What was the problem with Tony McCarroll? In my opinion he had the best rhytms, and coolest looking drum kit. Their songs were so much more punchy with his drumming
He didn’t get along with Noel but he also refused to get drumming lessons. In a lot Noel was jealous of tony. Tony had a secure family life while Noel was broken.
Lo mejor que oasos puede hacer para su gira mundial es llevar a alan white y a tony mccarroll...., ambos son los baterias de oasis y se merecen poder las canciones que ellos crearon. A lead drummer and a rhytmic drummer.
I disagree. I love the songs Alan White does play on but man, I am not of fan of the way he plays all the oasis songs that Tony McCarroll had originally played on. His jazzy groove style of playing just doesn’t fit those songs in my opinion. Some Might Say and Acquiesce sound so much heavier and better with Tony’s Raw/Straightforward punk style of drumming along with the rest of the songs Tony plays on compared to Alan White rendition of oasis songs originally with Tony.
Dont give a fuck McCarroll smashed it and will always be THE Oasis drummer for me.
agreed 10000%
@@ysgramorssoupspoonliam should do the ultimate fuck you to noel and have Tony as the drummer on the DEF MAYBE tour.
yes..
BEST OASIS DRUMMER AND ROCKER HAIR
The best drummer oasis had
What was the problem with Tony McCarroll? In my opinion he had the best rhytms, and coolest looking drum kit. Their songs were so much more punchy with his drumming
Noel is to blame, stupid as hell
Totally agree 👍🏻
Simple. Noel didn’t like him!
He didn’t get along with Noel but he also refused to get drumming lessons.
In a lot Noel was jealous of tony. Tony had a secure family life while Noel was broken.
Absolutely
FIRST time i hear liam sings the second verse of the original version. fucking amazing and EPIC jaja
+Nazareno Rodriguez Not in the order haha
Lo mejor que oasos puede hacer para su gira mundial es llevar a alan white y a tony mccarroll...., ambos son los baterias de oasis y se merecen poder las canciones que ellos crearon. A lead drummer and a rhytmic drummer.
TONY TENIA EL ADN OASIS, QUE LASTIMA QUE LO HAYAN SACADO, POR LEJOS EL BATERIA MAS ROCKERO DE OASIS. DEBERIAN TRAERLO DE VUELTA EN LA GIRA MUNDIAL
classic live version
You can clearly see Noel is sick of Tony in the beginning
Never thought I'd say it but noel was so out of tune
Noel was pissed at Tony at the beginning
I thought that too, couldn't work out why he seemed in time to me.
I think he's annoyed by boneheads guitar loud feedback
@@sergiobarbosa3192 idk the cymbal hitting seemed kinda slow to me
Noel you shouldn't throw with rocks when you live in a house of glass.
Your singing is worse than Tony's drumming.
Nothings wrong with his drumming
That is 100% true in this case... Tony is a great drummer.
he was so much rock n roll for noel.. i think
but her groove and the voice of liam its mmake a fire
Biblical
:25 you're fired Tony
I’m a massive Noel fan but he was so out of tune in this gig
Is this the only time Liam actually sings this properly live with all the verses?
no, he sing the second verse in glastonbury 1995 too
@@ximi2377 Yeah I noticed after I commented. Shame he never did again. 😩
Actually, he sings all verses properly now. lol
This song sounds so much better with alan white on drums!
just a little bit better
@@stephano7022 8 year old comment.
I disagree. I love the songs Alan White does play on but man, I am not of fan of the way he plays all the oasis songs that Tony McCarroll had originally played on. His jazzy groove style of playing just doesn’t fit those songs in my opinion. Some Might Say and Acquiesce sound so much heavier and better with Tony’s Raw/Straightforward punk style of drumming along with the rest of the songs Tony plays on compared to Alan White rendition of oasis songs originally with Tony.
Alan whites fucking shite should have had his brother.
@@DenKulesteSomFins and?