IPRI Podcast | Reflections on the Indus Waters Treaty

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 49

  • @SurajKumar-vb1yu
    @SurajKumar-vb1yu Рік тому +9

    we will divert the flow of indus water ..😌

  • @illam8147
    @illam8147 Рік тому +1

    Very intellectual man....we respect your views sir even being from India .

  • @nayyerasaba8006
    @nayyerasaba8006 Рік тому +1

    All the points are well explained by this intellectual man.

  • @Arunh9-pw7lp
    @Arunh9-pw7lp 3 місяці тому

    Such a professional man👍🏼. Lekin dar ka mahaul to h😂. Iwt will be scrapped. Rote rho!

  • @vickey3992
    @vickey3992 Рік тому +13

    As an Indian we don't want modifications we want Abrogation and History tells us that many countries have violated many treaties , there have been many instances when a treaty was abolished around world
    It's our water 💦 we will fight to take it and we will correct the mistakes made by Nehru

    • @ayazhaider8136
      @ayazhaider8136 Рік тому +1

      Tm logo ki itni aukat hy k abrogation kr sku?

    • @vickey3992
      @vickey3992 Рік тому

      @@ayazhaider8136 jab 370 Kashmir se Abrogate kar diye toh ye kya abhi hum dams bana rahe hai 4-5 saal aur lagenge phir dekhna kitni aukaat hai humari Bhikhari Pakiyo

    • @kaalpaheliya
      @kaalpaheliya Рік тому +5

      @@ayazhaider8136 Aata aur Chini kharidne ki to aoukat nahi hai aur chale hai aukat ki baat karne

    • @ayazhaider8136
      @ayazhaider8136 Рік тому

      @@kaalpaheliya bhae bhokay reh laun gay mgr tm jaisu ku ni chorain gay.

    • @munish259272
      @munish259272 11 місяців тому +2

      @@ayazhaider8136 Well did you took permission to attack india 4 times
      india was giving 80% of water to pakistan that was unfair already and then we asked to talk becuase this is very unfair for you to take 80% of the water and you said no.
      Now no treaty

  • @pkgp7056
    @pkgp7056 Рік тому +11

    IWT should be abrogated, Blood and Water can not flow together.

    • @MrAzambhabib
      @MrAzambhabib 4 місяці тому

      Of course but remember that this would mean war and this war would result in mutually assured destruction of both countries who would be crippled for atleast a century. If you want to do it then proceed by all means.

    • @narendragupta7076
      @narendragupta7076 4 місяці тому

      ​@@MrAzambhabibyes....we want to proceed

    • @MrAzambhabib
      @MrAzambhabib 4 місяці тому

      @@narendragupta7076 To proceed on not to proceed is the perogative of your and mine government and not us. Should this happen both India an Pakistan will be crippled for atleast a century and all dreams of progress and prosperity for millions will be destroyed.

    • @narendragupta7076
      @narendragupta7076 4 місяці тому

      While u seem to be theoretically correct but if u have cancer like pakistan u would like to remove it asap. Prerogative are being set as per the mindset and desires of the people of their state....in ur country it is also equally applicable that is why ur state is sponsering terrorism in my country. Today every pakistani citizen is so much radicalized and hindu-hater that it has gone beyond imagination. Now, when something like IWT hurts, everybody in pak becomes secular, liberal and most loving peacemaker as well as development oriented. This character has been identified by new generation in India. We are not going to buy any such type of arguments. We are continously bleeded out due to terrorism from ur pakistan so we find it correct to go for any such action whether conflict/ war etc which hurts you more than us, probbably then it may realised by pak.

  • @shriramk7682
    @shriramk7682 10 місяців тому

    India got about 30% of the total water carried by the Indus system located in India while Pakistan got the remaining 70%. The treaty allows India to use the western river waters for limited irrigation use and unlimited non-consumptive use such as power generation, navigation, floating of property, fish culture, etc. I believe there is no violation of treaty by India

  • @psarathy66
    @psarathy66 Рік тому +2

    Interestingly i am not seeing any place where the actual dispute is being discussed. For example pak telling that the change will reduce my quota of water or india saying that we are loosing our quota of water

  • @SomnathDe-h7d
    @SomnathDe-h7d Рік тому +1

    Just reverse the position. Had India attacked in 1965, 1971, 1999 Pakistan, what Pakistani would have done with the water flow.
    Modi was right in saying water and blood can't flow from one place.

    • @YoutubeGuru-h1w
      @YoutubeGuru-h1w 27 днів тому

      If Pakistan the size of India. It would have kept Kashmir (assuming Hindu) and would have captured other vital points.

  • @kaalpaheliya
    @kaalpaheliya Рік тому +7

    Typical Pakistani, starts with english and after 2 sentence switch to Urdu 😂😂😂

    • @MAbdurehman-i8c
      @MAbdurehman-i8c Рік тому +1

      Urdu humary qomi zuban ha Aur English serkari hum dono per maharat rakh te hain because tum Jase idot qom b tu ha😅😅😅😅😅🙄😜

    • @kaalpaheliya
      @kaalpaheliya Рік тому +1

      @@MAbdurehman-i8c chukiye, Urdu is na Indian language, aur tumhari tarah hum nahi hai jo Arabo aur Turko ko apna baap bana le, 😂😂😂

    • @MAbdurehman-i8c
      @MAbdurehman-i8c Рік тому +1

      Jo komey apne forfather's ko buhl Kate hain aon ka mukadar sherif is zami se metna hi hota he😂😂😂😂The end of India book read please 😮😮😅😅

    • @kaalpaheliya
      @kaalpaheliya Рік тому

      @@MAbdurehman-i8c Hame pata hai hamare forefther kon hai, lekin tumlogo ko nahi pata ki tumhare forefather kon hai, jab Islamic invader bharat aaye to unlogo ne yaha ki aurato ko gulam banaya unka r@ape kiya aur uss r@pae se jo bachche paida huye wahi tere forefather hai, to asal may tumlog nasali taur par h@r@mi ho 😂😂😂

    • @amnanoor9714
      @amnanoor9714 Рік тому

      app ki goron ki gulami abhi tak thandi jo na ho pai....fake accent indians

  • @parveenshah6429
    @parveenshah6429 Рік тому +1

    Pakistan ne mushriki dariya de ke 😅😢😂
    Naa le ke bolo bhaijaan
    Mashraki dariya ta india vich flow ho ke hi Pakistan aaunde hn yani india de kol hi si
    Han western vi india ne hi dite han tuhanu ohi sambh lo
    Unha da paani vi samander vich saat dende ho
    Dam na baniyo
    Gustakh e ra..soool te gulam e ra..sool hi bani rakho loga nu
    Alha deta banda leta h lai rakho 😅😅

  • @chilarai4734
    @chilarai4734 4 місяці тому

    Arrey Yaar, forget IWT and focus on an omnibus international law that supercedes it. India intends to ABROGATE it and not indulge in Chai-pani BS. Enough.

  • @Arunh9-pw7lp
    @Arunh9-pw7lp 3 місяці тому

    Dar ka mahaul h😂

  • @SureshVaghela-x6u
    @SureshVaghela-x6u 4 місяці тому

    Upper Country ko 70persun Pani milta hey.

  • @suraj-gd9qy
    @suraj-gd9qy Рік тому +11

    The treaty was not with present-day Pakistan it was with older Pakistan which comprises Bangladesh. we have sympathy for Bengalis so we agreed on the treaty but after the separation of Pakistan the treaty can be considered null and void and still Indian govt is coordinating, It is a shame for the Indian govt to issue such notices to Pakistan, India should do whatever they like and should not go to any court where Pakistan is presenting its case. India still values Pakistan and wastes its money on fighting such allegations. Shame on govt of India for entertaining terrorist-sponsoring countries and let the beggars rattle wherever they can.

    • @irfanashraf7350
      @irfanashraf7350 Рік тому

      If Godi media had educated you how international treaties work,you would not have made this filthy comment.

    • @suraj-gd9qy
      @suraj-gd9qy Рік тому

      @@irfanashraf7350 dude you don't know anything about me then coming to a conclusion like such is a stupid idea, read before coming to any such conclusion.... And get a life before telling me my comment is filthy because I am not doing any personal attacks on you unlike you..
      And i really don't care about the media man....

    • @anonmyoushacker9334
      @anonmyoushacker9334 Рік тому

      ​@@irfanashraf7350India is getting literally nothing from you madarasa chap and on the other hand you are living on the water of india. I think pakistan should import urine of india and process it to drinking water 😂oh sorry i forget you guys don't even have proper meal to eat😂

    • @MAbdurehman-i8c
      @MAbdurehman-i8c Рік тому +1

      You don't say that you have sympathy for Banglias instead of this you separate it from us cunningly. 😏😏😏

    • @suraj-gd9qy
      @suraj-gd9qy Рік тому

      @@MAbdurehman-i8c so what, blame your founder who divided my nation... now those foundation has made it bankrupt... enjoy happily

  • @fazalkakar1130
    @fazalkakar1130 Рік тому

    Ipri, could you please change the host. Having issue in her talking style & pronunciation.,,, which negatively impacts the whole clip

  • @rajeevd972
    @rajeevd972 Рік тому

    Water and blood cannot flow together.
    U wanted thosand cuts. Expect it to be returned.

  • @SureshVaghela-x6u
    @SureshVaghela-x6u 4 місяці тому

    Pakistani ke under Pani kab ka bandh kar diya hota.

  • @SureshVaghela-x6u
    @SureshVaghela-x6u 3 місяці тому

    Pakistani upper side me ho ta to kab ka pani bandh kar deta.