Hello Gothik Serpent. I have been a record collector for almost 50 years now. I have almost everything by Porcupine Tree now. I want you all to know that I am hooked on the way you did "The Incident" Each of you is very talented. Believe it or not, I have watched this cover of "The Incident" 8 times. This is my 9th time. I have also been loving the special effects which are fantastic. I will start to collect Gothik Serpent albums soon. However, since I am a major collector I will only buy my favorite albums by my favorite artist by Gothik Serpent. In other words, I will be buying any and all Porcupine Tree stuff you all make and any groups I currently collect. I love KERWIN TSANG and his voice and the way he plays a lot. I am also impressed with Chapman Sticks' bass playing. I also really like Olivia Kong female vocals on The Incident. Without Olivia Kong things would be very different. I can tell over time she will become better and better with her excellent voice. Also, What a great job to Tau Bower. I must listen to "INTERLOPER" I think I will do that now. I deeply urge anybody who has a favorite group in your life not to overlook Gothik Serpent. This is my very first tribute band that I will soon start to collect.
Thanks so much Larry for your extremely flattering comment. I'm humbled that you've listened to my cover of The Incident that many times. I will also relay your praise to Olivia and Tau. Do subscribe to this YT channel if you haven't already, as I am constantly working on more music, including my next original album!
This is great. I agree that The Incident is underrated and is not a collection of half baked ideas. I would take Incident over Closure/Continuation any day.
Incredible! Probably close to the best UA-cam cover of any artist I've seen, especially for a whole album as challenging as this. Sound quality is great as well! You should be proud of yourselves.
I love how you personalized Time Flies. And some of the images were breath taking during the track. And then that bass solo, wow! You absolutely blew this well beyond expectations! This is so, so amazing!
No one can discribe this kind of Music, also I cannot discribe Tool.....but I love this kind auf Rock'n Roll. I is the heart of us all...!! Unbelievable.....Greez from good old Germany...
Bravo! Such a criminally underrated album. It's hard to stand up to Fear of a Blank Planet or Deadwing... but The Incident is absolutely amazing in its own right. I really like the flow of the album. It reminds me of the Abbey Road medleys with the cohesion. You folks really did it justice too!
I don’t usually leave comments but this was so incredible and well done I really just had to say so. The incident is my favorite porcupine tree album and this rendition of the main suite was remarkable!!! Incredible work
I love this album and the cover too. Having seen Steven’s latest interview still can’t believe he doesn’t rate it highly. To me it is really captivating
By far the best PT covers out there. It's very exciting to me to find other people who are so touched by his music the way I am. Really really great job on these songs. And I love the changes to the lyrics at the start of Time Flies. Made me smile
This was the album that got me into PT and might still be my favorite of theirs. This is amazing, it really feels to me like you did the record justice with every detail!
By far their most underrated album. Love the shared chord progression of the blind house and octane twisted-the seance. You executed it flawlessly!! Good job
was just talking about you with a fellow music and PT lover, said they should check you out, i had no idea this was sitting waiting for me, but wow this is gonna be impressive, it's 3:30 in the morning and im like damn.. do i play it now, or wait til i can turn it right up, i might take a sneaky look now and come back for the rest later
Thanks for all of your effort put into this project. Love The Incident way up high on my list of favorite PT albums. I completely disagree that they were repeating themselves at this point as this album stands on it's own. Hoping this gets more eyes on it as what you have done is well deserving of acknowledgement/views by PT fans and even the band to see and acknowledge. Thanks Again
Thanks! Total agreement with you, it's got its own sound compared to the rest of the catalogue. I'd love for the band to see it, it would be a dream come true.
@@gothikserpentmusic No problem I am thoroughly impressed at the musicianship and all you did here. Will probably never be read of course but I have sent the link in messages to each member of the band and would ask others to do the same. Looking forward to hearing some of your own music in the future. I would not be surprised to see you tackle The Incident Bonus Tracks.
@@mikehirsch3741 Wow! Thanks so much for that. I'm working on my original album now and will squeeze in more covers like this in between so keep an eye out.
Brilliant! A real achievement all the way around and the wonderful/creative animation and editing was a really unexpected "icing on the cake"! Kudos all!
As a big fan of the original album, I have to say you have done a tremendous job and have, at some points, even improved on the original. I really hope this blows up!
@@gothikserpentmusic Yeah, my friend over here has been wishing for more Gothik Serpent PT covers and you just covered his favourite album. Stellar effort.
La perfección que logra Porcupine es tan asombrosa que no puede ser entendida por mucha gente...obviamente todo de la mano de Steven Wilson por la música, una mente brillante---felicidades chicos por el esfuerzo y la gran calidad conseguida----------------------------------The perfection that Porcupine achieves is so amazing that it cannot be understood by many people...obviously all from the hand of Steven Wilson for music, a brilliant mind---congratulations guys for the effort and the great quality achieved
Amazing job! So much to love about your cover and interpretation! "I was born in 1986..." Very clever! Thanks so much for all your hard work! This was a joy to listen to and watch!
Amazing work! All those years, I thought this was the Porcupine Tree Swan Song, only to surprise us last year with the Closure/Continuation release. You have done a beautiful job reflecting the passion of the music and honoring the spirit of the original. I enjoyed your little tweaks as well!
What an amazing cover version 🎉 please stay in your „own style“ and don‘t try to get closer to original! It has something beautyful in your singing style and specially the Bass-playing - amazing work- thank you for that and i hope i can hear more of you - what about the Solo-Album from SW „The Raven…“ want to hear it in „your style“ 😊 Greetings from Germany- Freddy
Any chase your thinking of thouring. If you do so please come to norway. Lokation: Bergen in usf verftet. STEVEN WILSON played there 07.02.2016. Kinda like a rewamp eavening. Awesome work❤
LOS FELICITO DESDE ANTOFAGASTA CHILE, TREMENDO TRABAJO VISUAL Y GRAFICO CON LA INTELIGENCIA ARTIFICIAL.... PROFESIONALES EN TODO SENTIDO A NIVEL DE ARMONIZACION, MELODIAS, Y VOCES.
Next level masterpiece. Turns on a few good Souls 2 this.Our World leaders and so called freedom fighters need locking in a room and made 2 watch This. ❤😢Karma
Came back for another listen though, must have already done it another half a time cuz playback was at about 31:00, love that the quiet bit at 31:40, sounded different from what my ear knows of that part, but still totally put me in that ready state for when 'HOW, DOES, TIME~ ' kicks in, the que was still there within the vibe.
there are so many key moments in this and im only 17:40 mins into it, oh RACK off dude, you just gave me goosebump chills down my SPINE with some of those backing creeping less than obvious vocals as i typed this, omg so good haha but as you were both singing, and you had Liv on side vox, i was just thinking damn this is such impressive production, never mind the amazing playing, attention to detail, ear for the sound in the first place, i'm sorry, but im no where near done hyping the hell outta this, you've done AMAZING :D
Tau, you sir are a demon on those drums, an animal, Animal the muppet perhaps :P all i know is it's very admirable, i drum a little, but i'll never have the talent to follow Chris or Gav, brilliance! and yet again loving Olivia's additions to this, combined with knowing where to place her, she's got a gorgeous voice, you go girl :)
@@CyPhaSaRin Haha thank you. It made my day to read your thoughts and know that all the hard work that went into this was worth it. Hope you manage to get through the whole thing!
@@gothikserpentmusic oh i did, 3am in the morning, but that was a good thing because i was able to get immersed right in this with headphones, and you know PT, immersion is one of their specialties, one that you by no chance missed, i'll be back to enjoy this in full again very soon :) thank you for sharing
This is absolutely wonderful. I can't believe anyone would cover this full album and do it so well. I'd love to hear you do the second CD as well. That has some great songs as well. You must really love doing this, and it shows. I wish you the best. How did you do the visuals? It seems like some sort of AI treatment. It really fits the mood of the album.
Did you do a "First Regret" (from Hand.Cannot.Erase) transition right before I Drive the Hearse? It's subtle enough and love how it works tying it together.
Thank you! Basically, I personally felt that after the thunderous finish of the title track, the way Your Unpleasant Family starts up with the same energy and drum beat was kind of awkward. Then when I read SW's autobiography, where he wrote that parts of The Incident were half-finished ideas he glued together, it explained everything. So I tried to combine it with The Yellow Windows of the Evening Train to make the whole package more cohesive.
I love the reintpretation of the arrangements and the atmosphere, i like how you also worked to connect the songs further, is there any way I can download this?
Thank you! A lot of energy was spent finding ways to further establish flow between the songs. I believe you can click the Download button under the video at the bottom right.
Thanks so much! I have a Bandcamp page with three original works and a cover album: gothikserpent.bandcamp.com/ We're also on Spotify: open.spotify.com/artist/1T78Zdvx2VHyVdBYFiDwOd
Haha, the irony is that Olivia is actually a very cheerful and bubbly person, and I specifically told her to stop smiling in the video because it didn't match the somber tone of the music! Thanks for your comment.
![Porcupine Tree - Warszawa [Full Album]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UJXrwTtkxJ0/mqdefault.jpg)
Steven Wilson should be proud of your performance ! Good job guys !
Hello Gothik Serpent. I have been a record collector for almost 50 years now. I have almost everything by Porcupine Tree now. I want you all to know that I am hooked on the way you did "The Incident" Each of you is very talented. Believe it or not, I have watched this cover of "The Incident" 8 times. This is my 9th time. I have also been loving the special effects which are fantastic. I will start to collect Gothik Serpent albums soon. However, since I am a major collector I will only buy my favorite albums by my favorite artist by Gothik Serpent. In other words, I will be buying any and all Porcupine Tree stuff you all make and any groups I currently collect. I love KERWIN TSANG and his voice and the way he plays a lot. I am also impressed with Chapman Sticks' bass playing. I also really like Olivia Kong female vocals on The Incident. Without Olivia Kong things would be very different. I can tell over time she will become better and better with her excellent voice. Also, What a great job to Tau Bower. I must listen to "INTERLOPER" I think I will do that now. I deeply urge anybody who has a favorite group in your life not to overlook Gothik Serpent. This is my very first tribute band that I will soon start to collect.
Thanks so much Larry for your extremely flattering comment. I'm humbled that you've listened to my cover of The Incident that many times. I will also relay your praise to Olivia and Tau. Do subscribe to this YT channel if you haven't already, as I am constantly working on more music, including my next original album!
@@gothikserpentmusic Thank you so very much. Also. Thank you for letting Olivia and Tau know how I feel. Also looking forward to your next album!
wtf I love The Incident now
Now?
The incident is underrated by its creators..
This is great. I agree that The Incident is underrated and is not a collection of half baked ideas. I would take Incident over Closure/Continuation any day.
2 TRUE, Incident,is P_T`s, Codex😇
The Incident fans rejoice!!!
Man those Harmonies on Kneel and Disconnect .... beautiful. Such a great interpretation of this masterpiece
Thank you, that particular section is a huge reason why I wanted to cover The Incident.
Incredible! Probably close to the best UA-cam cover of any artist I've seen, especially for a whole album as challenging as this. Sound quality is great as well! You should be proud of yourselves.
Thanks so much! It was an incredible experience unpacking the band's songwriting and sound design when doing this cover.
I love how you personalized Time Flies. And some of the images were breath taking during the track. And then that bass solo, wow!
You absolutely blew this well beyond expectations! This is so, so amazing!
Thank you! The bass solo came about because I was having a hard time understanding how to play the guitar solo in the original.
What an outstanding effort and you all were amazing all throughout. Keep it up! Wish PT would see this
These guys could definitely pull of a PT tribute tour.
I'm going to draw the line and I think the cover is excellent, my congratulations, what you do is incredible
I'm speechless, you did an amazing job guys!❤ Finally someone has recognized the value of this underrated masterpiece.
Thank you so much!
No one can discribe this kind of Music, also I cannot discribe Tool.....but I love this kind auf Rock'n Roll. I is the heart of us all...!! Unbelievable.....Greez from good old Germany...
I just discovered this band, this is a masterpiece, keep doing what you are doing.
This is one of the best albums! So underreated! Thank you for this!
You guys blow me away. I hope you get gigs and play this live. Frigin awesome
Awesome, than you very much for that!
BTW: As someone born in 1967, I adore how you changed the lyrics to Time Flies!
Thank you! Given the autobiographical nature of Time Flies, I thought it would be more suitable to adjust it that way.
great job, no small feat either!
Thanks so much.
Your cover came on when I asked Google to play The Incident by PT and I thought it was a PT recording at first. You all killed this!
Wow, so Google mistook this cover for the original? That's incredible.
This definitely earned a subscription. I feel this album is hugely underrated. You absolutely nailed the movement from Time Flies to Circle of Manias.
Bravo! Such a criminally underrated album. It's hard to stand up to Fear of a Blank Planet or Deadwing... but The Incident is absolutely amazing in its own right. I really like the flow of the album. It reminds me of the Abbey Road medleys with the cohesion. You folks really did it justice too!
Thanks! I rank The Incident third among all PT albums, but it's special to me because that tour was the first time I saw them live.
I don’t usually leave comments but this was so incredible and well done I really just had to say so. The incident is my favorite porcupine tree album and this rendition of the main suite was remarkable!!! Incredible work
I love this album and the cover too. Having seen Steven’s latest interview still can’t believe he doesn’t rate it highly. To me it is really captivating
wow wow wow!!!!!!!!!!!!!! fantastic!
By far the best PT covers out there. It's very exciting to me to find other people who are so touched by his music the way I am. Really really great job on these songs. And I love the changes to the lyrics at the start of Time Flies. Made me smile
Thank you for the kind words! Always a pleasure to find others who feel similarly about their music as I do.
This was the album that got me into PT and might still be my favorite of theirs. This is amazing, it really feels to me like you did the record justice with every detail!
Perrrrroooossss ❤
Y zaguateeees mi compa, que nivel de proyecto!!
You guys! 🤗
This is incredible! 👏
This is amazing! I've been a big PT/SW fan for 20 years now, and you've done an incredible job. Please do In Absentia next. Love from Northeast India.
Thank you! I do have a cover of Sound of Muzak on the channel, and when I have time I'd love to do the rest of the album.
By far their most underrated album. Love the shared chord progression of the blind house and octane twisted-the seance. You executed it flawlessly!! Good job
it really needs to get back to PT, such an epic homage to their work
The Washington DC show was missing I Drive the Hearse. Sad edit! I did get to see two concerts during The Incident tour however...Such great music!
Great covers! Love the AI images too! Brilliant work guys.
was just talking about you with a fellow music and PT lover, said they should check you out, i had no idea this was sitting waiting for me, but wow this is gonna be impressive, it's 3:30 in the morning and im like damn.. do i play it now, or wait til i can turn it right up, i might take a sneaky look now and come back for the rest later
That’s what I’m doing now .. this is great 😎
This was quite an undertaking but you nailed it! The music is top notch and the visuals are really well done.
Love this album, this band, and TDEP t-shirt of the vocalist ❤
Thanks! I regret not being able to see TDEP live...
Fantastic cover of the original. You nailed it, especially for the vocals. It looks incredible with those animations.
Thanks for all of your effort put into this project. Love The Incident way up high on my list of favorite PT albums. I completely disagree that they were repeating themselves at this point as this album stands on it's own. Hoping this gets more eyes on it as what you have done is well deserving of acknowledgement/views by PT fans and even the band to see and acknowledge. Thanks Again
Thanks! Total agreement with you, it's got its own sound compared to the rest of the catalogue. I'd love for the band to see it, it would be a dream come true.
@@gothikserpentmusic No problem I am thoroughly impressed at the musicianship and all you did here. Will probably never be read of course but I have sent the link in messages to each member of the band and would ask others to do the same. Looking forward to hearing some of your own music in the future. I would not be surprised to see you tackle The Incident Bonus Tracks.
@@mikehirsch3741 Wow! Thanks so much for that. I'm working on my original album now and will squeeze in more covers like this in between so keep an eye out.
Brilliant! A real achievement all the way around and the wonderful/creative animation and editing was a really unexpected "icing on the cake"! Kudos all!
Thank you! I felt that because The Incident was such a cinematic sounding album, it was necessary to have visuals to tell the story.
Grossartig!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Wow. That’s awesome. Great job
As a big fan of the original album, I have to say you have done a tremendous job and have, at some points, even improved on the original. I really hope this blows up!
Thank you! It was indeed a lot of work and I'm delighted that you enjoyed it.
@@gothikserpentmusic Yeah, my friend over here has been wishing for more Gothik Serpent PT covers and you just covered his favourite album. Stellar effort.
Improved? Definetly not.
This is brilliant guys, what a legendary effort :)
You are to be commended . Keep it up , you will go far . Your whole presentation is chilling ❗
I really enjoyed listening to this whole thing, extremely well done! I also thought the vocal harmonies on kneel and disconnect were AMAZING!
Thank you! Those harmonies at that part are one of the main reasons I wanted to cover the whole thing.
Ah y videos a la altura de ese gran trabajo
Amazing cover! Thank you for not over-embellishing the vocals!
Thanks so much!
Amazing. Absolutely loved this! So happy I found you. Can’t wait to watch everything else you have produced.
Thank you! Do also check out the new original song we did: ua-cam.com/video/aHf0I4lM6c0/v-deo.html
❤
No words!
Amazing! Thanks a lot!
La perfección que logra Porcupine es tan asombrosa que no puede ser entendida por mucha gente...obviamente todo de la mano de Steven Wilson por la música, una mente brillante---felicidades chicos por el esfuerzo y la gran calidad conseguida----------------------------------The perfection that Porcupine achieves is so amazing that it cannot be understood by many people...obviously all from the hand of Steven Wilson for music, a brilliant mind---congratulations guys for the effort and the great quality achieved
Brilliant job
Amazing job! So much to love about your cover and interpretation! "I was born in 1986..." Very clever! Thanks so much for all your hard work! This was a joy to listen to and watch!
I'm delighted you enjoyed it, thank you!
Серъёзно поработали.Респект.
You've done it once again, Fabulous! Brilliant!
Amazing work! All those years, I thought this was the Porcupine Tree Swan Song, only to surprise us last year with the Closure/Continuation release. You have done a beautiful job reflecting the passion of the music and honoring the spirit of the original. I enjoyed your little tweaks as well!
Excellent!! congrats! it's a pleasure to listen you!!
What a great work!! Nailed it
What an amazing cover version 🎉 please stay in your „own style“ and don‘t try to get closer to original! It has something beautyful in your singing style and specially the Bass-playing - amazing work- thank you for that and i hope i can hear more of you - what about the Solo-Album from SW „The Raven…“ want to hear it in „your style“ 😊 Greetings from Germany- Freddy
Thank you Freddy, really appreciate your words. I will certainly be sniffing around for the next PT/SW song to cover!
Any chase your thinking of thouring. If you do so please come to norway. Lokation: Bergen in usf verftet. STEVEN WILSON played there 07.02.2016. Kinda like a rewamp eavening. Awesome work❤
Супер! Очень трудная и увлекательная проделанная работа! Вы супер! Спасибо большое!
Большое спасибо!
LOS FELICITO DESDE ANTOFAGASTA CHILE, TREMENDO TRABAJO VISUAL Y GRAFICO CON LA INTELIGENCIA ARTIFICIAL.... PROFESIONALES EN TODO SENTIDO A NIVEL DE ARMONIZACION, MELODIAS, Y VOCES.
Next level masterpiece. Turns on a few good Souls 2 this.Our World leaders and so called freedom fighters need locking in a room and made 2 watch This. ❤😢Karma
Great cover. I haven’t listen to this album in years and to me, it’s actually a lot better than the band and Steven think of it.
It really is, the PT guys really need to give themselves a lot more credit.
Fantastic cover y'all!!
RESPECT!
Amazing
Simply an awesome rendition of this album! You guys and gal are very talented. Keep it up (with more PT covers 🙂)!
Simply amazing
Brilliant job!!!!!
Came back for another listen though, must have already done it another half a time cuz playback was at about 31:00, love that the quiet bit at 31:40, sounded different from what my ear knows of that part, but still totally put me in that ready state for when 'HOW, DOES, TIME~ ' kicks in, the que was still there within the vibe.
That was great🎉
Congratz guys!!
this is amazing work guys!!!
Great cover album. You are really cool
broooother!!! this.. im speechless..
there are so many key moments in this and im only 17:40 mins into it, oh RACK off dude, you just gave me goosebump chills down my SPINE with some of those backing creeping less than obvious vocals as i typed this, omg so good haha
but as you were both singing, and you had Liv on side vox, i was just thinking damn this is such impressive production, never mind the amazing playing, attention to detail, ear for the sound in the first place, i'm sorry, but im no where near done hyping the hell outta this, you've done AMAZING :D
Tau, you sir are a demon on those drums, an animal, Animal the muppet perhaps :P
all i know is it's very admirable, i drum a little, but i'll never have the talent to follow Chris or Gav, brilliance!
and yet again loving Olivia's additions to this, combined with knowing where to place her, she's got a gorgeous voice, you go girl :)
@@CyPhaSaRin Haha thank you. It made my day to read your thoughts and know that all the hard work that went into this was worth it. Hope you manage to get through the whole thing!
@@gothikserpentmusic oh i did, 3am in the morning, but that was a good thing because i was able to get immersed right in this with headphones, and you know PT, immersion is one of their specialties, one that you by no chance missed, i'll be back to enjoy this in full again very soon :) thank you for sharing
This is amazing - well done! I can only imagine all the hours it took to record this! Such an underrated album as well.
Thank you! It took six months, working on the music and visuals Mon-Fri, 9-5, to get it all done.
looks and sounds great. Good job, well done!!
Thanks
🙏
Muy buen cover
Awesome!!
This is absolutely wonderful. I can't believe anyone would cover this full album and do it so well. I'd love to hear you do the second CD as well. That has some great songs as well.
You must really love doing this, and it shows. I wish you the best.
How did you do the visuals? It seems like some sort of AI treatment. It really fits the mood of the album.
Thanks so much, it really was a labor of love. Yes, the visuals are done with AI.
Did you do a "First Regret" (from Hand.Cannot.Erase) transition right before I Drive the Hearse? It's subtle enough and love how it works tying it together.
Yup, I'm glad you noticed! Thanks.
What an incredible, stunning work guys, but what happened with your unpleasant family? (The shortest but magnificent song by PT)
Thank you! Basically, I personally felt that after the thunderous finish of the title track, the way Your Unpleasant Family starts up with the same energy and drum beat was kind of awkward. Then when I read SW's autobiography, where he wrote that parts of The Incident were half-finished ideas he glued together, it explained everything. So I tried to combine it with The Yellow Windows of the Evening Train to make the whole package more cohesive.
I love the reintpretation of the arrangements and the atmosphere, i like how you also worked to connect the songs further, is there any way I can download this?
Thank you! A lot of energy was spent finding ways to further establish flow between the songs. I believe you can click the Download button under the video at the bottom right.
Your stuff is objectively great. How can i support you? Do you have a website, do you have anything I can BUY?
Thanks so much! I have a Bandcamp page with three original works and a cover album: gothikserpent.bandcamp.com/
We're also on Spotify: open.spotify.com/artist/1T78Zdvx2VHyVdBYFiDwOd
Αν και έχει παραμείνει στην αφάνεια είναι πολύ ωραίο άλμπουμ μου θυμίζει λιγάκι το stupid dream.
I was ready to dislike it, because i'm picky with covers, but I really enjoyed it! You guys did a terrific job. Well done!
Glad you enjoyed it! I'm also picky with covers which is why I was quite careful and took my time with this rendition.
Your video should get so much more views…
so nice... so beautifull.... why you change the lyrics :(
bonnie the cat?
Possibly!
..and what a great cover, but the female singer is a little bit introvertetet......smile a little bit more and show your emotions....great job Ok🤘
Haha, the irony is that Olivia is actually a very cheerful and bubbly person, and I specifically told her to stop smiling in the video because it didn't match the somber tone of the music! Thanks for your comment.
What's the point?
It's the same thing in worse.