It's selective data to fool low IQ people, Talked about manufacturing but not showing manufacturing percentage of GDP. Talked about PLFS data, but adjusted for inflation their is no increase in income of labor. Talking about LFPR, but not talking that most of the labor gain has gone in agriculture as farm labour. Typical lutians delhi sitting in AC room.
रामराम , अर्थशास्त्र आणि त्याचा सामाजिक प्रभाव या विषयी एवढं समग्र आणि सूक्ष्म विवेचन ते ही सुलभ पणे फारच क्वचित ऐकायला मिळते . डॉ शमिका यांना विनम्र प्रणाम . आयोजकांचे विशेष आभार .
Dr. Ravi is a perfect example of a cosmopolitan, globally aware economist and citizen. Still she knows and grasps the Indian reality like not many of her tribe do.
Dr.Shamika is one of the most sensible economists around Yes society must wake up to reality of ticking time bomb of societal problems adversely affecting the viability of the nation Pvt and public sector must allow for working mothers and non working mothers
wow, such an enlightening talk. Lot of take home points. We must start encouraging people to have three kids in South and states with less than 2.1 population growth. Even if we start asking for more kids ,it wont happen in next couple of decades. So to prevent adverse dependency ratio we need to start working now ,although it may look bizzare idea as we have been drilled about 'over population' since our school days. Must change lessons in our text books about excessive population.
The most AMAZING PODCAST ...a big THANKYOU TO DR RAVI ......SO IMPRESSIVE ..BRILLIANT ..a very big WOW ...thsnk you Sangam talks for this guest ....please arrange more talks with dr.Ravi
Exceptional economic analysis by the brightest star performance. May your capabilities be replicated for the future generations.Any more adjectives about your delivery of thoughts will be short of thoughts. Congratulations,🙏💐
1:13:59 Solution is joint family which our tradition practised (to solve space problem which occur when too many nuclear families occur) with couples producing 3 progenies.
Bottom 25% has to be the target group But giving an all India figure sometimes are not very encouraging. Also giving the improvement in the top 25% or upper 50% would help us compare how fast we are catching up with China and the developed world
The section on population growth is vv critical.... fertility is dropping rapidly all across the world and now also in India. We have to devise ways as a society to tackle this problem....I believe tradition and our roots may be part of the solution to emphasize the need to give birth to the next gen. It needs to be stressed among our deracinated youth(which includes me as well) which has a faulty notion of 'high population of India' and thereby do not feel the need to have children or just have one child.
It’s ok to be a mother and make care economics viable You have hit the nail on the head - European and US metrics are not viable for traditional societies like ours
If you need a diversified economy, they you need a big country, or at least some kind or federalism. All this is a result is uncertainty in the geopolitics and geoeconomics..
Impressive presentation and heart warming. However, in spite of wide spread indications that we are moving in the right direction, doubts remain because their several indicators in opposite direction as well. This is because it’s widely believed that the data is fudged; an example is the inflation rate, government data show one number but households/I experience an entirely different number in the streets. NSSO may be doing a great job but people don’t believe its data. Put it out of government may be they will. 7+% gdp growth government and RBI say, but consumption and corporate profits over past several months don’t reflect it. You are influential enough with this government to create an independent data collection and analysis agency that is managed by a group of independent individuals including capable academics like yourself. I have hope on future of India and people like you and the Prime Minister. Another point on the video presentation, camera is focused on the speaker most of the time, which is fine for the audience in the room but not people watching the video on UA-cam who have hardly any time to absorb the graphical or other data presented on the screen. May I recommend that the camera is on screen most of the time and lesser on the face of the speaker. For your consideration for future presentations.
We can't compare Bharat with any other nations. Bharat woman has more gold than govt . So unless we have own formula for economics we always get same shortcomings.. House works aren't included in service in Bharat because it's not paid. Most importantly Bharat culture always preferred shri Ram in jungle than Ravan living in golden palace.. Thousand years of invasion and colonial era wasn't for making Bharat wealthy and prosperity for Bharat... All for looting only . It continued even after independence as corruption and adulteration... So unless we endorse Bharat as Hindu nation officially we can't expect nationalism and prosperity for Bharat no one cleans others houses..
I wish Madam traveled in the metropolitan cities of our country and see for herself the number of homeless people and people begging. Thats the reality ! Comparison with China will be apple to apple, since we were almost similarly economically a few decades back and, population wise we are similar. Some data presented seem to be utopian, eg the % of income spent on food going down? Check the food inflation vis a vis growth in income. Gold plating stats or not showing critical stats doesn’t solve any problem. Otherwise insightful presentation. Thanks
Madam, sorry for pointing out this, India map is not correct in the maps you are using, though those maps might be from different sources, I wish you should not have used it but got it created.
exactly The cameraman is a m0r0n. 🤦♀i had given this feedback to them on some earlier video also where the cameraman was focusing on the speaker while the speaker was focusing on the slides they were presenting. All the valuable information was lost as a result. Must be the same cameraman. At least he/she showed some slides in this one. 🤦♀dont now why they keep focusing on the speaker more than the slides. 🤦♀
But i don't think so we are self reliable until now. We import the trillion dollars of goods and services from the other countries. and our Prime minister compare our country to the German and Japan. Have you ever seen the Infrastructure of the German and Japan. Now india beats the German in GDP. Have you ever checked the Population rate of German and Area of population. Now german is no. 3 in exporting countries and its imports the fixed goods( nuts,bolts,steels and bolt). They have already stablized the Solar panels( in 2008). Why do compare our country to the weak countries.
Bro, look at where we were 30 years back and where we are now. If there is continuous improvement then we are good else we have to work to reach that stage. I don't think EU per capita should be our goal? Their PPP is much lower. Also we are a very complex society. We often do not agree on anything hence making fast progress is very difficult. Slow and steady should be our mantra
Hounarable sbi bank may total many rajboharo ki silver coins gold coins mani thi histori of bank emperial bank transfer to SBI bank central bank in rajvada bank account hounarable indian currency are powerful in the world in silver coins and gold coins are valuable dolar and uro dolar are nothing in Indian heritage curency hounarable bharatiya heritage currency are World powerful currency in the world nivadak bp pareek
Do you have any idea how many unemployment rate in our country. The Rate will be increased. And on the other hand our PM or the BJP Government are Promoting the AI(Artificial intelligence). Even today i saw the Chief justice of India he was also promoting the AI. But he forgot about the Population size of our nation. Have you ever thought about the US population. Even 20% people's don't have a US citizenship. Have you ever heard the Indian AI company. I don't think so. They are just adopting the foreign AI tools. But they forget about the Upcoming generation or young generation. Nvidia has already sold the AI based Tools or cheaps to Mercedes or BMW. Now they want to sell in the Indian market. Because nvidia CEO know india is very biggest Market.
I'm sure they have idea, I mean it takes one Google search. AI is going to impact jobs globally not just India, but it's not a doomsday scenario, and any country that doesn't adapt will get behind.
First AI doesn't take jobs, the person using it will be. India the back office for USA and other developed countries. If they started using AI we r f*ked. So using it ourselves to create than just be a back office guy. Creativity always belongs to humans AI can enhance it but can't steal it .
@@VijayRS-nj2kc first of all AI is not going to take away jobs, the person who uses it will. And India is currently back office for developed countries, if they started using AI then we r fked. By using AI before them give us a head start in the race. AI can never over take creativity it can just enhance it. U r just anti govt. Want to spread nonsense by wt ever means.
@@VijayRS-nj2kc first of all AI is not going to take away jobs, the person who uses it will. And India is currently back office for developed countries, if they started using AI then we r fked. By using AI before them give us a head start in the race. AI can never over take creativity it can just enhance it .
Bro, the figure of 80 cr comes from National food security bill of 2013. It does not mean that 80 cr people are poor. Again this move is a master stroke as a lot of food grain are wasted due to storage issues. Better some one consume it than wasting it
Modi's institutions are packed with Economists, Historians, Media Persons, Academicians, serving and former bureaucrats, and others , who are notable for a unique but shared capacity for cherry-picking. In language of neuro-science, their brains are lacking in the right hemisphere which enables forming the overall picture, and the left hemispheres of their brains which in this context we may say enables cherry-picking, is badly mis-shapen.
Have you ever thought about the Un-equality rate is rising day by day. How do you say our country growth rate is increasing. I don't think so our country growth rate is increasing. When you compare our country to the south Korea, japan, China and Singapore. Then you will get the answer. NDA Government is providing the business to the few people's of our nation. Have you have checked the hunger rate in our nation. Even they didn't get the sufficient malnutrition for the growth of the children. Have you ever thought about the medical facilities. I don't think so you know about the rural condition of our nation. You know what we have a lots of population but resources are very less. Have you ever thought about why Rajiv Gandhi wanted to Birth control. Because he knew after 2 decades it is very difficult for the nation.and on the other hand our PM said we are providing the free ration to the general public or we are providing the Solar panel. Let me tell you one think. If we don't have a sufficient or basic things. I don't think so our country will develop. Yes I'm totally agree with you our nation growth rate is increasing but it is good for the 1% of population or rich peoples of our nation. I have a lots of things to explain you but i don't think so you have answer.
Bro we have enough resources first of all, but we r mismanaging it. And secondly in the last decade we were able to bring more than 600 million people out of poverty. Today almost every person is connected to the banking system and they were able to get benefits from the government. And about health care, do u know about ayushman card? It provides 5L per person free health care for poor. Yes we r lacking behind but look at where we have come from. India's digital revolution is a masterpiece. U r talking about our government being capitalistic and inequality but we just came out of a socialistic government where everyone r equally poor. Today we r one of the highest start up countries with 108 unicorns.
Country growth rate is increasing - look at country GDP how it has grown from 2014 to 2024, even in $$ terms. Mind you in Rs it will be much higher. India is 5th in GDP , that's hard numbers...in $$s. Just one example...to substantiate see how the tax revenues have grown and hit 23 lakh crores ~ In addition 30 crore bank accounts were added leading to financial inclusion. They have added 70,000 crores India's defence exports have grown 37 times compared to 2013. 50 % exports to USA India's cell phone assembling thanks govt policies is another example of Grand success & employment through Make in India
Dr Shamika Ravi's statistical explanation needs more exposure through the local media in India. Another brilliant economic mind. Thank you Ma-ji.
It's selective data to fool low IQ people,
Talked about manufacturing but not showing manufacturing percentage of GDP.
Talked about PLFS data, but adjusted for inflation their is no increase in income of labor.
Talking about LFPR, but not talking that most of the labor gain has gone in agriculture as farm labour.
Typical lutians delhi sitting in AC room.
रामराम ,
अर्थशास्त्र आणि त्याचा सामाजिक प्रभाव या विषयी एवढं समग्र आणि सूक्ष्म विवेचन ते ही सुलभ पणे फारच क्वचित ऐकायला मिळते .
डॉ शमिका यांना विनम्र प्रणाम .
आयोजकांचे विशेष आभार .
Dr. Ravi is a perfect example of a cosmopolitan, globally aware economist and citizen. Still she knows and grasps the Indian reality like not many of her tribe do.
Thank you DR SHAMIKA RAVI & SANGAM talks for this TALK 👍❤️
Dr.Shamika is one of the most sensible economists around
Yes society must wake up to reality of ticking time bomb of societal problems adversely affecting the viability of the nation
Pvt and public sector must allow for working mothers and non working mothers
Excellent lecture by Shamika Ravi ji. Good to see data driven talk.
An excellent talk. Very interesting and informative. Congratulations Sangam and Dr. Sahab. Jai Bharat.
Superb articulation by madam. Impressed by the quality of people we are having in govt economic council.
very impressive madam.U should do such lectures in all colleges,unis and social platforms.
wow, such an enlightening talk. Lot of take home points. We must start encouraging people to have three kids in South and states with less than 2.1 population growth. Even if we start asking for more kids ,it wont happen in next couple of decades. So to prevent adverse dependency ratio we need to start working now ,although it may look bizzare idea as we have been drilled about 'over population' since our school days. Must change lessons in our text books about excessive population.
Great talk. What a fantastic person to have in the government !
An excellent talk, v thought provoking n the final point on putting a value on care was an absolute shocker...thank you so much.
Absolutely Brilliant Lecture. Thanks a ton to Shamika ji
The most AMAZING PODCAST ...a big THANKYOU TO DR RAVI ......SO IMPRESSIVE ..BRILLIANT ..a very big WOW ...thsnk you Sangam talks for this guest ....please arrange more talks with dr.Ravi
Absolutely 💯 right
Very scientific and extremely well narrated. Thanks a lot.
Such a delight to hear from learned people...
Exceptional economic analysis by the brightest star performance. May your capabilities be replicated for the future generations.Any more adjectives about your delivery of thoughts will be short of thoughts. Congratulations,🙏💐
We understood well how Indian socio economic transformation has been taken place while rest of world going in different phase.
1:13:59 Solution is joint family which our tradition practised (to solve space problem which occur when too many nuclear families occur) with couples producing 3 progenies.
The stats on narrative building is a cracker. On dot. Hits the bulls eye.
“Narrative Economics” - New semantics.
Problems are well analysed . Hope PMO will apply at ground level.
Bottom 25% has to be the target group But giving an all India figure sometimes are not very encouraging. Also giving the improvement in the top 25% or upper 50% would help us compare how fast we are catching up with China and the developed world
Really an enlightening talk .
Brilliant insightful presentation
Excellent presentation ma’am
The section on population growth is vv critical.... fertility is dropping rapidly all across the world and now also in India.
We have to devise ways as a society to tackle this problem....I believe tradition and our roots may be part of the solution to emphasize the need to give birth to the next gen.
It needs to be stressed among our deracinated youth(which includes me as well) which has a faulty notion of 'high population of India' and thereby do not feel the need to have children or just have one child.
Also, as usual in India this 'problem' only affects the dhimmi Hindu community by and large....
Insightful
Excellent sangam talks
Very good talk
Brilliant presentation. It explains a lot based on actual datas. There are visible progressive changes in the country.
27:39: What did you cut here?
It’s ok to be a mother and make care economics viable
You have hit the nail on the head - European and US metrics are not viable for traditional societies like ours
If you need a diversified economy, they you need a big country, or at least some kind or federalism. All this is a result is uncertainty in the geopolitics and geoeconomics..
Impressive presentation and heart warming. However, in spite of wide spread indications that we are moving in the right direction, doubts remain because their several indicators in opposite direction as well. This is because it’s widely believed that the data is fudged; an example is the inflation rate, government data show one number but households/I experience an entirely different number in the streets. NSSO may be doing a great job but people don’t believe its data. Put it out of government may be they will. 7+% gdp growth government and RBI say, but consumption and corporate profits over past several months don’t reflect it. You are influential enough with this government to create an independent data collection and analysis agency that is managed by a group of independent individuals including capable academics like yourself. I have hope on future of India and people like you and the Prime Minister. Another point on the video presentation, camera is focused on the speaker most of the time, which is fine for the audience in the room but not people watching the video on UA-cam who have hardly any time to absorb the graphical or other data presented on the screen. May I recommend that the camera is on screen most of the time and lesser on the face of the speaker. For your consideration for future presentations.
Where can i download the ppt slides, prof Dr Ravi has presented?
Our women don't want to produce children😢Sooo much true😪.
It is Most threatening thing for india as a community and also as labour😢
We can't compare Bharat with any other nations. Bharat woman has more gold than govt . So unless we have own formula for economics we always get same shortcomings.. House works aren't included in service in Bharat because it's not paid. Most importantly Bharat culture always preferred shri Ram in jungle than Ravan living in golden palace.. Thousand years of invasion and colonial era wasn't for making Bharat wealthy and prosperity for Bharat... All for looting only . It continued even after independence as corruption and adulteration... So unless we endorse Bharat as Hindu nation officially we can't expect nationalism and prosperity for Bharat no one cleans others houses..
MMR is number of deaths per 100,000 births, not 1000 as stated by the speaker.at 10:08
100
I wish Madam traveled in the metropolitan cities of our country and see for herself the number of homeless people and people begging. Thats the reality !
Comparison with China will be apple to apple, since we were almost similarly economically a few decades back and, population wise we are similar.
Some data presented seem to be utopian, eg the % of income spent on food going down? Check the food inflation vis a vis growth in income.
Gold plating stats or not showing critical stats doesn’t solve any problem.
Otherwise insightful presentation.
Thanks
Madam, sorry for pointing out this, India map is not correct in the maps you are using, though those maps might be from different sources, I wish you should not have used it but got it created.
Omg show the slides for longer ffs!
exactly The cameraman is a m0r0n. 🤦♀i had given this feedback to them on some earlier video also where the cameraman was focusing on the speaker while the speaker was focusing on the slides they were presenting. All the valuable information was lost as a result. Must be the same cameraman. At least he/she showed some slides in this one. 🤦♀dont now why they keep focusing on the speaker more than the slides. 🤦♀
India map was wrong, so please before presenting check it once.
But i don't think so we are self reliable until now. We import the trillion dollars of goods and services from the other countries. and our Prime minister compare our country to the German and Japan. Have you ever seen the Infrastructure of the German and Japan. Now india beats the German in GDP. Have you ever checked the Population rate of German and Area of population. Now german is no. 3 in exporting countries and its imports the fixed goods( nuts,bolts,steels and bolt). They have already stablized the Solar panels( in 2008). Why do compare our country to the weak countries.
Womp womp 😂
Bro, look at where we were 30 years back and where we are now. If there is continuous improvement then we are good else we have to work to reach that stage. I don't think EU per capita should be our goal? Their PPP is much lower. Also we are a very complex society. We often do not agree on anything hence making fast progress is very difficult. Slow and steady should be our mantra
crude oil stop krde na india le lode lag jayenge. it means indian economy is unsustainable.
Hounarable sbi bank may total many rajboharo ki silver coins gold coins mani thi histori of bank emperial bank transfer to SBI bank central bank in rajvada bank account hounarable indian currency are powerful in the world in silver coins and gold coins are valuable dolar and uro dolar are nothing in Indian heritage curency hounarable bharatiya heritage currency are World powerful currency in the world nivadak bp pareek
Do you have any idea how many unemployment rate in our country. The Rate will be increased. And on the other hand our PM or the BJP Government are Promoting the AI(Artificial intelligence). Even today i saw the Chief justice of India he was also promoting the AI. But he forgot about the Population size of our nation. Have you ever thought about the US population. Even 20% people's don't have a US citizenship. Have you ever heard the Indian AI company. I don't think so. They are just adopting the foreign AI tools. But they forget about the Upcoming generation or young generation. Nvidia has already sold the AI based Tools or cheaps to Mercedes or BMW. Now they want to sell in the Indian market. Because nvidia CEO know india is very biggest Market.
I'm sure they have idea, I mean it takes one Google search. AI is going to impact jobs globally not just India, but it's not a doomsday scenario, and any country that doesn't adapt will get behind.
First AI doesn't take jobs, the person using it will be. India the back office for USA and other developed countries. If they started using AI we r f*ked. So using it ourselves to create than just be a back office guy. Creativity always belongs to humans AI can enhance it but can't steal it .
The problem can be attributed to missing the manufacturing bus due to socialist policies of govt pre 1991. It will pick up but needs time
@@VijayRS-nj2kc first of all AI is not going to take away jobs, the person who uses it will. And India is currently back office for developed countries, if they started using AI then we r fked. By using AI before them give us a head start in the race. AI can never over take creativity it can just enhance it. U r just anti govt. Want to spread nonsense by wt ever means.
@@VijayRS-nj2kc first of all AI is not going to take away jobs, the person who uses it will. And India is currently back office for developed countries, if they started using AI then we r fked. By using AI before them give us a head start in the race. AI can never over take creativity it can just enhance it .
India was indepent on 15 august 1947 since India has No beter Economic devolomsnt Policy
Did she talk about 80cr bhikari being fed on the shoulders of salaried middle class?
Bro, the figure of 80 cr comes from National food security bill of 2013. It does not mean that 80 cr people are poor. Again this move is a master stroke as a lot of food grain are wasted due to storage issues. Better some one consume it than wasting it
It's better than haj subsidy.
I support my fellow citizens who were overlooked by khangress.
India has more problem no empoyment no beter law for protection women Economic devolomsnt Policy very bad
NONSENSE..LADY iNDIA IS SUFFERING FROM JOBS CRISIS, GO SOLVE IT
Modi's institutions are packed with Economists, Historians, Media Persons, Academicians, serving and former bureaucrats, and others , who are notable for a unique but shared capacity for cherry-picking. In language of neuro-science, their brains are lacking in the right hemisphere which enables forming the overall picture, and the left hemispheres of their brains which in this context we may say enables cherry-picking, is badly mis-shapen.
And your brain is stuck in that place where the sun doesn’t shine 😂
What use of crony policies, when the per capita GDP of India is lower than that of a few African countries ?
Hollow words of no value.
There's a difference in percapita gdp and gdp ppp😂😂
You look at the data for decades and you will realise the difference. Plus on PPP , India stands third after China and USA.
@@vish2553 India is ranked 122nd on GDP(PPP) and 141st on GDP(nominal)
@@vish2553 PPP does not reflect reality due to differences in local costs, taxes, tariffs, and competition.
@@AnonymousAntony-o8qkeep your politics out of an economic video. We're trying to learn something.
Stick to politics on those videos
Stupid UA-cam update
Have you ever thought about the Un-equality rate is rising day by day. How do you say our country growth rate is increasing. I don't think so our country growth rate is increasing. When you compare our country to the south Korea, japan, China and Singapore. Then you will get the answer. NDA Government is providing the business to the few people's of our nation. Have you have checked the hunger rate in our nation. Even they didn't get the sufficient malnutrition for the growth of the children. Have you ever thought about the medical facilities. I don't think so you know about the rural condition of our nation. You know what we have a lots of population but resources are very less. Have you ever thought about why Rajiv Gandhi wanted to Birth control. Because he knew after 2 decades it is very difficult for the nation.and on the other hand our PM said we are providing the free ration to the general public or we are providing the Solar panel. Let me tell you one think. If we don't have a sufficient or basic things. I don't think so our country will develop. Yes I'm totally agree with you our nation growth rate is increasing but it is good for the 1% of population or rich peoples of our nation. I have a lots of things to explain you but i don't think so you have answer.
COPE harder
As if the congres did a fantastic job in developing the country the problem the country is facing is because of congress pathetic self glorified rule.
Bro we have enough resources first of all, but we r mismanaging it. And secondly in the last decade we were able to bring more than 600 million people out of poverty. Today almost every person is connected to the banking system and they were able to get benefits from the government. And about health care, do u know about ayushman card? It provides 5L per person free health care for poor. Yes we r lacking behind but look at where we have come from. India's digital revolution is a masterpiece. U r talking about our government being capitalistic and inequality but we just came out of a socialistic government where everyone r equally poor. Today we r one of the highest start up countries with 108 unicorns.
Country growth rate is increasing - look at country GDP how it has grown from 2014 to 2024, even in $$ terms. Mind you in Rs it will be much higher. India is 5th in GDP , that's hard numbers...in $$s.
Just one example...to substantiate see how the tax revenues have grown and hit 23 lakh crores ~
In addition 30 crore bank accounts were added leading to financial inclusion. They have added 70,000 crores
India's defence exports have grown 37 times compared to 2013. 50 % exports to USA
India's cell phone assembling thanks govt policies is another example of Grand success & employment through Make in India
@@mashnasa1 😂😂
Most negative information about India..most positive to china..the source unknown...the source from china..or..america..to create jealousy..weapon🤣🤣🤣
Oh this is the lady that Anand Ranganathan COMPLETELY DECIMATED in a debate!
What are you saying??? They both talked on similar lines in that panel. Both of their ideologies align.. So, no difference there!
This lady used wrong map of india and showed kashmir in pakistan
This woman an urban naxalite
I reported this channel