Debt funding for consumption and inability to pay back , will take us down. This in addition to the freebie culture and loan write off , by politicians to come to power.
"Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions , so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
Another great video sir 👏. Your insights are very helpful which provide an unbiased view of the economic landscape with historical references also which is very helpful for the young ones genz etc. It is well said: in the long run, India disappoints both the optimist and the pessimist.
Thank you so much for your kind words and thoughtful feedback! We are glad you found the insights valuable and unbiased, especially for the younger generation navigating today’s economic landscape. We'll keep bringing more such content to deepen understanding and inspire informed perspectives. Stay tuned!
Almost nobody seems to see these realities staring at us presented so clearly by Debasish! Our macro economic numbers reflecting performance of the top 15% of our population seem to dazzle the echo chamber and keep the government machinery active in matters affecting the same 15% almost exclusively. MSME & Agriculture sectors, instead of playing a bigger role, are in a state of distress instead. Is someone in power listening to us at all??
Always wait anxiously for Debashish sir's golden insights. This time, though, had already read the news article in their newsletter summarizing the same 😎
Thank you for your thoughtful comment! We're glad to hear you're enjoying Debashis Sir's insights. It's great that you also catch up with the newsletter updates-it’s always nice when the content resonates across platforms. Stay tuned for more in-depth discussions!
Indias growth vanished. I run a small fast food shop. The sales topped in july 2023 (say 100 units). Then the sales is halved during jan 2024 (say 55 units) and it is still at the same level.
Investors know this government is corrupt to the core and has insatiable appetite for money. They won't mind, but in fact welcome, some degree of Corruption, but too much and most investors won't take risk.
Thank you, sir, for your analysis and the sum-up at the end. I wish to make 2 comments: 1. The tag-line of this presentation does not match exactly with the "end-line", the closing lines, I mean. The former sounds up-beat about the economy, the latter (is more balanced and closer to truth) is not so up-beat. 2. You seemed to gloss over the fact that more than 80 crore citizens (more than 55% of the population) is living on doles. A large percentage of the potential working population (youth and children) are NOT BEING SKILLED, EDUCATED, HEALTH-CARED AND INCENTIVIZED ENOUGH, so that they can enter the economy and drive it. How, and from where, do you expect a sustainable growth to come from?
Would you clear my small doubt? Broad money in the economy as a share of monetarily measured nominal annual GDP was about 0.5 times in 1960. It has seen a secular and steady increase over the years. It is more than 1.42 times the monetarily measured nominal annual GDP today. (For India, the figures are 0.22 and 0.82 respectively.) Let me translate it for non-economists. My blood pressure was 115/70 when I was born in 1960. My blood pressure has steadily increased over the years and now it reads 325/200. What would that mean? Anyone interested in economics can answer this question. Kindly do not come back with a "the economy has grown" answer, that would be stupid, and I am being nice here! We are talking in relatives not absolutes here. Just like a higher BP would have altered my body's structure and makeup and turned it into a powder keg, waiting to blow -up. Why have I yet to receive an answer to this question? What are the central banks doing? What is the economic academia doing? Unfortunately, our mainstream macroeconomics is as much of a Voodoo as Modern Monetary Theory.
Hello! I got a glimpse of the question. Yes steady increase happened due to two major instances at least in BJP era firstly post demonetisation excess printing of money post that Covid time economic measures like liquidity adjustment, reverse repo which got new name in money market, piling up the reserves dollar and gold with an anticipation of potential crisis. GOI excessive capital expenditure! Your follow up question what is Central bank doing ? trying its best to play to the tunes of……. If u know you know and celebrating the success of UPI. Raised many red flags related to bank deposits deterioration alerted govt. Saving are going to investment route like mutual funds, F&O public is not spending instead investing. If u pull the aggregate demand formula. C, I, G, X-M. At least 2 engines fired at a time in some years 3 engines. Some months on that time all 4 engines (festive spending, World Cup in India, election spending, marriage expenditure). Plz connect the dots. I haven’t brought the FDI/FII angle.
@@luttaprasanth3806 My question has nothing to do with the BJP or Congress. It deals with the macroeconomic policies of almost all central banks. I compared data from 1960 to the present. The data I am presenting is primarily for the world, not just India. It is a macroeconomic query, questioning our theoretical macroeconomics.
Suggestion - when you shared net IT exports, please share the total exports from India too, share the absolute numbers of other sectors and more importantly the percentage; reason - else it gives an impression of picking up a piece of data to present a biased opinion - the game that is being played by almost everyone nowadays - does not apply to you though.
India is people and business community have capatilist... high expectations and government running crony - corruption capitals and social free- bee policy plus all laws do one thing that is -- price control policy...so .... even big business can't make profit...!!!
Thanks for sketching the true picture. What is your view on the free 'Revdis' being dished out by govt as well as all the political parties,right from free electricity ,loan waiver etc to farmers,free food for poor and so on,which is non productive and so wasteful ?
Don't know what Mr Basu will say but I feel as indian society belongs to every Indians irrespective of SE status basic health care which includes food, water, basic medical care, education etc are basic rights and not doles. These are critical input for a productive economy.
In the past 10 years economy has stagnated but black economy has become white, hence the GDP growth. that is why tax revenue is going up but people are not getting richer.
Proceeds of growth not shared with the misses
Do you share your increments with others?
Debt funding for consumption and inability to pay back , will take us down.
This in addition to the freebie culture and loan write off , by politicians to come to power.
We need more of such unbiased and neutral coverage about the state of affairs, which is hard to find today. Please keep posting.
"Thank you so much for the appreciation of our work. It is true that more people should benefit from the frank discussions in these videos but we live in a world of paid influencers who have resources for promotions , so independent voices get drowned out. May we request you to help spread the word by sharing these videoblogs and subscribing? thank you”
Rare sane sound about the reality of Indian economy
Debasish da and Sucheta madam are par excellence. Anything they upload is worth listening to.
Appreciate your kind words. Hope you would help in spreading the word about our channel and encourage others to subscribe as well!
Another great video sir 👏. Your insights are very helpful which provide an unbiased view of the economic landscape with historical references also which is very helpful for the young ones genz etc.
It is well said: in the long run, India disappoints both the optimist and the pessimist.
Thank you so much for your kind words and thoughtful feedback! We are glad you found the insights valuable and unbiased, especially for the younger generation navigating today’s economic landscape. We'll keep bringing more such content to deepen understanding and inspire informed perspectives. Stay tuned!
Please cover 1] Unsecured Lending - percentage numbers & absolute numbers 2] Entrepreneurship - India's big big hope. Thank you,
India need govt + babu free system s and machinery on top . To run country..😢!!!
Almost nobody seems to see these realities staring at us presented so clearly by Debasish! Our macro economic numbers reflecting performance of the top 15% of our population seem to dazzle the echo chamber and keep the government machinery active in matters affecting the same 15% almost exclusively. MSME & Agriculture sectors, instead of playing a bigger role, are in a state of distress instead. Is someone in power listening to us at all??
Good in depth assessment without biases.
Glad you liked it . please subscribe to the channel
Always wait anxiously for Debashish sir's golden insights. This time, though, had already read the news article in their newsletter summarizing the same 😎
Thank you for your thoughtful comment! We're glad to hear you're enjoying Debashis Sir's insights. It's great that you also catch up with the newsletter updates-it’s always nice when the content resonates across platforms. Stay tuned for more in-depth discussions!
Great analysis.
Thank You .I'm glad you found the information helpful. Please subscribe to our channel for more such content.
Thank you for covering the underlying current brewing in the economy.
You're welcome! I'm glad you found the information helpful. Please subscribe to our channel for more such content.
Back to basics needed
How do you put more money into people's pockets? Education, Medicine, Food for all are required to have a democratic dividend that is productive.
correct presentation! nice!
Glad you found the video to be useful. Please subscribe to our channel for more such content.
I have burnt my fingers in investing in equity and mutual funds as well as in fixed deposits...It is hood winking investors by corporates 😅😅😅
Cool info & analysis❤
Glad to hear you liked it! Please subscribe to our channel for more such content.
Indias growth vanished. I run a small fast food shop. The sales topped in july 2023 (say 100 units). Then the sales is halved during jan 2024 (say 55 units) and it is still at the same level.
Recession is coming. Escape while you can.
Food inflation is at its max
@@Iamreal11xingping Not much but at upcoming it's will be worst
Investors know this government is corrupt to the core and has insatiable appetite for money. They won't mind, but in fact welcome, some degree of Corruption, but too much and most investors won't take risk.
Thank you, sir, for your analysis and the sum-up at the end.
I wish to make 2 comments:
1. The tag-line of this presentation does not match exactly with the "end-line", the closing lines, I mean. The former sounds up-beat about the economy, the latter (is more balanced and closer to truth) is not so up-beat.
2. You seemed to gloss over the fact that more than 80 crore citizens (more than 55% of the population) is living on doles. A large percentage of the potential working population (youth and children) are NOT BEING SKILLED, EDUCATED, HEALTH-CARED AND INCENTIVIZED ENOUGH, so that they can enter the economy and drive it. How, and from where, do you expect a sustainable growth to come from?
You're welcome!
Would you clear my small doubt? Broad money in the economy as a share of monetarily measured nominal annual GDP was about 0.5 times in 1960. It has seen a secular and steady increase over the years. It is more than 1.42 times the monetarily measured nominal annual GDP today. (For India, the figures are 0.22 and 0.82 respectively.)
Let me translate it for non-economists. My blood pressure was 115/70 when I was born in 1960. My blood pressure has steadily increased over the years and now it reads 325/200. What would that mean? Anyone interested in economics can answer this question. Kindly do not come back with a "the economy has grown" answer, that would be stupid, and I am being nice here! We are talking in relatives not absolutes here. Just like a higher BP would have altered my body's structure and makeup and turned it into a powder keg, waiting to blow -up. Why have I yet to receive an answer to this question? What are the central banks doing? What is the economic academia doing? Unfortunately, our mainstream macroeconomics is as much of a Voodoo as Modern Monetary Theory.
Hello! I got a glimpse of the question. Yes steady increase happened due to two major instances at least in BJP era firstly post demonetisation excess printing of money post that Covid time economic measures like liquidity adjustment, reverse repo which got new name in money market, piling up the reserves dollar and gold with an anticipation of potential crisis. GOI excessive capital expenditure!
Your follow up question what is Central bank doing ? trying its best to play to the tunes of……. If u know you know and celebrating the success of UPI. Raised many red flags related to bank deposits deterioration alerted govt. Saving are going to investment route like mutual funds, F&O public is not spending instead investing.
If u pull the aggregate demand formula. C, I, G, X-M. At least 2 engines fired at a time in some years 3 engines. Some months on that time all 4 engines (festive spending, World Cup in India, election spending, marriage expenditure).
Plz connect the dots. I haven’t brought the FDI/FII angle.
@@luttaprasanth3806 My question has nothing to do with the BJP or Congress. It deals with the macroeconomic policies of almost all central banks. I compared data from 1960 to the present. The data I am presenting is primarily for the world, not just India.
It is a macroeconomic query, questioning our theoretical macroeconomics.
Suggestion - when you shared net IT exports, please share the total exports from India too, share the absolute numbers of other sectors and more importantly the percentage; reason - else it gives an impression of picking up a piece of data to present a biased opinion - the game that is being played by almost everyone nowadays - does not apply to you though.
Sir, excellent starting. I'm in agreement with you. Educate poor investors under stated the reality and facts of micro.
Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed the topic.
Well presented, Realistic View of the Indian Economy, I am not an economist but what you said makes sense and seems like the True picture 👌🙏
Glad you found the video to be useful. Please subscribe to our channel for more such content.
India is people and business community have capatilist... high expectations and government running crony - corruption capitals and social free- bee policy plus all laws do one thing that is -- price control policy...so
.... even big business can't make profit...!!!
Thanks for sketching the true picture.
What is your view on the free 'Revdis' being dished out by govt as well as all the political parties,right from free electricity ,loan waiver etc to farmers,free food for poor and so on,which is non productive and so wasteful ?
Don't know what Mr Basu will say but I feel as indian society belongs to every Indians irrespective of SE status basic health care which includes food, water, basic medical care, education etc are basic rights and not doles. These are critical input for a productive economy.
Questionable FM tone in US!
Why 2% succeed and 98 % unable to in India?
What pendulum of growth? The surge on the back of pandemic recession? It has always been tepid growth since 2014.
Again judging on hindsight as everyone does, normal and no differentiated views.
In the past 10 years economy has stagnated but black economy has become white, hence the GDP growth. that is why tax revenue is going up but people are not getting richer.
Yes actually mae growth toh normal hi hai itni population kae lie but formalization of economy has happened
Thank you Sir
You're welcome! Please subscribe to the channel for more content.
रुपये की हालत देखी?