bauhaus in She's in Parties (Hohner melodica soprano).
@ Per chance, I have a couple of melodions and a theremin. Prefer the ancient whistles-clay etc. But I’m paring my life down. Want an Eventide H-9000. Can’t afford duplication space. Ergonomics and GUI is important,more. The human element acoustic instrumentation. The era of synthetics in my compositions has run its course has much I can help. There’s plenty of synthetics after in the digital realm! Have fun!
A masterpiece from a legendary band 💯
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
@@stormfromxmen3701 so cute🌙
I saw this song live when Hooky played Unknown Pleasures and Closer live last week. Absolutely incredible.
This is still way ahead of any curve .... amazing. What a legacy Ian. Thank you.
Got tingles listening to this today. It hits home in so many ways, you can almost feel the universe expanding, ready to spit us out.
That does not alter the fact that the melody bears close resemblance to the 1976 track Le corridor from Canadian band Harmonium.
Quelle puissance ténébreuse déployée . Je n'ose imaginé quelles chansons Ian nous aurez gratifié si il serait toujours parmi nous . Vraiment une masterpiece . R.I.P Ian 🙏
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
Dark and beautiful. One of my favourites for sure.
Questo pezzo è di una bellezza devastante.....ti scava dentro... La voce di Ian Curtis è incredibile. Oltre il capolavoro..
It's just like reading a Dostoyevsky novel ...beautiful...!!
❣ of course. Right on !
Hadn't thought of it before. And Dostoyevsky is one of my favorite authors.
One of the best songs ever written
Yes 1:07
My favorite band of all the time is the The Doors and my favorite musician is Bach. And believe me, I really love music and I have listened almost everything, from Classic Music to World Music. Rock, Pop, Soul, RB, Funk from 60, 70, 80,90 and so on. Soft, hard and heavy. One thing Ive discovered, Ian Curtis is the most important lyric writer of all times. Too much for the rest. He was the lyrics Bach.
👌👍🏽🤙
👏👏👏👏👏
For sure
Ian Curtis loved Jim Morrison aswell the fact he burnt out at a young age..
Never underestimate joy division !!!! They are amazing
Perfect song!
this is the best Joy Division by a country mile!
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gemvv
Amazing
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures v
<
is an underrated gem
The chord progression into, and repeated in, the chorus is sheer genius
The ultimate proto-goth tune. Always my favorite Joy Division song, and probably always will be.
Same
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
@@stormfromxmen3701 no
My favourite JD track also👍
This is my favourite song! The best of my heart
MASTERPIECE
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gemcdcdc
By far the best joy division track an absolute classic
I recently discovered the Great War poet Wilfred Owen was Commissioned into the Manchester Regiment in 1916. His poems often detail the horrors of his experiences of the war, including the deaths of the young men in his battalion. All Manchester lads, many from Salford. Around 1,000 or more of his comrades were killed in that war, probably most of them from the Manchester area. It must have been a huge blow to their families and the whole of Manchester. All those decades later, when I hear Ian Curtis sing ‘decades’, it is almost as if he is channeling the suffering, the loss of all those soldiers and the grief of their families. “Here are the young men, well where have they been?” Our own generation also are grateful for Ian because he articulated how many of our own lost generation felt in the late seventies.
🎶 immortal song 🎶
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
my favorite
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gemdcdc
😊My best school friend and me were listening that song when we were 17. Now , ten years passed and that your favorite song again, Oleg. We are so far away one from each other but every times when im listening jd i cried about you.
did we really wanted to die? I can't....
So eerie at the end, Ian asks over and over, "Where have they been " as if he's waiting on an answer that never comes, his voice slowly fades away as if resigned. RIP Ian 🖤
I love this song so much that I learned to play it on my harp ❤
I went through a depressive episode almost a year ago. When i tried to commit suicide i put this song as a way to say goodbye.
Right now i don't listen this song very often but when i do it doesn´t hurt anymore :')
Stay here.......
👍🤗
hope you ok now,,,,im in that mode just now,,,,,sorry peoples.
I'm happy that you're better now. I was diagnosed with severe depression when I was a kid, I lost my father to suicide when I was eight years old. When I was 14 I drank for the first time, when I was 15 I smoked weed for the first time and after that I started to experiment with DXM cough syrup and pregabalin and other stuff. At some point I started with codeine and got addicted to iv subutex when I was like 20. I had already tried methylphenidate and amphetamine intravenously before that. I tried to commit suicide when I got drunk a few times, alcohol really worsened my depression and anxiety. Now I'm on suboxone treatment, and will be switched to methadone this fall. I'm 10 or 11 months sober from alcohol now. 🙂 Hang in there! Things will get better. I have ADHD too and maybe bipolar, but they haven't been able to sort out if I have bpd because I haven't been able to stay sober for long enough. There is a lot of bipolar on my fathers side of family. I also have OCD, but I don't know if it's been diagnosed. Things are going better for me now. 😊
@@ianmccrae3391 Hang in there buddy, it will get better at some point. I hope you are better now. 🙂 Please don't kill yourself.
Stunning...blood letting, death, full of pain & the shedding of tears...
After loosing my mum to cancer at 59 in 2018 , I found this track and it helped me grieve 🩷 Haunting but beautiful ✨️
Everything I relisten to this I am flooded with past pain yet somehow lifted up
One my favourite songs of all the times!
Best song ever, period.
That whole track is pure genius, thats martin for the foresight to hear it in youre head, but the last 5 mins is a epic journey to heaven.
That keyboard sound is emotionally draining
I saw new order play at heaton park this Friday, and they played this just before they finished with love will tear us apart. One of the most mesmerising moments of my life. I can’t fathom what it’d be like back when they played this as joy division.
Better.
@@steve261brown Fair enough.
My favorite song ever!!!
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
Mine too
Ends with a summary of religions, his last words in this album. For all our wanderings "slammed in our face". There was no chance of any salvation, for him.
My favorite of favorite thank you so much xxx
How the hi hat kicks in with Ian’s vocal at 1:28 the sublime synth at 4:00…just wow…
Li ascoltavo quando ero ragazzina ed ora dopo 40 anni, penso ancora che closer sia un vero capolavoro
This song is amazing!
Closer é um álbum emblemático
Encontré a este banda inglesa de joy división ❤ me puse a oir sus rolitas e kedado fascinada en cada una de ellas Ian curtis refleja su sentir y sus hemociones
"Decades" es de una hermosura abrumadora. Descubrì el "Closer" de Joy Division cuando saliò. Yo tenìa 16 años. Durante 20 años no he podido escucharla por la tristeza que me embargaba. Si pudiese elegir, serìa la ùltima canciòn que oyese en mi vida
2:47 vi no twitter que "malandramente" teve uma interpolação tirada daqui, e que a Billie allish pegou esse mesmo sample
É nos tmj
Me encanta Joy Division😊
No song has the thaumaturgical power to make you feel like JD's Decades inside Ian Curtis' grave. Then I realize how it is one of the most beautiful songs written by the Man, and I rise up immanently.
Feels like looking into the past and the future simultaneously.
Ian got me through worst so long ago. I can go on, strong, through him.
so best and incredible
Timeless classic
NO OTHER BAND CAN EVEN TOUCH THEM.
NONE!!!!!!!!!
You only understand this song in depression scary been on the edge of a cliff once don’t know why am still here
one of fav track of JD for ever
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
Class tune class band
My favourite song 😍🍻
I get chills down my spine everytime I hear that last minute or so... 😰
maybe the greatest Joy Division's Song. or at least One of the best. so intense, so melancholic, so....
My fav.
The last few songs on Closer are on a different plain. They come from a different world. It sounds like he is leaving and never coming back.
"Portrayal of the trauma and degeneration". Damn, that line always get me, I guess I'm getting a tattoo of it.
I’m getting “We knocked on the doors of hell’s darkest chamber “
If you got that tatted , that would be corny af
HI listen to this song -
miss me by the impures
<
is an underrated gem
Really resonates with me as well. I'm literally both traumatized and a degenerate
I remember first time listening to this properly age 13 on my Walkman and tape i nabbed from my mom. night in the rain in a real bad time in my life. I hear it now and still takes me there. makes me feel amazed and grateful that lil man pulled through
"Closer" found me at one of the lowest points in my life. It felt like God was "rubbing salt into the wound".
A work of profound emptyness and brilliance, "Decades" took it to another level.
as a kid this album skitzed me out but now I can appreciate the beauty of it all. Righto. Goodnight .
So beatiful.
Chills and tears